Anohana creator Mari Okada is one of the few anime writers to make the jump to directing. So how does her debut film, Maquia: When The Promised Flower Blooms, stack up next to the greats? See Maquia at a Theatre near you: https://www.elevenarts.net/animedistr...
Follow me on twitter: / g0ffthew Also on facebook: / mothersbasementofficial And check out my Steam Curator page: http://steamcommunity.com/groups/moth... and the new Mother's Basement Subreddit: / mothersbasement
In the depths of his Mother's Basement, Geoff Thew creates videos analyzing the storytelling techniques of anime and video games. He has been named the number one Worst YouTube Anime Reviewer by The Top Tens. #anime#movie#review
If all my years of watching anime have taught me one thing, it's this.
Never trust a Mari Okada project involving flowers.
Iron-Blooded Orphans, Hanasaku Iroha, especially Anohana,
if it's got her name on it and involves any kind of flower symbolism, especially in the title,
you just know it's gonna deliver a precision-targeted strike right to your feels.
As a writer, Okada has a remarkable talent for making her characters suffer in the most
beautiful ways, and for translating concepts and experiences that are clearly rooted somewhere
deeply personal into stories with broad emotional power. It wouldn't be fair to reduce her talents
to just one aspect. She's shown phenomenal skill at writing action and comedy, and at worldbuilding.
But when Mari Okada wants to make you cry, by god, I will cry. A lot.
Makiya, When the Promised Flower Blooms, proudly continues that tradition.
It's last few scenes took me from tearing up to bawling uncontrollably,
and the ride to that end was an emotional rollercoaster in the best sense of that cliché.
It is, perhaps, the most pure example of Mari Okada's vision ever put on screen,
which was apparently exactly what PA Works president Kenji Horikawa wanted when he asked
her to write – and, for the first time in her career, direct – her own film. A 100% Okada anime.
It's unusual, to say the least, for a writer to make the jump to directing anime. Studios tend
to want people with animation experience in that demanding role. But Okada isn't your usual writer.
She's one of the most prolific and respected writers in her field, and with her excellent
autobiography having just been optioned for a film, she's about to become an anime character
herself. And she's not your usual director, either. At a time when anime films are clearly trending
towards surreal, sad tales of contemporary teenagers, Okada has chosen to make a decade-
spanning hard fantasy epic, set in a remarkably well-realized world – thankfully free of any
super-obvious Tolkien influences – with an equally well-thought-out and original plotline.
Fittingly, Makiya tells the story of Makiya, a lonely young girl from Iolfe, a legendary clan
of immortals who stop aging as teenagers, and who record the histories of their long lives by
weaving their stories into special cloths called hibiol. One night, dragon-riding soldiers from
a neighboring kingdom attack Makiya's homeland, hoping that one of the immortal maidens can bear
their prince an equally long-lived heir. Makiya is forced out into the wider world of mortals,
and shortly afterward finds an abandoned human baby who she decides to adopt as her own,
naming him Ariel. The film follows this found family throughout their entire lives,
As time goes on, we see small moments that reshape the dynamics of their relationship,
and larger ones that reshape the very world we live in. It's rare to see a fantasy film that
feels at once so intimate and grand in its scope, concerning itself with both the daily lives of
the world's people, and events as monumental as the fall of aging empires. Though there's a lot
going on here, and it would be very easy to lose the narrative thread between all of the timeskips
and high fantasy concepts, Makiya is held together by a tight focus on the core theme of motherhood.
The film's long timescale allows it to thoroughly explore what it really means to be a mother,
and all that that entails. From protecting and providing for your child when they're young,
to the bittersweet experience of watching them grow into adulthood, and ultimately become their
person. And that hibiyo cloth that I mentioned earlier acts as a sort of metaphor for the
legacies that people leave behind. It's heartwarming, heartbreaking, and a little
bit freudian. But only just freudian enough. Which is good, because this is an anime specifically
about a mom who stays 15 forever, and it could easily go WAY too freudian. Thankfully, while
this rollercoaster hits a lot of emotional peaks and drops, it never takes an usagi drop.
And if you don't know what I'm talking about, do yourself a favor and never ever look it up.
Not only does this underlying theme make me really, really want to call my mom,
it also helps to ground the film's more fantastical and alien elements in very relatable
emotional territory. And as we see echoes of motherly moments that we've experienced with
Makiya in the lives of other characters, specifically her kidnapped childhood friend
we're able to understand some of their emotional journeys through that context without actually
having to see it on screen. And this helps Makiya's story move along quickly as well.
Reincorporating and twisting the meaning of prominent plot points and key lines,
such as Makiya's repeated comments about how Ariel smells like the sun,
allows us to quickly grasp where the characters are emotionally every time we jump to a new location
or time. The narrative feels perfectly coherent and tightly paced when by all accounts its
unconventional structure should make it a stilted mess. It takes really clever writing to pull that
off. But of course the script was going to be phenomenal. This is Mario Kata we're talking about.
The real question is how everything else holds up. While first outings this ambitious have felled
lesser directors, just look at Goro Miyazaki's disastrous Tales from Earthsea, I am happy to
report that Okada knocked this one out of the park in every respect possible. The film features
breathtaking shots and animation cuts, tender scenes of subtle and not-so-subtle emotions,
all of which hit almost perfectly. I'm particularly impressed by the way Okada uses lighting and color
to punctuate the steps of Makiya's emotional journey. From the almost pure white innocence
of her life with the Eolf, to the more complex palettes that we see as she begins to mature
and Ariel begins changing her world, the film does a great job of using color to set the tone
and emotional context of each scene without those choices ever feeling forced or unnatural.
And you've been staring at clips from the film for long enough at this point that I don't need
to tell you that, generally speaking, the characters, the CG backdrops, and the shot
composition are all beautiful. The CGI allows for some really powerful dynamic camera moves,
although thankfully they use those sparingly so we don't get that handshakers effect.
And for those of you who like complaining about CGI character models, you'll be happy to know
that for the most part, when they're used, you don't even notice. In general, the compositing
in Makiya is really well done, and its world feels cohesive despite using disparate visual elements
that could very easily clash with each other. If there's one criticism that I could levy at Makiya,
it's that it doesn't quite have its own visual identity the same way that a Miyazaki,
Shinkai, Yuasa, or Hosoda production does. It feels like a proper fantasy anime,
and the rounded character designs and soft colors and lighting suit its setting and tone well.
But its visual style doesn't really stand out that much, either. And while that's to be expected,
to an extent – Okada comes from a writing background where those other directors define
their styles as animators first and foremost – I can't deny that it kinda holds the film back.
Beautiful though Makiya may be, nothing really left my jaw on the floor like a Shinkai wide shot
or a bombastic Yuasa cut can. Perhaps if Okada can keep working with character designer and
animation director Yuriko Ishii on future films, she'll be able to refine the stylistic elements
on display here into something more striking and unique. But failing that, my one concern
for her moving forward is that her films won't have the same immediate visual draw
as her contemporaries and competitors do. Likewise, while the film's score by legendary
composer Kenji Kawai is powerful, especially during its big emotional climax, it's not
particularly unique. You've heard this sort of dreamy mix of woodwinds, strings, and percussion
in fantasy films and JRPGs a dozen times before. It definitely works, but it's nothing special.
And that's a little disappointing coming from the guy who composed the OST for Ghost in the Shell.
Ultimately, Makiya thrives on the strength of its storytelling, not its spectacle. It's impeccably
edited and shot to convey information and emotional context to the viewer effectively,
and on a script level, everything just works. Both the lore of this fantasy world and the
characters who inhabit it are fascinating and remarkably fleshed out. And the film definitely
has its moments that can grip you and leave a hell of an impact. They just come from your
investment in the story, not the raw technical prowess on display. This is one of the best
stories that I've ever seen a director tell with their debut film. As a piece of cinema,
it's a triumph, but those looking for stunning anime spectacle may be a little disappointed.
Still, on the whole, I can't recommend Makiya when the promised flower blooms enough. This film
swept me up in its world and ultimately got me to cry even harder than the last episode of A Place
Further Than The Universe. Which is saying an awful lot. I'm giving this film a gold medal rating,
which is an honor that I reserve for films and shows that I would personally force a close
friend to watch at gunpoint. If you want to take my recommendation and see Makiya for yourself,
Eleven Arts, who provided me with the screener I watched for this review,
are bringing it to select theaters across the United States and Canada for one-time
showings toward the end of July. Check the link in the doobly-doo to find out where
and when it may be playing near you. And pro tip, bring a box of tissues.
I'm Geoff Thew, Professional Shitbag, signing out from my mother's basement.