Next Steps: • 💸 Start eliminating debt for free with EveryDollar - https://ter.li/knf775 • 📞 Have a question for the show? Call 888-825-5225 weekdays from 2–5 p.m. ET or send us an email.
A woman seeks advice regarding her husband's 31-year employment on his parents' farm. The parents exert extreme control over the couple's income, time, and home, despite the couple paying for half of the property. The host identifies this as a toxic family dynamic and a marriage crisis, urging the woman to establish financial independence and set firm boundaries.
Brought to you by CHM, a budget-friendly, faith-based alternative to health insurance.
chministries.org slash budget. My husband has worked for his parents, his family's farm for
the last 31 years. They're super controlling. Is it crazy for me to expect a plan for succession?
They control his salary, his time. They even control the house we live in. Like,
we paid for half of the house, and they refused to put any of it in our name. Like, we can't even
remodel it. I went to them, and because it's built in the 70s, I have, like, electric blue bathrooms.
I asked them to remodel it, or he wouldn't ask them. I asked them by a letter. They wouldn't
even respond, but they told him that I wasn't grateful enough for the house that they provided
for us, but we paid half of it. So it's zero resentment. So it's paid for in cash, but they
paid half, you paid half. Yes. This is insane, Patty. You know that. I know. Nothing about this
is normal. Okay, so on one end of the spectrum, they control his income and time, yada, yada.
That would be like having a boss, right? Yeah. You're the company. You could say,
Dave Ramsey controls my income and time. Yeah. So there's a level of, like, I'm working for
a person, and they have set up a company in a certain way, but the housing situation
for sure is not... Yeah, you guys are not in a good spot because if the house is not in your
name and you put half of your money into it, you legally have no assets, right, from a home
perspective. Correct. So what is your husband saying? These are his parents. Does he see
that as not good for your future? He doesn't really mind. He thinks that they will just be
fair when the time comes. But my thing is I will ask him, like, we have no retirement plan
with him because of course you expect your ground on a farm to be your retirement plan.
And that is fine. When we started this 30 years ago, we used to have family meetings,
and it would be like, oh, we're gonna let you start signing checks. We're going to let you
do this. We might have you buy some more ground and put it in your name. None of that ever came
to fruition. And so now, here we are 30 years later, and we have nothing. You're in a bad
business deal. So that's a marriage problem, Patti, between you and your husband deciding
what you want your life to look like. And it's as much his fault and your fault as the parents'
fault. They've just set up the life they want, and you guys have chosen to go along with it
until you're fed up and you've called this show. So at that point, it's going to be, yeah, you and
your husband have to figure out what you want your future to look like. Hey, George here for
Churchill Mortgage. Listen, with interest rates dropping, this might be your window to buy a home
or refinance. Building equity through home ownership is still one of the best ways to
create safety and security in your life. And you decide when the time is right. And my good friends
at Churchill Mortgage will give you a custom plan and a special offer so you can buy or refinance
the smart way. Go to churchillmortgage.com slash Ramsey offer. That's churchillmortgage.com
slash Ramsey offer. This is a paid advertisement. NMLS ID 1591. NMLSconsumeraccess.org
equal housing lender. But yeah, you and your husband have to figure out what you want your
future to look like in a pretty big way. Because it'll probably, if you do it the right way,
I think the healthiest plan is going to include a lot of boundaries that have not existed for 30
years. And I don't know if his parents will be up for the task, but your husband kind of has to
decide, do I want my future and my marriage and my family to be taken care of, or am I going to
just still be a child and still do what mom and dad say, right? I mean, to a degree. Oh, absolutely.
I don't think they're going to take kindly to him all of a sudden having a backbone, do you?
No, no, they won't. And he knows, like he tells me, he's stuck between a rock and a hard place.
And when I ask him, I'm like, so basically we can't make a plan for our family.
Yeah, you're trapped.
I mean, you can't even get the money out of this house because you can't even sell it.
No, we can't.
Okay, my question, Patty, why did you write them a letter? Why did you not just call and
talk to them? Is the relationship strained right now that you can't just call and have a discussion
about it? I can talk to my mother-in-law, but the father-in-law doesn't talk on the phone,
or he doesn't talk, or he doesn't want to. So I just thought it will be easier
than I could just express myself a little better with that. And I thought my mother-in-law would
call me back, but she didn't. And then she just went to my husband, and she wouldn't even show
it to my father-in-law because she said I wasn't grateful enough because he was very-
There's some narcissistic behavior that I'm capturing here. And I think this is going to
have to come between your husband and his parents.
Yeah, I mean, at this point, Patty, it's you and your husband that it's the issue.
There's a marriage issue between you and your husband, and there's a
business family issue between your husband and his parents, and it's going to get awkward.
And for him to continue to choose them over you, Patty-
That's what hurts.
That's where the resentment is coming. I mean, I hear it all in your voice,
which I get. I would be pissed, too, probably. But also, have you said anything for 30 years?
Oh, yeah. Lots of times. Lots of times.
And so what does he say? What does your husband say?
He just shut down. He's shutting down.
You guys need to go to marriage counseling. You'll have a breakdown in your marriage.
Well, we tried that. He showed up for two times, and then he wouldn't do it again
because they told him that it was crazy, too.
Okay. So, well, Patty, you have some decisions to make about your life. So,
I don't know if we can fix that on a seven-minute call. I'm so sorry, but-
Fixing 31 years of toxic relationships.
Yeah. So, I mean, there would be some ultimatums for me. Not in a threatening way, but just in a,
I'm sick and tired of this, and I don't feel safe. I don't feel like we have a future. I don't feel
secure. I have a lot of fear. I don't like how I've been treated in this part. And, Patty,
if you've had stuff in the past that you've done wrong, admit that, too, right? I mean,
it's not like it's all their fault. I'm sure there's been tiffs and taffs throughout the years.
But yeah, if I'm married to a guy, and as a wife, that you're saying all these things,
and he doesn't at least listen, take into consideration, have conversations about it,
figure out a way to make this life work for you, I don't know what else to tell you.
Yeah. That's kind of what I thought. And he makes it like when I say, so, basically,
we are not going to know what we're going to get until your parents are no longer with us.
And he'll go, so, now you want my parents dead. And I'm like, that's not the case.
This is just common sense in planning. And so, I knew that's what was going to happen.
I think an ask would be that we need to create our own retirement plan. How old are you guys?
55 and 52.
Okay. Well, I would say, for me to feel secure, I need a path of retirement that has nothing to do
with your family and the farm, because nothing is documented. And so, there's not security there. We
have security in it because we don't know what's going on. And so, I want to start putting money
away for our family in retirement, right? And you guys put that in the back, and I don't know if
he'll go for it, but that would be a plan. Are you working outside the home, Patty, or have you?
I have. I have. So, about 10 years ago, I started my own business, and I was super
blessed. And so, I have been putting away for me, or putting into retirements and stuff,
step plans, Roth plans.
Good, good.
That's what I would be doing, is creating your own little island to be insulated from the chaos
that could ensue.
I'm creating my own little island, but I was just told that, he's like, well, now you're becoming
financially independent from me, and you don't need me. And I was like, yeah, that's been part
of my plan, because you just didn't care for our family, and you just do everything with your
family. So, I had to take care of myself. So, I have been blessed to be able to do that.
Yeah. I would continue that.
Well, yeah, in conversations moving forward, something John Deloney always talks about is,
the more you point the finger, your family, you, all of that, immediately defenses go up. Like,
that's just human nature. He's going to want to defend himself. I mean, that's natural. So,
as much as you can talk about you, Patty, and what you can control is you, and what it's doing to you,
and that's how I would approach the conversations with your husband.
But yeah, you guys need some deep untangling. And there are a lot of generational farmers
that we've talked to on this show, that's very difficult from a financial perspective,
passing down generationally between siblings. I mean, there's a lot there,
and people have done it really well and communicated very clear expectations.
Everyone is in the know. It's been very clear. This sounds like the opposite, Patty,
that it's very, very muddled, and a lot of questions.
All you can do is continue to ask for clarity, and set up your own boundaries, and set up your
own financial world, not because you don't trust your husband, but because you need security in
your own life, whether that's with him or without him. You deserve that. So, I appreciate the call.
This is going to take a lot of untangling, and I don't know that you can do it in their lifetime,
but I hope there's a lot of redemption and healing on the other side.