For decades, scientists believed that art began with Homo sapiens around 30,000 years ago. But a discovery in a cave in western France may completely rewrite that story.
Inside the La Roche-Cotard cave, researchers uncovered mysterious engravings that could date back 60,000 years. If confirmed, they were not made by modern humans… but by Neanderthals.
Using experimental archaeology, traceology and cutting-edge dating techniques, scientists investigate who created these strange markings and what they reveal about the cognitive abilities of our ancient relatives.
Documentary : Neanderthal: The First Artist Direction : Thibaud Marchand Production : TSVP
Curious about everything, an expert in nothing?
Accessible anytime, anywhere, SLICE is your weekly dose of short documentaries. A slice of history, science, ecology or architecture, to discover amusing anecdotes, inventions, unusual stories, bizarre, entertaining and instructive.
Be smart, have a SLICE!
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Researchers are investigating the La Roche-Cotard cave to determine the origins of mysterious engravings. Using OSL dating and traceology, the team discovered that these abstract marks and a figurative mask date back 60,000 years. This evidence proves that Neanderthals possessed symbolic cognitive capacities and created art independently, long before Homo sapiens arrived in Europe.
Comments are disabled for this video.
The saying goes that the best of humanity is found in our art, and that art is said
to have originated around 30,000 years ago.
Born from the minds and the hands of our ancestors, the Homo sapiens, this firmly rooted
paradigm has never been questioned, until now.
Now according to our models, artistic behavior can be ascribed only to modern humans.
But on the banks of the Loa River in the Turin region, a recent discovery could well bring
these long-held beliefs into question.
Deep in an unknown cave named La Roche-Cotard, a team of prehistorians from all over the
world are conducting a top-secret investigation.
On the walls of the cave, they have identified some surprising engravings that seem to date
back to the dawn of time.
It immediately caught our attention, because it doesn't look like the other decorated shelters
or caves that we've been studying up until now.
It's a style that hasn't been catalogued before.
There's something about it that doesn't match our references.
When were these engravings made?
Who created them?
Were Homo sapiens truly the first artists in human history?
From the banks of the Loa River to all four corners of Europe, using cutting-edge technology,
these researchers go over the evidence with a fine-toothed comb to try to lift the veil
on these mysterious engravings that might change everything we think we know about the
origin of art.
The seeds of the investigation were planted 100 years ago.
When François Vachon went out hunting that morning on his private estate of La Roche-Cotard,
he couldn't have imagined what was about to happen.
Deep in the heart of the estate, his dog suddenly ran into a crack in the rocks.
When the dog didn't come out, he tried to enlarge what seemed to be an entrance to some
sort of den.
That's when he discovered a cave.
A natural cavity, more than 40 meters long, carved out of the soft Tufo stone.
It was composed of several rooms, some of which could only be accessed by crawling through
narrow passageways.
But at the time, he didn't realize the importance of his discovery.
Once again, the cave fell into oblivion.
Some six years later, a young prehistorian named Jean-Claude Marquet read about the existence
of this cave in an old journal.
No one had studied it yet.
Intrigued, he sought out and obtained permission to go inside.
Suddenly, one element caught his eye.
The walls of the cavity were adorned with surprising engravings.
He quickly realized that it was probably a prehistoric cave, but very different from
the more famous caves, like those in L'Escoule.
However, being in the very early stages of his career, he didn't have the means to launch
a real study.
So he had the entrance sealed off, and promised himself he'd come back as soon as he could.
In the end, Jean-Claude Marquet would have to wait 50 years before achieving his dream.
He became a museum director at a young age, and his career kept him away from La Roche-Cotard.
But he never forgot his promise to himself.
Today, he has finally returned, and he's determined to lead the investigation that's been on his
mind for so long.
As we move forward, you'll see some very intriguing things.
He's put together a multidisciplinary team to try to lift the veil on the mysterious
traces he discovered.
Here we have a very interesting panel, a triangular one.
The base of the triangle is at the top.
And all over this triangle, nearly over the entire surface, we have parallel lines.
It's very curious, this panel.
Very curious indeed.
Triangular.
Rectangular.
Or wavy.
Jean-Claude has identified a total of five engraved panels, spaced out at regular intervals
all along the wall of this room.
And in another part of the cave, there's a different-looking panel decorated with diamond
patterns.
He feels that these panels date back to the prehistoric era.
To confirm his hypothesis and conduct a thorough investigation, he decides to put together
a team of experts composed of some of the world's most famous prehistorians, such as
Professor Jacques Jobert from the University of Bordeaux.
When we visit a new site like this, the first thing we have to do is make sure it's authentic.
It's a bit of a Pavlovian response for prehistorians.
We're always afraid that what we're looking at might be fake, or the result of natural
causes.
So we have to make sure these lines are of human origin, that they're what we call anthropic,
and were really made by humans, not animals such as bears, or simply created by natural
causes.
Geology can be very wily at times.
It has fooled many a prehistorian.
So the first thing we do is make sure the traces were actually created by humans.
This mission has been entrusted to Jean-Baptiste Fauvel, one of the members of the research
team and an expert in traces left by animals on cave walls.
He starts by studying the panel that seems to show a series of diamonds.
We suppose, based on everything that's been found in this cave, that these traces were
made by bears.
It's pretty common.
Cave bears hibernated deep inside caves and karstic regions, and they regularly scratched
the walls with their claws.
We're very familiar with the kinds of vertical traces that five claws would leave on the
wall.
Sometimes you get a succession of lines that intersect with one another, creating geometric
shapes like the diamonds we have here.
This panel was not made by humans.
On the others, however, Jean-Baptiste Fauvel doesn't recognize the traces of bears or any
other animal.
Could they have been made by humans?
To find out, Jean-Claude Marquette asked prehistorian Dorota Wojciech, the head of one of the biggest
traceology labs in Europe, to join his team of experts.
She has studied each of these panels meticulously, and she's confident in her conclusion.
From a traceological perspective, if we compare the claw marks with these traces, the depth
and the shape of the traces is different.
This means we can fully rule out that they were made by cave bears or any other species
of animal.
They're too organized, too symmetrical, too regular.
Traces like these require a certain cognitive capacity, choosing the spot, using the light,
and then deciding on an interval.
Not too strong, not too weak, so they'd be visible, but not too big.
There are many different elements that attest to a certain level of organization, so they
must be man-made.
Dorota Wojciech presented her conclusions to the other experts on site for validation.
I remember there were four or five of us there, and as experts, we often tend to hang back
and wait for one of the others to voice their opinion.
But it didn't take long for us to agree that the traces had been made by humans.
As a scientist and traceologist, I immediately started thinking about how they had been made.
Understanding how these traces were created is crucial for the team of prehistorians,
because it could help them discover who made them.
A few kilometers from La Roche-Cotard, in another troglodyte cave with two full walls,
Jean-Claude Marquette and Dorota Wojciech have launched an unprecedented experiment.
We might as well start with panel number two instead of number one.
We just have to wait for the photogrammetry.
And we have to time it, too.
Yes, of course.
They have asked a team of archaeologists to reproduce these traces using prehistoric tools,
such as wooden spikes and flint arrowheads,
or even their fingertips.
The results of this experiment speak for themselves.
We're almost positive that they were done using fingers,
because the walls are so fragile that simply touching them leaves a mark.
When we used a finger, we got exactly the same types of lines shaped like a U.
So, these are finger traces.
Prehistorians see these digital traces carved into the cave walls as a form of abstract art.
Art is currently estimated to have appeared around 30,000 years ago.
That was when the Homo sapiens, our ancestors,
started painting large, figurative frescoes representing animals.
But they also made abstract art with their fingers.
Could the traces in La Roche-Cotard have been made by Homo sapiens as well?
There's only one way to find out.
By trying to date them.
Two prehistorians have agreed to take on the challenge.
Eric Robert, a researcher at the Museum of Man in Paris,
and Guillaume Guérant from the CNRS,
who specializes in the dating of archaeological sites.
When they called me to ask if I would help out in the study,
I was very enthusiastic and intrigued.
I definitely wanted to take part in the research,
but at the same time, I was kind of skeptical,
because we don't really know how to date traces on cave walls.
We don't really have a good way of dating the works found inside caves directly,
which is unfortunate.
If the drawings are done using charcoal, for example, that's ideal.
We can use carbon-14 to date them, but that's not the case here.
Guillaume Guérant has an idea of how to work around this problem.
When the cave was discovered in 1912, it was obstructed.
But how long had it been that way?
That's what Guillaume Guérant wants to determine,
because he believes this information could be an essential clue
in understanding who may have left these traces.
There are certain things about La Roche-Cotard that are in our favor,
because it's like a sort of time capsule.
Over the course of this cave's history, it was closed off for a long time,
We know the Loire River left a lot of alluvians along the cliff
out of which this cave is carved.
In addition to that, there's sediment that has fallen from the plateau.
So we actually have two sources of sediment that sealed off the cave's entrance.
That means that the traces must have been made when the cave was accessible,
before it was closed off.
So our goal is to determine when the closing happened.
To that end, Guillaume Guérant is preparing to use a cutting-edge technique.
There's a method of dating that has developed recently called OSL,
and it can be used to date the exposure of rocks to daylight.
To put it precisely, we can measure the time that has passed
since the last time it was exposed to daylight,
which means just before the cave entrance was sealed off and obstructed.
We're going to head out into the field to try to figure out when the cave was sealed off.
What we could say, if we wanted to sample something, this one is fine.
Okay, so that would be perfect.
This process of dating is a crucial step in the prehistorian's investigation.
But it is also particularly delicate,
because this is the first time the OSL technique will be used inside a cave.
This is the tougher one.
And then we tried this bit there.
We don't think we have something in the middle.
Yes, but it is also softer to force.
Two Danish physicists who specialize in OSL have offered to help.
All of this is rocks, but I think if we want sediment, we can go up here.
But we should just clear a section.
The advantage here is that we have a single question,
which is to know when the cave stopped being accessible to man.
We can't accept results in the form of maybe yes or maybe no.
We have one simple question, and we need one simple answer.
First, they must take samples from the upper part of the entrance.
This is where humans could have slipped in before the cave was completely sealed off.
The rays of sunlight came through this opening and illuminated the wall.
According to the Danish physicists, certain minerals contained in these walls,
namely quartz and feldspar, are sensitive to light up to several centimeters deep.
Over an extended period of time of several millennia,
the sun's rays are able to penetrate into soft walls like these.
The moment when the wall ceased to be illuminated would have been recorded by these minerals.
And we may still be able to find evidence of that today.
What the physicists are interested in are hence these minerals,
because that's what will help them determine when the cave was closed off.
This means the researchers must take samples from the rock going several centimeters deep.
How thick do you want the sample to be, Trina?
Do you have an idea? Is it a matter of millimeters or centimeters?
How thick do you want the...
I would like at least three centimeters.
Okay.
The researchers believe this is the only technique suited for this context,
unlike radiocarbon dating, which is more commonly used in archaeology.
C14, that's a lovely technique, and it's a very good dating technique for many purposes.
C14 hinges on... you need biological material.
You need something that was once alive and then died.
It measures the ratio between the stable carbon-12 and the unstable carbon-14.
So you need biological material, and as we all know, that sometimes has a tendency of disappearing.
It's not necessarily preserved.
The advantage of our cell is that we can go anywhere.
We just need sand, basically.
Quartz or feldspar, we can basically apply it anywhere in the world in any situation.
And there is an age limit on C14.
But we usually say that around 40,000, 45,000 is where C14 runs out of steam.
You can't use it anymore.
Our age range is, depending on the site, we usually say we could go back 150,000 years if we use quartz.
And then we have another material, which we like a lot, which is feldspar, which is somewhat more complicated.
And here we usually say we can go back to about 500,000 years.
They take about a dozen samples.
So this one is O6, Trine?
Inside, and then outside, outside, and these two are these two.
A few weeks from now, the physicists will date these fragments at their lab in Denmark.
This process may confirm what Jean-Claude Marquette suspects.
He believes the cave was sealed off a very long time ago.
While digging at the cave entrance, he discovered these archaeological materials.
These are believed to be tools characteristic of a specific period in prehistory.
At least, that's what concluded Dorte-Voytchek upon analyzing them.
What we're looking at here is a carved tool that shows us all the usual traces of a tool that was carved by humans.
This tool would have been used to scrape and work animal hides.
But what interests Dorte-Voytchek the most is that this tool presents certain highly specific characteristics
that she can interpret using experimental archaeology.
She tried to reproduce this object from a block of silex using replicas of tools from the prehistoric period.
As a result of this experiment, she was able to determine that it had been shaped by cutting off slices, or slivers.
According to archaeologists, this technique is a feature of one specific species of humans,
which is not Homo sapiens.
This kind of stone knapping is called the Levallois technique,
and it's characteristic of the Neanderthals.
The Neanderthals were those who invented it.
Neanderthals.
A lineage that disappeared off the face of the earth more than 30,000 years ago.
This human species came before our Homo sapiens ancestors.
For nearly 300,000 years, the Neanderthals occupied all of Eurasia.
They were nomadic, which meant they were constantly moving around to find food.
The scientists are convinced that one of these groups stopped at La Roche-Cotard for a while.
A group of Neanderthal nomads probably set up a hunting camp in the strategic location overlooking Loire Valley,
where the skilled hunters could track the herds of bison that abounded in this region at the time.
But does that mean it may have been Neanderthals who carved these motifs into the cave walls?
That's what the evidence seems to point to so far.
For us, as prehistorians, it's really powerful,
because until now, no one could have imagined that the Neanderthals might have been capable of such symbolic illustrations.
You have to remember that, for a long time,
we thought the Neanderthals had a much lower cognitive capacity than our ancestors, the Homo sapiens,
that they were a sort of sub-man or half-monkey, or something kind of halfway between the two.
And suddenly, we have graphics on a cave wall that might have been done by Neanderthals.
We have to investigate,
because we don't know of any shelters or caves decorated with Neanderthal motifs in France,
at least not so far, and not in Spain, Italy, or the rest of Eurasia either.
So, this was incredible.
These elements could change our fundamental understanding of Neanderthals.
But first, we must be sure they're definitely the ones who could have made these traces.
Therefore, the traces must be dated.
The results of the OSL will be crucial.
This operation takes place a few weeks after the samples were taken,
some 30 km from Copenhagen, in this former nuclear research centre.
It's now home to the largest dating lab in Europe.
Guillaume Guérin has travelled here to attend the testing.
Hey there.
Hi.
How are you doing?
Welcome.
Good to see you.
You're welcome.
Yes, very good.
Are the samples ready?
Yes, they're ready.
Okay, so we can go and make some slices, get some minerals out of there, and see what we have.
Perfect.
The multi-step process will take place in a special wing dedicated to OSL dating.
The scientists must work in near-complete darkness, so as not to contaminate the samples.
The only light source is a weak yellow lamp.
So you can see the samples sitting in there.
I have actually started this morning, and this slicing.
There's a wire here that actually cuts in the rock.
So it's like cutting in butter.
Do you know the resolution, like how thick the slices are?
Yeah, usually I can make them 0.7 mm.
0.7?
Yeah.
That's a really high resolution.
Yeah.
They must retrieve the minerals from deep inside the sample.
The energy we're trying to measure will be released as soon as it's exposed to light.
So we only want it to be exposed to light inside our instrument, because then we can measure the energy coming out.
Once the rock has been cut into slices, those slices will be dissolved to try to collect the grains of feldspar.
As you see, the slices fall apart. They go into veins.
So I only take out the acids now.
So here I have to be careful not to pull out my grains.
So I do it slowly, so the grain stays.
Yeah, that's it.
So the grains stay at the bottom.
The information we're looking for is found inside these few tiny grains we extracted from the larger limestone matrix.
Thanks to these grains of feldspar, Guillaume Guérin should finally know the date the cave was sealed off.
It's time for the last step, placing the grains in this luminescence reader.
Inside, they're stimulated by light pulses that should release the information they contain.
The important thing is when it goes like this, I actually see it.
It's a really good one.
It was sold, actually.
Right. So older than we expected.
Older than expected, yes.
And that's what it is.
Yeah, that's what it is.
We were surprised to see that the sample is dated back to around 60,000 years ago.
Not only did that confirm that the traces were made in the prehistoric period,
but also, it was well before the Homo sapiens started making their way to Europe,
which was only around 45,000 or 50,000 years ago.
So if these traces were made at that point in time, they must have been made by Neanderthals.
They were the only ones there, so it must have been them who got into the cave and made these marks on the walls.
What that means is that La Roche-Cotard is the oldest known decorated cave in the world today.
This is huge.
The prehistorians finally have the proof they were looking for.
These engravings were indeed made by Neanderthals.
But at this point in the investigation,
the researchers must now figure out what status these traces should be given.
Should they be considered as actual works of art?
The question is whether these can be considered as art.
They're symbolic, that's for sure.
But can they truly be compared to the representational frescoes done by Homo sapiens,
our ancestors, tens of thousands of years later in Chauvet or Lascaux?
Let's be clear.
These traces aren't representational.
They're not on the same level as those found in Chauvet.
But nonetheless, they were clearly done intentionally.
They weren't accidental.
They were created with intent.
The most important example is the famous triangular panel covered entirely with parallel lines.
The triangular drawing,
and most probably the other drawings as well,
wasn't done in a hurry,
but was thought out in advance
before it started to be put on the wall.
These graphics depict fairly abstract things,
which throws us for a bit of a loop
because we've never studied anything like them before.
They're not figurative.
There's nothing representational about them.
So, are they a form of abstract art?
Or had they not come up yet with the concept of figurative art at that point in time?
Perhaps figurative art hadn't yet been conceived by these ancient populations.
That's entirely possible.
But when everything's said and done,
of course it's a kind of human art.
It's the early stages.
It's not realistic,
and it may be harder to understand than other forms,
but in my opinion,
there's no reason to exclude it from the overall idea of human art.
In that case,
can our ancestors, the Homo sapiens,
truly be considered as the first artists in humanity?
Or might it be time to revisit that paradigm,
which is taught in all the history books?
Because what these traces seem to show
is that tens of thousands of years before the Homo sapiens,
Neanderthals were already making art on cave walls.
After such an important discovery,
the team of researchers present their findings in a major scientific journal.
The announcement of their article's publication is the ultimate validation.
It's hugely satisfying to see the result of all of our efforts
and the hard work of so many people,
all experts in their own fields.
It's clearly a big accomplishment.
Publishing an article,
especially this one,
in a major journal with such impressive results,
is always a big source of joy.
I've known about this site for more than 40 years,
but 40 years ago,
it would have been totally impossible
for me to suggest,
let alone to experts,
the fact that these digital traces
could only have been made by Neanderthals.
They would have thought I was crazy back then.
It would seem that the Neanderthals
did indeed produce abstract art.
But a new element in the investigation
could lead to yet another surprising discovery.
The first time Jean-Claude Marquet
came here almost 50 years ago,
he discovered a very strange object.
He didn't know what to think of it at the time.
Today,
he has decided to take it out of his archives,
because in light of his recent discoveries in the cave,
it may prove to be crucial.
I'm going to wear gloves
because this object is unique,
so it's very precious.
It was found here in the late 70s
when I first came here.
After making a few observations
inside the cave,
my plan was to do a survey
in front of the entrance to the cave.
We dug down a few layers,
but found nothing of archaeological interest at all.
No wildlife,
no arrowheads, nothing.
And then, at a depth of 1.8 meters,
we found this object.
After writing down its location,
we removed it
and took a very close look at it.
And we were amazed.
What's surprising
is that this object presents
what looks like an image
of a face.
Jean-Claude Marquet noted one thing in particular,
a bone that had been slipped
inside this block of flint,
which seems to form eyes.
Here it is,
the enigmatic object.
Until now,
objects made by Neanderthals
have been deemed
non-figurative.
But here,
I believe we can see a face.
I really do.
Might the Neanderthals
have created figurative works after all?
It's such a burning question
that Jean-Claude Marquet once again
called on the Danish physicist
and OSL dating experts
for their assistance.
They took a coarse sample
of the archaeological layers
where the object was found.
Their findings leave no room for doubt.
This object is at least
60,000 years old,
just like the traces
in the cave.
So it could indeed
have been made by Neanderthals.
But in order to be sure,
they must confirm
that this object,
a sort of mask,
was made intentionally
and not created by chance.
Jean-Claude Marquet
asked traceologist
Dorte Wojciech
to study it.
She was able to find
what she would call
points of impact,
which is to say
proof that the object
was carved.
You can see them here.
There are at least
2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7.
Here you can see
some marks too.
So there are 10
or 12 at least,
if not more.
So I don't think
it's coincidental.
And a forehead?
There's no doubt about it.
The shape resembles
a mask,
a face,
something familiar.
Dorte Wojciech
also believes
there is another
argument in favor
of this hypothesis.
She has been able
to determine
that the bone
that seems to form
the eyes
was fixed in place
intentionally
using small pieces
of flint.
We have these small
stones that were
put inside
to keep it from moving
and it still hasn't
moved to this day.
To me,
that makes it look
intentional,
not only the shaping
of this block
into something identifiable
but also this piece
of bone that was
put into place.
I think it's very telling.
It seems as though
this object
is indeed a sculpture
created from
a block of flint
that Neanderthals
carved,
modified
and shaped
with the clear
intention of
turning it
into a human face.
Dorte Wojciech
knows how
groundbreaking
this discovery is.
Is it possible
that Neanderthals
were not only
capable of creating
abstract art
but also paved
the way for
figurative art?
For now,
this hypothesis
is kept undercover.
Jean-Claude Marquet
and Dorte Wojciech
are preparing
to share it
with the scientific
community.
Don't be nervous,
OK?
No,
it'll be fine.
Every summer,
a prestigious
conference brings
together Europe's
top prehistorians.
This year,
it's taking place
at the University
of Budapest.
There will be
a special session
dedicated to the
mass found
at La Roche-Cotard.
Are you ready?
Yes.
This is a big moment
for Dorte Wojciech
and Jean-Claude Marquet.
More than 30
of the leading experts
in prehistoric art
have traveled
to be here,
including
Italian scholar
Marco Perezani
from the University
of Ferrara
and Serbian
professor
Anna Majskic
from the
University of Belgrade.
I didn't really
expect that
many people
to show up.
Participants come
a little bit
from everywhere.
I mean,
we had participants
even from Australia.
Jean-Claude Marquet
might be
in the audience.
Do you want to
present something
or do you want
to comment?
Come with me.
OK.
I was a little nervous
because I had
no idea
how the session
would go.
I didn't know
what the atmosphere
would be like.
I also think
there were
a few people
in the room
who were
opposed
to the idea
that Neanderthals
could have
produced art.
As a result,
I clearly
wasn't feeling
that confident.
It has been
discovered
40 years ago
not in the cave,
not in the cave
in front
of the cave
in a Mousterian level.
For nearly
two hours,
Dorte Wojciech
and Jean-Claude Marquet
present their discovery,
defend it,
and try
to answer
all the questions.
They try
to convince
the experts
that this object
was indeed
a face sculpted
by Neanderthals.
What I've seen
yesterday was
impressive.
It resembles
let's say
a human face,
so it's kind of
anthropomorphic.
At the end
of the session,
many people
came up
to see the mask
up close.
It was a cast
of course,
not the original,
but they wanted
to pick it up
and look at the front,
the back,
etc.
Marco Persani
was very,
very intrigued.
Personally,
I don't think
there's any doubt
about it.
This is a very
creative representation.
It's very simple,
but it presents
the identifying
traits of a face.
Eyes
and nose.
The mouth
is missing.
The Neanderthals
didn't have much
of a chin.
It's true.
But it also has
a large
supraorbital torus
which could
correspond to
the faces
of Neanderthals.
Often in our
field,
any evidence
that might
in fact indicate
complex cognition
in Neanderthal
was tended
to be
so to say
explained
through
cultural influence
by Homo sapiens.
So what is really
interesting
about this site
is that
there was
there is a proof
that
there was
no contact
with
Homo sapiens
so you cannot
resort back
to this acculturation
hypothesis
to explain
the
discovered
phenomena.
Okay,
thank you very much
for this
very interesting...
This is a victory
for Jean-Claude Marquet.
What started
as a simple intuition
when he first
discovered
this object
50 years ago
seems to have
finally been accepted
by his peers.
The fact that
I was given
this chance
to present the mask
during the round
table today
was obviously
very emotional
for me.
Of course.
Yes,
it was very moving
especially because
I'm here
with Jean-Claude.
I know this is
the discovery
of a lifetime
for him.
It's very important.
I thought
the people
in attendance
look very interested.
They were very moved
and they seem
to be in agreement
with us.
Our concept
and idea
of art
will have to change.
It's exactly this.
I mean,
it's,
in a way,
simply the way
the science works
simply because
any science
is not
a closed
dogmatic system
but it has
to be open
for new discoveries.
This cave
in the Turin region
just made its way
into the history books.
That simple cave
will change
how we think about art
because thanks
to the traces
on the walls
the mask
and the perseverance
of all these researchers
everything seems
to point
to the Neanderthals
as the originators
of the most
beautiful part
of humanity.