Sure. It's cool to drink a bottle of great wine, but you never can get a true grip on 'how' good it was unless you have another bottle for context. Better than one other bottle, is two, or heck - a whole flight. Here, John Jens (aka JJ) and I open seven great Shiraz from Australia to see not just how the vintages are tracking post-release, but to see how their differences stack up on the table. In this video, we span different regions (Barossa, Hunter, Clare and Eden Valleys, Frankland River, South Australia and McLaren Vale), different vintages (2017 - 2021) and different styles of Shiraz. It was fascinating to open them all at the same time, and to look at the wines as they evolved over the course of an hour or so in the glass. I touch on a few past videos for context (links below), but perhaps most importantly, the concept of 'quality VS style', which I dive deep into in my recent scoring video. - 0:00 - Intro 1:51 - 2021 Tyrrell's 8 Acres Shiraz, Hunter Valley (13.3% alc) 5:44 - 2019 Torbreck RunRig Shiraz Viognier, Barossa Valley (15% alc) 8:37 - 2020 Swinney Farvie Syrah, Frankland River (14% alc) 15:00 - 2018 Penfolds Grange, South Australia (14.5% alc) 21:26 - 2018 Wendouree Shiraz, Clare Valley (13.5% alc) 26:20 - 2017 Henschke Hill of Grace Shiraz, Eden Valley (14% alc) 32:02 - 2018 Clarendon Hills Astralis Shiraz, McLaren Vale (14.5% alc) - Video links: How Wine Scoring Works - • How Wine Scoring Works - We opened the new Grange + Hill of Grace, Astralis, Laird + Powell & Son - • We opened the new Grange + Hill of Grace, ... - Penfolds Grange with Peter Gago - • Penfolds Grange with Peter Gago - Any review you see on my socials ( / erinllarkin , this channel and my website (https://www.erinlarkin.com.au) are never paid for by wineries or anyone else: the wines are featured on their merits - because they have risen to the top in tastings. If you try the wines I recommend and you like them - good! Because so do I. Thành phần nội dung
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This exploration of iconic Australian Shiraz examines how regional terroir, vine age, and winemaking philosophies shape the variety. From the elegant, low-alcohol profiles of the Hunter Valley to the bold power of the Barossa and the emerging quality of Western Australia, the discussion highlights the evolution of the region toward greater refinement and diverse stylistic expressions.
Hi, Happy New Year. JJ, I've got JJ back here again, John Jens, and we are looking at some
of Australia's greatest charades, but in context, because one bottle at a time is super cool, but
it's not actually that interesting until you put them into context and you work out what you like
and how much you like it and why. I really agree, absolutely and totally. So in the old days,
and you know, 30, 40 years ago, if an Australian was travelling overseas, an Australian winemaker
was travelling overseas to sell wine, the first question and the most important question he was
asked every time was, do you have a charade? Do you have it with you? Australia's exports
were based on charades and although we only produced 3% of the world's wine, we exported
an enormous amount of it and we were one of the largest suppliers in the UK and the largest
suppliers into America. Unbelievable from 3%, but true. These are the styles of wine that created
imagery about it and we've got here a cross section of single vineyard wines and blended
wines and tiny producers and some of the iconic producers. These are amongst the best of what
Australia does and in general, in the last four or five years, last two or three years of these
releases, I guess it's probably the last two or three years since they've been released, each of
these producers have produced the greatest wines, in my opinion, they ever have. Wine making is
getting better, fruit is getting better, depending on new technology and new knowledge in both areas,
I reckon the wines are getting better and better. And I think really interestingly for me, we're
looking at it not just a cross section of producer sizes and sourcing arrangements, but also
we're looking at different alcohols, different oak treatments, different regions and I think
they're really important when we consider the overall style of the wine. So let's just dive in
and we're just going to unpick things as we go because there's a lot to discuss.
So starting in the first glass, we've got the 2021 Tyrrell's 8 Acres Shiraz. This is part of the
sacred site range and they're very difficult to get, they're very hard to get. You've got to be
on the mailing list, but the mailing list is tiered, you've got to be in the top tier to get your allocation
and then you can purchase them. The wines are cheap, extraordinarily cheap for what they are, I mean
the vines for this vineyard were planted in the 1890s, just wild, really beautiful old stuff. You can
see here I've got the old patch, the Four Acres and Jono's and you know some of the vines here go
back to the 1879 for the Four Acres, so really, really old vine material and picked at a really
sensitive time, 13.3% alcohol makes it the lowest on the table and for me it's just pure and clear,
there's red fruits, red snakes, peppercorn, it's got this gorgeous flow of... If anybody's overseas
are they going to know what red snakes are? Oh you know jellies, like the jelly lollies. Lollies
is a different word in America too you know, sweets. They keep changing it in my tasting notes
to lollipop, I'm like it's not lollipop, they're different, sweets, anyway like gummies. It's got
that real raspberry character, but the good thing about Hunter Valley, the beautiful thing about it
is you get this flow of ferruginous tannin, which ferrous and rust and it's beautiful but super fine
and bloody and that's what you get here, it's balanced and complete and just sensational. I
love it, I love it, like I want to drink it, which is ultimately the best compliment you can give a
wine. Okay, so for me, a big wine, a big Shiraz producing region, actually a big Shiraz producing
state is South Australia, easily and clearly. There are finer, more elegant varietals,
styles in Victoria and Tasmania and a little bit in Western Australia,
but the Hunter Valley and New South Wales is a revelation, but only if you can never get to find
the wines. I've asked Erin about these recently because she's seen more of them than I am,
she's talking about McWilliams and she's talking about Tyrells. Not McWilliams, well yes,
Mount Pleasant. Oh Mount Pleasant, sorry good point. Mount Pleasant and also the Brokenwood
Graveyard Vineyard, there's some incredible vineyard sites in Hunter Valley producing
sensational age-worthy wines. The cool thing about it is that the style, so we're not talking
about the quality, but the style in Hunter for great Hunter Shiraz is slightly lower alcohol
than you will find say in South Australia, for example. I mean you're seeing low 13s here,
I think Graveyard is 14.5, which is very high for Hunter. Morris O'Shea, Mount Pleasant,
excellent wine, also in the mid 14s. These wines are high alcohol for Hunter,
of a lower style, which I really like. You can drink more of it. So I'm 74, when I was young,
the wines of these styles and the Mount Pleasant were legendary. You didn't ever see them,
fine, elegant, round, balanced, long, very, very finely textural, no obvious tannins,
and that's exactly what this is. This is the generations passing down to this particular
wine and this particular style. First time I've tried it, Cur of the Sea of Aaron, absolutely
stunning. You used red snakes, it's red berries. Delicious, since I must line up, may sound
heretical, if I'm wrong, I'm wrong, I would have picked it as a French Pinot. I think it's delicious,
sensational, brilliant finish, brilliant aftertaste. Aaron said around about a hundred
dollars. At a hundred dollars, I'd recommend that to anyone. Great wine. You're going to have to
work out how you're going to get on that mailing list though. Great. I'm very grateful. Thank you.
Yeah, we need to call Chris Terrell is what we need to do. Moving into the second wine,
this is the 2019 Torbreck Run Rig from Barossa Valley. So the Run Rig vineyard is a single
vineyard, like the Eight Acres is a single vineyard, single vineyard wine, and it's got
an inclusion of Vionia, which is co-planted with the Shiraz in that vineyard. This is 15%.
This is a big wine from a hot vintage. 19 was the first of two very warm and dry vintages, 19 and 20
back to back. And I think you really see that kind of brooding, dense, black, moody, Darth Vader
character in this wine. It's huge. An oak, charry, resinous oak. Do we know what the proportion of
Vionia is? That's low. It's like 2% something. Okay. But I noticed some of those same slippery
characters on others of Torbreck's wines as well. Do you think some of the others have Vionia in
them too? Yeah, some do. I can't remember off the top of my head which they are, yeah.
The thing about Torbreck is the wines are all, it's a style, right? So the Torbreck wines are
really big and glossy and high alcohol, but the fruit is so excellent. And Ian Hongerl,
the winemaker, is really, he makes really glossy, polished wines. So they're big,
but they're awesome. So you just have to decide whether or not that style is for you. It's not
for everyone. It's not for me, but I can absolutely and certainly appreciate it. And I've given some
blistering scores to the Torbreck Reds because he just executes it so bloody well. Very smart wines.
So I mentioned Shiraz and the people overseas, the importers overseas wanting Australian Shiraz.
This is the style. This wine in the past was the style that they wanted.
This is a more refined version. You've talked about Ian and what he's doing.
And he's obviously a very clever and a very classy winemaker. And this is the modern,
slightly refined version. So it's still got the power, the fruit, the weight, the density,
and the length, but the oak handling down either side is, I think, better selected,
better used. And despite, and we've both known the people from the past who've made the wines there,
15 and 16 in particular were extraordinary from the great vintages. And I will add that in our
restaurants, I'm with the Le Mans restaurant group in Perth, Western Australia, and our customers
come from basically a very wealthy base, very wealthy suburbs around us. If we give them
in any one of the given styles and price ranges, they love them. They think they're fantastic.
I'm probably a touch ahead on the 2015 and 2016, but this is still a lovely wine in the same style
and still one of Australia's better wines. Not cheap at around about $350, $400. Very,
very good wine. Love it. And everything that Erin said, I agree with in terms of style. Yeah.
Moving into Western Australia, it's not often that we talk about Western Australia and quality
Shiraz in the same sentence. That is changing courtesy of Franklin River. And Swinney,
who makes this 2020 Barbie Serrat, is really an important vineyard in the region. So,
we know that Franklin River is a sub-region of the Great Southern, and it is emerging over time. I
mean, there are iconic vineyards there that have been around for a long time that have been
servicing great wines, i.e. Justin Vineyard and the Jack Man from Horton. Great wine,
long been a great wine. The Swinney Vineyard is a very big vineyard, but it's not but,
and it's managed very well and sells fruit to lots of different producers around Western
Australia. So, often when a winery is based in another region, but makes a Franklin River Shiraz,
i.e. a Margaret River winery making a Franklin River Shiraz or a Geograph winery making a
from the Swinney Vineyard. So, we know that this quality of this fruit across the board is very
good. In this wine, these are bush vines, so hand-picked, hand-pruned. They pick the fruit
on a bunch-per-bunch basis. It's super detailed. The winemakers have a very skilled affinity for
grape tannin. So, they're using older, large format oak. So, the tannins that you get from
this wine are not oak-derived but fruit-derived, which I love. 2020 was a warm, short, fast,
large vintage in WA. Low-yielding, small berries, thick skins, early ripening, like the whole bit,
it was intense. This is a very tannic wine for me. It's quite closed. I really like it,
and I love what Franklin River does because it has a really clear expression, regional expression
in all of the wines, in the Riesling, in the Sorrel, and in more recent times, the Grenache
as well. Also, a Swinney wine. So, yeah, lots to say. Love Franklin River. I think we're really
looking at that region in its early stages. I mean, there are producers that have been making
wine there for 30 years, but I think that the trend is we're at the beginning of it.
Okay. So, for me.
Kind of out of breath there. That was a lot of information, but great.
Great little region, yeah.
Okay. So, the first vines are planted down there in the middle 60s, and as the years went by,
and Nuremberg's come back a couple of times to Jack Mann, the great Jack Mann was the
great winemaker in this state for decades, and was sort of the godfather of the industry.
As Tom and I and his family continue on these days, they're all winemakers and chefs,
the whole family, all of us in it. But I knew after looking at wines like Jack Mann and the
Abercrombie from Howard Park, that the winemakers who kept saying that Shiraz was the best red grape
variety from the region, I knew they were wrong. I couldn't understand why they kept saying it.
I could see quite clearly and quite easily that Cabernet was the finest. There's no question at
all. And then suddenly the Swinney vineyards came along, and wines like this and the Grenache from
these guys too, which have been brilliantly reviewed both in Australia and overseas,
and I finally had to confess. I gave up. I waved the white flag. I suddenly realised that despite
the quality of those wines, the Shiraz and the Grenache, in fact, and as Matt Swinney with his
sister Janelle, the owners of the vineyard, which is hundreds of hectares, as they say, they believe
absolutely and totally as against my now erroneous view, that the Southern Rhone varietals are the
future of the region. This wine and the Favi, they're not cheap. They're $150 each. They are,
in my mind, clearly the greatest Shiraz ever made in Western Australia. And I don't put
them amongst the greatest that this country's ever seen, but they're wonderful wines. They're
lighter, beautifully textured, serious length, placid, but fine lingering flavours. This one,
as you said a second ago, had plenty of tannin, more so I think than the two previous vintages,
because it's only the third vintage. I love the style, love where they're going. I'm a proponent.
This style is the future of Western Australian Shiraz, in my opinion.
I agree. I was thinking of so many things while you were talking then. I just always come back
to the region and the dirt and what it is capable of. And I think that this wine, when I was tasting
it while you were talking and thinking and agreeing, there's just such a mineral undercurrent
of ferrous tannin. And I know I said that about Hunter, but I see some similarities.
Franklin is far more kind of rugged than the Hunter in terms of the tannin profile,
but it has that same bloody vein through it. I love that. I love what they're doing. And
they have Merved in the ground as well, which I'm really glad about because I really like Merved.
Actually, my founding experience for great Merved was with the 2002 Picked, because they did a
museum release in 2010 or 11, and I bought a lot of it and drank it all and loved it,
which is their Straight Mataro. And anyway, yeah, I love Merved. So they have some Merved wines
coming, which if you haven't tasted them, they're really excellent and a revelation because again,
it's sort of a new high tide mark for WA and the variety, which is really cool.
I just can... Some of the great producers in Nerf to Pamp put out small batches of
not individual varietal, but other than mainstream varietals dominant in some of their releases,
Morvedra or Mataro is one of them with some of the people, I reckon it's their best release.
I reckon it's their best shadow Nerf to Pamp releases. I reckon some of them are great.
And I love the Swinney Morvedra as well, which is about 50 bucks a bottle, I think.
Awesome.
I think it's fantastic. I love it.
Me too. I've been sort of at Mat for years to... Morved, Morved, he did it.
I didn't know that.
Yeah, I love it. Grange, 2018 Grange, 14 and a half percent sourced from
all around South Australia, maybe elsewhere, South Australian wine.
And you can smell it. I mean, smelling through these wines, they're so different. I mean,
you get this pure kind of fruit expression and mineral overtones in the Tyrells and you move
into the Runrig and it's all charry, resinous oak and licorice, aniseed, dark chocolate, cocoa,
all that sort of stuff. You go into the Farby and it's much more placid. You get kind of mineral
kind of metal shavings and rust and blood and ironstone and black fruit.
And then you get to the Grange and it's just toasted coconut and oak, lots of oak. And
there's fruit there for sure. But I reckon now we've had these bottles on the table.
We've been talking a lot. We've had them on the table nearly two hours, a bit more.
And if anything, I feel like this is only just starting to crest the hill of
aeration. Like I would definitely, definitely be decanting this for many hours before you
open it. Because if anything, the oak has come out more in that two hours and I would expect it
to go the other way. So I reckon it's still got a little while to go before it's ready to drink.
Now, don't tell Karen, but before I drove down here today, I opened up many of these
and ran through them on my own, backwards and forwards, backwards and forwards,
forward and backwards. But I really wanted to get a handle on them.
I reckon people point wines for different reasons. I was with a guy, a great one of it yesterday,
when we looked at some great white burgundies, and he chose one and I chose another. He said
the one that he chose had greater length of flavour. I'm pretty into length of flavour.
I'm pretty sure the other one, which is a 2015 Domaine Le Fleuve Pucelles, the best of their
premier cruise. I thought it was far longer, far more elegant, and I far prefer that. So
everyone has different styles. Erin and I have different styles. Some of the greatest wine
writers in Europe have different preferences from exactly the same wines. In this instance,
I tried this this morning and it's been brilliantly reviewed. Half a dozen people,
four or five people in Australia have given it a hundred points, and a number overseas,
including some of the biggest names in the world of wine writing, have given it a hundred points.
I personally love it. It's rich, it's dense, it's restrained. It has all the oak characters that
Erin was talking about. They're all there, but more restrained than they've been in the past,
unless the word that you used a little while ago was idiosyncratically Australian,
less idiosyncratically Penfold. A marvellous wine. Great length, great power, very, very young.
Perhaps, I'd have to stop back and think back a little, but perhaps the youngest of the Grangers
I've seen in recent times, on release, appears to be the youngest. Massive staying potential.
Erin talked about breathing, so it's actually been breathing since about nine o'clock this morning,
and it's now about two o'clock. In Australia, and Erin and I talk about these things from time to
time, so I think we're under the same agreement, there are many of our wine friends, and most of
our friends are wine fanatics, there are many of our wine friends who would say, if you open
that style of wine, that big, rich, intense, quite heavily oaked style, you open the night before or
in the morning and decant them, put them back in the bottle, and then serve them that night,
they'll be better than if you opened a bottle at the same time and poured them together.
So that is getting better and better as it goes. I love the style, I've loved it for decades,
and because it's a generational thing in my family, my father had a great cellar at Grange too,
and from the time that we were 12, we were given about that much wine, if you can see that,
about that much wine to look at every night at the table, and we were expected to talk about it.
It's generational. I love the style, and it could be just the fact that I'm used to it. I believe
that the Penfold's winemaking team, with their Chardonnays, and their Syrah, and their Cabernets,
and their various labels that they do, which are increasing in number at the very top end
of the market, because they've got access to serious quantities of very, very good fruit.
I believe that they are the greatest winemakers in Australia, and I believe that in the last few
years, their wines have never been so good. They were great in the past. Hugh Johnson
said that it was many, many years ago, said that Grange was the Southern Hemisphere's only first
growth, and it was the big name in Australian wine for decades, and perhaps for a couple of
generations, and I reckon they've got better. I've reviewed this wine, both for Wine Advocate
and in a video, and I'll post the video link below. I had Petty Gaygo here, and we discussed
the new release wines, including the 18 Grange, and I think that vintage-wise, 18 was an excellent
year, and we see that red-fruited clarity in this 18 vintage, and in that scoring video that
I released a couple of weeks ago, again, the link is down below, I talked about the difference
between quality and style, and so in terms of quality, this is an extraordinary wine. We know
that it ages 50 or 60 years and beyond. We know that there's heaps of oak, but there's also heaps
of fruit. It's got a really clear story to it. Quality is very good. So for that reason, it gets
a very high score. When we talk about stylistically what we want to drink, what I want to drink,
I'm more inclined personally to be drinking a lower alcohol, finer, medium-bodied wine,
because I like the detail and the precision that that brings. That does not make it right,
it just means that that is exactly what I like to drink. So stylistically, this is too big for me,
but in terms of a quality rating, it's extraordinarily high. So there is a difference
there, and I really went into detail in that scoring video about the difference between
those two things. We should move on. We've got the 2018 Wendery Shiraz from Clare Valley,
13.5%. This is a really important wine to include, I think, because when we talk about quality
Australian Shiraz, people always go to these two wines. That's totally cool, they're great,
they are, they've earned their position. But the story is so much broader and more detailed than
just those two wines, and so that's why I brought a Hunter wine. That's why there's a Wendery,
this is a Colt wine. So Tony and Leader Brady in Clare Valley, you can only buy this wine off
their mailing list. In order to get on the mailing list, you have to write them a handwritten letter,
which then gets filed and included in the allocation mailer when it's appropriate,
either when someone leaves the mailing list or if there's space. I was there in October,
I judged at the Clare Valley show and I had dinner with them. I will tell you this quick
story because Tony said, do you want to taste? And I was like, I would love to. So he's like,
what do you want to taste? I was like, whatever you think. And a little bit later on, he's like,
so do you want to taste? I was like, yeah, I'd love to. What do you want to taste? Whatever
you reckon. He asked me a third time over the course of two hours, and I was like, I'm not
being rude. I know I'm being rude when I'm not giving you a specific answer, but I'm kind of
intimidated, which is weird for me because I see so many winemakers and wineries, but I didn't come
here to taste. I came here to meet you and to kind of just be part of that. So of course, I'm
deeply honoured that we can taste, but I don't want to impose and say, yes, I'd like to taste
all these things. He was like, oh, why don't you just say so? Let's go. So we went to the winery
and tasted all these beautiful things from tank because they store them in tank until they
classify them, blend them and then put them into barrels. So it was a hugely illuminating experience
for me on a number of different levels. But the one that was most important, I think, which I'd
like to talk about here in the context of this wine is the inherent character of the Wendery wines
when they are young, because when I tried them at such an incoherent stage, 2021 wines, in 2022,
they have this essence of Wendery about them that can sometimes taper over time, but I got the
essence of it then. And so I'm going to tell you what that tastes like. And for me, it was this
rose petal character, like a fresh garden rose, really aromatic and beautiful. The
petals themselves have a character and these wines have this like rose petal, minerals,
a little bit graphite, there's rust and blood. They're very clean, pure, sparkling sort of wines
and in the mouth now, very sedate and restrained and quite back palate, you know. Okay. So two of
the wines here have full recommended retail prices of over a thousand dollars. Another one's a little
over 500. Another one's around about 400 and the others aren't cheap. This wine that Aaron has
chosen to put in, firstly, it's got a cult following almost not like nothing else in the
country. In the big reviews and the big rankings, such as LinkedIn's, I think it's in the very top
range. And I think I might have two or three wines in there. So the world wants them. Australia wants
them. The wine lovers want them. They're prepared to pay an enormous amount for them. And if you
were going to buy this from the winery, what sort of price would you pay for it? Oh, I think it's $60
a bottle. And so $60 for some people is their second or third range wine. Yet this is one of
the most sought after wines in the country and they're selling it for that sort of price for
Celador. So some people may be grabbing it at Celador and then, or from their mail order list.
Oh yeah, you can't get it. There's no Celador. You can't get it. No tastings. And then maybe
even put it into auction. So they've got to be careful. Yeah, that's frowned upon, I think.
So at this stage, it has less volume, I think, than each of the other ones here. It's
understated, but it's also, what, a 15th or even a 20th of the price of some of these.
Quite extraordinary. And yet it's regarded, and the word that Erin and I were talking about before,
it's revered in the same way as some of these others are. It's quite an extraordinary wine.
And those rose petal characters and the density that's in there, I hadn't noticed it until you
mentioned it. I went and looked at it then. I agree totally with Erin's terminology, but I
hadn't picked up on it at the time. Yes, another outstanding wine and great value for money and
good that we included it in, I think. Yeah, absolutely. And I will do a Wendery
Vertical or Horizontal or something at some point, but I have next to none of the bottles. So
it's really going to be determined by when I can buy some more and then I'll open them,
which I feel like is really altruistic. But anyway, moving into the sixth wine,
because we do have to get moving. This is the 2017 Hentschke Hill of Grace from the
Hill of Grace Vineyard in the Eden Valley, which is obviously a zone of the Barossa Zone. So
Barossa Valley, Eden Valley, Barossa Zone. And Eden Valley is a really evocative and beautiful
place. And I always talk about it on these videos and it might be repetitive, but it's got this old
Australia feel. I mean, these gorgeous, gorgeous old big gums and kind of boulders that sort of
come out of the earth all over the place. It's just got this kind of magical feel about it. It's
quite severe and the wines are quite severe. And I like that too. They've got a gorgeous mineral
graphite vein. Now this, for me, 2017 was cool. I found the quality to be quite up and down
across the board from South Australia when it came to the 17 vintage. And for me, this wine
is just so savoury. There's like ham hock and pan juices and enoki mushroom and soy sauce and
truffles and meat, you know, meat. So for me, it's a little savoury and a little dry, I suppose, but
gorgeous finesse of tannin. I think that's the old vines, right? It's beautiful structure,
but not my preferred vintage for the flavours that it delivers.
He's got his separate thought on it. We're proud each to have our own thoughts on the wines and
we stick to them, as you already know, if you've seen any of our videos before. And I repeat that
some of the greatest wine writers in the English language in Europe, in the English language,
have polarised views on exactly the same wines from the same vintages. There's nothing wrong
with having your own opinion and sticking to it and always do. No one else should tell you what's
a good wine. Work it out for yourself and practise it. You get better at everything you practise.
In this instance, yes, I am a fan of this wine. Now, Erin has a way of using words and she has a
wine vocabulary and a way of putting, weaving the words together that I don't have. And my
generation didn't use the terms that she used a few seconds ago, such as pan juices, enoki mushrooms,
meat, and the first one you used was? Soy sauce.
Yeah, you used soy sauce. Ham hock.
Ham hock. Now, but as soon as I picked it up and started smelling it, that is there.
That's there too. That's there. But my generation had never gotten used to those. I think you've
summed it up really well. I think it's very good. Now, but so I know that this is more overtly
flavoured in those areas than previous vintages, but I'm a very, well, you know, I'm not a very
forgiving man, but in this instance, I'm a forgiving man. I believe, I reckon that everyone
likes wine for different reasons. So I reckon if you've got a grange, you'd like it because of the
power, the strength, the structuring, the great power of the density and those tendons down either
side. Something like our version of Chateau Latour. If you could have a rich, dense, intense,
deeply coloured DRC Pinot Noir, we get a fine, elegant, fragrant, wafting Pinot Noir from
another great Grand Cru vineyard. There's all different flavours and characters. You can have
a great Chateau Ekem, which I'm sure Erin drinks a lot more of than she should.
I've got some for dinner tonight, actually.
Which is just unctuous and seamless, but they're not the things that make a great wine, in my
opinion. My view is that the thing that makes a great wine is length of flavour. This has got
length of flavour, in Robbie Hillsmith terms, in spades. This has those characters that Erin's
talking about, which I think are a little bit overt, but I'm forgiving of those because you've
got that flavour initially, those flavours up here, but then by the time you get to the middle palate,
it's becoming longer, leaner, lingering, silky-textured, and just lingers and lingers
and lingers and just gradually dances and drifts away. And I love that. I'm into the length of
flavour, so I'll forgive the slightly overt nature of the characters that you're talking about
and think it's absolutely marvellous. I love this wine. Erin's already discussed the vintage to an
extent. For a vintage that wasn't great, it's a triumph for the vintage, quite possibly the
best wine, quite possibly, I'm not saying it is because I need to stop and really think about
that and look at some of our tasting notes, could be the best wine of the vintage out of that
general region. And I'd also say that, and Erin and I have talked about this before as well,
the Hill of Graces in the past were truly wonderful. When I was young, they were great.
My dad just loved them. They were the first wines I settled for in the 1970 vintage. But,
the more recently, despite the fact, just during the 80s, the 90s, the noughties,
the wines were fantastic. They were great. Right now, they have never been as good. I've said to
Erin previously that I reckon the 2015 isn't a great half-dozen Australian reds I've ever tried.
That was exquisite. Tyson Stelzer, who Erin used to work with at the Wine Companion, and who's one
of the great names in Australian wine, he says he believes the 16 is better. I don't. I'll stick
with the 15. I'll always stick with the 15. Thank you. So, I reckon Henschke 2 have never done
better. The wines are truly great. And I know this isn't the greatest of all of them, because of the
characters that Erin's talking about, and because they're slightly less vintage, but under the
circumstances, brilliant wine. I love it, and I'll love it in the years to come. I'm sure you're
probably right about the years to come bit. I think it will age beautifully. In the final glass,
we've got the 2018 Clarendon Hills Astralis, which is from Clarendon in McLaren Vale.
And this is a really interesting wine, because like all of them, they are evolving and changing
over time. And certainly, this one is coming together a little better than it has previous,
because when we looked at it together earlier, I said it's very ripe. It is ripe. It's 14.7%
alcohol, but it tastes ripe as well. It's got like a plum pudding, shortcrust pastry,
jam sort of character to it. But actually now, as it's breathing, the tannins are sort of rising
through that, and it's becoming more of a savory wine, which is very cool, because it is quite
sweet. The style of Astralis is opulent and luxe. And I've used the word sybaritic quite a bit in
Tasty Notes to describe some of these sorts of wines. Sybaritic, yeah, it's a great word.
It's kind of got sexual overtones, but it essentially refers to like lush, opulent,
voluminous, generous sort of characters, right? And that's what that style of Astralis is over
the years. That's what it is. I mean, it's garnered, I don't know the number, but many
hundred point scores. And actually, interestingly, I know I'm talking a lot, but interestingly,
while I was there in June, we looked at, I tasted with Roman and Alex, and we looked at the
20. There was no 19. The 18, the 17, and the 90. I can't remember if it's 94 or 96,
but it was the first labelled Astralis. And I liked the 20 the most. Like, I don't know,
it was a very hot year. Maybe they picked it a bit early. It had a bit more restraint, very fresh.
I loved it. But to me, it was a little shift in the right direction from the 18,
which felt ripe then and feels ripe now. You know, I know you're taking breaths at all then,
but just wait. When we looked at the old Astralis, Roman opened it and he was like,
just wait. He's just going like this. Hold on. And he wanted to make sure if it was right to taste.
Alex and I are like, and he's like, just wait. And we're kind of like, just hold on. It's pretty
good now. Now you can go. We were there maybe like five minutes, maybe 10 minutes. He's sort
of just sitting on this bench overlooking the vineyard waiting. But it was a beautiful wine,
and it sort of shows that it had moved into this really lovely pinot place. You know,
a truffly pinot sort of space. It was very light and gorgeous. Definitely a great example of an
aged Astralis and why aging Shiraz can take it into a really beautiful and new.
Okay. Now, many, many years ago, when I was young, at one stage, I did tasting of the 1978 Bordeauxs,
and the Bordeauxs were fantastic. The 79s came out and they were very good as well. I did tastings
over here in Western Australia, lined up 15 or 20 of them at a time, charged people to come along,
and people loved them. Now, I don't recall what vintage it was. It might've been 80 or 81. I did
it the following year as well. And the wines were really disappointing as compared to what we'd
seen. And I said to the room, because I sell what I believe in, in our retail stores and our
restaurants. I said, guys, if I was you, I wouldn't buy any of these. I'm disappointed in these. And
someone said, well, why on earth have you put them on? I said, if all you ever did was look at the great
wines, how would you know that they were good wines unless you tried lesser wines as well?
So I think it's very important that you see both sides. So in this instance, the last tasting of
these wines, of some of these wines, the key wines here that Erin and I did, we looked at the 2015
and 2016 vintages. Great vintages for Shiraz. I'm going to put the link to that video down in
the link as well, because if you haven't seen that, it's quite a cool intro to this because we
look at the Astralis, the Hill of Grace and the Grange. We look at the Laird from Torbrach
and the Powell and Sons Steinert Flaxmans from Eden. So that's a cool thing to look at if you
haven't seen it yet. With great information and the wines are very good. Now, some of these from
17, some of these are from 19, not quite as good of vintages. And I think it shows to an extent.
I've said that the Henschke from 17 was a triumph for the vintage, but it's not as good as 15 and
16, I don't think, in terms of quality. Now I'm a little bit that way on this guy. I just, it's,
so over the years, Astralis has wowed the world. It's only about, I spoke to Alex, Alex has come
into Perth to host Tasting First on a couple of occasions, and Alex Bratasiak, from the family
that make the wines, he said they make about 17,000 cases of which 1,000 dozen only are sold
in Australia. All the rest is sold overseas because the reputation overseas is extraordinary.
It's fantastic. In America, the Astralis, and I don't recall the exact periods, but a five-year
period, a 10-year period and a 15-year period, which I looked at some years ago, four or five
years ago, just to get context. I was looking for the context. I averaged the points over that
period of time. They averaged high points in Grange and high points in Hill of Grace,
which are Australia's flag bearers overseas. So it's an extraordinary achievement. The wines were
bigger, softer, rounder, incredibly complex, great length, wonderful finishes, wonderful aftertaste,
almost opulent, but all in balance, flowing, not quite the richness perhaps of Run Rig and that
slight viscosity that comes perhaps from the Viognier, or you might think of other things,
but nevertheless, truly great wines. I think that this is a wonderful wine,
but I think that 15 and 16 are pretty good. And given that Erin says, which she did say a couple
of minutes ago, and we're going to hold it to it, that the 20, she's had a good look at, she thinks
it's slightly better. I'm looking forward to see that come out. So when do you reckon that will be
coming out? I don't know. I think it's released, but I don't know. But I don't know. Okay. We'll
check it out though. But great news. If it is out there now, and given Erin's thoughts and I've
compared to the others, which are great, it'll be worthwhile seeking out and going for it. I love
the style and this finish is very good. It's a very, very good wine. Not my favourite in this
line-up and I've seen better. There's some stiff competition here. Absolutely. But not my greatest
experience of Australia so far, but not far behind it. Yeah, that's it. Epic wines.
Thanks for watching. If you haven't subscribed, please do already because I have so many more
things coming up this year. 2023 is going to be big and you wouldn't want to be the last to know
about it. Are we allowed to talk very briefly about New Zealand? Sure. I mean, the announcement
should be happening today, so it will probably happen this week. So this might even be a
forward announcement, but I'm going to take over reviewing New Zealand for the Wine Advocate.
Should have been as of the 2nd of January, which is today. So we'll see where that goes,
but it's going to be a big year full of great wine. So for both Australia and New Zealand and
also for Erin Larkin. We can include La Colina in this. Have you had that? Oh my God. Yeah,
really great. God bless. Thank you very much. Thank you.