The Committee on Energy and Commerce is the oldest standing legislative committee (established 1795) in the U.S. House of Representatives and is vested with the broadest jurisdiction of any congressional authorizing committee. The Energy and Commerce Committee is at the forefront of all issues and policies powering America’s economy, including our global competitive edge in energy, technology, and health care. The committee is led by E&C Chairman Brett Guthrie (KY-02) and E&C Ranking Member Frank Pallone (NJ-06). The Subcommittee on Environment is led by Chairman Gary Palmer (AL-06) and Ranking Member Paul Tonko (NY-20).
Good afternoon. I'd like to welcome everyone to today's hearing entitled
Rules of the Road, Examining Legislation to Modernize the Clean Air Act's Mobile Source
Requirements. This hearing continues the committee's efforts to modernize the Clean Air Act
to reflect the modern landscape of air emissions and trends. At the core of the Clean Air Act is
the idea that we can protect our environment without sacrificing economic growth. But it's
been decades since Congress updated the Act, causing many of its outdated provisions to become
burdensome and counterproductive to its original goals. That's why this committee is considering
nuanced and tailored updates to improve the Clean Air Act. Today, we will consider 10 pieces of
legislation that aim to provide common sense updates to Title II of the Clean Air Act,
which governs mobile sources. I welcome feedback from our witnesses and others as the committee
considers these bills. I also would like to thank Representative Fedorchik and Representative
Langworthy for their work on these bills and their leadership in modernizing the mobile source
provisions of the Clean Air Act. The witnesses we will hear from today have extensive experience
with the challenges presented by out-of-date provisions and are well suited to explain their
impact. I look forward to the testimony on the discussion drafts and legislation. I'm particularly
interested in testimony that relates to the continued use of the California Waiver and the
Clean Air Act. One of the bills we will consider today epitomizes concerns of the committee. The
Locomotives Act, introduced by Representative LaMoffa and championed by Representative Obernolte,
illustrates the problematic outcomes associated with the waiver. In 2023, the California Air
Resources Board proposed a rule that would ban the operation of any locomotive 23 years
or older from operating in California unless it is running on a zero emissions configuration.
The proposed rule, issued in the twilight of the Biden-Harris presidency, was withdrawn before the
current administration took office, but it would have effectively prohibited 67 percent of the
national locomotive fleet from entering California and accessing two of the nation's largest ports.
Under this proposal, trains would be required to stop at the California border or any state that
might adopt these standards and wait for a compliant train to collect their cargo,
increasing transit time and cost. These disruptions to our national rail system would
also impact national security, causing delays and operational breakdowns. Two of the largest
rail carriers in the United States estimate that they would each have to pay the state of California
$800 million annually in compliance costs. Basically, rail would be economically infeasible
in California, and these costs would be passed along to American consumers. This is especially
worrisome because under the Clean Air Act, the California rule would become national in scope.
Two-thirds of the locomotive fleet would be prohibited from operating in California by 2030,
and even more states could have adopted this approach under the Clean Air Act.
I have real concerns with allowing the state of California to set national emission standards
for trains, cars, and all other mobile sources, especially given its track record of Green New
Deal policies and EV mandates. Our vast nation depends on a complex and healthy transportation
system. California should not dictate national policy. Congress needs to do its job and modernize
the existing statute. We must revise existing law to meet modern life. If we do not, our nation's
families will pay the price. I thank the members of this committee who are leading these efforts,
and I hope my colleagues will take this opportunity to engage in positive discussions
about the legislation before the committee today. Thank you.