The Balkans—a region renowned for its complex and diverse ethnic makeup. Yet, despite this diversity, a vast majority of its inhabitants speak South Slavic languages. But this wasn't always the case. Historical accounts and archaeology suggest that Slavic-speaking populations are relatively recent arrivals, appearing only from the 6th Century AD.
Before the Slavs, the Balkans were a mosaic of peoples: Illyrians, Dacians, Thracians, and Greeks, all under the long shadow of the Roman Empire. Even Germanic groups, like the Bastarnae and the Goths, made their presence felt.
All of this raises a fascinating question: Did these migrations and cultural shifts leave a lasting genetic footprint?
In this video, I dive into a major 2023 study by Olalde et al. that analyzed the DNA of 136 individuals from the 1st Millennium AD Balkans. We'll explore the ancient genetic landscape, the surprising absence of Italian Roman ancestry, the massive influx of Anatolian DNA, the mysterious rise and fall of Gothic-related ancestry, and the profound, permanent impact of the Slavic migrations.
I also examine the perplexing cases of modern non-Slavic-speaking populations—Romanians and Albanians—whose genetic makeup offers unique insights into how language and genetics can diverge.
Sources: Olalde et al. (2023), "The genomic history of the human population of the Balkans."
This video analyzes a 2023 genetic study by Olalde et al. on the Balkans' population history during the first millennium AD. It examines how migrations from Anatolia, Germanic tribes, and Slavic populations reshaped the region's genetic landscape, contrasting genomic data with archaeological evidence to explain the ancestral makeup of modern Balkan nations.
Comments are disabled for this video.
The Balkans are perhaps one of the ethnically most diverse regions of Europe.
Despite this diversity, and perhaps paradoxical to it, there's also a large degree of common
ground between many of the groups in the region, from the Croats in the west to the Bulgars in the
east. I'm of course referring to the majority of the inhabitants of the modern Balkans speaking
South Slavic languages. This hasn't always been the case, however. In fact, Slavic-speaking
populations are a relatively recent arrival in the Balkans, if the historical accounts,
supported by archaeological evidence, are to be believed, and there's little reason to think
that they shouldn't. According to these findings, the Slavs probably only started arriving in the
Balkans from the 6th century AD onwards. Before that, the region had been part of the Roman
Empire for centuries, when it had been inhabited by a variety of peoples, among them most prominently
the Illyrians in the west, the Dacians in the north, the Greeks in the south, and the Thracians
in between these groups north of the Aegean. Germanic-speaking groups such as the Bastarne
and the Goths are also reported in the region, in the case of the former as early as the 2nd
century BC. The Goths, on the other hand, probably didn't arrive in the Balkans until the 3rd century
AD. That being said, they are mentioned in the sources continuously until the 6th century,
and were a major player in the Balkans for centuries. All of this begs the question,
did these various groups also leave a lasting genetic impact on the region?
Well, lucky for us, a 2023 study by Olalde et al attempted to answer this question already,
and in this video I'll be taking a closer look at this particular paper and put its conclusions
in the appropriate historical context. In the study, the authors looked at a total of 136
individuals from the Balkans during the first millennium AD. Whilst this number of samples is
much higher than in some other studies of this kind, we have to ask the question whether the
results of this investigation can truly be representative of the entirety of the population
of the Balkans for this period, which probably numbered in the millions. This is just something
to keep in mind once we examine the study further. So, what did the authors find? Before the arrival
of the Romans on the scene, the Balkans could be divided into several genetic clusters or groups.
An Aegean group that had been present in the region since the Bronze Age and which can probably
roughly be associated with the Ancient Greeks. A group identified as Iron Age Bulgarians,
which might be connected to Thracians and possibly Dacians. Another group in the region
of modern Albania, which can also be traced back to the Bronze Age and might be connected with
Southern Illyrian or Mesapic speakers. And a Western group native to modern Croatia and Serbia,
perhaps corresponding to Northern Illyrians with some Celtic influence. Although these groups are
clearly visible in the genetic data the study provided, they shouldn't be seen as completely
separate entities from each other. Like everywhere else in the world, neighbouring groups intermix
with each other and so we have fluid transitions between these different clusters.
When the Romans arrived in the region from the 2nd century BC onwards, one might have assumed that
they would have brought Italian and mixture from their homeland with them. But intriguingly,
that wasn't the case despite centuries of Roman rule in the region. When comparing this with
other frontier zones of the empire, however, this isn't too surprising. In Britain, for example,
Italian ancestry doesn't seem to be present at all in the ancient or the native modern population,
at least according to a 2022 study looking at the genetic makeup of modern Britain and Ireland,
which I've covered in a previous video. This makes sense when we keep in mind that
Rome didn't colonise its provinces in the same way modern empires did. They did found cities,
so-called coloniae, which served as administrative centres of the conquered regions, but usually
largely left ruling these regions in the hands of a local elite, which was controlled by Roman
officials and of course, the military. Although some settlers from Italy would have ventured into
the newly conquered provinces, the majority of the inhabitants would have been the same people
who had lived there before, often for centuries or even millennia. So, not detecting much of a
genetic footprint from ancient Italians isn't too surprising. More interesting than the absence of
Italian ancestry is an influx of Anatolian admixture during the imperial period between
the time of the birth of Christ and 250 AD. According to the study, individuals from western
Anatolia made up a significant portion of the population of the investigated Roman towns in
the Balkans, up to one third in one particular settlement known as Viminacium, the capital of
the Roman province of Moesia, located in modern eastern Serbia. A similar influx of easterners can
be detected in the Italian heartland of the empire at this time, pointing to major population
movements from the east into the west. Because of this presence of Anatolian-related ancestry
in Italy in this period, the authors theorised whether some Romans might have come from Italy
after all, but that their ancestry could ultimately be traced back to Anatolia.
Be that as it may, these individuals left a lasting genetic impact on the Balkans,
resulting in an average of 23% of Anatolian ancestry in medieval samples of the region,
and reaching up to 44% in modern Albanians. In late antiquity, individuals with mixed ancestry
from central and northern Europe, as well as the Steppe, can be found in the Balkans.
Because they show up at pretty much the same time the Goths are first mentioned in the sources,
people carrying these admixture components were most likely Goths or related people.
The Goths are recorded to have migrated from central Europe to the Steppe north of the Black
Sea during the 3rd century, where they apparently intermixed with the local population. From there,
they gradually moved into the Balkans over the following decades where, according to this study,
they also intermixed with their native inhabitants, showcasing up to 55% local Balkan ancestry.
The dominant Y-hypergroups among males with central slash northern European ancestry,
namely I1 and R1b U106, also point to a northern origin of these individuals.
In stark contrast to the aforementioned Anatolian admixture, these hypergroups,
as well as the central slash northern European and Steppe admixture, vanished almost entirely
after the 7th century. According to the study's authors, this might be due to a relatively small
number of these people settling in the region in the first place, or possibly displacement,
which, in my opinion, could have only been facilitated by the Eastern Roman Empire or
by the arrival of a new group on this scene. The group in question had the biggest and most
lasting impact on the region and is associated with the arrival of Slavic-speaking populations.
Between 30 and 60% of the genes of the modern inhabitants of the Balkans can be traced back
to these people, the study's authors calling it, quote, one of the largest permanent demographic
changes anywhere in Europe during the migration period, end quote, and they compared it to the
shift observed in England a few centuries earlier. Interestingly, both males and females
from Eastern Europe seem to have participated in this migration in equal parts. The authors
displayed this shift visually in one of their PCA plots, where samples from both before and after
700 AD are shown. Before, most individuals clustered fairly closely with one of three groups,
bronze and iron age genes, iron age individuals from Croatia, or, albeit in far smaller numbers,
central slash northern Europeans, probably representing a few Germanic individuals who
barely had other admixture. There are a few outliers which show some overlap with the
population of the modern Balkans, but these represent those individuals which exhibit a
mix of central slash northern European admixture with ancestry from the steppe and from the
original inhabitants of the Balkans to differing degrees. After 700 AD, the genetic composition of
the Balkans shifted significantly. Now, the majority of the samples seem to overlap with
population of the modern Balkans, though some still cluster fairly closely with the iron age
inhabitants of the peninsula. None of these samples show overlap with Germanic-speaking
groups, however. Perhaps surprisingly, the Slavic-speaking newcomers also seem to have
contributed at least a quarter of the admixture of modern Greeks, this figure understandably being
much higher in Macedonia than in the Peloponnese, reaching up to 40%. Even some of the Aegean
islands exhibit up to 20% of Eastern European ancestry. The non-Slavic-speaking Romanians
also exhibit high levels of Eastern European ancestry, about 55.4%, which puts them above
Bulgarians. Albanians, on the other hand, another non-Slavic-speaking group, show some of the
lowest levels of Slavic ancestry in the region at 31%. So, in conclusion, what can this study and
its results tell us about the history of the region? Firstly, even before the arrival of other
admixture components, the Balkans seem to have been a fairly diverse region. This has always
been clear from a historical and archaeological perspective, but it has now been also confirmed
by archaeogenetics. The influx of individuals with Anatolian-related ancestry in the 1st century AD
was probably facilitated by the incorporation of the region into the Roman Empire and left a lasting
genetic impact. Whether this could have happened without the empire is difficult to determine,
but it probably eased the movement of people between regions which, at least in this case,
weren't in particularly close contact before.
Also of interest is the presence of Central-Northern European ancestry in the Balkans during late
antiquity, coinciding with the arrival of Goths and other Germanic people in the region.
The study shows that, if this ancestry component can be in fact associated with them,
on their migration they intermixed with the population of the steppe before intermixing
again with the inhabitants of the Balkans, pointing to the complex interactions of Germanic groups
as they migrated from their northern homeland towards the Roman frontier and finally into the
empire itself. The study's authors pointed out that some of the burials which were interpreted
as Germanic based on their grave goods showed both individuals with and without Central-Northern
European ancestry. All of this goes to show that these groups, although apparently retaining a
cultural and linguistic Germanic identity, incorporated other ethnicities into their
culture. This flexibility might have been one of the major contributing factors in their long-term
success, culminating in the establishment of two Gothic kingdoms on Roman soil during the 5th
century. The almost complete disappearance of ancestry that can be associated with Germanic
speaking groups is also intriguing. The historical sources of course tell of the migrations of Gothic
groups out of the Balkans, most notable the Austro-Invisigoths in the 5th century, but it is
assumed that their respective groups only numbered in the tens of thousands and we know of other
groups in the region at the same time, such as the ones of Theodoric Strabo.
So this, combined with the genetic data, suggests that the Goths might have still been present in
the Balkans until at least 700 AD, even if they're far less prominent in the sources after the 6th
century. By the time the Slavs arrived in greater numbers from the 8th century AD onwards, the
remaining Goths were either pushed out or there were only so few of them left to begin with that
barely left a genetic trace. If their disappearance can be explained with a more or less violent
displacement, they might have been seen as a threat by the incoming Slavs, but this is only
speculation at this point in time. Lastly, the study has shown that the linguistic shift from
Latin, Greek, Gothic and the indigenous languages of the region to Slavic was in fact accompanied
by a partial replacement of the previous populations by the newcomers. This is in
line with what has been observed in England and other studies, where the change from Latin and
Brythonic went hand in hand with the partial replacement of the Romano-British inhabitants
by incomers from the continent. One thing this study unfortunately didn't address, at least not
explicitly, is how Romanians and Albanians fit into this picture. They are both of particular
interest because, aside from the Greeks, they are the only non-Slavic speaking populations in the
region. Let's first take a look at the genetic makeup of modern Romanians. Astonishingly, at
55% Central Eastern European atmosphere, they derive more than half of their DNA from Slavs.
Another quarter of Romanian DNA is derived from ancestry similar to the Iron Age population of
Bulgaria, and another 11.4% from Western Anatolia, this component apparently only
entering the region during the Ottoman period. The Roman Anatolian component is only at 8.6%.
Interestingly, the atmosphere from Iron Age Bulgaria and Romania is about 5% higher than
Bulgaria itself, but none of these figures are particularly outstanding and none of them offer
a plausible explanation as to why the population of Romania retained a Roman language. On the
contrary, the only genetic component that had been linked with the Romans, the Anatolian ancestry
from the Imperial period, is the lowest in the entire Balkans. The fact that Romanians don't
stand out genetically but appear pretty much exactly as expected based on their geographic
location suggests that those Slavs that entered Romania for some reason adopted the linguistic
identity of the local populace. Perhaps some Roman speakers from Bulgaria migrated north at some
point as well, slightly bolstering the Roman-speaking population there and leading to
the influx in Bulgarian Iron Age associated ancestry in Romania. Modern Albanians, on the
other hand, derive about a quarter of their DNA from the Bronze and Iron Age population of Albania
itself, as well as almost 44% from Roman Anatolians. This admixture component is also
very high among Southern Greeks and the inhabitants of the Aegean Islands, reaching up to 84% in the
In the case of those regions, I believe it is reasonable to assume that this admixture
component might have arrived there fairly early, probably earlier than on the Balkans,
due to the millennia-old connections between the Aegean Islands in particular and Anatolia.
In Albania, however, I think it is more likely that for some reason, many of the Romanised
Anatolians that we had previously found on the northern frontier of the Empire
coalesced in the region at some point. From the data the study provides, we can assume that this
probably happened after 300 AD, as prior to this date, the highest levels of Anatolian DNA
were found in the north. Interestingly, Anatolian DNA is very low or absent from the modern
inhabitants of the northern Balkans, suggesting that individuals carrying this admixture component
went south. But surprisingly, admixture levels of Anatolian DNA only reach 11% in Macedonia,
leading me to believe that the majority of the individuals carrying this admixture went to
Albania instead. In the historical context of the region, the most likely reason for their
move south, in my opinion, seems to be the arrival of the Slavs. The various Germanic groups could
have also been responsible, but as we have seen, they probably weren't present in large enough
numbers and generally intermixed heavily with the local population. The rest of the genetic
makeup of modern Albanians is mostly derived from Slavs, but at around 31% this proportion
of Slavic DNA is among the lowest in the Balkans. Only southern Greeks and the inhabitants of the
Aegean Islands showcase lower levels. But how does all of this relate to the special status
of the Albanian language? It seems to me that the original speakers of Albanian, or its most
likely ancestor Illyrian, were probably the original Bronze Age and Iron Age inhabitants of the region.
When the Slavs arrived in the Balkans, many individuals with high degrees of Anatolian
ancestry went south, leading to a relatively high degree of this ancestry in the region.
Since this admixture component is the highest in modern Albania, we might assume that the
population would have switched to speaking a form of Latin instead of the ancestral language.
That this didn't happen might indicate that the arrival of individuals with high degrees of
Anatolian ancestry in Albania didn't happen overnight but was a drawn-out process,
probably lasting centuries. At least this is my theory on the data available in this study.
Perhaps similar processes happened in Romania, leading to the Slavic newcomers gradually
adopting their form of Latin. Anyway, what are your thoughts on this study? Let me know in the
comments below. If you enjoyed this video, feel free to check out my other videos on the genetic
history of Europe. It would help the channel immensely. The same goes for liking and subscribing
of course, but you probably already know that. Anyway, thank you so much for watching,
and I'm looking forward to seeing you in the next one.