The Life Of Arthur Plantagenet, Viscount Lisle | Henry Viii’S Forgotten Uncle. Edward Iv’S Other Son

What Was The Life
13 followers
1 Video View·Apr 28, 2026
He was Henry VIII's forgotten uncle and the brother of the princes in the tower,
yet the life of Arthur Plantagenet by Count Lyle, like so many illegitimate royal children,
is shrouded in mystery. In this Plantagenet documentary from History Calling,
I'm going to look at what we do know about him, from his mysterious origins to what may have
happened to him after the disappearance of his brothers Edward V and Richard of Shrewsbury,
and during the reign of his uncle Richard III. You'll hear how he integrated into the new
Tudor era and worked with his brother-in-law Henry VII, sister Queen Elizabeth of York,
and nephew Henry VIII, and I'll also tell you about his marriages, the pets he and his wife
sent to Anne Boleyn, one of which she liked, one of which she didn't, the scandalous final
chapter to his life, and the very unexpected way in which he died.
Arthur Plantagenet was the illegitimate son of King Edward IV and was clearly recognised as such
given that he was allowed to use the surname Plantagenet, which was the name of the royal
house at the time. Despite this illustrious paternal family line, however, so little is
known about him that the identity of his mother remains unclear to this day. The most popular
theory, though, is that she was called Elizabeth Lucy, and that she was the daughter of a Hampshire
gentleman called Thomas Waite, Lucy being a married name. Other names which have been thrown into the
The woman Edward IV supposedly married before he wed Elizabeth Woodville in 1465. If true,
that would have made the marriage to Elizabeth bigamous and their children illegitimate,
and I already have a video on that topic where you can hear the evidence for and against this
earlier marriage. I'll leave it linked on screen and below for you. The date of Arthur's birth is
also extremely unclear. He seems to have been born before 1472, though, because there is a
reference in the royal household accounts that year to an illegitimate male child of Edward's
being there and receiving robes, which suggests that he was more than a baby. This would indicate
that he was raised alongside his legitimate half-siblings who were born between 1466 and 1480,
and who included Princess Elizabeth of York, the future Edward V, and Richard of Shrewsbury,
Duke of York. These latter two are known to history as the princes in the tower.
As for how early he might have been born, well, his father was born in April 1442,
and if we assume that Edward wasn't begetting any children until at least his late teens,
then Arthur could still have been conceived as early as, say, 1459 when Edward was 17,
and born as early as 1460. We therefore have a huge date range to contend with,
though I think his later activities as a jousting companion to his nephew Henry VIII in the 1510s
would suggest he was born later in this range, and probably during Edward's marriage to Elizabeth,
for despite their famous love union, Edward was anything but faithful to his queen,
and Arthur wasn't his only illegitimate offspring.
There are no decent images of Arthur, and so we know very little about his appearance.
I'm using generic images of medieval men for this video, and maybe some AI images,
but if I end up doing that, such pictures will be labelled as AI. I don't know yet
if I'll be going down that road, though, at the time I'm recording this audio.
The fact that King Henry VIII sent him a suit of his own armour at one point, though,
might suggest that he was tall, just like his father Edward IV and Henry himself,
both of whom easily cleared six feet, which was very unusual for the time period.
Other than the 1472 document, we actually know nothing else for sure about Arthur's
life for the rest of the 15th century. He was clearly well-educated for the time period,
able to read, write, ride and joust, and his later job working in Calais would suggest he
spoke French too, but beyond that I wouldn't like to speculate. I would like to offer up
one other possible reference to him, though, which I can't stress enough, is just supposition.
Before I reveal what it is, however, if you enjoy Great History content with an emphasis
on loyalty and the use of primary sources, why not go ahead and hit that subscribe button so
that you can stay up to date with all my uploads here on YouTube. You can also become a member of
my YouTube community and get bonus material and perks by hitting the join button underneath videos
and following the on-screen instructions. Or you can become a Patreon at patreon.com
slash historycalling, where I share even more extra material, including early access to ad-free
videos and mini-podcasts. It's linked below for you, as is my book, Find Your Irish Ancestors
Online, and my website, historycallingofficial.com, where you can sign up to my free mailing list and
As you may know, Arthur's father died in April 1483, leaving the throne to his eldest legitimate
son, who was only 12 years old and who became Edward V. Edward V, however, was soon placed in
the Tower of London, along with his little brother, Richard of Shrewsbury, on the orders of their
paternal uncle, who then declared himself Richard III. The two boys were never seen or heard from
again, and although I always get blowback when I say this, I think the most likely scenario is that
King Richard had them killed. Their exact fate, however, is one of the English royal family's
greatest mysteries, and it continues to spawn documentaries and books to this day, claiming
that they have solved some or all of the puzzle. In one such documentary, aired on Channel 4 in the
UK and which I reviewed, I'll leave the relevant video link below for you, a document was produced
which referred to a son of Edward's being on mainland Europe in 1487, having been, quote,
expelled from his dominion. Now, the presenters argued that this must have been one of the
princes in the tower, who somehow escaped from that great medieval fortress, made his way to
mainland Europe, and yet left virtually no paper trail. But as I said in my review video, even
assuming this wasn't a medieval typo, Edward IV's nephew, John de la Pole, Earl of Lincoln, was in
Flanders at the time, having fled England, and the document could have referred to him, it could also
be a reference to Arthur, as we have no idea what he was doing or where he was during this period,
and of course, he also fits the description of a son of King Edward. Unfortunately, neither possibility
was mentioned during that documentary, which I felt really cherry-picked the evidence it discussed
to support the theory its presenters wanted to be true. By the by, since that documentary aired,
another has come out with an entirely different take on the mystery, and which I also reviewed.
Again, I'll link it below, along with a video I made which looks at all the evidence for this case
in detail. So we don't know how Arthur responded to the death of his father, the disappearance of
his brothers, and the reign of his uncle Richard III, nor do we know what he made of the conquest
of England by Henry Tudor, who became Henry VII in 1485, after winning the Battle of Bosworth,
at which Richard died, and who married Arthur's half-sister, Princess Elizabeth, in January 1486.
Their first son was born that September, and given the same name as his half-uncle,
but I wouldn't read too much into this. Rather than being a nod to Queen Elizabeth's illegitimate
half-brother, Prince Arthur Tudor was named in honour of the mythical King Arthur of round-table
fame. So had Arthur Plantagenet died by the year 1500, we would barely know he'd even existed.
We have only one, maybe two references which might be to him over the preceding three decades,
neither of which actually name him. We therefore have to acknowledge the possibility that those
references are to another illegitimate son of Edward IV's who has been otherwise forgotten
by history. For one thing we do know is that Edward got around, and I hope I've demonstrated
to you by now how light the surviving paper trail for an illegitimate royal child can be.
We now come to the later part of the reign of Henry VII. In 1501, the King recommended an
illegitimate child of King Edward's to his own mother, Lady Margaret Beaufort, and this is more
likely than not a reference to Arthur. We also know that he was working in the household of his
half-sister, Queen Elizabeth, by 1502 at the latest, and that he was listed as one of her
household servants at the time of her death in early 1503, where he attended her funeral.
David Gromit, writing in the Oxford Dictionary of National Biography,
notes that Arthur must therefore have known his half-nephew, the future Henry VIII, from childhood,
because Henry was being raised at Eltham Palace under his mother's supervision,
and I think this is a fair enough assumption. Certainly, their later close relationship,
despite a huge age gap, suggests that they had a long history together. With his sister dead,
Arthur moved into the King's household, where he served as an esquire for the body to Henry VII,
and when Henry died in 1509, Master Plantagenet, which is still all he was at this point,
transferred into the household of the new monarch. Arthur did well for most of the reign of Henry VIII.
As mentioned, he joisted with his nephew and took part in feats of arms at court in 1510,
and in 1511 he was finally married for the first time, at the age of at least 39 it would seem,
to Elizabeth Grey, daughter of the first Viscount Lyle, and already the widow of Edmund Dudley,
whom Henry VIII had executed the previous year. Through that marriage, she was the mother of the
future Duke of Northumberland, and therefore grandmother of Lady Jane Grey's husband,
Guildford Dudley, and Elizabeth I's favourite, Robert Dudley, Earl of Leicester. See how everyone
at the Tudor court was connected? Arthur and Elizabeth would have three surviving daughters
together, named Frances, born anywhere from 1512 to 1520, Elizabeth, born around 1520 to 22,
and Bridget, whose arrival may have been the cause of her mother's death in 1525 or 1526.
Given the length of the marriage, I would speculate that there were other children who died young
or miscarriages. It was also thanks to his wife that Arthur finally became a peer, though the
way in which the title came to him was quite convoluted. The Lyle Viscountess had passed from Elizabeth's
father to her brother, and then to her young niece, another Elizabeth Grey, which is confusing, I know.
This little girl was betrothed to the King's favourite, Charles Brandon, in 1513, and he was granted
the title of Viscount Lyle to hold through her. However, he then got a better offer in 1515, when
the King's sister, the newly widowed Mary Tudor, Queen of France, decided she liked the look of him,
and having married her, Charles sold on the wardship of little Elizabeth, who then died in 1519.
The title now passed to Arthur's wife, who became Viscountess Lyle in her own right, a very unusual
situation, by the way, for a woman to hold her title on her own like that, and she and Arthur were
Four years later, on the 25th of April 1523, Arthur was made Viscount Lyle, in recognition of Elizabeth's
claim, and he continued to hold that title even after her death. In the early 1510s, however, all
of that was still years in the future, and Arthur was busy with military and civilian duties for the
King. He was made a Commissioner of the Peace for Hampshire in 1512, and took part in military
campaigns against France in 1513, nearly dying when the ship he was captaining, the Nicholas of
Hampton, hit rocks that February. A letter from Henry Howard to Henry VIII described what had
happened, and Arthur's response to it, saying that he had been in extreme danger and had, quote,
called upon Our Lady of Walsingham, which is a religious shrine, for help and comfort,
and made a vow that, and it pleased God and her to deliver him out of the peril,
he would never eat flesh nor fish till he had seen her. Sir, I assure you he was in marvellous danger,
for it was marvelled at the ship, being with all her sails striking full, but a rule with her stern,
that she broke not on pieces at the first stroke. Sir, we shall have a great want of him out of
your noble army. Despite this near-death experience, he continued to fight, and was knighted for his
trouble near Tournai in France on the 14th of October, 1513. When he returned to England, Sir
Arthur Plantagenet was made Sheriff of Hampshire the following month. Seven years later, he was
still in high favour with the King, and was attending him at the famous Field of the Cloth
of Gold in 1520. He may be one of the little figures we see attending on the King in this
famous portrait of that event. He continued to hold high positions at court and beyond,
and the King's trust in him seems to have been unassailable. He met Charles V of Spain with
King Henry in 1522. He was made a Knight of the Garter in 1523, served as a Gentleman of the
Privy Chamber from 1526 until 1533, and in 1525 he was named Vice-Admiral of England,
deputising for another illegitimate royal boy, Henry VIII's son Henry Fitzroy, Duke of Richmond,
who was a child of only six at the time. He was also made Constable of Portchester Castle,
and was sent to meet with Francois I of France on behalf of King Henry in 1527,
meeting the French King again when he went with Henry and Anne Boleyn to France in the autumn
of 1532. As David Gromit has said, and it's from him that I got a list of Arthur's appointments,
this cursus honorum, this phrase means that Arthur was getting a succession of offices
of increasing importance, suggest that Viscount Lyle, as he became in 1523, was a competent and
trusted soldier, diplomat, and administrator, certainly not the ineffectual bungler as which
he has sometimes been represented. It seems Arthur was also a genuinely good person. Henry VIII found
him to be, quote, the gentlest heart living, which only makes the King's later treatment of him,
which we'll come to shortly, all the more disgusting, while John Fox wrote in his famous
Book of Martyrs that Arthur was, quote, of a most gentle nature. To his servant John Hussey he was
ever called the pleasantest-witted man in the world. Lord Lyle remarried in 1528 to the widowed
Honor Lady Bassett, née Grenville. The new Lady Lyle was a forceful and organized personality
who brought him seven stepchildren, but she was already well in her 30s, maybe even her late 30s,
and the couple would have no offspring of their own. There may have been a miscarriage in 1537,
however, though bear in mind she would have had to be in her 40s by that point, and eventually
Arthur's daughter Frances would marry Honor's son John Bassett. The Lyles were evidently in love.
When apart, Arthur once wrote to her that, I had never better health, but I think so much on you
I cannot sleep in the night. She was by his side as he embarked on what would be both the pinnacle
and the undoing of his career in 1533, when he was made the deputy of Calais, which was still then
in English hands, the last remnant of the once mighty Anglo-French empire that Arthur and Henry's
Plantagenet ancestors had built. It was while he was in Calais that Arthur kept up a series of
correspondence with those at home and abroad, now known as the Lyle Correspondence, and which is one
documents for the study of this period of the reign of Henry VIII. It's also where most of what
we know about Lyle comes from, even though the letters only cover seven years of his life,
leading up to 1540, when everything would unravel for him. In his foreword to the 1982 edition of
the Lyle letters, Hugh Trevor Roper gave a summary of what Arthur's job was, saying,
Lyle's duties at Calais were to ensure the defence and provision of the town, to see that
the soldiers' wages were paid, and, most difficult of all, to keep the peace among the English
officials, all of whom were on the make and some of whose families had been entrenched there for
generations. In time of war between its neighbours, the King of France and the Emperor, he had to
preserve the neutrality of Calais, and of course he had to entertain visiting Grandis on their way
to or from England. Another more unusual job he had was sourcing and sending treats to Henry's
wives. Anne Boleyn liked dotterelles, for instance, which are a kind of bird, which were sent over to
England still alive and put in her garden at Greenwich until she wanted to eat them. She also
enjoyed a songbird sent to her as a pet, though she didn't favour the monkey Lady Lyle sent as well,
as she disliked the animals. For Jeanne Seymour, it was fat quails, again a type of bird, which she
had a hankering for in May 1537 whilst pregnant with Edward VI. Some duties were less pleasant,
though, and as the Governor of Calais, it was presumably Lord Lyle who had to arrange to send
over the town's executioner to relieve Anne of her head in 1536. Not all tasks were so grim,
however. Arthur and Honor kept up a lavish lifestyle in France and even had a troop of
actors to amuse them. Arthur's time in the country has received a mixed response from historians.
Some consider him to have been a fairly incompetent Governor, others think he did the best he could
with a difficult situation. For instance, there were arguments over who should get jobs within
the Governor's retinue, one of which, with the Mayor of Calais, who wanted his son to get a
It was a pain, too, when his man at court, Henry Norris, ended up on the block as part of Anne
Boleyn's downfall, and Arthur and Honor were living beyond their means in Calais and were
often in debt to various tradesmen. At least he was getting along well with Thomas Cromwell,
though, who was the new favourite minister of Henry VIII. Things could be worse, he might have
We now come to the year 1540. For context, Henry VIII was in a miserable marriage to Anne of Cleves,
whom Arthur will have met at Calais in late 1539 while she was travelling to England,
which he was desperate to get out of so that he could marry her lady-in-waiting Catherine Howard,
and he was in an increasingly bad mood with Thomas Cromwell, who had been a supporter of
Though Arthur had previously maintained good relations with Cromwell,
things had soured between them over religious policies, and Arthur gradually allied himself
with Thomas's enemies. Cromwell wasn't going to take this lying down, though,
and the King's uncle was called home to England, his papers were seized, which is why we still
have them, and he was arrested and thrown in the Tower of London on the 19th of May,
the fourth anniversary of Anne Boleyn's death, if anyone's interested.
Two days later, the French ambassador, Charles de Marillac, described what had happened and why
in a letter to Anne de Montmorency, who was a French noble man despite that first name. He said
It is commonly said he is accused of secret intelligence with Cardinal Poole, who was his
near relation, and of certain practices to deliver the town of Calais to Poole. However, the said
Lord Lyle is in a very narrow place, from which no one escapes unless by a miracle.
There had already been brought to the same place ten or twelve mortes pays, this is a type of
who charged the said deputy with words contrary to honour and fealty.
De Marillac was correct, by the way, that Lord Lyle was accused of treasonable correspondence
with he and the King's first cousin once removed, the exiled Cardinal Reginald Poole,
son of Margaret, Countess of Salisbury. Lady Lyle and the daughters who were with her in Calais
were also detained and placed under house arrest there. This was a very unexpected and
scandalous turn of events. There had never been any hint that Arthur was anything but a loyal
subject to his nephew. He'd somehow successfully navigated the Wars of the Roses, made his peace
with the new Tudor regime, survived a shipwreck and been a close friend of Henry VIII's all these
years, and yet now he suddenly found himself languishing in the tower. In some ways it's
even more surprising than what happened to Anne Boleyn, who after all had a famously
tempestuous relationship with Henry, who was known to fall in and out of love rather easily
and wasn't able to provide him with a son. Of course, Arthur wasn't the only one the
King turned on that year. Cromwell himself quickly went from the one ordering the arrests
to the one being arrested, and he was sent to the tower too on the 10th of June,
then executed at the end of the following month, having been charged with, among other things,
treason for communicating with heretics at Calais. Arthur was plainly innocent,
but as Anne Boleyn could have told him if she hadn't been lying in pieces under the floor of
the nearby chapel of St Peter at Vincula, that didn't really matter to Henry VIII,
nor did the fact that he and Arthur were family. So instead of going free, Viscount Lyle remained
in the tower for over a year and a half, during which time his cousin, the aged Margaret Countess
of Salisbury, was executed. He must have wondered if he'd be next. Finally, however,
the King relented and made moves to free his now elderly uncle, a man who had always been
loyal to him and who he'd known since childhood. In January 1542, Lyle was restored to the Order
of the Garter, and on the 3rd of March, royal servant Thomas Risley, later Earl of Southampton,
came to see him with the wonderful news that he was to be set free, with his honour and goods
restored, as de Marillac would later write. Unfortunately, the shock of it all was too much
for Lord Lyle, and he promptly dropped dead from his rejoicing, presumably of either a heart attack
or stroke. Either way, the timing of it all is something stranger than fiction. Not many of
Henry VIII's family members were sent to the tower and then pardoned, and it was a cruel twist indeed
for Arthur to die a free man, yet still in his prison. He was buried in the tower just as so
many of Henry's other family members were, including wife number five, Catherine Howard,
and one-time sister-in-law, Jane Boleyn, who'd been killed just a few weeks earlier. I don't
know the exact location of his grave, but I would assume it's in the chapel of St Peter at Vincula,
though not under or around the altar, which is where all the really famous people are,
or are assumed to be interred. His distraught widow was released and lived on until 1566,
while nine days after his death, his title was given to his stepson from his first marriage,
John Dudley. And so ended the life of a man who always lived close to the throne,
but never had any claim on it. Someone who seems to have been a pleasant, inoffensive gentleman of
the court, always loyal to his Tudor masters, and yet who ultimately died as a result of an
odd combination of Henry VIII's anger and his mercy. He's not well remembered by history,
and much of his life is a tantalising blank. But Arthur Plantagenet will have known,
and even been related to, all the major players of the closing years of the Wars of the Roses,
and the early to mid-Tudor period. And if we could only talk to him now,
I'm sure he'd have some stories to tell. I hope you enjoyed hearing about his life.
Let me know below if you think he might have been the son of Edward IV,
floating around mainland Europe in 1487, and to learn more about some of the incidents and
people mentioned in this video, try one of these options next. Whatever you choose,
please enjoy, and until next time, keep learning!
