Hot Hatch Comparo 2025 Toyota GR Corolla vs 2025 Volkswagen Golf R

Automobile Identity
371 followers
#automobile #autos #cars #4wheels #luxurycar #sportcar #highspeedcar #testdrive #toyota #tesla #porsche #hyundai #rollsroyce #royall #suvs
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video compares the 2025 Toyota GR Corolla and the 2025 Volkswagen Golf R, analyzing their performance, engineering, and interior quality. While the GR Corolla is celebrated as a raw, rally-inspired machine, the Golf R is presented as a more refined and effortless driving experience, ultimately taking the lead for its superior agility and comfort.
Hot hatch day! We are in Hatchipie, California with the Toyota GUR Corolla and the Volkswagen Golfer.
Sorry, that's the GR Corolla and the Golf R. We need to have a serious talk with the guy who does our cue cards.
Anyway, both of these all-wheel drive turbocharged cars are updated and improved for 2025.
And today, we are going to figure out which one of them is best using our of the year criteria,
which I'm supposed to have memorized, but once you get to my age.
Advancement in design, efficiency, engineering excellence, performance of intended function, safety, and value.
Now, I am really eager to get out and drive these things on these beautiful curvy roads,
but let's take a very quick look on what has been changed for 2025.
The GR Corolla absolutely stole our hearts when it first came out.
It's powered by, God, I love saying this, a 1.5-liter 3-cylinder engine that puts out 300 horsepower.
And for 2025, that engine gets a 22-pound-feet-of-torque increase up to 295 so that it matches the Golf R.
Big news for this year is an 8-speed automatic transmission.
You can still get the 6-speed manual, but now there is an optional 8-speed automatic.
New front fascia, which actually has more openings for additional cooling, including transmission coolers.
New top-of-the-line Premium Plus model with this carbon fiber roof.
Pricing, base model with the stick shift, $39,995.
And the model that you see right here, Premium Plus with the automatic, well, this one stickers for $50,144.
Now, to the Golfer. It gets a 13-horsepower bump for its 2-liter turbocharged engine, now up to 328 horsepower.
Torque remains unchanged, and of course, the Golf R comes standard with a 7-speed automatic transmission.
It also gets a new front fascia, but it's the same good, smooth look that we've gotten used to over the years.
And this snazzy new Black Edition, which you see here.
Also, a very interesting option package in which you pay more for less stuff.
The Euro Appearance package removes the sunroof, removes most of the power seat controls, removes the front seat ventilation,
and removes the driver's seat memory function, but it saves 80 pounds, and of course, less weight makes you faster everywhere.
Base price on the Golf R, $48,325, so quite a bit more than the base GR Corolla.
And the car you see right here, with that Eurostyle package in the Black Edition, $53,731.
Well, we have a beautiful day with some fantastic twisty roads, which is where these cars are at home, so let's go drive some hot hatchbacks.
The biggest issue with this Corolla is the noise!
I'm only kidding, I can actually talk with a normal voice.
It is a little bit noisy in here, but I have to tell you I love, love, love a 3-cylinder engine.
I love the noises they make, I love that kind of low thrum, and I love that this car has only 3 cylinders and makes 300 horsepower from 1.5 liters.
That's 200 horsepower per liter, that is nuts!
This car has the DNA of some of the great high-tech Japanese sports cars, like the Mitsubishi Lancer Evolution,
and the Nissan GT-R, it's just that feeling of engineering unbridled and unbounded.
Now, it makes me so sad that the hot hatchback is an endangered species,
and I'm actually glad that Toyota came out with a relatively new one just a couple years ago.
You know, it's amazing how these cars have transformed.
I mean, really, I guess this all started in the late 60s, when automakers started putting great big engines into stripped-down intermediate cars,
like the GTO and even more so the Plymouth Roadrunner.
And then in the 80s, this was kind of the answer.
Volkswagen took the Rabbit, the Golf if you're European, gave it a little horsepower boost but a much stiffer suspension,
and the cars were all about momentum.
It wasn't so much about going fast in a straight line like you would in a muscle car,
but it was about really having a lot of fun in the corners.
And look at how the market has matured.
I mean, this thing is basically a road-going rally car.
It's got amazing engine technology, and of course, this very sophisticated all-wheel drive system,
because the classic problem with a front-wheel drive hot hatchback is that when you try to blast out of the corner,
you accelerate, the car sends the weight to the outside rear wheel, it unloads that front inside tire, and that wheel starts spinning.
Well, all-wheel drive pretty much squashes that problem with a 500-pound sledgehammer,
and these very sophisticated all-wheel drive systems can send the power exactly where it needs to go.
And the result is you can get out of that corner as fast as humanly possible with no worry about power oversteer,
no worry about losing power from understeer, you just go.
This is the pinnacle of the hot hatch, and maybe the breed is dying, but we definitely live the best hot hatch times ever.
Now, the big question is, does the automatic transmission kill the fun?
Now, my default answer is yes, but actually, we found that the automatic car is significantly, notably quicker than the manual car at 60 miles per hour.
It does have paddle shifters, and let me tell you, you are going to need them.
So here's the problem with this powertrain, is that if you kind of leave the transmission to its own devices,
it will want to upshift, and then you have to get on it, and then there's a pause, and then boom, all that power comes on at once.
You can be a lot smoother if you just put it in manual mode and start using the paddles, and that's what I found works the best.
Use those paddles, keep the engine between 5,000 and 7,000 RPM.
It's noisy, but that is the happy spot.
But of course, overall acceleration, just not as much as the Golf.
I had a chance to do a little passing of some slower traffic, and in these cars, it's all slower traffic,
and that was a little easier in the Golf than it was in the GR Corolla.
Steering is also interesting.
Toyota has used a very small wheel and a very fast steering ratio.
Now normally, this would make the car feel very twitchy, but the GR Corolla isn't.
It tracks really nicely, but very little movement of your hand gives you a lot of movement on the road,
and that's great if you're on a racetrack, but on an open road like this, it can actually make it a little difficult to place the car.
You have to be very careful.
The first couple of corners I bombed through, I couldn't understand why I was like a foot to the left or a foot to the right of where I actually wanted to be.
This car just wants to go straight ahead, and it takes a great deal of effort to turn it away from that,
and frankly, after a little while of driving, my dainty little princess hands kind of started to hurt a little bit.
But it does, in these corners, exactly what you'd expect a high-horsepower, all-wheel-drive car to do when you drive it fast in the turns.
At the risk of making our camera guy in the backseat sick, I'm going to give you a little demo.
You can bomb in, go hard on the brakes, downshift, come through the corner, look at all that grip.
Oh, a little dirt, it's fine with that.
Lots of grip, and then get on it, and away she goes.
Just fires you out like you've been shot from a proverbial cannon.
It is truly amazing.
This car is such an overachiever from a small car with a small engine.
Ooh, this road's getting very, very twisty.
This is all the GR territory.
This car is all about how you can use the technology to get through your favorite curvy road as fast as possible.
It is like a blind technological devotion to the art of speed, and I just love it.
If you like the feel of really, really working a car, really making it work as hard as it can to get going as fast as it can,
then the Corolla GR is going to be right up your alley.
I do really like the interior of this car.
I spent some time with both the GR Corolla and the Golf R before we started this video.
The Golf R does have a more upscale, more spacious interior, but I love the displays of information here in the Corolla.
I've got a turbo boost gauge, I've got another gauge that shows how grip is going to each of the four wheels
and what that all-wheel drive system is doing.
Nice, big, easy-to-see tachometer.
It's the information that you need to go fast.
It's all in keeping with this car's ethic as the technological temple of speed.
Both of these cars have fairly heavily bolstered seats.
That's to keep you in place when you're going around corners, and believe me, you are going to need it.
For a more, shall we say, hamburger-happy person such as myself, this seat is a little tight,
a little short on thigh support, even though I have fairly short thighs.
Not exactly molded, perhaps, to your average American posterior, let's put it that way.
But I expected this car to be a lot more uncomfortable.
It does have a very busy, very active ride, but really it's not that annoying.
It's bumpy, but not the kind of thing that you're going to regret every day when you go to work,
and I am very sensitive about those things.
I'm getting old, I like a car that rides a little smoother.
I don't have as much patience for a really stiff suspension, but Toyota's done a really great job here.
They've made the car stiff enough that it doesn't do anything untoward, it never skips, it never jumps
if you hit a fast bump too hard, and yet it doesn't beat the stuffing out of you on a rough road.
It's noisy, you'll hear a lot of tire noise, a lot of road noise,
but your backside is not going to regret your purchase of the Corolla GR.
And let me tell you, it is a blast to drive.
The all-wheel drive system in this thing is just amazing, so good at figuring out where to get the power,
how to get the power down, it's like being given a day pass from the laws of physics.
For $50,000, it's a lot of thrills, but the Golf R takes a very different approach to speed,
so let's park this GR Corolla, get in the Golf R, and see what the differences are.
The Golf R presents a very different experience.
It's a bigger car, it doesn't have all that, you know, fancy stuff on the dashboard.
I mean, this is the same interior in the Golf, which for many, many years was the Toyota Camry of Europe.
Even these seats, they're heavily bolstered, but they're a little wider, a little more comfortable for,
well, let's just say, a guy like me.
And the steering, the steering is a big difference. Bigger wheel, but also much, much lighter effort.
In fact, after driving the Corolla GR, which is so determined to go straight ahead,
you might say, what's going on here? Am I in a 1962 Ford Falcon, or what?
I can kind of see that young upstart, the GR Corolla, coming to the old man, the Golf R,
and saying, man, what happened to you, man? You got old, you lost your fire, you got soft.
And this old Golf R is going to turn to that young upstart GR Corolla and say, son,
let me learn you a little something about driving fast, because this thing has a ton of power.
Numbers-wise, it's the same torque as the GR Corolla, 295 pound-feet, a little more horsepower, 328 versus 300,
but, man, when you ask it to go, it just goes. It feels so much quicker, passes better, accelerates better.
And here's the thing, even though this car has paddle shifters, you don't need them.
Golf R uses a seven-speed twin-clutch transmission, which, in my opinion,
is the best automatic transmission for performance driving, because you get smooth gear changes
with no interruption in power, no weight transfer, and that's exactly what you feel.
You don't need to paddle down in the Golf R, you just give it a little throttle, give it a lot of throttle,
whatever you do, it always seems to have the right gear, and it just goes.
The rate at which you pick up speed is really something.
But it's not that you go, oh my goodness, I'm going way too fast, I need to jump on the brakes,
it's because the car has a consummate increase in its handling abilities as well.
As you may notice, I've got very, very light fingers on the wheel, and I'm actually in Race,
which is the heaviest steering setting that the Golf R has.
What it does, it doesn't really change the weight off-center, it's that as you dial in more lock,
the steering weights up more and more.
Now, you're probably saying, okay, Aaron, that's exactly what steering is supposed to do,
but I'm going to name-drop here, what this car reminds me of is the first-generation Porsche 911
with no power steering.
If you've never had a chance to drive one, most amazing steering ever.
It just feels so good and light and easy off-center,
and then as you get closer and closer to the limits of grip, the steering adds weight,
it starts kicking back a little more, resisting a little more,
letting you know that you're getting close to where the tires are going to let go,
and that is exactly what the Golf R does.
It's there, it's getting nice and heavy, and then steering weights up,
next thing you know the tires are squealing, and then you're into the understeer,
and then the all-wheel drive system works its magic to correct that.
It's just so wonderful and so progressive.
It's just amazing how this car just communicates with all of your senses
and lets you make speed that just seems so easy.
And that really is the difference between the Golf R and the GR Corolla.
In the Corolla GR, when you drive fast,
it really feels like you are demanding everything that car can give you.
And in the Golf R, it's a little bit more peaceful.
You're making incredible speed, but lighter hands on the steering wheel,
you can almost enjoy the scenery.
It makes the speed just seem that much easier,
not that it requires less skill, but it certainly requires less concentration on the mechanical bits.
It gives you more room to just enjoy the experience of a fast drive down a challenging road.
It's quieter, it's got a smoother ride,
you don't have to keep the engine screaming and bouncing right off the limiter.
The miles just fly by.
This one strip of road seems a lot shorter in the Golf R than it did in the GR Corolla.
It's just a magical experience.
An older, a more mature, a more confident experience.
Not the same feel as the technological powerhouse that is the GR Corolla.
Of course, there's amazing technology in this car.
Rather, if you've ever driven with a really talented racing driver,
you're going at incredible speeds, but they're sitting there,
and their heartbeat is like it's sitting idle.
They are just so relaxed, and that's what this Golf R feels like to drive.
I know the sound isn't there, but believe me, the speed is there.
We are flying, and it's just so simple, and so wonderful, and so organic.
It's an experience that I absolutely love.
And in this car, it gives the tire squeal a little bit earlier than the GR Corolla has,
but still plenty of grip.
And when you do get to the point where physics starts to fail you,
well, the all-wheel drive system sorts it out.
You can feel it taking power out of the front, moving it to the back,
doing whatever it has to do to complete the maneuver that you have started,
getting the car pointed in the direction you want to go.
A little bit of sand there. It didn't even phase it.
A little too much speed, just a little understeer.
Oh my gosh, this thing is so good!
I had to stop talking because I, well, I wet myself a little there.
Oh, $50,000, huh?
What do I have to sell to get one of these?
In the GR Corolla, to me, it's all about the machinery,
and in the Golf R, it is all about the experience of driving fast.
Which is better? Neither. I love them both.
I love the machinery. I love the experience.
If I had to pick between these two cars, I don't know,
I'd probably just buy an old Hyundai Accent and live in a cave
so I didn't have to make such tough decisions.
I want to turn around and go drive this road again
because that's the beauty of this car.
That's the beauty of a hot hatch like this Golf R and the GR Corolla.
You just want to drive through the curves again and again,
and you just want to keep doing it until you run out of gas
or until the car rusts from beneath you.
The joy of driving is just encapsulated in these two magnificent automobiles.
So, now I've got to pick between them, and I've got to tell you,
this is one of those days I wish I had listened to my mother
and pursued a career in retail.
Because I don't know how I'm going to do it.
But let's start with our criteria.
Advancement in design. Well, that one definitely has to go to the Toyota.
I mean, look at it with the scoops and the strakes and all that other stuff.
I mean, that all makes sense. It's all functional,
and that's part of the beauty of that car.
That car is so much about the machinery of which it's made.
I think that one's got to go to the Toyota.
Efficiency. Well, you know, you would expect this to be a Toyota advantage,
but according to the EPA numbers, the Golf is actually more fuel efficient
by a couple of miles per gallon.
You know, even if you have a small engine, if you're using a turbocharger,
dumping lots of air in, that means you dump in lots of fuel.
So Golf's going to take you further on a gallon of gas, so that goes for the Golf.
Engineering excellence. Oh, my goodness.
How am I going to pick them?
I mean, the whole object of these cars is to go as fast as humanly possible in the curves,
and they both achieve that.
And I think that's a dead heat between the two cars.
Performance and intended function.
Well, this is what it all comes down to, isn't it?
You know, these both have kind of a different approach to them.
The Toyota GR Corolla is really all about taking the machinery and operating it
at its absolute max, but still with an envelope of safety, and it's so much fun to do.
But the Golf R kind of transcends that.
The Golf R is more about the drive.
Well, at the end of the day, even though they're both hugely thrilling to drive,
the Golf gives you a bit more, it's a bit quicker, and it is a little bit more agile,
and so I have to say, in terms of performance and intended function,
it's a very slight edge for the Volkswagen Golf.
Safety? Well, we only have crash test data on the Toyota,
but listen, these are cars that encourage you to drive as fast as you can on curvy roads.
You're probably going to kill yourself, so I think that's a wash for both of them.
And finally, value.
Now, obviously, the Corolla starts at a lower price, that's with the manual transmission
and without some of the extra cooling options and stuff like that,
and it's about three grand less expensive here.
But, in the case of the Golf R here, if you take away that Euro package,
and put back some of the things I wouldn't mind having,
like the ventilated front seats with the power adjustment and things like that,
the price is the same. The cars are both just a little bit over $50,000.
And if it was my 50 grand, which would I rather have?
I gotta tell you, I love them both, but the Golf R just has the edge for me.
Maybe it's because I'm a man of a certain age, and I appreciate the comfort,
and I appreciate the space and things like that.
It's just so thrilling.
But here's the thing, if you pick the Toyota Corolla GR,
I'm not going to tell you you picked the wrong car.
You can't go wrong. In fact, if you're buying one of these,
the winner of this comparison is you, you lucky bastard,
because you get to have one of these fantastic cars in your driveway,
and I hate you a little, because of it.
For more about these cars, visit us on the web at MotorTrend.com.
And please, can I drive your car? Please? Please?
I'll leave myself a note.
