Trapped! The harrowing story of Virgin Flight 024

Airlines in the World
86 followers
23 Video Views·May 10, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
It was half past seven on the evening of November 5th 1997 when the crew of a Virgin Atlantic Airbus
A340 reported for duty at Los Angeles International Airport. Around the same time 98 passengers were
arriving at the airport and checking in their bags for the long journey to London Heathrow.
The aircraft they were flying on was a four-year-old Airbus A340-300.
The A340 was a modern aircraft with an excellent safety record.
Operating as flight 24, this aircraft would fly through the night across the North American
continent and out over the Atlantic Ocean before touching down in the UK the next afternoon.
The flight was scheduled to take about 10 and a half hours.
Up in the cockpit of the four-engined aircraft were three flight crew members.
Sitting in the left-hand seat was 40-year-old captain Tim Barnby. Barnby was an experienced
pilot with more than 14,000 flying hours, just short of 3,000 of which were on the Airbus A340.
As it would turn out, he would need to draw on every one of these hours as the flight neared
Heathrow. Joining him in the cockpit was 32-year-old First Officer Andrew Morley.
Morley was new to the A340, with just 301 hours on the jet. However, he had over 4,500 hours on
the Airbus A320 and Fokker 100, meaning he was by no means an inexperienced pilot.
Sitting behind the two operating pilots was a relief pilot, 28-year-old First Officer Craig
Matheson. Matheson would take over from each of the pilots in turn during a portion of the
cruise. This would allow them to get some rest so that they would be fresh for the arrival into
London. Like First Officer Morley, Matheson was new to the A340, with just under 300 hours on
the aircraft. However, he had over 4,500 total hours of flying time. As the 13 cabin crew members
helped the passengers settle into their seats, the baggage was loaded and the pilots completed
the last of their pre-departure checks. The aircraft was loaded with 73 metric tons of fuel
for the long journey east. As soon as the final checks were complete, the cabin crew closed the
doors and flight 24 was ready to go. Just before 9 o'clock that night, slightly behind schedule,
the aircraft was pushed back from the gate at Los Angeles. The pilots started the plane's four
engines and began taxiing out to runway 24L. Their departure route would take them out over
the Pacific Ocean initially, and then northeast towards the UK. The First Officer was flying the
aircraft on this night, while the Captain handled the radios and did the paperwork.
All appeared normal as the plane taxied out. After a short taxi, the First Officer lined up
on the runway and set take-off thrust. Within moments, the plane was airborne,
and the Captain raised the landing gear. But unbeknownst to him, this routine action of raising
the landing gear had set in motion a chain of events which would change the course of flight 24
dramatically. As the left main gear retracted into its bay, a torque pin came loose. This pin
then tumbled all the way down, landing on the shoreline just outside the airport perimeter.
In the cockpit, the pilots had no way of knowing that this had just happened.
All they noticed was that the landing gear took a bit longer than usual to retract.
They had no idea that not all of their A340 would be accompanying them to London.
Blissfully unaware, the First Officer engaged the autopilot, and the aircraft began turning
northeast. The pilots and passengers alike were treated to an incredible view of the
sprawling lights of Los Angeles as their plane climbed out over the Pacific Ocean.
The A340 is a highly advanced aircraft, with sensors located all around it,
sending a constant stream of data to the plane's computers. Not too dissimilar to
how you send out mountains of data whenever you do anything online, and that's where this video's
sponsor, Incogni, comes in. Unlike the case for aircraft though, you probably don't want your
data to be scooped up wherever you go. When it is, data brokers sell it to businesses and marketing
agencies, leading to spam calls, emails, and even identity theft. If you're like me, you've already
experienced the negative effects of having your data stolen. I get countless spam and phishing
emails every week. This is one of the problems that I've been able to solve with Incogni,
which reaches out to data brokers on my behalf and gets my personal data removed from the internet.
And, importantly, they don't just get it removed once and leave it at that.
They make sure that it is taken down whenever it pops up again. This doesn't just go for email
addresses though. Any information you share online can get stolen and sold. Your home address,
your credit card information, your phone number, even your political beliefs and your employment
history. If you live in the US, you may even be up on a people search site, where anyone,
including landlords, employers, and random strangers can look you up and access your
personal information. You could track down all of the places your data appears online yourself
and get it removed. This would take hundreds of hours to do. Incogni makes this mammoth task
simple by doing it all for you, which means less spam calls, lower exposure to cyber attacks,
and reduce financial risks. Sign up to Incogni today using my link in the video description
or in the pinned comment on this video. You can get an individual plan for yourself or you can
protect your whole family with a family and friends plan, which covers up to 4 people.
Make sure to use my code GREENDOT to get 60% off your purchase. What's more, Incogni are confident
enough that you'll like their service that if you change your mind within the first 30 days,
you'll get a full refund. So, click on that link in the video description and pinned comment and
use my code GREENDOT. But for now, back to the video. Before long, Flight 24 had reached its
initial cruising altitude. With 13 cabin crew members attending to just 98 passengers, the meal
service went by quickly. Once it was finished, many of the passengers tried to get some sleep.
When they landed in Heathrow, it would be bright in the afternoon of the next day.
But just as the passengers settled in, up in the cockpit, an unusual indication had caught the
pilots' attention. While carrying out a routine review of the aircraft's systems, the pilots
had discovered something odd. The brake temperature sensor for the inner rear wheel of the left main
gear displayed two crosses, meaning no signal. The A340 is a highly sophisticated aircraft,
with banks of computers monitoring inputs from hundreds of sensors around the plane.
One faulty sensor, especially a single brake temperature sensor, wasn't too much cause for
concern. But the pilots didn't know that this time, this odd reading had a much more serious cause,
one which wouldn't make itself fully known to them until they were just moments from landing.
For the next few hours, the plane cruised peacefully eastwards, all while the Terminator
line, the line separating night from day, moved westwards towards it. By the time the plane had
reached the Atlantic Ocean, the first glimmerings of sunrise were appearing on the horizon.
It was a stunning sight for any passengers still awake, and for the pilots, it was the
calm before a storm they would soon unwittingly enter. Almost 10 hours after leaving Los Angeles,
flight 24 had begun its descent towards London's Heathrow airport. First officer Morley was back
at the controls after his rest, with Captain Barnaby to his left, and relief pilot Matheson
behind them. The weather that afternoon was good, with winds from the south, some clouds,
and great visibility. Air traffic control had told the crew to expect runway 27L for landing.
In just a few minutes, the flight would be making its final approach.
Just after 3pm, the first officer lined up with runway 27R at Heathrow.
The flaps were set, the speed brakes were in the ironed position,
and the airspeed was coming back nicely. The final step now was to lower the gear.
But just 8 miles from the runway, when the captain lowered the landing gear lever,
something strange happened. The right main landing gear and the nose gear extended and
locked into place as normal, but the left main gear appeared not to have moved.
The plane's computer sent out a gear unsafe warning, and more related warnings appeared
on the ECAM, the pilot's central display. There was no way the pilots could land in
this condition. If they did, the aircraft could go careening off the side of the runway,
possibly breaking apart, or even worse, crashing into the passenger terminal buildings.
However, sometimes it takes a bit longer than normal for the gear to extend.
There was a chance that the problem would right itself before they reached the ground.
So, they continued the approach, keeping a close eye on the gear indications.
But as they got closer to the runway, it became clear that the gear was not going to extend.
As they descended through 1400 feet, the first officer raised the landing gear,
and shortly after put the plane into a climb. The captain informed the tower controller that
the fight was carrying out a missed approach. Initially, the pilots figured that the gear
may have just been slow to extend. Now that they were carrying out a missed approach,
they would have more than enough time to get it down.
But as soon as they raised the gear, they got another unwelcome message.
The left landing gear hadn't locked up into place. In other words, it was neither up nor down,
it appeared to be stuck somewhere in the middle, not the best place for landing gear.
The captain informed air traffic control of the situation, and the pilots were given radar
vectors to the Bovingdon radio beacon. They began climbing to 8000 feet. At Bovingdon,
they would enter a holding pattern, giving them time to troubleshoot the issue.
The first thing the pilots tried was the gravity gear extension procedure.
They slowed to between 190 and 200 knots, lowered the landing gear lever, and then used the gravity
gear extension handle. This releases all of the hydraulic pressure, letting the gear extend and
lock into place by gravity alone. If there was a hydraulic problem with the left main gear,
this should get around it. They waited, and watched the indications closely.
But to their surprise, this had no effect. The other gear had lowered as normal, but the left
gear still appeared to be stuck. Whatever the problem was, it couldn't be solved by their
normal procedures. Luckily for the crew, they had encountered this issue just a few miles from the
Virgin Atlantic operations department at Heathrow airport. This meant that as they held at Bovingdon
to the north of the airport, they were well within radio range of the people who were perhaps best
able to give them expert advice. The captain contacted operations over the radio and informed
them of the flight's predicament. On the other end of the line were maintenance engineers and the
chief pilot and A340 fleet manager. If they couldn't help the captain, he would be pretty
much out of luck. The engineers suggested pulling and resetting some circuit breakers associated
with the landing gear in case there was an electrical issue. The pilots tried this, and
tried lowering the gear again. They watched their instruments, eagerly awaiting the extension
of the left main gear. But again, it did nothing. Then the engineers suggested the old classic
technique of raising the gear handle lever and then lowering it again, and then lowering the
gear by gravity extension. But no matter what the pilots did, they couldn't seem to get the gear to
extend. Flight 24 continued holding above London. After much troubleshooting, it began to dawn on
the crew that they may have no other choice but to land their massive aircraft without one of the
landing gear legs. To say this posed a challenge was an understatement. This was something the
pilots had never practiced in the simulator, and now they might have to do it for the first time
in the real aircraft with over 100 people on board. But the passengers and crew were not the
only ones who'd be affected by a crash landing at Heathrow. As soon as the airport's operations
duty manager found out about the stricken plane, he contacted the airline and told them that if
their flight crash landed at Heathrow, the airport would be left with only one main runway, causing
major congestion. As a result, he suggested that the pilots diverted to Manston Airport in Kent,
south-east England. This was a reasonable suggestion. Manston was a military base with
a 9,000ft long runway, well suited for a large aircraft like the A340. The airport had fire
rescue services and they would be ready for flight 24's arrival if the captain did decide to divert
there. But unfortunately, time was not on the captain's side. As the four-engine plane flew
around the hold at 8,000ft, it was burning fuel quickly. If the captain was going to divert,
he would need to make this decision soon. The plane had only one hour of fuel remaining.
But before doing anything as potentially catastrophic as landing without one of the
gear, the captain wanted to be absolutely certain that it even had a problem to begin with.
After all, it was possible that there was nothing wrong with the gear at all,
and that faulty sensors were the cause of all the indications.
From their position in the cockpit, the pilots had no way of knowing for sure what the issue was.
What they needed was for somebody on the ground to tell them.
So, the captain asked air traffic control if he could do something that very few pilots
will ever get to attempt at a busy airport like London Heathrow. He asked for a low-level approach
to runway 27R followed by a flyby of the control tower right over the centre of the airport.
This way, controllers could verify the status of the landing gear.
This manoeuvre was approved by air traffic control. The captain informed the passengers
and flight attendants of his plan. When they saw the terminals of Heathrow airport going by
right outside their windows, they were not to be concerned. Within a few minutes,
the captain had lined up with the runway. He was now acting as pilot flying, with the first officer
acting as pilot monitoring, and the relief pilot helping out with procedures and checklists.
It was a busy few minutes as the aircraft neared the runway. An engineer from the airline had raced
to the tower so that he would be ready to check the landing gear when the plane passed overhead.
With the aircraft barely 300ft above the ground, only slightly more than the wingspan of the A340,
the captain banked to the left and headed directly towards the control tower at Heathrow.
As he neared the centre of the airport, he banked to the right, giving those in the tower a clear
view of the left main gear and belly of the A340. The engineer standing in the control tower
determined that the left gear was partially extended and he described it to the crew of
flight 24 as hanging in the bay. This was not good news, but the pilots weren't expecting much better.
Now with the true state of the gear known, the captain began climbing and turning back northeast.
Eager to get the gear fully down for a safe landing, the crew wanted to spend a few more
minutes troubleshooting before attempting another approach. And this time, given that they had
already exhausted their checklists, the airline's A340 fleet manager suggested over the radio that
they try something a little unorthodox. He proposed that the pilots come back around for another
approach, but rather than trying to land, they should touch down on the right main gear in an
effort to bump the left landing gear down. The idea here was that this may shake free whatever
was preventing the left gear from extending. This was a risky manoeuvre. In order for it to
have any chance of working, the pilots would need to come down quite hard. But at the same time,
they couldn't come down so hard that they would break the only good landing gear they had left.
On top of this, there was also the chance that upon touching down on the right hand side,
the plane would just tilt over to the left and come crashing down, skidding off the runway.
The pilots were tempted. Landing without the left main gear was fraught with danger.
If they had any chance of lowering it, they would take it.
As they discussed this possibility with each other, the low fuel warning came on in the cockpit.
On top of all the other pressures they were facing, they now had the issue of time to contend
with. They had to make the right decision, and they had to make it fast. On top of the other
dangers inherent in the attempt to bump the landing gear free on the runway, even if it did
work, the pilots would still have to come back around and land again once they had freed the
gear. The extra fuel required for this was a luxury the pilots simply didn't have at this point,
and after already being on duty for 12 hours through the night, the pilots themselves were
now low on mental fuel too. With all of this in mind, the captain decided that the next approach
they would do would be their final one, and to keep things familiar, he decided that he would
be landing at London Heathrow, not Manston. The emergency vehicles at Heathrow got ready,
as Flight 24 began preparations for its final approach. Still trying to think of any last
minute solutions to the gear problem, maintenance personnel at Virgin Atlantic came up with another
idea. Rather than using g-forces on the ground to free the gear, what if the pilots used them
in the air? They asked the captain to try what would be a rather uncomfortable and frightening
manoeuvre for the passengers, to put the plane in a steep turn and keep pulling back on the side
stick in order to induce enough g-forces to pull the landing gear down. This was like a gravity
extension, but with more gravity. Again, it wasn't in the procedures, but it made sense,
and the captain figured that it was worth a shot. He put the plane in a steep turn with as much as
50 degrees angle of bank, so steep that it was closer to being on its side than straight and
level. With the high workload the pilots were under at this point, they hadn't warned the
passengers that they were going to do this beforehand. As they felt the plane turn sharply
and got pushed into their seats by the powerful g-forces, many of the passengers became nervous.
During the turn, they weighed one and a half times their normal weight.
As the captain banked low over London, the pilots watched their instruments carefully.
This really was a last-ditch effort to get the gear down. The seconds ticked on, but as they did,
the indications didn't change. Even weighing 1.5 times their normal weight wasn't enough to pull
the gear down. There was no denying it now. This would be an emergency landing.
Coming up to 10 minutes past 4 that afternoon, the crew declared a mayday to air traffic control.
All departing aircraft were stopped, arriving aircraft were put into holding patterns,
and the runways and taxiways were cleared of aircraft and vehicles.
The airport firetrucks now began racing towards the runway, and were given permission to enter
it once the A340 had touched down. Everybody on the ground was preparing for the worst.
Now, more low fuel warnings began appearing in the cockpit. The pilots really did have to land
as soon as possible. But still, there was another consideration to make. There was a 13 knot crosswind
from the south. Because the plane's vertical stabilizer acts like a weather vane, the aircraft
tends to point into the wind. If the pilots landed on runway 27R and lost control, there was
a chance they would go off the runway to the left and crash into the passenger terminal buildings
at Heathrow. The safer option, therefore, was to land on runway 27L. That way, if they went
off the side of the runway, they were less likely to crash into occupied buildings. With that in
mind, the pilots began setting up to land on runway 27L at Heathrow. To further increase
their chances of staying on the runway, the fleet manager suggested to the pilots that they land on
the right hand side of the runway. This way, when the aircraft swung to the left after touchdown,
it would have much more runway to eat into before going off the side.
This assistance from people on the ground was crucial, as even the augmented crew of three in
the cockpit was struggling to keep up with the intense workload as they configured the plane for
landing. It was an extremely busy environment, with constant communication within the cockpit
and between the cockpit and air traffic control, the airline, and the cabin crew. The pilots were
functioning well together as a team, with the captain flying the aircraft, the first officer
assisting with communications with air traffic control and the company, while the relief pilot
helped find information in manuals and kept the cabin crew informed of the situation.
To give them more time to run their checklists, the captain asked air traffic control for a 360
degree turn, which was granted. The pilots retracted the landing gear once more and went
through the checklist from the top to ensure that nothing had been overlooked. They also told the
cabin crew to prepare for an emergency landing and possible evacuation. These were the final,
crucial few minutes when the pilots still had the aircraft under control. They would need to do
everything they could to maximise their chances of a successful outcome now. When they got on the
ground, there would be very little they could do. At this point, nearing the approach path for the
runway, the pilots reviewed the checklist for landing with abnormal gear.
And here, they would meet one of the more important considerations they would have to make.
As it turned out, the pilots didn't agree with the instructions given in the checklist.
It told them to shut down all of the engines just before touchdown. The reason for this was clear,
the engines would pose a serious fire risk once they began scraping along the ground.
But the pilots knew that there was more to think about than just the risk of fire.
The engines supply hydraulic power to the flight controls. If the pilots shut them
down when they landed, they would have very little control over the aircraft.
They would essentially become passengers in their own airplane as it scraped and skidded
along the runway. To make this crash landing as survivable as possible, they would need to
be able to control the aircraft for as long as they could, even if that increased the risk of
fire. After discussing various possibilities with his colleagues, the captain devised a plan.
They would touch down on the right main gear, on the right hand side of the runway.
As soon as they touched down, the relief pilot would turn off engines 1 and 4,
the two outboard engines on the end of the wings. These were the engines that would hit the ground
first, and shutting them both down would reduce the chances of the plane swinging significantly
after landing. By keeping engines 2 and 3 running, the plane would retain hydraulic power,
which would allow the captain to control it using his side stick. He would use this control to hold
the left wing in the air for as long as possible, keeping the engines off the runway. Then, when
the aircraft had slowed down to the point that the wing could no longer stay in the air, the pilots
would shut down the remaining engine on the left hand side, followed shortly after by the inboard
engine on the right hand side. This careful, progressive shutdown of the aircraft's power
plants was aimed at balancing the risk of fire with the need to maintain control of the plane
for as long as possible on the ground. This was the plan anyway. Whether it actually worked,
as they zoomed along the runway at over 130 knots, or 240kmh, was another question entirely.
The fact was that the crew had now become test pilots, and their passengers unwitting guinea
pigs. Finally, the captain turned to line up for runway 27L. In a few moments, he would see if his
bet on the landing technique would pay off. Descending through 1,000ft, the pilots warned
the flight attendants and passengers that landing was imminent. Tension was high. There
was nothing the crew could do now but action their plan, and hope for the best. Just 200ft above the
ground, the pilots gave the order to brace. The flight attendants repeatedly shouted to the
passengers to adopt the brace position as the aircraft neared the runway. This was the moment
of truth. The captain kept the plane heading for the right hand side of the runway. Sitting behind
him with an overview of the cockpit, the relief pilot readied himself to shut down engines 1 and
4 on touchdown. Finally, the right main gear touched the ground. The relief pilot cut engines
1 and 4 immediately. The captain held the left wing up, but he went a bit too far and the outboard
engine on the right hand side scraped along the runway, sending sparks flying. The passengers held
on tight as the aircraft swung and shuddered violently. Fire crews began racing towards the
As the plane slowed down, it became harder and harder for the captain to hold the left wing in
the air. He knew he would now need to bring it down. He slowly released pressure on the side
stick and ordered for the inboard engine on the left hand side to be shut down, which the relief
pilot did. The left engines touched the ground, producing a trail of sparks and smoke along the
runway. The captain began braking, and then ordered the shutdown of the number 3 engine.
The aircraft skidded to the left, and the captain pushed his right rudder fully to the stop,
trying desperately to keep it from veering off the runway. This skidding put major stress on
the right main wheels, causing the tyres to burst. Finally, after a harrowing ordeal,
the aircraft came to a halt on the runway. Incredibly, everybody on board was safe,
with nobody sustaining even minor injuries during the landing. Within 3 minutes of touching down,
all of the 114 passengers and crew had evacuated. Captain Barnaby's technique for landing the
aircraft and shutting down the engines had proven so successful that Airbus adopted it
as their official procedure after the incident. As for the cause of the gear trouble in the first
place, investigators were not able to determine the exact failure sequence, as the gear assembly
was missing crucial parts. However, it was clear that the pin which came loose and was found on
the shore of the Pacific Ocean back at Los Angeles had been subject to higher loads than
anticipated by Airbus during its life, and therefore that the assembly which it was part of
would need to be redesigned. Nothing the pilots could have done during the flight would have been
able to free the gear. Airbus have since redesigned this part, making jammed landing gear much less
likely in future. On top of this, the changes they made to the checklists and to the quick
reference handbook have meant that crews are now better equipped to deal with these problems when
they do occur. This was an incident which could have ended up much worse were it not for the calm,
methodical approach demonstrated by the flight crew, the help they got from those on the ground,
and the willingness of everybody on board to think outside the box to accomplish a safe landing.
