Marco Rubio's recent comments on NATO reveal two things at once: how communication actually works inside the Trump White House, and what the United States really gets out of its NATO membership. When senior officials can't speak freely to the leader, they find other ways to get their message across. In this video I look at how Rubio appears to be communicating to Trump through the TV — and why it looks surprisingly familiar to anyone who has followed Russian politics.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This video analyzes Marco Rubio's recent comments regarding NATO and the United States' role in global alliances. The speaker argues that Rubio is not criticizing Europe, but rather attempting to persuade Donald Trump to maintain the alliance system by highlighting the strategic benefits of power projection and global reach that have historically secured U.S. superpower status.
It's been a while since I released a video because I've been very busy and also sick,
but I thought I'd get back into it by making a pretty simple video about something that
Marco Rubio said recently that I found interesting. It's about whether the United States should
withdraw from NATO, given that many NATO allies have been reluctant to help the United States
with a war on Iran. I think it says something interesting both about what the United States
actually gets out of being in NATO, but also about how communication works internally in
There are several interesting aspects to what Marco Rubio has been saying about NATO in the
wake of the war on Iran, but before I go into those things, I think it would be helpful to
just hear an example of how Marco Rubio talks about it. So here is Marco Rubio talking about
a meeting he had with the Italian Prime Minister, Giorgia Maloney.
That's a decision for the president to make. It's a decision every president makes.
The fact of the matter though is, and I said publicly and I've said repeatedly,
I've been a strong supporter of NATO throughout my career in the Senate and even now.
One of the advantages of being in NATO is that it allows us to have forces deployed in Europe
and bases that allow us a logistical ability to project power in case of contingencies.
Well, we had a contingency and some countries in Europe, like Spain as an example, denied us the
use of those bases for a very important contingency that in some ways the denial of those bases
actually impeded the mission, not severely, but at a cost and in fact even created some
unnecessary dangers. So one of the main reasons why the US is in NATO is the ability to have
forces deployed in Europe that we could project to other contingencies. And now that's no longer
the case, at least when it comes to some NATO members, that's a problem and has to be examined.
But ultimately that's a decision for the president to make. His team and people like myself and
others will provide him what those potential options are, but ultimately he'll have to make
that decision. He hasn't made those decisions yet. I think there are fundamentally three
important things to say about what Marco Rubio said here. The first one is that it is going to
make people angry in Europe. These statements are not going to be well received here. The reason
is that Rubio essentially argues that the United States is engaged in NATO, not because it is
interested in defending other alliance members, but rather because it enables the United States
to project power outside of NATO. And that's a problematic statement because NATO is fundamentally
a defensive alliance and it's not in any of the founding documents of NATO that any member state
needs to assist with wars of aggression that other member states might conduct around the world.
So the way people hear Marco Rubio's statement here in Europe is that the United States doesn't
really care about protecting the European allies against Russia. And that's kind of problematic
because in Europe, it really seems like the most important task for the alliance at the moment is
to defend against Russia. So many Europeans get angry when they hear Rubio saying these things,
but I think it's important to understand that it doesn't really matter what the Europeans think
because Rubio is not actually talking to the Europeans. It sounds as if he is, but in reality,
he's not. What Rubio is actually doing is trying to contribute to the American debate about NATO
by framing the answer the way he does. The argument he's trying to bring to the table is that there
are actually important benefits for the United States in being part of NATO. And that's an
important perspective because many of the other top figures in the American administration don't
really seem to share that perspective. They only complain about how the Europeans are useless as
allies, and they try to take advantage of the United States and things like that. So what Rubio
is trying to point out here is that there are actually significant advantages for the United
States in having this global system of alliances that was built after the Second World War.
Having allies across the globe has allowed the United States to project power worldwide by
taking advantage of bases and infrastructure and intelligence networks and all kinds of other
things and resources that come along with having partners that are scattered around the globe in
strategic positions. So when Rubio complains about how the Europeans have not allowed the United
States to use those bases during the war in Iran, on first glance, it sounds like criticism of the
Europeans and that he's arguing that maybe the United States should perhaps withdraw from NATO.
But in reality, what he's saying is that the Americans need to think very carefully before
starting to dismantle that system that has given the United States this global reach as a military
power. I think it's actually perfectly fair for American politicians to make that argument and to
justify their contribution to NATO by looking at what kinds of benefits the United States gets out
of these global alliances. It's a bit naive if Europeans think that the United States is only
engaged in NATO for our benefit. The reality is that NATO is just one part of a global system of
alliances that has, in fact, been extremely beneficial for the United States. It is this
system that has made the United States a global superpower. It's also the system that's made the
United States the richest country in the world. And that's also why I think it's an absolute
tragedy for the United States that they are now dismantling this system because that is,
in fact, what Donald Trump's policies are leading to. So there is something almost absurd about the
richest country in the world complaining about how everyone else is taking advantage of them.
But that is actually the message coming from many people at the top of the American system right now,
from Trump, from Vance, from Hexeth, etc. And Rubio is trying to set up a counter-argument
against those people and to point out that maybe it's not the greatest idea to withdraw
from the alliances that have made the United States such a strong country over the last century.
So that's the second point. Rubio is not actually talking to the Europeans here. He's trying to
contribute to an American debate about engagement in the global alliance system and whether it's a
good idea to withdraw from NATO. And of all the people in the top of the American administration,
Rubio actually seems to be the one who understands what's at stake.
The last thing I want to point out is that what Rubio is doing here says quite a lot about how
things work inside the Trump administration today. If you've been following Russian politics for a
longer period of time, this style of communication that Rubio demonstrates is going to be remarkably
familiar because that's exactly how people in the circles around Putin have been trying to
communicate for years. They don't have access to Putin personally, or they can't tell him directly
what they think. So instead, they try to transmit messages to Putin through the media. And since
they also can't say directly in the media that they disagree with Putin, or that they think
Putin might have missed something, or things like that, then what they do instead is they
wrap it in a container where, ostensibly, they are explaining to the public what Putin is doing
and why it's brilliant and smart because it addresses this or that issue. But then they
attach the message that they want to get through to Putin as if it were an issue that he's already
trying to address, when in reality it's not, but it's something that they would like Putin to be
aware of and they would like him to address. This message by Rubio smells exactly the same.
He's trying to get a message through to Donald Trump about how the United States is actually
benefiting from NATO and that it would be a bad idea to do anything drastic. But he's trying to
conceal it in a way that makes it appear as if he's simply explaining to the public what kinds
of considerations Donald Trump is already making. I think it says quite a lot about how things work
inside the White House today that Rubio appears to be resorting to this type of public communication
to get a message through to the leader. Rubio is, after all, both the Secretary of State,
he is the National Security Advisor, but apparently he does not have direct access to discuss these
issues face-to-face with the President. Now, I don't think it's actually because Rubio doesn't
have physical access to Donald Trump, but it does correlate with stories about how Trump is really
difficult to deal with in face-to-face meetings. As his advisor, you're not really allowed to tell
him something he doesn't know or you're not allowed to appear to be lecturing him because
he doesn't like that. And he also doesn't like to receive long briefings on stuff. So every message
has to be a maximum of 45 seconds long. But at the same time, it's also well known that Donald Trump
likes to watch TV and to consume a lot of news that way. And what this type of communication
from Rubio indicates is that his closest advisors apparently find it easier to reach the President
through TV interviews than they do in actual physical meetings with him, or at least that
they feel that what they tell him in private needs to be reinforced by making sure that he gets the
same message again when he watches the news on TV in the evening. So I do think this message from
Marco Rubio is interesting for several reasons. First, it does lay out the argument for why the
United States actually benefits from this global system of alliances that has been built up over
many decades and has made the United States the richest and strongest country in the world.
But it also tells us something about how decision making in the White House happens and how Donald
Trump's closest advisors apparently feel the need to communicate with him through the media rather
than doing it face to face. So suddenly we see this strange phenomenon from Russia that we've
known there for a while where people try to influence the President's policies by pretending
to explain in the media what the President is doing. This phenomenon is beginning to show up
in the American media landscape as well, and I think that's worth noticing. Now, before I wrap up,
I just want to mention that my book is finally out in international bookstores such as Amazon,
Barnes & Noble, and other international retailers. The book actually came out in English around
Christmas, but so far it's been kind of difficult to order internationally because you could only
get it through bookstores in Denmark or you could get it directly from me. But unfortunately,
that has meant that shipping costs have been very high. Actually, for most countries,
the shipping costs have been higher than the price of the book itself, and obviously that
is not great. But now that you can get it in international bookstores, the costs are
much more manageable. I'm going to leave a couple of links in the video description where you can
get the book, but really you can just search for it anywhere and it should be easy to find.
If you order it this way, it will be a paper bag and not a hard bag like this, but the words inside
are exactly the same. I've also received quite a lot of requests for the audiobook. It is coming.
It was supposed to be out a long time ago, but we ran into some problems with it. It's actually
a kind of interesting story. I will tell it at a later point, but the audiobook is coming and we
are working hard on it. And with that, I am going to wrap it up. But if you found the video helpful
or informative, then please leave it a like and remember to subscribe to the channel and click the
bell icon so you will get notifications when I publish new videos. And if you want to support
the channel, you can get access to also some bonus videos if you subscribe on my website
www.LogicAward.com. Thank you very much for watching, and I will see you again next time.