The Committee on Energy and Commerce is the oldest standing legislative committee (established 1795) in the U.S. House of Representatives and is vested with the broadest jurisdiction of any congressional authorizing committee. The Energy and Commerce Committee is at the forefront of all issues and policies powering America’s economy, including our global competitive edge in energy, technology, and health care. The committee is led by E&C Chairman Brett Guthrie (KY-02) and E&C Ranking Member Frank Pallone (NJ-06). The Subcommittee on Energy is led by Chairman Bob Latta (OH-05) and Ranking Member Kathy Castor (FL-14).
This hearing examines the transmission development landscape, emphasizing the need to modernize the power sector while maintaining state authority. The discussion focuses on the balance between increasing energy demand and the risks of federal overreach, arguing that methodical, state-led planning is essential to ensure grid reliability and protect consumers from rising costs.
Welcome to today's hearing and we thank our witnesses for appearing before us today to examine
the transmission development landscape. Today's discussion will be an important opportunity for
our subcommittee's continued work to modernize the power sector and chart a path towards energy
abundance, affordability, and economic growth. The witnesses before us will provide practical
insights into why states need to maintain authority over committee decisions, as well as
the engineering and affordability considerations utilities account for through their integrated
planning processes. Throughout this Congress, our subcommittee has received extensive expert
testimony on key issues facing the electric system. We discussed the affordability challenges for
American families. We've heard directly from NERC and our grid operators about the reliability
crisis. We've also examined the need for reliable energy during winter storms and power for future
industries like AI and manufacturing. Demand for reliable energy is rising faster than at any point
in history. Clearly, we need more generation and transmission and a great deal more of it.
Significant investment is flowing into the power sector. To protect ratepayers, states,
utilities, and grid operators alike must employ methodical planning practices to ensure investment
is going to the most reliable and affordable infrastructure needed to keep the lights on
24-7, 365 days a year. But today's discussion doesn't occur in a vacuum. For years,
policymakers and stakeholders have called for permitting reforms that make it easier
to build in this country. There's insurmountable evidence that certain federal authorities have
been an incessant impediment to the timely construction of infrastructure. Energy projects
are heavily litigated, challenged in court, and fight an uphill battle against the seemingly
endless regulations coming out of Washington. The situation with transmission is no different.
Time and time again, transmission development is impeded by the weaponization of federal
environmental permitting laws that extend project timelines and raise costs. At the end of the day,
those costs are borne by the consumer and limit economic growth. However, the term permitting
reform is grounded in the idea that we need to get the federal government out of the way
not to add more bureaucracy. This brings us to today's topic. Proposes to federalize
transmission processes and usurp state authority to serve the interests of a few while placing
the costs on all. Transmission planning across the country varies depending on market structures
and regulatory models. What they have all in common is an extensive bottom-up planning process
to use the most cost-effective and reliable options to connect generating resources to load
centers. When approaching a reliability challenge, sometimes the solution is building more
transmission. Sometimes that solution is building generation closer to the load.
And like all decision-making processes, some options are tossed aside.
Components of big wires to connect weather-dependent resources often say that they're
cheaper because no one pays for the sun to shine or wind to blow. Simply put,
if this were true, utilities would already be doing it. In reality, multi-state, inter-regional
transmission lines can come with billion-dollar price tags and bring engineering complications
that raise costs and undermine system reliability. We find ourselves in a reliability crisis because
of the disastrous public policies that drive out baseload power and increase reliance on
intermittent sources. These policies ignore the reality of transmission costs granted
assets of prematurely retiring baseload power and the need for backup during extreme weather events
just like we've seen during winter storm Fern. At the end of the day, these costs are all placed
into the utility bills of American households. The data speaks for itself. For the last two
decades, utility spending on generation has plummeted with abundant sheet natural gas,
while transmission distribution spending has skyrocketed because of intermittent energy
mandates. Permitting reforms is necessary, but we need to correctly diagnose what issues are
practically inhibiting efficient transmission development. I look forward to today's discussion
and examine how states are best suited to examine those costs and weigh the pros and cons of
transmission infrastructure, not Washington bureaucrats. With that, I yield back the balance
of my.