Why Nobody Can Fix Britain

Finance & Beyond
21 followers
Why Nobody Can Fix Britain.
This is the story of how Britain became broken, and why kicking out Keir Starmer won't fix it.
00:00 - Intro
01:39 - A Prime Minister on the Edge
03:11 - The Lost Decade(s)
07:56 - Splinter Effect
#MoneyMindset #FinancialWisdom #EconomicsExplained
AI Generated·May contain errors
July 4th, 2024. Election night in the United Kingdom. After 14 years of conservative rule,
Britain had had enough. A record number of voters turned out to throw the Tories
out of Downing Street. The result? Keir Starmer's Labour Party wins a landslide.
411 seats. The biggest Labour majority since 1997. Starmer had one simple message. Change.
Change begins now. A Britain that works for everyone, not just the rich.
Brits across the country were cautiously hopeful. They believed Labour would fix healthcare,
bring down the cost of housing, and finally get the economy moving after a lost decade.
But fast forward to today, and that hope is gone. UK public debt has climbed to 95.6% of GDP,
a level not seen since the early 1960s. Britain is projected to grow at the second slowest rate
in the G7, at just 0.7%. More than 7.2 million people are stuck on NHS waiting lists. And Keir
Starmer is now the third most unpopular leader in the democratic world, with a net favorability of
minus 47. In May, the country goes to the polls and local elections that could seal his fate,
and pave the way for Britain's sixth prime minister in seven years. We'll be looking
at where it all went wrong, and whether the new forces rising on the left and the right
offer Britain a way out, or a deeper hole to fall into. I'm Cam for 2 in 20,
and this is Great Britain, the road to nowhere. Before Starmer, the UK had gone through five
different prime ministers between the Brexit vote and the last election in July 2024.
So surely, after the chaos of the Brexit years, things must be better, right? Nope. 67% of the
UK population disapproves of the Starmer government. This is because of a series of
broken promises. He said repeatedly that he wouldn't raise taxes on working people,
but taxes on wages increased at the highest rate in the rich world last year. He said he'd deal
with the UK's chronically unaffordable housing by building 1.5 million new homes, or around 300,000
per year. But last year, new home approvals hit a record low, falling 7% on the previous year to
only 221,000. That is well short of that 300,000 per year target. He said he'd stop illegal migration
across the English Channel. But since he's been in office, 70,000 migrants have entered the UK
on small boats. That is a 13% increase from the year before. Meanwhile, his administration has
become mired in the kinds of scandals he promised to stamp out. For instance, his deputy PM, Angela
Rayner, was caught in an attack scandal and forced to step down. And worse yet, the ambassador to
Washington, good old Peter Mendelsohn, was sacked after it emerged that he was best friends with
Jeffrey Epstein. There are dozens of other examples, but the painting doesn't change.
Okay, let's give him a break though. The UK's problems didn't just start with him.
To put it simply, the country has two problems. Terrible growth, and debt that just keeps piling
up. Neither is new, but both are getting worse. And by the way, if you want to learn more about
the deep imbalances in the UK economy going all the way back to the Thatcher era, we'll link in
Alright, so Stormer got a bad inheritance. A country that has basically been in a slow-motion
economic car crash for the last 18 years. The UK's problems go back all the way to 2008,
where the country's economy was knocked off because of the global financial crisis.
And the sad thing is, its economic growth trajectory has never really recovered since.
If you want to see one chart that really captures just how bad the situation is,
it's this one from the UK Fiscal Watchdog. What it's saying, in really simple terms,
is that if UK growth had continued along the same trajectory it was on before the financial crisis,
the average real income in Britain would be around £52,500 per year, around 31% higher
than it is today. Like that is such a shocking statistic. But how did it get so bad? Well,
the root of the problem is that UK productivity growth collapsed after the 2008 crisis and never
recovered. UK workers have consistently had less capital or stuff. What I mean by this is
computers, machines, chat GPT subscriptions, you name it. It all helps them to do their work and
they've just had less of it. And what that means is they produce less. Moreover, UK employees are
working 4.1% more hours in 2024 than 2019, but only producing 3.6% more output. Meaning they
are working harder, but producing less per hour than before. The main reason for this is the UK
barely invests in itself. Even before the GFC, capital spending was far below peers. And there
are two big policy failures behind it. Austerity and good old Brexit. Let's break it down.
So after the 2008 crisis, the government, then led by David Cameron and Chancellor George Osborne,
chose to aggressively cut back government spending on public services and investment
in a bid to try and reduce the fiscal deficit. This hugely controversial policy was called
austerity and it meant less spending on physical infrastructure, less spending on human skills,
less spending on R&D to help the economy expand and modernize. For example, the IFS calculates
that the government department for business, innovation and skills saw its budget fall by
around 18% in real terms between 2010 and 2015. But in 2016, it got even worse. The UK voted to
leave the European Union. This was a disaster for the UK economy, creating a regulatory and
policy black box that some economists believe reduced productivity by 3 to 4% by 2025 and
overall GDP per capita by 6 to 8%. Now, many of you might be saying that maybe austerity may not
be so bad if it succeeded in bringing government borrowing back under control. And for a few years
it did. Well, sort of. But these savings were wiped out almost immediately by the twin storm
of the pandemic and then the energy price spike following the war in Ukraine, both of which forced
a massive increase in government spending. And the proof is in the pudding. The country remains
saddled by high public debt and a massive interest burden. The UK debt to GDP ratio is far above the
advanced economy average. It's so bad that interest payments on this debt were around 8.2% of
government revenue last year. And we can't forget to mention that the country has the highest
borrowing costs of any rich OECD nation. To put it real simply, the UK has ended up with the worst
of both worlds. Let me recap. The conservatives crushed the economy's future to try and save money
and ended up blowing all that cash on COVID stimulus and energy subsidies anyway. This all
happened well before Starmer even got into politics. But the result of it is that Starmer
is in a bind. To fix the UK's dire public services, he needs to fix the economy. And to fix the economy,
he needs to invest and spend more, but he can't because the government is already up to its neck
in debt. The truth is turning all this around will take years, maybe decades. But today it looks like
Starmer could only have weeks. Real quick, so you know how I said the NHS waiting list is 7.3
million people long? Well, the subscribe button for Toon20 has zero wait time, so if you've enjoyed
the video so far, don't forget to subscribe. Seriously, it really helps the channel. Now back
to the video. Okay, you might be saying, Cam, it's super easy to identify what's wrong with the UK
and very easy to talk in the abstract about potential solutions. But here's the thing,
to actually execute that, you need a clear political vision to drive it through.
The UK has the exact opposite. It is so polarized, so politically fragmented. Listen to this,
the share of people who believe the country is divided by culture wars has surged from 46% in
2020 to 67% in 2025. What was once a relatively predictable two-party system, basically between
two large, relatively moderate parties, has given way to two new forces on both sides of the
spectrum. Let's visualize this. Okay, so we all know about the Tories and Labour, like they're
centre-left and centre-right. There's also the Lib Dems in the pro-European centre, but they've
fallen a long way back in the polling. On the right, you have Nigel Farage's reform, which is
basically a reconstituted version of the UKIP party he used to win the Brexit referendum.
They've basically eaten away at support for both the Tories and Labour on issues like the economy
and immigration. And these guys have managed to bring over a bunch of former Conservative cabinet
ministers. And on the left, you have the Greens, who have surged in popularity under the leadership
of Zak Polanski. They've also been eating away at Labour's young urban base. The next general
election is still at least a couple of years away, so we don't have the detailed economic policy
manifestos to scrutinize. But what we can say is that if there was a general election,
no party would likely win a majority. That is very, very clear. If we look at aggregated UK
opinion polls, the most likely outcome is actually a reformed minority government at 42% likelihood,
followed by a Labour minority government at 16%. Put together, only 17% of scenarios would yield
a majority government. And that matters, firstly, because a divided coalition government will find
it much, much harder to push through a decisive economic policy agenda. And secondly, because
whatever coalition forms is likely to include one of the newer parties on the right or left,
like reform or the Greens. And let me stress again, we don't have the detailed manifestos
from the opposition parties, but there are strong grounds to question their economic credibility.
Let's take Reform, whose low-tax, anti-regulation platform resembles Liz Truss's disastrous failed
Singapore on Thames experiment. They are likely to be the senior partner in any future right-wing
coalition government. In 2024, they propose £90 billion in tax cuts that they believe will be
funded by reductions in spending on the Green transition and reductions in wasteful government
spending. That is double the £45 billion in unfunded tax cuts that spectacularly blew up
Truss Premiership. And it looks highly unlikely that they would be able to recover that amount
by spending less. They've also said that they'll save £30 billion per year by cutting an investment
in net zero, but the OBR actually forecasts that net zero investment will average only one-third
of that between now and 2050. And at the same time, they've said that they'll save £50 billion per
year through doge-inspired cuts to waste in government spending. But like, listen, even we
don't like wasteful spending. We even made a video about doge and one and a half years later,
doge's impact was minimal. Unfortunately, government waste is just a business. Additionally,
the Institute for Fiscal Studies puts that real number closer to £20 billion per year. That is
less than half what's being claimed. To put it simply, you're looking at a massive black hole
in the public finances that will need to be funded by more borrowing. And don't think we're not going
to talk about the left. You could probably see some kind of coalition agreement between Labour
and the Greens. And they've come up with a number of controversial ideas, such as wealth tax and
sharp increases in tax on higher earners. Let's break it down. So in their 2024 manifesto, they
pledged to raise overall taxes by a whopping £170 billion per year and spending by £160 billion.
That, if actually achieved, would be a massive 15% increase in the overall tax burden on the
country. And this doesn't just threaten to crush investment and chase higher earners overseas.
It's also just really hard to actually implement. For example, they said that they would raise £90
billion of their £170 billion from a carbon tax on emissions. But the IFS says this is pretty
doubtful, in large part because taxing carbon emissions so heavily would lead firms to emit
less and therefore ultimately pay less in tax. So again, like reform, you're likely looking at
a potentially substantial increase in government borrowing to pay for all these lavish spending
commitments. Except this time, you're also taxing wealth generation into the ground.
But the bigger issue is that it appears they don't understand Economics 101. In an interview
with podcasters Rory Stewart and Alastair Campbell, the Green leader, Zach Polanski,
couldn't clearly differentiate the deficit and the total government debt. That is super basic
stuff that someone in that position should 100% understand. The Greens have even flirted with
modern monetary theory, the idea that the central bank can simply print money to finance government
spending. Okay, this is actually hard to overstate just how crazy this is. Half the reason
Argentina got itself into such a mess is that the central bank in Buenos Aires used to print money
to fund the government spending, leading to runaway inflation and a collapse in the value of
the peso. Okay, who here thinks that the UK should really look to Venezuela or Argentina or even the
Weimar Republic as an economic role model? No one? Okay. The bigger point here is that the UK's
political system is getting more fractured, more siloed, and more divided. What the country needs
is steady, sober economic policymaking, but it's heading firmly on the path toward political and
economic gridlock. The UK's set of problems is clear. Years of underinvestment has killed
productivity growth, and that leads to a stalling economy that makes it very hard for the government
to bring down debt or fix the country's terrible public services. You also got the two main parties
who are on the rocks, and smaller, less experienced, and more radical parties on the ascent.
Starmer faces catastrophic local election results that threaten to end his premiership as his own
Labour MPs turn on him. But for all of his flaws, this won't solve the problem. The UK's economic
misery is not because of any one leader or any single decision. It's the result of a series of
long-term mistakes that the country's political system is too unstable, too divided, and too
focused on culture war issues to correct. Kicking out Keir Starmer will not change that. It is in
fact a symptom of it. So as Starmer's government braces for a brutal set of results, his supporters
and opponents alike should remember one thing. That change isn't always for the better.
Thank you for watching. Go check out our Discord community. It's in the description.
We actually talk and hang out in there. See you next time.
