Session 23: The Right Type of Financing

Profit Playbook
12 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
In session 23 of this 36 session corporate finance class,
I'd like to talk about picking the right financing for your business.
In particular, I'm going to argue that the assets you have and
their characteristics should determine the right type of debt
that you should be taking on as a business.
In these last six sessions, we've looked at coming up with the right financing mix
for a company and how best to move to that mix.
In this very last session on the financing principle,
I'd like to look at the other aspect of the financing principle,
which is coming up with the right type of debt or right type of financing for your company.
Now lay the groundwork for what we're going to try to do in this session.
Let me go back to a very, very simple proposition.
Think about the biggest advantage of using debt.
It's a tax advantage, right?
Interest expense is a tax deductible.
Think about the biggest advantage of using equity.
It gives you flexibility.
Flexibility in what sense?
In good times, you can pay out a lot in dividends.
In bad times, you don't have to pay any dividends.
So here's my definition of a perfect financing.
It combines the best features of debt and equity.
What I mean by that is I'd like a security which gives me the tax benefits of debt
while also providing for me the flexibility of equity.
And here's why it matters.
If you take a look at the chart at the bottom of this page,
notice that it's the value of a firm that goes up and down over time.
So essentially, you can think of it as a cyclical or a commodity company.
The value goes up and then it goes down.
Then it goes up again and goes down again.
And I've given you two contrasting debt issues.
In the first one, the value of the debt stays fixed no matter what.
And when the value of the debt stays fixed,
this company is in trouble every time the value of the business
or the value of the assets drops below the value of the debt.
And there are at least two places on the graph where it happens.
In those scenarios, this company is technically bankrupt.
Now, let's say I took the same company and I increased the amount of debt it has.
But I made the value of the debt go up and down with the value of the assets.
Tough to do, but let's say I could pull it off.
If I can do that, this company never goes bankrupt.
By making the cash flows on my debt move with the cash flows on my assets,
I'm reducing default risk.
By reducing default risk, I'm lowering your cost of debt.
By lowering your cost of debt, I'm effectively lowering your cost of capital,
increasing your value as a business.
My biggest sales pitch, matching debt up to assets,
is it basically reduces the cost of capital and increases the value of the business.
So what I'd like to do is take you through a five-step process
for designing the perfect financing for any company.
Try this out on a real company because it's not a complicated process.
Here's where the process starts.
If you want me to design the perfect debt for you as a company,
here's what I'm going to need from you.
I need some specifics on what kind of investments you face as a company.
So let's start to get specific.
Here's the first question I would have for you.
How long-term are your projects?
If your projects are extremely long-term,
then your debt should be really long-term as well.
An example of a company with really long-term projects would be Boeing.
A typical project for Boeing,
if you count in the R&D needed to come up with a new type of aircraft,
could be 35, 40, or even 50 years.
The right kind of debt for Boeing would be 50-year debt.
Now, in fact, Boeing was one of two companies in the late 90s that issued 100-year bonds.
The other, of course, was Disney.
But you can see why Boeing wants to issue really long-term debt.
In contrast, if you're Google and you decide to borrow money,
a typical project for a technology company might be only two or three years.
Your debt should be much more short-term.
So tell me something about the duration of your projects,
and I'll tell you what the duration of your debt should be.
The second question I'm going to ask you is about the currency
in which your cash flows come in.
Give me a pie chart of the currencies in which your cash flows happen.
So let's assume that your cash flows take the following form.
30% are in euros, 70% are in dollars.
If that is the case, I'd expect your debt to have the same pattern.
70% of your debt should be U.S. dollar debt, 30% should be euro debt.
Sounds simplistic, but very effective.
Third, I'm going to ask you how inflation affects your cash flows.
What I mean by that is, do you have pricing power?
If you have pricing power, you can pass inflation through to your customers.
You say, why do you care?
That determines my choice of whether you're a good candidate to use floating rate debt.
Think of how floating rate debt works.
The interest rate is set at the start of the debt issue,
but each year it gets reset based on what happens to some preset or market interest rate.
It could be the prime rate, it could be LIBOR, it could be the U.S. T-bond rate.
But every year, the interest rate in your debt varies depending on what that rate does.
So if that rate goes up, the interest rate in your debt will go up as well.
Let me connect that back to whether you have pricing power.
Let's say inflation goes up.
When inflation goes up, interest rates are almost guaranteed to go up.
If interest rates go up and you have pricing power, you're going to be okay with that,
because you can pass the inflation through to your customers and make those interest payments.
But if you don't have pricing power, you're going to get squeezed.
So if you don't have pricing power and you issue floating rate debt,
you're going to find your interest payments being high
in exactly the periods when you don't want them to be high.
And that is a problem.
The fourth question I'm going to ask you is about whether you're a
mature company or a growth company, and here's why.
If you're a growth company, I think you're a much better candidate for
issuing convertible debt, and the reason is fairly simple.
Growth companies tend to have low cash flows, not even because they're not making money,
but because much of the money they make has to go back into the company to create future growth.
So I'd like you to issue debt where the coupon payments are low up front,
when your cash flows are low, and that's exactly what convertible debt will do for you.
It'll keep the coupon payments low because you've added that conversion option into the debt,
and as you mature as a company, the convertible debt will get converted to equity,
and hopefully you can replace it with straight debt.
That's 80% of debt issues, right?
Fixed rate or floating rate, straight or convertible, how long term, what currency?
There's a final question I'm going to ask you.
Tell me what else affects your cash flows,
and I'm going to try to build it into your bonds or debt issues.
Take a couple of examples.
If you're a gold mining company, the biggest driver of your earnings
and cash flows every year is what happens to gold prices, right?
Wouldn't it be nice if I could get you to issue bonds where the coupon payments
are high when gold prices are high, and low when gold prices are low?
That's essentially what's called a gold link bond, and it's the first of a series
of commodity bonds that was issued by a company called Sunshine Mining in the early 1980s.
Today, there's a family of bonds which are linked to different commodities,
and if you're a commodity company, you can see the impetus
for issuing one of these bonds if you're raising money.
Here's a second example.
You're an insurance company.
You have good earnings, but you're afraid to borrow money because you're afraid that
you're one catastrophe or one disaster away from bankruptcy.
An earthquake in California, a hurricane in Florida, either could put you under, right?
But what if I could issue a bond where your coupon payments and principle were
tied to whether such a catastrophe happened?
Those are called cat bonds or catastrophe bonds,
and there are several billion of those bonds outstanding as well,
issued primarily by small insurance companies.
What it allows them to do is borrow money.
Remember, this is not to get a lower interest rate.
You will actually pay a higher interest rate on these commodity-linked bonds
or on the catastrophe bonds.
The advantage you get by issuing these bonds is if you did not issue them,
you'd have used equity instead, and the cost of debt,
even with a higher interest rate you pay on these special bond issues,
will be lower than the cost of equity.
So that's the first step in bond design is to start with the business you're trying to finance
and then try to match up the debt to the characteristics of that business.
Here's your second step.
Make sure you haven't been too clever for your own good, and here's what I mean by that.
In the previous step, you were trying to design debt that started to look like equity, right?
In fact, you might have done such a good job
that the tax guy might look at the security of just design and say,
hey, that looks so much like equity, we're going to treat it as equity,
in which case all your hard work has gone down the drain.
So the second step in the process is to make sure or get as close as you can to being sure
that the security of just design is still going to get you the tax advantages of debt.
And at this stage in the process, you might decide to add some special features to the debt
or massage it or change a few of the features to maximize your tax benefits,
because the tax law does have its own quirks about how it treats coupon payments
and face value and different types of debt.
So this stage in the process, what you're effectively doing is taking
your perfect bond that you designed in the first step
and making it meet the tax criteria to maximize your tax advantage.
So let's say you can pull this off as well.
So let's see where we are.
You've designed the perfect bond.
You've got the tax OK.
The third step is a little tricky.
If you are a publicly traded company, and especially if you're a regulated,
publicly traded company, you have three different groups you've got to keep happy.
The first are the bond ratings agencies, because they're trying to minimize default risk.
And in a sense, they want you to issue equity, right?
Because when you issue debt, they worry about default risk.
The second is equity research ambassadors who actually want you to borrow money
rather than issue shares, because when you issue shares,
you create that dilution bogeyman.
More shares outstanding.
The third is if you're a regulated company, it's the regulatory authorities,
whose regulatory capital ratios tend to be built around equity.
So they want you to issue equity as well.
So here's what you'd like to do.
You'd like to issue a security that threads the needle.
And what I mean by that is it acts like equity with the ratings agency.
Looks like debt to the equity research analyst,
and goes back to being equity with the regulatory authorities.
You're saying, there's no way I can pull that off.
No harm tried.
And lots of companies do.
In fact, many corporate finance departments and investment banks generate a big chunk
of their profits from creating securities that are different things to different entities.
Let me give you an example.
In the early 1990s, investment banks created a security called trust preferred stock.
Now I'm going to describe what trust preferred stock looks like.
And you tell me based on my description,
whether you'd put it into the debt bucket or the equity bucket.
On trust preferred stock, you have a fixed dividend.
It's set up front when you issue the security.
That fixed dividend is tax deductible.
And if you fail to make that fixed dividend,
you have to give up voting shares to the trust preferred stockholders.
Fixed payment, tax deductible, loss of control.
Hey, that looks a lot like debt to me.
But in one of the great coups of all time,
the investment bank that created the security
managed to get the ratings agencies to initially treat it as equity.
Think of the advantage now for you as a company.
You can now go out and borrow money effectively by issuing trust preferred.
And while you're borrowing money, your rating actually goes up
because the ratings agency treats it as equity.
It was an immensely profitable security for investment banks.
And not surprisingly, there was a lot of pressure
on investment bankers to essentially get clients to use the security.
So let's say you are low man in the totem pole.
It's the early 1990s.
And I'm asking you to sell trust preferred to everybody who walks in through the door.
And you want to do the least damage in the long term from doing this.
Think about who your best client would be for trust preferred stock.
And I'm going to give you two choices.
Would it be an under levered firm that is not borrowing money
because it has a rating constraint?
Remember, we talked that most companies have a rating below
which they don't want to drop.
Or is it an over levered firm that already has too much debt,
but might be able to get away with issuing this trust preferred?
Which one do you think is a better company to issue trust preferred
without creating long term damage?
I know which one I'd pick.
I'd pick the under levered firm because that rating constraint is artificial anyway.
So what that will allow the under levered firm to do is use its debt capacity
without worrying about violating that artificial constraint.
The over levered firm is over levered because it already has too much debt.
Getting it to issue preferred stock, even if you fool the ratings agency,
will create a cash flow problem for you.
In other words, you got to make those preferred dividend payments in the future.
And the only consolation price I might offer you is
you might go bankrupt, but you might go bankrupt with a really good rating.
That's not enough of a consolation price.
So if you're going to issue trust preferred, be careful,
because in a sense, you might fool the ratings agency,
but that's not the end of the game.
In fact, by the mid 90s,
the ratings agencies were starting to treat trust preferred as more debt than equity.
So guess what happened?
Investment banks came up with more and more complex securities
designed in a sense to separate companies from the debt more and more.
In the process, they created so much separation that there were companies in the late 90s,
like Enron, that I would wage if you walked in to Enron offices in the late 90s,
and you ask the CFO, how much money have you borrowed?
He would not have known the answer.
That's a dangerous place for a company to be.
So don't view this as a game.
It is true you've got to keep equity research analysts,
ratings agencies, and regulatory authorities happy,
but you have to do it without causing real damage to your company in the process.
So you've designed the perfect debt.
You've got the tax okay.
You've got these different groups reasonably happy.
Here's the fourth step.
You might have to add some special features to this bond.
You have to, in a sense, sugarcoat the bond to make it acceptable to bondholders.
You're saying why?
Either because you don't have a history in the bond market,
you have the wrong kind of history.
In other words, you've defaulted in the past.
Nobody wants to buy your bonds.
So to make them acceptable, to make them viable,
you've got to add some special features, protections for the bondholders.
Very early in these sessions, we talked about puttable bonds,
bonds that a bondholder can put back to the company in case it doesn't leverage buyout
or something else that hurts the bondholder.
You might add something like that to a bond to make it acceptable to bondholders.
In fact, you might add special clauses to these bonds
specifically designed to protect bondholders.
Remember why you're doing this.
You're not doing this because you care about bondholders,
but you're afraid that if you don't do this,
they will assume the worst about you and charge you a much, much higher interest rate.
So let's see where we are.
You've designed the perfect debt.
You've got the tax okay.
You've kept these different groups reasonably happy
and you've sugarcoated the debt just enough to make it acceptable to bondholders.
Here's the final step.
Make sure you don't lock in market mistakes that work against you.
What do I mean?
Let's assume that you believe that based on your financials,
you should have a single A rating
and the ratings agency has given you a double B rating.
In other words, they've messed up.
If you go out and issue 30-year fixed rate debt today,
you're going to lock in an interest rate that's way too high,
even if it's the right type of debt for you.
My suggestion, use some short-term debt,
even though it doesn't match up to your assets,
and try to use that time to convince the ratings agency to change its mind.
Maybe you'll succeed and you can issue the 30-year bonds next period.
What if you have a market mistake that works in your favor?
Now that creates an entirely different problem, right?
So let's say you should be rated double B and I give you a single A rating.
Do you see what you're going to be inclined to do?
You're probably going to borrow money you don't need
because I'm rating you too highly.
I don't have an issue with that,
but my concern is if you go out and borrow the money,
you're going to be inclined to try to use that money.
And when you have lots of cash sitting around without a use,
you tend to do stupid things.
So my suggestion to you is,
even if you have a market mistake that works in your favor,
don't try to take advantage of markets.
You got to work with them in the future.
So in summary, a five-step process,
design the perfect debt, get the tax okay,
get the different groups working at least in the same direction,
sugarcoat the debt if you need to,
and don't lock in market mistakes against you.
That's essentially the way you design the perfect debt for a company.
Let me try this for Disney.
There are five different businesses.
I'm going to try to design the perfect debt for each business.
Let me start with the movie business.
The movie business typically is short-term projects.
For Disney, for the most part,
these movie projects have been dollars,
though an increasing percentage of Disney revenues
from movies come from overseas.
So if I were designing a bond to cover the movie business,
I'd probably make it short-term for Disney.
Probably U.S. dollar for the moment,
though I might start to use foreign currency debt
if it's an action movie that gets a big chunk of its revenues overseas.
But here's one feature you might consider adding to that bond.
Movies have a skewed distribution.
What I mean by that is there are a few very big winners and lots of losers.
So if you could tie the coupon payment on this bond
to how well or badly the movie does at the box office,
that would help you, right?
It might not be as useful to Disney
as it would be for a company like Lionsgate,
which produces only movies.
But you can see what we're trying to do.
We're trying to design a bond for the movie business
and we're trying to match it up to the characteristics of the business.
If you're wondering whether anybody would buy this bond,
let me remind you of Bowie Bonds.
If you've never heard of Bowie Bonds,
David Bowie, rock star of the past,
got into a problem with his record company
and bought back the rights to all of his music in the early 1990s,
which left him with a cash flow problem.
So here's what he did.
He went to a banker in New York
and he issued bonds against his music, against his songs.
And what made Bowie Bonds unique was the coupon rate on the bond
was tied to how well the music did.
In other words, if he sold five platinum records,
the coupon rate was 15%.
If he woke up tomorrow and said,
hey, David Bowie's music is terrible,
we're not going to buy any of his records,
the coupon rate dropped to 0%.
If David Bowie can sell Bowie Bonds,
I don't see why Disney can't sell movie bonds.
So what you're trying to do is match up the bonds
to the characteristics of the business.
The broadcasting business, again for Disney,
primarily dollar driven still,
primarily short term.
So I would probably make it short term in dollar debt.
And if I could, I'd like to tie the coupon rate to the rating.
On the show, right?
Not bond ratings, but Nielsen ratings.
Again, I'm trying to design debt
that matches up to the characteristics of the assets.
The theme park business for Disney
is probably the longest term business.
That's where I'd expect to see the longest term debt.
The currency I'd issue the debt in
will depend on the makeup of tourists at each theme park
rather than where the theme park is located.
So again, designing debt to match up the business.
The interactive gaming business
is probably Disney's highest growth, riskiest business.
If I were issuing convertible debt as Disney,
that's the business against which I'd issue it against.
So with each business, what we're trying to do
is look at the characteristics of the business
and try to design the perfect debt for that business.
So let's look overall at Disney.
Given what I know about Disney as a company,
here's what I'd expect to see as its debt.
I'd expect to see debt with a duration
of roughly four to five years,
matching up to the fact that they have
these wide range of businesses
and the duration across the businesses
is about four to five years.
I'd expect to see a fair amount of foreign currency debt
because 18% of Disney's operations are outside the US
and a lot of floating rate debt
because Disney strikes me as a company
with a lot of pricing power.
So I'd expect to see a lot of foreign currency,
floating rate debt,
and debt with maturity between four to five years.
Let's see what Disney actually has.
If you remember, the maturity for Disney's debt
was roughly 7.92 years.
It turns out to probably works out
to a duration of roughly five to six years.
So not too bad.
Their debt has roughly the duration I'd expect it to have.
However, they have relatively little foreign currency debt.
It's about 5.4% foreign currency debt
and most of it is in Asian currencies.
They have no Euro debt.
So what I'd expect them to do actually
is have a lot more Euro debt
and I don't see that yet.
I also don't see very much floating rate debt.
I see about 5% floating rate debt.
And again, given their pricing power,
I'd expect to see a lot more floating rate debt.
So my overall conclusions looking at Disney's current debt
is I'd probably prefer it to be a little more short term,
a lot more foreign currency,
and a lot more floating rate, right?
So you're saying, how am I going to fix that?
There are a couple of ways you can do it.
One is you can use swaps and derivatives right now
to fix the problem right away.
And essentially what that'll mean is
you might swap some of your US dollar fixed rate debt
for Euro floating rate debt
and your problem will go away.
The other way to fix this
is Disney has a lot of investments it's planning to make
in the next few years.
If it funds these investments disproportionately
with foreign currency floating rate debt,
it's problem is going to go away as well.
So either way, Disney can get to a debt
that is right for it.
And that's pretty much what I would like it to do over time
is move its debt towards the right kind of debt
given the asset characteristics
that Disney has as a company.
So very quickly, let me try this first on my other companies.
Let me take Vale and BookScape first.
BookScape, it's a book retailer.
It's a single bookstore in New York City.
In fact, the debt that it has right now,
which is a lease on the bookstore,
strikes me as the perfect debt for BookScape.
So BookScape, I'm okay with their existing debt
because it matches what I'd expect it to see.
Vale's typical investment is in a new mine.
These mines have really long-term lives.
The earnings of cash flows in the mine
are linked to commodity prices.
If I were designing debt from scratch for Vale,
I'd make it really long-term debt
and tie the coupon rate on the debt if possible
to the commodity in question.
So if it's an iron ore mine,
I'd like to tie the coupon rate to the price of iron ore.
So Vale and BookScape were relatively simple.
With Tata Motors, a typical investment
is probably a new assembly plant,
either in India for producing Tata Motors cars in India
or in some other part of the world for Land Rover Jaguar.
So I would expect the debt to be relatively long-term
because these are long-term investments.
What currency I use will depend upon
whether I'm looking at a Tata Motors auto plant
or a Land Rover auto plant.
And Land Rover, I think, has pricing power.
So if the debt I'm issuing is for a Land Rover pricing plan,
I'd be more inclined to use floating rate debt.
Baidu's a high-growth company.
I would make the growth work in my favor.
And with Baidu, my suggestion would be
to try to use convertible debt.
And the reason their growth is going to work in their favor
is the growth option will actually,
the conversion option will actually become more valuable
with high growth and high risk.
So in a sense, with every one of these businesses,
I'm trying to match up the debt to their assets.
Incidentally, neither Tata Motors nor Baidu
has debt right now that matches up
to what I'd expect them to have.
And that's not surprising.
Many emerging market companies right now
have mismatched debt.
Part of it reflects our history.
10 or 20 years ago, these companies had no choice
but to borrow money from the bank,
and the bank set the terms.
And if the bank said,
we lend you only three-year fixed-rate debt,
that's what you had on your balance sheet.
I think the opportunities for these companies
to fix those mismatches are much greater
because they have access to capital markets
and they can now issue bonds.
So with all of these companies, my end game is
I want to see debt issues that match up
as closely as I can to the characteristics
of the cash flows of the assets
that they have as companies.
So here's what I'd like you to try.
Take a company, take a company you're familiar with,
and see if you can design debt for that company.
Think about whether you want the debt
to be short-term or long-term,
what currency you want the debt to be,
whether it should be fixed-rate or floating-rate,
whether it should be straight or convertible.
If you want to be creative,
think about what other features
you'd like to add to this debt
given what you know about the company.
Once you do that, you're going to discover
that designing the perfect debt
is not that complicated.
This really is not rocket science.
Thank you very much for listening.
