Birth rates are falling across the world. In many countries, populations are already shrinking, schools are closing, and labour shortages are growing. Why is this happening, and can it be reversed? This video examines the causes and consequences of population decline and what it could mean for the future of the global economy.
0:00 What's Going On? 1:38 Effective Fertility 2:45 Wrong Forecasts 3:21 Smartphones 5:33 Economic Costs 7:05 We're Ageing 7:41 Peer Pressure 8:49 Role of Women 9:17 Cheaper Housing! 10:31 Problems of Lower population 11:55 Benefits of Lower population
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Global fertility rates are collapsing, with Thailand as a stark example. While economic factors like housing costs play a role, the decline is a worldwide phenomenon driven by social shifts, digital isolation, and changing cultural norms. This demographic shift threatens economic stability and social vitality, signaling a broader withdrawal of civilization from real-world interaction.
Thailand's fertility rate has collapsed to around 0.8, one of the lowest ever recorded
in human history. If this fertility rate was to remain at 0.8, by 2050 Thailand's population will
fall to 47 million, by 2100 it will fall to 21 million, 2150 just 6 million and in 200 years
time just 2 million people. What is going on? Well you might point to high housing costs,
economic stagnation and successful family planning, but economics alone can't explain
what is happening. Across Asia, Europe, Latin America, even the Middle East, birth rates are
collapsing all at the same time. After peaking in the 1960s, population growth has collapsed and is
set to be negative by 2050, and the pace of decline may accelerate. As Bruegger and Ibbotson
say, the low fertility trap once in place is irreversible. This population decline will be
the defining issue of a day. It affects pensions, housing, debt, growth, universities and healthcare.
Modern economies were all built on one assumption, each generation would be larger than the last.
And will this brave new world lead to a nirvana of cheaper housing,
abundant resources, or a dystopian future of broken governments and collapsing society?
Well the story is that this is a long-term decline in fertility which has been happening for centuries.
But once you adjust for falling child mortality, the number of surviving children per woman in the
The first big drop in fertility occurred at the same time as contraception became
widely available. By 1980, fertility rates had dropped to just below two, and that was
considered fine. In fact, there was a relief that the feared population explosion may not
actually happen now. But what happened next was unexpected. Birth rates fell from low levels
to extremely low levels. And actually, the United States has one of the highest fertility rates in
the developed world. In Asia, rates have collapsed below one. It's only a few outliers with fertility
rates above 2.1. Now the UN Population Forecast Unit was set up in the post-war period when there
were genuine fears of unsustainable population growth. I remember being taught at school of a
Yet UN demographic forecasts have nearly always overestimated actual population growth. As the
FT reports, just five years ago, the UN predicted in 2025 350,000 births in South Korea. The actual
figure was just 230,000. The decline in population in Asia is stark. But an interesting thing is just
how stable fertility was from 1991 to around 2017. So what happened around the mid 2010s?
Well, the answer is quite possibly in your pocket. Smartphones, social media and online life have all
caused a 50% fall in the number of young people socialising. Young people spend less time dating,
less time meeting in person, and less time forming long term relationships. The world is
undergoing an unprecedented social experiment. And there is a clear direct link to the recent drop
in fertility. The polarising nature of social media is driving a wedge between men and women,
and marriage rates are falling. If you look at Turkey, it's a great example of a rapid decline
in fertility. And demographers point out that they fall in marriage rates, which is the biggest
factor. The real collapse is happening before childbirth. Fewer people are even forming
relationships. The share of adults who are single has risen sharply across much of the developed
world. And there's no sign of a let up in this trend. With Instagram, offering the perfectly
curated life, why bother with an imperfect partner? And for a real glimpse into a dystopian future,
the economists report that 7% of single adults would consider a romantic relationship with an
AI robot. Whilst fertility in the real world falls, there's a big growth in imaginary friends,
perhaps soon we'll be having imaginary children. But what is definitely true that whilst fertility
in the real world collapses, more people retreat into those digital worlds of virtual relationships
and endless online distraction. demographer expert Fernandez Villaverde, claims that social media
is behind the acceleration of fertility drops in places like Latin America. The thing is that if
social media is a culprit, there is no going back. Because you can't un-invent the smartphone,
you can't un-invent the internet. Governments can try legislating social media for under 16s,
but you can't regulate social changes like people staying at home and doomscrolling the way to
oblivion. A YouGov study of childless adults in the UK found that the cost of children was the
and it certainly is the case that housing costs to income ratios remain near record levels,
a big disadvantage to having more children. But the only problem with the housing theory of
everything is that it doesn't explain the near simultaneous drops in birth rates we see all
around the world, irrespective of housing costs, whether it's India, Egypt, Turkey or Russia,
the world's most populous countries have seen a massive fall in fertility all within a similar
time frame. A more extensive study in the United States found that only 12% cited economic costs.
A far larger factor was that people didn't find the right partner. Nevertheless, economics does
remain a factor and many countries have tried extensive government support for women who have
children. In South Korea, government subsidies can add up to nearly $30,000, yet despite huge
fiscal incentives, the fertility rate shows no sign of going above one, let alone getting close
to the replacement ratio of 2.1. The problem is that from an economic perspective, the cost of
raising a child in a highly competitive education system is closer to $260,000. Governments just
can't afford to decisively shift the fiscal balance of having children because the big problem is not
so much the immediate population decline but an aging society. The share of a population over 65
is going to rise and this gives the government a big headache. It means less tax revenue but higher
spending on pensions and health care. No one has really planned for what is coming next and by the
way, pensioners are not traditionally the kind of voters who will accept pension cuts to pay for
child benefits. And a bigger problem for many poor countries is that they're going to age even before
they get rich. But even if a government did offer massive child benefits, would it be able to change
social and cultural attitudes? An underreported reason for falling fertility is this social
imitation effect. We tend to copy, either consciously or unconsciously, what other
people in society do. To be childless used to be considered highly unusual, almost a matter of shame
and failure. Now it's almost the other way around. Who wants to be the only family with five or six
kids? It's become such an inconceivable idea for families to have more than one or two children and
there is almost a sense that if you have more than one you are diluting your resources that you can
devote to your only child. You might just be able to support one child through college and help buy
a house but two kids forget about it. Again the problem is that you can't change this kind of
peer pressure which is so strong within society. In the 1960s the UK government tried things like
buy British goods and although popular these campaigns had zero effect on shifting consumption
patterns. The point is that if you got exhorted by the government to have more children would you
feel it is your patriotic duty to take on the costs of having children? Since the 1960s of course the
place of women in society has drastically shifted. In particular the number of women going to
university has soared and now rates exceed that of men and with greater education comes greater
choice and opportunities. As a result many women delay marriage and have children at a later date
but it's worth bearing in mind that women with academic university qualifications actually now
have higher fertility than those women who don't go to university. So the big question is what to
make of the population decline and fertility changes? Well Japan was a pioneer for population
aging and decline and at around the same time as the working age population started to fall
Japanese house prices fell 50 percent and it took decades to start to recover. It's the same in China
big drop in the number of births and with a population decline it is corresponding to a slump
in house prices. Now of course there are many other factors at play like speculation and interest rates
but when the population slumped house prices will almost inevitably fall because the demand will
just not be there and we won't have to worry about having to build high-rise flaps on greenbelt land
we may well be knocking these ugly low-quality housing down and this raises the intriguing
question about whether a population slump is a good thing or a bad thing. For those who can't
afford a place to live at the moment there seem to be definite upsides of a smaller population
and for those fighting development on greenbelt land this pressure would simply not be there
with a declining population and ironically a fall in house prices might actually be the thing that
could help improve fertility rates. Now I think the biggest causes for concern are that the fall
in the young people will lead to big social changes, schools will close, universities will shrink,
entire rural villages and towns may slowly empty out, there will be decline in vitality, new ideas
and new taxpayers and this shifting demographic will lead to hard unpopular choices, raise the
retirement age, higher taxes, perhaps lower spending, probably oil free. It's not particularly
a recipe to reduce political populism but perhaps more concerning is the story behind the fall in
fertility, the decline in social engagement, the immersion in the artificial world of video games,
social media and online comparison. This decline in fertility and rise in isolation also is
corresponding to a rise in loneliness, depression and mental anxiety. Single young men are statistically
more likely to be involved in violent crime. Difficulties in meeting women has the potential
to increase that polarization and sense of isolation and at the same time the economic
costs for young people mean many have fewer children than they want because the cost of
bringing up children is so high. Now on the brighter side you could argue that some of the
factors causing a lower fertility are quite positive. We have more opportunities, more choice
and it simply might just reflect the fact that not everybody wants to have children.
Also perhaps whilst the environment is under increasing threat and global temperatures
continue to soar, a smaller population may actually be the long-term salvation
that would never come about from societies voluntarily reducing fossil fuel use and
pollution. Now perhaps population decline itself may be manageable but the social changes driving
it may be far harder to reverse. Less social interaction, fewer relationships, more isolation,
more life lived online instead of the real world. Fertility collapse may ultimately be
less about economics and more about civilization gradually withdrawing from itself. This next video
looks at the impact of technology on our brains and society. Thanks for watching do subscribe to
our channel and we hope to see you soon.