Filmmaker Alan and therapist Jonathan examine seven relationships from the sitcom to determine which couples are the healthie

Love Arcana - Where Love Finds Depth.
4 followers
1 Video View·May 22, 2026
Filmmaker Alan and therapist Jonathan examine seven relationships from the sitcom to determine which couples are the healthiest. They break down the communication styles, emotional maturity, and longevity of these fictional romances.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedA therapist and filmmaker analyze the romantic pairings of *The Office*, ranking them from most toxic to healthiest. By applying psychological principles, they examine how codependency, conflict avoidance, and mutual acceptance shape the dynamics of these relationships, ultimately determining which couples possess the stability required for long-term success.
It's hard to get worse than this as a couple.
I kissed Jim.
What?
You burn it, you buy it!
It's either your daughter or me.
My daughter.
You gave your baby an allergic reaction just to talk to me.
This is not actual affection, this is not actual devotion.
No, it's possession.
I love you.
They are so happy together
that when there are problems, they don't talk about them.
You didn't kill her!
I sang her her favorite songs.
Here's the weird thing.
They're absolutely perfect for each other.
Proof positive that there's someone for everyone.
Hello and welcome to Cinema Therapy.
I'm Alan Seawright, a professional filmmaker who needs therapy.
That guy waving over there.
Jonathan Decker, a licensed therapist who loves movies and TV shows.
Today, I'm going to have you rank some stuff from a TV...
You already know what it is.
He's going to rank romances from The Office.
Office romances from The Office, to be specific.
Fantastic.
They're all office romances.
And I'm guessing based on our other ranking episodes,
I'm going from least healthy to most healthy.
Of course, least healthy to most healthy.
That's what she said.
Probably.
That's what she said!
Listen, over the seven seasons of The Office,
there are actually a lot more couples and pairings
than we could fit into this episode.
Like, we're not even going to get to Jim and Karen,
and I love Karen.
Karen's great.
Yeah, we're just going to narrow it down to seven
that kind of represent the spectrum of, like,
the worst of the worst to the best of the best.
Yep.
So let's do this.
Number seven is Michael and Jan
are, in my opinion,
the most unhealthy couple in the history of the show.
It's hard to get worse than this as a couple.
Yeah.
Man, I would love to burn your candles!
You burn it, you buy it!
Oh, good!
I'll be your first customer!
But you're hardly my first.
That's what she said!
That TV.
That is a $200 plasma screen TV you just killed!
Good luck paying me back
on your $0 a year salary plus benefits, babe!
So this is a relationship based on
it's two people clinging to each other like life preservers.
Right.
When they fall into bed with each other,
Jan is recently divorced
and Michael is absolutely a rebound relationship.
And Michael isn't even super into Jan
other than he just finds her attractive.
But the moment she kisses him,
he's like, I guess I'm in a relationship now.
Guess that's it.
And then when she gets let go
and his whole thing is,
this is my life now
and I'm living my dream except for it's not.
Right.
I mean, there's not mutual affection.
There's not mutual respect.
There's not shared dreams.
There's not shared goals out of life.
It is literally, I don't want to be alone
and here you are.
And it's that way for both of them,
which breeds contempt.
It breeds resentment.
And it breeds this whole escalation
of who can hurt each other the most
until one of us caves.
Right.
I mean, this seems like classic codependence, right?
Yeah.
Well, in codependency, one person needs the other
and the other needs to be needed.
And what's interesting about Michael and Jan is
They're both both of those.
They do kind of this.
So it's like extremely, there's layers of the codependency.
I will say it yields
some of the best comedy in the show.
Like Michael's bit about getting a vasectomy.
Stip-stap! Stip-stap! Stip-stap!
You have no idea the physical toll
that three vasectomies
have on a person.
That whole bit is him doing anything to please her.
Yeah.
Sacrificing himself
and her expecting him to make her happy
and then
chastising him and attacking him
when he fails
because she is expecting him to do it
instead of being the captain of her own ship.
Of the main pairings on the show,
this is the only one that actually qualifies as toxic.
It's, yeah.
You put Michael and Jan together and it just goes.
Next, number six, is Pam and Roy.
This is after they've broken up
and now Pam's getting back together with Roy.
Remember that casino night
about a month before we were supposed to get married?
I kissed Jim.
What?
He told me how he felt and I guess I had feelings too
and we kissed.
Jim came on to you?
Just listen.
No, I am listening. That's the problem. I'm listening.
Don't yell.
This is over.
Yeah, you're right. This is so over.
You kidding me, Pam?
Come on!
Jet skis!
In real life, that's terrifying behavior.
On the show, it's mildly funny that his bro wanders in,
has no idea what's going on.
Let's smash some ----.
Yeah.
This plays also into
when we get to Jim and Pam,
the one thing that keeps Jim and Pam
from being the ultimate for me
is the fact that
when Pam was in a relationship and engaged,
not that he told her how he felt,
I think that's fine.
Give her a chance to figure out what she wants.
The fact that he goes in and kisses her without her consent
when she's engaged to somebody else
is played as this big romantic moment in the show
and it is because
we love these characters and these actors
but you look at that in real life and you're like
that's kind of messed up.
I know I'm talking about this now.
We're going to circle back to it when we get to them
but how this affects this situation is
Pam and Roy have a relationship where he doesn't see her.
He sees what he wants Pam to be
and that's how he treats her.
It's all about his convenience.
When he wants to be there for her, he will be.
When he doesn't, he won't.
But it's a perfect example of when I tell people
in relationships when they're in unhealthy ones
and they talk about all the good times
and all the good things.
We see good things with Roy.
We see times where he's good to Pam
but I always say the same thing.
It's not about what they're like at their best.
It's about what they're like at their worst.
And we just saw the worst of Roy.
And it's terrifying.
It's terrifying because it's all about
what I'm feeling in the moment
and he'll just tear up a bar.
That level of aggression and violence
and destructive acting out is...
What is the trigger that pushes him over
from doing that to a bar
to doing that to a person?
Yeah.
What are you wearing?
Did you know that your personal data
is sold by online data brokers?
Data brokers are corporations that collect
huge amounts of personal information.
Like social security numbers, birthdays,
past and recent addresses
and information about your relatives.
And package it all together to create
profiles or listings with your personal information.
You don't want those data brokers out there
selling your data.
That's wise and very insightful of you, Alan.
Identity theft is not a joke, Alan!
Oh, I agree.
With the risk of identity theft and phishing scams
it's a good idea to protect yourself online.
That's why I use Delete.me to keep your personal info private.
Because I'm impersonating you.
Publicly.
This episode is sponsored by Delete.me
a hands-free subscription service
that will remove your personal information
that's being sold online.
I've been using Delete.me for a few months
and it's already removed me from 318 listings
from over 100 data brokers.
Once you sign up for Delete.me
you just submit your info
then the Delete.me experts search for it
and begin the removal process.
You'll get a removal report in just 7 days.
And they'll continue scans and deletions
all year long.
Get 20% off Delete.me U.S. Consumer Plans
when you go to joindelete.me.com
forward slash cinema
and use promo code cinema
at checkout.
That's joindelete.me.com
slash cinema code cinema.
And...
What? Hey! Hey!
Tastes like Pixar.
Megan! Megan!
Number 5.
Ryan and Kelly.
We're really getting into the healthy ones.
I want you to tell me that you care about me.
That is what I want.
Kelly, I'm your boss now, okay?
You can't keep talking to me like I'm your boyfriend.
Oh, big, strong man. Fancy, new, whatever.
I don't think you ever cared about me.
I never cared about you?
Six months ago, Karen Filippelli sent me an email
asked me out.
I said no because I was committed to our relationship.
Well, I hope you're still committed
because I'm pregnant.
And guess what, buddy?
I am keeping it.
Okay, okay.
Do you feel prepared to help me raise a baby?
I can't talk about this right now, okay?
After work, we'll go out to dinner.
We'll talk about it then, okay?
We have a date!
The fact that you could
get such a belly laugh out of
a person just looking at the camera
and shaking their head slightly
is a testament to how great the writing and directing
is on this show.
We have a date!
This is a relationship based on manipulation
based on, depending on where they're at
convenience.
For a long time, Ryan's with Kelly out of convenience.
I hooked up with her on February 13th.
Once he gets promoted,
he's like, you and I are through.
Right?
And then she will do whatever it takes to keep him
and the issue is that
she doesn't want to be alone and she wants him
so she's willing to do what it takes
but if he's not choosing her, she doesn't have the confidence
to say, I want to be with someone who chooses me.
No, it must be him
at all costs.
If I get to stay and Ryan is laid off
I will kill myself.
And Ryan, for his part, we see time and again
I am in love with Kelly Kapoor
right here, right now
all I can think about is spending
the rest of my life with her.
Again, that could change.
Then in the seventh season, when she's with somebody else
then he's suddenly interested
because it's about having something that he wants.
You gave your baby an allergic reaction
just to talk to me?
And he only wants her if he can't have her.
This is not actual affection
this is not actual devotion
No, it's possession.
When I say affection, attachment, or attraction
are not the same thing as love
and they don't even really have affection
they've got attachment and attraction
and it's all very unhealthy
and really fun to watch.
It's so much fun.
And we get back to back Kelly
because next on the list is Kelly and Daryl
who I've got at number four
and the reason they're at number four
is because this is half of a healthy couple
What do you mean you have plans tonight?
I have my daughter tonight.
We're renting Charlotte's well.
You have to make a choice.
It's either your daughter or me.
My daughter.
I see how it is.
That was cold.
The fact that Kelly
is just a 12 year old girl
in 1991
Whatever.
I went to school with these people
and then we all grew up.
But she didn't.
So half of a healthy relationship
Daryl, when she says
it's either your daughter or me
and he goes my daughter
The timing is so perfect
The camera can't even catch up to how fast he's saying it.
And he doesn't even look at her.
And he doesn't even think about it.
Because Daryl has healthy boundaries.
I love in this relationship we get a sense of
Daryl knows who he is
Daryl knows what he's about
He knows what a healthy relationship looks like
And Daryl has no problem drawing healthy boundaries for himself
But his boundaries aren't selfish
It's not a I'm just going to get what I want
It's just this is how I will and won't be treated.
And we get another
great example of this right here.
Let's call this what it is.
It's like she only wants to hook up when Ryan comes around.
It's gotten to the point
where I get excited every time I see
that little dude walk through the door.
I just need to know
where this is going.
Hey
I like you
It's not to like
But you need to access your uncrazy side
Otherwise maybe
this thing has run its course.
Don't you dare walk away from me Daryl Philbin
Slow down
Take it over
Daryl Philbin is the most
complicated man that I have ever met
I mean who says exactly
what they're thinking
What kind of game is that?
Here's my take
They're mismatched because
of their drastically different maturity levels
I don't think
that Kelly is good for Daryl
I think Daryl is great for Kelly
Not like long term
but as someone to date and grow from
I don't think Kelly is necessarily bad for Daryl
either because he's so
mature that he's like they can have some fun
and he's not going to hurt Kelly
If anything
he's going to help her a little bit
and she's definitely not going to hurt him
She's using Daryl to make Ryan jealous
That is the purpose
of this relationship. Not great
But I also think the way he talks to her
She looks at him like
maybe going after Ryan was the wrong play
She looks at him and sees a man
because Ryan is definitely a boy
The thing about Daryl
He is happy to be in a relationship with Kelly
but she's either going to obey the rules
of what a healthy relationship
between adults looks like
or he's not going to do it
He knows what he wants and he's willing to be by himself
If this relationship isn't going to be
what he wants and needs
he's okay to be on his own
Number 3
Now we're getting to end game couples of The Office
Dwight and Angela
Hey, we nailed the sale
Where were you this morning?
I overslept. Damn rooster didn't crow
Why do you lie?
Liar. I'm not a liar
You are lying right now
It seems like he's lying
Stay out of this you
I know that you went to corporate this morning
and I know that you lied about it
and given our history
I need you to tell me right now
exactly what you were doing this morning
Michael, I cannot tell you what I was doing there
but you have to trust me
I would never do anything to hurt you
or this company
Okay, you know what?
I want you to think about your future at this company
I want you to think about it long and hard
That's what she said
There
I want to know what you were doing this morning
by the end of the day
Dwight going to bat for Angela
and then taking a bullet for her
and some would say
and Pam does say
that Angela is out of line for letting Dwight do this
and that's true
and here's the thing about Dwight and Angela
I have met any number of couples
in therapy and in life
where there are so many unhealthy
immature, petty
harmful dynamics
and yet they keep finding equilibrium
They keep bouncing through
healthiness on their way to all of it
It's like if there's a straight narrow road
of a healthy relationship
They don't stay on it but they cross over it
as often as they can
Dwight and Angela, throughout the whole series
their relationship is infidelity
She's with Andy
and then Dwight's cheating with her on the side
There's a lot of secrecy, there's a lot of lies
There's so many things where on the surface of it
you could justifiably say
this is not a healthy couple
but here's the weird thing
They're absolutely perfect for each other
and as the show goes on
we realize how aligned they are
in parenting goals
financial goals, life goals
how they interact
the chemistry that they have
This is a couple that if they were in my office
I'd be like, you're going to make it
but I would like for you to be
as not miserable as possible
You're going to make it but it's going to suck
But it's going to be really hard unless you can develop
some more maturity, some more accountability
some more forgiveness
and fairness
She wants him to take care of her cat
and the cat is sick
so because he's a farmer, he kills the cat
You didn't kill her
I sang her her favorite songs
Number two
A lot of people would put them at number one
Jim and Pam
I'm putting them at number two for a couple reasons
The first thing is
I do love their first kiss for the show
but I don't love it for real life
and then the second thing is
They are so happy together
and they enjoy each other so much
that when there are problems, they don't talk about them
They fail to do the work
Jim and Pam have been having marriage problems
they went to couples counseling
and it didn't go well
and they're both feeling very bleak
I know this was really weird
but I think we're making progress
so I'm really sorry that I have to go
but let's keep at this
Okay?
Okay
Just that energy of wanting to connect
but both being so hurt
distance where there was once closeness
I can understand why people
didn't want to watch it
but as a couples therapist
I love this because
this is the work
and I could have picked any number of
fun Jim and Pam moments for the show
to highlight here
but I wanted to watch this one
Jim!
Thanks
Alright, have a good trip
Bye
She's too hurt to risk it
Love suffers long
and is kind
It is not proud
Love bears all things
believes all things
hopes all things
and endures all things
Love never fails
and now these three remain
Faith
Hope
and Love
but the greatest of these
is Love
Are they not number one?
They're number one for
most beautiful scene in the history of television
and I know
that's slightly hyperbolic but only slightly
Yeah, that sounds like me saying something
They're not number one because we're going
least healthy to most healthy
and they arrive at a very beautiful place
but there's just been like some major bumps
along the way
but honestly as a couples therapist
I think that's beautiful and raw and real
and fantastic. My number one is
Michael and Holly
Just proof positive
that there's someone for everyone
She was assembling her chair
and they had their first real conversation
and quoted Yoda together
Badly
This is where I fell in love with you
and this is where I
ask you to marry me
It started
I love that they both go down on their knees too
It's such a derpy thing
Well because they were on their knees when they had the first
Yeah, I know
Holly Flack
Marry me will you be
Sounds more like Kermit
Your wife be coming
Me will I
They're both so dumb
I know, but that's my point
Every jar has a lid, huh?
Yeah, every jar has a lid
There's this great episode
It's the PDA episode
where they're just all over each other
and driving people crazy and Holly says
Everything he does is sexy
The man exudes
sex
Which he doesn't to anybody else
but the fact that she says that and she means it
She 100% means it
This is the sexiest thing that's ever happened
So every jar has a lid
They're so perfect for each other
We don't know as much about Holly
We know some of her past relationships
We know Michael's had some real dumpster fire relationships
For sure
And along the way he's exhibited a lot of unhealthy traits
Had a lot of things to work through
A lot of dishonesty
A lot of insecurity
But by the time he meets her
I love that Michael evolves
and matures and grows over the series
He's always still Michael
But there's a great bit
on his last episode
You know Steve Carell's last episode
when he and Holly, they're going off together
Something happens in a staff meeting
that he would normally get very hurt and offended
and defensive about
And he takes a step into it
and Holly's influence makes him realize
Oh, this really isn't that big of a deal
And we see Michael
accept influence from her
and act in a mature way
that is somehow
that should be completely out of character
but it's not
This is a perfect example
of growing into a better version of yourself
with and because of somebody
but not changing who you are
to make them happy
Michael with Jan was constantly
trying to be a different person
to satisfy her and please her
and then she was constantly
critical of, it's not working
and it's not what I want
With Holly, she wants Michael
exactly as he is
and exactly who he is and vice versa
and then they just influence each other to be better
but they're still the same people
and that's why they are my favorite couple
and I think the most healthy on The Office
Would you rate that couple Threat Level Midnight?
Threat Level What? Midnight!
Scarn! Michael Scarn!
So let us know in the comments below
if you think Jono got it right, if you think he got it wrong
How can we not have Jim and Pam at the top?
Sound off. Or something else, how would you rank
these couples? Also, are there any other
things that you would like us to cover from The Office?
I think we're going to do sort of an Office
Deep Dive. Tell us, do we want
a Hero Psychology for Jim?
Do we want a Villain Therapy for Dwight?
Is he the villain?
Or the reverse!
There's some hot takes that Jim is the villain
on The Office and honestly
there's evidence. Might not be wrong.
So until next time
I knew exactly what to do
but in a much more real sense
I also had no idea what to do
Sorry I annoyed you
with my friendship
and watch
The Office
Pam Pam, thank you ma'am!
