As America continues to celebrate its 250th year in existence, Glenn Ellmers, Salvatori Research Fellow in the American Founding, sits down with host Spencer Klavan to illuminate the life, teaching, and significance of Harry Jaffa, godfather of the Claremont Institute. Jaffa gave new life to, among other things, Abraham Lincoln’s rich understanding of Declaration's principles. Ellmers and Klavan contrast Lincoln’s statesmanship with the Marxism of John C. Calhoun, discuss the continuity of ancient and modern political thought as represented by the U.S., and consider what must be done to weed out corrupted political thought from higher education. Plus: the significance of Straussian teaching.
Chapters 00:00 Introductions 01:30 Harry Jaffa and the Founding 13:53 A New American Politics 22:11 MAGA, JQA, and Citizenship 29:08 Recovering American Ideals 34:15 The Heart of Straussianism 35:42 Closing Remarks
Hello and welcome back to The Close Read, your official Claremont Review of Books podcast. This
is another special 250th anniversary episode. We've been doing a couple specials, kind of a
mini-series, in anticipation of the thrilling 250th anniversary of the signing of the Declaration of
Independence with some of our top Claremont scholars to talk about the meaning of the
from a number of different angles. Today, I'm delighted to be joined by my friend Glenn Elmers.
He is the Salvatore Research Fellow at the Claremont Institute. He's also a prolific
author on sundry matters of political philosophy. His books include The Stole of Politics, Harry
V. Jaffa and the Fight for America, and The Narrow Passage, Plato, Foucault, and the Possibility of
Political Philosophy. It's the first of those that we're going to mostly focus on today because
what I'd like to talk with Glenn about is the great Harry V. Jaffa, who is one of Glenn's
teachers, or rather, I should say Glenn was one of his students. He's also, as I'll invite him
to explain, kind of the intellectual godfather of the Claremont Institute itself. Many of our
kind of laying out who Jaffa is and his significance kind of in the intellectual
lineage that leads to us having this conversation right now.
Sure, sure. Jaffa taught political philosophy for many years at Claremont,
and the founders of the Claremont Institute, four of them, were his graduate students.
Jaffa himself was enormously influenced by his teacher, in turn, the great Leo Strauss,
one of the great professors and scholars of political philosophy in the 20th century,
refugee from Nazi Germany. And Strauss, the most relevant thing is Strauss almost single-handedly
refuted the dominant intellectual dogmatism of historical relativism and said that we could go
back to the Greeks and read Plato and Aristotle and Xenophon and appreciate the great Western
tradition as showing enduring truth, right, and that the past is not dead, it is still alive,
it still has something to teach us. Jaffa, in turn, applied that same lesson to the understanding
of America, that principles of the American founding are not just reflections of, you know,
slave owners with white wigs, that these are not just artifacts of the 18th century, but to the
degree that they reflect human nature, permanent truths about justice are still true today and
relevant today. Jaffa actually worked himself backwards to the founding, beginning with the
Civil War, but I'm sure we're going to talk about that. Yes, that's good. I mean, I'm thinking of,
and I'm sure there are a number of passages that sort of reflect this, but I'm thinking of his
kind of magnum opus, A New Birth of Freedom, in which he says something like, you know,
there are Aristotelian principles in the Declaration. So very much kind of in the
line in that, taking that from Strauss, and as you say, taking it in turn kind of from Lincoln,
or approaching the Declaration, as it were, via Lincoln, which is very much in keeping with what
we've been talking about, because I had Lucas Morel on and we talked about Lincoln's approach
to the Declaration. Can you tell us a little bit about Jaffa's approach to Lincoln's approach
to the Declaration? Sure. I can't resist telling a wonderful little story about how Jaffa first
got interested in this. He had been a student of political philosophy and taken a lot of theory
classes, including a course on the Republic from Strauss. And if any of your readers are familiar,
even broadly, there's this great debate between Socrates and this character named Thrasymachus
about the nature of justice. And Thrasymachus says, justice is the interest of the stronger.
Jaffa, that is his course, okay, all well and good. He's in a used bookstore in downtown New York.
This would have been in the 1940s. And when downtown New York was full of wonderful used
bookstores, picks up a copy of the Lincoln-Douglas debates on the shelf, starts reading it. He
doesn't have the money to buy it, as in for graduate students, he goes back every day
and keeps reading. And as he reads this debate between Lincoln and Douglas, he says,
oh my God, it's exactly what Professor Strauss said. It's the same questions, the enduring
questions. What is the nature of justice? And Lincoln is arguing the Socratic position
that justice has a basis in nature that there is natural right. And Douglas, Judge Douglas,
is arguing the position Thrasymachus that the majority gets to decide what's just and unjust.
And that sparks Jaffa's great interest in Lincoln and the Civil War and the meaning of America.
Wow. Wow. No, that's terrific. And that is, I think, a running theme of A New Birth of
Freedom, which spends much of its time kind of preoccupied with the Lincoln-Douglas debates.
And yeah, I mean, this kind of through line from the ancients to the moderns is one of the
kind of flashpoints, I guess, of Straussianism. You're telling us, I think, that Jaffa's very
firmly in the kind of continuity camp, as it were. And I wonder if you could kind of lay out
for us Jaffa. And in your book, you really give a clear picture of this. Jaffa has an idea about
America as in world history, that it is, on the one hand, kind of sui generis and important and
indispensable to the march of history, on the other hand, continuous with this long tradition
that goes way, way back to the ancients. Can you describe that or say that better than I just did
in more detail? Sure, sure. So just to fill in the picture a little bit. So the study of Lincoln
and Lincoln's emphasis on the Declaration, then in turn sends Jaffa back to the founding,
which he hadn't really studied seriously, and then devotes himself to understanding the Declaration
and social compact theory, the principles of the American founding.
There's a great debate in the scholarship on America and particularly in Straussian scholarship
about whether America is ancient or modern. And this goes through the continuity that you're
talking about. And Jaffa says it's both. It's not purely ancient. The American Revolution does not
seek to recreate the ancient polis. Even if that was desirable, it would not be possible,
in part because of the introduction of Christianity and other ways in which the
world has changed. It's neither possible nor desirable to go back to the exact regime that
Aristotle talks about. But there are principles in Aristotle and Plato about the nature of political
justice, about the different kinds of regimes, about how human nature helps us determine
good regimes from bad regimes, that greatly inform the founder's understanding. And so
the typical Claremont answer to this question is partly ancient and partly modern. It's partly
ancient because the framers constantly refer back to these sources. There's a very famous letter
in which Jefferson is explaining about 50 years after the signing of the Declaration,
very close to his death, the sources, the philosophical sources of the Declaration.
And he mentions the authors of public right and mentions in particular Aristotle, Cicero,
Locke, and Sidney. Two ancients, two moderns. We should not discount the modern part. Again,
the founders were not trying to recreate the ancient polis. And so there is something
revolutionary. I mean, Joffre was also very emphatic that the American Revolution was
revolutionary. That's one of his disputes with the Paleocons, who in a way over-emphasized
continuity, that it's just a gradual continuation of English liberties. And we know that's not quite
true. And we see it in the documentation. If you look at the documents as the colonists are moving
towards revolution from 1775 to 1776, and Joffre talks about this in great detail, they move away
from the idea of reconciliation and English liberty to union, independence, and natural
rights. There's a distinct break from English liberties to natural rights, drawing on Locke
and others. And they saw this as a revolution in human affairs. Not new principles, not Pol Pot
year zero, not wiping blank the slate of human nature, drawing on ancient wisdom,
but at the same time doing something revolutionary, putting into practice for the first time in human
history, principles of the consent of the governed, sovereignty of the people, equal natural liberties
of the citizens.
So one of the things that we discussed with Lucas Morel is this idea, you know, we talked a lot
about this private note in which Lincoln describes the declaration as the apple of gold and the
picture of silver. And it's very important for Joffre as well, that this is the understanding
that Lincoln comes to of how the founding works. And we talked about the fact that in that note,
Lincoln doesn't even really quite say that it's the declaration, but rather this underlying kind
of nuclear reactor core of equality for all, right? The principle itself, liberty for all,
even, right? Which is wrapped around the human heart. And there's a second part of that, which
is that if that's true, then that principle has a kind of almost necessary logical unfolding.
And you get this in some of the speeches of John Quincy Adams. You certainly get it in many of the
kind of later interpretations of how the declaration works, that it's bound to have a
certain compulsion, as Madison says, upon the human mind. And you write very interestingly in
your book about the extent to which Joffre kind of has this idea also in mind, and particularly
whether he's a Hegelian. Because on the one hand, his whole critique and the whole Claremont
critique of modernity and whether modernity goes too far is in this scientific idea that
politics is just the working out of these necessary principles. On the other hand,
Joffre says, I leave it to you to decide whether the intervention of Christianity is a matter of
history, necessity, or divine intervention. I'm leaving it to you whether or not my interpretation
is really Hegelian. And you say in a single sentence paragraph, this is all very strange,
of course. It is very strange, right? I mean, how are we to understand the kind of balance between
America as like product of this necessary kind of historical moment that carries us
forth on the surge of liberty and America as distinctive contingent preface and kind of
necessary to preserve? How would you kind of square that circle on Joffre's behalf?
Sure. These are big questions. I'll do my best in the span of a short time. A common phrase,
which I'm sure many of the listeners have heard, is the miracle at Philadelphia.
The framers themselves thought that there was something miraculous. The American people thought
that there was something miraculous about the opportunity. You had the confluence of
highly educated, highly virtuous, highly religious, highly spirited people. You had an
extraordinary set of political leaders. You had a set of philosophical doctrines coming from Locke
and Montesquieu and others that were available to use. You had a history of English liberty,
which is not as much as some people say, but still an important piece. Many other factors
combined in an almost miraculous way to make this experiment in self-government possible.
Joffre also agreed with this, that there seemed to be something almost miraculous about
the way that America is able to draw on Athens and Jerusalem and Rome and combine the best elements
of that along with modern thought in a truly remarkable way. Now, here's the thing that does
not make him Hegelian, and we're getting a little into political philosophy here.
Hegel thought that the process of history was a rational unfolding, and this becomes even more
clear in Hegel's Disciple Marks, a rational unfolding that can be understood rationally
according to certain scientific laws. That's where Joffre's parts come in,
because to say that it's a miracle means it has a supernatural
supervention, you might say. And so to say that America is a result of providence
is not the same as to say it's the result of scientific historical laws, right?
And so he did see, in a way, an unfolding of history, that the great promises that began
in Athens and Jerusalem and Rome reached a kind of culmination, at least in theory. I mean,
we've never quite lived up to our best ideals, but the idea, the theory is really remarkable,
and he did see a kind of providence in that, but not the scientific historicism of Hegel and Marx.
And so this is very illuminating, and it really kind of brings in another aspect of
New Birth of Freedom that kind of blew my mind. And this is this idea of Lincoln's opponents,
right, and sort of the pro-slavery side of the pre-Civil War debate, include, of course,
John C. Calhoun. And Calhoun is sort of portrayed as a Marxist or as a sort of German historicist
type in New Birth of Freedom. Not something that you hear a lot in kind of interpretations of the
Civil War debates, but can you kind of flesh that out? In what way is the slaveholder argument
influenced more by this necessity, this picture of historical necessity?
Right. So Calhoun is drawing, I mean, the whole idea of inevitable historical progress,
shaping human nature, shaping history, a kind of deterministic way of looking at history,
goes all the way back to Rousseau, really. And Calhoun was a highly educated man.
He was familiar with the early development of this historicist thought coming out of Europe.
And it informs a kind of new political science that Calhoun develops. The key phrase there is
concurrent majority. And I think we probably don't want to get too deep in the weeds there.
But there's a whole second, there is a whole, I mean, Calhoun is really the first to introduce a
whole second strain of political theory and political science into America. The next big
leap takes place after the Civil War, when German historical thought comes to America in earnest,
takes over the graduate universities and various students of Hegel, like Woodrow Wilson and others.
And there are many Claremont scholars who've developed this at great length.
Picks up on some key points in Calhoun, and they introduce a new political science,
a new political theory, which is a radical break from the Lockean equal natural rights
principles that you find in the founding and in the Declaration.
Yeah. This is something which we currently have, I think, raging a debate whether, ironically,
whether Calhoun and to some extent Douglas or Lincoln gets the Declaration right. In other words,
the authors of the 1619 Project would like us to think that the Declaration is not what Lincoln
tells us it is, right? Lincoln really makes this assertion that the Declaration
actually intends to establish for all time this universal principle that's now going to get worked
out step by step, imperfectly, as you say, and not always with the best alacrity and messy ways.
But nevertheless, there's now this whole line of thought that no, actually, the Declaration was a
slaveholder document, right? It did cover over the interests of the majority slaveowning, whatever,
the majority slavery, the majority classes with this flowery rhetoric. And so it's Lincoln who
was kind of inventing this imaginary, pretty but imaginary version of what the Declaration actually
is. Where does Jaffa sort of sit in that? And how can he help us to kind of puzzle that out?
Right. So there's a scholar named Gary Wills, who's not that well known today, but he really
pioneered this with a book saying that Lincoln basically reinvented America, that's the famous
phrase, by introducing these ideas. And Jaffa, I think, shows amply and with quick abundant evidence
that Lincoln is simply doing what he claimed he was doing, which is drawing on the principles of
Jefferson and Fringes themselves. Going back to what you were saying, so there's a belief in
antebellum Southern Confederate thought, which is that the Declaration did not mean all men,
it meant white men. And, you know, Douglas says, and even more explicitly, Chief Justice Roger
Taney, who wrote the opinion in the famous notorious Dred Scott case, said that the
framers did not extend any rights to blacks. That's a misunderstanding of the Declaration.
And Jaffa shows again, carefully and scrupulously and abundantly through this historical evidence
that Calhoun and Douglas and Taney are wrong about what the Declaration meant,
that it did apply to all human beings. It is incoherent, if not understood that way.
And the great irony is that Jaffa spent so many decades fighting this, and it's now the left that
has basically taken up the same paleoconservative line, because what is the argument of the 1619
project, right? That equality didn't apply to blacks and slaves. So they're making the same
argument that Taney and Douglas and Calhoun made. Yeah, no, it is interesting because that's
another aspect of New Birth of Freedom that makes it, I mean, when you read a book that has lasted
that long, it's kind of fascinating to see who it was addressed to and who it is now addressed to.
I mean, who was New Birth of Freedom originally, who was Jaffa arguing with? I mean,
people will joke and say he was arguing with everybody all the time, but who was he aiming
this argument at, at the time? So just to dot the I's and cross the T's,
so the first great book is the 1959 Crisis of the House Divided, that's on the Lincoln-Douglas
debates. And one of the main criticisms he came in for was from his friend, Wilmore Kendall,
brilliant scholar, not a confederate, but a paleo-conservative traditionalist,
and criticized Jaffa for turning Lincoln into this almost frightening revolutionary figure,
who's willing to cast off all restraint, all tradition in the name of a kind of utopian
vision of justice. And that's a little unfair, but Jaffa was really struck by this criticism
and then spent the next 40 years or so thinking about it, and then grounding
the founder's social combat theory, the understanding of equality and natural rights
in a basis that I think responded to Kendall. And here's an important point that I wanted to
bring up, and it's so important now because it's so often misunderstood, and it's a point that I
and other Claremont scholars are always making. The equal natural rights of all human beings,
which is a theoretical truth, does not mean, never meant, and should never mean that America
has the moral or political or military obligation to secure the rights of people all over the world,
nor does it mean that we are the universal nation and that we are obliged to allow the whole world
to come in and enjoy the rights of being an American. That's a very important point.
And so a huge part of what Jaffa is doing in the long interim of the second book is,
you might say, putting this theoretical truth in a concrete historical context. The right
proclaiming the Declaration make a theoretical appeal to human nature, but they are done on
behalf of the good people of these colonies. We the people. So the American Revolution is waged
by Americans for Americans on behalf of our rights. And although, as John Quincy Adams and others
would say later, we wish well to all the world, we are happy to be an example, we are only securing
our own rights. And everyone else in the world, you can appeal to the same theoretical truths,
but you have to secure your own rights yourself, just as we did for ourselves.
That's a really critical thing to make clear.
Yeah. You came to JQA before I was going to. You anticipated me in that, because as many of you
start talking about this, it's like, yeah, this really does sound like the monsters to destroy
speech, right? And it is something I think I would imagine that you and all Claire Monsters are sort
of tasked with making this point in particular right now, when there's so much foment over
what sorts of military interventions is America kind of obligated to undertake,
and we've been through kind of Iraq and Afghanistan and so on and so forth.
Would you say that, not to get too hyper contemporary, but how do you think Trump
understands this question? In other words, it's hard to theorize Trump's sort of grand
principles, but just as a matter of revealed preferences, where do you think Trump and
recent kind of politicians surrounding him fit into this array of possible ways of understanding
the American project?
Yeah. My take on Trump has always been that he's not a scholar, he's not a theoretical man,
but he does have amazingly sound gut instincts. He seems to understand things instinctively.
And my friend, John Marini, who's one of the great Claremont Institute scholars,
going back to the old days, was one of the first to look at the MAGA slogan and take it seriously
and think about what it means, and to think about how Trump, in his weird, instinctive way,
captured something elementally true, make America great again, right? So it doesn't
mean anything about securing the rights of people in other countries. And yeah, it harkens back,
what was it that made America great? In part, it's our tradition of political liberty. In part,
it's our principles. In part, it's the legacy of the founding fathers, right? And so make America
great again is a nice way of capturing both the theory and the practice, right? The appeal to
human nature, but the fact that we are a nation securing our own rights. So I really liked the
way that Marini drew out the meaning of the make America great slogan. And I think,
you know, not to make too much of it, but it does capture, I think, something that's
really quite true about how properly to understand the American conception of liberty.
Yeah. You know, there's another dimension of this, I think, that is sort of the flip side of it.
And I've been saying that JQA is having a Claremont moment right now because, of course,
she's always dear to our hearts. But, you know, Flannery, Chris Flannery, just wrote this big
essay about him in CRB, Bill Allen's book about that speech. There's a lot of sort of JQA talk.
And one part of it is, yes, we have these universal principles, but we don't
go about sort of imposing them on others. The other part, though, is if we really
look to our own house, if we actually take seriously our charge to enact these universal
principles, then we will become a kind of beacon to the world, like just by virtue of being so
visibly an instantiation of these universals. We will kind of make those universals more powerful.
Is that also a kind of, does Jaffa have things to say about that side of it, I guess? And do you?
Sure, sure. You know, we started talking about Lincoln.
One of the great Lincoln speeches is the so-called electric cord speech,
which he gave in Chicago, where he talks about, you know, Americans are not only the descendants
of the Mayflower. There have been many people who come, you know, from different parts of Europe,
and they are all equally Americans. Right. So that sounds a little bit like that universalist idea
that we're supposed to open our borders to the whole world. But the flip side of it,
which people forget, is the electric cord has to mean we're bound by those common principles.
We're bound by common allegiance. We're bound by adopting certain opinions and virtues and habits
that make us Americans. There is something to that identity. And so that wonderful speech by
Lincoln is very easy to misunderstand. And I think Jaffa's explanation provides a good corrective of
that. We've all but abandoned, I mean, not leaving aside the problem of illegal immigrants,
even with legal immigrants, we've really abandoned to an extraordinary degree the idea that people
come here are supposed to assimilate and become Americans. And that means understanding and
adopting the principles and habits and virtues that make American citizenship possible.
Yes, this is something I think that the kind of advocates of mass immigration will kind of
overlook a lot of the time, that even if you think we should be this grand nation of immigrants,
like you surely have to take along with that the idea that immigrants should be
thoroughly schooled in the sorts of high order principles that we've been discussing.
I wonder if you had a way to just, maybe someday you will, if you were called upon to design
the curriculum for new entrants to this country in 2026, sort of fitting all of these large ideas
that we've been talking about to our present situation, do you have any thoughts about
what that would look like in an ideal world? Yeah, I've not given any thought. I mean,
no one ever asked me to design the citizenship test.
Not yet. Not yet.
Yeah, yeah, yeah. I mean, I bet you wouldn't go very wrong if you looked at what thoughtful
people came up with when that was first devised. I mean, in the very earliest days of the Republic,
basically we had a whole continent west of the Appalachians and there wasn't too much attention.
But when American law first then established principles for formalizing American citizenship
and a naturalization test, I would bet that those first tests were pretty good. And the first thing
I'd do is go back and look at those. It's sort of like all these homeschoolers who are going back
and looking at McGuffey readers. Turns out they're pretty good. I mean, the American people were
pretty sensible and pretty smart and they understood their own founding and their own
constitution pretty well. And so I would bet the first citizenship test we had were pretty sound.
Yeah. Okay. So this raises another sort of following question that I have about,
it's one thing to say to a people steeped in history and a kind of common consensus about
their national objectives, you must now live up to those objectives more highly. It's another
thing to say to a people that has been miseducated and uneducated and diseducated,
you must now recover these ideals. And this is a problem that is, I think, very much live
in the Republic to return to a classical source that we sort of began with. And I know that
it was a concern of Jaffa as well. What are the measures that you have to take in order to
take people who are already at the age of majority? So you can't, you're not educating
young people, you're not educating new arrivals. You're just saying our population needs to get
back on this train. How much hope do you have for that? How do you think that works if it does?
And where do we go from here? Yeah. Boy, I'm not sure I have a short answer. I'll only say this
and I'll maybe make a little commercial here for Jaffa and Claremont Institute as doing something
almost unique within the world of conservative policy organizations and think tanks, which is
the way Jaffa and his students and their students, now over 40 some years, bring to bear a close,
thoughtful understanding of political philosophy, going back to Plato and Aristotle and the Romans
and the whole history of Western philosophy, and an understanding of how modern philosophy
had really nefarious political effects. And you can't understand the problems in America,
or even in the whole Western world, without understanding the role that philosophy had
in the corruption of thought, in the degradation of our educational system,
in the degradation of our morals. And there's a tremendous amount of work to be done to
un-teach all the intellectual corruption that now suffuses our culture and suffuses our education
system from elementary school all the way up to graduate schools. And I think Jaffa's approach
with his background in studying with Strauss and then applying a broad framework of political
philosophy to understanding America is enormously valuable and especially valuable today because it
combines this big theoretical picture with a patriotic commitment to American liberty.
And I think you don't find that really anywhere else.
Yeah, you're making me think of an analog. Ryan Williams and I have been doing this series on
the Trump v. Slaughter case, which is about, of course, the administrative state. And there was
a very revealing exchange between John Sauer, the Solicitor General, and I think it was Sotomayor,
saying, basically, how do you expect us to overturn Humphrey's executor, this major
case for the administrative state, if this is the whole government now? This is just what we do,
right? And similarly, at a philosophical level, I think the degree to which that unlearning has to
be radical is something that Claremont and Claremont-Vaughn, as an inheritance from Jaffa,
I think is pretty good at stressing. Which leads me to my next question, and that is,
as a student of Jaffa, when you showed up bright-eyed and bushy-tailed to his seminars,
did you have to unlearn anything? What was it like for you, I guess,
entering into the presence of this guy? Sure. I mean, yes, I had to unlearn things,
as we all did. I was lucky. So my whole cohort, which includes people that a lot of the audience
will know, Mike Anton, RJ Pastritto, who's my roommate, who's now at Hillsdale, Phil Monius
at Notre Dame, we were all at graduate school together at the same time. Jaffa had retired
officially. Against his will, he was forced to retire, but didn't ride off into the sunset by
any means. He was around. He appropriated a large room in the basement of the library,
and he continued to teach informally. So in a way, it was not better, necessarily, but
really wonderful in that we could simply go and pick his brain for hours at a time.
And he'd paddle over to the Claremont Institute offices, where some of us were doing part-time
work, and he'd just give impromptu lectures. And so we were all of his students, although he had
stopped giving formal classes at that point. But yes, I think we all had to unlearn various things
that we had. I don't even know where to start, but it was a great educational correction.
Yeah, I think sometimes people talk a lot about Straussianism, and it becomes this
impenetrable thicket of different doctrinal disputes. But something that you have driven
home for me, and that I've seen also in practice, is that if Straussianism is anything,
it's a tradition of teaching. In other words, we do a lot of reading, a lot of talking about
these books, as we've done today, both from the founding and as a scholarship on the founding.
But it's in teaching and in the teacher-student relationship, perhaps, that Straussianism
shows what it is and what it's capable of. Is that fair to say?
Absolutely. And if I can indulge in a little plug, I have a book coming out a year from now.
It's been accepted at SUNY University Press. I'm the editor. And it's 19 essays on Strauss'
most influential students. So I have the essay on Jaffa, but there's essays on Alan Bloom,
and Harvey Mansfield, and Joseph Crook, and also on Tom West, and John Reaney, and Harry Newman,
several Claremont people. And the whole idea is Strauss was this extraordinary teacher,
and his students, in turn, have become quite extraordinary teachers. So that book,
which is titled Guardians of Inquiry, will be out from SUNY University Press next year.
Excellent. We love a plug. Yes. All logrolling is welcome and appreciated.
And yeah, I think that you see that in the delight and affection with which
people in this line of succession talk about their most immediate Dr. Fatah or the person
that they learned from. And you get that, I think, in your book, The Soul of Politics,
which I'm now going to plug one more time as we close out here, because it is just a wonderful
introduction to the man and his thought, and to many of the higher order questions, and indeed,
particular anecdotes that we've been discussing here today. Glenn Elmers, it's been a delight.
Thank you very much for joining us. Thank you, Spencer. It was great.