Is California's mail ballot system as exposed as critics suggest, or is the real story more complicated than what either side suggests?
Every election cycle, the same concerns resurface: ballots getting lost, signatures going unchecked, and results taking weeks to finalize. But the operational reality inside a county registrar's office tells a different story.
In this episode, Orange County Registrar of Voters Bob Page, who has been overseeing elections since 2018 and runs one of the largest county operations in the state, breaks down the mechanics of California's vote-by-mail system, the certification timeline, the upcoming voter ID initiative, and what petition signature fraud looks like from inside the office responsible for catching it.
00:00 - Intro 00:48 - Mail-In Ballot Process 02:47 - Concerns About Ballot Theft and Verification 12:24 - Challenges with Mail-In Ballots and Certification Delays 19:50 - Confidence in Election Results and Voter ID Initiative 31:20 - Registrar of Voters Role and Responsibilities
Every registered voter in California will get a ballot in California elections. Some people think
this is not good and is creating risks for elections. Let's find out if this is true. We
sit down with Bob Page to analyze the election process in California. He's going to take us
through all the steps, mailing the ballots, counting them, and what it takes to get the results.
I'm Siamak. Welcome to California Insider. Bob, it's great to have you. Welcome.
Thank you for having me. Appreciate it. We want to talk to you about elections in California.
Okay. And mailing ballots is a big concern for a lot of Californians, and the time it takes to
get the results is another concern. Can you tell us how the mailing ballot works? Yeah, so in
California law, every county is required to mail ballots to all active registered voters.
And we're required to do that at least 29 days before election day. In Orange County,
our register of voters actually is certified by the Secretary of State to actually print
vote-by-mail ballots. So we do everything in-house. We print about 1.9 million ballots.
We will be mailing them coming up soon. Probably before this airs, the Postal Service is picking
up the ballots on May 2nd. So voters will start seeing those ballots in their mailboxes starting
on Monday, May 4th. So everyone will get it, even if you plan to go in person? Yeah. Even if you
want to vote in person, state law requires that we mail a ballot to every active registered voter.
So all 1.9 million voters in Orange County will receive a ballot. We have certain things that we
put in place to make sure they get the right ballot, that they only get one ballot. One of
those things is that we, as I said, we print and prepare for mailing all the ballots ourselves.
So we have some equipment, some mailing equipment that takes a roll of paper, slices the ballots,
folds them, adds some instructions, puts them in an envelope. And every hundredth ballot that
comes out of that inserting machine, we then pull aside and quality check it to make sure that the
ballot for the precinct that's in the envelope matches the precinct for the voter to make sure
they're getting the correct ballot. So every hundredth ballot we're doing, we're double
checking to make sure the voter is getting the correct ballot. Then before we actually mail,
and once all the ballots are, you know, the envelopes are sealed, we are running those
envelopes through another piece of equipment, mail sorter, to scan the barcode on the outside
that's unique to the voter that we keep track to make sure we're only sending one ballot to
every voter. Some people have concerns. There's a couple of concerns. One is that ballots getting
lost or taken in the post office. How does that process work? Yeah, I mean, obviously in today's
society, in California and other parts of the country, there is a problem with mail theft,
right? I've never come across a situation where somebody specifically was trying to steal ballots,
but it is very common that on the week that we're mailing ballots, some people won't get their
ballots because of a theft. We actually had a situation in the special election, November 2025,
where somebody on the day that ballots were being mailed to voters, stole a whole post office
vehicle. So it had ballots for like a whole neighborhood on it. So once we found that out
from the postal service, we worked with them and with the police department, identified which voters
didn't receive their mail that day, and then we just did replacement ballots and got them
mailed back out to those folks. So we hear about these stories. How much theft is there? Is that
minimal or how do you guys see them? I don't have a number, but every election we're getting reports
of certain neighborhoods where mail theft occurred. Again, it's never an indication that
they're trying to steal the ballots. It's just there's general mail theft in the communities
right now. And so we're used to working with the postal inspectors and communicating with them.
When we find out about theft, we then work with the voters to make sure that we get them a ballot.
Another concern for people is that because everybody's receiving these ballots and if there
could be risks of some people that are registered and they might have passed away, or can you tell
us more about that? How does that work for you guys to verify that the actual people that are
receiving these ballots are legitimate people that can vote their citizens? Well, I'll first talk
about how we verify that the ballot we get back is from the voter. In California, if you vote by mail,
you're required to sign the return envelope. We then at our office compare, our staff compares
the signature that's on each ballot envelope with the signatures we have for that voter on file.
We're looking for similarities and it actually takes three people on my staff to agree that
there's significant enough differences between the signature on the envelope and the signatures
we have on file to actually challenge the ballot. And so, you know, we've got a process where when
the ballot comes in, it goes through that same sorting machine that I mentioned. It's scanning
to give the voter the barcode on the envelope to make sure that we know that the voter has voted
a ballot. So if they showed up that later that same day to try to vote in person, the voting
roster will show that person's already cast a ballot. So it's scanning the barcode to make
sure we give the voter credit. It's also taking an image of the signature on the envelope so that
teams that are working at computer stations can pull up the signature images for each ballot
and do that comparison. Then once all of the signatures have been reviewed and compared,
all the envelopes from that batch will be sent back through the mail sorter and they'll be sorted
between the signatures that were accepted and the signatures that were challenged. And then the ones
that have been accepted, then they go through the process of removing the ballot from the envelopes
and preparing them for actually scanning and tabulating the votes on them. So there's a
process. Every single ballot that comes in is processed and we do a signature verification on
it. If you step back then in terms of how do we make sure that only eligible voters are registered,
we are maintaining our voter registration file on a daily basis. In 2024 during the presidential
election year, on average we made 81,000 transaction updates to voter registration
records a month. So every day you're updating? Every day we're updating. I mean I always get
asked how often do you purge? We are working the file every single day. We've got a big team
because obviously if you've got 81,000 transactions a month and you have only five days to get that
work updated, you need to make sure you've got a good trained staff and enough people to work
through those. And how do you update them based on the information? Where do you get the information
from? What kind of criteria is? Yeah so the information comes from official government
sources or from the voter themselves. So a common example will be if we say we mail a ballot to
somebody and the post office can't deliver it because that person doesn't live there anymore,
the postal service can't forward the ballot. It has to come back to us. But if there's a forwarding
order on file, they'll attach that forwarding sticker to the envelope when it comes back to us
so that we can then update the record and say okay the forwarding address is still
in Orange County. We can update it or the forwarding address is in another county in the
state so we forward the information to that county so they can make that that person one of their
voters. Or if it says that the forwarding is out of state, then if it's out of state we actually
inactivate the voter. We then send them a notice that's forwardable and says hey we've received
information that you are no longer at the address that you're registered. We asked you to update
your voter registration information and we tell them that if they don't update the registration
information between the date they receive the notice and the second federal general election
in November of even-numbered years, they can be canceled after that point. That's part of federal
law under the National Voter Registration Act is we have to have that give them that advance notice
and give them two November even-numbered year elections that amount of time to actually update
the registration and if they don't then we do we do cancel them. We actually after the 2024
general election went through all of the inactive records and found the people we had sent notices
to before the November 2022 election and we canceled 176,000 inactive voters. They were
inactive so they weren't receiving ballots, they weren't getting other mail. Once you're inactive
you're on the roll but you're not actually receiving ballots anymore. Is there a chance
for people out of state to be able to vote? Is there a way for people if they wanted to
maliciously to just register here but register in another another state? Well when when people
register to vote under federal law if they're registering by mail they're required to provide
ID information so that their identity can be verified at the time they're registered to vote
and typically what that is is someone will give this their California driver's license number,
the last four the social security number and then that's how we verify at the time of
registration that this is a person who is eligible to vote. If they don't provide that
information when they register then they're flagged so that if they try to vote in a federal election
if they haven't provided proof of identity their ballot's not going to be processed.
In terms of you know could somebody be registered have a California ID and then move out of state
register there and not cancel? That's possible because we we're not getting information from
other states. So somebody is doing that in Arizona or they have a house in Arizona and
they have a place here or they have an address here it's hard for you guys cannot verify. Yeah
we don't get information from Arizona but obviously if we get information that somebody's
no longer living in California we will investigate that and if we need to we'll refer them to the
Secretary of State and to the District Attorney for investigation. In terms of the signatures you
said when these ballots come in you have three people looking at the signatures is it using this
computerized system or is it people actually trying to compare them? Currently it's people we are
looking at the possibility of incorporating automatic signature verification software
into the process but the way state law is written it takes three people to actually reject a
signature. So even if we use software you know software to verify the signatures if the software
says it's not the voter's signature I'm going to have to have humans actually review that work
before. So three people have to say these signatures don't match? Correct. And what about the results
when people mailing the ballots? Yeah. Some of them don't get counted I've seen some numbers as much
as one percent. In terms of rejected? Rejected. Can you tell us about that? Yeah I mean the common
reasons for rejection are the signature is missing or the signature doesn't compare or the ballot is
received too late. Those are the main three reasons why a ballot will get rejected. If there's a
signature issue where I'm required under state law to send a first class notice mail notice to the
voter to say hey you forgot to sign your envelope or your signature didn't compare here's a statement
for you to verify that you did vote this ballot and then we if that comes back then we're comparing
the signature on the statement to the signatures on file. So those are the main reasons why we have
rejections. Too late in California as long as the ballot is postmarked by election day or we receive
it by the close of polls if somebody can drop it off if they want in the envelope at one of our
drop boxes at a vote center or our office and as long as we get it handed to us by 8 p.m it's
eligible. If they want to put it in the mail which we pay the return postage they have until
that day on election day to make sure it's postmarked and then the postal service has
seven days to actually deliver it to my office and so if the ballot is postmarked after election day
it's rejected as being too late. If for some reason it was postmarked on election day but
the postal service got it to me eight days later it's going to be rejected for being too late.
What about the certifying? That's another major complaint in California is that it takes us a
long time to certify this. Can you tell us about that? What's the process like? Why does it take
so long? Well there's a couple things. One is we have to make sure that all the ballots we receive
are processed. So depending on voter behavior whether people voted early or they waited till
election day to turn their ballot in can impact how much time it takes to finish processing those.
What I will say is in Orange County since you know the two 2024 elections as well as the 25
special election those vote by mail ballots we received before election day we had about 90
percent of those ballots were in the results by 8 0 5 p.m on election night. When people are voting
early we're starting to process the ballots. You know if somebody doesn't wait for to receive their
ballot in the mail on May 4th and comes to my office on May 4th they can get a replacement
ballot they can vote it put it in an envelope and we'll start processing it that day. And so
we're really good about staying on top of it. I believe that 90 percent is a good it usually
takes at least a day to go from receiving a ballot to all the way through the scanner
and the verification and the audit stuff we do to make sure that that we can put it in the results
usually takes at least a day to do that. So when I say 90 percent to me that's good. But we do
receive a large percentage of vote by mail ballots are cast on election day that will either be
dropped off or will receive you know that week after election day. So that takes time. But still
since the 1970s counties have had four weeks to certify elections. It's been in place for a long
time. But what I will tell people is that we are getting more efficient on how we process ballots.
So if you go back to 2018 in Orange County in that general election November 2018
it took until 18 days after election day to have 95 percent of the ballots that were accepted in
the results that were posted. If you compare that to 2024 general election November 2024
we had at least 95 percent of the ballots that we accepted were in the results posted
nine days after election day. So we have through technology and staffing you know
even though there were 400,000 more ballots in 2024 than there were in 2018. But we've gotten
we've become more efficient on how we process those. The big thing that then takes time like
in that 24 election we have to do a tabulation audit to make sure to verify that the voting
system results are correct. And so what we do is called a one percent manual tally.
We will randomly select at least one percent of the precincts in the county.
And typically it ends up being more because you have to also make sure that you select
precincts so that every single contest on the ballot is included in the audit.
And then those randomly selected precincts we have to hand count every single ballot that's
in that precinct. And for the 2024 general election we ended up hand counting more than
39,000 ballots. We had 20 to 24 teams of four people on any given day that were that worked
10 days straight to do those hand counting. And they were working anywhere from nine to 11 hour
days in order to get that done. So we completed the audit the Wednesday of the day before
Thanksgiving which was 22 days after election day. But state law said we had to give voters
until that next Sunday 26 days after to cure a signature challenge to the ballot.
And state law prohibited me from certifying that election before 28 days after. So four
weeks after election day was when the first day I could certify and that's when we did.
My understanding is legislature wanted to come up with a statewide deadline for signature
curing on ballots. And they now after two elections of saying that voters would have
until 26 days after they've now brought it back a little bit to 22 days after. So for this election
this 2026 statewide direct primary the first day that I will be able to certify is 26 or 24 days
after election day that Friday of that third week after election day. I will probably be done
under the last two primary elections that we held in 22 and 24. We certified 17 days after.
So I will probably be at the point in the last week just waiting to see if any more voters
cure a signature challenge to the ballot. But that's an important part of what the legislature
philosophically has to decide is those deadlines. You know how many days do they give the post
office to deliver ballots that are postmarked by election day? And how many days do they give
voters to cure a signature challenge to their ballot? If they change those we might be able to
get done sooner. But there's other things that happen after election day that we have to do
audits to make sure that the results are accurate. Reconciliation to make sure we didn't misplace
anything. You know that's a process that takes time. Does the bulk of the time is this curing
the signatures? Is that is that what is the main reason why they get delayed? We in the last few
years have had 95 percent of the ballots process tabulated in the results anywhere from four to
nine days after election day. So the rest of that four-week period after election day is the audits
or the other ballots. Sometimes a voter will send a ballot and this damage that we know
won't go through the scanner. So we have to copy the votes from the damaged ballot onto a fresh
ballot and then audit that to make sure the votes were copied correctly. There can't be any
personally identifying information on the ballot for the voter. So if a voter initials something
or puts some personal information we've got to transfer the votes onto a clean ballot that we
can scan. And the law also says that if a voter doesn't follow the instructions but it's clear
what their intent was like say rather than filling in the square they circle the names.
If they've circled all the names if we put it through the scanner it's going to show no votes.
But it's very clear from looking at the ballot that the voter meant to vote for those people
that they circled their names. So that we either have to remake those ballots. So after four to
nine days the ballots that are we're still processing are the ones that have been challenged
for the signature issue, missing signature or non-comparing signature. We'll have a certain
number of people who haven't provided proof of identity yet under federal law. We're remaking
ballots and then we have provisionals. So people who aren't registered to vote 15 days before
state law still allows them to register same day and vote. But they vote a provisional ballot which
then requires us to do more research on each provisional ballot. We have to research did this
person vote someplace else in the state already. Are they you know did they put down information
that makes them eligible to vote in California in Orange County. Every once in a while we'll get
a student who shows up at a vote center on campus and they will do same day registration.
But put the address for registration as something in another county where their parents live.
And then we have to reject that ballot because they're not eligible to vote in Orange County
as to how they filled out the registration affidavit. So those provisional ballots take time.
But most of the ballots more than 95 percent are in the results within four to nine days.
You are in this position you're seeing all the process. How confident are you in the results you
guys provide? I'm very confident. I've been overseeing elections since 2018 in two different
counties. Every election we do what the audit I mentioned where we do the hand count. Orange
County also does a discretionary audit called a risk limiting audit which is another way of
manually tallying ballots rather not by precinct but just randomly selected. And every single one
of those audits and for every election that I've overseen since 2018 has not found a single error
by the voting system. Any kind of discrepancy that we find is based on human error. Either the
voter didn't you know mark the ballot correctly and the and the voting system didn't pick up on
say they used a light pencil it wasn't caught before it was put through the scanner to be
remade so the the scanner didn't pick up the the light pencil or they they made a stray mark that
caused it to be an overvote. That's not a an error of the voting system that's a human error that we
then caught in the audit. So as I said every audit we've conducted have confirmed the results
and any little discrepancies have been found have been human error based. What about the registration
side of things? You mentioned in the previous interview when we discussed like there was a
lady that registered her dog to vote in to just test the system. How does that work? Do you think
there is potential for things like that to happen? When people register vote under federal law
they are required to provide proof of identity at the time they register which is typically done
with an ID number that can be you know if they put down a driver's license number and all the
information that they write on the affidavit and that matches the information that the Department
of Motor Vehicles has for that that driver's license number all the same the name the date
of birth the address is all the same then we've verified that voter and you can't vote in a federal
election until that verification has happened. And so we do have right now we have of the 1.9
million voters we have 0.16 percent of our voters so less than two-tenths of a percent of our voters
have not yet provided proof of identity. So if they try to vote in this upcoming primary
they've been flagged and we will then notify them and say if they cast a ballot you still
have not provided proof of identity here's what you can provide us how you can get it to us for
your ballot to be processed. That's under federal law. State law has you know you end up having the
same kind of verification process using the Department of Motor Vehicles but state law says
that if a person doesn't have a driver's license doesn't have a social security number they're
still eligible to vote in California as long as they attest to being eligible that 0.16 percent
of our voters who are flagged they can't cast a ballot this upcoming primary. If there was a local
election in one of our cities that had no federal offices on it that flag would be turned off
because state law doesn't require that proof of identity currently before somebody can vote and so
the situation you mentioned and she just recently actually entered into a plea agreement with the
district attorney's office pleading guilty to one misdemeanor charge of creating fictitious
registration using the name of her pet and she'll be sentenced in October but she was originally
charged with additional charges that she tried to cast two ballots one in the 22 primary election
which the DA said her ballot was rejected for that fictitious registration and one that they said she
cast in the 21 gubernatorial recall election which had no federal offices are on it and the district
attorney in their charging documents said that that ballot was counted but they've now done a
plea agreement with her and she'll be sentenced in October for one misdemeanor count of creating
that fictitious registration. So this 0.16 percent they can vote in local elections but then when it
comes to federal they can't. They cannot. Now in terms of voter ID if we had voter ID how would it
work for you guys? Just recently like in the last week the secretary of state verified that the
petition for the California voter ID initiative had enough signatures on it to qualify for the
ballot in November and so I'll talk about if that became law if the voters approve that in November
of 26 what it would mean. So there's three basic pieces to that initiative in the ordinance that's
written for it. One is that if you want to vote in person you have to present some form of government
ID at the vote center or the polling place to be able to vote. Right now under state law if that
didn't pass what the state law is currently if you vote in person is the voters required to verbally
tell the employee my employee their name and their address and then we look them up in the roster
the voter confirms that's their information they sign under penalty of perjury with a warning
that's underneath the signature says if you're impersonating this person here's the charges you
face. So that's the law currently under the proposed initiative they'd be required to provide
some sort of government ID. It also then says if for people who want to vote by mail ballot
they will have to tell my office ahead of time here's the government ID issued ID for me that
I want to use for the purposes of verifying my vote by mail ballot and I will on the return
envelope write the last four digits of this government ID. So when it comes back to us
we'll not just be checking signatures we'll be checking that those four numbers to verify the
person's ID. The third element of that initiative if it passes is that it will require the state
and counties to on a regular basis verify that the voters on their database are citizens. It's
not clear as to what sources we're supposed to use to verify that it's kept very
general that we are to use some element of government resources to verify citizenship.
So those are the three pieces of that. All of those things are going to require some change
to California certification of electronic poll books, rosters, as well as the election management
systems where we store the voter registration system. So with the poll books I would want them
to be certified to scan somebody's ID. They come with a scanner that you can use to scan the bar
code on a driver's license and it'll look the person up on the database. That's a
feature I would want to have available to my staff if that became law. The election management system
that's certified by the state the counties use and the county voter registration database
vocal I would want that to be updated to allow there to be a field for voters to tell us what
government ID number they want to use for voting by mail purposes. There's not currently an available
field in that system so that's going to have to be updated and certified and I'll be looking to
the Secretary of State if that passes for guidance about how they're going to go about managing the
citizenship verification. Would it make it more efficient for you guys in terms of when somebody
comes with an ID then you can check right there if this is the person? There'll be a give-and-take
so the person voting in person rather than having to look them up on the roster if we're able to
scan their ID that would be more efficient yes. Adding another element to verifying a vote by
mail ballot by having to look up compared not just a signature but comparing the last four
numbers and the likelihood that a voter won't remember what number that they told us they were
going to use and then us having to notify the voter that the numbers don't match to give them
a chance to cure it assuming that's what the state says they will allow then that could add time to
the process so if this becomes approved by the voters how does the state legislature and the
Secretary of State want to actually implement it? Bob while we have you on yeah there has been
some reporting and we actually allegedly some people are getting signatures for people on
ballot propositions some are signatures on different names completely fraudulent some
other ones people are paying for homeless people to sign which is illegal which is illegal so can
you tell us what you're seeing and how can this be caught in the system? When voters sign a petition
those signatures have to be verified by us so with the it comes to your office it comes to
our office so the person circulating petition statewide they're collecting signatures throughout
the state they have to provide petition sheets that have voters from Orange County to my office
to then review the signatures first thing we do is we count how many voters signatures there are
we send that up to the Secretary of State and then they once they determine there's enough
signatures on petitions statewide to potentially qualify they then say the next step and say okay
counties you need to randomly select three percent of the signatures on the petitions you received
and examine those signatures so if somebody is paying a homeless person to sign somebody else's
name you know they're given a list here's a voter in this city I want you to sign their name
the circulator doesn't have access to the voter signature so if they're paying somebody to sign
it that person has no idea how that voter signs their name and so when we're doing the signature
verification we should then catch there's a forgery of that signature and that signature
would be rejected the potential benefit to the person doing the circulation is they're getting
paid to to collect signatures they're not supposed to get paid based on the number of signatures they
collect a lot of them get paid to go out and encourage people to sign those petitions but
that's where we would catch it so they're not supposed to get paid per signature right correct
they're not but some of them do from what it seems allegedly some of them if yeah if I had
information that was happening in Orange County that would be immediately go to the district
attorney to investigate and I know over the years they have actually successfully prosecuted
some people for lying on petitions for how they circulated them even the collector that's actually
asking for signatures should not get paid per signature right correct but that's how we would
catch it is is if somebody's out there saying here's a list of names I want you to sign for
these people that person has no idea how that person signs their name but if they come to you
and say hey I will pay you five dollars sign here because I will get fifteen dollars that's what the
allegation was in the in the video then they're both they'd both be breaking the law yeah okay
what about the company that's collecting those signatures yeah I mean if if the district
attorneys could can show that they had knowledge or they were directing it then yeah I could see
a prosecution of a company but it's not illegal for the company to pay somebody to go out there
and collect signatures and pay them per signature is that they're not allowed to pay them per
signature they're allowed to pay them like an hourly rate they're not allowed to pay them
per signature correct Bob you are in this position you're in charge of the elections
in Orange County correct big county in California what is it like for you to be in in this position
from one end you guys are doing all this work and there's another side of it is
somehow people are sensitive about elections and there's accusation of fraud what are your
thoughts on all this well I mean obviously this is a very critical job to the functioning of our
society in the county in the state in the in the country so I take the responsibility very seriously
and all the people on my team take it very seriously we're very committed to running fair
elections accurate elections we also run fully transparent elections we are always having members
of the public watching what we do how we're processing ballots comparing signatures there
is a huge responsibility that we we have and we're committed to that it had things have changed over
as you mentioned thing you know perceptions about elections have changed over time I would say prior
to 2016 most people in my role it was it was more of a behind the scenes type of role you were
dealing with candidates you were doing political parties and their lawyers but you weren't necessarily
having to answer conspiracy theories or allegations about how you conducted the election that's
changed over time so it's a big part of my job now is actually voter education talking to people
explaining them the processes how we take things seriously all the steps we make sure that the
election is secure and accurate we've been kind of creating a list of all those things that we do
every election and our like about 140 items that we do every election to make sure that the election
secure and the results are accurate you know so it's an important part for me to to educate people
to answer their questions and help them understand you know how we do things and why we do it and how
we do it fairly so it's a big part of that job now that we do but it's something that that I'd
gladly take on I understand how important this role and if that is important part of my job
now is to put information out and educate the public on a regular basis then I'm I will do that
Bob Page registrar of Orange County it was great to have you
I really appreciate you having me today thank you thank you what do you think about the mailing
ballot process in California and the process of counting the votes tell us in the comments
or email us at siamakacaliforniainsider.com we read all of your emails and comments
I'm Siamak Korami this is California Insider we'll see you next time