J K Rowling Roasts Emma Watson - Harry Potter Author Goes Scorched Earth | Reaction!

J. K. Rowling - the writer
1 follower
#harrypotter #jkrowling #emmawatson #nerdrotic #tyronemagnus #reaction #reactions #movienews #books #writer #author #actor #entertainment #woke #snape
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe video examines the deepening rift between J.K. Rowling and several Harry Potter actors, particularly Emma Watson and Daniel Radcliffe, over gender identity. It contrasts Watson's attempts at nuance with Rowling's blunt critiques of the actors' hypocrisy and the perceived \"agenda-driven\" direction of the upcoming HBO series.
What is happening, Magnusites?
Get over and follow the route that Tyrone Magnus sent you.
And, uh, see, I heard about, uh, was it a few months back that Emma Watson had been talking slick about JK Rowling.
Uh, excuse me, I think it was with all the trans stuff going on.
Even though a couple of the other actors might have ran their mouth.
So, she's going with scorched earth, huh?
Check this out.
Greetings, you over one million muggles in the 40% who haven't subscribed yet.
I've had a working theory that JK Rowling, who doesn't need any money, decided to go ahead with the Harry Potter TV show partially if...
I wanna hear her say her name. Is it Rowling or Rowling?
You know what I mean? I'd like to know.
Not solely to erase Daniel Radcliffe and Emma Watson from the story.
That might explain why some of the costuming and the sets in the TV show look so similar to the films.
It'll make it easier for them to pluck out Emma and Daniel and plop in the new actors on all the merchandising and in the theme parks.
And with a lot of the casting, maybe that theory was close to being correct, in my head anyway.
That was, of course, until Black's name.
But maybe that was a sacrifice JK was willing to make.
Because, once again, I'm here to report on the resulting find-out-of-the-f**k-around.
We're not gonna bury the lead on this one because today, prolific author and creator...
The find-out-of-the-f**k-around. I like that.
...of Harry Potter, JK Rowling, and you can insert your YouTube title here,
either Nuked Emma Watson from Orbit or Went Scorched Earth on Emma Watson
or Avada Kedavra'd Emma Watson from the Astronomy Tower.
Why aren't you all copying this down?
Because Emma Watson, who played Hermione Granger in the films,
and who has also been on a bit of a break from acting,
decided to resurface on a podcast to reopen some old wounds.
And let's just say, that was ill-advised.
I haven't heard about this.
And just for a brief recap, just in case some of you were living under a rock for the last five years,
no judgment, by the way, it's all over JK Rowling's views on one particular issue, which is...
Boys have a penis. Girls have a vagina.
Thanks.
And as you may or may not know, Daniel Radcliffe and Emma Watson over the past few years
have taken multiple opportunities to throw the woman under the night bus
who is responsible for their careers.
Now Rupert Grint, who plays Ron Weasley, has made his comments as well,
but they weren't as bad, but I'm not sure that makes much of a difference.
See, I told you it was her, Emma Watson, and a couple other actors ran their mouth.
I told you!
JK Rowling posted this back in March.
In response to the question, what actor slash actress instantly ruins a movie for you?
Three guesses. Sorry, that was the original question.
So now that some time has passed and it's not so in vogue to pile on JK Rowling anymore,
probably because her views were never wrong to begin with,
and it also has something to do with the cultural shift and this trend dying down violently,
as previously mentioned, Emma Watson came out of hiding and went on a podcast a couple of days ago,
and it appears that she kind of changed her tune.
Now before you hear this, I want to preface this by stating
you are going to hear the verbal equivalent of somebody walking over a field of landmines.
I really don't believe that by having had that experience
and holding the love and support and views that I have
mean that I can't and don't treasure Joe
and the person that I had personal experiences with.
I will never believe that one negates the other
and that my experience of that person I don't get to keep and cherish.
To come back to our earlier thing, I just don't think these things were either or.
It's my deepest wish. I hope people who don't agree with my opinion will love me
and I hope I can keep loving people who I don't necessarily share the same opinion with.
I guess where I've landed is it's not so much what we say or what we believe,
but very often how we say it that's really important
and that's really frustrating and not what you want to hear
when you're really angry and upset with someone.
I don't know. I just see this world right now
where we seem to be giving permission for this kind of like
throwing out of people or that people are disposable.
I just believe that no one is disposable.
Everyone, as far as possible, whatever the conversation is,
should and can be treated with, at the very least, dignity and respect.
What you just said is one of the most...
There was a whole lot of eggshell walking in that statement that she made.
Insanely idiotic things I've ever heard.
At no point in your rambling, incoherent response
were you even close to anything that could be considered a rational thought.
Everyone in this room is now dumber for having listened to it.
Well, that was a very long-winded, incoherent, professional adult pretender way of saying
we can agree to disagree, but she can't even say that
because all of her allies would turn on her in a moment.
You know, people like you, Emma, and I would argue maybe you should have led with this,
but that Hogwarts Express has left the station.
Now, J.K. Rowling did respond, and it was coherent, thoughtful, and savage.
J.K. starts out by saying that no actor owes her any allegiance
because they were in something that she created.
Emma Watson and her co-stars have every right to embrace gender identity ideology.
Such beliefs are legally protected, and I wouldn't want to see any of them
threatened with loss of work or violence or death because of them, like J.K. Rowling was.
However, Emma and Dan in particular have both made it clear over the last few years
that they think our former professional association gives them the particular right,
nay obligation, to critique me and my views in public.
Years after they finished acting in Potter, they continue to assume the role
of de facto spokespeople for the world I created.
In other words, you're a couple of ungrateful welts who were nothing more than contracted workers
who memorized reinterpreted lines from my source material, and you can feel free to piss off now.
Pretty much.
But then J.K. gets into what really stung that very deliberate jab from Emma Watson at the BAFTAs.
There's that clip of her at the BAFTAs, and it was just kind of like a really...
It's one of those things, too. It's like if you know her personally, it's something you can talk to.
You can message her about. You can call her about.
And that's what I'm telling you. I'm telling you, telling you, telling you.
I've experienced it in all this other stuff.
You start meeting people in the industry, in entertainment.
There are people that are only there to get what they can get from you.
They want to use you. They will stab you in the back.
They will say anything that they can publicly.
Well, in private, saying that they're your friend.
But they'll publicly do things that clearly show that you have no relationship whatsoever.
You have to. And I bet you it was like that with them.
I bet you that as big as that franchise was, they probably had some type of relationship with her
to where they could call her, talk to her, email her, text her, get a hold of her.
If there was anything that they needed to say to her, you know what I mean?
I'm telling you, you see all these people putting this public stuff out.
They were using people. I'm telling you, you know what I mean?
You see it happen with friendships, relationships, working relationships,
people around each other all the time.
And it's like you have respect for each other, at least you thought.
They're stabbing each other in the back, writing memoirs, all this other stuff.
I'm telling you, I do not trust a lot of people in this damn entertainment industry.
There's that bit where she says, I'm here for all the witches, but one.
It's just nasty.
I'm here for all of the witches.
Now it appears at the end there, she said, by the way, instead of except for one.
But Emma has never denied that was a jab.
JK goes on in truth.
That was the turning point for me.
But it had a postscript that hurt far more than the speech itself.
Emma asked somebody to pass on a handwritten note for me to her,
which contained the single sentence.
I'm sorry for what you're going through.
She has my phone number.
This was back when the death assault and torture.
What did I?
What did I just get done talking about?
She has her phone number.
If there was something.
See, watch out.
Entertainers.
Watch out.
These people can call each other and discuss this on the phone.
If they're really friends.
If they're really close, even acquaintances can do that.
Acquaintances in normal life.
Don't do this stuff to each other.
You know what I mean?
They're cool and they have each other's phone.
Yo, what's up, man?
I want to talk to you about what happened.
Yeah, yeah.
So tell me what happened so I can understand this properly.
Oh, okay.
Yeah, because I thought this and that.
You know what I mean?
They're not going to go for views and clicks.
You know what I mean?
Getting views off of your name and clicks off of your name.
Trying to get brownie points.
Hoping they can get people to think they're so great.
And all this other stuff.
By trying to make other people look bad.
When they could just call these people on the phone.
You know what I mean?
Like, come on now.
Threats against me were at their peak.
Emma had just publicly poured more petrol on the flames.
Yet thought a one-line expression of concern from her would reassure me of her fundamental sympathy and kindness.
But wait!
There's more.
Like other people who've never experienced adult life.
Uncushioned by wealth and fame.
Emma has so little experience of real life.
She's ignorant of how ignorant she is.
And JK goes on to rattle off some of the things that Emma Watson thankfully will not have to experience.
Some people really are ignorant of what they're ignorant of.
They just know.
And I think it's better if you're ignorant of something.
Like certain things before you're going to speak publicly to lash out at someone.
It's better to err on just not saying anything at all.
Not you mom.
A lot of us it's our grandmothers used to say.
If you ain't got nothing nice to say, don't say it at all.
You know what I mean?
That way you just take in all the information that you can before you speak to that person privately.
Homeless shelters, assault crisis centers, and women's prisons.
I wasn't a multi-millionaire at 14.
I lived in poverty while writing the book that made Emma famous.
I therefore understand from my own life experience what the trashing of women's rights in which Emma has so enthusiastically participated means to women and girls without her privileges.
The greatest irony here is that had Emma not decided in her most recent interview to declare that she loves and treasures me,
a change of tack I suspect she's adopted because she's noticed full-throated condemnation of me is no longer quite as fashionable as it was,
I might have never been this honest.
And again, Emma Watson wasn't the only one to rush to distance herself from J.K. Rowling and passive-aggressively pile on her five years ago
when she made the very controversial yet scientifically accurate statements about biology.
Rupert Grint basically called her his crazy auntie, which honestly isn't that bad.
Alfred Enoch, who was Dean Thomas, distanced himself.
Depends on how he said it.
Because if he said it in a very, I don't know, dismissive way,
or to make it sound like anything that comes out of her mouth now is just ludicrous or something like that.
You know, it all depends on how he said it, you know?
If I was J.K. Rowling, I just can't see anyone calling me their crazy auntie being not that bad.
You know what I mean? I would have to see his quote.
...as well. And then there was the aforementioned Daniel Radcliffe.
...auntie, which honestly isn't that bad.
Alfred Enoch, who was Dean Thomas, distanced himself as well.
And then there was the aforementioned Daniel Radcliffe.
Radcliffe previously wrote a statement supporting the trans community for the Trevor Project in 2020,
saying in part, to all the people who now feel that their experience of the books has been tarnished...
I know he did no role like that. What is this?
While it doesn't absolve the adult pretenders of their responsibility,
we certainly can't leave out the access media, who was certainly...
Listen how they frame J.K. Rowling's views in this.
Rowling recently wrote on social media, saying she would not forgive those who have supported trans healthcare...
I don't think she's ever come out against trans healthcare, unless you include this.
Then there are the actors who have supported J.K., or at least not completely sh** on her,
like Tom Felton, Jason Isaacs, Helen Bonham Carter, Ralph Fiennes, and the late, great Robbie Coltrane, who said this...
I don't think what she said was offensive, really.
There's a whole generation of people waiting around to be offended.
They wouldn't have won the war, would they?
And you know who else supports J.K. Rowling in her views?
The vast majority of the general public.
And that's reflected in this thing we call reality.
Some of you may recall that there was a narrative back in 2021,
that J.K. Rowling's views had affected her book sales.
Well, in 2018, it was reported that she sold 500 million books in total,
and by 2023, that number went up to 600 million.
So, I'm guessing that's not exactly true.
Let's consider the evidence. Anecdotally, at Barnes & Noble, a book chain here in America,
she has the largest section of merchandise and books of any author.
Hogwarts Legacy was a best-selling video game that definitely benefited from the failed boycott.
The Wizarding Worlds at Universal Studios Hollywood and Orlando are constantly packed,
and it's not unusual to wait three hours to ride Hagrid.
Oh, and they just expanded with the Epic Universe at Universal Orlando Resort.
Say that ten times fast.
According to the bookseller, Pottermore Publishing enjoyed a record year
as revenues increased to 48.8 million.
And that's British pounds, proper money.
Regal just ran a back-to-Hogwarts marathon where you could have watched all the Harry Potter movies.
You can also watch them on HBO and Peacock.
There's a brand-new Harry Potter audio series for Audible starting this November
with a full cast that, in some aspects, is better than the TV show.
No offense to John Lithgow, but Hugh Laurie is Dumbledore, hell yeah.
And yes, while not perfect, Riz Ahmed is much better casting as Snape
than Papi Estiado as Black Snape.
Speaking of that, yes, there is the Harry Potter series heading to HBO in 2027,
which had the potential of being the biggest show on that network or streamer
or whatever the hell you call them, since Game of Thrones at its peak.
I'm not ashamed to say I'm a massive fan of Harry Potter,
and I can acknowledge that it is the Millennials' Star Wars.
It is the biggest franchise out there that has the least damage.
That's why it's absolutely inexplicable and baffling
that they would make such a stupid decision as to cast Black Snape.
Forget all the controversy with J.K. Rowling.
This is the one thing that jeopardizes that show.
Got nothing against Papi Estiado as an actor or a person,
and I think he would make a great Kingsley Shacklebolt,
but not a very good Snape.
That's how it is.
Look, if you're not going to cast people that are the characters,
then don't do it.
You know, we're still in a day and age
where everybody's checking a box for something.
You know what I mean?
It's not the days of the first Daredevil movie.
You know what I mean?
Kingpin was a black man, and everybody was okay with it
because people knew that they were trying out something different,
and he truly embodied the physicality of who the Kingpin was.
He just wasn't like, it worked.
You know what I mean?
I didn't hear anybody snapping and flipping out
about the idea of Marlon Wayans being Robin
in one of the Batman movies when they were toying with that.
No one was talking about that.
And there's other situations,
like the flash with Iris and Kid Flash.
I didn't hear none of this stuff then.
You know what I mean?
It was a time when people were just trying out different things
and doing alternate universes and different takes on stuff.
But once people found out that there was an agenda behind it,
that was the reason why.
And so, in addition to you race-swapping people,
they were gender-swapping, sexuality-swapping,
and pushing a certain agenda.
All of that wrapped in one.
If people see any one of those things,
they're automatically irritated.
It's not even the fact that you're doing it anymore.
It's the fact that you're doing it for what many people see
as just the wrong reasons.
You're doing it to fake pander,
to say, look, look what we've done.
And people don't care.
They just want the character.
They want the real character embodied as much as possible
in that actor.
And you're not doing it.
And it's driving people insane.
And that's the reason why Ballerina didn't work.
That's the reason why Furiosa didn't work.
And both of them were not girl-boss movies.
But because people are so used to it now,
you've trained people to think
that they're all going to be girl-boss movies now
that people aren't interested in.
And it happens when you gender-swap.
It happens when you race-swap.
It happens when you sexuality-swap.
People don't want to hear it no more.
Keep on doing it.
Will he have straight hair?
Because if he does, that means Snape straightens his hair.
And while the female Voldemort rumor is absolutely ridiculous
and I don't think it's true,
you can't blame people for believing it after Black Snape.
But not to worry, Daniel Radcliffe and Emma Watson,
you might actually get what you want.
Depending on the success of the TV show,
you guys might no longer be the faces of Harry Potter.
Therefore, you won't have to worry as much
about that association with J.K. Rowling.
If you like what you heard, please like, share, and subscribe.
If you didn't like what you heard, I...
I hope they end up casting a female Voldemort.
I just want to see the fandom.
I want to see what they say.
See, because I'm not a Harry Potter fan.
I've watched all the movies and I enjoyed myself.
I thought that they were all good.
I didn't think any of them were bad.
I thought they were all good, but I wasn't hooked.
You know what I mean?
By the way, I'm a Slytherin.
Yeah, I know. People think I would be something else.
I'm the same as Merlin, the greatest wizard of all time.
A Slytherin.
But, yeah, it just didn't grab me like that.
You know, if a new movie came out, I would watch it again.
But knowing what this series is going to be,
I'm most likely not going to watch it.
If it came out tomorrow, I'm not watching it.
I just have no...
I already know what they're doing.
They're already doing the same dumb stuff that they've been doing.
I have no interest in watching it at all.
Who knows? Maybe by 2027 I will.
10 million subscribers!
