For Further Reading 📚 Cynthia Salzman, Plunder: Napoleon’s Theft of Veronese’s Feast (Farrar, Straus, Giroux, 2021) Cecil Gould, Trophy of Conquest: The Musée Napoléon and the Creation of the Louvre (Faber and Faber, 1965) Christopher M. S. Johns, Antonio Canova and the Politics of Patronage in Revolutionary and Napoleonic Europe, chapter 7 (University of California Press, 1998) Andrew McClellan, “Musée du Louvre, Paris: Palace of the People, Art for All,” in The First Modern Museums of Art: The birth of an Institution 18th- and Early-19th-Century Europe, edited by Carole Paul (The J. Paul Getty Museum, 2012) Andrew McClellan, Inventing the Louvre: Art, Politics, and the Origins of the Modern Museum in Eighteenth-Century Paris (Cambridge University Press, 1994)
Image Credits 🖼 Wikimedia (Shadowgate, smerikal, Ming-yen Hsu, Oakenchips, Mossot, Bryan Rutherford, 伊部リコ, Paul Hermans, GalleriX, Alvesgaspar, Sailko, Eduardo Franco Rondina, rob Stoeltje, jeffwarder, John Salatas) National Gallery of Art Statens Museum for Kunst, Denmark Rijksmuseum Musée Carnavalet - Histoire de Paris Library of Congress Getty Images
0:00 Introduction 0:45 Royal Art Collection at the Louvre 2:01 Louvre during the French Revolution 5:15 Looting of Rubens's Antwerp Altarpiece 6:23 Napoleon's spoliation 7:51 Disastrous extraction of Veronese's Mural 10:18 Paris as the New Rome 11:37 Partial restitution of Napoleonic spoils 12:25 Conclusion
The Louvre, the world's most visited and largest art museum,
housing more than 380,000 works of art dating from prehistory to the 21st century.
It is said that if you spend 30 seconds looking at every one of the 35,000 works of art on display
at the museum, it would take you around 200 days to see everything.
It makes me wonder, was the Louvre always this big?
How did it become the mega museum as we know it?
In this episode, we're going to explore the dark origins of the Louvre,
forged in the fires of the revolution and the wars,
centered around this man by the name of Napoleon Bonaparte.
I know it's hard to believe it, but the Louvre wasn't always an art museum.
It was built in the 12th century as a royal palace with a fortress,
which you can still see in the museum's basement.
As a seat of the French monarchy in the capital,
the Louvre housed the king's art collection, which began with Francis I in the 16th century
and expanded into one of the largest in Europe by the 1700s.
But this royal collection was not readily accessible to the French people.
In the early modern period, the notion of a public museum open to everybody did not yet exist.
Artworks were mostly kept private for aristocratic and princely patrons.
But beginning in the 1700s, there was a growing pressure in Europe,
influenced by Enlightenment philosophy,
to open up art collections for the enjoyment and education of the people.
And France was no exception.
In fact, it was in the 18th century that museums such as the Uffizi Gallery in Florence
or the British Museum in London became open to the public for the first time.
In France, when Louis XVI acceded to the throne,
there was an initiative to open up the royal art collection of the Louvre to the people.
But the project fell through because the crown was in financial ruins.
And it was actually during the French Revolution that the Louvre became a public museum.
Soon after the storming of the Bastille, under the banner of liberty and equality,
the properties of churches and former aristocrats were seized
and nationalized into properties of the state.
Countless artworks were confiscated or destroyed by the people
because they served as potent symbols of the tyranny of the privileged in the monarchical system.
And the idea was to gather confiscated works of art
and display them together in a public museum for the edification of the people.
And what better place to do this than the Louvre, a former royal palace?
One of the supporters of this idea wrote,
those treasures which were previously visible to only a privileged few
will henceforth afford pleasure to all.
Statues, paintings, and books are charged with the sweat of the people.
The property of the people will be returned to them.
On August 10, 1793, on the first anniversary of the abolition of the monarchy,
the Louvre opened its doors under its new name, Musée Central des Arts.
The Grande Galerie of the Louvre, running along the Seine River,
was chosen as a site for displaying the artworks.
But turning the quarter-mile-long gallery into a space for displaying so much art
posed significant challenges.
You can see the proposed solution to these problems in this imagined reconstruction of the space
painted by the artist Hubert Robert in 1796.
The newly built walls along the gallery to block the windows and maximize hanging space,
skylights above to provide natural light,
and columns to break up the space into several bays.
The painting shows people sketching and copying the artworks on display,
and adults and children conversing,
using the museum as a space for learning and appreciating art.
Although the renovations of the Grande Galerie took years to complete,
there was one change that was implemented rather quickly,
and that was the way in which paintings were hung.
Traditionally, in aristocratic and princely collections,
artworks were displayed without strictly following the chronological or national order.
They were hung side by side to allow them to talk to each other visually and aesthetically.
But at the New Louvre, artworks,
including the ones confiscated from churches and aristocratic residences,
were methodically divided into chronology and national schools for two reasons.
First, it was simply too time-consuming to make the aesthetic decision
of which painting looks best next to which one because there were so many of them.
And second, the chronological and geographic order
stripped the artworks of their former meanings steeped in monarchical past.
In other words, this new way of hanging cast them as objects in the grand narrative of art history,
neutralizing their sacred and social meanings attached to their former owners.
And this chronological and geographic mode of art display still persists in today's museums.
Doesn't that make you think twice about art museums?
And this issue of decontextualizing art became especially pressing
as the French government began its policy of looting art from other countries
that it invaded and occupied during the Revolutionary Wars.
In 1794, the French army defeated the Austrians in what is now Belgium,
marched into the cathedral in Antwerp,
took the altarpiece by the Flemish painter Peter Paul Rubens depicting the raising of the cross,
one of the most famous pictures in the world at the time.
They carted it off to Paris along with several other paintings
where it was put on display at the Louvre.
According to the author Cynthia Salzman,
the French justified their spoliation less as a military plunder
than as an act of liberating these works of art for the new republic,
stating that these artworks were more at home in France,
than the so-called alien soil in which they were subject to the gaze of servitude for centuries.
It was repackaging stolen art into public good under the pretext of liberty and equality.
And this looting of the Rubens' altarpiece set the precedent for the rampant spoliation
across Europe that gained steam with the rise of the new superstar Napoleon Bonaparte.
As a charismatic leader of the French Republican army during the Italian campaign,
Napoleon made art looting a routine element of his conquest,
his art consultants going around the occupied territories
with shopping lists of artworks to confiscate.
He also forced his vanquished enemies to surrender hundreds of famous paintings,
sculptures, decorative objects, and manuscripts in their collections as a condition of peace.
And it was in Italy that he confiscated an enormous number of high renaissance
and baroque masterpieces that would enter the Louvre's collection.
His Italian loots included the most famous paintings by Raphael,
who was considered the finest artist of all time,
Titian, Mantegna, Correggio, and more Rubens and Rembrandts,
as well as the four bronze horses atop the portal at the Basilica of San Marco in Venice
and the winged lion in the Piazzetta San Marco nearby.
Napoleon even forced the Pope into giving up a hundred sculptures from the Vatican and Rome,
including the superstars from classical antiquity such as the Apollo Belvedere,
the Leocuan,
the Dying Gaul,
the Belvedere Torso,
etc.,
as well as many, many paintings.
Because many of these artworks were never meant to be portable,
they had to be literally ripped off the walls and architectural structures
into which they were embedded.
The extraction of these works of art caused rampant destruction of their original settings,
including churches.
And their transport to the Louvre across land and water
put them in grave danger of damage and loss.
The most egregious episode in a destructive spoliation of art by the French
was the extraction of Veronese's colossal painting of the wedding feast at Cana,
painted in 1563,
to decorate the refectory of the Benedictine monastery of San Giorgio Maggiore in Venice.
Measuring over 32 feet in width,
this enormous canvas depicts Christ's miracle of turning water into wine at a marriage celebration,
and it was widely acclaimed for centuries as the most beautiful painting in the world.
To take down this massive canvas,
the French soldiers had to pry the canvas off the architectural frame and its stretcher,
wrap it around a cylinder,
pack it into a crate,
and ship it across the Mediterranean.
But to everyone's surprise,
as the canvas came off the wall,
the hidden nails holding the giant canvas together popped off,
and the paint covering these nails broke off into pieces.
The disaster didn't end there.
Once the 235-year-old canvas arrived in Paris after months of transport,
the French painting restorers found the massive canvas so difficult to work with
that they cut the painting into two halves,
slicing through the fragile 16th-century paint.
Such careless handling of historic artworks undermined the French argument
that these works of art were in such bad conditions in their original locations
and were better off in France
because the French knew best how to properly restore and maintain them.
In fact, when some of the looted paintings were returned to their original collections,
the Louvre restorers were later criticized for their heavy-handed techniques,
which permanently altered and damaged the works.
Napoleon looted art not because he loved or appreciated it,
but because he recognized the political impact
of building a massive collection of masterpieces from vanquished territories.
It gave him the aura of legitimacy and power lacking in his humble origins.
And the practice of spoliation certainly harked back to ancient Rome,
when art and architectural monuments were commonly looted during military conquests.
To posit France as a new Rome,
the French held a military parade on July 27, 1798,
showcasing the war booty from Italy.
In a long line of crates, manuscripts, animals,
natural history specimens, and famous works of art,
including the bronze horses of Venice,
were paraded from the Seine to the Champ de Mars,
to the marching of soldiers and military bands.
A song commissioned for this event sang,
Rome is no more in Rome.
Every hero, every great man has changed country.
Rome is no more in Rome. It is all in Paris.
Napoleon's loots from Italy and elsewhere were shipped to the Louvre,
which since 1803 was called the Musée Napoléon,
as well as other provincial museums around France.
The Louvre's collection grew exponentially,
and the period from 1810 to 1815,
when Napoleon was the Emperor of France,
was a heyday for the Louvre.
People from all over Europe flocked to Paris to see this mega-museum,
unprecedented in size and splendor,
housing the masterpieces of antique sculpture,
as well as 16th and 17th century art under one roof.
But as the fate of Napoleon declined, so did that of the Louvre.
Around the defeat and abdication of Napoleon in 1815,
various European powers, beginning with the Prussians,
marched into the Louvre and took away their possessions.
It is believed that out of 506 paintings taken by Napoleon from Italy,
one half was restituted, meaning that they were returned back to Italy,
and the other half remains in France.
Although many of the looted artworks still remain in the Louvre,
which partly explains why the museum today is so huge,
this process of restitution set the precedent
for the modern-day repatriation of artworks
unethically or unlawfully stolen
during wars and colonial regimes all across the world.
As you may already know, the Louvre is just one of many museums
that are built upon wartime loots and unethically acquired artworks.
The current controversies surrounding works of art,
such as the Benin Bronzes or the Elgin Marbles,
are clear indications that we're still grappling with the same problem.
Although I love art museums and think that they're essential parts of modern culture,
I think it's important to know where artworks come from
and how they ended up in museums.
And I hope this story helps you to see that museums are not neutral spaces,
but places very much shaped by political and cultural contest for power.
That's it for this episode.
Thanks for watching.
See you next time on ArtStoryLab.