LIVE: House Committee Hearing on 'Protecting Workers and Powering America: The Future of Mining'

Live News Network
1.4K followers
13 Video Views·May 8, 2026
The House Education and Workforce Committee holds a hearing, "Protecting Workers and Powering America: The Future of Mining," at 9:15 a.m. ET on May 8.
The Committee on Education and Workforce will please come to order.
A quorum is present. Right, Mark? We are the quorum. Unanimous quorum.
Without objection, the chair may recess the committee at any point.
I would like to thank Vincennes University for hosting today's hearing. It's great to be at an
institution that is educating tomorrow's leaders in the fields of firefighting, manufacturing,
workplace safety, and mining. Places where there are actual jobs that we certainly need.
Today's hearing will examine the U.S. mining industry and ways we can improve
the industry for both miners and mine operators. Under the Trump administration and Republican
leadership in Congress, there's opportunity for mining to grow and continue delivering for
communities like this one. America's mining industry is at a turning point. Last year,
President Trump issued three executive orders aimed at strengthening domestic mining production.
There were critical steps to ensure energy independence for
the nation. The Department of Labor and this committee are also taking steps to remove
burdensome policies and create regulatory landscape that allows mining operations to grow.
Acting on these executive orders, the Department of Energy recently announced
nearly $100 million in funding as part of its mine and future initiative, with $80 million going
toward the development and commercialization of advanced mining technology. This initiative
recognizes the innovative approaches being taken in the mining industry, where some of the most
advanced technology is being used to increase production efficiency and reduce worker exposure
and risk, even as we had the privilege of viewing yesterday in the mine itself.
Last July, members of this committee sent a letter to the Mine Safety and Health
Administration, MSHA, requesting that it revise the overly burdensome rule on respirable crystalline
silica issued by the Biden-Harris administration in 2024. The mining industry depends on small
and mid-sized operators and several provisions in this final rule placed costly obligations
on these businesses, which would likely cause them to close their doors.
But the work does not stop there. We must ensure worker protections keep pace. For example,
in July of 2025, MSHA created the Compliance Assistance in Safety and Health, or CASH,
program to support the anticipated surge in mining productivity following President Trump's
executive orders. MSHA also continues to award millions of dollars in grants to support mine
safety and health training across the United States. These investments in safety and health
paid off. In 2025, the mining industry experienced its lowest total injury rate
in history. While there's been outstanding progress in keeping our workers safe,
there's still more work to do. Collaboration between government and private sector
leads to safer workplaces, an educated workforce, and a stronger mining industry.
I look forward to hearing from our witnesses about ways to unleash the mining industry's
potential in a way that protects miners and benefits the communities in which they work
and live. Pursuant to Committee Rule 8C, all members who wish to insert written statements
into the record may do so by submitting them to the committee clerk electronically
in Microsoft Word format by 5 p.m., 14 days after this hearing. And without objection,
the hearing record will remain open for 14 days to allow such statements and other extraneous
material noted during the hearing to be submitted for the official hearing record.
I'll now turn to the introduction of our four witnesses. And to do that, I'll start by
recognizing Representative Messimer to introduce two of our witnesses who are both from the great
state of Indiana. Well, thank you, Chairman. And it's an honor to introduce two Hoosiers on this
panel today. Mr. Bruce Stevens is president of Resources Services LLC in Jasonville,
Indiana. He brings both private and public sector perspectives on the mining industry,
having previously served as president of the Indiana Coal Council and director of
Division of Reclamation and the state of Indiana's Department of Natural Resources.
Mr. Eric Carter is general manager of Peabody Energy's Underground Mine,
located near Francisco, Indiana. With more than two decades of experience in the mining industry,
he has seen firsthand how this sector has evolved and adapted to a variety of changes.
I thank them both for their contributions to strengthening our state's mining industry
and for testifying today. And I yield back. Thank you, Mr. Messimer.
Our third witness is Mr. Sam Petsank, owner of Petsank PLLC in Oak Hill, West Virginia. Welcome.
Our last witness, Mr. Arthur Wolfson, partner at Fisher Phillips LLP in Pittsburgh,
Pennsylvania. Welcome. We thank our witnesses for being here today. Pursuant to committee rules,
I would ask that each of you limit your oral presentation to a three-minute summary
of your written statement, which we have read. The clock will count down from three minutes
as we have many questions for you. Pursuant to committee rule 8D and committee practice, however,
we'll not cut off your testimony until you reach the five-minute mark.
I would also like to remind the witnesses to be aware of their responsibility to provide
accurate information to this committee. I'll first recognize Mr. Stevens for your testimony.
Five minutes. You're recorded right now. Welcome.
Thank you, Chairman Wahlberg, Congressman Messimer. It's indeed an honor to be here.
First, I want to welcome you to Vincennes University's Gibson County Center for Advanced
Manufacturing Logistics, which is the home of Vincennes University's mining training program,
which is the recipient of the Mine Safety and Health Administration's federal grant funding
to assist in the training and retraining of Indiana's miners. This institution provides
the required training for underground surface miners delivered by instructors with decades of
expertise across many aspects of mining. In fact, this facility averages training and retraining
nearly 3,000 coal miners each year. The facility is a true gem for Indiana's workforce development
efforts, and I encourage you to take a few minutes to see it firsthand if you haven't yet
had the opportunity. The classrooms, equipment simulators, and Indiana's only mock underground
mine for safety and rescue training speak for themselves. I encourage the committee to ensure
that stable mine safety and health grant funding is sustained for state-based mining training
programs and request consideration of expanding funding to cover planning, instructor hiring,
and upgrading equipment that has evolved technologically. Indiana's coal miners are
highly skilled men and women. They work in one of the most highly regulated industries in the nation,
subject to state and federal regulatory agencies, including those with jurisdiction over the Mine
Safety and Health Act, the Surface Mining Act, the Clean Water Act, the Clean Air Act, and others.
Miners today are not producing coal with picks and shovels, but rather with specialized mechanized
equipment that requires training and experience to operate. Their specialties span equipment
operation, electrical systems, mine safety, welding, computerized controls, and engineering,
and they earn high salaries, averaging over $90,000 annually with strong benefits.
They are very involved in their communities and quite generous, providing goods for those in
schools and communities who may not be as fortunate. These are the kind of people we want in our
communities. Unfortunately, the numbers tell a stark story. In 1988, 39 companies were operating
72 coal mines. Last year, six companies were operating nine mines. In 2014, Indiana coal
mines produced over 39 million tons of coal, more than any other year. Just 11 years later,
in 2025, Indiana produced 18.4 million tons, over a 50% reduction driven almost entirely by
regulatory pressure that forced coal-fueled power plants to close. Some of those regulations were
later overturned in court or revised, but the damage was already done. Miners lost good-paying
jobs and had to start over, often at lower wages with fewer benefits. The need for coal has never
been more urgent. Energy demand is surging due to artificial intelligence. Data centers increase
manufacturing, and foreign manufacturers return to the United States, all of which are straining
energy supply chains. To attract and maintain these industries, there must be adequate energy
available. At a time when consumer costs are rising, our nation needs to prioritize all forms
of energy. Coal is a dispatchable, storable, baseload energy source ready to power these sectors.
To do so, the utilities must be given certainty that coal will remain available and supported as
an energy source, and that regulatory reform will not be undone by a future administration.
As Congress mandated in the Surface Mining Control and Reclamation Act in Section 102F,
which directs us to assure that the coal supply essential to the nation's energy requirements
and to its economic and social well-being is provided, and strike a balance between protection
of the environment and agricultural productivity in the nation's need as an essential source of
energy. This mandate originated in 1977 and remains as important today as when it was first written.
Thank you again for the opportunity to address the committee, and I look forward to any questions
you may have. Thank you, Mr. Stevens. I now recognize Mr. Carter for your testimony.
Chairman Wahlberg, Congressman Messmer, thank you for the opportunity to testify today.
My name is Eric Carter. I'm currently the general manager for one of Peabody Energy's underground
coal mines here locally in Gibson County. I'm here to testify about the experience with current
available workforce in the state of education available for mining practices. In my 32 years,
I've gained extensive experience with laws, policies under the Mine Safety and Health
Administration and other federal state agencies. It is of my opinion that over time, education
standards and certain policies under the Department of Labor have hampered the ability of mining in
communities like this. Currently in my community, schools cater primarily to employers outside of
mining industry because it's rarely highlighted as a destination for those graduates. We currently
utilize mechanical, electrical, mining, and civil, environmental, and software engineers.
Not all high school graduates will attend a college, yet the mining industry
still sees opportunities ranging from general labor to managerial positions for an individual
with the wherewithal to learn and progress. What we see today in a culture shift among students
and individuals who have newly entered the workforce, there does not appear to be a clear
or well-promoted pathway for high school graduates to navigate their way into the trades,
including mining. We spent a significant amount of time sufficiently training developing new workers
compared to 10 years ago. This new development time is causing problems, delays in production,
as well as safety concerns. Most importantly, this kind of shift requires collaboration among
the administration, Congress, state partners, and industry to make sure there is a long-term plan
to invest in U.S. mining and to build back a stronger workforce to meet demand. Policies
like President Trump's executive order to prepare for high-paying skilled jobs and the Stronger
Workforce for America Act, which was introduced by Chairman Wahlberg, are much-needed solutions
to address the problems in our industry. Perhaps the most pressing challenge is one perception.
A career in mining today can mean operating sophisticated equipment, managing complex
logistics, working in an environment compliance, or leading teams of skilled professionals.
The earning potential is among the highest available to workers without a four-year degree,
and the career stability that comes with supplying minerals and energy to the American economy is
considerable. Changing this public perception, starting in our schools and communities,
is critical to protecting our domestic mining industry. Thank you. I look forward to your
questions. Thank you, Mr. Carter. I'll now recognize Mr. Petzonk for your testimony.
Thank you, Chairman Wahlberg and Congressman Messmer. It's an honor to be here. I'm truly
grateful for this opportunity. I am Sam Petzonk. I'm a miners' health and safety lawyer from West
Virginia. I formerly staffed U.S. Senator Robert C. Byrd and Cart Goodwin on issues of mine safety.
I'm closely familiar with the legislative history of the Mine Act and the appropriations challenges
that go along with it. I've represented thousands of coal miners and their families nationwide on
health, safety, and economic issues. I want to address two principal issues today. One,
the crystalline silica rule that you referenced that was recently set aside by the Mine Safety
and Health Administration, and two, the dangers that go along with cutting back on safety budgets,
safety agencies as we face these heightened risks of mining in heavily depleted mineral basins,
such as Appalachia and the Illinois Basin, including Indiana. As to the silica rule,
the United States has taken 100 years to provide miners with an independently enforceable limit on
highly toxic, respirable silica dust. We have instituted a breathable silica dust limit for
every other major category of American worker, except for the miners who face the most extreme
exposures. This is a long overdue matter. I think in the opinion of, and I see many mine workers who
are here today and working people, have known these risks for 100 years, and we all have. It's
been over, well over 50 years since CDC recommended a particular exposure limit that we still haven't
put into place. Hundreds, if not thousands, of miners in Appalachia have experienced this extreme
sandstone exposure in recent decades. As we mine thinner seams, we have to cut more sandstone,
and we are facing what I call a slow-moving hawks nest disaster. You may remember in the 1930s,
hundreds of African-American rock drillers died of acute silicosis in Fayette County.
I still practice in that county today, and I just yesterday received a report of a 28-year-old miner
with 10 years of mining experience who already has very significant lung function loss from
severe silicosis. I've represented 32-year-old miners, 36-year-old miners, miners who are seeking
double lung transplants in their early 40s or late 30s. This is an urgent issue, and I respect
the concerns about the industry and small operators very much, but my purpose here today is to say
the agency that is supposed to protect America's miners has abandoned them in court. The MSHA
didn't even ask. The MSHA was sued over the silica rule, but they have not defended it.
They could have asked the court to allow the rule to come into force to protect the most vulnerable,
and MSHA has not even asked for that. This committee has an important opportunity to
send a message to MSHA that you can protect miners, and you have a duty to do so under the
Mine Act, so I hope you will urge the agency to fully restore the silica rule and refine it later.
You can work on it, and you should, but secondly, as to the threat of cutting safety while we face
these escalating risks in the mines, the government's message is run more coal, and
we've heard that message for a long time in Appalachia, but the risks are growing because
in central and eastern United States, our coal basins are substantially depleted. We've been
mining for a long time, and you mine the good coal first, and then you have to get what's left over,
and we're in that getting what's left over phase right now, and that means we're cutting through
unstable high walls. We are dealing with unpredictable methane and extreme respirable
dust risks, so my second message here is it's not the time for the administration to be cutting
mine safety, and just this week, this administration has reportedly laid off one-third of the staff of
the Mine Safety and Health Review Commission, shutting down the entire Pittsburgh office,
and we now have only three administrative law judges nationwide to hear all the mine
enforcement actions in the country, and that's a real problem. By August of this year, with the
firings that have just occurred, the commission will lack a quorum. That means they will not be
able to conduct any business at all, and that has happened before, and it's caused major trouble and
backlog, which is a problem for mining companies, and you can make sure they appoint a new
commissioner to keep that thing operating, please. As to health more broadly, the Doge effort cut
a lot from NIOSH. We've restored a lot of it, but I've addressed in my remarks we have to
fully restore the continuous dust monitoring functions, and lastly, I just want to mention
that we have legacy commitments to miners. We should pass the Blackhound Benefits Improvement
Act, and as I mentioned, look ahead to protect rare earth miners. It's a new industry, and you've got
a lot on your hands. I thank you for the opportunity to address it. Thank you, and now I recognize
for his five minutes or three minutes of testimony, potentially five, I recognize Mr. Wolfson.
Thank you, and I likewise appreciate the opportunity to be here. This is a first for me
and a true honor to sit with my colleagues up here. Brief background about myself. I am a
practicing attorney and a partner in the Pittsburgh office of Fisher and Phillips LLP and a member of
the firm's workplace safety and catastrophe management practice group. My practice focuses
on counseling and representing employers with respect to their safety and health regulatory
requirements, and I maintain a subspecialty in mine safety and health regulatory requirements.
While I practice in all areas of safety and health law, the majority of my practice is
in the mine safety and health area, both coal and metal, non-metal types of mines.
My mining clients are regulated federally by the Federal Mine Safety and Health Act,
commonly referred to as the Mine Act, and the regulations promulgated by MSHA.
This is a strict regulatory framework and far exceeds, in terms of the burdens on employers,
what general industry faces under OSHA. This is for three primary reasons. Number one,
the Mine Act, unlike OSHA, requires mandatory inspections. Number two, MSHA has warrantless
inspection authority, unlike OSHA. And number three, mine operators are strictly liable for
any violations at their mine site. They do not enjoy the defenses that employers in general
industry enjoy under the OSHA scheme. However, within this framework, there are several
opportunities to improve the regulatory landscape while still achieving the goals of the Mine Act.
First, the Mine Act should include a pattern of compliance incentive that would stand opposite
of the pattern of violations sanction. The pattern of violations sanction is reserved for
mine operators with a demonstrated history of certain types of safety and health violations.
It has been said that it's reserved for, quote, unquote, the bad actors. Correspondingly,
there should be a performance-based incentive for the best of the good actors, which would
relieve regulatory burden for mine operators with a demonstrated history of compliance.
OSHA offers such an incentive to employers in the form of the Voluntary Protection Program,
which relieves potential regulatory burden under OSHA. This would require, however,
a statutory change under the Mine Act, and the committee should consider it.
Second, the MSHA enforcement scheme should reward and not punish mine operators who exceed
minimum regulatory requirements. Presently, mine operators frequently exceed the measures required
by MSHA's regulations, but can be cited for those very measures they take, and oftentimes,
those citations carry with them the elevated significant and substantial designation commonly
referred to as SNS, and MSHA frequently ignores the safety benefits provided by these measures
that exceed their own regulations. Finally, MSHA should undertake rulemaking to clarify key terms.
There are far too many vague and vague terms in the MSHA enforcement scheme with too much
gray area, which does not benefit either mine operators, miners, or MSHA. There are numerous
examples of vague terms, but I have highlighted two of them in my written testimony. First is,
again, significant and substantial, or SNS, which is an elevated designation reserved for
more serious violations. MSHA should undertake rulemaking and make a clear and workable definition
of SNS, specifically that an SNS designation is based on the particular facts and circumstances
of the violation at issue, which present a discrete hazard and a meaningful degree of
likelihood that the hazard would occur. Second, MSHA should undertake rulemaking to clarify the
term an injury with a reasonable potential to cause death, which thereby requires mine operators
to report these types of incidents to MSHA within 15 minutes. A bright line definition for what
constitutes such an injury would be beneficial to both mine operators, miners, and MSHA. The absence
of a clear definition leaves too much room for guesswork, particularly when such prompt operator
action is needed. These are two examples of many that MSHA could undertake to provide clearer terms
for the regulated community. I welcome your questions. Thank you for your comments. Under
Committee Rule 9, we'll now question witnesses under the five-minute rule.
I recognize Mr. Messmer for the purpose of questioning witnesses. Mr. Messmer. Thank you,
Mr. Chairman, and thank you to Vincent's University for hosting this important hearing.
Indiana is one of America's most important coal-producing states. Many of Indiana's communities,
including this one here in Gibson County, are built on coal mining. The mining industry also
is facing a harsh reality. In addition to regulatory burdens that operators must bear,
the industry has a growing workforce shortage. Vincent's University is taking steps to address
this worker shortage by training future generations of industry leaders. Workers must
be equipped to meet the demands of an evolving industry. Preparing workers to perform their
jobs safely and effectively is only part of the challenge. That's why safety training must be an
essential component of any training program instilling a lasting culture of safety.
With that, Mr. Stevens, you mentioned the many companies providing goods and services in the
mining industry in your testimony. Can you explain what type of companies these are and how they
impact and rely on the coal mining industry? Certainly. Thank you for the question.
It was mentioned I was president of the Indiana Coal Council for a number of years. That was a
trade association for the mining, the coal industry here in Indiana. We had about 100
members, sometimes over 100 members. Eight or ten of those were producing members. A couple of
them were large reserve holding members. Ninety percent of them were companies that provided
goods and services to the industry. With the decrease in the number of mines, the decrease
in production, those companies have been harmed. They are companies such as equipment and repair
are very large ones, transportation, both over the road and railroads, materials for the mining
industry such as the roof bolts and cribbings and conveyors and such, belting that you all saw
yesterday. Another thing is that last year there were mines, coal mines, only in six Indiana counties.
In 1988, they were in 13 counties. There were a lot more companies providing goods and services.
Distance has harmed them as well. It's a big impact not only to the coal miner itself,
but to those providing goods and services. It's said that for every coal mining job, there are
three or more indirect jobs that go along with that. I think three is a low number with respect
to that. That is a snapshot of those type of companies that have been harmed.
Also in your written testimony, you described the significant job losses to the Indiana's coal
sector. Why are these jobs so difficult to replace once they disappear?
Well, the first item I would say is that coal miners are highly trained, highly skilled
individuals. They command a good salary, as I mentioned, averaging over $90,000 a year
and many making more than that. They have very, very strong benefits. Jobs in the rural areas of
the state are difficult to match that. There may be jobs, but unfortunately, when a mine closes, a
worker has to face a choice of whether they're going to relocate or whether they're going to
accept a lower paying job, which has long-term impacts on families and particularly communities.
Mr. Carter, how do you recruit talent for your mines?
Currently, talent is recruited through various television ads, newspaper ads,
so forth, contractor supply companies. Very low-skilled workers come to the mines.
They go through extensive training programs that are required by IMSHA as well as
our organizations. So the experience of skills required in today's workforce,
you know, it's highly required for the mining industry, but workers that are trained in other
fields can easily adapt to the mining industry with their current skill level. These individuals
can bring a strong work ethic, very cultured safety background, as well as familiarity with
regulated industrial environments with targeted training and upskilling. These
capabilities can be efficiently applied to mining careers.
Thank you. Anything we can do to eliminate the stigma of career in mining for the next generation?
I think removing the stigma surrounding mining in the industry starts with better communication
about the workers and the mining actually looks like today. Too often, the perceptions are
rooted in outdated images or failed to reflect the industry's strong safety culture and advanced
technology commitment to environmental stewardship. By highlighting the wide range of
highly skilled roles and use of automation and data ad in Linux, the clear career pathways for
advancement, we can better demonstrate mining offers a stable, well-paying careers that align
with many existing industrial technical skills. When students, workers, communities understand
these skills are transferable to mining and supported by ongoing training and innovation,
it helps reduce misconceptions and informed awareness and respect for the energy.
Thank you. And with that, I yield back. I thank the gentleman from Indiana.
Now I give myself my five minutes of questioning. And again, thank you for the witnesses for being
here. Mr. Wolfson, as you noted in your written testimony, you support MSHA creating a regulatory
system that rewards mine workers who exceed their regulatory obligations in keeping their workers
safe. You mentioned VPP, voluntary protection program that OSHA has, which you don't have.
Can you provide some examples of common industry practices that go beyond the requirements of
MSHA's policies? Sure. Mining operators routinely provide both protections and
practices that exceed what is required by the MSHA standards. There are certainly
trainings that mine operators undertake that exceed what is required by part 48 or part 46,
both in frequency and substance. There is equipment. I've provided the examples of
shielded cables on underground coal, mobile equipment. There are proximity detection systems
on underground coal equipment other than continuous miners, which is all that's
currently required to have a proximity detection system. There are cameras on mobile equipment that
frequently isn't required. And mine operators invest a lot of money and time and resources
to provide these types of measures for the safety of their workers and for the betterment of their
operations. Thank you. Mr. Carter, thank you for putting up with us yesterday in the mine
and bringing us out as well. I also appreciate your support of my bill, HR 8210, the Stronger
Workforce for America Act of 2026, or really the reauthorized legislation that takes an
all-of-above plan and approach for workforce training. When it comes to mining, what does
an all-of-above approach to worker development and training look like? I think an all-above
approach to workforce development mining industries requires coordinated policy support,
strong industry participation across all full talent pipelines. This includes leveraging
existing federal workforce programs, such as the WIOA, alongside industry-led training,
registered apprenticeships, partnerships with community colleges and technical schools.
To ensure curriculum aligns with real-world mining needs, it also needs support from incumbent
worker training so current employees can adapt to advances in automation, safety systems, and
data-driven operations from an industry perspective. This approach would allow operators to develop
skilled, reliable workforce while giving workers access to long-term, high-quality careers. When
policy and industry work in tandem, workforce development becomes a strategic tool that
strengthens productivity, safety, and domestic supply chain. It's constant upgrading, isn't it?
Yes, it never ends. I appreciate that. Mr. Stephens, mining has historically
been a crucial part of this state's economic and industrial development.
What role should the government play in partnering with the private sector to sustain
mining industry's economic importance and long-term stability?
Thank you, sir. As I mentioned, this facility is a real testament to the
partnership that the federal government can have with learning institutions.
It plays a very critical role with funding, such as MSHA's training grant, which
Benson's University receives annually. What is necessary is some stability going forward.
There needs to be stable multi-year funding, so training programs,
which you will see if you have not already, there is a lot of equipment.
There's a lot of needs. There's the need to hire competent instructors and such,
so stable multi-year funding would be very welcome.
Then there's also opportunity for apprenticeships in mining. As Mr. Carter referenced,
I don't believe they are steering anyone away from a career in coal, but I don't think they're
directing them toward it either. There needs to be an understanding that today's
coal miner is a highly technically competent individual who can be in many different fields
and make certain that the opportunity is there for them to find jobs in the coal mining industry.
Thank you. My time has expired, but unless there's objection,
I'll take a chairman's personal prerogative. We have a witness here that was
identified for us by the Democrats on our committee. Mr. Petsank, you've come a long way,
and I appreciate you being here. Normally, Democrats would be asking you questions,
but since they chose not to be here, and I'm disappointed with that, I'm going to ask you a
question to make it worth your while here. Plus, I think you and I discussed a little bit before
we came out here. You highlighted considerations we should take into account regarding rare earth
minerals and the mining that will have to take place if we're going to be found in that realm
which we need to be. Can you briefly describe what some of those considerations might be?
Thank you. This is an industry that has not matured in the United States. We are looking
at producing rare earth minerals through traditional mining, pit mining, perhaps
underground mining. There is also an interest in essentially something similar to fracking,
which is called in-situ leaching. The health risks, there could be potential exposures there
that have not been well studied in the United States. My question for MSHA for years now really
has been, where is the science that will inform our enforcement efforts? NIOSH and MSHA should
be developing that so that we have the ability to identify the protective standards. The
International Labor Affairs Bureau of DOL has done some initial outreach in the Democratic
Republic of the Congo where most of the cobalt mining happens internationally. There's rare
earths, there's cobalt, there's lithium, there's a variety of new battery inputs, but we should be
studying them and lay a groundwork for regulating. I appreciate your attention to that very much. It's
an emerging issue that you can really make an impact. Thank you. Well, it's a real world issue
and there are wars developed around all of that. Thank you for those insights.
I now will move to a second round of questioning. I recognize the gentleman from Indiana,
Mr. Messmer, to begin that round. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Wolfson,
in your written testimony, you call for establishing a Federal Mine Safety
and Health Act, establishing a pattern of compliance designation.
What do you believe this added benefit in creating this kind of incentive program would accomplish?
The benefit would be to provide mine operators with the freedom to meet their safety and health
obligations through different avenues, not just by the prescriptive enforcement method currently
set forth by MSHA. Sure, mine operators would still be required to meet the standards
set forth by MSHA, but currently the way in which we evaluate whether they've done so is through
strict and heavy enforcement by MSHA inspectors. The OSHA example provides another path through
which OSHA does through its VPP, which would be a performance-based program by which mine
operators could demonstrate that they are complying with leading indicators for safety
rather than just strict enforcement. And if they meet those measures, then they could
achieve some level of relief from the enforcement burden that they currently face from MSHA.
And you commented that mine operators get cited for exceeding minimum standards. Can you give me
some examples of how they get cited for doing things that already exceed the standards?
Sure. So earlier with respect to Mr. Wahlberg's question, I offered some examples of some items
that mine operators commonly use that exceed the requirements of the MSHA standards. If conditions
were to exist on those items that are not required, that could subject mine operators to
additional citations, which goes on their compliance history for an item that they're
not even required to have. But probably even more concerning than that is that frequently these
citations carry with it a significant and substantial or S&S designation, which is
detrimental to the mine's compliance history and can lead to further sanctions. It seems
counterintuitive to subject mine operators to enhanced enforcement with respect to items that
they're not even required to have. And in contrast, MSHA should recognize the additional
safety measures that these items provide and consider that in the enforcement program.
Thank you. And will all those changes need statutory changes or can any be done by rule?
The pattern of compliance designation would require a statutory change because presently
Section 103A of the Mine Act requires that all surface mines be inspected twice per year and
underground four times per year. So that would require a statutory change. In terms of MSHA's
approach to the non-required items that exceed its standards, that would not require a statutory
change and frankly wouldn't even require a rule. It could be subject to a rule, but it could also just
be met by a change in how MSHA does business.
Thank you. Mr. Stevens, many of you mining industry as was decades or centuries ago,
but in your testimony you make a point out that this is an industry that demands innovative
approaches and highly specialized skills. How are schools, apprenticeship programs,
or other training opportunities adopting to meet these demands as the industry evolves?
Thank you, sir. Unfortunately, you're absolutely correct in the statement that absolutely many
people have a bad perception of coal mining at this point. As I mentioned in my opening remarks,
some still view it as miners with picks and shovels going underground every day and
loading coal in that manner. And miners work hard. They are absolutely some of the hardest
working people that there are. But the operations today, they're highly technical,
they're safety driven, they rely on advanced equipment. Automation is amazing in the mining
realm these days and skilled trades as well. So mining needs to be understood that it's modern
and that it's stable and that a person can earn a well compensated career. So expanding training
programs, apprenticeships and partnerships with high schools and technical institutions would
help. There are a lot of skilled jobs at the coal mines. If those high school students
have the opportunity to learn and then have the potential to go into another program,
welding is a great example. There's a great need for welders, not just in coal mining, but
in many, many sectors. A high school student with a background in welding could come to Vincennes
University, which has an excellent welding program as well and continue to learn their skill or they
could go straight to the mine and learn their skill there. So we really do need to focus on
changing the perception and there needs to be an emphasis in schools that there is still
a career path in coal mining and aggregate mining, other forms of mining as well.
Thank you and with that I yield back.
Thank you gentlemen. Mr. Stevens, returning to you, while we're discussing workforce development
and workforce safety, there are dozens of other policy areas that also have a large
impact on determining the success of mining industry, such as investing in technology,
infrastructure, permitting reform, tax incentives, and we could go on and on.
What policies and initiatives such as these would have the greatest effect in expanding
and improving mining operations? Thank you. Consistent regulatory frameworks.
I'd be here all day. Are of much importance. There absolutely has got to be certainty
going forward. Permitting reform, which was mentioned, that is of huge importance.
The goalposts can't be moved. There has to be consistency. When an applicant goes with the same
type of application for the same area, things don't need to be changed from application to
application. There needs to be specific time frames that an agency must perform within.
Some are very good. Others are unfortunately very bad and it takes a huge amount of time
and that drives up costs tremendously and it's very hard to get investors whenever you can't
go and say we have our permits. Sometimes it takes years to get some of the federal permits
and that's just really uncalled for. As I mentioned as well, there are many utility
regulations that are being looked at right now. Federal EPA and such and within Congress.
Utilities are the coal company's customer. Utilities have to feel as though they're not
going to be regulated out of business and any initiatives in regard to giving them a comfort
level that has them to endorse coal more so even than what they do would be very welcome.
Have them speak truth to power about what the real needs are. I often think how much good AI
has the potential of doing and permitting reform and bumping up the time frame by not going through
the same exercises over and over again. So thank you. Mr. Carter, your written testimony discusses
a variety of high-skilled jobs that are part of your industry and the broad perspective that's
there as well and opportunities that you have. Yet many students may not know about these
opportunities. Could you tell us where you're seeing the greatest demand for high-skilled jobs
and how we can better promote these opportunities to students and individuals working outside of the
mining industry? Currently, the biggest opportunity for high-skilled jobs is in the
engineering fields, whether it be mining, civil, electrical, or mechanical engineering, as well as
software engineers. Those roles in the industry are growing rapidly and are really needed to
progress the mines with the new technical data that comes along. All the equipment has evolved
to a specific point where it requires a very high skill set and those individuals can earn very high
amount of money doing those jobs. As Arthur mentioned earlier, there are
mines that have equipment cameras and so forth associated with equipment that's not required.
So it takes a highly skilled, highly trained person with ability to gain more knowledge to
work on these pieces of specialized equipment. So as far as to better promote the opportunities,
we need stronger partnerships between the industry, education providers, workforce agencies
to ensure students transitioning workers understand how their skills align with mining.
Increased exposure through career technical education, apprenticeships, internships,
and outreach to workers in manufacturing, construction, and energy can help demonstrate
these skills were transferable to mining. Clear pathways and visibility into long-term advancement
opportunities are key to attracting talent in both traditional and non-traditional backgrounds.
In the few seconds I have remaining, I'm going to take the risk, Mr. Wilson, of asking you this
question where you're seeing the greatest demand for high-skilled, excuse me, in reference to what
this committee did last year in submitting a letter to MSHA calling for revisions to the 2024
rule on respiro-crystalline silica so that the rule better aligns with reality that's out there.
How do you believe harmonizing MSHA policies with policies set for general industry by OSHA
would benefit the mining industry? Well, it would put the mining industry on an even playing field
with general industry. Currently, the MSHA silica rule that was promulgated in 2024 does not allow
mine operators to meet a level of compliance with certain measures that general industry enjoys,
such as respiratory protection, rotation of miners, and through alternative means that
certain OSHA-regulated employers enjoy through Table 1. It would provide the same level of
protection for miners while allowing mining employers to meet their obligations through
a variety of ways, the same as those employers regulated by OSHA enjoy. Thank you. And again,
taking the time of the Democrat members who aren't here, Mr. Petsank, I'd like to discuss
your written testimony, discusses emergency risks in the mining industry as our Workforce
Protection Subcommittee will hold a hearing on emergency safety issues next week. Can you offer
briefly your perspective on what those emergency issues in mining might be?
Thank you again, Chairman Wahlberg. Just on last week, the Office of the Inspector General
from the Department of Labor issued a report addressing MSHA's accident investigations
and emergency response capacity in the industry. I would urge the committee to look at that report.
It was disturbing to me that the Inspector General found MSHA had only documented in an accident
investigation for 3% of the accidents that merited scrutiny. So MSHA is failing to investigate 97%
of the concerning accidents right now, according to the Inspector General. I hope that you'll follow
up about that. MSHA has the budgetary, I appreciate that Congress is trying to protect this agency's
budget. Within the budget they have, we've got to ensure that they are conducting what is called
impact inspections to identify and go after persistent violators. That is a rational way
of targeting risk. Also, there's an internal auditing process to ensure that accidents are
accurately reported. We'd like to see more internal auditing within MSHA to ensure that
accidents and illnesses are accurately reported. So looking at the Inspector General's report would
go a long way. And if you could ask the agency to focus on sustaining its impact inspections
and it's what are known as part 50 audits to ensure accurate reporting. Those are all good
practices I think would benefit the industry. Thank you. I appreciate that. Thank you.
Seeing that the time for questioning has expired, I'd like to thank all the witnesses again
for testifying before the committee today. I'd like to thank the audience for being here as well.
We don't do these field hearings just so we can be away from home in our districts.
You're in your district, but had other members come, including myself, we're away from the
district. But these are crucial issues we really want to address. And that's why we have a bipartisan
effort to do that very thing. We're not trying to hide anything in this process.
We respect the mining industry. I think Representative Messmer and I both will say
that very strongly. Both having been in mines around this country and now most recently here
in Indiana, it's crucial that mining not simply be sustained, but given a future that advances
and increases. When we talk about rare earths, minerals, we talk about hard rock mining.
But I for one believe having a huge coal-fired plant in my district, second largest in North
America, on Lake Erie, that's producing power even during polar vortexes. I'm not sure if you
get that down here in southern Indiana, but we sure do in Michigan. To have weeks and weeks of
coal piles, they're ready to be useful to providing energy for all of the resources that
need energy is important. We intend to keep looking into this issue. It is our purposes
in the majority to build upon an economy, but to make sure that the mining industry
has an economy that grows as well. We want to make sure that safety is there,
but that creative tension that can be there brought about by the miners themselves,
the union representatives, where necessary, bring about those concerns. We're always willing to
listen, but there's a creative tension. Also, we want to keep mines operating.
We want the industry to survive and thrive. As businesses, there are those challenges that we
have to consider as well for the industry so it's strong. We also know, bottom line,
it touches families. It touches the economy, not simply of the country or region. It touches the
personal economy of families that expect that paycheck to carry on their needs and make a
future for their families as well. All of that is within the purpose of this committee and our
subcommittee dealing in that area as well. I appreciate the fact that we've had this opportunity
today to be here and that you've joined us. I want to say a special thank you to Vincennes
University for giving us a great space here. Now, we look forward to a virtual experience of mine
safety training as well that is very uniquely located here. We thank Peabody Mining Operations
for giving us real-world opportunity. I'm not sure you're ready to hire, well, maybe to hire
Representative Messmer. That's another thing, to have a member of my committee who actually comes
from a district that has significant mining operations across the spectrum is very important.
I think we have one Democrat member who has significant mining operations that we wish
could have been here as well to represent, and maybe in the future we can make that happen.
But we appreciate being in your district, the hospitality you've given, and the pounds I put
on with good food from your district as well. With that, having no further business to be heard at
this time, the committee stands adjourned.
