Vinča people (from genetics, writing, tech, etc.)

Ancient Europe: History, culture and Humans
93 followers
9 Video Views·Sep 18, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe video examines the Vinča culture of ancient Serbia (c. 5500–4400 BC), a sophisticated Neolithic society. It highlights their \"proto-urban\" settlements, early independent copper smelting, and complex social structures. The narrative explores their genetic origins from Anatolian migrants and debates whether their symbolic tablets represent the world's earliest writing before their eventual collapse.
11 kilometers, or just under 7 miles downstream from Belgrade, the capital of Serbia, the Danube
River cuts past a low, unremarkable hill called Belo Brdo. White Hill. And this hill is in an
area called Vinca. In 1908, a young Serbian archaeologist named Miloje Vasic started digging
into this hill, expecting to find traces of a modest prehistoric village. But what he found
instead was a 9 meter deep layer cake of continuous human habitation. A stratigraphic
record so dense that it took him decades to fully appreciate what he was looking at.
Beneath the topsoil lay tens of thousands of years of accumulated floors, hearths,
broken pottery, in the remains of a society that was more than 7,000 years old.
And one that was doing things that nobody thought stone age farmers were capable of.
They were smelting metal, building settlements larger than many bronze age cities, and scratching
these mysterious symbols onto clay that some researchers still argue may be the world's
oldest writing. Today we simply call them the Vinca culture. Like most people groups all over
the world, they never left us a name for themselves, so they're just named after the
general area of this hill. The first find of many sites that would be related to this culture,
but they left no king list, no clay archive, and they're not recorded by other people groups.
What we are left with is one of the best mysteries in all of archaeology,
in all of human history. A material record that is so rich that archaeologists have spent more
than a century arguing about whether to call them Europe's first civilization.
And it begs an even deeper question, is the fountainhead of civilization actually in Serbia,
flowing down into the Fertile Crescent, influencing the Sumerians and Egyptians,
whose civilizations would reach their peak thousands of years later?
Well, to understand the Vinca people in their context, you actually have to zoom out even
further. Farming began to emerge in the Fertile Crescent roughly 11,500 years ago, or 9500 BC,
during the transition from the last ice age into the warmer holocene. I have touched on a point
in my Aurignacian video, that you do have what could be seen as very early attempts,
or even accidental starts, toward domestication tens of thousands of years before this. Around
40,000 years ago, in modern France and Germany. But this is more the case of people just choosing
the best crops to eat. If you're looking at a field of a whole bunch of crops, you're going
to be drawn to what us humans dub as the healthiest ones. And so the crops that are the most attractive
to us, are the ones that are eaten the most. And so it's those seeds that keep falling in
their camp, or in landfill areas. Because there are a bunch of surprising finds about Aurignacian
campsites. One is that they were far more organized than a lot of people realize.
And researchers keep finding these landfill areas. These weren't dumb cavemen living in
their own filth. There's evidence that when they set up camp, they had this sort of dumping zone.
And another surprising find was that though these people were not sedentary,
they were traveling tribal bands, there are many cases where it seems like they did return to the
same spots. And that just makes intuitive sense. Even if a group moves with the seasons,
say they move four times a year, like snowbirds going from Canada to Florida,
of course they will develop a routine. They'll find places that they like, and just keep using
those same places over and over again. We shouldn't be surprised to see that there is
repeated occupation of the same prehistoric prime real estate. My favorite example of this
comes from Greece, in the Apodema Cave, where you have what is the oldest known Homo sapiens
fossil in Europe at 210,000 years old, which was found fused in this single rock with what
was dubbed Apodema II, a 170,000 year old Neanderthal skull. You heard that right,
the Neanderthal one is actually younger. It's 40,000 years younger than the 210,000
year old Homo sapiens skull. Without too much of a digression, the sapiens skull here is believed
to be part of one of the failed migrations. While the main out of Africa migration is dated around
70,000 years ago, there were likely countless and continuous excursions out of Africa,
obviously at least 210,000 years ago. Researchers do think Homo sapiens were in Asia and Europe
over 100,000 years before the main out of Africa migration, it's just that those groups died off,
and it doesn't seem like they contributed to the genetics of people today, at least not directly.
There's actually this fascinating detail that we can detect these earliest of groups
in Neanderthal DNA that then went back into later Homo sapiens. That was too cool not to mention,
I have a whole video on that, but let's get back on track. The point is, at these Aurignacian camps,
at these prime real estate sites, you are starting to see natural selection
shaping the evolution of some plant species, but in very minor ways, and I've never seen
any real argument that proper agriculture goes anywhere near that far back. It's just a cool
thing to keep in mind that this isn't so mysterious, there would have been starts
toward domestication on accident, people were just eating the best looking crops,
so the best seeds were deposited in these human-occupied areas, specifically in these
landfills, which anybody that has a home garden knows is going to produce some of the best soils
too. So when people came back to these sites later, you had more of the best crops. Some people
noticed this at some point, and our earliest evidence seems to point to this shift, this
intentional domestication effort really kicking in after the ice age, so around 10,000 BC.
Communities in the Levant and neighboring regions had already become increasingly sedentary,
independent on wild cereals, before people began deliberately cultivating plants like wheat and
barley. You do not need domestication to produce a lot of the things that we think of as being
with advanced civilization. That really is an older, outdated framework, something you could
have even learned at university decades ago, but like I said, this is not really the modern
understanding of this. Plenty of areas were rich enough in wild resources, and especially when
those people are getting close to things like domestication, things like herding, capturing
some animals in pens, from the small fish ponds made at the Jiahu site, to the cattle herders
throughout Africa. Even if that's not domestication, we see that people are actively managing resources
around them. It's the first steps toward altering the very species themselves. As that is the
distinction, wild and domesticated strains of plants and animals become classified as different
species. It's how we can trace back these domestication events. We can see where the oldest
evidence of these species are, and literally see how it radiates out from that point, whether that
be things like wheat, which I have a whole video on how we know the exact wheat strand ended up in
early China, or the cattle species that spread all throughout Africa. Gobekli Tepe belongs near the
beginning of this transformation. Its earliest monumental enclosures date around 9600 BC, when
the people constructing its enormous carved stone pillars were still predominantly hunter-gatherers.
You probably know the story that it's Gobekli Tepe that broke that older paradigm. That, I'm
making air quotes here, rule of archaeology, that domestication led to these kind of advanced sites.
Here you had megalithic architecture with hunter-gatherers. They knew how to get enough
calories out of their environment that it wasn't like some apocalyptic, barely surviving to the
next day kind of situation. But that date of Gobekli Tepe makes it extraordinarily early.
These monuments are 4200 years before the beginning of the Da Vinca culture. By the time
Da Vinca emerged at 5400 BC, Gobekli Tepe would have already been abandoned for 2500 years,
older than the oldest Roman ruins are to us today, about as old as the pyramids were to Caesar.
The connection between these worlds was the long expansion of Neolithic farming tradition.
Agriculture had become firmly established across Anatolia, basically modern-day Turkey,
producing large communities like Çatalhöyük, before farming populations expanded through the
Aegean and into southern Europe around 7000 BC. In the Balkans, these populations and their
descendants developed cultures like the Starčevo-Koroš-Kriš, which formed the background
from which the Da Vinca culture emerged. So you have farming starting in Anatolia around 9000 BC,
7000 BC it moves into the Balkans, and by 5400 BC we're getting Da Vinca.
This puts Da Vinca in a truly fascinating position between the Neolithic revolution
and the first civilizations. They really flourished around 5000 to 4700 BC, so thousands
of years after Gobekli Tepe, but still thousands of years before the Sumerian city-states or
dynastic Egypt. As an American who just celebrated our 250th anniversary as a country, I have to
point out how ominous it is that this civilization was so advanced, but realize that that's really
only a 300-year peak of Vinca cultural production. But again, the beginning is roughly around 5400
BC, more than 2000 years until the appearance of writing in Mesopotamia, and around 2800 years
until the Great Pyramid. Though of course it's not a sharp on-off switch, there's almost never
a sharp start or end of a people or culture, usually. And you do see a relatively straightforward
development process, really you could go back to 6200 BC, when the river valleys of the central
Balkans were the territory of Mesolithic hunter-gatherer fishers, and people whose
settlements at places like Lipinski Vir, in the Danube's Iron Gates Gorge, who produced these
incredible trapezoidal houses and these enigmatic fish-headed stone sculptures. Again, this is far
from the primitive caveman-like subsistence living that people think of with hunter-gatherers.
It wasn't this weird popular conception of them just always starving or something, only able to
think about their next meal. They were advanced in many ways, from architecture to artistic expression,
but they still were not farmers. As farming technology came up from Anatolia, the heartland
of the Neolithic fertile crescent package of wheat, barley, sheep, and goats, and then a bit later the
cattle and pigs, these incoming farmers, ancestors of the Starcevo-Koroš-Kriš, they moved up through
the Aegean and along the Mediterranean and Danube corridors, reaching the central Balkans by around
6200 to 6000 BC. Genetic studies of ancient DNA have confirmed what the pottery styles already
suggested, and isn't it great when all of that neatly lines up? But it shows that these early
Neolithic farmers carried strong Anatolian ancestry, closely related to the population that
also seeded the Linear Banchoromic or LBK culture that swept across central Europe along a separate
route. Potential bias alert and just something that's cool to me, when I was getting into my own
genetics, before I was as deep into this history and genetics stuff, I found it really cool that my
ancestors seemed to have just followed the Danube River. I didn't know what to make of that, and just
it's funny how you just think, yeah I guess that makes sense, you just keep exploring or moving
further along the river. And yeah, as deep and convoluted as a lot of this stuff can get, it's
important to remember some core things like that. People often followed coasts or rivers, and you're
seeing that here with the Neolithic farmers, up into Europe, through the coasts or major rivers.
There's what's dubbed a high-quality genome found at Vinča Belobardo itself, and that genome is VC32,
which dates from around 5616 to 5477 BC, but he belongs to the underlying Starcevo occupation,
which was immediately before the Vinča. But he too carried Y-DNA G2A2A1A3 and mitochondrial DNA
HV, which also places him close to the Neolithic Anatolian or Aegean farmers. To put it simply,
the people who created what we're calling the Vinča culture were largely descendants of migrants
whose ancestors had entered southern Europe from Anatolia, coming into this area about a thousand
years earlier. The indigenous Balkan hunter-gatherers weren't eliminated, but they do
contribute some ancestry, let's say up to 10%, and in some specific locations, like the Iron Gates,
it is around 50-50. And at Lepinský Vír, we actually have genomes that are all over the place,
from mostly native European hunter-gatherer, to a mix, to mostly Anatolian. And that whole picture
makes sense with colonizing. You would have some of the main cities, some of the most advanced
areas, be mostly of the incoming culture, genetics and the material culture lining up there.
And you can imagine different areas of more or less mixing. And there's a very neat paternal
line story underneath this, that G2A is a genome that's uncommon in most of Europe today, but it
was one of the signature male lineages of farmers who carried agriculture from Anatolia into Europe.
The fact that all three Vinča males from Gomulova are G2A fits with all this other
evidence I've laid out already, but it's also part of this larger European story,
that these G2A-heavy Neolithic paternal populations would later be overwhelmingly
replaced by the R1b-R1a step-derived paternal populations, about 2500 years later, around 3000
BC. And so for our Vinča story, around 5500 to 5300 BC, the descendants of the Starcevo farming
communities, which had been established in this region for the better part of a millennium,
they found good soils, had functioning cereal agriculture, spread domesticated livestock,
and began building up these villages or cities, overall this time occupying the same areas,
creating these layers upon layers that become these mounds. I think it's important to remember
that Tepe just means hill. Gobekli Tepe is not the only Tepe, of course. There are tons of these
hills all throughout Anatolia, and our whole story with the Vinča here started with Belo Bordo,
the White Hill. Everything from Jericho to Vinča and Troy, we are seeing what we saw with the
Aurignacian. Prime real estate is prime for a reason, and later people just keep agreeing that
this is the best spot to settle on. And so as Starcevo becomes Vinča, somewhere around 5300 BC,
they will eventually flourish around 4500 to 4400 BC. So even if you could say that they had a
millennia-long run, really it's even worse than I said before, it's a hundred-year cultural peak.
And going through these layers, we see that the transition from Starcevo to Vinča, again, wasn't
a sudden replacement, but just this gradual transformation. Pottery styles shifted gradually
from the Starcevo's coarser, impressed wares towards the finer, dark, burnished, and increasingly
elaborately decorated vessels that would become signature of the Vinča. Their toolkits also show
this continuity, with the same core repertoire of polished stone axes and grinding equipment
carrying across these boundary layers. They are refined instead of being just completely replaced
by different styles. No evidence of some dramatic collapse or pause, no break or loss of tech like
some Bronze Age collapse, it's just this slow refinement over the centuries, even if there are
some noticeable jumps. Because what did change dramatically was the scale and permanence,
as the Vinča communities began building larger, more architecturally regular settlements,
arranged with a level of internal planning that's led some researchers to describe them as
proto-urban. Rectangular, timber-framed houses, with walls inside that were made out of wattle
and daub, wattle being that interwoven stick framework which is filled in by mud, the daub,
and having these thatched or shingled roofs, while the houses themselves were laid out in rows,
separated by open lanes, and sometimes associated with field systems and livestock enclosures on
the settlement's edges. It would be recognizable to us as a village or a small city, while the
economy was mixed with einkorn and emmer wheat, barley and beans, cultivated in these fertile
alluvial soils, the soil right along rivers. Perfect for farming people, and that's why you're
seeing from Mesopotamia, the land between the two rivers, and up along the Danube river in the
It's the same idea. And of course, all of that more easily allows you to raise sheep, goats,
pigs, and cattle, which are used for their meat, milk, and hides, but also, talk about snowballing
your technology here, the cattle plows also help you to make more farms. They're used as beasts of
burden in farming. Now looking at these city layouts, and knowing the genomes of these people,
it's interesting to compare it to Çatalhöyük, which like I mentioned is far older than the Vinca,
one of the largest settlements in Anatolia, occupied around 7100-5950 BC. So it's about
2000 years before the Vinca. Both belong to this pre-urban neolithic world, between the
origins of agriculture, and what are usually thought of as the first true cities of Mesopotamia.
At first, architecturally they are almost opposites, Çatalhöyük was extraordinarily dense,
rectangular mud brick houses that were packed directly against one another,
generally without ordinary streets separating them. Very much like the Pueblo people of the
American Southwest. It's actually amazing how similar they are. There's plenty of room out here,
so why did the Taos build upward? They say the Pueblo was designed for protection. Protection
from your enemies. You see, there weren't originally doors at the ground level. Of course,
we'd have a ladder from the ground up. Then once we got on the roof, we had a hatch.
Like right here? Right here, yeah. We'd come in through the hatch.
So if the enemies come in, you pull up the ladder? You pull up the ladder, and they couldn't get up.
It's why, while of course nothing is one-to-one, but like I stressed with why it's so important
to understand the Aboriginal people of Australia, or the Khoisan of South Africa, so many living
cultures today give us insights on how people would have lived thousands of years ago. People
apparently moved across roofs and entered houses through openings in the roof using ladders.
Individual houses were repeatedly rebuilt in essentially the same locations, creating a
densely accumulated settlement mound. At its largest, Chattahoyuck covered around 13 hectares,
or 32 acres, but despite its size and density, archaeologists generally don't regard it as a
true city, because there's no evidence of a centralized government, obvious palaces,
monumental civic architecture, or the sort of administrative hierarchy associated with later
Mesopotamian urbanism. Now personally, I think that's a silly way to define a city. As if the
elders of Chattahoyuck did not all meet up to discuss shared issues, develop plans to deal
with these issues, I just think this niche archaeologist definition is too hung up on what
is just a difference in government. As if not having a king, or not having an official government
policy, even though you still have an informally agreed upon plan amongst a bunch of the leaders
in the community, I don't get why that's a meaningful difference. I bet you the hunter
gatherers in the region thought of that as a city, the way we think of a city as being different from
the suburbs. The difference back then would have been far more dramatic. I think literally, for all
intents and purposes, this should be considered a city. But the Vinca settlements developed a very
different spatial arrangement. The houses were generally freestanding wood and clay structures,
rather than just being these all connected on top of each other mud brick cells. They would have been
very sturdy, rectangular buildings, with the outer walls and frames being made from wooden posts and
beams. It's only those inner walls that are the wattle and daub. So think of it as halfway between
log cabin and your typical mud hut. Some were divided internally into several different rooms,
with ovens, hearths, storage areas, and working spaces. And with those houses laid out in rows,
with open spaces, what we would think of as streets. And they were enormous by the standards
of the time. I mean just sci-fi, and unlike anything else in the region. Settlements like
Stublina have been investigated through modern magnetometry, and they show hundreds of structures,
all carefully organized into this inhabited space. This, what I'm not supposed to call a city. And
there's even evidence at some settlements for ditches, or these boundary areas, separating
different portions of the community. Almost like different zoning. In zooming out, the geographic
footprint of the culture was also substantial. At its height, the Vinca material culture, those
characteristic black burnished biconical pottery, which just means two cones. Picture two simpler
vessels put together. You can just keep doing that to make these interesting shapes. It goes out,
in, and out again. And of course their distinctive anthropomorphic figurines,
which stretched all across what is now central and southern Serbia, but this was almost certainly
not a single unified state. Nothing suggests central political control across that whole area.
This is not a Vinca kingdom, but it was a remarkably coherent cultural sphere. They're all using the
same technology, they're all doing things the same way. The simplest way we could define culture here,
with these shared craft traditions. We know there was exchange networks between them, and everything
from how to build a house, how to lay out your proto city, how to fire a pot, or shape a figurine,
they did it all the same way. That's why we can call them all part of the Vinca culture.
And they would have had a sense of themselves as being distinct from those who did not do things
their way. We don't know what they called themselves, but they would have seen themselves
as a distinct people group. But before we do this deep dive part into the parts of those cultural
elements, I just really want to stress this final point about the sheer size of these cities.
For decades, popular accounts of the Vinca culture leaned into a mind-boggling claim
that Vinca settlements rivaled or even surpassed the size of early Bronze Age cities in the Aegean
and in the Near East. And while that's been corrected in some areas, it's basically true.
Older estimates of some sites ran as high as 100 hectares, so about 247 acres. Think of a square
measuring 0.62 miles, or 1 kilometer on each side. In modern times, that's comparable to a
substantial suburban neighborhood of roughly 1,000 typical homes in suburban America.
So those were the earlier claims, but then you get your more rigorous magnetometry surveys,
which let archaeologists map buried house foundations across an entire site. Like an
ultrasound for the earth, it's not invasive, you don't have to excavate anything. Some of
the flagship settlements have been reduced to around 25 to 35 hectares, maybe about 300 homes.
Drainovac is around 350 individual structures. Belovod and Plocnik, the two sites most famous
for early metallurgy, are about the same size, 350 structures. The site that started this all,
at Vinca Belo Burdo, is only around 12 to 29 hectares, depending on the phase of occupation.
But we get population estimates ranging from several hundred up to around 2,500 people at
its peak. But some sites were still genuinely enormous by any Neolithic standard, even by
later Bronze Age standards. Turskvina, at the village of Stubline, near modern Belgrade,
occupied around 16.5 hectares, enclosed by double ditches, but actually seems to have
housed a max population of around 4,000 people in the year 4800 BC. The most impressive is at
Divostin, occupied across two phases between around 4900 and 4650 BC, seems to have had over
a thousand houses constructed across the settlement's lifetime, with a population
figure that is several thousand. I would think that gets closer up to nearly 10,000 people.
And the houses themselves average about 616 square feet. But as you would expect,
with more material goods, there was more of a difference between people of that civilization
and their ability to acquire these goods. And so there are many cases of homes that were larger
than a thousand square feet. What's funny is it is more difficult to estimate the height of these
buildings. It's easy to find your main foundation posts, so we know the footprint of a building,
but estimates do think it was around eight feet tall, maybe at the peak of those pitched roofs
being about 15 feet tall. So again, this is kind of shockingly modern. We would be at home
walking through these Vinča sites, through their streets. It's a decent apartment or small-sized
home if you're standard around eight foot ceiling. I just thought it was such a cool detail that
these were laid out in a sort of grid, had streets, and were even the dimensions that
we would be used to today. Though they're probably more crammed than most people are used to.
Researchers think more people lived inside of those 600, 2000 square foot areas than most
people are doing today. You may have had sort of all your family living on one block or
relatively near each other. Researchers reason that there were clusters of around 20 to 50 people,
these extended households or lineage groups all living with each other. And again, like at
Čarohojec, there is a conspicuous telling absence in the archaeological record with no enormous
palaces, nothing like 10x their neighbor, no obviously elite burials loaded with all kinds
of prestigious goods, nothing that seems like administrative buildings. Somehow they were
organized without having to bow down to some king, without the stark levels of inequality
characterized by early cities in Mesopotamia or Egypt. And of course, there are plenty of
people groups alive today that still live like this. We see these forms of decentralization,
this so-called fission-infusion social organization, which is where these extended family
groups could all come together or break apart. We see this with the Bedouin communities of the
Arab world, pastoral people of Africa, indigenous people in the Amazon. There's actually the norm
all over the world to have groups of extended families make up tribes. Sometimes they can
link together with their neighbors, sometimes they break apart. For every reason you can think of,
from trade to specific ceremonies, defense against a larger, more alien neighbor, just that truly
fascinating intuitive understanding of marriage. In my Khoisan video, we talk about how even without
any understanding of genetics, of course, somehow people groups knew that they needed to mix up their
gene pool. People trading wives all across vast distances is a norm across people all over the
world. And they keep coming up, but I think it's best to just look at the Pueblo peoples, because
here is a decentralized social organization that was combined with large permanent and architecturally
sophisticated settlements, which even have the same populations. Hundreds or a few thousands of
inhabitants, without some king or centralized bureaucracy. Just the heads of the family worked
with the elders of the clans and their religious leaders, and they all solved their problems without
all the pomp and oppression and veneration of some king. And they're not some vanished society. They
still exist. Pueblo people like the Hopi, the Zuni, the Acoma, and Taos, they're still alive today,
living with this same sort of tribal government system. Exactly the kind of thing we should expect
was happening at these Vinča sites or in Čadohojik. Now that we understand the sheer scale, I think we
should turn to the one discovery that has done the most to rewrite Vinča's reputation over the past
15 years. It's their metallurgy. And that story centers on these two sites in Serbia. Bilovada,
in the country's east, and Pločnik, further south on the Tuplica river. Excavations here led over many
years by archaeo-metallurgist Miljana Radovojević and colleagues as part of a project called
The Rise of Metallurgy in Eurasia, uncovered copper slag, ore fragments, malachite beads,
and metal droplets in securely dated Vinča period contacts. The results were confirmed
through detailed chemical and microstructural analysis and refined with further excavations
published in a comprehensive 2021 monograph on these two sites, which pushed back the confirmed
date of true copper smelting, which is a qualitative difference in that it's not just
cold hammering of native copper. They're talking about genuine pyrotechnological transformation
of copper ore into metal, making Bilovada's furnaces the earliest secure evidence of
dated to 4900 BC. To put that plainly, people could have been finding raw ore and might use a
rock or hammer to work it into some rough shape, but true metallurgy is creating that molten metal
we think of with a forge, using molds, that kind of thing. It's totally different from just using
a rock to try and shape some natural nugget. This metallurgy would be chemically transformative,
and it allows you to purge imperfections and eventually create alloys, which leads to material
innovations from the Bronze Age up through our Space Age. And so this matters for far more than
just bragging rights. It's long been assumed that metallurgy diffused outward from a single point of
invention somewhere in the Near East, but this Balkan smelting tradition appears to have developed
independently at a location far distant from the traditionally assumed Near Eastern centers.
Showing that even if things like farming may have originated from Anatolia, it's just too
simple of a paradigm to think of all tech flowing out from the Near East. Like we see in a ton of
my other videos, it almost always ends up looking like a complex web of influences. Tech diffuses
from one center, and then new tech flows into that center from another point. Eventually you have many
different points all increasingly influencing each other. This great link between trade and
progress. And this operation wasn't small or secretive. Analysis shows copper mineral selection
at Belovoda and Plochnik followed consistent aesthetic and technical preferences. Miners
specifically favored black and green copper ores, a color coding that researchers argue reflects
deliberate cultural values placed on particular mineral appearances. In other words, they had
certain colors and color combinations that they liked, most likely before this actual smelting
began. That it wasn't driven by some material constraint, like we saw with something like
ochre. All around the world you have some of the earliest peoples using black, white, red,
and yellow, and so you can wonder if there's some sort of connection there. Why is it that aboriginals,
Anatolians, and the Seminoles of Florida all have this same color scheme? Well, to disappoint some
people, it's most likely not part of some lost global civilization. It's just that those are
the four most easy to produce, most common found color pigments, even in these very diverse
environments. But with the venture, they think these color schemes and patterns probably became
a cultural norm before they began this metal work. And so they're looking for ways to use those same
old colors, but in this new medium. And again, it doesn't seem rare, secretive, or with some elite
craft controlled by specialists. Evidence increasingly points to metallurgy as a common
communal activity, seen in many household sites and practiced for generations, as you have consistent
smelting technology tracing across around six centuries of production at all sorts of sites.
Ore was mined at scale from sources like Rudnoglava, one of the earliest known
copper mines in the world. And there's a documented technological link between
pottery firing and metal smelting. It's this same command of controlled, reduced atmosphere
kiln temperatures which produced the venture's signature glossy black pottery. This mastery
seems to have fed directly into the pyrotechnological know-how, which you need to
Once they mastered ceramics, an easier next step was to melt down ore, and to make casts and forge
that in these furnaces. And there's a really interesting end to that story, that at Plochnik,
researchers recovered what they described as a well-contextualized tin-bronze foil,
dated to around 4650 BC, meaning venture metal workers appear to have experimented with
true tin-bronze more than a thousand years before the so-called Bronze Age.
But it didn't stick. This early bronze-making tradition seems to have been short-lived,
an isolated, technical flourish, rather than the start of a sustained bronze industry.
And it's a reminder that technology isn't always a straight line toward the next innovation.
Sometimes these brilliant discoveries are made, they're used briefly, often in some obscure
context, and then for different reasons they just die out. You can't think of it as a tech
tree in some sort of civilization-like video game. And part of this makes sense when you
understand how it was used, and how it wasn't used. The copper produced was mostly used for ornaments,
beads, these small trinkets, items of personal adornment, and probably status display.
There are some functional tools, but this does seem to be the minority. Axes, blades,
and everyday cutting implements throughout the Vinca period continue to be made from chipped
stone, polished stones, out of bones and antler, just the way they had been done for millennia.
Metal entered Vinca life as a material for meaning and display, a bit like the fine ceramics,
it was tied to art, to personal expression, far from displacing stone as the material that was
most turned to for work, for actual practical tools. And this whole story reminds me of the
point of how Rome could have had steam engines, people toyed with the idea of man if they could
have just had an industrial revolution, that they had so many key parts, and understood the science
or principles behind this, but it never got applied to life-changing tech. They had steam-powered
machinery, but it was just like tech demo toys for the rich, not society-changing things like
a steam engine train. And it reminds me of the metalsmiths in the Americas. In South America,
long before Columbus, they developed sophisticated metallurgy with gold, silver, and copper alloys
in different regions in the Andes, and you had the deliberate production of copper arsenic and
copper-tin bronzes. But again, these metals carried enormous ceremonial, political, and aesthetic
importance, but they do not replace the stone tools, not anything to the degree of what we will
see with the Bronze Age, what we think of with Europe and Asia. Even more impressive is that in
sites in Ecuador and Colombia, again before Columbus, they were working with platinum. These
indigenous metal workers learned to incorporate platinum whose melting point is about 1768 degrees
Celsius, or 3214 degrees Fahrenheit, which was actually far beyond the temperatures attainable
in their furnaces. And so to do this, they were sintering tiny platinum particles together with
gold. They use sintering, which is kind of like the process of turning material into a kind of powder,
and so mixing these tiny platinum particles with gold. This allowed you to use the same mold process,
and so they're technically working platinum, getting around the limitations of their own
furnaces, but again it did not lead to any technological revolution. It in no way transformed
agriculture or warfare. It didn't even trigger them to work more with simpler metals. This is what I
mean by you cannot think of it as a straight line, this tech progression being like on a skill tree,
because platinum is one of the hardest metals to work with. These people in the Americas achieved
this far before the rest of the world, but those other parts of the world, like in Eurasia, end up
really developing a culture around bronze, even if they never got anywhere near to working with
platinum. And metal wasn't the only material that the Vinča were altering at a chemical level.
They've recovered cinnabar, which is mercury sulfide used as a red pigment, and apparently
sourced from a mine around 20 kilometers away at Šupca Stena, beneath Mount Avila. Combined with
malachite for green and other mineral pigments, it all shows this well-developed technology around
color. Likely achieved through tons of trial and error and lots of suffering, but it eventually
produced a deep mineralogical knowledge. Cinnabar added a dangerous dimension to Vinča pigment
working, because it is that mercury sulfide. Simply touching intact cinnabar is much less
dangerous than working with elemental mercury, but grinding the mineral into a fine red powder,
which you need for pigment, creates dust that could be inhaled or swallowed.
And heating cinnabar is far more dangerous because it releases toxic mercury-bearing vapors. So while
it was a pretty cool point to see that this metalwork seems to have been diffused across
a whole bunch of households all across these Vinča sites, that also means you had toxic
mercury vapors in tons of households all across the Vinča sites. And you simply can't determine
this mercury poisoning through the human remains evidence that we have, but it's reasonable to
think this affected them somehow. Of course you don't need a chemical understanding to still
experience the effects to infer or suspect that some of these illnesses seem to be connected to
the grinding or heating of this red mineral. You don't have to know why to suspect something here.
So the simplest is maybe they just did this particular cinnabar work not inside of the
household. Just because they did other work in the house doesn't mean they did all work in the house.
But a really interesting idea is that simple face coverings could have been used.
The researchers think they were mostly just grinding the cinnabar down, which was far
less dangerous than melting it down. The dust is less dangerous than the vapors,
but either of these might have still included some sort of protective equipment. And it's
kind of interesting when you look at it more broadly that there does seem to be this sort of
vibe with different cultures. What comes most to mind is the physically deformed Greek god of
metalwork Hephaestus. Some theories have wondered about the occupational poisoning as sort of
influencing this archetypal metalworker. And that the masked figures of the Vinca may have been
smiths. And that simple face coverings or even just nose and mouth coverings, anybody that's
worked any level of construction, even just pouring a bag of concrete, and actually even
just gardening, I have myself have just took on my shirt and tied it around my face, around
my nose and mouth. I understand that culturally we know way more about these dangers, but I still
think it's intuitive that you just wouldn't want to get this in your nose and mouth. I mean people
wear face coverings in all sorts of primitive cultures all over the world. Think of the Bedouin
covering themselves up from sand. You don't think people grinding down stones, and those using stone
tools to mine this stuff out in the first place, that they didn't sometimes just put a piece of
Eventually this could have been stylized, and maybe even could have taken on a supernatural
aspect. As like the old Arthur C. Clarke quote goes, any sufficiently advanced technology is
indistinguishable from magic. The real magicians of the gods were these actual sages. These
bringers of real technology, who like fishing tales, they kind of get glorified, embellished,
deified even in these cultures over time. But these were the bringers of real technology,
from the animals to plant domestication, ship builders, architects, and material engineers.
They must have been seen as magic-like, as like the gods, to primitive hunter-gatherer people
that they encountered. If you think that's a weird stretch, I don't know how to help you.
There are cargo cults today. We're not making some weird woo-woo or Atlantean point here,
it's just that with a supernatural mindset, I have a hard time thinking that the people who
weren't able to wield this high-tech stuff, like metalworking or megalithic architecture,
that they wouldn't see this as somehow magical. I'll stress that the peer-reviewed sources do
not make much of these masks on these figurines. And of course, as cool as the idea is, you gotta
be honest and see that there are masked figures and cultures all over the world. But it's not
this is a completely rejected or preposterous claim. There are Vinča figurines directly
associated with metallurgy. Rodoljević and Roberts' peer-reviewed 2021 review,
Early Balkan Metallurgy, Origins, Evolution, and Society, 6200-3700 BC, discusses this
really remarkable assemblage from Stublina. 43 clay figurines, accompanied by 11 miniature
implements, objects often associated with copper mining, and metallurgical tools. The authors
entertain the possibility that the assemblages represent a community or cooperative of people
engaged in mining and metallurgy. So while this is more about the figures, not specifically the
protective face equipment, to me it just seems natural to think that they would protect themselves
somehow from either the mining dust, the grinding dust, or just the sheer heat and fumes of these
furnaces. And that what started as a practical thing could have been seen by those not involved
in this work as a sort of garb, a costume. Like the garments of a priest, it's what set this class
apart. And I think the conceptualization of that, in the average person's mind,
wouldn't be that much different from a shaman's wardrobe. They're both working with different
types of tech slash magic. And just last point to make on this, it's interesting to think about,
is a madness point that you have with the 19th and early 20th century hat makers working with
mercuric nitrate, that they developed occupational mercury poisoning, which produced tremors, it gave
them slurred speech, it had emotional and behavioral impacts from irritability to depression,
strangely specific pathological shyness, broadly dubbed the mad hatter syndrome.
You've heard of the mad hatter, it comes from actual hat makers that were going mad,
they were going insane because of the chemical from their trade. We have much later prehistoric
evidence from the Copper Age site in Valencia, Spain, that does show mercury exposure among
people using cinnabar, showing that prehistoric mineral working really could expose communities
to physiologically and thus psychologically significant quantities of mercury. Again,
we don't have proof of that in the physical remains of people at Vinca, but it's because
of the physical limitations of these samples. In these later but very similar sites in Spain,
we do have evidence of this, and we have this modern case of this madness being specific to
this occupation. So to my point of your average people of 5000 BC, especially neighboring people,
who are looking at this genuine sci-fi thing called metallurgy, I think it's just such a
cool idea to think that they could have been viewed as a type of shaman. Maybe literally
with some of the typical madness and strange costumes that you associate with a shaman,
could have been seen as surprisingly similar with these metal workers. And now before moving on to
the writing, I do want to pause and just appreciate the pottery itself, it's often overlooked,
but this signature glossy black burnished ware, this isn't an accident, it requires very specific
controlled reducing or low oxygen atmosphere at very specific temperatures, the technique that
produces the characteristic sheen through a chemical reaction involving iron oxide,
acting as a fluxing agent in the clay. Somewhat similar to that platinum gold mix,
the idea is that these fluxing agents allow you to lower the melting point of glass forming silica.
Gives you that glossy look and feel of glass without needing to be as hot. And the fact that
this was produced consistently across hundreds of settlements over centuries, again implies a sense
of a coherent culture here with those that could transmit this specialized craft knowledge. Kilns
built and rebuilt to a known design, firing schedules understood well enough to reproduce
reliably and all of the same basic style. And again it's this ceramic mastery that allowed that
next step of metalwork. But of course, no aspect of vinticulture has generated more popular
fascination or more slightly frustrating academic caution than its many figurines and their incised
symbols. Their settlements have yielded thousands of clay figurines of these very stylized human
forms, often with these elaborate shapes and these masks, exaggerated hip and shoulder lines,
and these odd alien looking heads with slits or almond eyes. I don't think they're aliens,
but I'll use more words to just come back to maybe it is aliens. Because once I saw somebody
point out that maybe these look like mantis heads, I can't ignore the point I made in the Khoisan
and other African religion videos, that while most places around the world have a bird
associated with fire, mantis gods are actually the tech and fire bringers of many African peoples.
And we see odd mantis representations in religious contexts throughout the Middle East,
even in the Americas. I'm not really sold on this, but maybe even with Da Vinca.
And I've argued in those videos that maybe this is just because this was a cultural aspect
of the out-of-Africa migration groups. If this was a common belief throughout East and Southern
Africa, and those are where the people migrated out of, then that could explain why this is such
an odd but well-spread trope. I think it's interesting, and there are definitely examples
where it is clearly a mantis in different artwork with tons of different people groups.
I think with Da Vinca, we are just looking more at something like costumes. They could just be
fun toys. Imagine the hoopla people would make about all our action figures and superheroes
that archaeologists found that we have over the past century. It could have been little household
gods or figures, ancestors, stuff like that. Of course, we'll never know, but to this shared
culture point, we find their use across eight centuries and in this territory which today
spans many countries. Whatever they were, the Vinca people loved them.
And finally, we're getting to the Vinca symbols. Sometimes they're called the Danube script
or Old European script, with several hundred distinct recurring signs with these crosses,
chevrons, combs, meanders, or swastikas, and many complex composite forms,
some even appearing in short repeated sequences that kind of at first take do look like writing.
The most famous and most debated are the three Tartaria tablets, these small clay pieces
discovered in 1961 near the village of Tartaria in Transylvania. If the earliest proposed dates
for the site are correct, at around 5300 BC, these would predate Sumerian proto-Cuneiform,
which is usually regarded as the world's oldest writing system. It would predate that by a
thousand years. You've heard extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence,
but this one just has an extraordinary problem. The tablets themselves cannot be directly
radiocarbon dated. Originally, they were unbaked clay. It would have been perfect,
but to preserve them, a conservation team fired them for preservation, and so this destroyed that
radiocarbon option. So you try to take radiocarbon samples from the disturbed strata nearby,
right around where this thing was found, but the exact stratigraphic context of this original find
has been disputed. A few feet difference takes us from headlines to just expected, and some
researchers even argue that the tablets might be an intrusion from later layers, and so that would
be even less impressive. But broadly, when you take all these symbols over the whole Vinča area,
most researchers agree it's a really interesting phenomena of proto-writing. Mainstream archaeology
might debate some nuanced points, but they do think that the Vinča were using these symbols
to convey ownership, tally goods, signal their status, and are favorite used in ritual contexts.
And I do have a whole separate video already scripted out for comparing an issue with the
Vinča to a lot of the points made with Jiahu and modern Chinese languages in general,
to say that true writing is defined as encoding sounds. But for these Vinča symbols specifically,
the main issue can just be described as there aren't enough of them in combination. One of the
examples I have in this coming video is that imagine if you found a thousand different Chinese
characters, but you never actually found long sequences of Chinese writing. That's kind of the
issue here. At first, you think that's ridiculous not to think of this as writing. Look at how many
units there are. Look at how many symbols. How could this not represent all sorts of complex
ideas? But one, how do you get around just proving that they're just personal symbols?
Trademarks have been around maybe as long as trade, but there could be family clan signs,
symbols that were unique to one region but not another. And there simply aren't enough examples
where we get tons of different sentences that researchers can then find patterns with. Even
if no one spoke Chinese today, we'd be able to figure out a ton of the rules of the Chinese
language. Even if we had no clue what sounds these symbols make, and even if the same symbol
would evoke different sounds, different words, the different Asian languages, even then we could tell
that this was connected to a spoken language if, it's really crucial, if you had enough material
to work with. The researchers, of course, are never confirming some negative here. They're
not saying it is not writing, that it couldn't be writing, but just there is not enough evidence for
that. That you can even have what look like relatively complex ledgers, ways of tracking
trade from one person to another, that doesn't have to be connected to any spoken sounds. You
can have symbols that say, I gave five wheat to you. And I, of course, agree that we should stress
that that shows a more complex mental space than a lot of people attribute to some of our ancestors,
to people thousands upon thousands of years ago, to these prehistoric people. But it doesn't prove
that they would have spoken these symbols out loud, or that it was in any way connected to a
spoken language. The most defensible current position is that the Tartaria tablets, plausibly
Neolithic and culturally Vinca, cannot tell how proto they are. We're not even sure on the dating,
and there's no reason to think that this is more than proto-writing at most. And I have to do a
whole video on the hypothesized old Europe civilization, which some people think Vinca is
a great example of, and they speculate that it must have been far more broad than this Vinca area
I've been showing. Usually it's defined as being peaceful, goddess-centered, and matriarchal. And
it originates largely with the mid-20th century archaeologist Maria Gambutas. And this fit into
a broader claim of a sort of pan-Balkan script, which is now regarded by most archaeologists to
be quite a stretch. And I'm not sure the best comparison here to make with that idea. I guess
something like the idea of China. We know what area we're talking about, even though people want
to point out how diverse these different people groups are all across the area of modern China.
It is fascinating how many aspects of their day-to-day life, from artistic expression to
their writing, or further back their proto-writing, there's a lot of things that these people all had
in common that we don't see anywhere else in the world. There is some sense of shared culture
across this vast area. While the most up-to-date research on the Vinca does not think that they're
a good look at this sort of pan-European culture, or this old European script, that claim has proven
to be a bit of a stretch. But they do keep finding more and more evidence of these really vast
trade networks. You've seen in my other videos how things like obsidian and these spondylus
shell ornaments go back for literally hundreds of thousands of years. It's just a human thing.
And while most researchers think this was just with Homo sapiens, I wouldn't be surprised if
evidence comes out that extends that to Neanderthals as well, as we do know that they were sourcing
things, like obsidian, from over 300 kilometers away. And like we saw with that proto-Silk Road
map that goes back to 8000 BC, showing goods going all the way from this Balkans area all the way to
East China, they're not arguing a single trader was making these vast distances, but just by trading
with your immediate neighbor, and they do that, and so on, eventually things spread out far more
than we ever realized. And so technological advances, and more abstract advances like
proto-writing, would have affected a far greater area than just these red outlines of Vinca
territory, and they would have been affected by far-off people groups as well. With trade,
you will influence others, and be influenced by others. I don't want to make too much of that
point though, because like you see with plenty of people groups around all over the world today,
just because you're in contact with some civilization which has some technology that
you don't have, it's not like there's some automatic diffusion that happens. It's crazy
how much can just stay in the realm of novelty. Nomadic people could see a city in Çatalhöyük,
or in the Vinca lands, even see how they use things like proto-writing, and think it's interesting,
but still just go about their life the way all their ancestors had for thousands upon thousands
of years. Because again, there is no positive evidence that can prove that the Vinca had some
major impact on other European peoples, or even the things where they were particularly advanced
on, like metallurgy, it doesn't seem like they sparked metallurgy in Mesopotamia. And so now
let's turn to the closing here, the closing of the Vinca people. What happened to them? Why did
they disappear? Around 4400 BC, all those recognizable hallmarks of Vinca material culture,
from the black burnished pottery, these unique figurines, and these large settlements, they just
stop appearing in the archaeological record. You know something is uncontested when nobody's really
arguing against it. The dates are well established through radiocarbon chronology. From the minimalist
to maximalist of the Vinca people's impact, they all agree that it seems to stop around 4400 BC.
And like we've seen in so many other stories, let's just do the first one, which is climate
and environmental stress. There's evidence for a broader climate change in the southern Europe
regions, documented around 4200 BC, linked to a cooling event known as the Peora Oscillation.
Changes in rain and temperature patterns might have caused the collapse of cereal agriculture.
That has cascading effects across all of your domesticated animals, and of course your people.
This could have compounded issues that they might have already been seeing with soil erosion and
nutrient drainage from farming the same fields for eight centuries. Some think it may have been
something more simple, like just resource depletion, clearing too many forests to make
those nice sturdy houses. In the easiest to mine copper ore, eventually all the best sites were
just drained. And you could see a bit of evidence in support of this, coming from the relatively
nearby people of the Salcuza and Gumelnica, who are about 250 miles away from Belo Burdo.
They do continue farming, have metallurgy, and similar settlements, but they're a lot smaller,
and far more spread out. The most dramatic explanation floated for the Vinci's end.
In the broader collapse of what was dubbed Old Europe, across this entire Balkan-Carpathian
region, as it seems like something happened around 4000 BC, they looked to the population
movements out of the Pontic-Caspian steppe. The world associated with the early Indo-European
pastoralist groups, sometimes called the Kurgan cultures, and later the most famous,
would be the Yamnaya. We know that a thousand years later, for sure, they are going to be
changing Europe. That's why I included that audio from the Pueblo, where he's explaining
that the layout of these buildings, which were similar to Çatalhöyük, was so that you could
hide from attackers, who were the most likely culprits to be sending these raids. Of course,
everybody is going to have very local problems. It just popped in my mind when we're dealing with
this boogeyman from the steppe, the famous raiders that would be affecting both of these groups.
Again, of course the Yamnaya aren't the only raiding people, and the evidence we're absolutely
sure of is all around 3500 BC, but these people, and into Mesopotamia, all use the exact same type
of swastika pattern. When we know about the broader trade networks, obviously these people
were somehow in contact with each other. We can't say that the Yamnaya destroyed the Vinci,
we can't say for sure anybody did, that it wasn't just something far more dramatic.
Again, it could just have been environmental change, or just these cities collapsing under
their own weight. They couldn't support as many people in one spot, and so they just fractured,
just like these tribal people do all the time. Remember, they had no centralized king,
this would have been a far more natural thing to do. But I just want to stress that they were
in contact with steppe people, even if indirectly, and those sorts of raiding people are exactly who
you would expect to swoop in when your civilization is at its peak. It's the most
made joke about the steppe people, whether they're raiding China, or Mesopotamia, or Anatolia,
or Europe. Let's end there, please leave comments down for things you want me to dive into even
further. This will of course not be the only video on the Vinci, almost every section of this could
be its own hour long or more video. There's tons of stuff here, and I really do use your guys
comments to influence what videos come next. Please hit that like button if you made it this
far, it really does help out, and I'll see you in the next one.
