One of the most influential & genetically consistent people of all time (Anatolian Hunter Gatherers)

Ancient Civilizations
15 followers
24 Video Views·May 18, 2026
Pulling all the most recent research on the Anatolian Hunter Gatherers, or AHG people group, what would eventually become the Anatolian Neolithic Farmers, that would be crucial to the rise of farming and the Fertile Crescent, and change history forever.
AI Generated·May contain errors
What's up everybody, this video on the Anatolian hunter-gatherers will tell the story of the
earliest people in Anatolia, one of the most active parts of all of human history.
At the intersection of Eurasia, not too far from Africa and the Levant, it would be key
in the rise of the Fertile Crescent, and this video will pull from a ton of different peer-reviewed
articles, covering everything from the Ice Age climate, the earliest of their tools,
and even how around 20,000 years ago they were taking the first steps towards plant
domestication.
There's even really interesting cave art which lines up with the first domesticated
animals.
And would become the Anatolian Neolithic Farmers, one of the most influential people on all
of European history.
From their technology, down to things like their genes, this is the area where the SLC-24A5
allele developed.
If you saw the video on the development of light skin, you know that's one of the most
crucial alleles to the lightening of skin in Europe.
Of course the ANF people will get their own video, most likely a series of videos, but
first we should lay the groundwork for the earliest people in Anatolia.
And what's most shocking is how genetically consistent they are for tens of thousands
of years, despite being at a crossroads.
They do have influences from the Levant, from the Balkans, from the Caucasus, and the Near
East in general, but even up to modern history with the invasion of the Turks, these admixtures
only ever get up to around 10-20%.
Over tens of thousands of years, Anatolians have stayed Anatolian.
It's a fascinating story, so let's get into it.
The story of humans in Anatolia begins well before Homo sapiens set foot in this region.
During the Middle Paleolithic, so from around 250,000 to 40,000 years ago, Anatolia was
home to Neanderthals, as evidenced by fossils from sites like Karin Cave in southern Turkey,
and these inhabitants thrived in Anatolia's caves and limestone shelters, hunting ice
age fauna with stone tools.
By around 70,000 years ago, modern humans were on the move from Africa into southwest
Asia.
Genetic evidence shows that humans left Africa at least 60,000 years ago and interbred with
Neanderthals, picking up about 2-3% Neanderthal DNA in all non-African populations.
By 45,000 years ago, anatomically modern humans had reached western Eurasia, very likely including
the Anatolian peninsula, given its position at the crossroads of Europe and Asia.
As modern humans stepped into Anatolia, they would have encountered a rugged landscape
of mountains, steppes, and coasts.
The climate fluctuated greatly in this period, and warm interludes, forests, and grasslands
provided abundant game.
During colder spells, glaciers crept down mountain slopes.
But despite all these challenges, Homo sapiens established a foothold, and archaeological
records show that by around 45,000 to 40,000 BCE, early Upper Paleolithic people occupied
caves in southern Anatolia.
In the Hatay region near the Mediterranean, like, and let's just preface here, there
might be a lot of butchering of names, but like in Yuchal Gezili cave, we have a rich
record of these early modern hunter-gatherers.
Its deposits are dated to around 41,000 to 29,000 years ago, and there are stone blade
tools and personal ornaments like shell beads, all in a style characteristic to anatomically
modern humans.
The lowest layers show an initial Upper Paleolithic industry gradually transitioning into the
Amarian tool tradition by around 30,000 BCE, and this continuity suggests that the first
Anatolian humans carried technologies and lifestyles closely related to those of the
Levant, modern Syria-Palestine, where there are known to be early Upper Paleolithic cultures
like the Amarian.
They made bone tools, had that jewelry, and likely had rich oral traditions.
Like I said in the pygmy video, that likely gives us a look at how all humans all across
the world were living, and then they're just tacking on more tech.
So tight-knit social bonds, singing, communal work, stuff like that, and this emergent,
more advanced technology.
And the fact that we're seeing a mixing of cultures from this area really does foreshadow
the fact that this is at the crossroads of different continents, not too far from Africa,
and a bridge between Europe and Asia, something that will make this area one of the most important
areas on the planet throughout all of human history.
But let's zoom in on the Ice Age setting.
Through the Upper Paleolithic, Anatolian hunter-gatherers were fighting against dramatic climate swings.
The period from 25,000 to 20,000 BCE coincides with the Last Glacial Maximum, or LGM, when
global ice sheets peaked.
In Anatolia, the LGM brought cold, arid conditions.
Pollen records from Western Anatolia show that forests nearly vanished at the LGM, and
tree cover dropped to only 5%.
So picture a dry, steppe-tundra landscape.
Grasslands and patchy woodlands would have dominated, supporting herds of herbivores,
but eating mostly grasses and making plant foods for humans is scarce.
Human groups likely retreated into special areas with milder microclimates like coastal
zones or low-altitude pockets.
Anatolia's Mediterranean coast remained relatively hospitable, with the sea moderating temperatures,
and zooarchaeological remains support this scenario, with caves like Direkli in south-central
Anatolia containing bones of deer, wild cattle, and ibex dated to the Upper Pleistocene, which
all suggest these areas were the main human hangouts.
And in southwestern Anatolia, the Belbashi-Belbidi culture sequence spans the Late Upper Paleolithic
into the Epi-Paleolithic after the Ice Age, and this offers a really unique snapshot of
their adaptations.
The toolkits from Belbashi Cave were based on tiny, microlithic blades, small, sharp
stone pieces that could be hafted into arrow shafts.
And by the end of the Ice Age from 15,000 to 12,000 BCE, evidence shows that these Anatolian
hunter-gatherers were diversifying their diets.
In the Beldibi rock shelter, which was the successor to the site at Belbashi, we see
remains of coastal resources like fish and shellfish that have been discovered alongside
bones of deer and wild boar, and signs of plant gathering.
Grinding stones and wild grain remains all give us proof that these foragers were harvesting
wild cereals growing throughout this region.
This is pretty similar to what we saw with the San people way down in South Africa, living
by the coast, and if you saw that video, the main takeaway was that now that they had prime
real estate, caves on the coast that were rich with seafood, while also foraging out
to get some plants and other game, some researchers think this may have been the start of warfare
with bows and arrows actually being used to fish, like we see with other primitive people
living today, but that these start to get used in warfare, in defending this prime real
estate.
So I think it's very reasonable that the same sort of thing was happening here on the Anatolian
coasts, but there now is a key difference, the collecting of these wild grains and cereals,
things that will be more suited for farming.
Starting as early as around 20,000 BCE, this is all setting the stage for agriculture,
for the fertile crescent that would bloom in this area.
Paleoenvironmental data shows that when the Ice Age waned, so about after 18,000 BCE,
Anatolia greened rapidly.
Forests expanded earlier here than in parts of Europe.
As herb-rich meadows and woodlands returned, human populations likely grew and spread into
these new areas.
Remember, the trees were just down to 5% at one time.
Now we're starting to uncover the traces of the late Upper Paleolithic expansions, like
in northwestern Anatolia, a region that until recently had little known Paleolithic presence.
But a new, epi-Paleolithic cave was discovered in 2020.
Balik Cave, near Dakhili in Izmir province, has given us radiocarbon dates around 12,000
BCE, showing that hunter-gatherers were active on the Aegean coasts at the end of the Pleistocene.
And these finds stress that Anatolian hunter-gatherers, or AHG, were not confined to a single spot.
They occupied diverse habitats, from the Marmara region in the Black Sea coast, to the Taurus
mountains in Central Plateau.
If you want to subscribe so you don't miss it, of course I will be getting into all the
different people groups that emerged in this area, and there's going to be a ton of one-off
videos just covering specific aspects of these cultures.
I've joked in the comments before that this channel is going to end up being like Seasons.
We've started off in Africa, and there's still a whole lot more to cover there, but I imagine
eventually I'll be doing at least tens of different videos on Anatolia.
Let alone when we get to Samaria and Egypt.
So this whole area was what's called the AHG people group, but let's zoom in on their cultural
innovations, and then we'll look at the genetics.
During the Ice Age, Anatolia's foragers were creating art and ritual objects that give
us a really great glimpse into their minds.
In Dirigli Cave in 2009, archaeologists found a small figurine of a voluptuous female form
carved in clay or soft stone.
This 3cm Venus figurine is stylistically similar to the famous Paleolithic Mother Goddess statue
of Europe, but it is considered the first of its kind in Anatolia or the Near East.
It's been dated to around 16,000 to 14,000 BCE, while the Venus of Hullfels can be dated
to at least 35,000 years ago.
This suggests that this kind of fertility cult or ancestral figurines representing a
woman with surplus, the opposite of famine which threatens all species, and which is
the number one killer of offspring, idolizing this figure of abundance must have been common
to human groups for tens of thousands of years.
As we have it popping up in Central Europe 35,000 years ago, and 20,000 years later,
we have the earliest example in Anatolia.
I doubt the first one ever made was around 15,000 years ago, it's just the first one
we found.
People groups from Africa and Eurasia were likely all making these kinds of figures.
Just like the idea of convergent evolution, that different groups are responding to the
same environmental pressure, this is like the convergent evolution of ideas, that all
human groups wanted their women to be fat and happy and able to produce children.
And think about that this is popping up during the Ice Age, where there would be an even
deeper yearning for this to be true.
From the ubiquitous, enormous phallus-type sculptures to these voluptuous women, they're
making real in art form what they hope to make real in reality, a kind of sympathetic
magic.
Anatolia also has some of the earliest known cave art in West Asia.
In the Baldibi Rock Shelter, there are very faint rock engravings and paintings on the
walls.
These pictographs, showing stylized humans, mountain goats, and deer, are unique in this
region, and they likely date to the Epi-Paleolithic period, so around 12,000 to 10,000 BCE, which
is really interesting because it's right around the time that goats were first domesticated.
Goats and sheep are thought to be domesticated before things like cattle and chickens.
So while it's not as visually elaborate as European Paleolithic cave paintings, it does
show this same human impulse for creative expression.
And whether it's some form of memorializing some great event, even as simple as the way
a toddler will go through their day repeating the most impactful thing, or if again these
are a type of sympathetic magic, the idea that drawing it or producing it out in the
real world could help bring about the effect that it's portraying, this too seems to be
ubiquitous across human groups of this time.
And it's believed they would have had unique music and language, everything from instruments
to songs that were unique to them.
Of course, none of this fossilized, but it can be inferred by studying other groups.
Again, like in the pygmy video, researchers can tell that certain words and instruments
are believed to be from before 20,000 years ago, since they're shared across all pygmy
groups, even those that later became isolated due to climate change.
The pygmy lost their native language to the incoming Bantu, but they all have certain
words and concepts that are unique to them, and it's thought to be from before 20,000
years ago.
So again, we should expect the same thing in Anatolia, it's just that they haven't
stayed the same since then.
But of course, one of the most exciting and objective is the recent sequencing of ancient
DNA from Anatolian hunter-gatherers.
Until a few years ago, we only had genetic data from later farmers, leaving a huge gap
in our knowledge of ice age populations.
But that changed in 2019, when scientists extracted genome-wide DNA from a man at Pinarbashi,
a rock shelter site in central Anatolia, dated to around 13,500 BCE.
This epipaleolithic Anatolian turned out to represent a distinct lineage of ice age humans,
and that's what geneticists now call the Anatolian hunter-gatherer, or AHG lineage.
I stress this every time, but just cause you can say everybody came out of Africa, groups
eventually coalesce and there are distinct groups both within Africa and of course outside
of Africa, to the point that all people in what we call this group are more similar to
each other than anybody else is to them.
And so that's how we get distinct people groups.
And people like the Pinarbashi man are differentiated from other known Pleistocene groups.
They are not simply an offshoot of European hunter-gatherers, nor are they identical to
Levantine or Caucasus groups.
They shared ancestry with these people, but became distinct in Anatolia.
But of course their closest relatives are the Western hunter-gatherers, also called
the Ice Age Europeans, and other Near Easterners, like people of the Levant and Caucasus.
But one really interesting thing is that the AHG genomes are similar to the Villabrunna
cluster of Europe.
The Villabrunna cluster, named after a 14,000-year-old skeleton from Italy, shows the resurgence
of hunter-gatherer populations in Europe after the last glacial maximum.
The Anatolian hunter-gatherer's non-Middle Eastern ancestry appears most closely related
to this cluster.
In other words, the same genetic lineage that repopulated Europe at the end of the Ice Age
also contributed to Anatolia's population.
And so researchers infer that there was genetic contact between Anatolia and the Balkans,
or Europe more generally, happening sometime around or soon after the LGM, and before 15,000 BCE.
Whether people migrated across the Bosphorus land bridge or around the Black Sea, whatever
route they took, the gene pools mixed.
And this helps explain why the Anatolian hunter-gatherers are genetically similar to Balkan Mesolithic
people.
They share that post-LGM European heritage.
But the other part of the AHG genetic profile is drawn from the Ancient Near East.
Genomic studies show an influence from a population related to those in the Zagros Mountains,
or Caucasus.
This is sometimes called an Early Iranian Caucasus component, and it may have entered
Anatolia earlier than the European component.
One hypothesis is that during the LGM, or just before it, some hunter-gatherer groups
from the East, like those more habitable regions in the Caucasus, they expanded westward, bringing
with them new genetic lineages.
In supporting this, we have found the genome of a woman from Zudzana Cave in the Caucasus
in modern-day Georgia, dated to around 26,000 BCE, who appears ancestral to many later Near
Easterners.
These Eastern groups carried a mysterious lineage geneticists call basal Eurasian, the
base of heritage for Europe and Asia.
Basal Eurasians were an early branch of modern humans that split off before other non-Africans
diversified.
And what's crucial is that they did not intermix with Neanderthals, so they carry
none of that 2-3% Neanderthal signal.
This deep lineage is detected in later Middle Eastern farmers, and to a lesser extent in
Natufian foragers of the Levant.
The Anatolian hunter-gatherer genome shows only a small fraction of the basal Eurasian
ancestry, and this aligns with its intermediate position.
The AHD population had a more basal-free western ancestry than Levantines did, but also a touch
of that basal-rich Near Eastern heritage.
Overall, the simplistic take is pretty accurate.
They are at a crossroads, and they do have a mix of genetic heritage from the people
around them, which because of its unique location, it created such a unique genome.
Recent modeling of Pleistocene movement paths show that the Bosphorus was not an impassable
barrier for humans, it's actually the opposite.
Some of the easiest migration routes from Anatolia to the Caucasus or Eastern Europe
ran across the Bosphorus and through the Balkans.
This meant that groups could and did move between Anatolia and Southern Europe when
climate permitted.
The genetic evidence for a shared Villa Bruna-like ancestry around 15,000 BCE is the strongest
evidence corroborating this movement.
And so as the Ice Age ended, people from the general area of the Balkans or Black Sea coast
traversed into Anatolia, bringing new ideas and genes.
They might have introduced new tool types or hunting methods, but also Anatolian groups
could have migrated into Thrace and the Balkans as conditions improved there, so that by the
Mesolithic, post-Ice Age, archaeological cultures on either side of the Marmara Sea
show parallels.
The Iron Gates culture of the Danube Valley around 9,000 BCE and the Anatolian hunter-gatherers
have similar toolkits and a heavy reliance on fishing and large game, along with some
shared genes.
And of course, connections to the South are equally important.
Bordering the Levant, the cradle of early Natufian culture, whose people settled into
proto-villages by as early as 12,000 BCE, in the late Upper Paleolithic, Levantine foragers
of the Qibiran industry, which was a precursor to Natufian, they likely roamed north into
parts of Anatolia.
Archaeologists note that the Balbashi culture in southwest Anatolia show clear ties to the
Qibiran slash Natufian world.
Its sites were relatively stable base camps, much like Natufian camps in modern Israel,
and they're both exploiting wild cereals along with coastal resources.
Some even argue that the Balbashi-Beldibi groups became the first farmers of that region,
just as these people in the Levant became who we call the Natufians further south.
Obsidian artifacts found at Beldibi, sourced from volcanic areas of eastern Turkey, show
a trade or movement across Anatolia as well.
And this suggests a wide social network.
Coastal foragers were obtaining volcanic glass from hundreds of kilometers away, likely via
exchange with interior groups.
So by around 10,000 BCE, the very end of the Pleistocene, we see a patchwork of regional
cultures in Anatolia, interacting with each other and even far off neighbors.
Some caves like Okuzini and Kerane, near Antalya, show continuous occupation into the early
Holocene, showing a nice clean transition from hunter-gathering to the threshold of
farming.
And so the Anatolian hunter-gatherers did not live in a vacuum.
They absorbed genetic influences from Paleolithic Europeans and Caucasians, and they shared
cultural practices with Levantine peoples, while having trade networks of at least hundreds
of kilometers.
This unique position likely gave them resilience that could draw on a broader pool of ideas
and mates.
And so by the end of the period we're covering in this video, from 20,000 to 10,000 BCE,
you could say that Anatolia's foragers were cosmopolitan, at least in the Stone Age sense,
connected to far-off peoples, influenced by far-off ideas, while of course generating
tons of their own innovations, like microlithic arrows, and the start of cultivating new food
sources.
But the key is that they're still distinct enough to forge their own evolutionary path,
being genetically their own distinct AHG group.
So in summary, zooming all the way back out, around 60,000 years ago, out-of-Africa people
groups are either coming up through the Levant, or across into Arabia and the Middle East,
the Basal-Eurasians, and jumping ahead to 20,000 BCE, the Late Upper Paleolithic, Anatolia
was culminating in new forms of adaptation.
The following millennia, from 15,000 to 10,000 BCE, often termed the Epi-Paleolithic, the
descendants of those hunter-gatherers continued to develop this land.
They built seasonal camps, experimented with cultivating wild plants, and were taming the
first animals at this time.
And one of the most mind-blowing aspects is the genetic continuity.
Early Holocene skeletons, around 9,000 BCE, show that the first farmers of Anatolia were
overwhelmingly descended from the local AHG populations, with only minor inputs from outside
groups.
They even dated skeletons from across an area in Western Anatolia, which shows across the
thousands of years of different skeletons, they're all the same AHG DNA.
Tens of thousands of years of Anatolians.
And I've mentioned in other videos that even with the conquering Turks, the land is
called Turkey, at a cultural level everything from the language to the art, the religion
of Islam, came with this conquering force, but still only a minority of the genetics
of these people are Turkish.
Even today, they're simply described as Anatolian.
It really is incredible that they're staying so genetically similar for so long, while
still undergoing massive cultural transformations.
From living in caves and rock shelters, to building some of the world's first villages,
and having what is at least tied, if not the first domestication of cattle, sheep, and
goats.
And pioneering the cultivation of wheat and barley, kicking off what would become the
There's a ton of stuff I touched on in this video, that I will do a way deeper dive into
in future videos, so subscribe if you don't want to miss that, and please hit that like
button, it really is the best way to help me out.
But thanks for watching, I'll see you in the next one.
