Anne Boleyn's Re-constructed Face Revealed, with History

My Favorites
590 followers
372 Video Views·Dec 8, 2022
Shop prints & bookmarks: www.Etsy.com/shop/RoyaltyNow
What did Anne Boleyn really look like? After Anne Boleyn’s death, her image was essentially erased from England. The palace walls which once held the initials, H and A, are struck. Her portraits are painted over or destroyed. What we have left of her image is through posthumous portraits - potential copies of copies of a lost original
Hello everyone and welcome back to Royalty Now Studios where we bring figures from the past
to life with recreations and talk about their history. Today we'll be talking about one of
my all-time favorite figures, Anne Boleyn. Now Anne is notorious for being the second
wife of King Henry VIII and eventually being wrongfully executed on his orders.
First, we'll talk about her life and her fascinating history. I'll go through the
individual portraits of Anne, declaring which one I think is the most accurate,
and comparing them to the only contemporary image we have of her.
And then, of course, I will reveal my recreations. I've got two brand new ones to share with you
today. So let's go ahead and get started. The interesting thing about Anne Boleyn is that
she was never meant to be queen. In fact, she wasn't supposed to feature in English history
at all. She was, in fact, supposed to marry an Irish lord and disappear from the records.
Because her meteoric rise didn't occur until her midlife in the 1520s,
much of Anne's life has gone unrecorded. And much of what we do have recorded is from hostile
sources. Sources whose opinions are tainted by the insane ruptures in politics that her
queenship caused. Anne Boleyn was much more than the reputation that she has gained throughout
the centuries. So let's first talk about what we do know about the early life of Anne Boleyn.
She was born in either 1501 or 1507. Scholars cannot agree, and this makes her either 36 or
29 at the time of her beheading in 1536. As a young woman, Anne received some of her education
in the Burgundian Netherlands in the court of Margaret of Austria. She also spent time in
France as the maid of honor to Queen Mary Tudor and later to the Queen Claude. These were courts
full of intelligent, enlightened women that no doubt shaped her. When Anne is called to return
to the Tudor court in 1522, she has this air of foreign attractiveness to her that the other Tudor
women do not have. She now speaks fluent French, she's been educated by some of the brightest minds,
she's even possibly met Leonardo da Vinci during his brief residence in France.
At this time in England, the young and still handsome Henry VIII has been married to the
Spanish princess Catherine of Aragon for many years. But their marriage has become strained
due to the numerous miscarriages and stillbirths that Catherine has endured, leaving only one
Henry has grown restless, he's anxious for a male heir. He does have his one bastard son from his
former mistress Bessie Blunt, but it's not enough. Henry Fitzroy is not a legitimate heir to the
throne of England. So it's in 1522 that Anne is recalled from her studies in France to reside
back at the Tudor court. You see, the original reason that Anne came home from France was to
marry her Irish cousin James Butler in order to settle a property dispute. But the marriage
negotiations brokered by a certain Cardinal Wolsey failed. Now it's speculated that Anne had a few
quote, dalliances in her early years back at court, namely with Henry Percy and Thomas Wyatt.
Now the extent of these relationships comes into play later on when her loyalty is being questioned
by the king. But for now, Anne is one of the most intriguing women of the court and she's excelling
at the game of courtly love. So it was in 1526 that the eyes of the king have fallen upon the
Lady Anne. 17 love letters exist penned in the king's own hand. The early letters paint a picture
of Henry as a pining and desperately in love man who's being kept at a distance by his beloved.
By the later letters, Anne has accepted a proposal of marriage from the king. So let's look at this
timeline. There are many reasons to believe that at the beginning of their courtship, marriage was
never the intended outcome of their relationship. Henry and his queen Catherine had been unhappy for
some time before he even sets his sights on Anne Boleyn. Henry was likely just looking for a mistress,
someone to have fun with while he resolved his marital woes. You see, Henry VIII was actually a
deeply religious man and he was living in a time when the church and religion was at the center of
everything. He begins to question why he has no sons with Catherine. You see, Catherine had
originally been brought to England to marry his older brother Arthur who died not long after their
wedding. It was said that Catherine and Arthur never even made their marriage binding, never
consummating it. Maybe there were answers in his religion for his unhappiness. Henry finds one
answer in the book of Leviticus which states, if a man shall take his brother's wife, it is an impurity
and they shall be childless. Henry begins to consult his counselors about a possible annulment.
Eric Ives posits that even though Henry was asking for a divorce, he wasn't even thinking about Anne
Boleyn as queen yet. It happens to be after this that Henry asks Anne to be his mistress, not his
wife. She refuses to become his mistress, stating that she planned to keep her maidenhead only for
her future husband. So it was only later in the summer of 1527 that Henry turns his sights to
actually marrying Anne, not just making her his mistress. By the autumn, Henry is petitioning the
It was assumed that an annulment would be granted fairly quickly. Kings usually get their way after
all, but to say that their road to marriage would not be an easy one would be a vast understatement.
Catherine of Aragon absolutely refused a divorce. Henry's main argument was the religious one, that
her marriage to his brother had made her unclean, made their union cursed. The pope refused this
divorce vehemently. His predecessor had granted them a special dispensation to marry all those
years ago, resolving the brother issue there and then. So why would Pope Clement reverse that
decision now? It would be six long years before Anne would become queen. Six long years of
consultations with bishops, councils, and the pope. Anne's personal religion is not truly known to us
today, but she could certainly be described as evangelical. She agreed with the burgeoning
movement in Europe that people should be able to read the Bible in their own language.
It's without a doubt that she had an influence on Henry during this time, maybe even convincing him
to take matters into his own hands, which he dramatically does by separating from the Catholic
Church and becoming the supreme head of a new church, the Church of England. So despite the
former queen still living, Henry and Anne decide to marry in a secret ceremony that likely took
place on the 14th of November in 1532. Something interesting is that they may not have even engaged
in a physical relationship until they believed they were legally married. The Archbishop of
Canterbury, Thomas Cranmer, formally dissolves the marriage between Henry and Catherine of Aragon
on the 23rd of May, 1533. And this paves the way for Anne to be crowned queen. On June 1st, Anne
is anointed on the famous Cosmode pavement of Westminster Abbey. She's visibly pregnant with
a future heir and she's brimming with hope for the future. Unfortunately, this hope won't last too
long. Anne gives birth to a baby girl, the future Queen Elizabeth I, on September 7th of 1533.
Of course, there is this disappointment that she's not a son, but the couple are still young
and in love and they continue to try. By 1535, Anne is pregnant again. She's hoping for a son,
but there are rumors that the couple quarrels, that Anne's independence and her headstrong nature,
things that were so alluring to Henry during their courtship, are now seen as liabilities
and they're wearing on him. It is in early 1536 that a domino effect begins to take place.
First, on January 7th of 1536, the former Queen Catherine dies. Later that month, Henry takes a
near-fatal fall off of his horse at a tournament, after which he is unconscious for two hours.
This brush with death absolutely jars Henry. He's thinking, how can he have been king of
England for so long with no son? What is wrong with his marriage is that he simply cannot get
what he wants. Only a few days later, Anne miscarries and the baby was a boy.
Many scholars argue that this brush with death not only made Henry reevaluate his mortality,
but also may have actually changed his brain, a brain injury, making him into the paranoid and
dangerous man he becomes later in his life. After all these years he wasted trying to marry Anne,
he feels betrayed. Now that Catherine is gone, if he left Anne, he would actually no longer be
required to return to his former wife. Now that Catherine is gone, he would be free to take
another. His eyes land on the young Lady Jane Seymour, who is everything that Anne is not.
Where Anne is considered swarthy and dark, Jane is fair and light. Where Anne is headstrong and
obstinate, Jane is docile and compliant. It's a bit unclear when Henry's gaze really turns to Jane
as a potential third wife. But it doesn't take long before Henry and his council,
particularly one Thomas Cromwell, have trumped up charges of adultery against Anne. They claimed
that not only was Anne not a virgin before her wedding to Henry only just over a thousand days
Nearly all scholars agree that these charges are false. Henry's role is also somewhat unknown.
Was he genuinely convinced and heartbroken that Anne had been unfaithful to him,
convinced by his scheming counselors, or did he aid in creating these charges against her?
Anne is arrested on May 2nd of 1536. She is tried and found guilty and she is beheaded at the Tower
of London on May 19th, 1536. An innocent woman, alongside her supposed lovers Henry Norris,
Frances Weston, William Brereton, Mark Smeaton, and her own brother, George Boleyn. The poet Thomas
Wyatt, also one of the men imprisoned during the trial, witnessed the executions from his cell in
the bell tower. He writes a heart-wrenching poem about the horrors he's witnessed, aptly titled
In Latin meaning, around the throne, thunder rolls. Anne's legacy continues with us till this day and
she's not forgotten. In fact her execution actually makes more sense once you look at it in hindsight
when you see the erratic behavior of her husband King Henry VIII in the years after he gave her
execution order. In one of my favorite twists of history, the baby daughter that Henry was so
disappointed by, the future Elizabeth I, goes on to be one of England's best monarchs, ushering in
a golden age. So what did Queen Anne Boleyn really look like? One of the most unfortunate things
about her being executed as a disgraced queen was that her image was essentially erased from England.
The palace walls which once held the initials H and A are struck. Her portraits are painted over
or destroyed and what we have left of her image is through posthumous portraits, potential copies
of copies of a lost original. We do have one agreed upon contemporary image and that is a
portrait medal, referred to as the most happy medal, that was struck during her lifetime probably to
celebrate her second pregnancy and the upcoming birth of a son. The talented artist Lucy Churchill
did a restoration of the coin which she's allowing me to use here. So I'm going to compare each
postulated portrait of Anne to the coin throughout the video to see which one matches the best.
As far as physical descriptions of Anne, we do have a few, although how accurate these are is
unknown. As I said, most of what we know of her comes from hostile sources who don't really have
a vested interest in portraying her kindly. The rumors that Anne Boleyn had a deformed finger or
large mole on her face are false. They're pretty much created propaganda long after her death.
So the ones that are the most accurate are probably from the Venetian diplomat Francesco
Sinuto describing her as not one of the handsomest women in the world. She is of middling stature,
swarthy complexion, long neck, wide mouth, a bosom not much raised, and eyes which are black and
beautiful. The French poet Lancelot de Carle calls her beautiful with an elegant figure.
Now Anne's body has never been officially exhumed. It was hastily buried at the chapel
of St. Peter at Vicula adjacent to the tower in an old elm box. Her exact burial spot under the
tiles of the chapel is unknown. There was a restoration of the chapel in 1876 under the
guidance of Queen Victoria that had to exhume some bodies in order to do the work. They left
detailed notes of the skeletal remains that they found and even had them examined by a doctor.
He confirmed that the skeleton was of a woman between 25 and 30 with a delicate frame.
She was of slender proportions with a small lower jaw, and she had particularly small vertebrae,
lending credence to that story that she had a little neck. And she was probably between
5 feet and 5 foot 3, and of course no extra finger. All of these findings match up with
the physical descriptions we have of Anne, but of course there's a possibility that the bones are
not Anne's but rather Lady Rochford's or even Queen Catherine Howard's. These are two women
who were hastily buried near her in the same spot. In terms of painted portraits, Anne had
a very strong connection with the painter Holbein, who very likely painted her portrait during her
time as queen. It's assumed that if her official portrait was painted, the posthumous works we have
today were copied from that work. So let's take a look at some portraits that are supposed to be Anne
and discuss the case for each. First, let's look at a few of the Holbein sketches on which one of
my recreations is based. This first one has historians John Rollins and David Starkey on
its side. It matches one of the French accounts of her having a swollen neck or double chin,
although as I mentioned before, this isn't exactly a kind source to Anne. But the contentious thing
about this portrait is twofold. First, it's her state of undress. This woman is wearing a night
gown and a cap, which is really casual garb for a queen famous for her sense of style to wear
during a portrait sitting. Secondly, there appears to be some gold trim near her cap,
and some say this is hair. Others say it's just a gold trim on the cap, but it's hard to tell. Anne
was famous for having dark hair, so that just wouldn't track. The one solid piece of evidence
for this one is the inscription, Anne of Boleyn, Queen. This was added by a man named Sir John
Cheek, a man who would have known Anne and therefore would have known what she looked like.
But some argue that it's just not authentic or that was added at a later date.
So let's compare this one to the image on the Most Happy Medal. Then we have this other purported
Holbein image, which I actually think looks very similar to the first, even suggesting that they're
the same woman. I think that's really interesting. It's been theorized that this is a sketch of the
same woman, just one state she's pregnant and in one state she's not. I also think this one bears
a slight resemblance to the possible Holbein sketch of George Boleyn. Maybe that's just my
own wishful thinking, but they were siblings, so there could be some resemblance there if that
portrait ever got authenticated. This one has the same kind of authentication issues as the first,
where the identification of Anne Boleyn was added later and therefore isn't very reliable.
So let's compare this one to the Most Happy Medal. I actually do see quite a lot of resemblance to
this one with the fuller lips and the strong nose. Another one kind of in this style is referred to
as the Nidd Hall portrait, and the only link that this one really has to Anne Boleyn is the A.B.
brooch that you can see on her chest. But there are some scholars, particularly scholar Roland
Twi, who believes that this is actually a portrait of Jane Seymour that may have been misidentified
throughout the years. There's actually another variant of this portrait that has a jeweled brooch
rather than the A.B. brooch, kind of indicating that it was just changed up by the artist. But
there is an interesting tidbit where a piece of facial recognition software actually matched this
portrait to the Most Happy Medal, and I do think they look fairly similar. So then we have the
famous National Portrait Gallery image, which I've based two of my recreations on. This portrait and
several others have a very recognizable pattern, suggesting that they may be all copies of that
lost original we talked about. Apparently there was a full-length portrait of Anne that may have
existed as late as 1773. They're all dated after Anne's death, and they show her wearing the French
hood, black dress, and famous bee necklace. Let's compare these portraits to the portrait medal as
well. So in terms of similarity to the medal, which as I mentioned is the only agreed-upon
likeness of Anne from her lifetime, I think the closest resemblance to the coin is actually the
Nidd Hall portrait, which I wasn't expecting to come to that conclusion at the end of this,
and I think a close second is the Holbein sketches because of the strong nose.
But in terms of the historical likelihood of which portrait I think would be Anne, I would go
with the National Portrait Gallery pattern of images. Just because of their similarities, they
all look so similar that it would make sense if they were all copied from the same lost original,
which presumably would be that lost Holbein portrait. But these all have a really heavy
level of stylization to them that the other ones like the sketches and the Nidd Hall one just don't
have. So I'm sorry to leave you with such a nothing conclusion there, but if I were to create or
imagine the face of Anne, I believe it would be somewhere between the Nidd Hall portrait and the
Hans Holbein sketch that I've used for my recreation. So let's go ahead and get to the recreations.
Let's take a look at my recreations of Anne Boleyn from her own time as well as in the modern day,
now. Thank you all so much for watching. I hope you learned something and enjoyed your time with
Anne. Make sure to like and subscribe if you want to support us bringing history back to life.
We will see you for the next video.
