This panel critically examines the political economy of graduate education financing at HBCUs, with particular attention to Grad PLUS policy, access, affordability, and institutional sustainability. The discussion situates federal lending structures within broader equity considerations and their implications for graduate enrollment, retention, and long-term institutional viability.
Speakers include: Reginald K. Ellis, Ph.D.Dean and Professor of History Clark Atlanta University
Desideria Hacker, Ph.D.Dean, School of Graduate Studies and Research Norfolk State University
Scott Challener, Ph.D.Dean, Graduate College Hampton University
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Deans from Clark Atlanta, Norfolk State, and Hampton Universities discuss the critical impact of eliminating Grad Plus loans. This policy shift threatens the affordability of graduate education at HBCUs, risking student enrollment, institutional R2 research status, and educational equity for first-generation students who rely heavily on federal aid.
Comments are disabled for this video.
Good morning.
Welcome to our next session.
I am Dr. Reginald Ellis,
Dean, Office of Graduate Education
at Clark Atlanta University.
And I'm honored to moderate this upcoming session
entitled Finance and Assets, Grad Plus Reform
and the Political Economy of HBCU Graduate Education.
Today, we have two of the leading graduate deans
in the higher educational space
here with us this afternoon,
this morning to discuss the impact
of financing graduate education in the 21st century,
specifically post grad plus loan going away.
Before we get into our conversation,
I would like to pause and allow our presenters
to introduce themselves.
And I will start with Dean Hacker at Norfolk State
and then go to Dr. Scott Talloner at Hampton Institute.
Dean Hacker.
Good morning, everyone.
I'm Desi Hacker.
I'm the Dean at Norfolk State University.
And we'll talk a little bit more
about our academic portfolio,
but I've been at Norfolk State for the last 26 years
in various roles,
especially in the graduate education space.
I'm happy to be with you this morning.
Hey, good morning, everyone.
Dr. Scott Talloner.
I am Dean of the Graduate College at Hampton University.
This is my fifth year here
and I'm looking forward to the conversation.
All right, let's go ahead and get started
with the conversation.
As this conversation goes on,
if you have any questions that you would like to post to us
as it relates to this particular presentation,
please use the Q&A function
and we will monitor that throughout our presentation
and raise those questions as they come up.
I'm gonna start very quickly with a high level overview
to frame our conversation
and then we will jump right into our discussion.
As you all know, we are currently facing,
we're currently facing the end of the grad plus loan.
And so I've entitled this presentation,
OBBA Impact on Graduate Education.
This is a presentation that I presented
to the academic leadership team
here at Clark Atlanta University,
just so our leaders would understand what was coming.
And so I was in Florida for 17 years
and in the state of Florida, we dealt,
we deal with hurricanes.
And for many years prior to about 2017,
many individuals were not really concerned
when they heard warnings or tales of a hurricane coming
until one came, Hurricane Hermine in 2017.
And so since then, everyone now understands
the impact importance of listening to forecasters.
And so my theory was to frame this idea
around Hurricane OBBA approaching
and the impacts it will have on graduate education large,
but also specifically on black higher education.
The storm is forming the policy overview.
And on beginning July 1st of this year,
the graduate plus loan will be eliminated.
What does that mean for current graduate students
and graduate students who will begin their program
on July 1st?
There will be an annual federal loan cap per year
of $20,500 per year.
For the lifetime graduate loan cap
from their masters throughout of $100,000
that they will be able to receive in federal funding.
This will be an immediate impact
on the affordability and enrollment.
Now on our call, we have a public state,
state supported institution and two private institutions.
And so it's gonna be interesting to hear
how both of our types of institutions
are dealing with that last piece,
the enrollment, the immediate impact
on affordability and enrollment.
So let's look at the forecast or the storms aftermath.
The financial forecast and enrollment risk.
What we are embracing for or bracing for rather
is reduced borrowing capacities for the federal loans,
which is gonna pivot many of our scholars
away from the federal loan system into the private market
due to the loss of the graduate plus loan safety net.
Second thing is there's gonna be a potential delay
on doctoral completions due to the lack of funding,
the lack of resources.
And when we think about the graduate plus loan,
many of these scholars are using these funds to live,
to pay rent, to purchase grocery and just everyday living.
So these students are not just using these funds
to cover their tuition and fees,
they're also using these funds for everyday living needs.
And all of the institutions on this call
are R2 classification, which means they're producing
at least 20 doctoral scholars per academic year,
which places all of us at risk of maintaining
that R2 classification benchmark.
Projected impact on my current university,
Clark Atlanta University,
with the increased out-of-pocket cost for graduate scholars,
there will be potential enrollment decline
in graduate programs.
Higher attrition risk among dissertation phase students,
which will create a competitive disadvantage
among HBCU peers.
Now, again, with the current administration,
these policies came fast and furious,
and many of us in the graduate educational space
and in the R2 HBCU graduate educational space
have been talking about this very directly
to figure out how we are all going to offset
these potential losses.
So here's a strategic response.
One, we are proposing temporary suspension
of selected graduate fees for doctoral scholars
in their last three semesters of their dissertation process,
which will lower the out-of-pocket costs
for many of our graduate scholars.
We're working directly with our financial aid,
our partners in financial aid and scholarships
to expand institutional fellowships and assistantships.
And we also are launching financial literacy
and planning workshops so that our graduate scholars
understand the impact.
So they will, I'm sorry.
So they will understand the impact of the loan going away,
but also understand the impact
of what the private loan market looks like.
And then we are really working with our academic partners
and the academic deans and department chairs
and the faculty to look at and consider
revising their doctoral program and their curriculum
to ensure that scholars can earn their degrees
in five years rather than the national average of seven.
So in that way, many of these scholars
can leave their institution under the $20,500 per year,
$100,000 lifetime cap.
So what we will argue is and encourage all of our provosts
and CFOs to consider is a lot of institutional
response strategy, identify bridge funding mechanisms,
support communication plans to current and future students.
And one of the things that we've all learned
from our partners in CGS is communicate,
communicate, communicate.
And then we also want to protect enrollment growth
and our R2 trajectory.
So at this time, I will pivot the conversation
to my colleagues.
So we just kind of set the table
and I'll pivot my conversation to our colleagues.
And the first question that I will ask,
and I'll also bring up their presentation,
but while I'm bringing that presentation up,
I will ask the question, how do federal loan policies,
including Grab Plus Loan shape equitable access
to graduate education at HBCUs?
And I will start that question with Dean Hacker.
Thank you, Dr. Ellis.
I think much of what you said highlight
how it will affect graduate education at HBCUs.
If you think about it, many of our students come to us
with finance issues being of utmost concern for them.
And so the graduate assistantships that we provide
for doctoral students, but even our master's students
who want to further their degree have financial concerns.
So this cap has strong implications
on students maybe deciding to delay graduate education,
may impact them in terms of continuing or persisting
if there are issues in terms of financial aid,
allowing them to complete their graduate degrees.
And then similar to you, we are aspiring to R2 status
in which doctoral education is important.
And with programs being four, five, six years,
and seven in your case,
it's gonna hit that enrollment cap really quickly,
which will create challenges for our students.
And Scott, I'm gonna go ahead and bring up your slide.
Yeah, thanks.
While you're doing that, I'll just add a couple of things.
One, we know that a significant percentage
of our students come from HBCUs as undergrads, right?
So that's important, right?
Because when you look at the,
one thing that Desi and I were talking a lot about before
as we were preparing for this conversation
is when you think about where our graduate student
population is coming from,
this is both the awesome force of HBCUs and a challenge,
right?
So that we support our undergraduate students
to pursue graduate degrees at our institutions.
But our undergraduate students
also carry higher debt loads, right?
They have greater debt burdens.
And so they face greater risks.
And so that's one part of the puzzle
that we wanna unpack a little bit with you all today.
And I think, so the broader takeaway for us
was that we can't really talk about graduate education
without talking about undergraduate education.
So I know at Hampton,
it's about 36% of our undergraduates.
I think from our peers at North Carolina A&T,
I think that's around 40%.
So I think you can see in that 30 to 40% window,
that's what we're talking about
in terms of our student population.
And so looking really closely and getting better data
on what kinds of debt burdens
our undergraduate students are bringing
into the graduate space is gonna be really important
because that will affect their ability to borrow
within these new loan caps
and their ability to continue and complete those degrees
like we're talking about.
So thanks for pulling up the slides.
Can you run to the next one?
Okay, so just really briefly,
you already mentioned this, Reggie,
but we did wanna put this out there to everyone in the room.
Like thinking about HBCUs and the HBCU ecology,
it's really important to think about
all of our differences, right?
Our shared missions, our shared histories,
but also key points of difference, right?
So one of the advantages of us here
is that we have two private institutions,
Clark Atlanta and Hampton in the room,
and then we have a public, Norfolk State.
And the other piece that I wanted to say
is that there are differences even within those groups.
So there's just a little picture here.
I'm not gonna run through all of this,
but we are a little bit, we're an R2 institution.
We have about 620 graduate students.
That's a mix of on-ground and online programs.
We are master's heavy,
but we do have PhDs in atmospheric science,
business administration, counseling,
education management, nursing, physics,
and planetary science.
And we have some professional doctoral programs
in pharmacy and physical therapy.
And we also have some professional programs in our master's,
although I should put professional in scare quotes, right?
Because we know that our understanding
and how we think about professional degrees
as graduate professionals
and in the higher education community
may be at odds with how the federal government
and federal policy designates those degrees.
And I bring that up because as we know right now,
there's only, I believe, 13 professional degrees
that have been designated.
And right now, as we speak, nursing is not one of them.
Speech pathology is not one of them.
Audiology is not one of them.
Physical therapy is not one of them.
So I just wanna say that because when I say professional,
I'm thinking in the capacious sense of that term,
just to include all of our degrees
that are so important to what we do at Hampton.
Next slide, please.
And Norfolk State is a public university
and we're located in Norfolk, Virginia,
and it's classified as a research college and university,
but it's aspiring to R2 status.
And as I indicated, it has implications for us
in terms of funding doctoral students.
Our total enrollment is about 5,800
and we have about 729 graduate students.
We're pretty master's heavy right now
with three PhD programs in material science,
social work, and clinical psychology,
but we have four in the works
of going through the approval process.
And then we have a fair number of certificate programs
right now that we're growing those as well.
Next slide.
Okay, so this is just how I think a little bit,
I just wanted to say a little bit about,
so my background, I have a PhD in literatures in English,
right, so in English.
And when I think about the political economy
of graduate education at HBCUs,
I wanted to put down a couple of signposts.
So in a new way in the 21st century,
debt is a defining feature of economic life.
That was not always the case,
but it is for all of us in this room, no doubt,
and it certainly is true for our students.
Following mortgages, student debt
is the second highest consumer debt category
in the country, right?
So thinking about that and putting that frame on it
really puts, I think,
puts a finger on exactly what we're talking about
and the true scale and significance of this conversation
and its implications.
And then just one more bullet point here.
Tuition has increased 650 times faster
than the consumer price index.
So if you just think about paying,
we've been talking a lot about the price of gas
in our international conversation,
but if gas increased,
if the cost of a gallon of gas increased at 650 times,
we'd be paying $20 or more, right, for that commodity.
So education is a unique commodity in our current economy.
And what economists call the education premium,
that's the amount of money you earn
on the basis of having a degree
versus not having one,
is shrinking at the undergraduate level.
That is a new thing in the 21st century
for the US economy, right?
And those quotes, those are quotes from Annie McClanahan,
a scholar in my field, right,
who thinks a lot about the relationship
between debt and service work and labor and literature.
So although the premium for education
is under attack in our country,
we know that the graduate education premium is still there.
So if you look at this slide,
you'll see that as you go up in educational attainment,
your salary goes up, your rates of employment goes up,
and so there is still a benefit
for students getting graduate degrees.
And they can't get graduate degrees
if they don't get an undergraduate degree.
And so these things are, they are tied to each other.
We cannot separate them out.
Next slide.
So what this means is that pathways
to graduate education is really critical,
and that financial aid or federal aid policies
have direct implications for all of us,
both at the undergraduate and the graduate level,
because if we start removing financial assistance
to students, it's going to impact who will enroll,
who stays in, and then who graduates,
because federal aid fills those gaps,
especially for students that we tend to serve at HBCUs.
We tend to have a greater percentage
of lower wealth household students,
first-gen students, and working adults.
So they will be the ones who are burdened the hardest.
And so we need to look at this
both as a federal aid issue and also an equity issue,
because it's a pathway for our students to get ahead
and close some of the wealth gaps that exist in our society.
Next slide.
Yeah, I also just want to add,
it's a public good issue, right?
We know that our graduates who leave
with advanced degrees serve our communities, right?
They serve us, they serve our communities,
and they serve our industries where we need them most.
So another thing that Desi and I were talking about
and I hope we can all talk about is value, right?
And the value of a graduate education degree
is not just about ROI, right?
It's about the social value.
It's about the significance that a graduate degree makes
for people who live in our communities.
So I just wanted to say that out loud.
Reggie talked a little bit about this,
but we did want to just give you a quick primer on Grad Plus.
So, you know, it started in 2005
and it is ending July 1st or June 30th of this year.
What it actually is is an unsubsidized federal loan,
meaning interest accrues immediately
as soon as a student borrower takes it out.
And it allows graduate and professional students
to borrow up to the full cost of attendance
minus other aid with no lifetime cap.
And it was often used for tuition and living expenses.
I highlighted living expenses
because I think that's really critical, right?
When you think about the undergrads,
they don't have those, right?
But we know that our graduate students
carry significant living expenses in a different way
than our undergraduates do, right?
It's not that they don't have them,
but the significant,
the living expenses for graduate students
are much more significant.
And just regarding the lifetime cap,
actually just yesterday was announced
that the lifetime cap will now apply
for anyone who's still carrying a Graduate Plus loan.
So we can talk about that too.
That was clarified by the Department of Education.
So anyway, Grad Plus loans,
they require a minimal credit check.
And that's really important
because it wasn't tied to credit score, right?
It did take a quick look at bankruptcy
and other key markers of financial worthiness,
but it wasn't a full-blown credit check, right?
That we might experience
if we're taking out a significant loan.
It offered fixed interest rates, 8.94% for 2526.
And it had a significant origination fee, right?
4.228%.
And then it allowed repayment deferment
while students were in school.
And most Graduate Plus loans
are repaid on a 10-year repayment plan
unless the borrower extended up to 25 years.
And that was based on the total loan volume
with interest during school,
capitalized as soon as the borrower enters repayment.
And I said this already, so I'll skip that part.
But I think thinking more
about professional graduate degrees is really important.
And then the last thing I wanted to say,
just because I think it's really important,
probably we all know this,
but this is just important information
as you're talking with your graduate students
or your graduate student populations
who may still take out a Graduate Plus loan
before June 30th.
There is an interim exception in place
that allows students who are already enrolled
in the Graduate Plus program
before that ending termination date
to continue under the previous cost of attendance
minus other financial assistance loan limits.
And that exception lasts
for the student's expected time to credential.
That's the federal language.
And that is defined as the lesser of three academic years
or the remaining length of their current program.
So that really matters as we continue to talk
about research doctoral degrees
and the time to degree, right?
It's three academic years
or the remaining length of the current program
as of July 1st.
And so that's an important marker of what's to come.
And then you should know
that if a student transfers a program,
withdraws or exceeds that original program length,
they are no longer eligible for that legacy loan provision.
And so that's, and they will be transferred
out of the Graduate Plus provisions altogether.
So what I wanted to talk about just,
or mention in terms of the upshot for political economy,
if we think about that,
is the Graduate Plus expanded access
during its 21 year run
and it reproduced structural inequity, right?
So that contradiction is both true
and that contradiction is part of the structure
of this loan program.
Next slide.
And just related to the previous slide,
I just wanna emphasize that often graduate students
are using this to offset living expenses.
And even though many of our doctoral programs
in particular provide graduate assistantships,
we all know that those graduate assistantships
are not enough to really fully live off of.
So it allowed for additional support
for those students to complete their degree program.
So we don't want them to take on full-time jobs
and try to complete their programs.
So it does have a significant,
it can have a potentially significant impact
on those students.
So as we were thinking about this presentation,
we were asking ourselves, what do we need to think about?
What kinds of questions will help us dig into
what are the implications for each of our institutions,
be it private, public, nonprofit, or for-profit?
And so some of the questions that we came up with
is what percentage of our students will be impacted
and how will it affect our tuition revenue
at our universities?
And so at Norfolk State as a public institution
that we have fewer doctoral PhD programs,
we have a small percentage of our students
who are actually using Grab Plus Loans.
So it won't be as big of a hit right now.
It will for those students who get it.
But as we grow our doctoral portfolio,
we are likely to start having more issues
with students needing that
to supplement their educational journey.
Also, what percentage of undergraduate students
are Pell eligible and how many of those
and carry debt into their graduate programs?
As Scott, I think Scott said
that we have about 40% of our graduate students
are our undergraduate students.
So those are those students
who really rely heavily on financial aid
and are likely carrying debt
into the graduate education space as well.
And then which graduate programs will exceed
just because of the cost of tuition?
And for us at NSU, being a public institution,
out-of-state students have twice the tuition rate
than in-state students.
Those students are going to hit those caps much sooner
than our resident students.
And so we are likely to take a hit
on the number of students who are coming out of state
if we cannot supplement that in some way
in terms of providing support to those students.
And Scott, I don't know if you want to share
kind of from the Hampton perspective
on some of those questions.
Yeah, just a little bit.
So I have been talking with some of our colleagues
across the HBCU space about what percentage
of their graduate tuition revenue is funded by Grad Plus.
At Hampton in the previous academic year,
that was, we were looking at about $2.5 million
of graduate tuition revenue.
So what that translates into is risk, right?
It's not gonna be as substantial as it is
at some of the institutions mentioned below
at North Carolina A&T or Morgan State or Howard,
which have higher graduate enrollments, right?
Where the risk is gonna be more significant,
but it is a risk nonetheless.
And then, you know, DESE's student population,
we were talking about this,
but percentage of your under,
we looked at the IPEDS data, right?
The percentage of undergraduate students
who are Pell eligible at Norfolk State
is higher than those who take out Pell grants
than at Hampton, right?
So that's an important data point
for thinking about this conversation
and how we approach these questions
and the problems and challenges
that carry forward from them.
And then, you know, I will say that, you know,
just, I met just this week with our admitted students so far
who are coming in the fall, summer or fall of 2026.
And, you know, a number of them are not from Hampton,
but are from other HBCUs, right?
We had students from North Carolina A&T,
we had students from Spelman,
we have students from other places.
So it's important to think about this question
in this space.
I'm really glad that we're having this conversation.
The lifetime loan caps, that last question,
I am really concerned about our PharmD, our DPT,
our programs that are more costly
in our professional degrees
that are not eligible currently for the higher loan caps
as designated by the federal policy
that's coming into place in July 1st.
Next slide.
Okay, so I wanted to share this.
I was thinking about, you know,
both scholars like Andy McClanahan,
but all, and Chris Newfield,
but also I've been following Robert Kelchin,
many of you may as well.
But in his book, Higher Ed Accountability,
he wrote, and that was from 2018, so it's a bit old now,
but still, he's, you know, this is what he says,
you know, the percentage of borrowers
and the amount borrowed per student
has increased, right, since 2005.
Remember, 2005 is when Grant Plus kicked in.
And the total student loan debt has increased quickly,
nearly tripling just in the 11 years
between 2005 and 2016 after adjusting for inflation.
40% of that 1.26 trillion, which now is 1.27, right,
40% of that debt is held by graduate
and professional students, right?
So about $750 billion of total student loan debt
is held by students who are pursuing
or pursued an undergraduate education,
and 500 billion is held
by graduate and professional students.
And I wanted to just say that
because when we think about the political economy of HBCUs,
we wanna think about the broader political economy
of graduate education as well.
These two have interaction with one another as well.
Next slide.
Okay, and this just sets the picture
a little bit more specifically within HBCUs.
So you have the undergraduate picture there
just so we can have that out there.
This is according to
the National Post-Secondary Student Aid Study.
81.4% of HBCU students receive some form
of federal Title IV financial aid
in the 2019-2020 academic year
compared to 54% of all students.
67, almost 68% receive a Pell Grant.
64% receive a federal student loan.
Among HBCU students who do receive
that Title IV aid, the average amount is 13,126.
The average Pell is 5,050,
and the average federal student loan amount
is 10,961 for HBCU students.
And I added this particular statistic
because I think this is important.
African-American bachelor degree recipients overall
have an average of $52,000 in student loan debt
that they're carrying with them.
Nearly half of that is from loans they've taken out
to pursue graduate degrees.
So now shifting from that picture
to Graduate Plus specifically,
Graduate Plus is about 37.7% of federal student loans
that are given to graduate students at HBCUs.
And that's compared to a little bit higher
than at non-HBCUs, 33%.
Critically though, and this is important,
while there is a larger share of HBCU students
who rely on Graduate Plus loans,
they actually carry lower balances
than their non-HBCU peers.
And I think that speaks a little bit,
as the Century Foundation suggests,
to the difference to what we offer at HBCUs,
which is an affordable graduate education.
So, and now we could talk about
what affordable looks like and what it means,
but that's a really important point to think about.
So students are taking out on average a bit less
at HBCUs than at our non-HBCUs counterparts.
Next slide.
And so what this slide shows you,
kind of from what Scott has been saying,
is kind of who's going to be affected the most.
So you will see that the percentage of Graduate Plus
borrowers really fall predominantly
in the professional degrees across the board.
So master's, research doctorates have high enough debt,
but the professional programs are the ones
that are particularly going to be a problem
for us as HBCUs.
And how we address those issues
is going to be part of the conversation
that needs to happen over the next few years,
trying to help navigate this for our students
so that we can continue to promote those students
who can do the value added to our communities.
Next slide.
Yeah, so HBCUs, I think we all know this,
but HBCUs are in a really challenging
structural position, right?
We're structurally precarious.
We are less well-resourced with less cash on hand
and smaller endowments and more first-generation,
lower wealth eligible students.
At the same time, we perform a nationally recognized
critical role in the political economy of the United States,
both in terms of economic impact and labor,
workforce development, and so on and so forth.
The contemporary structural precarity of HBCUs
is historical, right?
But what it really means today
is that HBCUs are not in a financial position to say no.
It makes us more potentially vulnerable
to corporate and philanthropic capture,
and that precarity also means that we're less able
to provide institutional aid to our graduate students.
Desi mentioned this, and so did Reggie, right?
But we need to be able to support our students
now more than ever,
but we are not fully capable of doing so,
especially given the fact that some of our students
have that disproportionate need for that aid.
And then last but not least,
this is a little bit of a difference
between our two institutions,
but one worth thinking about is we primarily, as HBCUs,
support our graduate students
through federal and state funding, right?
And in particular, I think about Title III Part B, HBTI,
but also NSF, NIH.
And then for state, that varies,
but in Virginia, at Hampton,
we use the Virginia Tuition Assistance Grant,
which funds our graduate students
who are domiciled Virginia residents
who are pursuing advanced degrees
in health-related professions, right?
Desi, did you want to jump in here for a sec?
Yeah, at NSU,
we actually have state-funded tuition fellowships,
which can also support in-state
and a percentage of out-of-state students,
so the state provides that level of funding.
But also, I think the concern is,
as there is increased competition for research grants
and these limits with where we are in our country,
with what that means and who we can serve,
then there is concern about whether or not
those grants might be at risk
that provide a lot of support to our students as well.
Next slide.
So basically, graduate enrollment has really expanded,
especially at HBCUs since the 70s.
So we all see the need for a population
in which we have more skilled, more knowledgeable personnel
to work in our communities.
And so public HBCUs just anchor that graduate system,
enrolling a lot of our master's and doctoral students.
And while undergraduate enrollment is declining
across the board for many institutions,
we find that graduate enrollment is either stable or rising.
And I know it in a shoe,
we see that we have more capacity for graduate enrollment,
but we are almost at capacity
in terms of our undergraduate enrollment.
So a lot more focus has been on graduate enrollment.
So this shift has allowed HBCUs
to move from primarily undergraduate-focused institutions
to dual mission,
with a lot of focus on graduate and professional programs.
So we have a dual commitment
to both our undergraduate and our graduate students.
So this grad plus long issue has direct implications
for that growth as we move forward.
Next slide.
Yeah, so we're coming to the end here and we can wrap up.
But I think one thing that Reggie and I have talked about
and Desi and I have talked about
is how determination of grad plus,
what it will mean practically for our students.
And one thing it might do
is push them into the private market, right?
And on the one hand,
it's not clear that the private market is ready for that
and can even handle that.
On the other hand, I know everyone in this room,
I am sure, is very worried or concerned about our students
and whether they will be vulnerable
to a private market or lender
that is not transparent
and does not have the same regulatory framework
that federal loans have, right?
They have variable rates,
they have different repayment plans,
they may or may not be eligible
depending on credit score, credit worthiness,
FICO score, et cetera.
There's a lot of questions out there.
So there's a lot to talk about,
but what can administrators do?
This is just a list we came up with.
Well, first and foremost,
we gotta keep talking to our graduate students, right?
Especially about debt, about these issues,
about their lives,
about what inequality feels like
and looks like for them on a daily basis.
And broadly speaking,
we need to talk about the cost and value
of a graduate education and financial planning.
That's the most important one.
I do wanna see new partnerships
with regional employers for HBCUs.
I wanna see more tuition assistance programs.
I wanna see more service commitments
from the regional economies that we serve.
And that means the kind of exchanges
that you're probably familiar with
where a student will have some support
to close the gaps that we're addressing here.
And in exchange, they'll work for the industry
or for the employer for a number of years.
I'd love to see more industry-aligned
curricular revisions within our institutions.
And I really, this is a big one for me,
I really wanna see more partnerships
in and among and between HBCUs.
I do think at the end of the day,
there's an old story that's still true,
which is that we have to help each other
and do it ourselves, right?
There's not going to be,
with the end of grad plus,
there's not gonna be another grad plus,
there's not gonna be a graduate pal,
as far as I can tell, right?
We have to work with each other to lift each other up
and create the number,
expand the number and kind of pathways
to the master's and the PhD
for our students and the populations we serve.
I just wanna see us get creative too.
I do think remapping coursework is really important.
The second to last bullet point there is important,
just designing and implementing
stackable affordable credentials
is an affordability issue.
If a graduate student cannot enroll full-time
for all the reasons we've said,
then it's still possible for them
to begin a certificate or a micro-credential
and then build on that
and use it towards their actual completion
of a master's or graduate degree.
And then we do need more support across the board.
So graduate assistantships of all kinds
are one way to do that.
Next slide.
And so what can institutions consider?
We know that part of what the federal government is doing
is trying to push tuition rates down
because they've grown so much over the year.
And then there's also the question
about the value of education,
but we know there's a value of education
and a value for graduate school.
So considering are there new ways
of looking at tuition structures?
I know lots of states in Virginia
have incentives to keep tuition flat.
And so what can institutions do
in terms of pricing for our students
given the changes in our federal policies?
So fee schedules and total cost of attendance estimates
must be transparent
so new students know what they're getting into.
They must be evaluated and adjusted
to make sure that we are supporting our students
and aligning with the missions
of what we're trying to do as HBCUs.
We gotta look at the cost of attendance
and what's possible in terms of capacity for these students
because we don't want them to be vulnerable
to predatory lenders
because we know they are out there.
So are there things that universities can look at
while sustaining the university
because we know it's a balancing act.
Tuition income supports the institution,
supports the faculty to teach those students.
But are there other kinds of financial support
that can keep pace with the cost of living?
In the state of Virginia,
graduate assistants were required to get increases
in their assistantship rate over the last three years.
So we kept pace at what faculty and staff were getting
that graduate students had to get that as well.
But we know that some of these packages
are not livable wages for our students.
So are there ways to increase those funding supports
for doctoral students in particular?
And what about those funding sources
that many of us have access to with Title III?
Given that the allocation is fairly substantial
for graduate schools, especially in the STEM areas,
what can we do in terms of using those funds
to leverage additional support
for our students at the universities?
And then we also need to make sure
our financial aid officers and CFOs and those leaders
increase the support for student learning,
especially in terms of managing debt, considering debt,
looking at what the repayment plans are,
considering the different options that are out there.
We need them because they are the experts on finances
and what students need to consider
so that we can communicate that to our students
so that they can make the best decisions possible
to still get the degrees
that will enhance their lives and our communities.
And then finally, I know Scott and I have talked about this,
is the data infrastructure for HBCUs
are sometimes a challenge.
Trying to understand what is the data
to help us understand the impact of some of these issues.
So we need to have better data systems
so that we can pull up on it and make better decisions.
We need to make sure our data's clean,
robust, reliable, and actionable
because data is what's going to sell
what we need from other systems in our ecosystem.
And the bottom line is we just gotta communicate
all of this to our external stakeholders.
What is the value of a graduate education?
How does it affect our communities
so that we know that that educational premium
is still there for graduate education
so that it does not get lost in this conversation
of what is the value of college.
And college then drives graduate education.
They cannot get these degrees
without going through the undergraduate process
because we need to set the stage for the higher learning
that they need to do at the graduate level.
So these are some of the strategies
that we think we need to consider.
And now we wanna open it up for any questions
that you might have in the audience.
All right, I am checking.
We have one in the Q&A.
The question is, is there a conversation
going across HBCU graduate leaders about these strategies?
And I will say, yes, we have a monthly meeting
where we come together and we talk about these strategies.
And I will also say, I think,
Scott and Desi both talked about this piece
and I'll just make it very plain for this room
is that none of us believe in competition
outside of athletics.
And so we are all really concerned
about the long-term growth and development
of all of our institutions, especially right now.
As we, historically, we have been able
to survive some of these adverse policies
by this administration prior to 2020 and now post.
But these individuals have been very, very shrewd
in understanding higher education more this time
than they did post COVID.
And so, as you can tell, just as of yesterday,
they tightened this OBBA policy
as it relates to the grad plus loan going away
because one of the things
that we were telling our students was,
make sure that you apply for a grad plus loan
because you'll be grandfathered in.
And part of that would be the cap would remain the same.
As of yesterday, that cap now transitioned with you
if you are a current policy holder.
So they are watching us very, very carefully.
So I think, to my colleague's point,
is we have to come together as historically black colleges,
in the graduate educational space,
and write grants together, send our students to each other,
look for philanthropic support together
to ensure that these institutions last long
beyond our time.
I think we are currently out of time,
but we have, if the room is okay,
we have, I would like to at least address
two or three more of these questions before we log off.
Have another question, and I'll just,
so how we'll do it, colleagues,
I'll ask Desi one, then Scott the next,
and we'll try to get them all in
before we get booted out.
The next question is,
what are reforms that grad schools need to make?
Are too many credit hours being required?
Are there more cost efficient ways
to deliver instruction and compensate faculty?
And Desi, that will be yours.
Okay, I think we have got to look at curriculum.
We are traditionalists,
and faculty like to do what we've always done,
but I think we need to look at data,
and I think we need to look at markets
in terms of what the market needs
in terms of preparing students for the jobs
that we're sending them out to,
and streamline some of these processes,
and have more transparency in some of the processes
that students need to go through
to complete degree requirements,
and so I think each program needs to evaluate market data
to say these are the skills,
and these are the technical skills,
the durable skills that are needed
for a student to be successful in the profession,
and we should be relying on those industries
or those markets in which we're sending our students out to,
be it a research space, be it a industry space,
a nonprofit space, we need to rely on that
to reevaluate curriculum,
and then start to prepare our students
more directly for those things,
which means that we probably won't need all the stuff
that we think we need,
because we don't have to do everything
for a student who's in graduate school.
You learn it as you also graduate.
We need to prepare them for the entry-level positions
that the degree is preparing them for.
Yeah, I couldn't agree more with that.
All right, and so Scott,
since this is a proud Hampton alum that asked this question,
I'll ask you this.
How are HBCUs considering redesigning curriculum
to adopt meaningful pathways
that lead to AI-driven careers?
That's great, yeah.
So I think we talk a lot about this.
Right now, we are actually coming to the very end
of our work on our AI policy,
so that should be coming out and be published,
actually, probably within the week, I hope,
or in the near future.
So that policy, though, building that policy
has meant a lot of benchmarking,
has meant a lot of reading other institutional policies,
and it's meant a lot of conversation
about what AI means across all of our units
in the university system.
Universities are complex, right?
So what AI means to me and in the graduate college
is very different than what it means
for my colleagues in engineering, right?
And I understand you're a Hampton engineering alum.
So you may know, though,
that we just launched our undergraduate degree
in mechanical engineering,
and one of the features of that undergraduate degree
is that, or we will be launching it in the fall,
but one of the features of that degree
is that it has AI baked into it,
which wouldn't be the case
if we were too traditionalist, right?
So even in the process of developing that curriculum,
I've watched the conversations
and been a fly on the wall listening
to how we think about AI at the graduate level
and how these programs prepare our students
for graduate education,
where AI is part of the conversation
and AI-driven careers are part of the everyday work
that our career services does
and part of the everyday work that our faculty do.
It is very much a part of Hampton's conversations
in leadership spaces.
In the rooms that I am in, we talk a lot about AI.
I guess redesigning curriculum in other respects to me,
just echoing what Desi said,
is we got to have PhD programs
that have concentrations and pathways
that have AI baked into them.
I need to see that our advanced degrees
are preparing our students to enter the workforce,
enter the careers they want to pursue
in ways that are AI literate,
and that has to happen in the curricular revision process
as much as anywhere else.
I do want to echo too what Desi said,
that you want to see students having those experiences.
I want to see them in the industry spaces.
I want to bring industries into campus
so that we have that interaction
and that interaction is part of the shaping driving force
of what redesigned curriculum actually means, right?
So it's not just the traditionalists in the room,
but it's actually a genuine conversation.
So we're really making the curriculum aligned
with what our students actually do with their degrees.
And so for this final question,
I'll ask that we all give a stab at it.
And as part of our closing remarks.
And so the question is,
is there a collective strategy for educating students
and prospective students about these reforms?
And I can tell you that here at Clark Atlanta University,
I'm working, meeting with my partners in financial aid
and our CFO to look at what that strategy is.
And we are having,
we are planning a webinar for our current graduate students
and then also for our prospective graduate students.
And we're going to talk about all of the impacts.
So we're going to talk about the impact
of the grad plus loan going away,
what the other options are,
and we're going to constantly communicate
with those students throughout this process.
So they won't have, if you will,
sticker shop come July 1st to realize
that that option is going away.
And I'll say this as I close,
I think Scott and Desi did a great job
in highlighting the impact of it.
And Scott also hinted at this,
grad plus loan as we know it will not come back.
We were at the CGS in December.
And one of the thing,
one of the presenters who was an economist
that stated very clearly,
higher education is one of the longest funded entities
in the federal government
and longer funded than any other entity that has been funded.
And so the fact that this loan has gone away
and the fact, from my perspective,
that you have not seen any lawsuits
to try to at least slow that process down
suggests to us that it will not go away.
It will not come back.
And so in that understanding,
we, the collective, we have to be prepared
and pivot to what funding looks like
for the graduate educational space
moving into the 22nd century.
And I'll end with that note.
Desi and Scott.
So I just wanna say financial literacy in general
is important to talk to our students about.
I think we as a society do not do well
with debt and money management kinds of issues.
And so it is imperative for us as graduate leaders
to provide those opportunities to students
about how to do it better,
how to consider their options,
how to think through what all those things means
in terms, in the short term, as well as the long term.
And so I'm also working with our financial aid office
to see how we can improve upon that with our students
and prepare them better for how to navigate
the financial spaces that we all live in.
Yeah, just echo both Reggie and Desi.
Yes, working really, I think probably you'll see this
across the space, but just a much closer interaction
and working with financial aid officers
and with CFO's office to bring forward
and develop that collective strategy
for educating students and prospective students.
And something I do, I mean, we've been,
our financial aid unit redesigned its website
to do that work as well.
So there is a public facing component to that.
I'm glad that we're here talking about it.
Something I do as well is interact
with our graduate students
through a couple of different channels
to educate them about their options.
But it does, I think the game has changed so much
that everyone has to be, as you said,
much more literate about debt, about financial aid,
about how it works, about how these backend systems
interact with our students, their parents,
their families and our communities
because it is such a structural issue
that it cannot be ignored.
Well, thank you all for joining us.
Thank you to the audience
and the attendees for participating.
And I wanna thank the HBCU Center
for inviting us to have this most important conversation.
Thank you and enjoy the rest of your conference.
And we go backstage.