Legendary director Hayao Miyazaki returns to us with the latest film from Studio Ghibli, The Boy and the Heron. The director of such classics as Spirited Away, Princess Mononoke and My Neighbor Totoro, has made more classic films than most filmmakers can even dream of! That's why it's such a shame that The Boy and the Heron is the most disappointing film of the year, and his worst film to date.
Please check out the rest of my channel for more movie reviews:
Movie Reviews: The Zone of Interest: A24 Movie Review (no spoilers) - • The Zone of Interest - A24 Movie Review (n... The Killer - Movie Review (no spoilers): • The Killer - Movie Review (NO SPOILERS) - ... Talk To Me - Horror Movie Review: • Talk To Me - Horror Movie Review Oppenheimer is FANTASTIC but FLAWED - IMAX 70mm Movie Review | Christopher Nolan Film: • Oppenheimer is FANTASTIC but FLAWED - IMAX...
Top 10 lists: Five Underrated Horror Movies to Watch This Halloween: • Five Underrated Horror Movies to Watch Thi... I Asked ChatGPT for Movie Recommendations, Here's What Happened: • I Asked ChatGPT for Movie Recommendations,... Five Underrated Films From Great Directors: • Five Underrated Films From Great Directors...
Video Essays: Two Films by James Benning: • Video Essay: Two Films by James Benning Where to Start with the Films of Andrei Tarkovsky: • Where to Start with the Films of Andrei Ta... Female Prisoner Scorpion: Analysis, Influence and Politics: • Female Prisoner Scorpion: Analysis, Influe... How Night of the Living Dead Brought Politics into Horror: • Video Essay: How Night of the Living Dead ... #anime#movie#review
AI Generated·May contain errors
The Boy in the Heron was easily one of my most anticipated films of the year.
Hayao Miyazaki is a true legend among legends, having directed not just some of the greatest
animated movies of all time, but some of the greatest movies full stop. His previous and
supposedly final movie, The Wind Rises, was an outstanding film on all accounts,
combining rich historical and character drama with the director's dreamlike wonder.
So, ten years after that, Miyazaki has come out of retirement for a third time,
yes, he didn't even succeed at his third attempt, with a film that was billed as one
of his most mature works. With expectations this high, it's easy to be disappointed,
but here I really was disappointed. This is the director's weakest film by a far distance,
and I left the cinema feeling cold and underwhelmed. It really isn't all bad,
however. The animation is, as expected, properly stunning stuff. It's not just the colour and
visual wonder of the world, but also the motion of it all. The interactions between the film's
characters, the natural world, and objects within it has such a beautiful fluidity to it.
I shouldn't be blown away by the mere sight of someone opening a door, but it was done with
such artistry. Truly, this is the reason to go and see this film, and see it in the cinema.
On a pure aesthetic level, this sits up there with the director's other work,
it's quintessential Miyazaki. Similarly, the film's score by long-time collaborator,
Joe Hisashi, is one of my favourites of the year. Equal parts powerful, delicate and emotional,
it does unfortunately do a lot of the heavy lifting for the film, but nevertheless it
exquisitely complements the visual and adds to the beauty of the film as an audiovisual experience.
All of this combined means that the film really does look and sound like any other Miyazaki movie,
and it even somewhat feels like one too. But unfortunately, The Boy and the Heron lacks the
emotional and thematic depth of all of the director's previous films, and this is why I
was ultimately left so dissatisfied with it. The characters, relationships and story are
all very forgettable in this. Our protagonist, Mojito, whose name I just had to google because
I couldn't remember it even though they shout it in the film constantly, is dull as dishwater.
During the film's outstanding opening scene, you think, oh, he's gonna be this plucky kid,
perhaps even akin to Ivan in Ivan's Childhood. But for the rest of the film, he comes across
as more of a blank slate than anything else. You could make the argument that this is due to grief,
but if this was what was intended, that this change is because of post-traumatic stress,
then it was not properly explored or communicated. Similarly, his relationship with the Heron,
who in my opinion sounds way too much like Ryuk from Death Note to the extent where I thought
it could have been the same voice actor, was just a big nothing. It's not only cliched,
but also poorly done for what's a pretty standard narrative arc, and by the end of their journey
together, the film was telling us what their relationship had become rather than having
shown it naturally over the course of the second and third act. As I mentioned before,
this is primarily a film about grief. Miyazaki is a master storyteller, and usually packs so
much subtlety, commentary, both political and social, and depth into his work. But unfortunately,
this is another area where the boy in the Heron pales in comparison to the rest of the director's
great work. Grief is explored only on a surface level, in a way that many dime-a-dozen family
films have done before. If you want to see a film from a child's perspective that does the
same thing but better, then check out Danny Boyle's Millions. It's been a hot minute since
I've seen it, but I remember it being rather good. Or actually, A Monster Calls, which is an
English-language film from the same director as El Orfanato. That one will really rip your heart
out. Heron's exploration of grief really does pale in comparison to these films. While also,
the many themes that feel thrown in during the film's third act are presented in far too esoteric
a fashion to be impactful, and this is coming from an Evangelion fan. During the movie's climax,
I felt absolutely nothing, and this was quite possibly the collective consequence of these
themes, characters and relationships not working. In addition to that, however, the visual splendour
of the world is also somewhat dampened by the fact that, generally speaking, it is not very
well realised. And again, this is very unlike Miyazaki's usual affair. While much of the world
functions as obvious metaphor, it ultimately feels incredibly random. Every new area we visit feels
disjointed from the previous bit. When the film gets to its magical adventure, which is when I
began to realise that the film was losing me, it starts to feel like a parade of cute and cool
ideas that have been stitched together before its purpose was properly figured out. Compare this to
any other of Miyazaki's fantasy worlds, particularly those of Spirited Away and Princess Mononoke,
and you'll realise just how lacking The Boy and the Heron is. In those, we are learning something
new with every corner we turn, but here we're just confronted with something new that doesn't
tell us anything substantive about the world or anything meaningful about the protagonist and his
struggles. There's no world building here, only world showing, and this is why I'm pretty confident
that this film is going to be largely forgotten about by Ghibli fans. Turning it into one of the
few films directed by this all-time great, that doesn't stand alone in the popular culture.
It pains me to say that this is Miyazaki's worst film, and that it is for this that he came out
of retirement, instead of choosing to end on one of his better works. If you're a Ghibli fan, then
you know what, this isn't terrible by any means, and if you can catch it on a very big screen,
you'll enjoy it on a sensory level. But as it stands though, this was a huge letdown, I can't
imagine ever going back to this one really, and I'm going to give it a five out of ten.
So what did you think of The Boy in the Heron? Do you agree with me, or is this just another
hot take? As always, let me know in the comments below. If you enjoyed this video, please consider
tipping me on Ko-Fi, the link is in the description, and also in the description is the link to my
podcast, The Extreme Cinema Podcast, the most recent episode of which is an epic two-parter
discussing the filmography of David Lynch, my all-time favourite director. Thank you so much
watching this video, please like, share and subscribe, and I will see you all next time.