Southern Bluefin Tuna Case (Conflicting treaty obligations)

Global Affairs Academy
6 followers
Jun 4, 2026
In this international law case the parties (Australia & New Zealand v Japan) were bound by two applicable treaties with different dispute resolution mechanisms. Which of those should prevail? The ICJ found that this is an ongoing problem made more and more complex by the ever-increasing network of bilateral and small multilateral treaties
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedSince the Cold War, international law has shifted from large multilateral treaties toward smaller, bilateral or limited multilateral agreements. This trend creates a \"patchwork\" of overlapping obligations, as seen in the dispute between Australia, New Zealand, and Japan over tuna fishing, highlighting the complexity of determining jurisdiction and enforcement when multiple treaties apply.
One key feature of international law since the end of the Cold War is less large multilateral
treaties involving many countries and more bilateral treaties between two countries or
smaller multilateral treaties involving a limited number of nations. Between 1973 and 1982 most
nations in the world became parties to the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea or UNCLOS.
This treaty includes measures for the protection of biodiversity in the marine environment. In 1993
however, Australia, New Zealand and Japan concluded a much smaller treaty, the Convention for the
Conservation of Southern Bluefin Tuna. These three nations were all involved in fishing for southern
bluefin tuna and they had a collective interest in carefully managing the tuna stocks. In 1998
stocks were still declining but Japan commenced what it described as scientific fishing for
southern bluefin tuna. Australia and New Zealand said that this fishing was in fact commercial
fishing in breach of the 1993 Convention. Australia and New Zealand then commenced action in the United
Nations in the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea, the body charged with resolving disputes
under UNCLOS. Japan challenged the tribunal's jurisdiction because the much smaller 1993
Convention contained a separate dispute resolution process. Japan said that Australia and New Zealand
should have followed that process instead. The tribunal noted that this was not an unusual
situation in international law. They said it is a common place of international law and state
practice for more than one treaty to bear upon a particular dispute. There is no reason why a given
act of a state may not violate its obligations under more than one treaty. There is frequently a
parallelism of treaties both in their substantive content and in their provisions for settlement of
disputes arising thereunder. The current range of international legal obligations benefits from a
process of accretion and accumulation. The tribunal tried to determine whether it had jurisdiction or
not by undertaking a detailed and quite artificial process of pulling apart the language of the two
treaties. They determined that in this instance the dispute resolution process of the 1993 Treaty
should take precedence. What we learned from this case is that in the modern patchwork of many small
overlapping treaties it can be difficult for nations and for international bodies to work out
precisely what their obligations are and precisely how they can be enforced.
