Today's video is a tasting of two Brunello di Montalcinos priced at around $20 per bottle. Both are exclusive labels, one to Costco, the other to Trader Joe's. Brunello at this price is virtually unheard of, but here we are with two options. Both are from the highly acclaimed 2020 vintage. Each wine will be tasted twice as part of a single-blind tasting, meaning I know which wines are in the tasting, but not the order poured. First, I'll taste the wines soon after they are opened.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This video features a blind tasting and comparison of two budget-friendly 2020 Brunello di Montalcino wines: the Kirkland Signature (Costco) and the Poggio Lentano (Trader Joe's). The reviewer evaluates both wines immediately upon opening and again after four hours of aeration to determine which offers better value and quality.
Today's video highlights two Brunello di Montalcino's,
both of which are exclusives, one to Costco, the other to Trader Joe's.
It's virtually unheard of to find a Brunello priced at around $20,
but here we are with two options.
Both are from the highly acclaimed 2020 vintage.
As for the tasting, there'll be two rounds and it'll be held as a single blind tasting,
meaning that I'll know which wines are in the tasting,
but I won't know the order in which they're poured.
I'll taste the wines soon after they've been opened.
I'll retaste the wines after several hours.
Let's get to it.
One of the wines is the 2020 Kirkland Signature Brunello di Montalcino found at Costco.
It's a seasonal wine that tends to sell out quickly.
You'll find it in the lay down wooden wine bins.
The price is up a bit from the last vintage.
I picked it up for $21.79.
The other wine is the 2020 Poggio Lentano Brunello di Montalcino sold only at Trader Joe's.
It's a limited time release available seasonally.
I've not tried this in previous vintages.
The price is also up a bit from the last offering at $23.99.
To get things started, my partner pulled the corks,
then she popped the wines into numbered burlap bags.
In terms of color, Sangiovese is typically just medium deep.
Wine one is a bit deeper and denser at the core.
Wine two has less color density.
With both, I could see my fingers through the base of the bowl.
With the side-by-side, wine one is on the left.
You can clearly see a difference in color.
With time, the color will continue to fade, often gaining an orange tinge at the rim.
Let's see what's going on in the wine glass.
There is a tart cherry characteristic.
That really is most evident.
Very typical of what you'll find in Sangiovese-based wines.
A bit of a plummy note.
It's also a dried herbal characteristic.
And sometimes with Sangiovese-based wines, you'll find a bit of a sun-dried tomato character.
This has it in a very subtle way.
The use of oak is really not overt here.
It's very subtle.
But there is a bit of alcohol heat.
And in recent years with Brunello, the vintages have been quite warm.
Oftentimes, the wines will be 14, 14.5, even a little bit higher than that.
This does have a bit of alcohol heat to it.
It's not off-putting, but you certainly can tell it's there.
On the palate, nice weight, good density.
The fruit has a good level of ripeness.
Again, that tart cherry character, that plummy note really is quite evident.
Quite savory.
The acidity is quite lifted.
And this is very typical for this sort of wine.
The back palate is very dry.
There's certainly some tannins there.
So there's a bit of astringency on the back palate.
Wine's a little bit tough right now.
It's really not showing a lot of character.
It's more like a single note.
It's not layered.
It's not complex.
It's really not showing its full range.
And I'm curious to see what happens with this wine with a bit of aeration.
So I'll come back to it in a few hours.
If you've not yet subscribed to my channel, please consider doing it right now.
Hit the like button.
Definitely hit that notification bell so you won't miss a thing.
If hype is an option, please hit that as well.
And share with your like-minded wine friends.
All of this helps to grow my channel.
It's very much appreciated.
The aroma on wine, too.
Similar sort of tart cherry characteristic.
It's more understated.
It's a bit more subtle.
More of a red fruit note than the previous wine.
This has more of a strawberry raspberry characteristic.
But again, it's not overly expressive.
It's not a very overt style.
It's more subtle.
And there is a little bit of alcohol heat here, just as there was in the previous wine.
And oak influence here is minimal.
This wine's really not showing a broad range of character.
Hopefully a bit of air will help that.
On the palate, a good weight here.
Again, that tart cherry character shows through.
A bit more of that red fruit note.
The acidity is just at a moderate level.
A little softer than the previous wine.
Oak is not a big component here.
Oak is really not so much here to lend that smoky charred vanilla character.
My feeling is this is probably older oak.
And it's really there to impart more of a softening effect through a slow oxidative process.
Wine's actually rather narrowly focused on the palate.
Just medium length.
It does finish very dry.
There's a bit of tannins here.
But the wine also seems quite mature for a 2020 Brunello.
It seems a bit advanced in that regard.
I don't know if air is really going to help this.
But let's give it a little time and we'll see what happens.
At this point, around four hours have passed since the wines were first opened.
And the remaining wine was not to can it.
It was just poured into a separate glass.
A four-finger pour of each.
A healthy pour of each.
I've come back and I've tasted the wines every now and then over that time.
So I have a bit of a read on it.
But my advice is this.
Brunello generally does benefit from aeration.
Long aeration.
Top bottlings oftentimes I may open in the morning to have that evening.
Sometimes I'll even open the wines the day before.
So if the wines are not fully mature, they definitely do need a good amount of aeration.
And even if the wines are mature, oftentimes they'll benefit from some as well.
So let's see what's going on here with the retaste of wine one.
So the aroma has changed a bit here.
It still has that tart cherry characteristic.
That plummy note to it.
There's some savoriness here.
The intensity has lifted a bit.
It's not really what I would hope.
I would really hope it would have a bit more than what it's showing.
But it has developed.
On the palate, again, the weight is good.
The structure here is quite good as well.
That oak note is there.
But again, quite subtle.
It has developed.
And on the back palate, it's softened a little bit.
And this has been four hours or so.
I'm really curious to see how this wine shows maybe later tonight or even tomorrow.
It's improved, but for Brunello di Montalcino, truth be told,
I'm really wishing, hoping that it would have shown a bit more.
It's not a bad wine.
But it's certainly not living up to the class that is Brunello.
So let's see what's going on with wine two.
The second wine has also had around four hours to aerate.
So let's see what's happening there.
Also, I have tasted this wine a few times over the last few hours.
Now in this case, the aroma actually has faded a bit.
And that's really quite disappointing for a wine of this sort.
That fruit intensity, which was actually rather subtle to start with,
has now even been a bit more diminished.
On the palate, there's some nice weight here.
There's no doubt about that.
But there's this odd character here where the fruit actually seems ripe.
But at the same time, there's also a bit of dilution.
On the back palate, it's really quite soft.
Certainly softer than the previous wine.
Lower acid, lower tannin level.
The level of maturity here does seem much more advanced.
But unfortunately, the time to aerate really did not help this wine.
So in that regard, not a good end result.
Time for the reveal.
And truth be told, neither wine in today's video was a standout.
But if I had to choose one, it would be wine one.
And that is the 2020 Kirkland Signature.
I've had this wine in previous vintages.
And my feeling is those past years really did show better than the example that I had today.
If you've tried the 2020, I'd love to hear from you.
Please comment down below.
I try to follow up on each and every comment.
Second wine, the Poggio Lentano.
This one really didn't do it for me.
That said, I'm a big fan of Trader Joe's.
In terms of value for the money, I think they really do a fine job.
This one just really did miss the mark.
Now, I try to bring you very good values for the money.
Today was a challenge.
If you're looking for value, search out a state bottled Rosso di Montalcino.
Oftentimes, you can find very good bottles in that 25-ish range.
Wines that are really better than what I had in today's offering.
Also, recently I posted a long format video on some wines from the Southern Rhone Valley.
Generally, they can be found for under $20 per bottle.
The wines are fantastic.
So you might want to check out that video.
As always, I appreciate your support.
Please come back again before too long.
Cheers.