Pike and Shot River Faceoff (Total War: Medieval 1212 Mod Battle # 181)

Historical Identity
26 followers
14 Video Views·Apr 29, 2026
Indypride and I bring two pike and shot armies up to the river crossing... the results are... messy
Check out the rest of my channel for more Total War content including massive battles, warhammer news, and historical documentaries
For Massive Battles be sure to check out this playlist: • 11,000 Man Siege of Cyrene (Massive Battles)
For documentaries on classical antiquity check out this playlist:
• Classical Antiquity (Documentaries)
Hey, what's up guys? We're gonna be playing a game between myself and IndiePride.
This is gonna be the Medieval 1212 mod for Attila and
it is gonna be a river crossing, but it's gonna be an interesting river crossing in that we're doing a full pike and shot build
for this river crossing. So we're gonna be sending troops back and forth essentially to die.
So this is IndiePride's force. We're contesting both river crossings. So up front he has
three of these handgunner forces, a fourth one standing in the back, and then a huge line of these
medium Polarn infantry.
So there's Catalano, Aragonese, pikemen, which look really cool.
So we're just doing, like I said, a pike and shot build, which is gonna be pretty interesting, somewhat thematic.
I've always wanted to see how this would pan out.
So Indie's gonna go ahead and send his first force forward wading into the river and these gunners look really epic,
super heavily armored. You can watch them as they wade through and now they're gonna get some of their shots off.
It looks like mostly that was a whiff, so here I come.
I'm gonna be closing in on him. A couple more of the shots gonna be connecting, just pop on the HUD.
So these are gonna be frontiersmen, medium infantry with medium skirmishers backing them up.
My guys are holding up their shields as if that would try and maybe do something.
But anyways, we're gonna take our first attempt at it, our first shot at it.
Meanwhile, Indie is gonna take his first shots literally at it.
So my skirmishers are gonna be at least harassing him, keeping him back. So let's watch my dudes.
And looks like they've chickened out just because his guys
were rallying. Now they're gonna form up.
Ooh, and all those surrounding forces on the left side unloading on my guys. A couple of them seem to have been clipped in the retreat.
But I get out of range before these men can get up close. And look at this, he's got the pike
halberd unit in the back. Man, these guys are so incredibly armored. And then the shot in the front. So nice combination there.
So this is gonna be mostly where we're gonna be doing this little dance back and forth. Ooh.
See actually as this front rank gets hit by all sides. So here comes another volley.
I don't think I'm even gonna have a chance to get up close. Let's see if my guys can even close the distance here.
I brought a couple of my own units. We're now gonna be firing close support.
We're gonna be able to charge forward across the open straits. So here we go, straight into his guys.
But cavalry gets a counter charge just at the last moment. Those guys also equally heavily armored.
Luckily, it does mean the Indie Pride's forces are susceptible for my counter shots. So I'm gonna start unloading on his cavalry.
They're gonna think better of getting closer my guys, and they're gonna do an about-face.
Meanwhile, you see the covering fire of his dudes shooting at me.
My guys are gonna be charging forward with my halberdmen. Trying to close the distance with the supporting fire. Just
crushing everything in front of them. And this pike and shot stuff is really cool.
So now I've closed in. I've been able to reinforce my frontiersmen who are up front.
So now I have some of my own halberdiers against his halberdiers. I'm sending him some medium skirmishers.
I'm gonna try and focus fire on these dudes. We're just trying to support from this hillside position.
Overwatching our guys. And you can see he has a nice flanking shot right into my dudes.
So this is gonna be a prime target. A couple more by the riverbed are we find sideways.
At the carnage that's taking place over there. More of Indie's guys are gonna reshuffle around to try and get some shots off.
My skirmishers combined fire. It's gonna be pouring a lot of damage into this hilltop.
So while Indie's distracted over here with this combat. I believe, yep.
I was able to move in some of my peasant archers. So these guys are pretty shitty.
Peasant bowmen, but I figured, you know, we're just gonna start chipping away at his guys. So
Looking at the faces of my dudes. They look pretty dopey.
See only a couple of them actually getting volleys off and his guys meanwhile are heavily armored.
So it's gonna take a lot of shots to do anything. They're just gonna
You know, this guy's bleeding profusely on the ground, but he's just gonna shake it off. No one really cares.
They're looking over their shoulder as if nothing happened. This guy takes an arrow to the shin.
Seemingly not doing anything. So yeah, I'm slowly chipping away on this side while the main battle is underway.
Let's go ahead and return to this front. So in the meat grinder of the center,
I've lost a lot of guys. Mostly my skirmishers in the front.
Hobbermen are coming in. I pulled up my hand gunners. We're gonna be firing from amongst the reeds.
At his position.
It's not quite clear who is gonna be winning this. He does have better fire
arcs on me.
Two units firing one over another down into my guys. So I'm gonna pull out of that knowing I don't need to commit.
I'm gonna let my javelins
presumably try and knock out some of his weaker guys and it looks like I've been able to crush through one of his
heavy infantry.
Some of my own and this is a civil war. I know this is a looks like I am
No, I'm not the Spaniards.
Indie pride is. I am not sure who this is. I'll have to check later. But anyways, this is
quickly becoming a bloody affair.
Not only from the halberds slicing through units, but also the supporting fire of the armor-piercing
handgunners. Friendly fire, enemy fire coming all through here. And then my own Jeanettes or skirmishers pouring on
more. And this is really cool the deployment of the Aragonese
pikes here. Really
standing by the pike and shot formation.
That looks freaking awesome. And this is the kind of stuff I'm looking forward to in
Total War Warhammer where you can really get some pike and shot going hopefully with the Empire and instead of facing off against humans
you're facing off against chaos warriors or orcs or other cool stuff.
So here comes my perhaps second or third wave. So I've thrown more halberdiers into the meat grinder against equal
troops. Indie's gonna be throwing in some more of his own guys into the mix where it is a like I said a bloody
just carnage filled beachhead. More of my guys pouring into the fight. These are
frontiersmen again, medium infantry. They're just meant to hold firm, but Indie's gonna throw in his heavy guys.
I just want to pop on the HUD just to see what these guys are. So these are the
heavy late period pull arms. They've lost one man in response. My guys are crumbling there. You've lost 20 men.
I just want to see a little bit of combat between these guys.
So I'm not voting too well right through there.
Maybe a couple lucky kills. The supporting fire is probably doing more than my frontiersmen. The rest of this unit here
looking so cool. Some pikes deployed in the background and now Indie's gonna be bringing those guys up to bear to plug any
form of gap that I may have had here. My own cavalry is gonna get a nice
shock charge
flattening his
handgunners. His pikes are gonna push forward. However, they did not have their pikes deployed yet. Now they do.
This is gonna be an opportunity for me to focus fire on them. Indie's cavalry is gonna counter charge in here.
Meanwhile, the rest of my forces are retreating.
This is a beautiful shot of the battle.
So it's been ping-ponging back and forth. Whoever gets within range of the enemy gunners is gonna get thrashed.
This is exactly what's happening to the cavalry here. Caught in a very very bad position. You can see the general
I believe here trying to point to his men to charge forward across.
And he does break into my initial line of medium handgunners. However, they all really
heavily armed, so they should be able to hold out. Another huge block of gendarmes charges into my guys. More
halberdmen. So this is not going well for me. On the far rank, I'm continuing to fire away, doing no damage to the handgunners.
I pulled in some of my halberdiers, medium pull arms.
Cavalry is gonna be plugging that far gap, but mostly Indie is swarming through this position.
Some of the cavalry is gonna sneak its way through.
This is my last line on this front, and it is only a couple men thick as I try and hold them back.
Meanwhile, my heavy handgunners are gonna try and reform behind this position.
I do have some more cav that were hidden, and so they're gonna be coming out.
They do look really cool.
So actually, this is the Serbian Grand Prince.
He's charging here, and it looks like it has successfully forced the enemy cav back.
However, now that the enemy pikes are in my mix, I do not have access to these pikes with such long reach.
So this will be to Indie Pride's advantage. Halberd's into the mix as well.
He should be thrashing me pretty effectively. I do have some
supporting fire here, although it looks like it was tied up with the enemy cav that penetrated through.
So things not looking super good for me. I am gonna be focusing fire on the, uh, oh, they're called calm down.
So that's wrong. But anyways, I'm gonna be focusing fire on them.
You can see a couple move orders being told for my cavalry to reinforce this position.
Indie Pride's gonna be pulling back.
I'm now gonna attempt an assault on that force,
but mostly I want to come back and try and help on this front. My main line is somehow holding, actually.
It looks like with the close support of my dudes, the halberdiers are kicking ass. 142 kills for their name. That is incredible.
I don't know how they're holding through. Indie is pushing forward. He's gonna try and clip my general.
I'm gonna commit some of my medium handgunners to get up close.
I need to tie up his guys, keep them back, pull out my Grand Prince.
So it looks like I've been able to hold his forces at bay with the reinforcements.
This should be enough for me to perhaps beat this back. Yep, unit on the right being broken.
Somehow I was able to hold this back. So this is epic.
So my guys are gonna reform on my side and again, a pool of dead marking the high watermark.
Ooh, and one of these guys picking himself off the ground.
This man perhaps not being so lucky. I think he's gonna stay down for the count.
Telling his buddies that he is not feeling so well, and he's just gonna just gonna settle down for a little nap.
I don't I don't blame him.
The main problem though is once I have kind of destroyed his front lines,
it's gonna open up the opportunity for him to get some volleys off.
So Indie has brought back one of his handgunners, a pretty healthy force.
You can pivot to this side where I'm gonna be trying to do some sort of a charge on this front.
I got my gennets. I got all my peasant crossbowmen facing his guys.
So I'm gonna see, okay, what happens when you set a bunch of peasants against heavily armed and armored units?
And the answer is not very much. So this is more of a holding force.
I have a lot of units, but not much quality.
So I brought my halberds close because I was fearing a cavalry charge.
I'm gonna pull out before I get dealt too much damage.
The rest of my force is pulled over to the right where like I said, I think I've I've been able to rally and
make better results of this.
I think Indie's Pride's units at this point have
broken for the most part. His attention is focused elsewhere.
So I'm gonna get some nice easy shots into some of his dudes that would have otherwise rallied.
So that's going pretty well for me.
More of my guys storming on that side.
We can return to this engagement where I don't think his guys are within range.
So once again, I get a little bit of an advantage while Indie Pride kind of just stares at me from this point.
I think he's gonna be contemplating a charge, weighing the odds of you see more of my cavalry
being pulled back and sent to the right flank.
So peasant crossbowmen or peasant bowmen are the only thing really holding this force back.
The general at this on this side can
propose a charge at any point. He has the heavy infantry, tons of heavy infantry at the back.
This could easily crush through my forces. So I have to be a little wary of what's going on here.
More guys being sent to the right. And yeah, these hand gunners.
Let's see, the rightmost unit was the one I was shooting at the entire time.
So that entire time just goes to show how weak
the peasant bowmen and skirmishers are. Only did two kills on this force.
Pretty sad stuff. Although it does look like I'm gonna be taking more hits at the
Aragonese King.
Over here, Indie has re-engaged most of his dudes.
Although the balance of forces is evenly matched now that I've reinforced with more guys. Cavalry in particular.
Ooh, who are these? Pronesia Lancers.
I want to get a close look at this because the attention to detail in the unit models in this mod are just super epic.
So I've spotted a bit of an opportunity.
That's gonna be a chance for me to knock some of his dudes. Although against polearms,
this is not gonna be going well for my cav. You can watch as he starts to
take them off their horses. Oh my god, my guy's just melting away seemingly. So good thing
I have a couple heavy axemen thrown in the mix.
With gunners on the high ground to support.
Oh my god, you see that decapitation right there? Brutal.
This battle, it's not quite won on my side and my heroic
halberdiers, who were holding this flank for a good amount of the time, have actually now been destroyed.
Indy's focusing fire on my guys. The rest of the troops being broken, however. General rallying here.
So I have one on this flank. So my guys that had disengaged from that fight actually
pulling back to reinforce this position where I was hoping to hold out. Indy has moved up his
medium gunners to get shots point-blank with my archers. We're having a bit of an awkward confrontation where he has positioned himself
just point-blank with my archers.
Second he gets volleys off, which is gonna be immediately.
Good thing to move point-blank with peasants and look at how much damage he is doing to my guys.
Meanwhile, the returning fire to the peasants is doing absolutely nothing.
I mean look at this, taking shots to the shoulder. That guy's got a shot to the
yeah, right shoulder on that guy, left shoulder on him. This guy has his his wrist being just completely shattered.
I'm gonna attempt to counter charge against some of those guys. One of my medium lancers is gonna penetrate.
So I'm trying to get up close and personal, deal some nice damage like I was able to on the other flank.
We'll see how well that does. Indy's gonna move in some of his guys, medium polearm infantry, in close support.
This guy's in the rear getting some shots off, but he doesn't have the best angle. Although my cav was
obliterated in that engagement. Just the supporting fire, I believe, from his troops. Some guys here firing on the flanks.
So cavalry really not playing a big role in this battle.
It just gets shredded to pieces by the armor-piercing capabilities of these handgunners.
I decide, well, maybe if I can get up close with my halberds, it's gonna be good.
However, this is when Indy commits his epic looking dudes, two units full of them.
And I don't quite have the numbers on this flank to do well. You can see the puddles of water from the supporting fire
I'm trying to get in, but this time I don't really have the angles of fire that I need.
I only have one handgunner unit here firing at his dudes.
The rest are gonna be these really crappy peasant bowmen.
If I gloss over all of them, zero kills, five kills on the skirmishers, three kills here,
zero there, and eight here. So combined only about ten kills for five units. That is not good.
Especially when you get the heavy pressure here, overwhelming my halberdiers. I perhaps overcommitted units on that side.
And what's happened is now he's gonna be free to break loose amongst my ranks. Peasant bowmen, like I said,
standing no chance against his guys. Maybe when he gets up close, I get a couple extra volleys.
We can check this out. Waiting amongst the reeds, cavalry in the distance, charging forward right into my guys.
He's gonna plow through my archers, then he's gonna get into my skirmishers.
And some of these guys, armed with maces, are gonna be clobbering through my skirmishers.
Although point-blank, looks like we're gonna be able to throw a couple javelins into that guy.
Yeah, this is gonna be brutal. With no heavy infantry support left on this flank, I'm gonna get absolutely thrashed.
I am taken, shaken, casualty sustained, 60 men left and one of my guys.
So once you get to about half strength, this is gonna be pretty brutal.
One of them has already broken. The second one is now gonna start to rout.
Here comes the rest of Indy Pride's force, moving forward.
And this is the scary infantry block that I just don't really have enough units to deal with.
I've wasted most of my cavalry. A cavalry charge against this, once it gets across out in the open, would probably be pretty beneficial.
But I really don't have much left.
Indy, at the deployment, had more heavy infantry. I believe this battle,
I had invested a bit too many of my unit slots into the peasants, which is never a good idea.
So like I was saying, these archers, not gonna be able to hold this back.
Although,
skirmishers in the rear have been able to... I don't think they...
Oh, yeah, it looks like they actually did take out a couple of the enemy cav, and looks like we took out the second.
So these guys being the MVP of the peasant units with 21 kills.
However, now we're gonna start to feel the burn.
Incoming hand gunners, they're gonna be focus firing my guys. Starting to get a chain route here.
Indy is gonna move his force over in this position to chase after my guys. My units are now trying to reposition.
I formed up into wedge, which I figured would be a better way to hold back against these guys.
It does give you some bonuses. Meanwhile, the rest of my force is gonna be making its way back over here to try and support.
But then at the end, the timer ran out and I had taken more losses.
Didn't get to see the final conclusion of this battle, but I think you saw a nice amount of killing taking place in the river.
So definitely fun stuff. Pike and shot is not something you see every day. Pretty interesting.
Like I said, it does hold promise for what we'll see in Total War Warhammer.
I'm gonna end the replay. We can take a look at some of the
stats that happened here.
Admittedly, that replay did not go completely as it happened in real life. It was somewhat bugged.
I believe the replay glitch occurred.
So that's why I wasn't able to see the the final stats and also why the units were behaving in a bit of a different way.
So anyways, apologies for that.
Hope you guys enjoyed it. Nonetheless, definitely a cool fight and I got a couple more of these to share with you.
So hope you guys enjoyed. See you in the next one. Peace out.
