Old Rivals! (Online Battle #89)

Historical Identity
26 followers
May 24, 2026
Once again the Romans and Carthaginians have at it! This time I have tweaked my forces since my last engagement with Indypride, lets see how my new build fares
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedOakley demonstrates a tactical victory as Carthage against Rome in Total War. The strategy focuses on \"picking apart\" the Roman army through independent flanking forces, psychological manipulation, and precise micro-management to neutralize the strength of Roman legions and secure a cost-effective win.
Hey, what's up guys? This is Oakley, and we're gonna be doing a one-versus-one multiplayer battle
I am gonna be playing as Carthage and the dastardly Romans are gonna be my opponent. Hope you guys had a great Halloween
I did as well
And I'm just sort of recovering the day after went downtown to the bars
And I was actually Napoleon so I probably should be playing Napoleon Total War right now just to kind of celebrate that anyways
We're gonna be back here, and yeah, let's get this battle started
I'm gonna be playing as Carthage as I said and my build is gonna be rather spread out
That's just something you guys see me doing it's something
I like to do against the Romans and because I think Rome is a faction that really needs to be picked apart
They're best when concentrated
You really need to pick them apart, so let's put this on slow motion at least
I'm gonna have
Two scutarii cav over there and one scutarii cav over here
And then a noble blood cav or noble cavalry sorry as my general over on the right flank and then on both flanks
I have mercenary Cretans with late Carthaginian hoplites
That's gonna help me just sort of toy and play with the flanks
That's something you guys see me do all the time is have a functional
And small group on the flank
I think that's something you definitely have to do have something that can hold its own and function independently on your flanks
That's very useful so archers something to back them up like
Spearman and then cavalry so have those three in combination on the flanks, and you can do a lot of work
And just see how much damage you can wreck on the flanks and once you think you've done enough damage
Engage with the center, but I would recommend having a functional flanking force on each on each side anyways in the center
I'm gonna have these late Carthaginian hoplites in the center guarding my Cretans as they start to push out
And then we have to leave it Libyan infantry, and they're gonna be guarding a Libyan Peltas
I figured I would bring Peltas because they could soak up a good amount of fire from his Syrians and plus I can use their
armor-piercing
Javelins to try and kill some of the Romans or at least get them from the flank
And then I'm gonna have over here two of these mercenary Sam knight warriors who are very strong and then two African pikemen
You know when the fight comes down to it
I want to have some
Pikes ready to just be able to hold a key position and the pikes are gonna be the best way to hold that and then
I want some infantry who can really
Tango with the Romans and that's gonna be mercenary Sam knight warriors
So this is probably a better build than the one where I faced against indie pride that you guys that you guys saw earlier
So we'll see how this comes
Comes out is my opponent's gonna have a long line of these legionary cohorts that I believe
There's a Bacardi somewhere
Nope, I guess not
okay, so just legionary cohorts with various ranks in the front and he's gonna have three of these Syrian archers and then on this flank to
auxiliary and Praetorian Cav a
little heavier on this side auxiliary
Praetorian and he's gonna have two of these new medians and
Joe on the back
Anyways also with the the Halloween
I'm sure you guys saw that CA released that update with you can play in a nightmare mode where there's like flying
Pig are they pixies? What are they? Anyways, like basically all the flying crows
Become these like things with face or harpies. That's what they have
Faces on them and then they change the the filter effects and the moon looks really ghastly. So that's really cool
I'm glad CA did that it was a really nice touch
Also, they released a little bit more info on how sort of vassal or
Puppet kingdoms can work in Attila. So maybe I'll do a video on that
but I figured I was just gonna enjoy relax Halloween not do like any videos for that and
You know, maybe package it into the next video
So anyways, if you guys haven't heard that news, I'll probably you know embed the link below in the comments
You can go ahead and check out their video. They do have some details on how that works out
But anyways, let's get back to the battle itself
So as I said have these functional wings and just kind of send them out and start seeing what your opponent is gonna field against
you
So on this side, for instance, I realized that he has some jab calf two of them
In fact, and the way I'm gonna counter that is I can't just rely on if you look at what's on the screen here
This is my typical functional core for this army. It's gonna be archers hot plates and calorie
I figured that was not enough to face his guys. So always feel free to augment your flanks
And I knew I needed some more archer support because he had two range units
So I had to bring in some archers not only to fight back those guys
But also, you know position them here and be able to face off against his Syrians
So to hold that army at bay and I have some more hoplites to to reinforce that and then also some more noble calorie
My opponent is gonna be scared by this move. Let's go ahead and look at this from his perspective
So he's gonna be a little scared by what I'm doing there
And also his Calvary here is gonna start to be engaged by my guys as I start swinging around this way and
My center is just holding back what I should do what he should do
Sorry, he's probably get out of this formation and start pairing up, you know
Send two archers this this way
Two archers this way and then send up his legionnaires in the center the archers in the cab can hold up the flanks and then all
These legionnaires. Oh, they can totally crush this army. So that's what he should probably do and just as Rome
I think you just really need to find a way to deliver a huge punch
and so that's usually securing the flanks and then just punching through with the
your your your core of legionnaires
My opponent is gonna decide to play a little bit with his new medians, which is probably a good move
So let's go ahead and put this on play. I just try and milk them. See how many kills you can get
So my archers on this position are gonna start to get some shots off and I'm gonna have
Obviously some support in front and there we go
Some volleys are gonna start to get off and they're gonna get some early kills
Some of the new medians gonna start biting the dust
I'm gonna always have these hoplites nearby to try and save me you can see he's gonna start to scare me off
So I'm gonna fall back, but I fall back to more cavalry and more units over there
So always always make sure when you have archers you have something to fall back to
He's doing a good move to he's sending one of his legionary cohorts and that's probably a good counter to what's going on here
Hi armor, he can bait some fire from me. And then if he decides to really push this advantage
Oh, these legionnaires can totally take out my hoplites
So it's a good thing to move this force over here and he's also gonna be sending another one
So what I'm gonna decide to do is move up and I want to specifically target my archers and I don't want to waste
Them at his legionary cohort. I want to make sure I take out his
His range guys as quickly as possible. So my archers gonna move up here. I'm gonna take them off fire
Well, that's something you have to do any type of situations is know how best use your ammo
So I believe he thinks I'm gonna be targeting his legionnaires
I think he's gonna go into either square formation or something that thinking I'm gonna be engaging
but actually I'm gonna go ahead and target the unit behind them and
Just try and whittle those guys away over on this flank. He's gonna try and get far around the flanks not gonna allow that
I'm gonna put my hoplites over here and then pull my cretins in order to engage
Yep
See you can see how he figures
Oh the logical thing is gonna target my infantry and I can just soak that up
Oh, and it looks like my archers are falling for it. So I should have retargeted those guys. Yep. You see me doing that
I'm gonna retarget. I don't want to waste any ammo on these legionnaire cohorts
I'm gonna target the more vulnerable
Numidian Calvary and Praetorian Cav. Praetorian Cav rather than the auxiliary because of course Praetorian are more expensive and look at this
I intentionally left a little gap here to bait a charge from my opponent
I knew I had enough time to react so I'm gonna be able to pull in
All my cavalry here ward off a strike and yep
He's gonna be forced back as he does that I'm gonna be able to continue to get you see
I retrained my archer fire maybe I will get some volleys against his guys
Yep, so
Something you can do that gets a little cutesy is try and
Feign a weakness so you can see how I had, you know, two archers with my my reinforcements on the flank
I tried to feign a weakness which pulled in his cavalry and allowed me to get some more shots on and
You know, I don't think he has enough range on this side to be doing that
However, he did reinforce with two legionnaire cohorts now, but you'd see I'm really not targeting these guys
I'm having all my shots fired above them at his cavalry, especially his Praetorians
And uh, keep in mind that he has a wing over here and I have a wing over here and also a center
So as this type of engagement is going on realize that you know
I have to do a lot of micro and realize that your opponent is doing a lot of micro
So something you should notice is at any point in mind is say, okay
I'm doing a lot of micro my opponent's doing a lot of micro. What can I do then?
And so what I'm gonna do is start engaging on this flank
But very very slowly inch my way up not do anything too sudden on the campaign map on the mini-map and not do anything too
Crazy, I don't want to move my center. That'll sort of pull his eye back over here
I'm gonna make a big move with my cavalry and you can see, you know, if I might if I'm the opponent
I'm gonna be looking over here. I'm like, oh god, you know cavalry are flanking over here
and I'm gonna have all sorts of stuff moving out here trying to distract him from this and just cause all sorts of chaos and
Really force his attention over there in the meanwhile. I'm gonna be slowly slinking my forces up
Slowly, but surely and try and get my archers in range to take out his Praetorian calf
So that's some some of the psychological
Psychological things you can do in your games is if you know, your opponent is microing draw his attention
You know bait him into an engagement or bait him and you can even bait your opponent into a micro
Micro commitment so, you know fling everything at him, you know kind of flail your arms make him react in some way say hey
Hey, hey, look look at me. Look at me and he'll look at you and then go ahead and do something a little devious
on the other flank
And so I'm gonna start, you know pinging his calf over here and obviously targeting his Praetorians who are of the two the more
Expensive unit and he's not gonna react to this
quite yet
so yep continue to engage here and
Yep, continue to pick off his guys and I'm gonna move in with some of my guys
Really force his eye over here move forward with to my Libyan infantry
I figured I'd be able to take out his Syrians who I won't be able to take out with my own Queens
Not quite because he has too much armor
So I figured I'd come in here threaten my opponent Peltas are good at armor penetration and then I'm gonna pull back
You can see it's pulling all of his attention over here and he hasn't quite realized what's going on yet
And these guys are already at six kills and that's a lot in terms of bringing down these really high
Cost units and now now it's gonna be ten and then it's gonna start going up and up and up
Over on this side. He's gonna keep trying to commit with these
Numidian calf, I don't think they're super effective especially in terms of how I'm countering them with my units this close
They're gonna do a decent amount of damage
But I don't think they're quite worth the the cost that he invested in them
Especially against that Cretans like this if he was able to use them in combination with the archers deployed in the front
Oh, he'd be doing a lot more damage
But I think he's just way too committed to having this force here
And now he's starting to he's starting to break out of that. I'm gonna go and have a cavalry charge right here. So
Zero kills crazy, huh? Even from the flank
Wow, that's crazy. I figured that these guys were in block formation not at all facing me and I charged him from flank
Nope, didn't almost no damage
So, you know, at least I caused them to break up and I just fall back with this
Formation get some easy kills on his guys with my Cretans and then over here my opponent finally realized what had happened
I was able to get
47 kills break his legionary cabin
He's gonna fall back and reposition trying to isolate with my guys with the Syrian archers
I'm gonna boogie on out of there and then he's gonna fall back to this position and now I figured okay
He's angry enough. He's gonna start engaging with everything and turn around to counter his Praetorians and
Then I'm gonna go and chase off some of his new medians here and he's getting a bit too strung out with the Legionnaires
They use this is not how you want to
Sometimes you want to play with Rome's like this, but this is probably the deadliest point for Rome is when they get caught out
Without the the main bulk of their forces, that's something that was obviously proven right by history if you look at Cara
and
how they fought against the
Persians or the Parthians even Rome was always gonna be susceptible to having themselves pulled out and then piecemeal broken up
Look at this this force that it's gonna be at the whim of my guys. You can't really do anything
You can chase away my cab as much as he wants. It's gonna open him up to rear strikes from my own archers
He's gonna charge in here and try and knock out my
My Cretans my Cretans are at this point out of ammo. So I was kind of using them as bait
And I'm gonna disengage from this fight. I don't want to lose too many of my skitarii cap
I figured you know, I would have my hoplites here just to do enough damage to force him back
I'm gonna start reforming for this front and he's gonna start pinging me with his archers
So I'm gonna have to pull this back
However, I'm a little bit focused on my micro here and now I isolated my target this guy all the way over here and let's
Watch this engagement
That's gonna just smush those Romans and over here. I've pulled up my javelins
Like I said, these guys are very good at armor penetration
Even against the huge scutum that the Romans have to put them on the flank. Let's wait for this wait for another volley
There you go
Easily kill a couple of these legionnaires and I'm slowly gonna pick my way across this line and just allow my troops my Libyans
or late Carthaginians, sorry to hold this flank up and
Then I'm gonna land a rear strike
This is exactly I think what it takes to to beat Rome fix them with your hoplites get some armor damage with units like Peltas
oh my god, they're just pincushions and
Then get get cavalry strikes in the back
And especially if you can get your javelins over on the flank or the even the back
Oh, there's these guys will shatter. Look at look how much damage I did just with a couple volleys from that javelins
I'm gonna retrain those guys back here and really try and take out the remainder of his guys in the rear
I'm gonna engage with some of his auxiliaries. They're scared and my archers who are now out of ammo
They're gonna continue to serve as bait
So that's something you can do Joe. Don't just use your archers
For you know for their kills with the arrows. They can also be used to get kills indirectly by using them as bait
So here I'm kind of flailing my arms pretending
I'm a helpless little Cretan archer and it's gonna pull in his cavalry fully formed
60 unit 60 man
Auxiliary cab is gonna be baited into a charge into hoplites just because he figured he'd get my Cretans
It's gonna open them up to rear charge from my noble cab. So you can see the psychological
Type of stuff you can do with your opponent
You know flailing your arms over here to distract him and cause micro on one flank and then sneak attack on the other
also have you know a
Pretending to be vulnerable to draw in your opponent
He comes out with you know, ten men down and all he gets for his kills is you know
Taking out some of these. Yep. Another one here is also out of ammo and I'm continuing to just oh look at me
Oh, no, I'm so weak. I'm pulling him into these fights and look what I have back here
Some Libyan infantry or when you're perfectly positioned to get some job javelin fire off against these guys
So that's something how you can use your archers instead of just you know
Sending them into melee somewhere pretend you still have ammo and use them to bait these types of reckless cavalry charges
So, you know all he got for the entire expenditure of that unit, you know, 40 men down already
all he was able to do is
Take out most of that unit and most of this unit, but they're already out of ammo
So didn't quite matter gonna fall back and he decides he's gonna try and isolate this force
And I'm gonna decide to just turn and turn about and look at this
His guys have gotten way too eager and now I can do an about face take these guys out and actually pressure his archers
So he's gonna actually start to realize that it's gonna get some follies off and then he's gonna fall back
But he's gotten a little bit exposed at this point now look at this the return fire from my archers
Basically doing nothing. This guy's taking a oh my god. This guy's filled with arrows and he's not going down
Yeah, just goes to show how you can't really take those engagements with a big cluster of Syrians
But you want to get them with your your skitarii cavalry and whatnot
And now I'm gonna put the pressure on and I'm gonna force, you know
My pikemen now are gonna be formed up and now this is exactly what I want to send to engage on his guys here
I'm gonna move up my mercenary stamina at warriors
And the rest of my Libyans I'm gonna continue to clean up this flank
Got a nice charge to finish up his cav here also gonna clean up his cav here
I still have remaining guys and now they're gonna be able to wheel around and fight my opponent. I'm gonna reform my pikes
Just to hold this flank
Let's look at some of them facing off against legionnaires. Am I my cavalry is still running around here trying to take out his
Some of his archers and he's gonna counter charge me and so that's gonna be I think the end of my cav
You know, they're gonna get a couple more kills against the Syrians, but I've seen Syrians tank a lot
It's hard to kill these Syrians because of their armor and it really takes a committed
Engagements to take these guys out especially with his legatus and other troops committing to this fight
He's gonna be actually able to to hold up pretty well
His own archers are gonna start targeting my pikemen probably the best use of archers is to take out these units
They are pretty susceptible to archer fire. If you can keep it sustained enough
He's gonna weaken my flanking one
Which is probably the best move and try and you know
But I'm gonna have to drop my pikes and then start pressing advantage and he's gonna you know
Not accept that head-on and move around the flanks and just allow his archers to pick my guys apart
And yep, like I said, that's gonna be the end of my scutari
I'm gonna send in some more noble cav just to try and take out and
Collapse on his guys and then I'm gonna retrain break this formation really break this and that's exactly what you need to do against a
Force, you know if you can flatten guys up and have them just as they're coming back up face pikes
Oh, that's exactly how you should be using pikemen
Anyways, he's gonna scoot on right past my other unit and charge into the rear very good use of Roman troops
However, it's gonna expose his rear
And here we have my guys engaged something you'll notice is with your pikes. They're gonna have a very hard issue. Look at this
I'm standing basically with my spears through the Romans. They're just not doing any damage
So now they're gonna start chopping away and what I'm gonna be doing and what why you're seeing all this shuffling
He's because I'm constantly just like right-clicking in battle right-clicking on his men
And if you have the ability to focus your micro
Oh, you're your pikemen will be super effective and you can see just the activity that's happened now by continuously right-clicking
It's gonna continue to force the Romans back and your spearmen get oh so more effective if you can do that
So, you know make sure you you're not taking away from other critical micro
But if you can focus on your pikemen and really spam the click attack orders
Oh, you can do so much damage and you can see just how much more effective those aggressive pikemen were
Anyways, he was able to clean up the the rest of my cavalry here
but I did engage on his Romans on this front and
Then over here is the goddess is gonna kind of run around. He's a little scared
I felt this are gonna be ready for this fight. I don't quite know. Nope. They have no ammo
So I'm gonna try and chase off his Syrians and he's gonna commit everything he can here
Libyan infantry are gonna now swoop around to the back and try and help, you know
Collapse on these Romans who actually got behind my pikes and my pikes are gonna be dropping pretty precipitously
I'm gonna obviously have another sandwich on this side, but over here as well, you know Sam Knights should be winning this fight
But the Romans are they're hard to kill
Now here you can see some more Libyans and another thing to do
Don't engage these guys right away if you don't have to I'm gonna hold them here and because I know they have a couple more
Javelins with them. I'm gonna allow them to just get some free javelin kills
This is something you should do regularly in every battle if you have the the ability to just stand still for a couple seconds
And get some volleys
Look at how many Romans I'm killing think of how long it would have taken me to do that, you know with a sword
By waiting out here. You can get so many more kills so much quicker
Just with you know, a couple seconds worth as opposed to committing
So make sure you get those extra volleys off and then engage you can see I didn't even need that strike to kill these Romans
And then over here he's finally gonna be collapsing the rest of his troops were chased off and there you go
that's gonna be the final collapse of my opponents forces and
There we go. The music you can hear in the background
This is gonna be obviously the total war Rome one music mod where you can play Rome one music and I always love that celebratory
Uh, I think that's a barbarian victory
Anyways, we'll go ahead and end that and yeah, you can see with the army my opponent fielded the army
I feel very cost-effective. I think they did a lot even my pikemen
Maybe they weren't getting that many kills, but I think overall this army had a pretty good synergy to it
Anyways, I hope you guys enjoyed and I will see you next time. See ya
