I Spent 1000 To Find The Perfect EDC Backpack

SilkRoad Technology
124 followers
#technology #highend #gadget #robot #apple #iphone #macbookpro #gaming #accessories #gears #samsung #tesla
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe speaker evaluates 15 backpacks over two years to find the ideal daily commuter bag. After testing various high-end options, including the Aer Citypack Pro 2, Rework Toshi, and Bellroy Transit, the Evergoods CPL24 is crowned the winner for its superior versatility, comfort, and space management, serving effectively as both a daily carry and a short-trip travel bag.
I have been obsessed with backpacks.
I mean, it's something we use every single day, so why not find the best one, right?
So for the past two years, I've been testing backpack after backpack,
only for some of them to fall short in some way or another.
It's a bit of a problem.
But finally, after testing 15 total backpacks and spending way more than I'd like to admit,
I have found the perfect daily commuter backpack.
Now, the last backpack video I made a couple of months ago,
I ended up picking the Able Carry Max EDC as the perfect backpack,
which I still think is an amazing backpack, but it's just not for me.
It's too big for my daily commute and just for my body in general.
Many of you backpack enthusiasts commented and told me to try the Air This and the Go Ruck That
and of course, go ahead and spend more money trying to find perfection
and so I listened.
Some were really good, others left me wanting a bit more
and one I kept coming back to over and over again.
So before you go off telling me to stop wasting your money, Patty,
perfection isn't real.
I get it.
Any of these backpacks really would do the job
and real life me would use any one of them.
But let's be honest, you enjoy seeing me spend money
and doing the hard work so you can reap the benefits.
So the first backpack I tried since then is so well known
that it's got its own acronyms in the backpack world.
The CPP2, also known as the Air Citypack Pro 2.
This honestly might be the most recommended,
most looked at and most sought after backpack in the industry.
Air is one of the top brands amongst the carry world.
Yes, it is called that and if you know, you know.
And this backpack is one of their best sellers.
Behind the Travel Bag 3, which I quickly took out of consideration
because well, I wouldn't call walking to and from the parking lot traveling.
Before this, I tested the smaller Citypack 2 for a couple months
and that backpack was near perfect
with its only downside being the 16 liter capacity.
I left no room for extras after packing my essentials.
Plus, who wants a backpack that runs the risk
of spilling its guts every time you open it?
Not I, that's for sure.
So its bigger sibling, the Pro version
with a roomy 24 liters of space should solve all my problems, right?
And so, I went to their website to pick one up
but it wasn't that easy.
There's multiple versions of the CPP2.
A regular, an X-Pack and an Ultra.
Too many choices.
First impressions wise, the biggest differences seem to be
the colors and the price tag.
The regular starts at $209 and it's gray.
X-Pack is $239 and is orange
and Ultra is mint at $259.
Oh boy, those accents look good
but the bag sure is pricey.
Now looking farther though,
it's really the material differences that truly matter.
Now this is where things can get a bit nerdy.
The original CPP2 uses 16AD Cordura
which is water resistant but not waterproof.
It also tends to be heavier and it's very fashionable.
The X-Pack version uses the VX42 X-Pack fabric
with waterproof YKK zippers
for the ultimate waterproof backpack.
Then the Ultra uses Ultra 400X by Challenge Sailcloth.
It's super waterproof, waterproof zippers
and it's lighter weight.
So really, the decision is which one?
And after some research
and scrutinizing the sales pages on each backpack,
I ended up getting the Ultra.
It's supposed to be more water resistant,
more lightweight and more durable
with the caveat that it might delaminate over time.
Luckily, Air said yes when I asked them
if I could try out this CPP2
and they sent it over for testing
and when it arrived,
I instantly moved all my things to it
and man, it does have a decent amount of room.
Especially the middle pocket.
It opens like a suitcase.
Boom!
The Sailcloth is uniquely wrinkly
like a sheet you put in the dryer
and you forget to take out until many days later.
You might say it's got personality
or you might say it looks rumpled.
The amount of internal organization is decent too,
except for one major problem.
If you fill up these front pockets,
the middle pockets back here get super tight,
rendering them nearly useless.
The water bottle holders are also extremely tight as well
and it makes it inconvenient to constantly take out
and put back your water bottle.
Although the tightness does make it good
for storing stuff like your phone or your earbuds.
It really is a good backpack.
It self-stands, it looks great,
got a hidden air tag pocket and it holds a lot.
After a couple weeks of use,
I found one thing that kept eating at me
every time I went to use my backpack.
Literally, the zippers just destroyed my hands
with the zipper teeth scratching them up like crazy.
Especially in this cold dry winter.
It also doesn't help that they were very hard to open.
You have to get leverage from the other side
or else they just, they don't slide.
So while it's an amazing backpack
and it could totally be the one backpack endgame pick,
I wanted to try something else.
A backpack I kept seeing over and over again
with a name that I'd never heard of before
and that's the Rework Toshi 20 liter backpack.
There were so many comments that I just had to look it up
and I had to check it out.
At first glance, it looks eerily similar
to the Air Citypack Pro 2, like oddly similar.
Plus it sits at $189, which is significantly less expensive.
So instead of a heaping 24 liters,
we now top out at 20.
Look at their company though.
They put so much effort into designing their products
that I just, I had to give it a shot.
So I did ask them to send it over
since they were out of stock when I first checked it out
and surprisingly, they said yes.
In fact, they had even heard of the channel before.
How nice of them.
All these slots for tablets,
but what's the point of bringing your iPad at all
if it isn't properly upgraded with today's sponsor, Paperlike.
Today, I'm putting on the new Paperlike 3
and if you aren't familiar,
these bad boys aren't just for protecting your screen,
they're for the note takers and artists of the house.
If you've ever used an Apple Pencil with an iPad,
you know the exact problem this product solves.
Writing on that glass screen just feels slippery,
but the Paperlike 3 solves that,
giving you a more tactile feedback as you write and draw.
That idea isn't all that Paperlike has up its sleeve.
It also manages to solve my number one problem
with every screen protector I've ever used.
Installing it isn't doctorate level rocket science.
It comes with a whole load of tools
that make sure the setup process goes smoothly,
with no air bubbles or misalignments or any of that.
It even has a QR code that sends you straight to a video guide.
The result?
No dust, no bubbles, perfect alignment.
It looks like the iPad came this way.
The main thing I use my Apple Pencil for is note taking,
which feels a lot better with this sort of tactile feedback,
but I know watching me take notes isn't exactly visually exciting,
so here's me trying to draw a dog.
Look, don't make fun of me.
I may not be an artist,
but at least the pencil feels good
while I'm performing crimes against the art community.
At under 0.095 millimeters of thickness,
the Paperlike 3 is specifically designed
to stay below Apple's accessory design guidelines.
That means the screen is just as responsive
as it is with nothing at all.
So if you're tired of feeling slippery when you write on your iPad,
be sure to visit the link in the comments and the description.
So Rework is a smallish and newish brand
that currently sells primarily slings,
and this is their first backpack.
Coming from the EDC Max at 26 liters down to the Citypack Pro at 24,
and now to 20,
you might be thinking isn't that too small for an EDC backpack?
It's like a backpack for ants.
Honestly, I was thinking the same,
but if you put it side by side with the Citypack Pro 2,
they look like they can hold the same amount of stuff.
One of the things I like the most is that there's zero branding.
I guess Air is like that too,
mostly there's a tiny Air logo on the side,
but the Rework Toshi is black,
it's sleek and minimalistic.
It makes sense because they wanted a clean design.
The internal organization is very similar
and they give you some nice quality of life improvements
over the Citypack Pro 2.
Like how these front pockets actually have stretch in them
and they're more see-through than the stiff ones on the Air.
We also have a stealthy quick access kangaroo pocket on the front
which you can access from either side.
In theory, this one is useful but I find myself reaching in
and not being able to get what I want.
The zippers scratch up my hand
and the pocket really isn't that flexible
which is weird because almost every other pocket in here
is either stretchy or extra roomy
like these ones here or even the internal for the accessories
and this stretchy mesh is everywhere.
What's really cool about Rework is that they're a small company
and they're very close to their customers.
They make videos explaining their design
and walking through every pocket in the backpack
and after watching these,
I understand the intention for everything
and that you really can make the toy leaders feel bigger.
Now the material isn't as fancy as challenge sailcloth
but it does the job.
I used it through rain and it did all right.
It wasn't a heavy storm.
Now if you're in the Pacific Northwest,
maybe might not go with this one,
might go for something a little more waterproof
but just doing the daily commute,
the Rework works great.
Although between these two backpacks,
the choice is pretty dang hard.
They each have their strengths and weaknesses
and they work well as daily commuter backpacks.
The biggest issues I have with the Toshi 20 are the straps.
The shoulder straps feel slippery while I'm wearing it,
almost like they're too wide
and the sternum clip is especially small
compared to other backpacks
but I think that's a personal problem.
I think I just don't have wide enough shoulders
and the zipper gets stuck for the main compartment
when you get through this threshold here.
It's not bad at first
but it really just annoys you the more you do it.
Other than those issues,
the Rework Toshi leader is impressive
for a backpack from a new company
and oddly enough,
if I had to choose between the two bags,
I would pick the Toshi
because of how lightweight and functional and stylish it is
but if I got the Citypack Pro 2 in Cordura,
maybe I'd like that more.
Okay, we've looked at the Citypack Pro 2
and it's more affordable competitor,
the Rework Toshi
but what about the King of Carry?
Or maybe that's air.
I don't know, I see both brands equally often.
No matter where I go,
whether it's YouTube, Reddit, forums, TikTok, whatever,
I see this bag talked about repeatedly.
The Evergood CPL 24.
I know, CPL, what the heck is that?
More acronyms.
I didn't know either until I looked it up.
This is the Evergood's Civic Panel Loader
and yes, that is one of the most expensive bags
I've ever seen in my life.
It also looks like a jet pack,
a really sleek jet pack on your back.
Lots of people consider this bag
the king of commuter backpacks.
The perfect everyday carry, so to speak.
It's a design that's over eight years old
and has been at the top of the Evergood's bestsellers list.
So I asked Evergood to see if they could send me one to test
and they said yes.
I picked out the 24 liter in green,
which is actually more of an olive color
and the only question that came to mind when I got it was,
why is this bag so popular?
It doesn't even self-stand.
It doesn't have a water bottle holder.
Heck, it's got weirdo organization.
Why is there a key leash in the same pocket
you're supposed to put your phone?
That's how your phone gets scratched up
and yes, that's spoken from experience.
The leash is also sewn directly into the bag
so you can't move it anywhere else.
This bag, it took me a while to switch to this one
since I had to sacrifice a bunch of features I was used to
but once I used it for a bit,
I discovered things that I didn't know before.
It can stand but it has to be on its side.
It only stands on one side, the left side.
This gives you access to the laptop compartment
as well as the front quick access
which has more organization
and if you store things in the middle, aka like this way,
you can open this up and get out things conveniently
but if you carry a water bottle,
you have to make sure it's 100% closed
or else it just spills all the way through.
Now it really could use more organization.
The middle feels like a huge black hole
where things just go in there and get lost
packing cubes would help on this one.
Over time though, I liked it more and more
but there was one thing that I couldn't stand.
The fact that I had to adjust the straps
every single time I put it on and off.
It's even worse when you wear a jacket or a watch.
It snags every single time.
There's also no strap holder either
so these things just dangle
which is unfortunate because it's super stylish.
So is the CPL24 that good?
Is it better than the two previous bags?
That is a tougher question
since I feel like it's in an entirely different category.
The price alone puts it a notch above the rest
but the biggest thing is that it changes how you carry.
The 24 liters feels so much bigger
than the Citypack Pro 2 at the same size.
Maybe it's how it's laid out
or maybe it is roomier.
It can hold way more.
There's an option to get this in 16
but I mean that's sizing down quite a lot
which maybe I should have done
because I'm a small person.
So I even gave the CPB, the Civic Travel Bag, a try
but it's really just too big for regular use.
I took it for a three-day trip to CES
and it's a trooper.
So far, the backpacks recommended in the comment section
are absolute killers.
It's almost impossible to decide
but what about the smaller brands
like Alpaca or Bellroy?
Maybe I'm a complete noob
and maybe they're not as small as I think they are
but I really don't see them as often
as I do Air or Evergoods.
So I figured I might as well check them out too.
Maybe they're actually hidden gems.
So I picked up two more bags.
The first being the Alpaca Elements Pro Bag.
This bag seemed like a great contender
since it's the same price as the Toshi bag
but it has 24 liters instead of just 20.
It also looked great with quick access pockets
and water bottle holders.
So they sent me one to test out.
When I transferred all my stuff to it though,
there was one issue.
Where was my 24 liters of room?
I haven't even packed everything in yet
and it was feeling stuffed.
It also only has one main compartment
and it was combined with the laptop pocket.
Really, I'm expecting more separation
especially at this price point.
So unfortunately, this bag didn't stay
in my rotation very long.
It was just a tad too small
even though it looks good
and has a cool modular system that you can add on.
The straps were pretty hard to adjust
and as a short person, I did that a lot
but I really do love their Metro Pro Backpack,
the small version.
Also picked up the Bellroy Transit Work Pack Pro
in 22 liters.
They happen to sponsor a mineral integration previously
which happened to be a bonus
since I've been wanting to test this out in the first place.
This backpack felt amazing.
The fabric is so smooth.
It's different than the rest.
It's actually very similar to the layout
of the City Pack Pro 2 and the Toshi
but with luggage straps in the large middle compartment
and a enclosed water bottle pocket
and a hidden pocket right here.
However, they chose not to add a front quick access one.
I wore this one about two to three weeks
and the main issue I had was with the straps.
They're thin at the bottom here
so they dig into my sides when I wear the bag.
So despite being such a great bag,
it wasn't my first choice.
Then which one is the winner?
For me, it's between the Rework Toshi
and the Evergood CPL 24.
That one comes with a little bit of caveat
and a little bit of trade-offs and you know.
But if you had me at gunpoint and told me
you had to pick right now,
it would be the CPL 24.
The space makes sense.
It looks amazing and it's comfortable.
Honestly, it's just a very versatile bag.
I can use it daily
but I can also take it on a short trip
where the Toshi isn't big enough to hold that much stuff
and with that, I hope to say that my backpack journey is over
but you know how it is,
a new bag comes out and you see something different
and you're like,
I wonder how that feels on my back.
All of these backpacks make for great daily commuter backpacks
and what's good for me might not be good for you.
They can fit everything I carry plus more
and they look fantastic.
So what this has really taught me
is that once you find something you really like,
don't look at anything else.
It's like getting married, just commit.
Seriously though, you'll save a lot of money
if you just put the blinders on
and appreciate what you have
but if you're interested in backpacks,
chances are you might like this video as well.
It's not a backpack video.
Trust me, click it.
