How Did Cao Cao Destroy His Most Talented Son?

History & Culture of East
10 followers
42 Video Views·Jul 1, 2026
Brilliant Strategist (7:00 - 13:30): Fa Zheng was the architect of many of Liu Bei's victories, most notably the campaign to capture Hanzhong. The video highlights his military talent and political analytical skills, which helped Liu Bei rise from a weak position to become one of the three major powers.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe video analyzes the power struggle between Chao Pi and Chao Zhi for the succession of Chao Chao. While Chao Zhi possessed superior literary genius and initial favor, his arrogance and lack of discipline led to his downfall. In contrast, Chao Pi’s persistence, strategic networking, and resilience allowed him to secure the throne, though his subsequent reign was marked by petty vengeance.
Welcome back to battlecry historical records.
As discussed, after a fierce struggle among his 25 sons,
only two remained, Chao Pai and Chao Zhi, vying for the legacy Chao Chao had built.
As we know, Chao Pai emerged victorious, going on to oppress his brothers,
immortalized by the Seven Steps Verse. Yet, looking at how Chao Pai reached the summit,
it had nothing to do with him being the eldest son.
It was his persistence and tireless efforts to prove himself
and the fatal errors caused by Chao Zhi's arrogance.
Eldest, Second, Legitimate, or Secondary.
Chao Pai, courtesy name Zi Huan, was born in 187 in Chao County,
present-day Buzhou, Anhui Province. He was the firstborn son of Chao Chao and Lady Bian.
In his youth, Chao Pai mastered the classics of the Hundred Schools.
Born in turbulent times, Chao Chao brought him to the frontlines early.
He learned archery at six and horse riding at eight.
By ten, Chao Pai was already campaigning with the army.
As mentioned, Chao Chao had 25 sons in total.
Chao Huan, the eldest legitimate son, was the favored heir.
However, in 197, Chao Huan died while campaigning in the south.
Devastated, his mother, Lady Ding, severed ties with Chao Chao.
Lady Bian then became Chao Chao's primary wife.
Chao Pai became the eldest son, a turning point in his rise to power.
But this shift did not win him his father's favor.
As mentioned, he didn't favor the eldest son by birth.
Believing the throne should go to the most capable.
After Chao Huan died, Chao Chao doted on Chao Chong,
a brilliant prodigy famous by age six.
But in 2008, Chao Chong suddenly passed away at 13.
Chao Pai offered his condolences, only to receive a cold reply.
My misfortune is your good fortune, he remarked.
Once again, Pai realized he was not the chosen one.
After Ong and Chong, Chao Chao turned his favor to Chao Xi.
With a gift for poetry, Xi often accompanied his father on campaigns.
Naturally, Xi emerged as the leading heir candidate.
In short, Chao Pai was always cast in a supporting role.
No matter how he tried, he could not win his father's heart.
Like a diligent student never favored by the teacher.
He was a lonely child, left in the shadows and forgotten.
Pai deeply felt his father's cold indifference.
Chao Xi, born in 192 in Chao County, Pei State.
He was the third son of Chao Chao and Lady Bian.
From childhood, his talent stunned his father.
Much like Chao Chong had before him.
Legend says Chao Chao once doubted Xi's writings.
Asking if someone else had ghostwritten them.
Xi replied, my words flow effortlessly, test me right here.
After several tests, Chao Chao was convinced and grew fond of him.
Xi was only 10 when the Bronze Bird Terrace was built.
Yet when ordered to write, he composed the Bronze Bird Terrace O,
leaving his father stunned.
As he matured, he produced many renowned works like his Eastern Expedition Ode.
Or writings on the campaigns against the East, Wu, and the State of Shu.
He wrote of women's laments and abandoned wives.
And poems of great sorrow.
His contributions were so immense.
He became a central figure in shaping an entire era of literature.
Known in Chinese history as the Jianan poetry style.
Beyond his literary prowess, he was no slouch in military matters either.
Historical records note he held the critical defense of Yi City.
While Chao Chao campaigned against Sun Quan.
From the campaigns against the Wu Huan and Lu Biao.
To the Battle of Red Cliffs, he followed his father everywhere.
Given such talent, Chao Chao often considered naming him the heir apparent.
But officials urged against bypassing the eldest son, halting the plan.
Yet, we know Chao Chao was cold-blooded and would never hesitate.
To enforce a new order or suppress his own children.
With two sons gone, Chao Zhi became the prime candidate for the throne.
Everything seemed perfect for the prodigy, but Chao Pi would not yield.
Chao Pi realized he lacked his father's favor and affection.
Should he just step aside and let his younger brother rule?
Of course not.
One only truly fails when they give up entirely.
Chao Pi knew that without support, he had to remain calm and patient.
As long as he refused to admit defeat, no one could break him.
While Chao Zhi followed Chao Chao on his various expeditions.
Chao Pi remained at Yi City to manage the daily affairs.
Wherever rebellion stirred, Chao Pi was quick to lead his troops.
These experiences honed his ability to handle emergencies.
Back in the city, he showed great respect to veteran officials and scholars.
Actively expanding his circle of influence.
Before long, Chao Pi built a formidable team of advisors.
All while maintaining favor with his father.
Even in the realm of poetry, though less gifted than his brother.
He persisted in his writing, eventually compiling his own collection.
Though to this day, his work is often compared to that of his brother, Chao Zhi.
Despite knowing this, Chao Pi quietly pressed on in his literary pursuits.
Beyond writing poetry, he refined his skills in criticism.
He dedicated significant effort to compiling an anthology of the great writers of the Jianan era.
He offered objective, fair assessments of their work.
His Dianluan was China's first formal work of literary criticism.
Leaving a profound legacy for future generations.
Despite being the son of Chao Chao.
Chao Pi remained, in many ways, like any other man.
Struggling in the depths of life.
Often suppressed by his own kin.
Yet Chao Pi possessed a great strength.
He refused to bow to fate.
This defiance helped him stay composed even in his darkest hours.
He grew stronger through pain, tempering resilience with patience.
Eventually, his father's officials and Chao Chao himself took notice.
Arrogance, however, poisoned Chao Zhi's future.
Unlike Chao Pi, in the face of public acclaim.
They said, Chao Zhi holds eight-tenths of the world's talent.
They meant that if talent were measured in units.
Ten being the total, Chao Zhi claimed eight.
But this premature praise led Chao Zhi to adopt.
A subjective, complacent mindset.
Moreover, Chao Chao failed to raise his son properly.
Guiding Chao Zhi down a misguided path.
Regardless of status or power.
If it benefited Chao Zhi, Chao Chao provided it all.
He even intended to pass the succession to Chao Zhi.
And tasked Yang Xiao with gathering talented officials.
To serve as Chao Zhi's right-hand man.
Unexpectedly, such indulgence backfired.
Believing he was the heir, Chao Zhi became reckless.
Committing blunders that alienated officials and courtiers.
Chao Zhi grew unrestrained, acting on whim and drinking excessively.
Chao Chao's lax discipline led to mounting problems.
When Chao Chao prepared for battle, both sons came to see him off.
Chao Zhi improvised a speech praising his father's merits.
Deeply impressing everyone present.
Chao Pi, however, took advice from his attendants.
They urged him to show genuine sorrow and concern instead of flowery words.
Chao Pi followed suit, clutching his father's robe in tears.
Moving Chao Chao to respond in kind.
Conversely, Chao Chao grew wary, doubting Chao Zhi's devotion to the family.
In 217, a drunken Chao Zhi rode through the emperor's private gate and path.
This reckless act disappointed Chao Chao.
Yet he still offered his son a chance.
He punished the officials but spared Chao Zhi from any direct consequences.
That chance arrived in 219.
When Chao Ran was besieged at Fanchun by Guan Yu.
Amidst the crisis, Chao Chao dispatched several armies to reinforce him.
Chao Zhi was appointed as commander of one of those relief forces.
But Chao Pi's trap worked, Chao Zhi ended up hopelessly drunk.
Enraged by this, Chao Chao stripped him of all military command.
At this point, Chao Chao had completely lost faith in him.
Chao Zhi was cast aside from the political stage.
Though Chao Zhi was undisciplined and impulsive.
Had Chao Chao intervened sooner with stricter guidance.
And helped him overcome his flaws.
Perhaps his fate would not have been so tragic.
Chao Zhi possessed extraordinary literary talent.
Which made him prone to arrogance.
As a father, Chao Chao should have gently reminded him.
That there is always someone greater.
There is always someone more talented.
Yet Chao Chao failed to do so.
Instead, he constantly fueled Chao Zhi's ego.
Giving everyone the clear impression that Chao Zhi was his choice for heir.
Which only invited envy and certain failure.
Chao Chao bears significant responsibility for Chao Zhi's tragic life.
But Chao Zhi is not without blame.
His arrogance and reckless reliance on talent cost him his edge.
Turning the favored son into an outcast sidelined from the throne.
Clearly, between a son who lacks genius but strives to improve.
And one who is gifted but disrupts order.
Whom would you choose?
Chao Chao surely chose as you would.
Chao Pi became the successor.
Yet upon ascending the throne, Chao Pi proved quite petty.
He began settling old scores, including some trivial grudges.
First was his uncle, Chao Hong, dating back to his youth.
While out, Chao Pi saw his friend Lu Feng wearing a precious jade pendant.
Chao Pi boasted he could buy one too.
But he lacked the funds.
He recalled his uncle, Chao Hong, who had recently returned from battle with rewards.
He went to borrow money, but Chao Hong refused, claiming he had none.
This incident left Chao Pi harboring a deep grudge.
Once emperor, he used a pretext to imprison Chao Hong and sentence him to death.
The court was horrified, as Chao Hong was a pillar of Wei.
Moreover, he had once saved Chao Chao's life.
If Chao Pi executed him, he would surely lose the support of his subjects.
Officials pleaded for mercy, urging the emperor to revoke the death sentence.
Yet, Chao Pi remained adamant about executing his uncle.
Only after Empress Dowager Bian intervened did he spare his life.
Though he still insisted on seizing Chao Hong's entire estate.
Later, the Empress Dowager pleaded once more, and Chao Pi finally relented.
Reluctantly returning the property while seething with resentment.
The next target was Yang Jun.
A seasoned veteran official from the days of Chao Chao.
The grudge began when Chao Chao asked him who should succeed him.
Yang Jun gave a vague answer, citing the strengths of both Chao Pi and Chao Xi.
Without explicitly favoring anyone.
For that alone, Chao Pi felt slighted and held a deep grudge.
Once emperor, Chao Pi made a surprise visit to the district where Yang Jun lived.
He claimed the area lacked proper decorum and had Yang Jun imprisoned.
Sima Yi and other officials begged for his release.
Some cowed out until they bled, yet Chao Pi refused to grant amnesty.
Recalling Chao Hong's ordeal, Yang Jun realized it was personal vengeance and took his own life.
Just as Chao Pi basked in power, news of Wu's betrayal turned his face pale.
He immediately ordered his armies to invade Jiangdong.
Official Bao Sun dared to advise against the campaign.
Hearing this, Chao Pi recalled an old grievance with him.
Years ago, when Chao Pi was heir, the brother of his consort,
Lady Guo, broke the law and faced death.
Chao Pi had tried to intervene, but Bao Sun refused to show leniency.
Now, the time for revenge had come.
He dismissed Bao Sun, blocking his path to ever return to power.
Yet in the end, Bao Sun was executed.
Bao Sun was the son of Bao Xi'an,
who saved Chao Chao's life during the Yellow Turban Rebellion.
Chao Chao had always treated the Bao family with great favor.
But Chao Pi showed no hesitation in killing his father's benefactor's son.
Because of this, many argue that
Chao Pi's pettiness sowed the first seeds of division within Chao Wei.
This provided the perfect opening for Sima Yi.
In no time, he won over the people and seized control.
