Loch Ness Monster - Surgeon's Photo - +Real Or Fake?

Decoding Loch Ness
7 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe speaker analyzes the famous \"Surgeon's Photograph\" of the Loch Ness Monster, moving from a childhood belief in the creature's existence to a skeptical conclusion. By examining biological improbabilities and the behavior of the photographer, the speaker argues that the iconic image is a fake, though he remains open to the possibility that some phenomenon exists in the loch.
Hello there. Mother, Stan, other interested parties. Yes, today I offer what I believe to be
definitive proof as to whether this iconic image of the Loch Ness Monster is indeed a real or fake
photograph. Now I'll just give you a bit of background. My interest in all things Loch Ness
began in my formative years when I read this book. The Loch Ness Story by Nicholas Whitchell.
And that is THE Nicholas Whitchell. Yes, there's a picture of him there on another edition. Yes,
Nicholas Whitchell. Now having read said book I became convinced of the existence of a large
animal or animals swimming around in Loch Ness. Why did I come to this conclusion? Well,
it was just a sheer weight of evidence. The eyewitness testimony. Things like, for example,
the Rhine's underwater flipper photograph. NAB's photo in Uckert Bay. Yes, now I know that's the
Disney one but the real one was like postage stamp time. You know what I mean? Sonar. Yeah,
for example, that one there. Yeah, I don't know if you can see much there but two large objects
chasing fish around in the depths of Loch Ness. And this photo. Now what is, first of all,
what is so compelling about this photo? Well, it's lines, it's symmetry, it's proportions.
Everything about it looks right. I mean, I think that's the main thing about this is that if a
animal did shove its neck out of the loch, you know, one afternoon and somebody took a photo of
it, it would pretty much look like this. Its proportions are right and you get a sense of
something under the water as well. You can see this dark area here, maybe a flipper there.
There's a circular wave pattern emanating from it. I mean, everything about this suggests to me
an animate object sat on the top of the loch. In a nutshell, that is what is so compelling about it.
And to illustrate my point, I would like to show you a few other
head and neck photos taken in the loch. Yes, stick, stick, bird. You have to squint for a
few of these. Stick. Here's one I made earlier. Here's another I made earlier. Life on Mars.
A large plesiosaur type animal residing on the loch surface. Or so I thought. Now,
I think in the 90s, was it? In the 90s, Giza comes forward and says this photo is in fact a fake.
Now, my initial reaction to this was, you know, Giza is a publicity sinker. I mean, Giza says
this was actually a plasticine model on top of a submarine floating about the loch. You know,
I mean, to me, I mean, there was no way it would look as good as that. I mean,
wouldn't it sink, flip over, all this sort of stuff? I thought, no, I just dismissed it.
You know, cobblers, you know, I mean, cobblers says it all, doesn't it? But then more recently,
more recently, I sort of, I started to think about this. I started thinking about this a bit more
and I sort of subjected this to a more rigorous critique, shall we say. I mean, let's just,
let's just have a look at this. This is an animal, right? Let's, let's consider a few
things about it. Well, for example, for a start, I mean, it's quite happy there,
sat on the surface of the loch. Indicates to me this is clearly an air-breathing animal,
yeah? Now, if it's an air breather, you would think you'd see a lot more of it on the surface,
breathing air. Some other things to consider as well. I mean, if you think of other air-breathing
aquatic animals, for example, a whale. Now, a whale has a massive blowhole, you know,
sucks in gallons of air, can stay in the water for quite some time. Consider this creature,
right? Small head, small mouth. This isn't going to be able to, you know, inhale much air and
submerge for any length of time. In fact, this animal looks to me as though it probably spent
as much time in the air, out of the water, as in it. So why, you know, why no more sightings?
Secondly, the plesiosaur angle. Now, you know, plesiosaurs could not do that. The neck had to
remain horizontal to the body because of the vertebrae. So, a small point, because this
doesn't necessarily have to be a plesiosaur, but you know. Most of the fish in Loch Ness are in
top 30 meters. Usain Bolt can cover 30 meters in about just over three seconds, flat out. Yeah,
it's not a great depth. One of these things, or a family of these things, charging about,
you know, feeding on fish, you'd see disturbance on the water, you know, yeah. Also, I mean,
there's been sightings in Loch Ness going back hundreds, you know, maybe thousands of years,
who knows. Now, there's not a huge fish population in the loch. I've heard that the fish population
would probably sustain 10 to 20 individuals of a large animal like this. Now, that would present
problems over a length of time. I mean, we're talking about disease, accidents, drop in the
population, gender imbalance, and chronic inbreeding. So, all of a sudden, it doesn't
look so convincing, does it? But, have I come to the main thrust of this video, the proof.
Okay, well, Wilson the surgeon, who took this photo in 1934, actually took four photos.
The famous one, two blanks, and that one, just the head, the neck, above the water.
Now, when Wilson, there's a picture of him there, by the way, yeah, might not have caught that, yeah.
When he went to the chemist to collect his photos, he only wanted this one. He did not want the one
showing the head out of the water. Now, let's consider this for a moment. If this is genuine,
this is quite simply the most remarkable wildlife photograph ever taken, and that being the case,
that would be the second most remarkable wildlife photograph ever taken. Now, why did Wilson not
want that second photo? Well, at the risk of stating the bleeding obvious, it was of no value to him.
Now, why was it of no value to him? I mean, if I'd taken a picture of a creature, the most, you know,
famous creature on the planet, you know, I'd want all the photos of it. I'd even want the blanks.
But Wilson didn't want it. Why is that? Well, quite simply, this and this are fakes. He didn't
want the second photo because he'd already got the Hollywood photo. He'd got this. This is what
he was after. This is what he was going to present to the world. Thus, this one became worthless,
and he didn't want it. Simple as that. And just to enlarge on this again,
to go back to some earlier things I've shown you, McNabb's photo. In the real photo,
the tower, the reflection tower is bent, which suggests maybe a bit of trickery going on. I
don't know. Wake of a boat? Boat removed? Quite possibly. That is the original unenhanced picture
of the flipper. Yeah, I don't know quite what that is. I think I had it for soup this afternoon,
whatever that is. The sonar, yeah, two ships chasing fish, yeah, two boats above, reflections
off the loch's bottom. They're in shallow water. Who knows? But that's another video. Yes, I think
I might do another video. The Loch Ness Phenomenon. And just one thing I will say, I'm not dismissing
the chances of there being a creature or creatures in the loch. Just because this is a fake doesn't
mean there isn't something going on there. In my next video, I will address the actual Loch Ness
monster thing as a whole. And the key photograph to me, believe it or not, is that. That is the key
photo to the Loch Ness Phenomenon. And I will explain why in my next video, if I ever get around
to doing it. Yes, if you got this far, thanks for viewing. Have a good evening and a keen piss.
