Fresh off an awful week of baseball against the Braves and Cubs, Phillies fans are speculating Dave Dombrowski could make some major changes now. Would firing manager Rob Thomson be one of them? On the latest Hittin' Season podcast, John Stolnis, Justin Klugh and Liz Roscher debate that, the team's abysmal play in Chicago and Atlanta, and the task ahead for them. Also, did the Red Sox' firing of Alex Cora speed up the Thomson timeline?
Chapters:
00:00 - Phillies' Struggles and Current State 05:05 - Is Rob Thomson Getting Fired This week? 15:02 - Evaluating the Roster and Future Moves 19:45 - Dave Dombrowski's Role 26:29 - The Impact of Player Changes on Team Dynamics 31:49 - The Role of Chemistry in Team Success 36:36 - Assessing Player Performance and Future Potential 40:01 - Long-Term Phillies Contracts and Their Implications 44:42 - Looking Ahead: The Road to Recovery 49:19 - Final Thoughts on Team Direction and Management
Buy Justin's NEW book, "Summer of the Cheap Weiners: What the 1941 Phillies Were Up To While Joe DiMaggio Was Making History" at Brookline Books! https://www.brooklinebooks.com/978195...
From WHYY, it is hitting season.
Hey there, podcast pals.
I'm John Stolnes from the good fight.
You can follow me on X and blue sky at John Stolnes coming up.
We are recording on the Monday off day between the Atlanta brave series
where the Phillies just lost two out of three in Atlanta, coming off a
whole road trip through Wrigley field.
And Turner field is at Turner field.
I don't even remember what it's called anymore.
Uh, but Truist in Atlanta, Truist, Truist park, Truist park.
Thank you.
Yes.
Uh, Phillies returning home for a three game series against the
San Francisco giants, uh, on Tuesday night.
So we are here for the round table edition of the podcast, and we are all
on Rob Thompson, hug watch, uh, here at the, uh, hit and season headquarters.
I mean, maybe not even hot Rob Thompson, but there's, it just, we're, we're
kind of all sitting here recording, anticipating maybe something happening
today to shake the Phillies out of the doldrums they are in.
We're going to talk about all of that.
We'll talk about the series in Atlanta.
Uh, and we'll talk about some other interesting things that are going on
around the league, specifically with the Boston Red Sox and the New York Mets.
And, you know, Hey, a couple of good things happened during the
course of the weekend as well.
We will mention those too, but, uh, joining me on the round
table, Liz Rosher and Justin clue.
Uh, Liz of course is the editor of Sabres baseball research journal.
You can follow her on X and blue sky at Liz Rosher.
Liz, how are you?
Doing well.
Thanks.
Uh, I decided not to subject myself to too much Phillies this weekend,
though I did watch, I guess you could call them highlights.
Some of them were highlights.
Most of them were not highlights, but yeah, I'm, uh, trying to get ready
for a new week of Phillies games.
So let's, let's see what could happen.
Could things be good?
Who knows?
Well, I mean, if anybody who tuned in, who stayed tuned in to the game on Sunday
after the second inning, my hat's off to you, I would also encourage hobbies for
you, um, something, something else, uh, just to kind of, uh, just, just to kind
of make, make your time worth it because, uh, yeah, that series ended in a very
ugly way, Justin clue from baseball prospectus, the dirty inning, absolutely
hammered a couple of podcasts that he hosts over on our hidden season, Patrion.
Uh, and of course, author of the new book, you can see it sitting behind me.
Summer of the cheap wieners with the Phillies were doing during the 1941
season when Joe DiMaggio was engaged in his fixed 56 game hitting streak.
Follow him on blue sky at Justin clue.
Justin.
How are you feeling about doing a little reading about the 1999 Phillies?
Uh, the last team that they, uh, they had a milestone amount of losses for, um, and
I was looking at the last game of the losing streak, the Phillies had that
September, they have like one of those sneaky little collapses of a Philly season
that we like started promising.
And then by this point was absolutely over, but it was great because they
were going to play the Astros and they had hit three Astros batters with pitches
the day before, and then Paul Byrd who pitches inside was starting against the
Astros the following night and he hit two Astros batters in the first inning in a
row and the way the umpires had issued warnings was set up that like if the
Astros retaliated in any way, their pitcher and manager would be ejected
immediately.
So they just had to sit there and take it while Paul Byrd kept hitting Astros
batters and then, you know, got revenge when the Phillies were crushed, uh, 12
to two and their losing streak continued to a historic amount.
So, uh, yeah, I just thought I'd share that little tidbit.
These things look the same, no matter what time period they're happening in.
It was 1999 Phillies.
That was a, that was a trip around the sun.
Let me tell you folks, uh, that 1999 season, if you weren't around for that,
those were some days right there.
Cause I mean, you, you, you factored in it's bad enough watching this baseball
team play right now in a beautiful ballpark with, with elegant surroundings
and other things to do, you know, you could go get a sick, go get
crab fries and chickies and pizza.
You can go play whiffle ball.
You can just walk around and have a craft beer someplace.
I mean, there's at the vet in 1999, it was dark.
It was dank and folks, there was nothing to do.
If you saw a guy with a whiffle ball bat, you ran in the other direction.
There was nothing else to take your attention away from the field in 1999.
So as a whole other level of misery friends.
So, uh, for those of you who didn't experience that you're, you're lucky.
Um, but, um, but we, we are watching some really bad baseball by what we all
thought was a very good team right now.
And they may still be a quote unquote good team somehow, somewhere, but it is
not showing itself on the field or in the standings or in the box score.
They broke a 10 game losing streak, which is really what matters.
If you break, they broke a 10 game losing streak on Saturday and extra
innings, and then lost on Sunday, six to two in a game that was
nowhere near that close.
They have lost 15 of their last 18 games heading into Tuesday's
series against the giants.
They are nine and 19 on the season.
They are 10 and a half games out of first place.
They're negative 54.
Runder differential is still the worst in baseball.
They're even seven and a half games out of a wildcard spot.
Now they don't have the worst record in baseball anymore because that
belongs to the New York Mets, who I believe are now nine and 20, or maybe
they're tied with the Phillies at nine and 19.
I can't remember anymore.
The point is it has been a truly monstrous start to the season, and
this was the road trip from hell for these teams.
So Justin and Liz, as we sit here on a Monday, we're all kind of feeling
it feels like changes in the air to me.
Anyway, it feels like a change is coming.
Justin, do you feel the same?
Do you, do you feel a change in the air?
Does it smell like change?
And if so, like, what do you think is going to happen here as we record
on about three 30 in the afternoon, Eastern time on Monday afternoon,
over the next like 24 hours or so?
Well, even understanding that at any second, I could be proven totally wrong
of these three teams that everybody's talking about here as underwhelmers
to start the season, Red Sox, Mets, and Phillies, uh, the Phillies, I
would, I would imagine would be the last team to, to make whatever
move they're going to make.
They are a little more rigid and slow moving when it comes to this kind of
stuff, they're very purposeful in their decision-making, uh, remember
when they were going to fire Gabe Kepler and John Middleton flew around
the country and talking to various organizations about what a completely
fake thing and Dave Dabrowski is, uh, is an institution to, to in baseball.
So it's a, it's a little different.
I feel like to be moving on from a potentially like an era defined by
him, or if you want to put it on Rob Thompson, I think that's a little
more realistic, but that's a big move that I don't think the Phillies
see as the center of the issue.
So I think it's one they'd be slower to make if not, uh, less likely to make.
I just feel like the, the Alex Cora firing has sort of stored, stirred
people up a bit, even though you can, you can clearly trace Dabrowski's
history with Alex Cora, but even if you want Rob Thompson gone, the list
of replacement candidates can be longer than the list of other people who just
got fired for the same reason you want to fire Rob Thompson.
So I'm not sure what the giant appeal is there just because
another guy is now available.
Do you realize why he's available?
Like that, I don't know.
That doesn't seem to super add up to me, but like, yeah, we got to fire this
guy for chronic lateness and his replacement, this man who I hear is
never on time, perfect.
Well, Liz, I know one of the things about the Alex Cora thing is they
saddled him with a terrible roster.
They kept stripping players away from the roster and all that kind of stuff.
But I mean, I don't, I don't know.
I mean, maybe that some of that is true, but I mean, the, the kind of start they
got off to, you know, it's, it was surprising certainly this early in the
season and Dave Dabrowski, it's always been said he's, he has said he needs to
wait 40 games before he really wants to make a decision and historically
that's what he's done.
He's let managers go mid season, but usually not until late May, early June.
Once about 40 games are under their belt and the Phillies aren't, they aren't
there yet, right?
At nine and nine and 19, they got what, 28 games under their belt at the moment.
So it's, it's see, it still seems early.
And yet.
Here we are.
It really does feel like maybe not, maybe not Rob Thompson, but it certainly
feels like something is going to happen.
Maybe I don't necessarily feel like something's going to happen.
What I feel is that, uh, Craig Breslow, I think he's the GM or the president
of baseball operations.
I can't remember off the top of my head, uh, for the Red Sox, press
the panic button way early.
Because the panic button, he smashed it and it's all broken now.
And that's the thing when you fire everyone at once, that's now, that's the
only move you can make and now you've made it instead of, I don't know,
cutting a hitting coach or a pitching coach first, did you see the picture
of all of the coaches after they'd been fired, standing arm in arm, smiling
some with thumbs up in front of the van that had driven up to take them all away.
It's interesting.
They sent a van to take all like these six, seven adults away.
Like this was, well, send your cars to you.
Uh, you're you, we're not allowing you to drive your car.
These are, these are team cars, you know, so we're going to, maybe
they were all driving away.
That's the thing.
Not only did he do it on a Saturday night, he did it while they were away.
Yeah.
And on like, you couldn't wait till Sunday after it was all over.
And the players couldn't do that in Boston.
The players are ticked off.
It's a dumb thing to do.
I mean, and Breslau was trying to save his job.
I mean, he is only doing as well as the Red Sox is John Henry.
The owner is allowing him to do to be fair, but you know, he knows that he's
the next, he's the next guy in line to go.
He's got to be, I mean, it doesn't matter whether he can pull the boat up or not.
I don't think he's going to be able to, and he's definitely going to be fired.
So do you think that same factor is coming into play here in that
Dombrowski knows he can fire Rob Thompson all he wants, but doesn't
that just put the next crosshair on him?
Like it was all, he's isn't all he's doing like buying time.
If the team doesn't turn around, cause the team, you know, on the field
isn't going to change no matter how many coaches or managers you let go.
It's not until the trade deadline for sure.
And I think that's certainly a possibility, but that's why I think the
dynamic this, this week in Chicago and Atlanta was really interesting.
Um, Matt Gelb reported in the athletic that, um, Dave Dombrowski summoned
three of his top scouts to not scout the opposition, which is what they
are normally doing, but to scout his own team in Chicago and Atlanta.
Um, they said that they're not snooping.
Thompson insisted every, no one was snooping.
Everyone understood it was Dombrowski showing like an
outward sign of power.
While the Phillies flounder, the question is like, are they trying to
send a message to the coaching staff?
Is it a message to the players and, and, and all of that?
But it was a very unusual move.
What Dave Dombrowski did this week, bringing in his three top scouts
to evaluate his own team, which, I mean, I don't know if anybody has a
television set, uh, and can, can watch these guys on TV and see the way they
play, but like this, this can't be good, right?
I mean, this can't be good for Rob Thompson.
It can't be good for the coaching staff.
You know, sometimes when a manager gets fired, they take the bullet for the
hitting coach or the pitching coach.
Like the, they'll, they'll say like, Hey, we want to fire the
hitting coach or the pitching coach.
A manager will say, no, no, we'll just put it on me then.
It'd be because they do try to shield, you know, their, their, their
hitting their, their positional coaches or whatever it might be.
And Rob Thompson said about his job security, he said, well, I
mean, that's natural, right?
Talking about the questions about his job security.
He says it's normal.
And I've never worried about that in my entire career.
I worked for a guy for 28 years talking about George Steinbrenner who, as the
Seinfeld episode will tell you, fires people like it's a bodily function.
And it never bothered me.
It didn't, I don't have time to think about it.
I'm a person that thinks about other people and what I can do to help them.
And it's out of my control.
So that's where I'm at.
So it just kind of goes into, that makes me curious about like,
oh, if they let hit Kevin Longo.
How does Rob Thompson handle that?
If they say we want to let Rob, uh, Kevin Longo, Caleb
Cotham's not going anywhere.
I mean, he's going to stay as a pitching coach.
He could even be the new manager.
Honestly, if they chose to go in, in that direction, which I would probably
like more than Dusty Wathen or, you know, um, yeah, or, or Mattingly
or, or, you know, whoever else.
Yeah.
I mean, it's the other guys that we know about.
Yeah.
So, so I don't, I mean, it is early in the season to, to, to fire the manager.
It's not too early in the season to fire a hitting coach.
Um,
and I, I want to, can I just quick comment on the, on the scouting thing?
Cause I didn't want to, I didn't want to, cause I don't necessarily
think it's good or bad for anyone.
Like what he's doing is trying to figure out what is wrong with the team.
And so he's taking his three best scouts and saying, look at this team
and tell me what's wrong with it.
He's like, what?
Did our, do we know that they are his three best scouts?
Does he, did he truly like put his three best guys?
So in the article, Gelb said that he summoned three of his scouts, but I
mean, I heard also say like his three most, his three preeminent scouts,
like his three best guys.
Um, that's even funnier.
That's even funnier.
I know that's just such a funny little detail.
Sorry, Liz, go ahead.
It is completely, but it obviously it's a detail there to try and convince us all.
Oh, look, John, we're twins.
Hey, we're both making the same thing.
Yeah.
Look at that.
Waterloo friends.
There we go.
Waterloo.
St.
Brandon, everything.
Holy cow.
The one with the flavored sound.
Guys, we're all drinking.
This is not an ad.
We're all drinking water.
We have sparkling water.
Waterloo sparkling water is the best sparkling water.
It truly is.
It's way better than any other sparkling water.
When I need to wash the taste of the Phillies out of my mouth,
there's only one seltzer I crack open.
Nectarine Waterloo for you.
That's right.
Waterloo, if you're listening, we are open.
Anyway, I don't think it's good or bad.
Like, I, I, I don't see how this could be.
Honestly, I don't think how it could be bad.
Like Rob Thompson's on a scout.
None of the guys on the team are scouts.
Like he's asking scouts, go evaluate my team.
What did they do?
Well, what did they do badly?
Maybe it's just a thing for show, but like it's something like, I mean,
it at least shows they're doing something.
I agree.
I agree with that point.
Certainly that it, that it's like, yeah.
Okay.
This is a response.
We're all wondering what the response is going to be in this, this, you know, now
that we've hit the Felix Reyes button and darn it, that didn't work, we're going to
try to bring some scouts in and, and, and scout ourselves like we're an opponent.
The question that I just circled back to is like, what are, so what are three guys
who haven't been watching the Phillies going to tell you that you don't
know already about this team?
That's like, I get fresh eyes and all that, but you said they're not going to be,
are they going to be listening into coaches conversations with players and like weighing
the communication factors as well?
I feel like probably not.
Uh, and you know, they said that, cause they said they're not going to be snooping,
which to me sounds like they're, oh, they're not going to be like rifling
through players, pants, pockets, and like going through their lockers and stuff.
And you're like, oh, okay, well, uh, so I, I mean, I get, I, I, I, I get you Liz.
And I agree that it sounds good that, okay, we're, we got to do something,
but I, I'm kind of curious.
What, what are we going to learn here?
What are we going to learn?
What's going to be actionable that comes out of this, because that's
really all that anybody's looking for.
And what, what does snooping even mean?
I'm trying to figure that out.
Like, why do you, why do you need to say that?
You know, like, what is he, what are they doing?
It's like they're at their lockers and the scouts are like across the room.
Well, that's what I'm saying.
I don't think they're trying to identify what's in there.
I think what they're trying to specify is like the scouts are in the stands.
They're not in the clubhouse.
They're not watching how the players interact.
They're not watching how the, how the players go about their business and the
conversations they're having and trying to judge attitude or trying to judge
enthusiasm or anything like that.
They're strictly the way that read to me was they're doing the job of a scout,
which is to sit in the stands and watch the team on the field and
watch the decisions that are made.
So their job is to figure out perhaps who is tradable.
Essentially, let's improve the team.
It's let's trade Brandon Marsh.
Essentially is what we're going to learn from this.
Trade our only good player right now.
Well, I mean, you're going to treat, here's the deal.
Like if this team doesn't recover, they're going to be trading guys at the
trade deadline.
Yeah.
The, the, the point is this all should have been done this past off season.
This should not have waited until now.
We talked about it right after.
We didn't say after the playoffs lost to the, to the Dodgers, they, they need to
move on for Rob Thompson, but we, we, I know the three of us had a serious
conversation, like is now the time and not cause Rob's a bad manager, but just
because, and everybody says, you know, Rob's Rob's a good manager.
Rob's a good manager.
Oh, if you fire Rob Thompson, that's not going to fix anything.
Well then why do you have a manager?
Like you, you do need to, they do have some responsibility.
If you're going to give him credit for winning games, then he's got to take some
of the blame for, for losing games.
But it is on the, it is the player's responsibility to make sure that they're
playing up to the way it's up to their potential, the way they're supposed to
play.
But frankly, this is Dave Dombrowski team.
And Dave, if, if Rob Thompson gets fired, Dave Dombrowski should be fired as well.
Now that's not going to happen.
I think Dave Dombrowski is in John Middleton's inner circle of trust.
And I think he is in, I think he is a Philadelphia Phillies team president as
long as he wants to be.
But yeah, I just, this is, this is stuff.
Dave Dombrowski should have done last off season.
We all saw the holes in the roster.
There was no creativity this off season about trying to fix them.
I think that they have overvalued some of their players, specifically guys like
Alec Baum, and they've just, and they kept coming back and saying, we're going to
make these little marginal moves and little marginal things.
And yeah, the psychology of failing over and over and over and over again is never
going to affect us at all whatsoever.
It's going to be fine.
And, and now this, we are talking about things and it certainly seems to me like
on the verge of doing some things that probably should have been done last off
season.
Yeah.
They're playing catch up because they set out with this.
I don't know.
I was going to say they set out with this plan, but I don't think you can see that.
I think actually all winter you kind of just saw this, this team that didn't have
like a set plan.
And then the Bichette thing seemed like it came together really fast and messily.
And that was part of the contributing factors to it, not ultimately happening.
And, uh, their goal being to like bring these guys back, then having to put real
Muto on pause while they work out the Bichette thing.
I don't know.
There just seemed like there was some plans and ideas that perhaps they were a
little caught off guard, didn't work out.
And then they had to start the season with a perhaps different type of roster
than they were planning to have.
And then they had to sell that.
They had to sell that even though visibly they didn't actually try to, to, to have
such a, Oh, we're doing like a youth thing this, this summer at camp.
It's really important.
We're trying to get the young guys more, more involved.
And that's like the center of our, of our motivation here.
And Harper's got to get back on track and everybody, you know, it's going to, that,
that, that's going to be why the, how the offense works.
And then those things just don't work.
And because sometimes in baseball things just don't work, but partially, I think
we're seeing here both reasons inside and outside the Phillies are not hitting.
The Phillies are not scoring.
The Phillies aren't doing a whole lot.
Well, so I think ultimately what you're just seeing here is a plan B or potentially
C that by definition is less likely to hold up under scrutiny and then didn't.
And here we are in April and now they've just got to scramble for a plan D or plan
E and it's just way too late.
It's way too late.
So you've got some combination of not wanting to spend or being overly
confident or, or, or getting out Fox at times just led to this position that the
Phillies perhaps have been like playing from a plant from an uncomfortable
position since the season started.
I don't.
Uncomfortable position is a good way to put it, but it doesn't seem like Dave
Dombrowski wasn't, he was sort of acting uncomfortable.
Mostly I want to say that I just don't want us to let John Middleton off the
hook because Dave Dombrowski built, built a team and we don't know if he did the
best he could even with the resources he was given, but we just have to keep in
mind the resources he was given, I don't know, or what, or what he was promised
when he took the job a number of years ago, you know, well, he was,
this podcast has never and will never let John Middleton off.
Oh no, of course.
John Milton stays on the hook.
That's his job is to be on the hook.
Yeah.
So I didn't mean to imply that we wouldn't, I just wanted to make sure I
mentioned it in this conversation because it's not like I'm trying to let
Dombrowski off the hook, but I just want that to be a factor in everything
because Dave Dombrowski is good at his job, you know, given the resources.
I think he is good at his job for the most part.
I just don't think he's been good right now.
I just don't think he's been good with the resources he's been given.
And unfortunately that's his job.
Here's, here's my Dave Dombrowski take and I, Dave Dombrowski
has gone to the hall of fame.
I think he did a great job putting the 2022 Phillies together
on that team that went on a run.
I think I feel like most of mostly since coming to the Phillies, he, he has had
more moves, not workout than have worked out and he has not reshaped the farm
system in a real, a real, made it into a real strength the way that he had said
that he wanted to do and was going to do now six years later, um, they're still
not producing high-end talent, especially on the position player side.
Um, I mean, you've got, this is a $300 million roster.
Felix Reyes is hitting cleanup for you against left-handed pitching.
You, that lineup, that lineup was crazy.
That line was so sad.
You're starting a while in, in the, in the rubber game against a team in first
place, after you just broke a 10 game losing streak was to have Felix Reyes
and left field playing like his what?
Fifth game, fourth game, fifth game, hitting him cleanup, hitting him number
four on a $300 million roster.
And then Dylan Moore is getting a start in center field because you don't want
to expose Justin Crawford.
You look, he's been struggling of late.
Okay.
You don't want him to play against Chris sale.
So this is not the outfield of a $300 million roster.
And especially the day after you just get a, you finally get a feel good win
against the Atlanta Braves and you go out there and you just put in a totally
uncompetitive roster on the lineup on the field.
That's on Dombrowski for forcing Rob Thompson to having no other option than
to try Felix Reyes in the cleanup spot.
But it's also on Rob Thompson for not recognizing like, Hey, maybe this isn't
the day for Dylan Moore to get a start in center field.
Maybe this is the day to try to win this particular series and
put our best guys out there.
Even if I told him a few days ago, they were going to, they're
going to have the day off.
Like there's just, I don't know that Dave Dombrowski is quote
unquote good at his job anymore.
I think it feels to me like time has passed him by with a lot of these moves.
He'd had to cut.
He had to release Taiwan Walker and eat a bunch of money this week.
He had to release Nick Castellanos this off season because, and
just eat a bunch of money.
He's had to do the same thing with guys like Whit Merrifield.
Um, he probably should have done it with Max Kepler last year.
We'll see how Adolis Garcia works out, but there have been, I feel like,
and I, you can make, I mean, we all, we all thought Trey Turner was a good
signing and, and you know, I don't know what it's all going to look
like at the end of the day, but I'm not feeling great about that.
The Aaron Nola contract looks like an absolute and utter total
and complete disaster.
And where are the trades?
Like where, yes, he went, he got to run.
That's great.
I feel like there's an, any number of GMs who could have targeted
Duran as a top closer and, and found a deal with prospects in the organization.
Like, I don't think Dave Dombrowski pulled off a special, Oh, Dombrowski
does it again, type trade last year for Joe on Duran.
I guess we're ripping themselves apart.
Like that was the, they were throwing players out the window.
He was just open.
He just rolled down his window as he drove by and was like, yeah, hop in.
So, I mean, I think he's going to be the president of baseball
operations for as long as he wants to be, but I'm, I'm no longer in the
camp that Dombrowski really is on top of things and that he's, I
don't know that he's good anymore.
This is the concern.
This was the concern that we kind of, we mentioned, but then didn't
give a lot of weight to after the Bichette thing collapsed, because
he wound up going for a deal with opt outs, which is the trendy thing
to offer players and more valuable.
Instead offering him more years, which is a, you know, we're entering
the part of some of these longer term contracts with these guys that
people are starting to complain about how long they are when nobody
was complaining about how long they were when they signed them, because
that's what got them to come here.
Uh, but like that's, that's becoming an issue now.
And it started to feel like, okay, did he just, did, did Dombrowski
get outmaneuvered by the Mets?
Or did they, did he just not like kind of factor in that the kinds of
deals that attract players have perhaps changed and amount of years
is not what he was prioritizing at that time.
I think it's that.
I think it's, I think it might be that.
I think he got, I think Bichette got offered a deal that he wasn't
expecting from the Mets and it was so much more attractive to him because
it required him to, he didn't have to commit, he could choose where he
wanted to be, and I think more and more players want the power to be able
to choose where they go all the time.
And for the record, after their first six years, they want to be
able to go where they want to go.
We can all see what Boba Shett season has been like.
So, you know, to sit here and say like imply he's some sort of difference
maker, yeah, obviously, but first of all, but I will also add that, you
know, coming to Philadelphia, that would have been exactly the kind of
change people were talking about.
Something they hadn't thought of, but was big enough to change the
lineup and the landscape of the team and the overall, like look of the,
of the roster in a significant way.
And who knows, maybe that is the thing that's different that we've
been saying the Phillies are missing.
I'm not super confident it would have been, but who knows?
Maybe, maybe you'd see a more positive result, who knows, but that's the
kind of thing we were talking about.
And for reasons that may have to do with, yeah, like you're the point
you're making, John Philly's missed out.
They did.
And, and they, and just listen, Dave Dabrowski's made some bad decisions,
you know, as, as the, as the guy making all the baseball calls don't, I
mean, and, and look every, I'm not expecting perfection, you know, like
every, every baseball decision maker is going to make a bad call here and
and they're going to move a lot of bad calls sometimes, you know, sometimes
they're going to go into a slump themselves, you know, but they're, the
Phillies are paying for it right now with, with, and they have not, they're
younger, the guys that they, that came up in 20, 21, 22, 23, like Bowman
Scott, they have not improved.
They haven't gotten any better.
That's, that's been a huge problem with this team.
They know they're hoping Justin Crawford is going to provide
something for them this year.
He got off to a good start again, has stalled a little bit, still
very early for the kid.
And so you want to have patience with your number nine hitter.
He's, he's not the problem, but also, you know, just kind of, and I keep
going back to the sell job of Dombrowski this off season of, of Otto Kemp and,
and Justin Crawford, it's like, we're making all these changes.
You guys don't understand.
All right, man.
You know, like JT rail Muto, the reason folks were nervous about a three
year, $45 million contract is because he might hurt his back.
Trying to make a play at home at home plate and miss three weeks.
You know, when you're that, when, when you start to get up in English,
you start to miss more time.
And now we're, now you're looking at Marshawn and Stubbs, right.
For a couple of weeks.
And that affects the pitching staff that affects the starters.
And we haven't even talked about the starters yet.
So there's just, it's just, it's just, it's.
I think the thing is it's baffling to see a team that's this
talented struggle this much.
And I know Mets fans are saying the same thing.
Like, it's just how can a team with this much quote unquote talent.
Look this terrible.
Like, and it's, it's not just that they're, you know, that they're.
Bad players playing badly.
Like they're making all kinds of defensive mistakes.
Like they're making mental errors that Rob Thompson is making mental errors
and Andrew painter in the game on Friday.
I want to get your take on this.
Andrew painter in the game on Friday is in the six is has two
outs in the sixth inning.
I think the bases were loaded.
It's not if they had, they had two men, two runners in scoring position, but
either way, they did not have a left-handed reliever.
They had four available and didn't have one of them up and ready for the
possibility that Michael Harris would be called on to pinch hit.
So when they call Michael Harris up to pinch hit, they have to
leave Andrew painter in the game.
Painter falls behind two and oh, and then grooves a fastball down the
middle that Harris hits for a multi RBI double that gives Atlanta the lead.
Like that's the player.
You'd love to see him execute there, but he's a rookie kid.
And there's your, your manager's kind of supposed to have that in his mind.
Like that.
Hey, you got Michael Harris on the bench.
We should have a lefty up just in case we got four of them.
I think we can spare one here and they it's just all that's the kind of stuff
that we have been seeing all season long from give you one more trait Turner.
I get, I think it was in the game on Friday where they, he had an easy ground
ball with runners on first and second and two outs.
I think it was in the eighth inning.
Easy ground ball comes to him.
Acuna gets a good jump off.
First base starts late covering second and Turner assumes he can flip the ball
to start for the easy force out at second base.
But can't get it.
But but starts late getting there.
He gives up.
Turner, all of a sudden,
I was rushing his throw to first base and throws it high and wide.
Everybody's safe.
It didn't result in a run being scored that inning.
But like that's that's the kind of crap that we've seen from this team here
so far, and I can't explain it other than it's mental.
I was just going to say, I think one thing we have to consider
is that talent is not enough.
One thing that 22 Phillies had that this team doesn't is clear chemistry.
And one thing that the last great Mets team had
that these last few Mets teams haven't had is good chemistry.
And I think that is something we can't ignore.
I know it's intangible.
I know it's ineffable.
I know it's something it's hard to describe, almost impossible to create.
And it just has to happen naturally.
Whatever is going on, it's not happening.
And that has to be considered in some way.
If not by changing players,
then by trying to figure out how to change the clubhouse,
you know, whatever the clubhouse culture is, it's not working.
That's the only thing.
What else is there?
They're all talented.
They all know how to do what they do.
Like, I don't think we're debating that.
We're not.
How are these talented teams not doing as well as they could?
Environment has like a fair amount to do with this.
And doesn't the manager kind of set the tone for that environment?
He does.
That's very true.
I'm not trying to defend Rob Thompson in any way.
There was a time and it probably, you know, I think it was 2022
what you're talking about.
And you saw a different Phillies team out there when perhaps the hands
off, relaxed player first approach that Rob Thompson comes is the perfect
exactly what the team needed.
And, you know, again, we've kind of talked about this being the issue,
but the idea that that overall philosophy held
while the team continued to change and the players kind of evolved and had
went through their struggles or bounced back or whatever, but like the clubhouse
atmosphere kind of really hasn't changed.
And I don't know if the players would admit, I don't think they would.
Schwarber, I believe is on record saying like, we don't necessarily think a
change is, you know, we don't think that's necessary at the moment, but.
That kind of culture can lead to a lack of accountability.
And I mean, these guys have become pretty detached out there.
It seems like they just from each other, from, from proper execution, like it's,
it's just the kind of mistakes you're talking about are not the kind of mistakes
you want to see a team that's supposed to be this good making, but also not the
kind of mistakes you want to see a 33 year old veteran, all-star shortstop
making who is people's like MVP candidates, not too long ago.
And then when the manager's falling asleep and like making the same kind
of brain farts as the players, that's when you start to get concerned.
Okay.
Perhaps this culture is now like it's, it's permeated too much.
It's gone too far in one direction.
It does not mean you bring some drill sergeant in there
to over-correct or anything.
It just means right now, this might not be the, uh, the right headspace for this
team, and I think it's pretty obvious that that headspace is the problem.
You know, losing streaks, we think of as like lines that just go through a season,
but they're really like circles and they start small and the more you lose, the
bigger they get, and then eventually there's coaches inside that circle.
Does it stay on ball now?
Now it's big enough that you could fire them.
Then it gets a little bigger in the managers inside that circle.
And you're like, okay, now we got to fire them.
I think the Phillies are at a point where the circle's big enough that you could
get rid of just about anybody and make a solid argument for doing so.
But I think you're right, John, obviously Middleton's not going anywhere.
And obviously I don't think Dombrowski's going anywhere.
So I think Thompson's the biggest message you could send you, but you
could make an argument, you know, that it's also not his fault.
All right.
So let me, let's get ourselves on the record as we're recording this.
Well, after four o'clock here on Monday afternoon, when the Phillies take the
field against the Giants on Tuesday, is Rob Thompson still the manager?
I say that he is now that I've been, I thought it was going to happen today.
I really did.
I don't, I, I, as, as we sit here as when I started the day, I felt for sure
they're going to make a change today.
They're going to make a change today, but I don't, it's not happening today.
So it makes me think maybe Dombrowski really does mean what he says about 40
games and that's what I was going to say.
I think he's, I think he's sticking to that.
Uh, was he at 28, 28 games on the season?
So yeah, I think you still got, that sounds like an amount of time.
That sounds like an infuriating enough amount of time for people who are already
upset to have to sit through and see a final decision of some kind.
Of course, if the Phillies win like 10 of their next 12, we're not
going to be talking about it at all.
So, you know, I've just, uh, I'm just saying my, my official response is, yeah,
I think he's going to stick to that 40 cause we're sitting here talking about
how perhaps Dombrowski is too entrenched in his ways and this is one of his ways.
Yeah, I agree.
All right.
Um, a couple other things from the Atlanta series we can get into.
Um, Aaron Nola, I don't know how deep the conversation we want
to have about Aaron Nola.
Um, but everybody kind of chuckles and rolls their eyes when I talk about Aaron
Nola, but now we're all on the same side again, weird side.
I get him wrong this off.
See, I saw him in spring and I really don't know how.
No, I know.
I'm sorry.
What did you say, Liz?
What did you just say?
I said, didn't we all, but I realized we all interesting question.
Yeah, I have no memory of what I said about Aaron Nola.
If I'm being honest, I know I predicted an all-star game appearance for Aaron
Nola this year, cause I really love what I was getting from him.
I well, I saw the elevated velocity in spring.
He looked great, man.
I mean, it's in Philly.
He might be there in like street clothes, right?
He might just be, he'll be so far away from Philadelphia.
He's not in the game that 10 pitches into the game on Sunday.
They're down three.
Nothing.
I think the first four or five hit balls, a hundred miles an
hour or faster off of him.
I mean, just destroying the baseballs off of him.
He has a 6.03 ERA, but here's the number since the start of 2025.
He has a 6.15 ERA that ranks 130th out of 133 starting pitchers with
at least 100 innings pitched.
In that span.
How could we have seen this coming?
And shut up.
And at grace at grace, Del Pizzo tweeted from 2026 to 2030, the
Phillies will pay Aaron Nola another 180, 100, 122.8 million dollars.
That's what's left on the Aaron Nola contract.
I thought, I thought we'd see better.
I'm sorry.
You're right, Justin.
Take, take your victory lap.
Do it.
I could, I could, I could ask you why, but I feel like
the velocity was up.
That's what I thought.
The velocity.
Yeah.
The, uh, Hey, what Vila wasn't really the problem.
Uh, I feel like his fastball and curve command were terrible.
Just inexcusably bad.
Um, I will say Matt Olsen went up and got that one, the home run that was like up
and in, and he still turned all that and crushed it.
So you gotta give Olsen a little credit there.
Uh, but the one I really, I think is particularly damning is Gillette and
Lee, a Braves number eight hitter.
Eli white crush on middle and sinker into the Phillies bullpen.
I'm sorry.
If you're giving up no doubters to Eli white, there's something
wrong on a, on a, on a metaphysical level.
There's something wrong on a molecular level.
Uh, if you're giving up home runs, it's so clear to, to, to him.
So, yeah.
Um, no, I don't know.
Kind of in the, in this space with the Phillies in general, you know, Bryce
Harper had that quote after the last loss, like, yeah, it keeps saying the
same thing, hate that this is going on, blah, blah, blah, blah.
That's been the case with Aaron Nola.
Every time it's like, wow, what happened in this start?
That was very strange for Aaron Nola.
I was like, well, there was an Aaron Nola start.
So, you know, that all that stuff happened, that happens in an Aaron Nola start.
Uh, he had, you know, he was like, he struck out the first three hitters he
saw and then gave up a grand slam after walking the bases loaded and
then hit three batters in a row.
Like that's, that's the Aaron Nola adventure.
We're going to be on, here's a question I actually thought of
while you, while you were talking.
And this is not, this is not supposed to haunt you, even though
it is a little bit haunting.
But of the guys that the Phillies have locked up long-term here, you know,
you're Harper and Turner and Nola and Wheeler and Lizardo, and I guess
we would say Schwarber now long-term.
Wow.
How many of them do you think we've already seen the best of?
Cause I think you could probably say Sanchez and Lizardo we thinking maybe
there's still higher than the peaks we've seen of them because those might
be your only two real candidates.
I, I would say, and Liz, I'm sorry to, I'll jump, I'll just say quickly
and I'll let you offer your thoughts on this.
I would say we, I don't know that we've seen the best from Lizardo yet.
I think there's still more from more, more to see from Lizardo, especially
since he's gotten off to a slow start this year, Chris Sanchez.
It's going to be hard to top last season.
Um, but I think he can repeat that.
He hasn't looked as good this year, but I think he can repeat that.
Um, we've, I think we've clearly seen the best.
We saw the best of Trey Turner before he came to Philadelphia.
He has yet to match the level that we saw in LA despite finishing
fifth in the MVP voting last year.
I don't think he was the fifth best player in the national league a season ago.
And so we, we, we're, we're never going to get that Trey Turner that we saw
in Washington and Los Angeles.
Um, Kyle Schwarber again, last year was probably the high watermark, but I do
think we're going to see 40 to 50 home runs from him again this year, next year.
So I'll say, I think you can, you're still going to get kind of peak
Kyle Schwarber for another year or two.
Um, and then Nola for sure.
Um, I mean, just, you know, Harper is the, is when we can talk about Harper a
little bit here too, because Harper is the really the, the only player who's
off to a really hot start this year.
He's really the only player who has consistently been good real ever since
the first week on a game in game out basis.
Um, and so for, for all the heat that he took on for me on this podcast and
from, uh, from others elsewhere, he it's unfortunate that he's been the one
guy, it's like 2021 all over again.
He'd been like the one guy who has hit really well, he's got six home runs
hitting two 6345 on base 500 slugging eight 45 OPS.
Um, those numbers are kind of right where he finished up the year last year,
but I feel like he's actually been a little bit more impactful here
than he was a season ago.
So I would say Harper, I don't, we're not going to see the best of Bryce
Harper, but probably good Bryce Harper.
I feel better about that now than I did three weeks ago.
Yeah.
And that's fair.
Um, but I, I think the, the thought enters your head watching an every
Aaron Nola started knowing how much time remains with him.
I think about the calls to resign him back when that was the topic of the day.
And we went three for three on that.
We all said they should do it.
And there wasn't really an option not to.
And I mean, I can't say we were wrong at the time, but this
is the Aaron Nola experience.
And I'm, I'm sure, you know, we had to own some level.
I've seen the, the days of this kind of start from Aaron Nola happening a
couple of times in a row, at least we're not over, so, yeah.
Um, we probably should have, I think we were all nervous about Aaron Nola
pitching for someone else and realizing there wasn't anything obvious, an
obvious way to replace him in the moment.
But you know, I think, um, we do tend to look at things from a very short term
view, um, but you know, the Phillies thought it would be a good investment.
It's just such a long contract.
My goodness.
It's it's so long.
Yeah, it is.
He also hasn't, I'll say this.
He also hasn't thrown his last good start.
You have to imagine as well.
There's more of that coming, you know, he needs another pitch.
He needs, he needs to develop another pitch.
Like Cole Hamels kept developing different pitches as his career
went along and his velocity.
He's got to learn how to, he's got to learn how to, how to pitch with the
stuff he's got instead of the stuff he had.
And I think that's where a lot of pitchers fall down.
They don't want to learn how to pitch as themselves.
Now they want to keep believing they could do what they used to.
Aaron Nola, you cannot.
You have to get on the band.
We got to get on the train of new pitches or you're just not going to, you
know, you'll be out of baseball.
It just will not happen.
And this isn't in his control, but he's also going to look better cushioned
in a rotation of other more dominant starters in that Aaron Nola's got a
three 50 ERA in the middle of other guys who are like looking at two, three
than that.
He's a lot more tolerable and sustainable and survivable as a starter.
So like the fact that nobody is pitching super well right now is just
exacerbating his, his own bleeding of runs.
Yeah.
And that's the starting pitching falling apart.
The way that it has here early has been the real shocker.
Uh, the fact that Chris Sanchez gave up 10 hits in his last start and has given
up more hits in his last four starts than any pitcher in baseball has given
up in any four starts this year.
Back to back to back to back.
You know, he's just, he's been giving up a ton of hits.
He's got a really high whip right now.
Uh, Jesus Lizardo, same thing.
Um, the Phillies did an Andrew painter, you know, he's again a rookie, but hasn't
looked like the phenom, um, that we were, that we were hoping to see yet.
It's unfair to expect that right away.
But also, you know, when you're like the number one point, he was like a top 10
prospect in baseball, if not a little bit higher than that, it would be nice to see
that guy a little bit, but it can't all be on him.
You got to, these other guys got to do their job first and let's one last little
bit from the Atlanta series.
And this is good news.
Zach Wheeler looked really good in his first start back, uh, on a major league
mound, his velocity was up, um, was throwing 95, 96 miles an hour.
So certainly way better than his final start in Redding when he was 92 93 and
pitched pretty well through five innings in Saturday's win.
So that is a, if he can pitch like that, a monster upgrade from Taiwan Walker with
the team released last week.
That is at least some good news.
And I have more confidence that the rotation will pick things up certainly than
the offense.
But if that happens, then the Phillies can get themselves out of this.
It's just, um, they've, it hasn't happened yet.
You have a couple of starters who started pitching, you know, things start evening
out for them and they started pitching the way they're supposed to be able to
pitch and you start seeing, you know, their, your opponent gets some of the bad
breaks that the Phillies have suffered almost exclusively in these games.
Then yeah, you're going to be able to squeeze some more one run wins out.
But at this point, I'm just tired of looking at this team in terms of like
probability statistics and just want to see them execute on a fundamental level
without having to like, Oh yeah, they scored 13 runs and they did still like
commit three errors.
Like just have a, have a play a clean nine.
Let's let's, let's start there.
You got a very soft stretch coming up.
So, you know, but also you can't really say that because this team couldn't get
absolutely destroyed by anybody in this league.
So regardless, objectively softer schedule coming up than playing the Braves
and Cubs every game, be able to take advantage of that with some, some
pitchers who are improving themselves with lineups that are, despite their
ability to beat the Phillies, still weaker than the Braves and Cubs and more
easily beatable.
So hopefully that allows them to get a little more footing under them.
Liz, I'd love to hang my hat on that, but they had an easy start to the schedule
at the beginning of the year and didn't take advantage of it, you know?
So, yeah, I don't know.
I, my whole, my hat is hung on.
It can't be this bad the whole time.
It just can't.
Well, because I'm saying it can't, it just can't be the, it can't be that bad
the whole time because it simply can't be, it's just not going to be this way
the whole season and I'm sure fans are saying the same thing to themselves
right now, you know, and I don't know how many people in the Phillies
lineup as it currently stands.
Do you expect to see better things from over the long-term of the season?
Like Harper's playing very well.
Marsh is playing very well.
I'll give Sosa a little credit.
He's come through a bunch of, like a couple of times so far this season.
Schwarber, you want to say, is pretty much doing what Schwarber does.
Batting average is down in the dumps, but that's, you know,
where that lives typically.
Turner will be better.
Expect to see a better Turner.
You expect to see, I mean, are we going to say Baum and Stott?
Or are we just like, we've pretty much said we know what to expect from them.
Yeah.
And I don't think you're going to see much more from Garcia either.
I think Adonis Garcia is giving you exactly what he is.
Yeah.
So that's three, three starters in the start.
That's a third of your lineup that you can't really expect much from.
Real Muto too, when he comes back.
And Real Muto, yeah.
Offensively.
So yeah, four out of five hitters that expectations are very low for.
That's too many.
That's way too many.
Well, it's too early for, for, for us to start making predictions on, you know,
you know, are they going to, you know, will they get the playoffs?
Or who finished better record, the Phillies or the Mets?
You know, there's, there's a win in the division.
I'll say it.
Well, they're not winning the division.
No, that's the division's over.
Um, there's no doubt about that one.
Division is over.
Yep.
So, so it's all about the wild card now.
And you know, there are three wild cards in each league.
I will say though.
And, uh, I saw this, I saw this, uh, statistic online.
The Mets and Phillies are both 10 games below 500, uh, entering play on Tuesday.
In order to grab a wild, a wild card spot.
Let's set the number at 86 wins is, is what the number is.
And I think that's low.
I think you're going to need more than 86 wins given how well the
NL central is playing right now.
There are 134 games remaining.
The Phillies and the Mets would need to win 77 of those games
in order to get to 86 wins.
That's a five 80 winning percentage.
That's about it.
The pace of a 94 win baseball team.
If the Phillies started playing at their best right now, I think they can do that.
They can get to 86 wins.
I don't think that's going to be enough.
I think they're going to need to play 600 ball the rest of the way
in order to get a wild card spot.
And I don't know that they can play at a 96 to 97 wind pace from here on out.
We don't know what it looks like when this team gets hot yet.
So, yeah, I mean, that could be a good thing or a bad thing based
on what you're talking about.
But you know, the teams that these Phillies keep getting compared
to didn't win 86 games.
So, yeah, they'll have to play at a level higher than they
seem currently capable of playing.
They have to play with a fervor and an enthusiasm that they also don't
seem to currently be playing with.
So they would have to be playing with a lineup that they don't
seem to be currently playing with.
So there are a couple of factors here that need to change.
And based on how fundamental or deep you feel those factors are,
that's going to determine, and I guess I'm talking to Dave
Dabrowski when I say this, that's going to determine what level
of person you're about to fire.
Because he's looking at a keyboard that only has like two
buttons on it at this point.
And one of them is fire Rob Thompson and see what happens.
Yeah.
And as of the end of the recording of this podcast, Rob Thompson and the
rest of the coaching staff remain in place.
And I'll say too, the same as being the same as with the Mets.
Up to the minute fired anybody here, uh, 28 games in.
So, um, I can't imagine, uh, what the response is going to be if no one is fired.
But I agree.
I don't know that certainly Rob, I don't think Rob Thompson's
getting fired, uh, by, by Kevin Long.
Maybe.
I don't know.
We'll see.
We'll see how it all shakes out here over the next little while.
Um, let's finish up here with some final thoughts, Justin,
anything to wrap up the show?
Well, just a zip zip zip shut.
What we were just talking about.
Anything the Phillies do, no matter what seems possible or whatever, whatever
they do next is only going to be part one of a plan that has to work.
And so even then, if you're like waking up and cheering, cause Kevin Long was
fired, it's like, all right, so what did you really gain here?
Like what, what truly is the, is, is the response to this going to be?
I think there's going to be way more to do after that.
And some of it's about like swapping people out and some of
it's about getting people going.
But you know, there's a lot of different ways things can still go, even after
whoever you want to fire gets fired.
So we'll see.
Uh, and the other thing I'll say is, uh, I was just on the WIP daily podcast
talking about Summer of the Cheapleaners with Joe Giglio.
So you can check that out, uh, over at WIP.
Uh, yeah, I got to talk about the book.
Got to talk about what it's about.
1941 Phillies and what they were doing during Joe DiMaggio's historic hit streak.
And also just how the whole thing came together, like the research and people
like I've talked to since and everything.
It was just a good conversation about Summer of the Cheapleaners, which you can
get from booksellers near you currently.
Fantastic.
Check that out, everybody.
Liz, final thoughts.
Uh, just a few more comments about Dave Dombrowski.
That popped into my head after we were having that conversation.
I feel like when the book is closed on him and the Phillies, it will be a lot of,
mostly about the things he didn't do rather than the things he did do.
But I, considering that a decent amount, at least at this point of what he did
do is still relatively defendable.
But the one thing that we should not forget is that Taiwan Walker, almost for
the entirety of his contract, was kind of a waste of money.
That is one of the worst contracts the Phillies have given out in a really long
time. And he was just released.
Think about the number of times we have said, when will he be released?
Years. Almost for the entirety of his contract.
We've been sitting here wondering, well, I don't think they're going to release
him because they need to pay him $72 million over the next however many years.
I just want to remember, I just want everyone to remember that because it's a
singular, like, everyone's like Taiwan Walker's a great person.
This is not about him as a person.
That was a bad contract.
And, uh, I don't, I'm never going to be able to forget it.
I don't think.
And, um, Aaron Ola may dwarf that contract, that level of bad contract, um, as time
goes on.
Yeah, but we've already discussed that at length and it was a lot of fun and I'm
glad you all were with us on that journey as we, as we spoke about Aaron Ola yet
again.
All right, everybody, that's going to do it for this edition of hit and season.
And, uh, we will be back.
Some of us, some number of us, if there are, if there is a big move to be made in
the meantime, there'll be some kind of a, an emergency podcast just to kind of,
just to kind of discuss it a little bit.
Um, so you can kind of look out for that.
Got a big guest coming up on the midweek edition of the hit and season podcast.
So make sure you check that out, uh, coming up, uh, probably on Wednesday
night, we'll release that.
Uh, you're not going to want to miss that.
Uh, you can of course, watch this podcast, this round table edition over at the
WHYY YouTube channel.
Go over there and subscribe and you'll get every round table episode of this
podcast there.
And of course, tell your friends and your family members about the hit and season
podcast.
If you'd like to listen to us on audio only Apple podcast, Spotify, wherever it
is, you get your podcast.
That's where you can find us.
Thanks everybody for tuning in.
We'll talk to you next time, right here on hit and season.