Public Safety at Risk: RM Raskin Opening Remarks on Preserving the Face Act

House Committee of the Judiciary
69 followers
Apr 28, 2026
TW: @HouseJudiciary | FB: HouseJudDems | IG: HouseJudDems | M: /HouseJudiciary
Mr. Chairman, thank you very much, and I want to thank all our witnesses for joining us today.
We are in a weird time warp groove with our friends across the aisle. Most of their energy
is now focused on pardoning people who attacked the Capitol on January 6th, wounding and injuring
150 of our police officers, disfiguring and disabling some of them for life. Their time
is spent vacating the criminal convictions of the Proud Boys and Oath Keepers who engaged
in seditious conspiracy against the U.S. government, which means conspiring to overthrow
and put down the government. And now the Department of Justice wants to vacate
those convictions that were handed down by unanimous juries. They want to give millions
of dollars to convicted criminals like Michael Flynn, for example, President Trump's disgraced
former national security adviser. They gave him $1.5 million for a lawsuit he brought against
the government and already lost. He lost it in court. And nonetheless, they wrote him a check
for $1.5 million. They wrote a check for another $1.5 million or $1.25 million to Carter Page,
who unsuccessfully sued the government for damages, losing four different lawsuits. And nonetheless,
they just wrote him a check of the taxpayers' money, $1.25 million.
And now they're all lining up at the trough. A lot of the January 6th insurrectionists,
want their $1.25 million payout. And Donald Trump has sued the IRS for 10, no, forgive me,
not 10 million, $10 billion. He wants 80% of the IRS budget that he's suing the government for.
And he's also suing for the search warrants handed down by an independent neutral magistrate
where they executed a search on Mar-a-Lago and found lots of classified documents and
confidential and secret documents he shouldn't have. And he's suing there
for several hundred million dollars as well. So it's a big piggy bank for them.
But so now we are having our third hearing about the claim. I'm not sure I fully understand it,
but I think the claim is that the activists who forcibly blocked health clinic entrances
and prevented women from accessing lawful reproductive health services were somehow
unjustly prosecuted under the FACE Act, which they intimate is unconstitutional,
but eight different federal circuit courts have upheld its constitutionality as a perfectly
lawful exercise of Congress's powers under the Commerce Clause and not in any way in violation
of the First Amendment. Okay, but they continue to want to pander to people who think that they
never should have been prosecuted for their criminal conduct. So this hearing is an after
the fact justification for President Trump's anti-choice pander pardons, which took place
last year as one of his first acts in office. He pardoned nearly two dozen people convicted again
by unanimous juries of FACE Act related crimes, including one of the witnesses here today,
Ms. Edel. As with the January 6 rioters and insurrectionists that he pardoned, Trump and
his mega allies are attempting to rewrite history to portray convicted criminal conduct as peaceful
protest and to cast the dedicated public servants who sought to protect patient safety as the
villains. So let's discuss some of the facts of Ms. Edel's case. She was pardoned by President
Trump and invited, I think, as an example of the so-called peaceful protesters. A jury convicted
her along with six co-conspirators of federal civil rights offenses, including a FACE Act
violation arising out of their blockade of a reproductive health care clinic in Sterling
Heights, Michigan in August of 2020. A jury of her peers, not deep state prosecutors, a jury
of her peers drawn from her community convicted her by unanimous vote after a trial borne by an
impartial federal judge. She was one of two defendants convicted of another FACE Act violation
arising out of their actions and yet another clinic blockade in Saginaw, Michigan. Now I
have no problems with the fact that Ms. Edel and others like her have strong moral convictions
about this, as did Martin Luther King and John Lewis. They had strong moral convictions about
Jim Crow apartheid and segregation in America and they participated in civil disobedience.
They violated various trespass laws in different cases and they were arrested for it and they were
willing to accept their punishment as the price for trying to get a law they considered or actions
by the government reversed and to dismantle racial segregation. But what these protesters
have a problem with is other people accessing their own health care. The civil rights protesters
weren't trying to stop people from getting health care and they were willing to nonetheless accept
the consequences of having a sit-in or whatever, but here they don't seem to want to accept it,
the fact that they violated the law and in fact they violated the law precisely in order to prevent
other people from exercising their constitutionally protected rights to health care. That's exactly
what they were doing. So I'm afraid there's a huge difference between them and other people
who have participated in civil disobedience in the past. We got a statement from the founder
and operator of the Sterling Heights Clinic who was present that day, which I'm going to enter
into the record in full, that described what happened. She writes this, perhaps the most
dangerous and appalling episode of clinic violence I've ever experienced since the FACE Act became law
took place in August of 2020. Our Sterling Heights Clinic was blockaded by extremists
who prevented me and other staff from entering the clinic. Patients were stuck in their cars,
including three women who were coming in for medical abortions following the detection
of fatal fetal anomalies. One woman was actively losing amniotic fluid and was scheduled for the
second day of a two-day procedure. She needed immediate medical attention. She huddled with
her mother and her husband, trapped in the parking lot, while extremists plastered signs
of fake fetuses on her car windows and shouted, God loves you, God loves your baby. And the woman
cried back, I know God loves me, I know God loves my baby, but my baby is dying. Her baby was missing
most of its brain and had no kidneys. This woman later shared her powerful testimony at trial.
As eight different federal circuit courts have found, Congress has the power under the Commerce
Clause to protect people against being harassed and interfered with as they go to get medical
attention. The FACE Act is a legitimate exercise of congressional power, and these people were
properly arrested and prosecuted for perhaps their very morally sincerely held views,
but they violated the law. These politically motivated pardons of FACE Act violators,
as well as January Sixers and dozens of white-collar criminals and fraudsters,
are all part of a political strategy that's got nothing to do with justice. And now this is the
equivalent of the government giving people green light to go out and break the law. And indeed,
there are numerous reports that President Trump has been pardoning promises, has been promising
pardons rather, to everyone who works for him. As President Trump continues to endanger public
safety with pardons like this, they are making threats against the Southern Poverty Law Center,
which is the main not-for-profit organizational antagonist to the Ku Klux Klan and the Neo-Nazi
and the white extremist groups. And they're being investigated and prosecuted for having sent people
undercover to research what's going on in those groups to get the information to government for
prosecution. So now the administration, which has pardoned 1,600 extremists who attacked the U.S.
Capitol, who violently assaulted our police officers and tried to overthrow a presidential
election, which Joe Biden won by more than 7 million votes, 306 to 232 in the Electoral College.
Well, now after having pardoned all of those people, they want to attack the Southern Poverty
Law Center. And that is an amazing attack on the First Amendment for real. I yield back to you, Mr. Chairman.
