LIVE: Justice Department Provides Updates on the 2024 Collapse of Key Bridge

Live News Network
1.4K followers
5 Video Views·May 12, 2026
The U.S. Attorney for the District of Maryland and the Justice Department’s Environment and Natural Resources Division hold a press conference at 10 a.m. ET on May 12 to provide an update about the investigation into the collision incident involving the M/V Dali container vessel and the Francis Scott Key Bridge in Baltimore on March 26, 2024.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Good morning. In the early morning hours of March 26th of 2024, the motor vessel Dolly
crashed into the Francis Scott Key Bridge, tragically killing six people and causing
catastrophic damage to our region. Today, the United States unsealed an indictment
charging three defendants, Synergy Marine Private Limited, Synergy Maritime Private Limited,
and Radha Krishnan Karthik Nair with crimes related to the disaster, including conspiracy
violations of the Ports and Waterways Safety Act, misconduct or neglect of ship officers
resulting in death and obstruction, among others. At approximately 1.29 on that late
March morning, the Dolly, a 900-foot container vessel, crashed into the Key Bridge,
causing the death of six individuals working on the structure and the total destruction of the
This resulted in a downed bridge that obstructed the channel and shut down the Port of Baltimore.
The port did not fully reopen until June of 2024, more than two months after the crash.
And although reconstruction of the bridge is ongoing, the state of Maryland does not expect
it to be completed until 2030. In the meantime, Maryland residents and commuters remain unable
to use a portion of the eastern span of I-695. As alleged in the indictment, the Dolly struck
the Key Bridge because it lost power twice in a four-minute period of time prior to striking the
The first power loss was likely caused by a loose wire in a high-voltage switchboard.
But critical systems on the Dolly were designed with redundancies and automatic restart capabilities
so the Dolly quickly regained power after the first blackout. However, shortly after the vessel
regained power, a second loss of power occurred. The second loss of power happened because the
defendants relied on a flushing pump to supply fuel to two of the Dolly's generators.
The flushing pump, however, did not automatically restart. Instead, it needed to be manually
restarted. When the flushing pump was not restarted in time after that first blackout,
the ship's two running generators became starved of fuel, causing a second blackout.
The indictment alleges that if the Dolly had been using the proper fuel supply pumps, then the
vessel would have regained power in time to safely navigate under the Key Bridge. But because the ship
was using the flushing pumps, which did not have the redundancies, the ship did not regain
power in time. As alleged in the indictment, the use of the flushing pump, a non-redundant
fuel supply pump, was a hazardous condition under U.S. Coast Guard regulation and a violation of
international law. The indictment further alleges that since 2020, the operators of the Dolly,
Synergy Marine, and Synergy Maritime used the flushing pump as a continuous fuel supply pump
on at least three vessels, including the Dolly, and that Synergy employees, including Karthik
Nair, knew about the improper use of the flushing pump and the risks that it presented.
As alleged in the indictment, Nair and others took steps to hide the use of the flushing pump
on the Dolly both before and after the crash. The indictment further alleges that after the crash,
Nair falsely told the National Transportation Safety Board that he was unaware that the Dolly
was using the flushing pump. As alleged in the indictment, the government's investigation
also found that Synergy employees, including its shoreside technical managers, fabricated
and directed the fabrication of safety inspections and certifications related to vessel systems.
Synergy later provided many of these false certifications to the NTSB and to a federal
grand jury in Baltimore. I would like to thank our partners at the Environmental Crime Section
in the Environment and Natural Resources Division of the United States Department of Justice for
working with us on this matter. I would also like to thank our federal and state law enforcement
partners who assisted in this investigation, including the FBI, the Environmental Protection
Agency Criminal Investigation Division, the U.S. Coast Guard, and the Coast Guard
Investigative Service. I especially want to thank the first responders who quickly cut off traffic
to the Key Bridge and who engaged in rescue efforts following the elision, including the
Maryland Transportation Authority, the Baltimore City Police Department, the Baltimore County
Police Department, Maryland State Police, and the United States Coast Guard. I also want to note
that an indictment is only an accusation. All defendants are presumed innocent until proven
guilty at a trial beyond a reasonable doubt. We look forward to pursuing our case at trial.
I will now turn it over to Adam Gustafson, the Principal Deputy Assistant Attorney General
for the Environment and Natural Resources Division. Thank you.
Thank you, U.S. Attorney Hayes, and thanks to your team in the U.S. Attorney's Office for your
partnership in this case. Good morning. I'm Adam Gustafson. I'm the Principal Deputy Assistant
Attorney General at the Environment and Natural Resources Division in the Department of Justice.
We join the U.S. Attorney's Office in prosecuting this important matter.
The indictment alleges criminal conduct that led to the death of six Maryland residents,
the destruction of the Key Bridge, the discharge of pollution into the Patapsco River,
the closure of the Port of Baltimore, causing billions of dollars worth of damage.
The catastrophic elision on March 26, 2024, occurred within the Chesapeake Bay Watershed
at the western edge of the bay. When the dolly crashed into the Key Bridge, massive pieces of
the bridge fell into the Patapsco River, along with vehicles, cargo containers, and other debris.
The crash also resulted in the discharge of oil into the water. Following the laws for the safe
operation of commercial vessels is essential to doing business in our nation's ports,
especially the Port of Baltimore on the Chesapeake Bay, our nation's largest estuary.
We enforce these laws to protect the public from disasters like the one that brought us here today.
The indictment we've unsealed today alleges that Synergy and its employees,
including Karthik Nair, broke the law in ways that caused this tragedy.
The dolly twice lost power in the early hours of March 26, 2024. Without power, it could not
safely navigate the bridge. The first power outage was likely caused by a loose wire.
Although the dolly restarted, we allege that the second outage prevented the dolly from being able
to avoid the bridge. We allege that that second outage resulted from the dolly's use of an
unapproved flushing pump in the fuel oil supply system. That unapproved flushing pump was a
problem because it did not automatically restart after the first outage. We allege that Synergy
knew about the improper use of the flushing pump on the dolly and on other Synergy vessels,
and willfully failed to notify the Coast Guard of this hazardous condition.
We allege that the possibility of such a catastrophic power failure should have been
no surprise to Synergy. In fact, the dolly experienced two blackouts at port the day
before the elision, and we allege that Synergy's employees didn't investigate or report those
blackouts as the law requires. We also allege that the defendants provided false documents
and false statements to the NTSB during its investigation. In the time since the crash,
the initial economic fallout has continued to expand. The Key Bridge carried about 12 million
vehicles annually. That's about 23 vehicles every minute. Some of those vehicles are left without
any efficient route, including trucks carrying hazardous materials that can't use the tunnels
under the harbor. The Port of Baltimore, one of the five busiest ports on the East Coast,
was completely closed following the crash, and it wasn't fully reopened until 11 weeks after.
In the meantime, container traffic into and out of the port ground to a halt. The economic and
human costs of this catastrophe have been borne every day by ordinary men and women,
and most of all, by the families of the six workers who were killed.
I echo the gratitude expressed by U.S. Attorney Hayes to the first responders and our federal
and state law enforcement partners for their tireless efforts to clear the channel,
investigate the elision, and prevent future disasters. As U.S. Attorney Hayes noted,
an indictment is only an accusation. All defendants are presumed innocent until proven
guilty at trial beyond a reasonable doubt. And now I'll turn it over to EPA Assistant Administrator
Jeff Hall. Good morning. I'm Jeffrey Hall, the Assistant Administrator for the Office of
Enforcement and Compliance Assurance at the EPA. Our Criminal Investigations Division worked on
the FBI and the Coast Guard from the beginning to develop it. I want to thank the Department
of Justice colleagues for bringing this indictment today. EPA Special Agents were among the first
aboard the MV Dolly after it struck the bridge because it carried over 760 tons of hazardous
materials. Our Criminal Investigation Agents are specially trained to operate in high-hazard
environments, including in disasters and in the aftermath of chemical releases and in confined
spaces. So that day, they donned protective gear, deployed air monitors, navigated a maze of
dislodged cargo containers, and assessed the threats to the city and the river coming from
the ship. They ensured that there was no immediate danger of a major release of hazardous materials.
And then our agents role transitioned to working alongside the FBI and Coast Guard
as a co-lead in this investigation. Their hard work resulted in this indictment today.
Although we are fortunate that not all of the hazardous materials escaped their containers,
some materials did, including oil and other chemicals, pieces of the bridge, vehicles,
and other debris that fell into the Patapsco River, which is used in international commerce,
polluted it, and obstructed its navigability. But we narrowly avoided worse. Certainly,
but for the quick action of MDTA, there could have been many more deaths from passers-by on
the bridge. And when a ship strikes a bridge, it and its cargo, as well as whatever else hazardous
might be on the bridge at the time, can poison rivers, large watersheds like the Chesapeake,
cities, and their drinking water, causing harm and disruption and requiring intensive cleanup.
Indeed, hazardous materials routinely crossed the Key Bridge as the only route in the area,
and its destruction means that they now must take longer routes through other areas of the
community. We cannot allow ourselves to be placed in such a vulnerable position.
This administration and the EPA are committed to ensuring that foreign corporations do not profit
off of polluting America. The United States is not a safe harbor for third-world pollution.
Toxic substances, illegal pesticides, and even hazardous waste enter the United States every day,
sometimes illegally, and they do so on foreign ships that pollute our waters.
Until America can reindustrialize, we must vigilantly police these dangerous imports
and the vessels carrying them to ensure that they comply with our laws and that we protect our
nation. This is precisely the type of situation that must not happen again. Foreign-flagged
vessels with foreign crews carrying dangerous cargo cannot flout our laws, poison our communities,
and destroy our infrastructure. We proudly join the U.S. Attorney's Office in prosecuting this
case. We will rely on the Department of Justice to prove its allegations in court. Thank you.
Now you'll hear from Special Agent in Charge Jimmy Paul of the FBI Baltimore Field Office.
Good morning. My name is Jimmy Paul. I'm the Special Agent in Charge for the FBI's Baltimore
Field Office. The Key Bridge collapse forever changed Maryland. It changed the way we look
at bridges and the way we look at ships. This tragedy changed six families forever. Alejandro,
Miguel, Dorlean, Maynard, Carlos, and Jose were making our roads safer when they lost their lives
on that fateful day in March of 2024. We know, as is laid out in this indictment,
the collapse should never have happened. As alleged, the bridge was struck and collapsed
because those who were responsible for the ship's operation deliberately cut corners at the expense
of safety. Marylanders felt collective shock seeing a defining part of Baltimore's skyline
gone in just seconds. That shock turned to shared grief as we learned of the six lives lost
and the unimaginable terror felt in their last moments. Daily commutes, international and
domestic commerce, entire communities were upended and remain so. The economic cost,
as well as the cost of rebuilding the bridge, is in the billions. The FBI responded immediately to
the collapse, helping with the urgent search and rescue and assisting family members of those lost.
The FBI also opened a criminal investigation. We worked this case methodically and diligently
over the past two years. FBI investigators became experts in the complex inner workings
of these ships and the rules and regulations that govern this industry. The FBI executed more than
two dozen federal search warrants, including aboard the Dolly and its sister ship, the Saltoro.
We located witnesses across the globe. We conducted close to 200 interviews.
We spent hundreds of hours processing, reviewing, and analyzing terabytes of data,
which brings us to today's announcement. The indictment shows that Synergy and Radhakrishnan
Karthik Nair repeatedly failed to document, investigate, and report significant safety
risks and hazards aboard the Dolly. They forged safety inspections and certifications. They
falsely claimed the ship was in good working order and then lied to investigators about their actions
when they were questioned. This indictment should send a message to all ship operators
that circumventing safety requirements and breaking U.S. laws will not be tolerated.
The FBI collaborated closely with our partners throughout this investigation.
The EPA's Criminal Investigation Division, U.S. Coast Guard Investigative Service,
the Maryland's U.S. Attorney's Office, and the Department of Justice's
Environment and Natural Resources Division. We are grateful for their commitment to finding
the truth and holding those responsible accountable. This was a tragic and significant
moment for Baltimore. The FBI named this case Last Twilight. That name harkens back to another
significant moment in Baltimore's history. The phrase at the twilight's last gleaming is from
our national anthem and the Star Spangled Banner was penned on a vessel in the waters near where
we stand today. Where the bridge once spanned and where six lives were tragically lost. The
altered skyline is a constant reminder of this tragedy. For the FBI it also serves as a reminder
of our commitment to finding the truth and to bringing justice to everyone affected.
I thank you for your time today and I will turn it back over to U.S. Attorney Hayes.
Thank you everyone. While this is an ongoing prosecution we'll be limited in our answers
however we will take a few questions. Sir. Do you believe that the ship operators,
sorry I'll do that again. Hi Tom Costello with NBC News. You believe that the ship operators
and you believe that the superintendent deliberately misled the NTSB and the FBI
and do you believe other ship operators might now right now may also be also skirting the safety
laws of this country? So yes as alleged in the indictment there are obstruction of agency
proceeding and false statement charges related to statements made by Synergy employees to the
NTSB as well as false certifications related to safety inspections. As for your second we
certainly hope that folks in the shipping industry will take note of this indictment
and to the extent there are any other investigations ongoing I'm not able to comment. Yes.
Hi I'm Hayes Gardner with the Baltimore Banner. Is Nair or anyone else from Synergy in custody and
if so what was the extradition process like? We currently believe that Mr. Nair is located in India.
Yes. Hi Jessica Sanken Fox News. Just to follow up on that do you think you can get Nair to face
justice on U.S. soil? We are going to enforce all of and use all of our available law enforcement
tools to attempt to do just that. And given litigation and other pending factors do you
think this 2030 reopen date will hold? I'm not able to comment on that that was something I would
refer over to the state. Yes sir. Oh sorry wherever the mic goes. Campbell Roberts from the
New York Times. Does the settlement that was reached to the civil side of the DOJ
is could that be affected by the findings of fraud or obstruction or other things that
might have misled authorities about what actually happened? We view that settlement as separate. We
the individuals here were not involved in that specific settlement so I won't comment directly
on that but we do view them as separate and unrelated to the criminal investigation as of
this time. Yes. Hi Scott Mossioni with WYPR News. Would there be a possibility of having
reparation type funds given at the end of this if they are found guilty in a criminal court? And
then also is there a what would the maximum sentencing be underneath these these charges?
Certainly so we'll lay out more details in the upcoming press release as to the specific maximum
sentence. What I will say for the corporate individuals there will there is a possibility
of a fine that would be twice the loss amount so which is currently estimated to be at least 5
billion so that is is one of the available penalties. We also of course will attempt to
upon conviction if appropriate and you know available to us seek restitution and or forfeiture
related to any criminal conviction. Yes ma'am. Hi Katie Mettler with the Washington Post. The
civil trial related to this case is scheduled to begin in a couple weeks. Do you have any sense of
how the criminal case is going to impact or what the interplay will be between those two cases as
they go to the court at the same time? I do not. That will ultimately be up to the judge overseeing
the civil case along with parties in that case. Yes sir. Holmes from CNN. The flush pump system
is that installed because it is a cheaper system? Was there an issue with the the original system
or was that just intentional? What was the reason behind the flush pump I guess? So as alleged in
the indictment which I'll stick to the four corners of the indictment as much as I can
there was the availability of the fuel supply that was approved and within international law.
However the ship operators the defendants elected to use the flushing pump
instead. Well I'll leave it at that for now given that it's an ongoing investigation
and there are additional details within the indictment.
Yes sir up front.
Hey there Gary Grumbach with NBC News. Have you had an opportunity to inform the families the
families of this development and what was their reaction? So we do have obligations to consult
with victims throughout the process and they were provided a heads up that there would be an
announcement of course given that it was this indictment was just unsealed this morning. There
are limitations on what we were able to share with the victims prior to the unsealing. Hi there
Phil Yakovsky from WBAL radio here in Baltimore. You mentioned the flushing pump system. How many
other Synergy ships have this system and is that it was that a concern to you when you heard about
that given the number of ports around the country? So as alleged in the indictment there are at least
three ships under the folks doing business as Synergy that our investigation revealed
were using the flushing pumps. One of those ships was the Dolly and two sister ships.
Tommy Clark WBAL-TV. Can you just explain this flush pump system is it how common is this? Can
you familiarize us with is this rare to see a case like this or is this something that you're
concerned could be on other vessels beyond Synergy? So given that this is an ongoing prosecution I'm
limited in what I can say as it relates to that. What I'll say is speaking to this one
in the four corners of the indictment like I said we did have our investigation revealed that at
least three ships used this flushing pump in lieu of the approved fuel supply system.
Yes sir in the back. Hi Jeff Morgan with WMAR here in Baltimore. It's our understanding that
there are still crew members here in the United States. Do you know what the process will be like
for them? Is there any charges that could come to the other members of the crew or is this
limited at this point? So as of this point we have the three into all the two corporations and the
third defendant an individual who's charged. It's an ongoing investigation and we will bring
any additional charges if and when appropriate.
Hayes Gardner Baltimore Banner. This is a follow-up. Regardless of charges the crew
members who remain here they could be kept here for other reasons to be witnessed. Did you expect
those crew members to remain here indefinitely? At this stage there are crew members that are
still located in the United States and we will continue to work with the appropriate authorities
to determine their status going forward. Hello Katie Mettler from the Post. When was the NTSB
notified that they had been given false information by Synergy and their employees?
That is not contained within the indictment so I will not be able to answer that one today.
Sounds good. Yes sir. Can you clarify those crew members who are still in the United States are
they being held here in some capacity by the DOJ? In other words are they restricted and not a lot
to leave? I'm going to ask any of the folks behind me to correct me if I am wrong. However my
understanding is that they are here by agreement with various authorities within so not in custody
or not otherwise held but have agreed thus far to stay present in the United States.
At this point we're going to divulge that information.
Tommy with BAL again. I want to know you have this massive team behind you here. It obviously
took so much to get to this. It's been two years. Can you share for us what this means to get to
this point where you're announcing this? I mean this is pretty major not only for Baltimore,
for Maryland but the entire eastern part of our nation. Explain to us what that means.
I am grateful for all of the hard work. As you see we do have an incredible team standing behind me.
All of them worked together over the last two years to make sure that they were meticulously
developing the evidence. As special agent in charge Jimmy Paul said that included
a lot of review of evidence of digital files, interviews, looking through obviously boarding
the ship. So all of that work has come to an indictment. However this is only an accusation.
These are only allegations and we have more work to do. Hi Dan Belson with the Daily Record. The
indictment was handed up about a month ago. It wasn't unsealed until today. Could you talk a
little bit about what went into that timing and what happened in the interim there? That is a
very good question. One that I will not answer right now but I appreciate that and at the
appropriate time if and when appropriate we can certainly reveal that information.
Thank you so much.
