California Doctors and Patient Battle for Treatment Approvals | Hooman Melamed

California Insider Show
1.9K followers
255 Video Views·Mar 1, 2025
Medical decisions should be made by doctors and patients, but increasingly, insurance approvals shape access to care. Spine surgeon Dr. Hooman Melamed shares his firsthand experience with the growing barriers to treatment, from delays in urgent procedures to financial pressures influencing medical choices.
Why are some surgeries harder to approve? How do industry trends impact patient care? And what can be done to fix the system? Dr. Melamed offers insights into the challenges—and potential solutions—facing modern healthcare.
Views expressed in this video are the opinions of the host and guests and do not necessarily reflect the views of The California Insider.
We are hearing from California doctors
that dealing with health insurance
has become a big headache for them,
to the point that patients are suffering as a result of it
because getting approvals are getting harder and harder.
My guest today is Dr. Humaan Malamad,
who's a spine surgeon, who's in the middle of all of this
and has been dealing with insurance and patient care.
He's here to tell us how money-making
has become a core part of healthcare,
and as a result of it, patient care is suffering.
Make sure to share this episode with your doctor friends
because a lot of them may face the same challenges,
but not many come public with it.
I'm Siamak Khorami, welcome to California Insider.
Humaan, it's great to have you on, welcome.
Thank you very much for having me,
it's a pleasure to be here.
You're a spine surgeon and you're here to tell us
there's a lot of trends in your industry
and you're concerned about some of them
as a doctor, as a surgeon.
Insurance has become extremely, extremely difficult.
I've been doing it now almost 20 years now.
So I started in August of 2005 and I've seen the trend.
In the past, you used to get an approval
for surgery, no problem.
They would approve the surgery right away.
Or the treatment, you wanna go to MRI,
you wanna, you know, anything.
Doctors, it was the relationship
between the doctor and the patient.
So the insurance was there to help facilitate that.
Now, you cannot get any approval, hardly.
You get rejected a lot, right off the bat.
You can't order MRI, you can't order CT,
you can't get surgery approved.
You actually, I've had to hire an extra person,
literally in my office now, to help with doing a PO,
calling the insurance, phone calls.
It used to be very quick, like 10, 15.
Now, you could be on the phone 45 minutes to an hour
on the phone, holding.
Transfer from this department, that department.
They've created more roadblocks
in order to get a treatment authorized for the patient.
Now, the more expensive the treatment,
the more roadblocks.
Spine surgery, very expensive in general.
So they have more and more roadblocks
that they have put up, basically, to get this approved.
So then you have to get on the phone with a doctor.
I never, hardly recall, have to talk to a doctor
to get my surgery approved.
I was never accused of, oh, you're doing the wrong surgery.
So they want you to talk to another doctor,
or they wanna talk to you?
They basically, we request, I said,
I'm requesting, like,
why are you not authorizing my surgery?
They're like, okay, you can talk to one of our doctors.
It's called peer review, peer-to-peer review.
Two doctors talking about why I wanna do the surgery
and what is the medical justification for it.
So now, they have come up with guidelines.
This is where it gets even bad.
Doctors, you're supposed to help for the patients,
not to help the insurance company.
These doctors that are on the phone,
I can totally tell they're not talking
based on their experience or what.
They're talking the guideline of the insurance companies.
And a lot of times, these guidelines,
sometimes they're flawed.
They're based on very, very old information or not correct.
There's a lot of literature that supports a different view.
So I tell them, look, I have all this literature.
Oh, I can't, oh, I can't go based on that.
Why not?
Well, I have to go insurance company guidelines.
So then I say, well, what's the point
of this doctor-to-doctor discussion?
We can't discuss real evidence.
I said, this evidence you're talking is from a decade ago.
I have new, emerging literature.
One time, a doctor said, you know what?
I'll get it to you.
You know what?
Okay, you know what?
You're right.
I'm gonna approve this surgery.
I swear to God.
Another one came up.
This same doctor came for another thing.
I had to talk.
I said, you know what?
Remember, you approved that for me.
I swear to God.
He said, you know, I got in trouble for that.
So it's become so frustrating.
I'm not a volume guy.
I don't do, so it's not like I have so many patients
I see in my clinic.
Every patient for me counts,
and it becomes very frustrating
that I can't get my patients approved,
and they're calling me, they're upset,
and sometimes I don't have a choice.
I just have to go to the emergency room.
I have one today, right now.
I have a patient in the emergency room today.
Right now, I have to send,
because I know it's gonna take weeks and weeks
to get approval.
And this patient can't.
She's been already, she saw me on Tuesday in tears.
Young lady, yoga teacher,
neglected for three months, basically.
So the patient has pain
if they come to you with the back pain?
Usually, most patients, listen,
what drives them to a doctor is pain.
For spine surgery, it's usually some kind of a pain there.
Back pain, neck pain, shooting pain down their arm,
shooting pain down their legs or something.
It's some kind of a problem
that somehow the patient Googles it,
or their doctor, whoever, they see a primary care.
Oh, you have a spine problem.
You need to go see a spine specialist.
So that's how they end up coming.
Most patients are now very educated.
They go online, look at it.
They have neck pain,
that the pain shoots from the neck,
down the arm, from the back, shoots down.
They know, they're educated enough
to go see a spine surgeon.
So that's how a lot of them come to me,
word of mouth, basically.
So they come to me, and it's very upsetting
because I feel like you wanna help them.
These people are literally,
I mean, they're in tears crying.
They're not faking it.
And then you call them, and they don't care at all.
Like they take, oh, you have to go through appeal.
You have to do this, you know.
And finally, like this patient exactly today
that I'm telling you, I'm gonna be operating on her tomorrow.
I said, you know what, don't worry, go to the,
I'll take care of you, go to the ER.
That's how we have to do it.
So you have to do the surgery to the ER.
Which is really bad because it's more expensive
for the system overall.
So the patient has to say, you know what,
this is an emergency, I have to go to the ER,
I can't do it.
And then they could get the surgery.
Yeah, I mean, this patient today said,
what do I do when I, I said, tell the truth.
I said, tell them the truth.
How long you've been suffering, what is going on?
Like, for example, their leg or their arm starts,
stops, like starts not working.
They start getting weaker.
Becoming numb or?
Numb, weaker, like, hey, I can't use my hand.
My foot is like, it's not coming up, you know.
And you tell that to the insurance,
and they're like, well,
the patient has to do six weeks of therapy first.
I said, by the time they do it, it's too late.
Permanent nerve damage.
And what do the insurance companies require from you guys?
So you have to justify, right?
Before, did you have to do that,
or they will trust you guys?
No, they used to trust and stuff.
But I get it, listen.
There's some doctors who do bad things.
I totally get it, you gotta protect.
But they have the data.
They have the data on every doctor.
You know, they can look to see,
how is this doctor trending, basically?
Versus this other doctor.
How is the patient's outcome?
They know what happens after,
because they are the ones
that are authorizing physical therapy after,
narcotics after.
So they know the data,
and I feel like they're applying a blanket,
basically, approach.
Not helping, rewarding good doctors,
but punishing everybody together under one umbrella
for, I feel, for money, basically.
And what's the impact on you,
as a doctor, and other doctors?
It's so frustrating.
I swear, this is one of the reasons that I,
I talked to some of my good friends,
who were like,
this is one of the reasons you wanna quit medicine.
Because you went in there to help people,
and you feel like there's so many roadblocks.
Like, it really boils your blood.
I mean, for me, personally,
it agitates me so much,
because now I have to sit down.
I have to draft, like, in the middle of clinic,
I have to drop everything,
go draft a letter of, appeal letter,
this patient's surgery was denied.
Talk to the patient, to calm him down, basically.
Get on the phone with the doctor,
and then you get more frustrated,
because this doctor doesn't care on the other side,
about what's going on with the patient.
And it just ruins your day.
I mean, it's the stress that gets created,
the emotional agony.
Oh, you know, go like that.
How much you can take?
In a sense, when you mentioned
that these insurance companies should have the data,
and can you tell us what's,
for us that may not know your space,
you know, how can somebody know
what's a good surgeon,
and what's a surgeon that maybe not as ethical,
or is not doing as well?
That's very difficult.
I'll be honest, I think I feel bad for the public,
because I do, a third of my surgeries are revision.
I fix other people's botched up.
And it is very unfortunate,
because I feel the public trusts physicians.
You know, we look at physicians,
you know, at this high standard,
that they're gonna do the right thing.
And I do think there are some amazing, amazing physicians,
who they don't care about anything other than patient care.
They just, they don't care about money.
They don't care, free surgery, not get paid or not.
They wanna do the right thing for the patient.
But unfortunately, just like any industry,
there are bad physicians too, for that.
I think patients should not just look at Google,
but start getting references.
Call the hospital, for example, where the doctor operates.
Ask the hospital, the nurse's station,
that the patients get admitted.
That's a good place, the nurses will tell you the truth.
How these patients, doctors,
how many of the patients come back for repeat surgery?
That's the thing.
You know, patients don't know.
How many patients come back, repeat surgery?
With the same doctor, right?
With the same surgeon, yeah.
Listen, no surgeon has perfect results.
I'll be the first one to tell you,
I absolutely don't have perfect results.
I've had patients where I had to bring them back.
But I'm talking about,
listen, if you do everything by the book
and quality's there, right?
If the quality's there,
patient doesn't have the best outcome sometimes.
You know, nobody can say,
ah, you should have done it this way, that way.
You know, something doesn't go perfect.
You know, it's fine.
But I'm talking about where you look at the post-op X-ray
and you're like, wow, this was not done well at all.
No wonder why the patient's coming back for repeat surgery.
Or if you look at the schedule
and you see the doctor did eight surgeries in a day.
Wow.
Is that doable?
Yeah, there are.
How you do it,
I've seen some of the doctors
are doing concurrent overlapping surgeries.
If patients don't know this.
And I tell the patient, I said,
I've done this, I've done this for a decade.
I've asked a lot of patients.
I said, would you allow me
to do two surgeries at the same time?
They're like, what do you mean?
I'm asking, would you allow me,
if you knew that I'm gonna have another surgery
going on at the same time,
I'm gonna go from one room to another room
and somebody else is gonna be doing part of your surgery.
Are you okay with that?
Not a single patient has said yes.
Would you be okay with that, Sihamani?
No.
Of course not.
This is such a sensitive thing
because especially spine surgery.
Exactly, exactly.
To me, this is not a volume surgery.
How many is usually can you do per day?
So it depends on the type of the surgery, okay?
It depends on which type of surgery.
So let's say there's like one big scoliosis,
like a big major operation.
The real amazing spine surgeons I know in the country,
they would only do that one surgery for the day
and that's it.
They would not try to, because you know what?
It's a big sensitive operation, big incision,
lot of moving parts.
They wanna just focus on that one patient,
do the perfect job.
But some of these guys, they would schedule two or three,
they will do this room here, another room, another surgery,
and then another one after, another one after.
They're doing like four in a day.
And of course, the results are not as good.
It's like a factory.
Exactly.
It's becoming a big business, right, essentially?
Of course.
The hospital is making a lot of money
because they're allowing this overlapping surgery.
So imagine one surgeon is basically generating
seven, eight surgeries for them in a day,
versus me, who in a day will do two?
Who's making more money?
So the hospitals like that too, in a sense.
I feel like they go along with it, basically.
They don't, they kind of look the other way.
My experience has been hospitals tend to favor people
who generate a lot of money for the hospital.
I've seen that.
Our sponsor today is Shen Yun.
There's been some negative press on Shen Yun recently.
Shen Yun's mission is to revive ancient
and traditional Chinese culture.
Shen Yun performance started by a group
of Falun Gong practitioners in New York.
Falun Gong is a spiritual and religious group
which believes in living by truth, compassion,
and tolerance, putting others first.
The Chinese Communist Party, CCP,
has been persecuting it since July of 1999 in China.
Since Shen Yun started, CCP has been targeting it
in the U.S. and across the globe
by playing different kinds of schemes
to cancel the shows or impact the performance.
The current negative reporting originated
from some Chinese social media accounts.
And we know that CCP has given a new directive
to go after Shen Yun and Falun Gong in the U.S.
by turning the public opinion against them.
If you hear something negative on Shen Yun,
make sure to do your own research
and your own due diligence.
Despite all of CCP's campaigns against Shen Yun,
the show has managed to grow significantly
across the world.
I highly recommend you go see it.
I've been going to it for the last 14 years
as they change the performances every year.
They're coming back to California.
Make sure you go see it.
So essentially what you're seeing,
from what you're saying, in your space,
money has become the major factor.
That's what I'm challenged.
I feel like money has become,
the profit has become the most important thing.
And we're losing sight of individual quality patient care.
And also, more aggressive surgeries.
If you go look up, fusion operation,
which is where you're putting rods and screws in patients,
has gone up in the last decade significantly.
There was an article, I don't remember where,
maybe Wall Street, New York Times,
I don't remember, but they talked about this,
how the number of fusion operation implant
has gone up significantly.
And that's where I have a problem with,
because I feel most patients don't need fusion operation.
And I feel like they're being pushed
into that unknowing to the patient, basically.
Patients do not know.
Literally, I saw two patients yesterday in my clinic,
both came to me, and they had seen two other spine,
each had seen two other spine surgeons.
They both were told their lower back,
they need fusion or artificial disc, doesn't matter.
It's some kind of implant-based surgery.
And when they saw me, I said, you don't need that.
You just need a little rotor-rooter,
and I will inject your own PRP,
your own bone marrow, inside your own disc.
And they just looked at the shock.
They're like, that's not what I, I never even heard of it.
I thought, I'm gonna come here,
you're gonna tell me one of these,
what the other guys told me.
They're like, how come these guys didn't tell me?
I said, I understand.
Is there more money in that?
Of course it is.
So, for spine surgery in general,
if you divide it, basically, the pay,
usually, it's very simple.
You either are putting some kind of an implant in,
or no implants.
So basically, you're either doing
some kind of a bony decompression,
some little opening, what I call rotor-rooter,
or you're putting some kind of a device in,
some kind of screws, rods, or artificial disc implant in.
The implant-based surgeries in general,
on average, they pay four to five times more.
Facility fee and for the surgeon, on average.
So, from what it looks like,
there is a push to make money
from doctors and hospitals, Jared.
And then the insurance companies,
on the other end, don't want to pay.
Correct.
So, I get what they're trying to do,
which I think, you know, it's important to regulate,
to stop bad practice of medicine, too,
but you have to reward good physicians, basically.
You can't put everybody together,
and patients are, poor patients are suffering,
who are being, seeing the good physicians
who want to do the right thing,
but they can't get it done,
because these other guys are ruining it for all.
And these are patients that have insurance,
like normal insurance?
Yes.
Can you tell us more about just normal cases
with individual insurance or corporate insurance?
The one thing I've seen, which I don't think it's fair,
they're all tiers, insurances, so depending.
So, if you're like the executive
that has this very, very high-end corporate,
high-level insurance, or in Congress,
everything gets approved right away.
But lower-tier ones, usually middle, like individual,
like, you know, lower-tier ones,
if they're like, not what we call self-funded
or fully funded, no, they put a lot of roadblocks.
So, it's like a VIP treatment.
Think about it, it's like, you know,
it's like they say money talks,
so if you're corporate, you're paying that high dollar,
yeah, your stuff gets approved right away.
But other average, common people, no, they don't get it,
which I don't think it's fair.
I think everybody should be treated the same,
no matter whether you're Elon Musk
or the guy that's barely making the minimum wage.
I think health insurance should apply equally to everybody.
The patient I just literally saw
that came to my office on Tuesday,
neglected for three months, I feel bad.
She called my office, we came in,
and my office knows, I try to do pro bono surgery,
at least one or two pro bono surgeries per month,
you know, help people.
I used to go, up until 2007,
I used to go outside United States and do free surgery.
Then I was just like, wait a minute,
we have people here that are not getting good care.
I can help people here, you know,
let me take care of our own people first, you know, here.
So, I started doing more free surgeries here,
which actually, I'm helping more people
than I would have gone if I would have gone abroad.
So, I started doing-
Because you don't have to spend the time
and travel and all that, right?
So, you go there for a week, how many surgeries?
But here, I said, you know what,
at least if I do one, at least minimum one,
if not two surgeries free a month,
I'm doing at least 12 to 24 people
of maybe more free surgeries a month, basically.
A year, I'm sorry.
So, anyway, this patient, like Medi-Cal is one thing,
which is, I think is terrible,
because one of the things Obamacare did,
they open up Medi-Cal, especially in California.
Like, a lot of people got Medi-Cal,
which is for low income, you know,
they're subsidized by the government.
Now, Medi-Cal is not bad.
They cover your basic needs, you know,
your basic OBGYN, like pediatric,
your well checkups, your-
Like preventative.
Preventative stuff.
But when it comes to specialist care,
my God, these people are treated,
I hate to say it, it's like a cattle, like a factory.
They don't, and that's what really bothers me, okay?
The doctor, if you have the Medi-Cal,
they pay very little, which is fine,
but you can't treat people based on,
you have to treat everybody equally.
That's where I get upset,
because I feel like the doctors who are Medi-Cal,
they treat these people like a factory.
Like this lady I told you-
Because they have to do a lot more
to make the same money, right?
The same money, yes, so they're like-
Because they get paid very little back.
Exactly, so they spend very little time with them,
they treat them just not good.
It's like a volume thing, you know, the volume thing.
And I was very upset when I heard like this shocking story,
this poor lady, young lady, if she had a regular insurance,
she would have had her surgery like two months ago,
basically, she would have had the surgery,
but she was neglected, they run around,
she went to the ER at a hospital,
and she was like, oh no, you're fine,
go follow up with your thing,
because she had Medi-Cal, get rid of it.
That's another thing I found,
is like a lot of the hospitals, by law,
they're supposed to take these Medi-Cal patients
and take care of them, because they're a non-profit,
but they don't.
They're not doing what they're supposed to do
based on their non-profit status.
They're supposed to, you know,
I believe 25% of what they're supposed to take
is supposed to be indigent, low-income Medi-Cal,
but they don't, and nobody's looking into that.
Anyway, this poor lady bouncing around, bouncing around,
somehow, I don't remember how she came to me.
I saw her on Tuesday, I felt so awful for her.
I told my office, let's start getting authorization,
then it's Medi-Cal.
Like, this is gonna take weeks.
This poor lady literally crying,
like her balls out in so much pain, like nobody cares.
You know, you feel bad, it's like a human being.
I said, you know what, don't worry about it.
I'm gonna do your surgery.
If we can't get anywhere,
I'm gonna have you go to the emergency room.
I was supposed to do her surgery this morning.
There was a miscommunication with my office.
Anyway, I spoke to her late last night.
I said, you know what, come to the ER today.
I'm gonna do your surgery tomorrow.
Don't worry.
He said, what about you?
You know, I said, don't worry about money.
I'm not charging you anything.
Don't worry about it.
I'm gonna take care of you.
So I'm gonna do her surgery tomorrow.
And when you do the ER, you just donate your time.
I just donate my time, yeah.
So you just tell them to go to the ER
and then you just go there.
I just go there, yeah.
I just went in today and I'm gonna go,
you know, do her surgery tomorrow, basically.
I'm gonna take care of her.
I said, and I do that every so often, you know,
help patients who have no means.
And that's what makes me very upset
because I feel like people are being very treated,
not as a human being, you know, some dignity,
but they're looking at, oh, this one has a good insurance,
you know, or not.
I used to be somewhere.
I swear to God, the place I used to be,
one of the doctors, some of them I know,
they look at insurance,
what type of insurance the patient has.
They get differential treatments.
The first thing they look at is not who the patient is
or what is wrong, what type of insurance they have.
Because the insurance companies will give them a hard time.
Not a hard time, but who makes more money?
Like some of the insurances, they pay more money.
So they treat patients based on that.
Like, for example, like Medicare doesn't pay,
like I remember where I used to be with this group.
Patients used to be in the waiting room.
And I remember I was seeing my own group of patients
and the patient came and says, I don't understand.
I've been sitting here two hours waiting to be seen.
We're like, sir, who's your doctor?
They said, my doctor is so-and-so.
We're like, I'm sorry.
We'll let them know we have nothing to do with it.
We're a separate practice.
So in my office, I was sitting there.
My medical assistant went to the doctors,
told whatever, this patient.
I heard the doctor said, you know what?
I don't care.
They have Medicare.
They can wait another two hours.
It's like free.
I don't care.
Get the other patient with a PPO in.
I swear to God, this I heard it twice
on two different patients.
Wow.
This is like, unfortunately, it's like this battle.
I feel like insurance is not doing the right thing.
Some of the doctors are not doing the right thing.
So guess who suffers?
The public suffers.
The patients are suffering
because they're not getting the good care.
Care is getting delayed, denied.
It's a tragedy.
And it's just getting worse and worse, basically,
because nobody's looking into this.
When was a time when you realized things have changed?
You know, I've been 20 years.
So I would say about-
So you started as a surgeon right away, right?
20 years ago.
Yeah, 20 years ago.
You come out.
You're thinking everybody wants to help patients
do the right thing.
And you know, you don't pay attention.
You kind of go along with it.
And then once I started, I think about after Obamacare,
about a couple of years after,
I started noticing the change.
And I think when I feel like
what the insurance companies start squeezing,
I think that pushes people, doctors,
to start doing things they're not supposed to do
because they're trying to be to get paid more.
Like, for example, they lower the reimbursement.
So guess what?
You do more aggressive surgeries
to keep making the same money.
Or do more surgeries.
And you lower your-
Exactly.
Or push more patients into-
You know, I can begin to tell you,
I mean, there are patients I see
I'm the second or third or fourth opinion.
They come into me.
They're ready to have surgery.
I tell them, no surgery.
They're like, what?
I said, there was a lady, 75 year old lady.
She's like, what doctor?
My MRI shows me this.
The three surgeons have said, I need to have surgery.
I said, okay.
What bothers you?
What is bothering you?
Mom, I have a little stiffness here.
I said, is that all?
That's all, right?
Yeah.
I said, you golf.
I said, you ride your bike.
I said, you go for a hike.
You swim, right?
You don't have any discomfort other than some stiffness.
I said, yeah.
She said, yeah.
I said, so why do you want to do surgery?
Because the doctor told me.
I said, but look, think about it yourself for a second.
You're not in danger.
They're treating the MRI, not you, basically.
So that, I see that too.
A lot of patients are being told,
they're treating the imaging,
not what's wrong with the patient.
So for example, let's say I get an X-ray
of your knee right now,
and it shows you have moderate arthritis,
but you have no pain.
Are you going to do a knee replacement?
And it's so risky, right?
This is such a big risk to take,
and something could go wrong, right?
Yes.
And then there's the cost.
Yeah, I mean, I saw literally a patient-
But there's a push from the industry to-
Yes, the doctors, like, you know,
I feel like the reimbursement's going down,
like the Medicaid reimbursement's going down.
It's unfortunately pushing doctors
to start doing more surgeries,
more aggressive surgeries to make up for this loss.
And that, for sure, I've noticed a trend.
What do a neurosurgeon, a country artist,
and a television and radio host have in common?
They all saw the writing on the wall.
Big Bank sharing your financial information
with big government.
Join them as owners in Old Glory Bank,
the pro-America online bank that protects your privacy,
security, and liberty.
Invest today at own.oldglorybank.com.
And before we get into how to fix this,
Hooman, you, you're coming forward,
and this is risky for you.
Like, usually people from the aerospace doctors
don't wanna talk about this.
Why are you doing this?
Because I saw my own dad go to jail.
He believed in what he stood for.
My dad used to be the Ministry of Health in Iran.
It was a big position in Iran.
And he went to jail because he, you know,
he was being forced to do something,
to change some hospital rankings against his will,
and he wouldn't do it.
He would not give into it.
They wanted to give him money.
He said no.
He was not corruptible, and I saw him.
And when he went to jail, when they arrested him,
they told him, all you have to do is to do this.
Come on out and make a statement.
My dad was like, I'd rather rot in jail
than to do what you guys, I'm not doing this.
And finally, with public pressure,
because he was the righteous man,
after four months, they released, I saw him.
And my dad, before I went to med school,
I remember I was getting on the plane
to go to my orientation for medical school.
This is in 95.
And my dad said, just remember three things about medicine.
You're gonna have three priorities in life.
Number one, patient care.
Number two, patient care.
Number three, patient care.
You just remember that.
And what I experienced in Iran when he went to jail,
we used to go visit it,
and what he said has always resonated.
And when I start seeing things
that I feel like they're absolutely wrong,
I can't just look the other way.
It just boils my blood.
Because my dad was in charge of an ER,
like the Mayo Clinic of the ERs in Tehran.
It was Pars Hospital.
And he was in charge of the ER,
and he ran that place.
Everything was based about patient care.
Not money.
Okay, you know what?
You need to spend, I don't care.
No, this is right for the patient.
This is what we're doing.
And I saw that.
Everything was about patient care.
So here, I feel like we've lost that.
I think profit is becoming more important
than patient care.
So that's why I'm speaking out,
and I'm hoping, and I have a mentor in residency,
which I'm proud to share the name,
Dr. Robert Miller, who I've talked to a lot.
And he always, he stood up for patients.
He always said, listen, we need more people,
watch, he said, watchdogs.
He said, we need more watchdogs like you.
Stand up.
If you have more people like you,
all this stuff is gonna stop.
So do you think more doctors should come out
and speak about what they see in their space?
Yes, we talk amongst each other privately,
and people are afraid of retaliation.
They don't wanna speak out
because they feel like their whole life could get ruined.
And they can.
You know, if these guys wanna ruin somebody,
they can ruin somebody.
How would that be, like you won't get reimbursements
or like other-
Reimbursement at hospitals would start
if you see something not right at the hospital,
the hospital will basically can initiate
what's called a peer review against you.
Like, oh, you did this wrong here.
You did that wrong here.
You know what?
We're gonna suspend you.
You can't operate.
And they're gonna drag you through.
You can go through a few years,
two to three years of you're suspended.
You can't practice.
If you can't practice medicine,
how are you gonna make money?
You're done.
That's why people are afraid.
They don't speak up.
And you're not afraid of that?
No, because I feel like the truth
and you do the right thing,
I think always, yes, you pay the price for it,
which I have actually,
but I can't, like, as I was talking to Dr. Miller,
actually, a few weeks ago,
I was telling him about some of my stuff.
I said, do you think I should just be quiet
and look the other way?
He's like, no, no, you do not do that
because you have a soul.
You don't know how you're gonna sleep.
It's your conscience.
That's why I can't.
And now, Houman, how do you think,
so I'm sure you have thought about ideas
how we can fix this.
Do you have any thoughts?
What could be a fix to this situation you see?
I think the thing is that we have to start
rewarding physicians in every specialty
who have good patient outcome over years.
That's not a difficult data.
Insurance companies have the data.
They know, for example,
if a foot and ankle doctor or spine surgeon,
let's use my field,
you're doing the surgeries.
Okay, this guy, let me see.
He's doing less invasive surgeries
unless patients are coming back for repeat surgery.
So he's doing surgeries that are costing less,
that are less extreme.
Yes.
And then they're getting less comebacks,
less mistakes.
And less medications after,
less narcotics after.
They're recovering faster.
So they're not basically using the system,
oh, they need more therapy,
they need more narcotics,
they need more pain management.
They're getting faster recovery.
The surgery is working properly
and the patient is coming.
So if you have more narcotics afterwards,
that's not a good sign.
Of course not.
It means the surgery wasn't that great.
You have to give somebody 90,
like a simple surgery
that you have to give them 90 pills of like Norco.
There's something wrong with that.
90 pills.
There's a good chance
that that patient's gonna be addicted.
There's 30, 40% chance
that patient's gonna be addicted with 90 Norco.
So I went, personally me,
I was not satisfied with that.
So in March of 2018,
I started doing narcotic-free surgery.
I said, you know what?
This is not good enough.
We need to start basically
doing something about this opiate endemic that we have.
So I started adopting a holistic approach
where I'm not treating you, your spine,
I'm treating you as a whole,
like your whole body.
Because at the end of the day,
whether you operate on the knee, hand, spine,
doesn't matter.
You're operating on a human being.
What is the whole body is doing?
Because if the body is falling apart,
you start to optimize,
how do you think you're gonna recover from the surgery?
How are you gonna recover from surgery?
So I said, with what was going on in our healthcare,
with poor nutrition that we had,
and obesity, diabetes,
and this was really affecting outcome, basically.
You can't ignore, no, no, no.
I'm just focusing on your spine.
I don't care.
No, it doesn't work like that.
So I started basically focusing on gut health,
probiotics, educating the new patients on nutrition,
important, I call it the anti-inflammatory diet,
not weight loss.
You could be skinny.
You're still gonna get lecture.
It's not about being skinny, overweight.
It's about lowering inflammation in the body.
So if you lower inflammation in the body,
if you start basically treating people holistically,
putting them on proper supplements and nutrition,
guess what?
Sometimes they actually heal.
They don't need surgery, number one.
Number two, if they need surgery, now they're optimized.
And that's how you avoid, basically, narcotics,
and they get faster recovery, basically.
So I don't, I have another patent-pending approach,
a cocktail I do during the surgery
that I inject it also at the time of the surgery.
And that really helps the patients tremendously,
very pain-free after,
hardly requiring any pain pills after.
We do give them some pain,
but I give them Tylenol.
I give them something like Celebrex, Lyrica,
and very low-acting opiate that's called Tramadol,
and very few pills, and that's it.
We don't give any more.
Of course, there are exceptions.
Once in a while, you have a patient, difficult, of course,
but I will tell you, 90% of my patients,
we don't give them Percocet, Oxy.
You know, we have to adopt, basically, as a surgeon,
I think start educating.
Like, when I went to residency,
there was, all the focus was on orthopedic surgery,
musculoskeletal and stuff.
It was not focused on the total body,
the gut health, the metabolism,
you know, your pancreas, your liver.
This stuff is important.
You know, it makes a big difference.
So I think we can start there
by start getting people more healthier
and educating patients, spending time with the patient,
but that means you can't see 60 people in a day.
You have to spend, my new patients,
I spend 45 minutes to an hour,
my office knows, they can tell this.
My competitors sometimes, other people I know,
they're seeing 60 people a day or 100 people.
How can you spend quality time with a patient,
educating about all this,
if you're seeing 100 people a day?
Listen, the insurance companies have the data.
They know on their per month,
this doctor is seeing this many patients.
They know this, he's seeing this many patients.
They know, okay, this doctor, let me see,
they did 100 surgeries and well, you know, 70% was fusion.
This doctor did 100 surgeries, 70% was non-fusion.
Well, these guys are doing a lot better.
They can easily start looking at this data,
but the problem is that they don't,
they pass the buck to the patients.
So how, they increase your premiums,
your deductibles every year goes up.
You mentioned, we have had guests on the show
that actually become addicted
after going to these operations.
Exactly.
They had an operation and then they actually went in
and they took these pills and they liked it
and they got addicted.
Did you see that happening?
Absolutely.
So that was the thing that was upsetting me
because I feel like I was basically adopting
what was taught to me with no, not default,
but this is just, it gets passed on.
Every residency you go through,
this is just the way you do medicine, it gets passed on.
Nobody's like critically thinking,
well, is this really right to do it this way?
So I started basically, you know,
one thing I remember I learned and my dad used to say
is that never be satisfied with what you're doing,
even if it's going well,
always try to figure out, could this be better?
If you don't think like that, how are you gonna get better?
So I was always thinking like,
okay, can I do the surgery better?
Can I treat the patient better?
So I started thinking, you know, always getting better.
And then about 2013,
I got introduced to this whole branch of medicine
called functional medicine, basically,
integrated functional medicine,
where it looks at the human body as a whole.
None of that was taught in medical schools.
They don't teach that stuff.
They're teaching you how to push drugs.
You have high cholesterol, here's a drug.
You have hypertension, blood pressure, here's a drug.
You have autoimmune, oh, here's a drug for it.
But why do you have high cholesterol?
Why do you have-
It doesn't get to the root cause.
The root cause.
So I learned these guys and their root cause
and why we have higher cancer.
We have higher chronic diseases,
neurodegenerative disorders.
Like it's getting bigger and bigger
and we're spending the most highest dollar
than any other place in the world.
We're getting worse and worse.
So these functional doctors are dialing it back
and treating the patient holistically
by using food as medicine.
I was basically, I was becoming pre-diabetic.
If you looked at me at the time,
I was less than 10% body fat.
People knew it was amazing shape, but I was pre-diabetic.
You wouldn't believe that.
I had cholesterol was like going like crazy.
I had acid reflux.
So my friends thought, here's a bunch of pills.
And-
Oh, so your doctor friends-
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
They're like, oh yeah, you got to just do cholesterol.
I'm like, ah.
There was a colleague, a friend of mine, Dr. Tazib,
Rochelle Tazib, T-A-H-Z-I-B,
which I credit her with really opening my eyes.
And when I talked to her, I was like,
I've never heard of this.
What is she talking about?
So I started reading a little bit
and I started attending conferences.
And I actually went to her, said, you know what?
Let me see if she can.
And I went to her.
She got rid of all of my problems
by just using food and supplements as medicine, basically.
And I couldn't believe it.
Everybody was like, ah, it's not going to work.
And that's how I learned in med school.
Everybody was like, you can't lower your cholesterol by 50%.
That's impossible.
You need to have, you know, this is just life.
You get older.
But no, I learned from her and I started adopting
that practice, started incorporating it to my own practice.
And I saw the results where if you treat patients
holistically, the way I did, it makes a big difference.
Like the patients are like happier, less pain,
much faster recovery.
And, but you know, this stuff takes time.
You got to sit down.
The problem is the insurance companies do not recognize
any of this extra work, basically.
They're not reimbursable.
So the doctors are just treated the same.
It doesn't really matter if you do eight surgeries a day
and you kind of look at it as a factory
or you do one really good one and you really care
about that patient or two good ones.
They don't care.
They don't care about that.
It's unfortunately, to me, it's like if a guy came out,
I've had, like we had, I had a patient who was a nurse
actually and very well, highly skilled nurse
that she's been in administration right now.
She came to me, she wanted surgery.
She was out of, her insurance had no
out-of-network benefits.
And they treat us like commodity
because she wanted me to do the surgery
based on what she heard, whatever, and stuff.
The insurance company basically were trying to send her
to a guy who just finished training six months ago
to do a big, complex surgery.
Like if it's your spine, do you want a guy
who just finished fellowship a year ago, two years ago?
Or you want them to go to somebody who's experienced
with a very good track record to do a very complex surgery?
Because I've been, I've seen the results
that the bad spine surgery can ruin someone's life.
Can you become paralyzed, right?
Is that, or?
No, it's not even just paralysis.
That's extreme, but it's more like chronic pain.
Like you get dependent on opiates.
Like your quality of life is ruined, basically.
You're in just pain.
You can't stand up straight.
You're basically punched over.
You're in so much pain.
Like you're, it just ruins your life.
They treat you rather than saying, you know what, this guy,
so I had to get on a call with a doctor.
Thank God the doctor, he actually was good.
He said, you know what, this is a no brainer.
I'm gonna approve the patient to have surgery with you.
I totally, everything you're telling me makes sense.
I get it, I get it.
You know what, no, no, no.
That's it, approval.
But the insurance was pushing the patient
because I saw the name of the doctors they gave.
And I'm like, none of these doctors
have more than two years of experience doing this
because to them, it's not about the money
because they can pay their in-network doctor.
Very little, very little money.
And unfortunately, the hospitals, the healthcare,
I feel like doctors who are getting good,
they don't reward them, so they leave.
So then they have a lot of the hospitals,
the corporations now, healthcare,
they hire these young, super young doctors.
So if you go look at a lot of the hospitals, big hospitals,
there are different departments,
you'll see a couple of really good doctors who are very good.
The rest of them are all these super, super young people
because they don't wanna pay them.
And 95% of the public doesn't really have access
to those really good doctors
because those doctors only treat royalty or super VIP.
They're only so much time they have.
Everybody else gets stuck with these guys,
with the minions.
Now, do you have any recommendations for the patients?
To me, experience matters.
I can tell you what I know now,
experience really makes a difference.
It's not about your skills.
Even if you have the best skills, you come out,
you don't have experience.
And I've learned in spine surgery, experience really matters.
So find out the experience.
How many cases of these have they done?
Talk, call the hospital, talk to the nurse's station
that know, the nurses know all the doctors
who are doing the surgery, spine surgery.
They know all the spines.
They will tell you who they would go to.
Call the nurses, ask references.
Say, I wanna talk to five patients.
Also read, don't just look at a five star Google review
or 2.5 star Google review, read the reviews
because sometimes I know a doctor
who has like two star Google review,
but none of the reviews are about him as a doctor.
It's about his office staff, it's like terrible.
So that's not fair to the doctor.
Read this stuff, as I get references,
get multiple references basically.
And especially, I think if you're being offered
a big operation, fusion operation,
you know what, get another opinion.
Don't just jump into it.
Find out if there are alternatives that can be done,
alternative surgeries.
Sometimes patients are not told that.
Get a second opinion, put the brakes on.
And I tell you, another thing,
don't always listen to fear mongering.
I've had patients who've been told,
if you don't have surgery in 48 hours,
you're gonna get paralyzed, which is not true.
You know, it's wrong.
Sure, super small percentage of the population,
yes, you need emergency surgery, no problem,
but not every patient.
If you don't have any ongoing like bad nerve damage
going on, meaning if your arm is working,
your foot is working, your leg is,
you don't have that much weakness,
you don't have that much numbness,
you're not in danger, okay?
You have time to get a week to get other opinions.
Don't, if a doctor is really pushing you
and just listen to your body, get second opinion,
third opinion if you have to,
especially the bigger the surgeries.
Ask the doctor, I need to talk to five of your patients.
And ask questions, listen.
The doctor's job is to sit down,
you know what I do when I finish?
I never like come and talk whenever I leave.
I always, at the end, I say,
do you have any other questions?
Listen, there are sometimes patients, I get it,
they're asking the same question repeatedly,
but I never tell the patient, okay, enough, like whatever,
or you know what, I gotta go see, you know,
let the patient basically like, you know what,
no, I don't have any other questions, thanks, okay.
But if you're sitting there, ask the assistant
or the medical assistant,
how many surgery does he do a week?
If they say he's doing, oh, 15, 20 surgeries a week,
that's a red flag.
Does he ever, you know, how many surgery he does in a day?
Because spine surgery, I remember my mentor told me
that if you can do six really,
six or seven really good surgeries,
but do a really good job, that's very good.
Six a week?
Six a week, yeah, six or seven a week.
And you can do the job like really well focused on that.
You don't need to do any more.
You don't need to do more than that.
More than that, depends, listen, if there's like,
I've done like sometimes nine in a week,
but they were like little,
like one and a half hour surgeries, you know,
like he would do three of them in a day,
three of them in a day, three of them in a day.
So that's not, yeah, no problem.
But I'm talking like the spinal fusions
where they're taking longer.
And you can ask him,
how many fusions is he doing basically?
If they're doing a high volume surgery,
these are the things to do.
How many patients does he see in clinic?
If they're telling you, you see,
oh, we see about 50, 60 people a day in clinic,
that's a red flag.
From eight to five, really can see 60 people
and give them quality.
How many minutes are you spending per patient?
These are the things basically.
But patients have to be proactive, ask questions,
don't feel like you're rushed basically.
You shouldn't feel rushed.
We have heard from some doctors
that the problem in the healthcare
is a lot of patients have no idea what's the cost.
Yes.
They don't know what costs what.
They will find out afterwards.
Now, you might-
Get a surprise bill.
You either get a surprise bill
or your insurance will pay for it.
So you might have gone through a surgery
that costs five times more.
Somebody could come and see one doctor
and pay double the other doctor
or go to a hospital that costs like five times more
and other one.
Do you think this is a big factor
that's causing a lot of these problems in the healthcare?
Or do you think there is a way to solve this?
I think some, yes, because by law,
all hospitals were supposed to put on their website
the transparency.
There was a law that was passed a few years ago,
the transparency law.
The hospital was supposed to publish
exact amount they're charging for every surgery.
But unfortunately that hasn't happened.
And nobody is holding hospitals accountable
for that, hey, this is a law, you're not doing it.
Some hospitals are, they're not doing it.
And yes, you could go one hospital
that says an appendectomy, let's say your appendix out.
One hospital will say 10,000,
another hospital says 60,000 or knee replacement.
One hospital says 15,000, another hospital says 80,000.
Same exact surgery, basically.
So to me, part of the problem is also
the bigger the hospital, the corporate,
they tend to charge more because they're also,
because they have a lot of patients,
because the bigger the corporation,
the big name hospitals, they tend to command more
from the insurance company.
So for example, a simple, let's say, appendectomy,
one hospital could get paid because of their contract,
could get paid, let's say, 10,000.
Another hospital for the same surgery
is gonna get paid 50,000 from the same insurance company.
From the same insurance company.
Yeah, so it doesn't matter,
Aetna, United, Blue Cross, doesn't matter.
Same insurance is gonna pay one hospital this much,
another, because of the contracting,
because of the power one hospital has.
So that's how I feel healthcare costs increasing,
because when these bigger hospitals are charging this much,
and then eventually, they're starting to buy out
all the little guys.
So now, for example, a freestanding healthcare facility,
I'm sorry, imaging.
There was a place I knew, I used to send my patients,
if they needed cash, $150 for a CT scan.
Now, they got bought out by a major hospital, basically.
So now, the cash price for that is like $450.
Same CT, same tech, same everything.
No difference.
Because now, because they commanded, it's the same.
Three times the price.
So the reimbursement now, for the same imaging,
because I remember I talked to the radiologists,
I'm like, hey, why don't you guys merge it?
They're like, yeah, the reimbursement, simply.
So now, because they bring their contract,
so now, the same thing is being paid
three times, four times more.
Because the insurance is paying for it, right?
Exactly.
Or they have a better deal with the insurance.
They have a better deal, they have a better contract.
So this is our contract, you need to pay.
And unfortunately, the insurance companies,
when they get squeezed, ultimately,
they squeeze the consumer, the patients, basically.
They either charge more, or they might not approve that.
Or approve it, yes.
That's exactly right.
I mean, we know they charge more,
because our premiums have gone up.
The premiums have gone up every year.
And part of the problem is there's also a monopoly
that's happening with the insurance industry
in different counties and states.
Before Obamacare, we used to have,
I could go as an individual and look at the list.
I'm like, okay, you know what I want to get, for example?
I want to get this one here.
And you know what, the premium was,
I remember the premium at the time was like $200.
And I had amazing insurance.
My deductible was less than $2,500.
And I could go to anywhere in the country, get it done.
When Obamacare came, guess what?
You don't have a list anymore.
You only have one major insurance,
individually in California, that 90% can only get.
That's all you get.
So now they know I have the monopoly.
They can also control that, deny,
because you don't have any other choice, basically.
So now they can increase your premium,
like my premium every year is going up.
Deductibles get a little bit more.
Co-pay increases.
Co-pay used to be 10, 20.
Now it's like 50, 60, 70, 80.
It's going up, basically, for the same thing.
Because I feel, I get it.
The insurance companies are getting squeezed
because the hospitals are charging more.
They've created a monopoly.
It's like this kind of a system
where the hospitals and the insurances are,
profit is basically becoming the center point
for all of them.
So one squeezes the other one.
The other one squeezes around the patients, basically.
Dr. Human Malamed, orthopedic spine surgeon.
It was great to have you on California Insider.
Thank you very much.
It was a pleasure.
I loved it.
Thank you very much.
Let us know what you think
of this conversation with Dr. Malamed.
Do you think the healthcare system
has become more about money than patient care?
You can always reach out to me
by emailing me at siamakacaliforniasider.com
or make sure to comment.
We read all of your emails and comments.
We'll see you next time.
