Five fights built modern cosmology. The sixth might break it.
In this 8-minute explainer I trace the debates that doubled the size of the universe overnight, made Earth older than the cosmos that contains it, and turned a hiss of radio static into the strongest evidence we have for the Big Bang. Then I argue that the final debate — eternal inflation and the multiverse — may quietly turn cosmology into something that is no longer science.
What I cover:
- The Great Debate of 1920 and how Hubble settled it with a single Cepheid - Why the steady-state model was a serious idea, not a punchline, and what killed it - The age paradox that nearly broke 20th-century cosmology - Penzias and Wilson, pigeon droppings, and the accidental Nobel Prize - Inflation, B-mode polarization, and the question I have spent my career trying to answer - Why "a theory that explains everything explains nothing" is the Popper trap the multiverse may have walked into
If you have heard physicists say the multiverse is the natural conclusion of inflation — I think that is exactly where the argument should start, not end.
For more on this debate, my book Losing the Nobel Prize covers the BICEP2 episode and what it taught me about the line between inference and evidence: https://briankeating.com/book
Subscribe for long-form conversations and no-dumbing-down explainers from Into the Impossible.
🎯 Support Into the Impossible on Patreon — get my weekly M.A.G.I.C. Message, unfiltered bonus content, and live monthly Office Hours with me: https://www.patreon.com/drbriankeating
This video explores the evolution of our understanding of the universe through five great scientific debates. It traces the journey from believing the Milky Way was the entire universe to the modern hypothesis of a multiverse, highlighting key discoveries in galactic scale, stellar energy, cosmic age, the Big Bang, and cosmic inflation.
WHAT IS THE TRUE SIZE OF OUR UNIVERSE?
Ancient astronomers had long observed strange shapes in the night sky, bright luminescent
arms and arcs glowing in the darkness.
The most famous one of these, the Great Spiral Nebula and Andromeda fascinated astronomers
for generations.
Harlow Shapley of Mount Wilson Observatory argued for what at the time was the mainstream
hypothesis.
These spiral nebulae, like Andromeda, were simply dust clouds at the edges of our Milky
Way galaxy, which back then was believed to contain the entire universe.
His opponent in this great debate was Heber Curtis of Lick Observatory in Northern California,
who proposed something radically different.
These weren't dust clouds in the Milky Way at all, but each one was an entire island
universe, each cloud a separate galaxy, just like our Milky Way.
But for this to be true, the scale of the galaxy implied that they must be impossibly
farther away than ever considered before.
The debate was inconclusive for another three years, when Edwin Hubble, using the powerful
new 100-inch telescope at Mount Wilson, made a discovery that changed everything.
His observation of a special type of pulsating star called Cepheid Variables within the Andromeda
Nebula proved that it wasn't a nebula in our galaxy at all.
It was far beyond our own galaxy, millions of light years away, an enormous city of billions
and billions of stars, and it was located 2.5 million light years away.
Think about that.
Overnight, on a cosmic blink of an eye, our galaxy grew from one galaxy to literally billions
of them, each containing hundreds of billions of stars themselves.
But this raised a new question.
If we were surrounded by these cosmic lighthouses, what was the energy source that powered them all?
Physicist Hans Bethe was faced with a puzzle that had stumped scientists for generations.
How could stars possibly generate enough immense energy to last for billions of years without
burning out?
The prevailing theory of the time suggested that stars were powered purely by gravitational
collapse, the pressure of gravity, like an invisible hand compressing the star to collapse
on itself.
While this is a true phenomenon, and it's important to star formation, Bethe and his
peers knew that this process was inadequate to the task.
It could only power a star like our sun for about 20 million years, and we already knew
the Earth was much, much older than that.
Instead, Bethe proved that stars are actually cosmic nuclear reactors, fusing hydrogen into
helium and converting mass into pure energy, Einstein's famous E equals mc squared equation
in action, a mechanism that could explain not only the star's incredible luminosity,
but also their longevity that would make Peter Atiyah jealous.
This leads us into the third great debate.
New techniques called radiometric dating could now precisely measure the decay of radioactive
elements.
This turned ancient rocks into cosmic clocks, and revealed that the Earth was 4.5 billion
years old.
There was just one problem.
Edwin Hubble had also discovered that the universe was expanding, with galaxies moving
away from us at enormous speeds, speeds proportional to their distance.
This is what we now call the Hubble relationship.
The velocity is proportional to the Hubble constant times the distance.
Based on the expansion rate that he observed, the universe would be younger than some of
the objects within it, including the Earth.
This would be like you finding out that your mother is younger than you.
Now, Walter Bata came to the rescue.
He showed that Hubble had measured the cosmic distances wrong.
That updated the Hubble constant, and proved that the universe had been expanding for much
much longer than Hubble originally calculated.
Now we know the universe is some 14 billion years old, plenty of time to create objects
like the Milky Way and Earth itself.
But this didn't settle everything.
In fact, it launched the fourth great debate.
In the 1960s, most scientists believed that the universe had existed forever, unchanging.
This is called a steady state model, where matter was continuously generated to fill
in the gaps as galaxies moved apart from each other, and that kept the average density of
the universe constant.
But it had always been there.
That is until 1965, when Arnold Penzias and Robert Wilson, two physicists working at Bell
Labs in New Jersey, made a startling breakthrough, discovering something serendipitously.
And that was a background noise that appeared to be in the microwave radio antennas that
they had built to measure the first communication between early satellites in the early 1960s.
This persistent, unexplained radio noise seemed to come in all directions, day and night,
and it couldn't be removed.
After consulting with Robert Dickey and his team, including my PhD advisor's PhD advisor,
David Wilkinson, they realized that the static was actually the cosmic background radiation,
the cooling remnants of the previously hot, dense universe, which had expanded over billions
of years, cooling off from tens of millions of degrees to a mere three degrees above absolute
zero.
But what caused the universe to come into existence from the beginning?
Which brings us to the fifth great debate, still ranging today in 2025.
When three physicists, Paul Steinhardt, Andre Linde, and Alexander Vilenkin, realized something
extraordinary about the first moments of cosmic inflation.
Cosmic inflation describes the period of incredible expansion in the universe's first trillionth
of a trillionth of a trillionth of a second.
Vilenkin and Steinhardt and Linde suggested that inflation wouldn't just create one universe,
it would have to generate an infinite number of universes.
Physicist Alan Guth, the father of inflation, called it the ultimate free lunch, an infinite
number of universes emerging from practically nothing.
In the inflationary scenario, each universe is like a bacterial colony in its own petri
dish, growing and evolving in isolation, separated by vast expanses of space-time.
Each dish could have its own completely different laws of physics, and completely different
constants of nature, resulting in unimaginable possibilities of what can possibly exist.
But this creates a profound problem.
If anything is possible in this infinite ensemble of universes, any theories about the nature
of creation itself, have we reached the limits of what science can tell us about our cosmic
origins?
Some say this theory is dangerous, not only for science, but also for society, which depends
on the scientific method.
This fifth great debate is still in progress, and one answer to it may lie here, in Chile's
Atacama Desert, at 17,000 feet, one of Earth's highest and driest places.
This is the Simons Observatory, and with it, we're looking for something called B-mode
polarization, a subtle twisting pattern, a curling pattern, of light's polarization,
of the CMB radiation left over from the Big Bang.
This polarization pattern, B-mode signal, would provide the strongest possible evidence
for cosmic inflation, and also the first direct evidence of primordial gravitational waves
from the universe's first instance of existence.
If we can observe these patterns, it would be the strongest evidence yet that the multiverse
is what its proponents claim it to be.
But, until the dust settles on our final cosmic debate, we must return to our initial question.
What is our place in the universe?
Is it designed uniquely for our existence?
The constants of nature, like the strength of gravity, or the mass of the electron, or
the speed of light, are they as precisely calibrated and tuned for our existence as
they seem to be?
In the world of the multiverse, are they simply the result of a cosmic coin flip?
One day, hard data may solve and settle the fifth great debate, but in the meantime, one
thing is for certain.
As humans, we'll keep asking questions.
We will keep pushing, aware of our own limitations, but never ceasing to seek, but seeking to
perpetually expand our understanding, beyond each cosmic horizon, one debate at a time,
until we arrive into the impossible.
I'm Brian Keating, and if you'd like to dive deeper into the cosmic controversies
of the multiverse, check out my conversation with one of the godfathers of the multiverse,
Andre Linde, where we explore first seconds of the universe's existence.
Thanks for watching, and remember, the greatest debates in science aren't always about finding
the right answers, they're about asking the right questions.