בתקופה האחרונה, הלוחמה נשענת יותר ויותר על שימוש ברחפנים ולסין יכולות יצור רבות בתחום כיום.
ממשל טראמפ פונה כעת אל מעבר לחברות הביטחוניות הגדולות, ומאפשר להשתתף במאמץ גם לחברות סטארט-אפ ואף לחובבים.
מדוע חל השינוי הזה? מגישת חדשות NTD שוחחה בנושא עם ברנט סדלר, קצין לשעבר בחיל הים האמריקני ועמית מחקר ב"קרן המורשת", המתמקד בלוחמה ימית ובטכנולוגיות מתקדמות.
סדלר אומר בין היתר: "...הדבר הטוב הוא שמתפתחת באוקראינה תעשיה "מפלצתית" בתחום הזה מתוך צורך הכרחי. לכן עם היכולת של אוקראינה, אני מקווה שהמלחמה תסתיים בעתיד הקרוב מאוד, יכולת הייצור הזו חייבת ללכת לאנשהו. המשמעות היא היצע שיוריד את מחירי הרחפנים, אם אוקראינה תמשיך לייצר אותם. אבל זה אינו פתרון בר קיימא, זה גם לא בהכרח סוג הרחפן הנכון שצבא ארה"ב זקוק לו... עלינו לבחון ברצינות רבה ובאופן מעמיק את שרשרת האספקה שלנו. המנועים החשמליים [שכיום מיוצרים ברובם בסין] הם הבעיה הבולטת ביותר, אך לא היחידה. הדבר יהיה קצת יקר בהתחלה עד שהתעשייה בארה"ב תוכל לייצר בהיקף גדול את כל רכיבי הרחפנים מהקטנים ועד הגדולים".
"אם לא יהיו לנו רחפנים או כלי שיט בלתי מאוישים המצוידים במערכות נשק מתקדמות על הסיפון, לא תהיה לנו עוצמת האש שאנחנו צריכים בים. סין מבחינה בכך, והם פחות ופחות נרתעים מאיתנו. אז אם לא נשיג את זה בעתיד הקרוב מאוד, נמצא את עצמנו במצב שבו סין היא זו שתכתיב את תנאי העימות או את העיתוי לעימות עתידי, ולא אנחנו", מוסיף סדלר. ____________________
The Pentagon is shifting its drone procurement strategy by engaging startups and hobbyists to rapidly scale the production of low-cost attack drones. This move aims to counter China's industrial dominance and address critical firepower deficits in the Pacific, though challenges remain regarding supply chain dependencies on Chinese components and the need for larger, long-endurance platforms.
Increasingly, modern warfare is depending more and more on the use of drones.
Now, the Trump administration, as it races to build out a massive fleet of the critical assets,
looking beyond the major manufacturers, turning to startups and hobbyists. Why the shift?
Joining us now is retired naval captain Brent Sadler. He's a senior research fellow at the
Heritage Foundation, focusing on naval warfare and advanced technology. He's also a former
Pentagon official. Brent, thank you so much for joining us. Great to see you again.
Today, the Washington Post reported that the Pentagon is turning to smaller companies
and even hobbyists as part of its drone dominance contest. That's to make more
small, low-cost attack drones. What do you make of this approach?
Well, I think it's inevitable for a couple of things. One is the experience. I mean,
if you go back to the Azerbaijan-Armenia war, this preceded by about a year the war in Ukraine,
which has made famous the use of drones, but also unmanned vehicles with increasing levels
of autonomy, that has become a reality on the battlefield. But for the U.S. military,
it's a different dynamic. It is how do you deter or how do you pace an industrial
goliath that is the Chinese Communist Party, and how do you catch up with the deficit in
smaller but still very lethal weapon platforms in larger numbers? This includes the biggest
thing is with naval platforms, so unmanned surface vessels able to carry very advanced weapons.
You're seeing that right now starting to mature with the delivery of some of these
medium-sized unmanned vessels. And digging into that, the Pentagon hopes to buy up to 300,000
drones through this contest with a budget of $1.1 billion. Now that works out to less than
$3,700 per drone. Does that price point sound realistic and doable?
I think when you're talking about the smaller quadcopters, and if you start to produce at
large scale, it's achievable. But that does not, I think, include the larger platforms you're going
to need to be sustained for many months in a Pacific theater war, launching long-range
strike weapons. These quadcopters, the things you see in the battlefield in Ukraine, going after
soldiers in trenches is just not going to cut it. But clearly, the other part of this is even if
you're going to build those, the electric motors are overwhelmingly sourced out of China, so we
have a supply chain problem we still have to deal with. I want to get to China, but very quickly to
your earlier point, what specific capabilities or specs is the Pentagon looking for in these
drones to consider them successful? Well, for deterring China in a fight over the future fate
of Taiwan, it's the medium-sized and larger unmanned or what they call optionally manned
ships, because those are the only ones that have the ability to stay at sea for 30 days to 90 days
in the open ocean of the Pacific. And to be able to carry the types of munitions like Tomahawk
cruise missiles or SM-6s, which have a range of missions they can cover to take out aircraft and
also missiles, but also ships at great range, you need a large platform. So the sooner that you can
get those types of unmanned vessels to the Pacific Ocean with munitions on board, that's going to be
the metric to decide success. And the success is deterring China from a fight in the near future.
And to your earlier points, there are growing concerns about drone parts coming from China.
Now China, of course, dominates the global drone industry and even some of our law enforcement
agencies rely heavily on Chinese components. Now there are reports of trying to phase them out,
but practically speaking, how easy is it to build out drones with a domestic supply chain?
Well, the business model as it exists right now, because you have highly subsidized,
it's not an open market in China, you're going to have to have some intervention,
unfortunately, to get there. The good thing is you've got a monster in this sector that is
developing in Ukraine because of necessity. So with Ukraine's capacity, hopefully the war
ends in the very near future, that capacity has got to go somewhere. So you're going to have a
supply that's going to drive down the price of many of these drones if Ukraine continues to
produce them. But that's not sustainable, that's not the right type of drone for the US military.
But again, we have to take a very serious and close look at our supply chain. The electric
motors are the most obvious, but it's not the only one. And it's going to be a little costly
up front until we actually get industry in the United States at scale producing all the components
for the drones from the small to the large. And to your point, what kind of strategic risks
does this pose to the United States if we fail to match China's drone production capability?
Well, we won't be able to get firepower to see. The traditional Navy ships are aging out faster
than we can build them. And it takes three to five years to build a cruiser or destroyer,
an aircraft carrier, it takes many years. And if we don't have drone or unmanned vessels with these
advanced weapons on board, we're not going to be able to have the firepower at sea that we need.
China takes note of that, and they're less and less deterred by us. So if we don't get our hands
around this in the very near future, we are going to find ourselves in a situation where it's China
that dictates the terms of the contact or the timing of a future fight, not us.
Well, on that note, Brent Sabler, as always, thank you so much for joining us.
Thank you.