"US-Iran war: Who has the upper hand in negotiations to end conflict?"

World Trending News
1 follower
37 Video Views·May 31, 2026
No decision on a possible deal with Iran was made after U.S. President Donald Trump left a two-hour meeting held in the Situation Room on Frida
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedWhite House officials and President Trump met to discuss a potential deal with Iran, focusing on a ceasefire, the reopening of the Strait of Hormuz, and nuclear disarmament. However, no agreement was reached. Expert Imran Bayomi suggests the current talks are likely for a ceasefire extension rather than a final peace treaty, as core issues remain unresolved.
White House officials, including President Trump, held a two-hour meeting Friday in the Situation
Room on a possible deal with Iran. However, that gathering concluded without an agreement.
Before heading into the meeting, Trump said he intended to make a final determination
on a ceasefire with Iran, which would involve the reopening of the Strait of Hormuz
and Tehran committing to never developing a nuclear weapon.
Joining us now is Imran Bayomi. He's an associate director with the Geostrategy Initiative
in the Atlantic Council's Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security to unpack
all these latest developments. Imran, thanks for joining us today.
Thanks for having me.
So firstly, what do you think is preventing leaders on both sides from finalizing a deal?
What's the main sticking point right now?
So I think it's the fact that this isn't really a deal. What I think Iran and the United States
are negotiating is an extension of the ceasefire. So you've heard numbers like 60 days thrown out.
Basically, it would be an extension of the ceasefire to actually allow the U.S. and Iran
to negotiate on these really tough issues like Iran's nuclear program, the release of frozen
Iranian assets, Iran's missile program, Iran's support for proxies, and then the Strait of
Hormuz as well. So I think it's more of an issue on how to get to these harder,
bigger topics of negotiation rather than a deal to end the war completely right now.
Okay. And who would you say has the upper hand right now in these negotiations? Can the
U.S. naval blockade successfully force Iran to back down over time perhaps? Or do you think
Tehran has established a new normal of control over the Strait of Hormuz?
So I think the U.S. is negotiating to open the strait, which was never closed before the war.
So certainly Iran has demonstrated an ability to close and control the strait, and that's
certainly concerning to the United States and its allies as that inhibits the transit of a
critical waterway. That being said, the U.S. blockade on Iran has an impact. It will have
more of an impact over the coming months. We'll see how long the U.S. keeps that up. We'll see
how long the regime in Tehran can weather that blockade. I think the regime can probably hold
out longer. This is not a government that's afraid to pass hardships down to its people.
I think as long as the regime continues to take in income and can sustain itself,
the well-being of the Iranian people and their potential hardships as imposed by this naval
blockade on the United States side is not a priority for the government in Tehran to resolve.
That being said, I think both sides are looking for this to end eventually. The regime in Tehran
is weakened. The United States is facing international pressure, domestic pressure
to end the war. Certainly allies around the world are feeling the global crunch of this fuel crisis,
and so I think both sides are looking for some sort of off ramp. In terms of who has the upper
hand, I think it's tough. It probably changes day to day on issue to issue, and there's no clear
winner here. Okay, switching gears slightly now, this week Iranian missiles were intercepted in
Kuwait. As we know, Iran has repeatedly targeted U.S. bases in the Gulf region. So on one hand,
these Gulf countries rely on U.S. security guarantees, and on the other hand, they remain
vulnerable to Iranian retaliatory strikes. So how do you see these countries managing that
balance going forward, and how might they respond now? So I think that's the big question. I think
a lot of these countries made or assumed that the United States would be their primary security
backer in the region. I think they were taken by surprise when the United States launched this war,
and the question now is, do they continue to ally with the United States after the conflict,
or do they form their own security partnerships? I don't think we'll see any of them immediately
allying with Iran overnight, but I think they'll be trying to find a way to work with the regime.
That being said, I think their primary concern is that the eventual peace deal, whatever the
United States and Iran agrees to, leaves Iran in a hardened place, still retaining its capabilities,
more hardline elements of the IRGC are in control, more emboldened to use force, and I think that's
a certain concern for the Gulf states. The United States needs to demonstrate its commitment to
these allies, and we'll see what exactly that looks like. Okay, I want to talk about Oman now.
Oman has historically served as the region's bleeding neutral mediator. However, this week,
we did see President Trump explicitly warn Oman to behave or face military consequences.
How damaging is that rhetoric toward neutral allies and mediators in the region?
So I think the most important thing to watch are President Trump's actions. I think the
President has used rhetoric time and time again. Sometimes, actions match that rhetoric. Other
times, they do not. I think after the President said that, you saw the Treasury Secretary meet
with the Omani ambassador. I think even though Oman has kind of offered to play this negotiating
role, there's coordination on all sides, right? So the United States is not going to just attack
its close ally in Oman overnight. At the same time, they're probably aware of what Oman is doing
and understand its critical role to end the war. That being said, this rhetoric certainly doesn't
help kind of improve ties amongst allies or reassure them of the U.S. security guarantee
going forward or Washington's role in the region. All right, Imran, thanks so much for your time and
perspective today. Thanks for having me. That is Imran Bayomi, an associate director with the
Geostrategy Initiative in the Atlantic Council's Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Security.
