What The Farmer’s Dog Is Actually Selling You

Homemade Dog Food
318 followers
1 Video View·May 8, 2026
The farmer's dog makes more than $1 billion per year
selling fresh dog food.
I fed it to my own dogs for six months
and snuck into their vet-only portal so you don't have to.
And in this video, I'm breaking down whether their food
is actually as good as their marketing makes it look,
why they won't share the ingredients
that go into their food with the general public,
and at the end, I'll give the farmer's dog
a final grade, A through F,
so you know if it's actually worth
your hard-earned money or not.
And as always, this video is not sponsored.
I used to think the farmer's dog
was like the greatest food of all time.
You know you're feeding the exact right amount
and it's a fresh food so it's super healthy for your dogs.
It's made from high-quality human-grade ingredients.
Man, we used to be so big on human grade.
But I just learned how to actually judge dog food
from a veterinary nutritionist,
and now I'm applying what I learned
to every single pet food I come across.
So let's order the farmer's dog.
Now, like many of these fancy
direct-to-consumer pet food companies,
you do have to take a quiz
before you can actually order the food.
But the farmer's dog does something
that no other pet food company does, as far as I can tell.
They won't show you any of their ingredients,
any of the guaranteed analysis for their recipes,
or any of the calorie counts
without you taking the quiz first, and I'll prove it.
So if we go to their main site,
let's click on Our Food.
See recipes and pricing.
Quiz.
Okay, let's go back.
Let's go find your recipe.
Quiz, okay.
Maybe in the FAQ, Our Recipes, Our Food.
Okay, nothing there.
What if I just Google, like, the farmer's dog ingredients?
Oh, okay, here.
The farmer's dog ingredients and recipes, great.
It's like a blog article.
Okay, they don't list the full ingredient panel
of any of their recipes.
Visit the farmer's dog to learn more about our recipes.
Home page.
So literally, I can't find the ingredients anywhere
without taking the quiz.
If I'm understanding correctly,
the billion dollar company that built their brand
on being more transparent is somehow less transparent
than most other pet food companies?
I guess we're taking the quiz.
Now, I'm gonna order a few different recipes
so we can try them all out,
and we'll talk about the price in a little
because, whoa.
Now, while we wait for that to be delivered,
let's look at their marketing.
The reason I wanna look at their marketing
is to see if they're using any fear or shame
to get pet parents to buy their food.
And you might be asking yourself,
well, how does that apply to me?
Why does that matter?
When a company is using that kind of marketing,
as a human, it doesn't matter who you are,
me, you, anybody.
When you hear that kind of marketing,
it's trying to put you into your fear-based amygdala
of your brain, your reptile brain.
It's hard to make good decisions even
when you're submerged in that kind of marketing.
You almost have to get up,
take an emotional lap around the room,
or go have a snack, however you process your emotions,
and then come back and evaluate the food.
So if I have to take some deep breaths
or do some meditation before I can even evaluate a pet food,
that's not worth my time or energy.
So fear-based marketing can literally put us
in a mental state that makes it harder
to make good, informed decisions.
Now, on the Farmer's Dog homepage,
we do start to see a lot of the same marketing verbiage
that many of these other companies use.
More good years, implying their food
can help your dog live longer,
but I don't see any citations here.
You shouldn't be the only one eating healthy,
as if dogs eating any balanced food
aren't already eating a mix of meat, vegetables,
fruits, grains, and vitamins,
which is extremely healthy even by human standards.
Real food, as opposed to, what, fake food,
which isn't a thing.
And then human-grade safety.
We talked in the Spot and Tango review
about how that's not really an indicator
of high-quality food,
and there's no one really verifying
if these claims are true or not.
But I actually remember seeing something
from the Farmer's Dog that looked like actual proof
of human-grade.
Yeah, right here.
It says they use USDA-inspected facilities
with inspectors on-site to ensure safety,
they rigorously test their food multiple times
for safety against harmful pathogens,
and they sanitize after every cook
to reduce the risk of cross-contamination.
That doesn't mean that the brand is perfect by any means,
but oh my gosh, is it nice to see a company
actually backing up their claims with something real.
Spot and Tango, please take note.
And that's not the only thing they're doing right,
because when I went looking for proof behind the claim
clinically shown to support healthy aging,
I actually found something.
A real peer-reviewed study
published in an actual scientific journal
conducted at Cornell University over an entire year.
Basically, they took 22 older sled dogs
and split them into two groups.
One group stayed on kibble,
and the other group switched to the Farmer's Dog.
And the group that was on the Farmer's Dog
showed lower levels of compounds linked to aging
and higher levels of protective antioxidants.
Now, was this study funded by the Farmer's Dog?
Yes.
Do three of the four authors work for the Farmer's Dog?
Yes.
Does that automatically make it bad science?
Absolutely not.
And I'm not gonna poo-poo good research,
peer-reviewed research, just because of who funded it.
Now, it is important to note that this study
and the results of the study
don't say that they necessarily lead
to better health outcomes,
but this is a great start.
This is how you actually back up your claims
with real science.
So, I was feeling pretty good about the Farmer's Dog
up until this point,
and then I just came across a page titled, Why Fresh?
Farmer's Dog, what the is this?
For as long as any of us can remember,
we've been trained to feed commercial dog food.
What do we have to show for it today?
Over 80% of dogs will get some form of dental disease
in their lifetime,
roughly the same percentage who eat dry food.
So, they're putting these two numbers next to each other,
hoping that you'll connect the dots,
that kibble is causing dental disease.
You know what other two things line up perfectly?
100% of people die, and 100% of people drink water.
So, water must be killing us, right?
Two things happening at the same time
does not mean one is causing the other.
And Farmer's Dog, why don't you put the rate
of dental disease in kibble-fed dogs
compared to the rate of dental disease in fresh-fed dogs,
and we can look at those two numbers together?
Is it maybe because those are telling a similar story,
which is that dental disease is pretty common in dogs,
regardless of what you feed them?
And as we keep going, it only gets worse.
We have this animation showing low-quality ingredients
turning into kibble, followed by a post
claiming that 4D meat, which stands for dead,
diseased, dying, or disabled, is allowed in pet food.
And I'm not gonna lie, when I first heard this
four or five years ago, I was terrified.
The idea that animals could die not via slaughter,
and then those are just thrown into the food
that I'm feeding my most precious loved ones
is literally one of the scariest things I've ever heard.
And the farmer's dog knows that.
That's why they're talking about it.
But here's what they're not telling you.
Going back to the late 70s and early 80s,
the FDA had these old compliance guides
that basically told their enforcement staff
not to take any action against 4D meat in pet food.
That was real, and yeah, it was bad.
No one is denying that.
But in April 2019, the FDA pulled those guides.
Gone.
They replaced them with way stricter requirements
where any company that wants to use those ingredients
now has to do a full hazard analysis.
And we're talking about testing for salmonella,
E. coli, heavy metals, even pentobarbital,
which is the euthanasia drug
that everybody says is in dog food.
Literally right here in the FDA guidelines,
it says, quote,
animal food that contains a detectable level
of pentobarbital using an FDA-validated method
is considered adulterated.
And then it says that companies have to have processes
in place to, quote,
determine whether animals have been euthanized
using pentobarbital,
and if so, exclude those animals from use in animal food.
So even if a company is using 4D meat,
they have to test it to all ends of the earth
to make sure it has nothing hazardous in it,
including the euthanasia drug.
And all that testing and compliance,
it ends up being more expensive
than just sourcing the meat
from a USDA-inspected slaughterhouse in the first place.
So most pet food brands are gonna benefit,
even financially,
from just taking the safer route in this situation.
This big, scary thing
that the farmer's dog is warning you about
was largely addressed seven years ago,
and I don't see that anywhere on this page.
Another example of this fear-based marketing
that the farmer's dog uses
happened like two weeks ago with their co-founders.
Basically, the Clean Label Project,
which is a nonprofit that tests consumer products
for contaminants,
released a study where they tested 79 dog foods
for things like lead, mercury, arsenic, and cadmium.
They found heavy metals in basically all of them,
and the headlines made it seem
like your dog's food is toxic.
And the farmer's dog co-founders
jumped on this immediately,
releasing a post that said, quote,
recent news about the heavy metals in pet food
is concerning, but not surprising.
Pretty scary, right?
Except yet again,
what the farmer's dog and everyone else
quoting this study won't tell you
is that every single sample tested in that study
was within the established safety limits,
not a little bit below it, well below it.
The study also compared dog food to human consumables
like juice and protein powder,
which is like comparing the mercury
in your entire dinner plate
to the mercury in your glass of orange juice.
Of course the entire plate has mold.
And seven of the dry food samples
had fish as the main protein.
Zero of the fresh foods had fish as the main protein.
You know what fish is higher in than most other proteins?
Mercury.
So a big chunk of that scary comparison
is probably just fish.
But the farmer's dog doesn't mention any of that.
They just post concerning, but not surprising,
and let the fear instilled in innocent pet parents
do the selling for them.
This honestly is one of the worst cases
of fear mongering I've come across yet.
And I started asking myself,
why is the farmer's dog going after kibble so hard
and they're not going after raw food or air dried food
or canned food even, which is just as processed as kibble?
And then I thought, well,
what's the biggest untapped market for them?
Or another way to put that is,
what do pet parents feed the most of currently?
And 80 to 90% of pet parents feed kibble.
So it kind of makes sense to go after
the largest market share that you haven't gotten yet.
I don't know, that's just my opinion.
Let's see if the actual food can make up for this.
Okay, I'm gonna try really hard
to put all of that fear mongering
in the back of my brain for now,
because honestly, the farmer's dog
is doing something really cool.
Instead of dog food coming in giant bags
or frozen bricks like a lot of raw and fresh companies use,
the farmer's dog is actually personalized.
And I'll show you.
Each of these pouches is exactly one day's worth of food
for my specific dog, based on the info I put in the quiz.
So I don't have to worry about measuring at all,
which when it comes to fresh food is actually really nice.
They put your dog's name on each pouch,
which I think is a nice touch.
And then they also send you this meal prep container,
which is basically to store the pouch inside
if you feed two meals a day
and you don't wanna feed all of this at once.
This is cool that they thought of it.
I never ended up using it
because what I do is just roll these down
after I fed half of it and clip it,
throw the whole thing in the fridge.
I don't really wanna dirty a dish
just to save this for dinner.
And the food itself is pretty much what you'd expect.
It looks like somebody took fresh ingredients
and combined them and gently cooked them
and put them into a pouch,
which is I think exactly what they do.
According to their website,
their meals are prepared in human food facilities
where each recipe is gently cooked at low temperatures.
They're then quickly frozen
for safe shipping and storage convenience.
And they have four main recipes,
beef, chicken, turkey,
which I think is their best looking food,
and pork.
Now, like Spot and Tango,
the farmer's dog doesn't include
any real relevant nutrition information on the pouch,
which is kind of frustrating
because when I'm considering a pet food,
there are a lot of different things I'm looking for
on the food itself.
Starting with the brand's contact information.
We're gonna have lots of questions
for the brands here in a few.
So I wanna make sure I have a consistent way
to get a hold of them.
Next up is the complete and balanced statement.
This tells us that the food has all of the proper nutrients
that my dog needs to survive
and they're in the right proportions.
Then we have the guaranteed analysis.
This breaks down how much protein, fat,
and fiber is in the food
and it gives you the caloric density
so you know exactly how much to feed your dog.
We don't use this info a ton when we're judging pet food,
but it's nice to know where it is in case you do need it.
After that, we're looking for the full ingredient list.
Because remember, the Parmer's dog
would not show us the ingredients
before we submitted our information in the quiz.
In their turkey recipe, we've got turkey,
chickpeas, carrots, broccoli, spinach, parsnips,
and their vitamin and mineral pack.
So synthetic vitamins and minerals
just to help ensure the food is complete and balanced.
Nothing overly concerning,
though I do wanna point out
that they use legumes with those chickpeas.
And there are some experts that believe that legumes,
when they're used in large quantities in pet food,
might contribute to DCM, that deadly heart disease in dogs.
Now, Dr. Conway has told me
that there are no ingredients she avoids in pet food,
she just ensures that they're all in the right proportions.
I'll be honest with you,
I don't really know what to think about legumes right now.
So my default is to kinda avoid them
until I learn more information.
And finally, we get to the life stage.
And this will tell us if the food is formulated for puppies,
pregnant dogs, adult dogs, or all life stages.
And we hope, and we cross our fingers,
that it's not all life stages.
See, dogs have different nutrient requirements
depending on where they are in their life.
Puppies and pregnant dogs
have higher nutrient requirements
because they're growing and need more fuel
to support that growth.
Adult and senior dogs have lower nutrient needs
because they just need to maintain the weight
that they're at.
But all life stages food,
that has to meet the nutrient requirements for all dogs,
which means it's great for puppies and pregnant dogs,
but for adults and seniors,
the nutrient levels are gonna be off.
Unfortunately, their main recipes are all life stages.
Now, you know how I said
we look for the brand's contact information?
Here's why that actually matters.
The next available agent.
Hi there, my name is Bryce,
and I'm just calling with some questions,
some nutrition questions about your food.
And I was hoping to find somebody
that could help me answer those.
Do you care about nutrition too?
Okay.
Yeah, that's totally fine.
Let me just run you through them.
You can kind of tell me if you can give me that info
or if it's maybe easier to send an email.
Okay, first question,
I wanted to know who actually formulates the recipes
and what their title is,
how they're actually involved with the food itself.
Formulated.
That's great.
What kind of testing is done on the food
after it's actually done?
Nutrient testing, heavy metals, things like that.
A testing of E. coli
or any kind of microbial biological factors.
Wonderful.
And then is the food tested after it's finished
to make sure the nutrients actually match the formulation?
Infection or anything wrong with the food.
Wonderful.
Where is your food actually produced?
Okay, so we actually produce human-raised facilities.
They follow under USDA.
I understand.
And does the farmer's dog actually own those facilities
or is that like a third-party partner they're working with?
Yes, it'd be third-party partners.
And do you know like what kind of involvement
the farmer's dog has with those facilities?
Do they oversee what's going on in there?
Is the farmer's dog able to go in
and ensure things are happening as they should?
Okay, wonderful.
Who is responsible for food safety?
Basically, if something happens with your food,
if there's a recall,
is there a food safety team in place
that handles all of that?
Okay, thank you very much.
I really appreciate all your help today.
You too, bye-bye.
Okay, I don't know if you just heard that,
but Kenzie was listening in the other room
and she said, so different than spot and tango,
which is beyond true.
They answered in 26 seconds.
I was already talking with somebody
and they might not have known every single detail
about every part of their operation,
but they gave me real answers
to every single one of the questions I asked
and then said, if they couldn't answer them,
they will connect me with somebody on their nutrition team.
I can't remember the exact verbiage,
but I think he said nutrition team.
Yeah, I'm quite impressed.
That was really solid.
That is what you hope a brand is willing to do for you
and you hope that's what a brand is willing to answer
because in my opinion, when a brand is transparent,
it shows that they believe in what they're doing
and they're going to show you.
They're going to prove it.
They're not gonna hide behind something proprietary.
Now, let's talk about the price.
Every single month for a 50 pound dog,
the farmer's dog would cost $209.
This is what it would look like for dogs
at different weights and this is the price per pound
as well as per kilogram of food.
The farmer's dog sits in this weird gray area for me
because on one hand,
I think they're doing something really important.
They're pioneering fresh food
from a science first perspective.
They have board certified nutritionists on staff.
They're funding real research at real universities.
They're doing feeding trials
that go way beyond what's required
and that stuff matters.
I am not gonna try to pretend that it doesn't
but then you look at their marketing
and it's just bashing, kibble over and over and over again
using correlation as causation,
using outdated scare tactics about 4D meat
that were addressed seven years ago,
jumping on a heavy metal study
that they clearly didn't talk to their science team about
before firing a post to their half a million followers.
All of this to convince you
that if you're not feeding fresh food,
you're failing your dog
and that is the part I just cannot get past
because you don't have to tear down every other option
to prove that yours is good,
especially when yours is good.
You don't have to terrify pet parents
into buying your product.
You made a cool product, stand by it.
With all of this info,
I think it's only fair to give the farmer's dog
a final score of honestly, not bad,
but holy God's fix your marketing.
Another food we get asked about all the time
is spot and tango
and what we found when we looked into their ecosystem
was insane.
That video's right here.
