Brad Confronts Trans Activist Who Called JK Rowling 'Clinically Stupid!'

J. K. Rowling - the writer
1 follower
2 Video Views·Jun 2, 2026
Brad Polumbo confronts trans activist Serena Munroe on her comments calling JK Rowling 'clinically stupid' for believing women are defined by biology, in this clip from the latest "Brad vs The World."
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedA debate between a host and a trans woman named Serena regarding biological sex, gender identity, and policy. The conversation evolves from a disagreement over J.K. Rowling's definitions of biological females to a consensus on the importance of biological reality in sports and the protection of children from medical transition.
Well, you are also retweeting posts that were mocking J.K. Rowling for the idea of defining
a woman by biological female traits. Do you stand by that?
Yeah, that I stand by. Again, this is my duality here. I do not like what J.K. Rowling has to say,
honestly.
Okay, well, let me pull up that post that J.K. Rowling actually said,
being biologically female means having a body that is observably organized to produce large
gametes, eggs, as opposed to a body organized to produce small gametes, sperm. A woman is
female whether or not her eggs have been fertilized or not. A man can never be female.
And that was in response to a post that said, your daily reminder that trans women are biological
women. The term biological woman is made up by anti-science folk who want to other trans women.
If you think that being female is strictly about the ability to get pregnant, you will invalidate
cis women as well as many who aren't able to do so. So that was the original post that J.K.
had responded to. Then you called her clinically stupid for that statement. What do you think?
You stand by the idea that it's clinically stupid to define female by reproductive
orientation and biology?
I mean, I don't deny biological sex exists or that reproductive biology is real. Humans are,
you know, that's just how human biology is. It's legitimate biological framework. I mean,
where I disagree is that the idea that gametes alone settle that debate itself.
Well, I don't think J.K. Rowling thinks it's only that. And I think from what it sounds like
earlier, you were saying that you don't deny biological sex exists, but you think you can
actually change it.
I do. I mean, I think that, again, this is what I think and how I believe it is that, yeah,
you can through the hormones and through medical transitioning that I feel that I am a biological
woman. I am biologically a female, even though I don't produce those gametes.
But you're not, though. You were born biologically male.
I was born biologically male, yeah.
And your genetics are male.
I believe that's not my case.
You believe that you're not genetically male because of your hormones.
Sorry. I believe I was born genetically male.
But are you and you acknowledge you are still genetically male?
Reluctantly, yes. But I still I believe that I am.
See, this is this is the issue. This feels way more like an emotional
problem. This seems more like an emotional problem. And I'm not trying to be mean because
I'm trying to seem like a nice enough person. You really do. And so there's some debates where
I could come on here and really like kind of be mean. I don't want to do that here.
I feel like this stems from something maybe a little bit deeper just with you.
I'm not a therapist, but if I could kind of LARP as one for just a second, I think you have
maybe an issue with integrating aspects of yourself and looking at yourself as a whole
person. For me, I don't have an issue integrating the fact that I'm male into my view of myself and
who I am as a person. My childhood, where I come from and what I still am is a part of my journey,
just like all of it is. And what's to come is a part of my journey. And I feel like when you sort
of deny parts of who you are, whether it's your biological sex, whether it's things you may have
done in your past, whether it's whatever, you can't deny reality because you end up living in
a way that doesn't make sense. I mean, you yourself acknowledge that you have a cognitive dissonance
on this issue. And if we have a cognitive dissonance, it means we're not seeing things clearly,
which definitely means we can't go and argue for things clearly and coherently. It definitely means
we can't go out there and suggest policy positions if you yourself admit you have a cognitive
dissonance on how you see this issue. Does that make sense? No, it does. Thank you. I appreciate
the feedback. So I guess the final kind of subtopic on this issue before, and maybe we
won't solve all the big picture debates today, but it just feels to me as somebody who does
respect and support autonomy and freedom for trans individuals, particularly adults,
that that is very much not the motion or direction that things are going in at the moment. There's
very widespread backlash to trans people, activism, however you want to identify it or describe it.
And to the extent that that backlash is kind of affecting just adult trans people who want to
live their lives, I don't support that or like that. But it does seem to me somewhat inevitable
that when you cling to the 20 side of the 80-20 issues, like the trans sports issue,
that you're going to have that kind of backlash. So why is it that all the groups and even activists
and even folks like yourself, Serena, can't just give that ground up? Fear of erasure,
I would say, from how I view it. Fear of being erased and not being able to
do what you like and exist. I mean, it's one of those things where you spend your entire life
in fear of what you are and who you are. And when you finally be able to accept it and, you know,
live your life and do what you like, it's one of those things that you want to cling to every
aspect of it. And it's, I mean, for me, it's kind of, it's difficult. And as Blair pointed out,
for me, there is, I do have a lot of dissonance with it. And some people can do it better than
others. I just have to point out, and this is to be constructive. You mentioned, you said that you
lived your life in fear. And what was the other word you used in regards to how you saw yourself
fear and denial of yourself? Fear and denial. Okay. And then you said, but then you accept it
and do what you want to do. I don't feel like from this conversation and things that you've said that
have been very illuminating about who you are and how you feel, I don't think you did cross that
threshold of accepting yourself because you still say you have such a hard time acknowledging
something as basic as your biological sex. That doesn't sound like an acceptance to me. That
sounds like a refusal to integrate that part of yourself. It's one of those things that I'm still
working on. I'm going to continue to work on to be able to accept that. And that's honest.
That's fair. But I guess what I would suggest is that I actually understand your fear of not
being able to live your life and not being able to, if presenting yourself in many ways as a
woman is what will make you happiest in life, I support that for you. And obviously we have this
backlash of people who would, some who would genuinely try to make that illegal or institutionalize
you or something like that. And I don't support that, obviously. But I do think that the clinging
to the most radical positions on this debate is the most likely thing that will lead to erasure,
right? Like will lead to public backlash. Because if you tell people that the two options are
totally rejecting trans people or accepting biological males in women's sports,
biologically male sex offenders in women's prisons, they're going to pick the totally
rejecting trans people. Most people are. Trans kids. Correct. We live in a democratic society
where we do have some degree of majority rules. So it's like if your alternative was
let trans people live, accommodate the trans community in certain ways, and we will respect
your boundaries and acknowledge biological reality in the instances where it is important.
I mean, that I think could be a winning message. I don't think this can be a winning message,
Serena. You know, you're probably right. And I'm probably wrong. I mean, there. This is one
of those things where we're holding on to something so hard, so, so ardently that it's
going to hurt more in the long run than in the short run. OK, well, then do you think you could
see yourself going forward, being a proponent in the opposite direction and actually telling
other trans people and other trans activists, hey, we got this wrong. Trans women should not
be in women's sports. Kids should not be transitioning. I guess we haven't even talked
about that. If the message is important, how we deliver that message would be important
and making sure that we ensure their psychological safety with that saying, hey,
sorry, this is how it has to be. We're not we're doing this to protect the sport itself.
But this is just one aspect of everything else. You still have everything for you. I mean,
again, it's all how it's all it's all about the messaging. Well, but it's also not. That's an
interest. I mean, there's there's propaganda and there's messaging and there's the way that you
say things. But I find that people on the left are always so much more focused on that and they're
focused on the way that you say things rather than like, OK, so you're sitting here saying
you're kind of understanding you were wrong, maybe on the trans athlete thing. So would that actually
lead you to switch your position publicly and advocate against trans women being involved in
women's sports or at least leaving the debate altogether and stop pushing for them to be in
the sports? Because it really is those two kind of options. You either support it or you don't.
Yeah, I would support it. I would support saying trans women should be in the biological side of
the sport. They should be in. Wait, in women or men's? Men's. OK, well, hallelujah. There's a
point now. I've got to be honest, Serena. I I fear you may exit this conversation and get back
into the blue sky Twitter kind of trans rights activist echo chamber and maybe go back to your
former position. Here's the thing with my positions, and I'll make this abundantly clear.
They do change. But if it makes sense from a holistic standpoint for the society as a whole,
then that's where that's where I land and that's where I'll stay. And, you know, I'll gladly
take the hate that I'm going to get for flipping on this issue from my community and my fellow
trans men and women. I think this is the first debate I've ever done where the person actually
changed their mind. Oh, my God, that's crazy. Well, you haven't talked about trans kids,
though. I don't know how we feel about that, but. OK, I mean, this is Bradshaw. I'm not going to
Brad, this is your show. How do you want to do this? I mean, is that something you you stand on,
Serena? But stand on like you, you are a hardcore believer that kids should transition or no.
Oh, God, no, no. I think kids, kids need to be kids. OK, all right. Well, here, kids,
kids are always going to have a lot of questions, a lot of issues. And this is my stance on it.
Well, welcome to the Blair White Army, Serena. Wow. Wait, you made a face.
You sound like me. What's going on? I think kids should just I as a kid going
through my own dysphoria and issues. I wanted a therapist. In fact, I did a post on Twitter
about this earlier. I wanted a therapist to talk about it. I didn't want to transition.
I didn't know what it was. If kids have these issues and parents, I understand it's scary.
It's a lot of unknown, especially if coming. If you don't have any understanding of
the trans community, find a specialist to have to talk to and have a better
understanding and have your kid. I'm not sure I trust those specialists,
but all that could be a conversation. That's a whole that's a whole other thing.
Yeah, but I appreciate you guys coming together, having a conversation. I think we need more of
that, including on these contentious and fraught issues. Thank you both so much for making the
time and coming on the show. Thanks for having me.
