Riccardo Giacconi, Masatoshi Koshiba, Raymond Davis; Nobel Prize in Physics 2002: Official Interview

"Physics & Astronomy"
21 followers
Dr. Giacconi, Dr. Koshiba, Dr. Raymond Davis and Andrew Davis,
welcome to Stockholm and to this Nobel interview.
Yesterday you received the Nobel Prize in Physics for this year, 2002,
and the Nobel Prize gives you fame and it gives you money too.
Do you feel happy, Dr. Giacconi?
Well, all I can tell you is we had a wonderful time yesterday night
and then at 7.30 in the morning I was woken up by the grandchildren before they had breakfast
and then after they had breakfast because they were leaving and having them here was perhaps
one of the very happy things I could do for them that made me happy.
So the family makes you happy.
Very much so.
What do you say, Dr. Koshiba?
Yes, I felt the same.
I also brought my granddaughters.
They were happy and I was happy too.
And Dr. Davis?
Same with me.
My wife said, why don't we take all the children and that'll be the way we'll spend
our money.
The week of your life.
And it's worked out beautifully.
They've had a great time.
Yes, we have.
Speaking as one of the children.
Of course, all of the grandchildren are here too.
We're going to get a lot of this out of him.
But I would like to say that the three of you share also another experience, I would say,
of many years of work and trying to get and interpret the signals from space.
And what you also share is the experience of not getting things right.
Maybe also experience of getting accidents.
Did you ever think about just quitting the field?
No, not at all.
Can I expand a little on this?
I used to be asked to give early morning breakfast talks to the donors and sponsors
of Hopkins University.
And I used to wake them up in the morning asking them the question, what does it mean
if Hubble telescope, upon being on the launch pad, blows up?
What does it mean?
And my answer was that the point of it all was not this piece of metal and glass, but
what we were learning in doing it.
Learning about our own field, learning about being able to work together.
And at the end of this process, whether it blew up or not, it almost...
Well, of course, much better if it didn't.
But this, of course, woke them up in the morning.
I mean, this prospect.
But basically, we had changed.
And we had changed in such a way, we learned enormously.
And it was easy to build the next one.
So progress, I think, we tend to overemphasize the stuff which is a result of the hardware.
But there is a tremendous amount of learning that goes in doing this and in preparing for
this.
And that will remain no matter what happens.
No, I never doubted that I would go on.
Do you mean that you learn even more if things go wrong?
Sometimes.
It's not obvious that the lessons are then properly implemented.
But yes, you do.
Sometimes not such a fun way to learn.
No, that's not a fun way.
But it's good because it's a reality check.
I mean, in many activities in human life, there is no reality check.
One can claim he is the greatest.
Here, nature is a kind and abundant mother.
But it's also a hard taskmaster.
That is, if you don't do it right, you just wonder what happened.
What do you say, Dr. Koshiba?
Well, it is true that I did have difficulties from time to time in my experiment.
I never give up.
I think about it over and over again until I find some solution.
This is the way I have been doing my work.
And you, Dr. Davis, you were working for 30 years trying to measure neutrinos from the sun
and never getting it right, I would say.
How could you persist?
Well, first off, it's funding in science.
You have to get enough money to really do it right.
And I found that not too hard to do because the funding agencies have been very good to
the laboratory that I live in, and that's a very important factor.
But you've got also heavily criticized.
For example, as a chemist by your colleagues, physicists, how could you communicate?
They're the same.
Most of my experiments are really using chemicals and physics.
The other thing, I did a lot of work underground.
So I wanted to find someone to dig a hole for me, quite deep.
And you go to a mine and talk to their management, and they say,
oh, yeah, you could do it.
So you went to this gold mine in South Dakota.
But in looking for neutrinos the way I did, you really need that.
And the company that has to help and dig a little for us.
Have you ever visited your father in the mine?
Yes, I visited many years ago.
Before I answer that, I thought I would say a little bit more also about the experiment.
You were saying, do you have difficulty with perhaps being wrong?
In the end, of course, it was not wrong.
The experiment was right, and the solar model was right.
It was the neutrinos, which in some sense are misbehaving,
or at least not behaving in the way people had expected them to.
But in the early days of your experiment,
and the challenge of physicists and theoreticians to you to say,
there must be something wrong with this step.
I mean, that made your experiment better because you did more tests.
And you never think of giving up at that stage.
You continue to believe, know from your own knowledge that it's correct.
And you try to follow up on that and make the experiment better,
do more tests to convince other people that you're right.
And so that's how it works.
In my case, I visited the mine in 1968 when I was 18 years old.
And the whole family drove across the country,
and we visited the mine on the way.
And I'm the oldest of five children.
I was the only one over 18 at the time.
So I was the only one permitted in the mine.
And my mother was not permitted in the mine.
Because at that time, women were not permitted in the mine.
It was considered to be unlucky.
Of course, today there are women miners working.
So things have changed.
I would like to continue a little about being a scientist.
I would say that this is the thing that you never quit it.
In spite of all the difficulties, this leads to the Nobel Prize somehow.
And Dr. Jack Connolly, you mentioned before that one of your favorite lectures
is the story of the white whale, of Moby Dick.
Is this a metaphor for science?
Well, I think that we do science because we must, and we want to.
What do you mean by must?
Well, we can't help it.
I mean, we're interested.
There is something.
We are lucky.
We hit upon a problem which really holds our interest.
And then we wish to carry out the work.
One of the greatest difficulties is persuading somebody else,
which normally is required to give you funding,
or somebody else means an agency, one or the other.
And for instance, in my case, when I started off,
I tried to convince the National Aeronautics and Space Administration
that I wanted to go look at stars in X-rays.
And they thought this would not be interesting.
So then I had to go to the Air Force.
And I asked if they could be interested.
And they, at the time, were interested in studying the moon, perhaps.
And so that's why my proposal emphasized the moon,
because this was interesting for a sponsor.
But basically, I was doing what I wanted to do.
And then misfortune, criticism, and so forth.
Well, you internalize a lot of this.
But basically, you're doing what you want.
And that's a fantastic reward, I mean,
to be able to be allowed to do in life what you want to do.
So it's very difficult to deflect you and adversities and so forth.
Well, I mean, maybe one could give up.
But it never occurred to me that I would.
And so the adversity was just something that,
particularly in the space program,
you have to become accustomed to the fact that there may be failure.
And so do you stop? Not at all.
You go on. You try to figure out a better way.
You try to figure out some way to put in more,
you know, disaster-proof approaches and so on.
But I haven't heard anybody really involved that would quit.
What makes people quit, I think,
is when they absolutely cannot convince their peers
that what they want to do is rational.
And therefore, they find great difficulties in getting support
because of peer-review system and so forth,
particularly in the United States.
And that, since, you know, we are people sensitive,
just like anybody else, you tend to internalize that
as a self-criticism.
Maybe I don't know what I'm doing.
And at that point, you're lost.
It can be devastating.
Well, I have been too arrogant to ever get to that point.
Okay. So what about the story of Moby Dick?
Well, Moby Dick is only a funny story.
When we launched Einstein,
there was a question of what should be the name.
And we had been very impressed with the name
that the British gave to their own little satellite,
which was called Ariel.
And Ariel is nice because it gives you an idea
of a light, spirit, England.
You don't have to say more.
You know it's a British satellite.
So we were wondering what was the equivalent.
And some of my colleagues suggested Pequod.
Now, Pequod happens to be a Massachusetts Indian tribe.
So it said Massachusetts.
And that was also the name of the ship of Captain Ahab.
And they saw some similarities between my behavior
and that of Captain Ahab.
Chasing the white whale, yeah.
Well, chasing a dream,
notwithstanding the difficulties and nature.
And the white whale is evil.
So you're chasing evil.
And then this name was vetoed
because Congress would have objected,
the environmentalists, about chasing whales.
And the Congress, particularly of the United States,
would have been sensitive in chasing white whales,
which would have been a wasted enterprise.
So we never got called Pequod.
But I always have kept in my mind the Moby Dick story
because it's reliving the myth of Prometheus
has been picked up by Dante in Ulysses
in his Divine Comedy.
And then I think Melville.
That was just a retelling of the myth
in Puritanical New England.
So I found it interesting.
I have another question also.
You two especially, Dr. Giacconi and Dr. Koshiba,
you are leaders of big experimental groups.
There are several hundred people,
or even thousand maybe, working together.
What is the input or the role of individual creativity
in comparison with the work in science of the group?
What would you say about that?
You ask me a very difficult question.
As a matter of fact, I don't know how to explain it well.
How important is the individual in science?
Individual is very important.
There's no doubt about it.
Even if you were to...
You do also need a good collaboration spirit.
The only thing you can achieve this or acquire this
is that you get trusted by your colleagues.
How? I don't know.
Well, you just trust your colleagues and they trust you.
I don't know.
What would you say, Dr. Giacconi?
Has also a big collective to lead.
Well, I mean, we are, after all, working in the United States.
So some of the things I'm going to say
are fairly common, at least in management experience
in the United States.
One thing is, I think that when you are involved
in big science, big enterprises,
it becomes a little bit different than being in a faculty.
I mean, if you've ever been to a faculty meeting,
there are 30 people, each one has his own ideas.
And we rarely agree on anything.
And therefore, if you are asking for a recipe for action,
this is very tricky.
I mean, you can't get action.
Now, when you are involved in major programs,
and particularly in the space where there is a deadline
and so forth,
the problem is not only to have creativity by the individuals,
but have that combined with discipline.
Now, you can't have discipline.
Discipline is not, in science, doesn't work.
I mean, these are creative minds that can't be told what to do.
And so what I found works very well
is that we work like a band of brothers.
Meaning that, yes, somebody is a recognized leader,
but he is a leader because he has ideas
and because he's contributing leadership.
If he doesn't, somebody else in the wolf pack will take over.
But it's not quite as wolf-type image would suggest.
Because, for instance, I can say that,
fair conscience, that, for instance,
the Hubble Space Telescope Institute,
which was created from the ground,
no major decision of any kind, technical or managerial,
was taken without reaching consensus.
And I don't mean vote.
I mean consensus.
We would talk until we were blue in the face
so that we could agree.
However, once we had agreed on a technical approach
or managerial approach,
then there was an implied pact
that we would carry out this decision,
even if we had disagreed originally
with all our might and all our loyalty.
That, in order to do any of this,
you need to achieve a level of communication and truth
that is hard to achieve.
And, I mean, I was very accustomed,
as a leader of this group of scientists,
being told I was totally stupid.
And that was perfectly OK.
In fact, the only real bad thing
was if somebody thought so and didn't tell me.
Because that would have been really dangerous
to our progress.
So I was able to do that when I was young
at American Science and Engineering,
where we did the work,
discovery work and then the work on Uhuru at Harvard,
and then Space Telescope.
And later on, I became a little bit more imperious
because I'm getting a little impatient.
I didn't have the time quite to go through all of this
and building up this through a period of education.
But that's the way to do it.
And I think I see no conflict
between feeling fully contributing
and allowed to create as an individual
and to recognize that you need to work cooperatively.
And when that works,
those are moments in human life which are very rare.
There is a great sense of privilege
in belonging to such a group.
The young generals of Alexander
must have felt that way, right?
Yeah.
There is this spirit in science
that science goes its own way somehow,
that scientists can be replaced,
that something is in the air.
If I don't do this, maybe somebody else would do.
What do you say about that, Dr. Koshiba?
Well, science is a special type of recognition.
And by its nature,
it is a common asset of the entire human being.
Therefore, if I didn't build this detector
and detect supernova neutrino,
well, supernova happens every 30 years
in the average galaxy.
But in our own galaxy,
the previous one was more than 300 years ago.
However, eventually,
other people will think of detecting
such neutrino signal and then find it.
There's no doubt about it.
But when it comes to a different type of recognition,
like, for instance,
when you are listening to the music you like,
then you and the recognized subject,
there's no separation between the two.
You and music are just one entity.
You enjoy it.
You don't analyze it.
You don't study it.
You just feel it.
This is a type of recognition
different from scientific recognition.
And, for instance, as I used to say,
if Mozart didn't make this particular music,
there would be nobody who can produce the same thing.
Do you agree with that?
What do you say, Dr. Davison?
I certainly believe this.
The scientists, they like each other
and they don't get,
I mean, they like to hear
your story, you know.
I've never had any trouble with that.
Most people are interested in what you are doing.
It's kind of free.
It's very important to be at a really good laboratory
that has a very good staff.
And I was lucky with going to Brookhaven National Lab
because there were so many scientists
on all kinds of things that aren't,
say, they're engineers and so forth.
And at Brookhaven, if you're doing an experiment
and you talk to somebody,
somebody will weigh in.
You say, rise time counting.
I never heard what rise time counting was.
And I just go to the electrical engineers
and I said, yeah, I'll build you one of those.
And so...
So even if you work alone,
you need this kind of people.
Yes, and you have a large body of scientists
that you talk to.
We all talk to each other very much.
You shouldn't have the impression
that you're sitting a mile underground
with a tank of perchloroethylene
by yourself counting argon atoms.
This enterprise involves discussions
with lots of different people.
You discuss with scientists and engineers
every day, every aspect of your work.
It's constantly an interaction
of different people and expertise
from many different fields.
And that's the way science gets done.
There's a lot of talk
and a lot of back and forth of ideas.
Yes.
Do you agree with that, Dr. Giacconi,
that science is in this way working
or individual scientists don't matter
as much as individual artists?
Well, we have had a running discussion
with Professor Koshiba,
who obviously has thought about this
perhaps longer than I have.
But I do not.
I do not agree to this.
But I do not have a very good way
to express it.
So I can only express it
by stating some things.
For example, let me think a moment
of Kepler.
Kepler had the following problem.
The astronomy.
The following problem,
that he was thinking
about the motion of the planets.
He was very careful
in interpreting Tycho Brahe data.
And he tried to express regular laws.
However, there was a fundamental problem
in his mind, which was the following.
It wasn't obvious how the planets
would actually be dragged in the sky
according to these laws.
So what was the actual mechanism?
Well, there was an Italian scientist,
not quite as famous,
who had solved the problem
by saying that the planets
were inhabited by living beings
who would fly like swans,
flying around the sun in formation.
Now, Kepler didn't accept
that at all, thank God.
However, he had no idea
of gravitational laws.
And so for him to say
that there was a law at distance
whereby the sun could influence
the motion of the planet
was like magic, was worse magic
than what he suggested,
which was that there would be
magnetic brooms pushing the planets
along in their orbit.
At least it was a physical explanation.
Now, the jump of going to that,
from that, to actually
recognizing the physical laws
that regulates this motion,
to me, is a creative jump.
And the question that I really
have been asking myself more
since I've heard this concern
of Professor Koshiba
was the following.
It is quite true that, presumably,
we're living in one world,
and if we knew all about it,
all aspects of it,
then we would have to agree
how it works.
However, it's not clear to me
that, for instance,
during a period
in which you have no idea at all
of probability, quantum theory,
or whatever,
you really are conceiving the world
in the same way as you would
if you have a different
theoretical outlook.
And whether there would be
part of reality
that actually would remain hidden
or unimportant
or not interpreted to you.
So basically, all I'm saying
is very simple.
Does language determine
our thinking in a fundamental way?
Because then,
the scientific discoveries
can be interpreted
in a linear way.
We are progressing
one on top of the other.
But basically, we are
within a confined civilization,
a certain type of language.
Is there some other aspect
that we can ever appreciate
if we continue in that language?
That's why it would be interesting
to find an alien civilization.
I'm sure they would work
in the same world.
Would they really conceive of it
in the same manner?
I don't know this.
I want to think about it more.
But it seems to me
that maybe not.
And finally, one should say
that I did feel
as a creative scientist
all my life
and to be told that I'm not,
then I don't like it psychologically.
But he may still be right.
But I was trying to put
enough of a thought about it
to say, well, this example
I'm using of the aliens
is that obviously,
the aliens should ultimately
come to the same conclusion.
Now, they could have had
infrared vision.
They could have had x-ray vision
or whatever.
At that point,
would they come up
with the same world view
that we have?
That I find, I don't know.
I can't answer.
So yeah, this is another way
of putting the question
of what you are doing
as a scientist.
Are you studying the nature
as it is?
Or are you just testing
your models?
You're my spokesman.
He does that to me.
He did that to me once before.
But then he's very tough on me
when I don't give
the right answer.
So I know this trick.
I have seen this trick.
What would you like him to say?
I think that what Professor
is saying is that
you get into a car
and you don't know anything
about impulse or momentum,
et cetera.
But if you hit a wall,
you hit a wall.
And so you must come
to the conclusion,
to certain conclusion.
All I was saying was that,
yes, I agree with that.
And thank God we have a proof.
But I was asking
a slightly different question.
That is, have we really
conceptualized in our mind,
in the way we look at the world?
I mean, here we are.
I see that tripod.
I see the chair.
And so that is obviously
a concrete structure.
I can't perceive it as waves.
I can't.
I can't do it.
Is it because I'm too dumb?
Would somebody else
who has been trained
in a different way
see it as an energy pattern,
a field?
What conclusion would he draw
about the natural world?
OK, that's all I'm saying.
So thank you for taking your time
and sharing your thoughts with us.
Thank you very much.
