Lawyer Doctor React to Grey s Anatomy Malpractice ft Doctor Mike YouTube

Biologists and Doctors
10 followers
7 Video Views·May 21, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedA legal and medical expert critique a medical malpractice scene from a drama, highlighting significant inaccuracies in courtroom procedure, evidence rules, and medical practice. The analysis focuses on the lack of realism regarding civil litigation, the psychology of physician apologies, and the medical improbability of the plot's central surgical errors.
The prosecution rests.
That's it?
On that?
He's a plaintiff's lawyer.
He's trying to get damages on behalf of his client, the snowboarder.
Two script errors here, major.
That's like getting your name wrong.
Hey, Legal Eagles.
By popular demand, I'm finally tackling a medical drama that involves malpractice.
But to do that, I think I'm going to need a medical consultation.
Doctor, we're ready for surgery.
Let's dig in.
Are we losing this case?
It's too early to panic.
We haven't presented our sign yet.
There she is.
You haven't presented anything.
Where was his opening statement?
Where was it?
Where was his opening statement?
Where were all the questions that he was asking of the other witnesses?
Yeah, don't they, like, after the witness presents for the plaintiff,
right away the defense gets to speak to them?
Yes.
Well, there's two ways of doing an opening statement.
You can do what's called reserving the opening statement,
where instead of giving your opening statement immediately after the plaintiff,
you wait until the plaintiff has presented their whole case,
and then at the start of your case, then you give your own opening statement.
And there are strategic reasons why you might do that.
In a case like this, you would 100%
Want to go right after.
Get right in there, explain all the things that the plaintiff did not explain to you,
and get your theme out there, which is that this is a bad thing that happened to a good kid.
It's not a matter of medical negligence.
It's just that all of these complications that no one could have foreseen happened
caused this whole cascade of things.
But the doctors did everything right.
His legs were black. I knew it wasn't good.
They cut them off that night.
So this is the plaintiff's girlfriend.
She would have been a great witness to start things off.
Telling the story.
Emotional, sad.
No medical stuff whatsoever.
And whatever she witnessed firsthand, which is going to be colored by a layperson,
it's going to seem really horrible based on what she saw.
That would be a great way to get your story out there.
Did you have any indication that Dr. Torres was even worried about something like amputation?
I mean, did she ever mention that it might be even a risk?
No, but she was worried about it.
She was worried about what it would do to her reputation.
Why would you say that?
I have no idea.
I heard her talking in the hallway.
She didn't know I could hear her.
What did she say?
She said, I can't be the doctor who turns an Olympic athlete into a doorstop.
Is that hearsay? That sounds hearsay.
That is exactly an example of hearsay.
However, there is an exception to the hearsay rule.
In the federal rules, it would be 801D2, federal rules of evidence,
that is an admission by a party opponent.
So this is the plaintiff using the statement of the defendant against them.
Arguably, this is an admission by a party opponent or a declaration against interest.
It's also being used for its non-hearsay value in terms of she's literally turning
someone into a doorstep, which is incredibly un-PC.
I can't believe they included that in here.
But also that she was flustered.
She was worried.
She is partially admitting fault.
So it sort of informs all of her downstream actions.
Can you get off of that thing for five seconds and look at this plate?
Yeah, no, hold on a sec.
I'm just, I'm following up on that clinical trial in Germany using Peterson hip joints.
I'm trying to get them to send me their data.
Well, they're not going to release anything until it's published.
Sometimes they will.
It's called a preprint publication.
Is that the kind of research that an orthopedic surgeon would do before
doing surgery for the first time?
Well, using a hip that she's never used before?
It should be.
Because you want to know what the implications of using the joint would be, what side effects
patients had, especially if it's different than the research that already exists.
I would expect that a surgeon at the top of her field would research clinical trials.
She would examine whatever publications the manufacturer has put out.
It's not like there's hundreds of studies that they have to go through.
There's like a handful that are good quality.
So like two, three studies that you go through and you know them inside out,
you know what the complications are and you present it to the patient,
getting them to understand what the risks would be.
And again, that's not the core of the problem here.
The core of the problem is how she acted after the procedure.
So like, that's the real issue here.
I don't think the joint is even the problem.
There, sent.
Oh, that's it?
That's how she does her research?
Like, oh, okay, now show me this.
I sent a text trying to explain that to the jury.
You have to believe me.
I did everything I could.
Look at this text.
I DMed the author.
That actually would have come out in evidence.
Really?
Oh, yeah.
There would be so much discovery and document requests,
and you would absolutely look for electronic documents,
including emails, texts, anything that references the hip,
Travis Reid, the snowboarder.
You'd ask for all of that from the doctor,
and it would have been turned over to the other side.
So for example, the plaintiff can request personal emails as well?
Oh, absolutely.
Wow.
That's really the bread and butter of litigation these days.
People are relatively smart in terms of not saying things that they shouldn't say,
or at least not having a record of it.
People say all kinds of crazy stuff on emails.
Hey, Travis.
Hey.
You know, I'm thinking about snowboarding.
In fact, I've picked up a board.
Burton Blunt, you familiar with that one?
Good board.
No, you can't ask these questions.
There's better boards for beginners.
What size shoe are you?
I'm a 13.
You might want to look into an extra wide.
Object.
Don't hang over too much.
A little overhang's fine, but too much is going to cause drag.
Yeah, and drag's bad.
Objection, your honor.
Where's this going?
Objection, where is this going?
That is not an objection recognized by the federal rules of evidence.
You'd be objecting from the very start of this.
This is not relevant.
I get it.
You're trying to humanize your client, but the way you would do that is establishing
the background that is actually relevant to his economic and non-economic damages.
100%.
He's not able to snowboard now.
So the obvious form of damages would be the lost income that he would have been able to make.
And that would be a huge part of this case too, in terms of disputing whether he would
even be able to snowboard in the future.
Because remember, he started out this episode with arthritis.
Arthritis so severe that he couldn't-
Land the trick.
He couldn't land the trick and he needed a replacement hip.
That's one of the reasons why you might bifurcate a trial like this, which means that
half of the trial is about establishing liability.
Who was negligent?
Which parties were negligent?
Doctor, hospital, et cetera.
And then only once you have established the relative fault.
So you can have this person's responsible for 10%, this person's responsible for 50%.
Once you've established that, then you would go forward into damages.
And then there would be a huge battle where the defense would say, maybe we were negligent,
but this poor kid was never going to be able to snowboard again anyway.
Therefore, we don't owe damages in the form of his lost income.
Is it true that Dr. Torres had never actually done an operation with this kind of joint before?
Objection, speculation.
He knows that because she told him.
That's an example where probably the hearsay wouldn't come in.
Okay.
It's sort of speculation as to whether that is in fact the case.
It's true.
But you went ahead with it anyway.
She said she had done a lot of research.
She said she was confident.
So you trusted her to use her expertise to advise you and to keep you safe.
When in fact, what you got was a botched surgery, an infection.
This is a leading question, an extremely leading question.
Look at you now.
That's not a question.
You don't get to pontificate from the well of the court.
The main thing is you have to ask actual questions in an examination.
These aren't actual questions.
There's nothing there.
I'm really interested to see how she handles this,
because I think situations like this decide whether or not a patient is actually going to continue.
If you come in and you take some of the fault yourself and you actually say, sorry,
statistics show less likely for a lawsuit to happen.
But doctors, I don't know if this is like older training and ego thing, what is it?
But they're afraid to say sorry and say we made a mistake.
And as a result, more like it looks worse to the patient.
The doctor doesn't care.
They're not going to fix this.
Other patients are going to get hurt by this.
Whereas if you apologize, point out what you did wrong, point out what you learned,
how you're changing the system so it never happens again.
It doesn't protect you, obviously, but it gives that honesty to the patient
where they're less likely to proceed with litigation.
Well, I would assume that doctors are worried about getting sued and admitting fault.
So that is a reason why they would.
But isn't it interesting that it's actually backwards?
Something similar happens when you're questioning patients.
Something that med students are always hesitant to ask is if patients are thinking about committing
suicide or hurting themselves.
And students say, I don't want to ask that.
What if it actually leads them to do that?
No such evidence.
Asking that question does not offend people.
It does not cause more rates of suicide.
And it's actually reassuring and you can get a lot of information that could actually help
you protect the patient from committing suicide.
Yeah, I imagine that's one of the reasons why empirical evidence-based medicine is so
important, because everyone has these hunches, but sometimes it's not borne out in the data.
It's Dr. Torres's fault.
Improper opinion.
Objection.
Move to strike.
You feel very strongly about that.
It's not just a feeling.
I know it.
She told me.
What, she admitted that she was at fault?
Yes, she did.
I'm curious about this.
The day she cut off my legs, she came into my room.
She'd been crying.
She told me she was sorry.
It is illegal to use a physician's apology against them as evidence of guilt.
Your Honor, this isn't about the apology.
This is about everything else you said with the apology.
I'll allow it.
Oh, okay.
So big problems here.
Okay, I hope so.
It is in fact the case that there are about 40 states in the US that have what are called
I'm sorry laws, which as you just talked about, allow the facilitation of doctors to apologize
to a patient.
In those states, it is illegal to use the doctor's apology against them in court like
this.
There are limits to that, though.
If the doctor goes further than apologizing into admitting fault, then that is a statement
that's not covered by the I'm sorry laws and can be admissible.
She said if there was anyone to blame, it was her.
She said this never should have happened.
She said if there was any way she could change things, she would.
Those were her exact words.
Yeah, I don't think that's really admitting fault.
Yes, they were.
The prosecution rests.
That's it?
On that?
No, that's not the issue.
He's a plaintiff's lawyer.
The prosecution is a criminal thing.
He's saying that he represents the state and is prosecuting someone for criminal guilt.
He's a plaintiff's lawyer.
He's trying to get damages on behalf of his client, the snowboarder.
Two script errors here, major.
That and then them saying postoperative infections are common.
In the middle of surgery when he didn't even have his infection yet.
That's like getting your name wrong.
And the surgery, it went smoothly?
The cut position and the femoral resurfacing were perfect.
What wasn't perfect?
Well, at the end of surgery, the patient desatted,
which means his oxygen level went down and his heart was beating really fast,
which is really dangerous.
We thought he might have a clot in his lungs,
so it was vital that we finish the surgery quickly.
And that's when you left the sponge?
Yes, and I would do it again.
So this is actually really good direct examination.
Yeah, I agree.
And the defense is actually putting their main witness first,
which is probably the right way to go.
It's either that or go with an expert.
It's sort of crazy that the plaintiff did not have an expert.
You would have multiple experts in a suit like this.
It would be a battle of the experts.
Well, the patient's life was at risk.
I believe that the sponge wouldn't compromise the joint.
I made a call and I was right.
It was the right call.
So leaving the sponge was deliberate, not a mistake.
You weren't being careless or distracted.
I mean, I think at this point,
we haven't seen anything that's related to the sponge at all.
We actually never heard about the sponge again.
What does the sponge have to do with him getting an infection in his heart,
leading to septic emboli going to his legs and losing his legs?
Unless the sponge caused an infection in the hip,
and then because of that sponge being there,
then his hip was infected, then his heart was infected,
and then he threw the cloth.
We have to assume that they left the sponge in for weeks
because he went home, came back with a fever.
Yeah.
So he still has the sponge?
If they thought there was a sponge,
but they needed to close to make sure he wasn't having a pulmonary embolism,
they closed, they check.
He's not having a pulmonary embolism.
Then they do the x-ray to see if there's a sponge, in fact, in there.
Wow, they send him home with a sponge.
Well, they might've been incredibly negligent.
Well, then that's not her fault.
Then it's a hospital issue.
Make sure his BPNO2 stat stays stable and bring me his post-op x-ray.
I want to locate that sponge.
See?
Yeah.
I'm on team sponge.
It's my job to prioritize my patient.
That's exactly what I did.
I wasn't focused on anything or anyone other than my patient.
Let's talk about this embolectomy.
What happened to the post-op sponge?
I guess we'll never know.
Yeah, we'll never know.
You know what's funny?
In the beginning of the opening statement,
he said there's one crucial mistake.
Right.
And I can't wrap my head around what the...
There's so many mistakes.
I don't know which one is the one they're going after.
It's a cornucopia of medical mistakes.
Yeah, exactly.
Let's talk about this embolectomy.
Dr. Yang wanted to do the heart surgery first.
You wanted to work on Travis's leg.
Yes.
Why?
Well, his foot was turning gray.
Oh, okay.
So this doctor is saying that she wasn't distracted,
and we know that there were things going on that obviously affected her judgment.
This would have come out in the deposition, presumably.
The other attorney would have asked,
what was going on that day?
Were you distracted in any way?
And they might know the information that she's withholding from the jury here.
And if you do that, it's the absolute worst thing you can do,
because true, it might be an ancillary thing,
but to the jury, it would look awful.
You have lied in front of the jury,
and now your credibility is toast,
and you are going to be found liable.
Well, his foot was turning gray,
which is an indication that the limb is starting to die.
And I wanted to restore blood flow.
Once a limb turns black, there's nothing we can do.
As a vascular surgeon, you are an orthopedic surgeon.
Could she have dual specialties?
No, they're not even related.
Maybe like a vascular cardiothoracic.
You see how you could be like a vascular surgeon that works on the lower body,
as well as someone who works in the chest?
But a dual board certification in orthopedic and vascular,
I've never heard of that.
She knew that the heart would keep throwing out clots until it was repaired.
Do you cook?
A little.
Okay, let's say you're cooking,
and you start a grease fire in your kitchen,
and then it spreads to your curtains.
Is she questioning her own counsel?
I mean, it's rhetorical.
You can get away with that.
What do you do?
Do you put out the grease fire,
or do you extinguish the curtains?
Which disaster do you tackle first?
It's so cynical of these writers.
Oh, she's talking in terms that the jury can understand.
I don't understand them.
I can't follow the analogy, though.
They needed to tackle the worst thing first.
But was that the worst thing?
Probably not.
Or the fact that the heart is throwing out clots all over the place,
and they'll continue throwing out clots whether or not you fix it.
It's not a perfect metaphor.
Yeah.
And if I can't feel for my patients without getting sued,
then I guess I'm just going to keep on getting sued,
because that's who I am.
I mean, I don't think I would want my client to say that
she's going to be sued multiple times.
This is one of those times where maybe she's lapsing into a narrative,
which technically you're not supposed to do.
But if I was the plaintiff's lawyer,
I don't want to come off as overbearing and argumentative and objecting,
even if I'm right on a ticky-tack objection.
You just let it go.
You let her tell her story and let things move along.
I think it's from a clinical trial on the Peterson hip.
I thought I never heard back.
Well, you probably should have followed up on that.
Encloses the data you requested, but please be advised,
we've currently put a stop to our trial.
There have been five instances of infection
caused by the Pseudomonas bacteria.
What?
We've traced the source back to the Peterson joint.
Wait, so it wasn't the sponge?
No, apparently it was the hip manufacturer.
So why do they keep talking about the sponge if it was never in the patient?
I don't think he's a good lawyer.
That's such a problem.
So they closed, worried that there was a sponge.
There was in fact no sponge,
and yet they're still discussing it in the court?
It's a big swing and a miss.
I can't just sit on this.
I have to tell them, right?
I wouldn't.
You didn't willfully ignore any data.
You didn't act irresponsibly or maliciously.
You worked off the information you had at the time.
Well, okay.
Act of God, I like that word.
So, okay.
So that is technically true.
She acted on the information she had at the time.
So in that sense, she wasn't actively reckless.
She didn't know that it was, I guess, a recalled hip.
The thing is, if you get the hip, in order to get it,
you would have known about the recall.
Right, exactly.
Yeah.
It's not like you get it off eBay.
If this clinical trial is having multiple instances of this infection,
it's a defective hip, I'm sure Peterson has recalled this hip.
If she didn't check to see if that...
No, you can't get it.
You physically can't get the hip.
It's not like they send it to you and they're like,
well, you should check if it's recalled.
No, you're ordering it from them.
Caveat emptor.
Buyer beware.
The only thing is, if they could have pre-ordered the hip,
got it before the recall, then the recall happened.
Possibly.
There's a lot of negligence going on here.
Hey.
Okay, thanks.
They've reached a verdict.
That's quick.
Well, we have no idea where we are in time right now.
So it's not uncommon to engage in settlement discussions with the other side
right up until the time the jury actually announces...
Oh yeah, absolutely.
Wow.
Because at that point...
People get nervous.
All the evidence is out.
You know how the trial went.
So you hear about people settling on the courtroom steps.
Happens all the time.
Wow.
Happens all the time.
I've literally written out a settlement in bullet points on a legal pad.
Really?
Transcribing in the hallway.
Sign both sides.
It's kind of like a letter of intent.
Wow.
So then at that point, do you stop the jury negotiations?
Yep.
You just go in front of the judge and say,
Your Honor, we don't need to hear the verdict.
We have decided to settle.
Wow, that's so cool.
I think it's going to be...
If she presents that letter and it's entered into evidence,
it's either going to be clearly her fault because the manufacturer did reach out many times
and she just missed it.
Not just a solo letter.
Or it's completely the manufacturer's fault because sending one letter like that is not
sufficient to say, Hey, this hip is completely malfunctioning.
I would really like to see the text messages.
Some person at the Peterson Institute.
Hey, Dr. Torres.
Gonna insert this real quick.
Hip recalled, LOL.
Can an apology actually heal our wounds?
Not literally.
Someone to save her from a dying self.
Ease our pain.
Always taking 10 steps back and one step forward.
She's tired.
Wait, what?
Yeah, you don't know.
No, no, no.
Maybe it's too late.
How do you know what he said?
I'm pretty sure what he mouthed was...
Not guilty.
That's a prosecution.
That's a criminal thing.
It was never an option that she was ever going to jail.
But good job.
You're not guilty.
All I'm saying is hashtag missing sponge.
Because if there was no sponge and it was caused by infection of the actual joint,
she literally did nothing wrong.
Maybe the sponge traveled down his leg.
It wasn't an embolectomy that was needed to solve.
It was a spongeectomy.
Mike, on my channel, I give these videos a grade for legal realism.
Will you join me in giving it a grade for medical realism?
Do they want me to?
No.
Will I?
Yes.
We're doing it anyway.
I think that's the longest review I've ever done of an episode.
Certainly metaphorically, if not literally, based on how much time it took.
Well, because without a sponge, if the sponge don't fit, you gotta quit.
I'd have to say that based on everything that we saw,
Grey's Anatomy gets a D minus at best.
How generous of you.
It's an F minus for me on this episode.
I could not follow it medically.
F. F. F minus.
Lots of negligence, which I'd love to see, but other than that, totally unwatchable.
This is a super long episode, so be sure to check out part one on Dr. Mike's channel.
Well, Dr. Mike, I'm sorry to say that our patient barely survived the operation,
but if you'd like to see more reactions to even more ridiculous legal dramas,
check out this playlist with all of my other legal reactions and Dr. Mike's channel for
the best reactions to all of the crazy medical dramas out there.
I'll see you in court.
