Alain Aspect Nobel Prize in Physics 2022 Official interview

Scientists won the Nobel Prize
12 followers
May 14, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Where does your passion for science come from?
Oh, when I was a kid I lived in a small village in France and at that time it was very rural
so there were not so many technical objects but I was fascinated by any tool from the carpenter,
for people like that and I don't know why but I was really always fascinated by
technical objects and then I was a reader of Jules Verne. Jules Verne is an inspiration
or more it was confirming what we were learning. You remember it was in the 50s and the 60s,
it was after the war and there was the idea of progress and there is one book of Jules Verne,
L'Ile Mystérieuse, The Mysterious Island, where engineers and scientists arrive on an isolated
island and because they have the knowledge of science and technology they will be able to
develop a comfortable civilization so that was a belief that science is good for humankind.
Are you still a reader?
Oh yes, sometimes, you know, for the pleasure I go into one of these old books.
What made you decide to pursue science?
I think really since elementary school I was attracted towards scientific between-code things
because at elementary school it's very simple but anyway anytime the teacher was doing a little
experiment between code I was always interested by that and then I went to high school and it
turned out that at that time for four years in high school there was math and natural science,
biology, but there was nothing about physics and chemistry for four years and I felt frustrated.
I was waiting for the moment when I would learn physics and chemistry so I think I was always
fascinated by it and what happened is then in the last year of high school I had a fantastic
teacher at high school who really determined my life because he taught me what is the approach
of physics that is to say a blend between pragmatism but also solid mathematical model
and at each time finding the simplest possible model but anyway it must be sophisticated enough
to render an account of the phenomena and this is really a high school teacher who taught me that.
When did you know you wanted to pursue quantum mechanics?
Well I smiled because the story is interesting.
I had excellent studies, excellent courses at university except for quantum physics.
Seeing it from now clearly it was a very bad teaching. The professor did not understand
what was really quantum physics and so I had that frustration. I knew that it was important
and I knew that I did not know it well and what happened is that while I was in Africa,
in Cameroon for military service, I was teaching rather than going to the army,
I had the opportunity to buy a book by Claude Cohen-Tannoudji, Nobel laureate in 1997,
Bernard Lieu and Frank Halloway and I learned quantum physics into that book and then I
understood what it was about and when I came back to France and found the paper by John Bell,
which determines our experiments, I was ready to appreciate the paper by John Bell.
What does it take to proceed in science without support from others?
You know when you are teaching it's a different world. So for me the week was
cut in two parts. There was the part dedicated to building that experiment and making tests
and progressing in the development of the experiment that I was doing and on the other hand
there was a teaching and teaching is very rewarding because if you feel that the students
understand what you are explaining, that they are making progress, really it makes you happy.
So in fact I think the fact that I was teaching was crucial for me. Well teachers is very important,
I mean the fact that we have a future scientist depends on teacher and elementary school teacher,
high school teachers. What advice would you give to a student interested in science?
Well more generally my advice would be follow your taste. Don't listen to fashion because maybe
nowadays I tell you that this is a fashionable subject but five years from now it will be
another one. So I think you should really work in what you are interested in. It may be basic science,
it may be technology, it must be application, it just depends on the person. Each person is
able to know exactly what is his or her passion and this is what they should follow.
How do you like to spend your free time?
Well what can I say? It depends on the moment in my life. When I was younger I was spending
a lot of time in sport, hiking, playing tennis etc. When you get old you are not as fitted for
doing so much sport. So what do I do? Cooking, I like cooking. I also like rehearsing for magic
tricks. Since I got mandatory retirement I thought I had some free time and I started learning to do
magic with cards. I'm not an excellent magician but anyway I know some classical tricks.
But when I do these tricks, rather than saying the usual words of a magician, I pretend that it
is quantum. So when a card jumps from here to my hand I say oh this is a quantum tunneling effect.
So I spend some time doing that and of course spending time with the family,
my wife, grandchildren, my children.
Are there any similarities between quantum physics and magic tricks?
Not at all. Because magic tricks, really if you want to do well a magic trick, it has to become
automatic, like riding a bicycle. And then your fingers work independently of you. And then you
can think about a speech which has nothing to do with what you are doing. So you can pretend that
it is quantum physics because your fingers work without thinking of them. So it's certainly not
like an experiment because in an experiment each time you turn a knob you have to think
about what you are doing and observe and react. What environments help with creativity?
I need to have apparatus and knobs to turn. And so, for instance, when I cook there is something
which is very special, love parfait, perfect egg. It has to be cooked at 64 degrees Celsius,
not 62, not 66. So I like to have a thermometer and to tune the heating etc.
Probably it reminds me of doing an experiment. Adjusting everything in real time, observing,
reacting, tuning. Can you tell us about the object that you're donating to the Nobel Prize Museum?
The original thing in my experiment is the fact that the experiment is about two photons
traveling to detectors. And the idea is to change the setting of the detector
while the photons are traveling. And this takes only one or two dozens of nanoseconds,
so it has to be very fast and you cannot rotate an object in a few nanoseconds. So my idea
was to have a switch and the switch would send the light either towards the first apparatus
or towards a second apparatus. And if the switch was fast enough it would be equivalent to a single
apparatus rotating from one position to the other one etc. And this was my initial idea. I had
published it from the beginning and a company had promised to deliver the switch. In fact,
the switch was my idea. It was based on the interaction of light with an acoustic standing
wave. And a company had promised to deliver it. But I wanted it big enough and after some time
the company said we cannot deliver it because it's so big we cannot make it, it's too big.
And the reason was that when they were sticking a transducer on a crystal it has to be done at
high temperature and then because the relation is different between the material it was breaking all
the time. So the problem was a contact between the material and the transducer. And I was despaired
because I needed that. And I began to think and when you are despaired you become creative.
And suddenly I realized that I did not need a crystal. Water turns out to be a good material
for that. And now if I have transducers in water no problem of different dilatation. There will
be no breaking. So we built homemade and the object I come is really homemade. I mean it's
like you know I don't know how you say in French a bricolage. You know it's one thing which is not
a nice object. But it worked. What about the future of quantum mechanics excites you?
Well in fact what is exciting in the last say decade or decades is the fact that some smart
people discovered that entanglement can be used for applications. And there's a whole world of
quantum technologies. And the idea that maybe we have a quantum computer or a quantum simulator
which is able to solve problems that we don't know how to solve with our usual computers. I think
this is very exciting because you know when you have been working in fundamental science and
suddenly somebody comes and says you know you pair of entangled photons can be useful for something.
I like this idea. OK. And so this idea of a quantum computer I think that they can be fantastic. We
have problems of optimization for instance. You know now we have wind electricity, solar electricity
and the equilibration of the electric grid. It's a very complicated problem. It's so complicated
that you cannot find a solution with a standard computer because it's called a difficult problem,
a problem for which the time of computing increases exponentially with a number of elements
to adjust. It may well be that a quantum computer can help solve this kind of problem, not only this
one of course, but this kind of problem. And to be honest I would be excited to see that.
Do you ever think about your professional legacy?
Oh no. But I can think about it. I think that if there is something I would like to teach
is curiosity. And when something interests you, just go into it and try to understand
better and better. And don't listen to people who tell you it's not interesting. If you find
it interesting, just continue with it. What do you think about people saying
that you proved Einstein wrong? Often people say that my experiment
showed Einstein wrong. And I think it's not fair at all because what happened is that Einstein
raised a problem and his vision of the world was such that he came to the conclusion that
one must complete quantum theory. And Niels Bohr disagreed with him. And the experiments we have
been doing on test of Bell's inequality show that quantum mechanics cannot be completed along the
lines that probably Einstein had in mind. So from this point of view, it's true that he was
not fully right. But he did not know about our experiments. In his time, he could think that
his interpretation was compatible with standard physics. So we don't know what he would have said.
And moreover, I told you that entanglement is a very important property. Who put the finger
on entanglement and say, ah, this is really amazing? It is Einstein. So really, when people
say, oh, you showed Einstein wrong, I say, come on, I showed Einstein was great. And if he had known
what we have today, nobody knows what he would have said.
