Part 2 of Echoes of Olympus The Enduring Gifts of Ancient Greece David Mendelsohn

Echo of Antiquity
24 followers
#Arts #History #Culture #EchoofAntiquity #EchoesOfOlympus
Sculpture Greek Sculpture Traditional Arts & Culture
I'm really delighted to be here with you again, and so I guess we can add another country.
I was just a few days ago in Kyrgyzstan, where I actually celebrated, I kept Shabbat with
the community there, and I will be tomorrow doing Shabbat here.
So it's kind of adding to the list, I guess, of the Jewish communities of the world, and
we'll be speaking about that a little bit, I think, throughout the lecture.
Gila, I was wondering, is it being recorded right now?
Yes.
Okay.
I just want to make sure.
Okay, good.
So here, I'll start by sharing, I guess, my slide.
Let's see if it's working here.
Okay, good.
Here we go.
Very nice.
All right.
So I basically, I want to start by continuing, last week I gave us all a challenge, which
is why the Greeks?
What was going on with this weird cultural stew bubbling over there?
I don't know if it's a combination of historical circumstances, DNA, religion, or society.
Whatever it was, as we saw last week, it gave rise to democracy, the court of law, and we're
going to also see it gave rise to the gift of writing and reading for everybody, accessibility
to knowledge.
And this included, of course, what we call science, what they call philosophy, the love
of knowledge, biology, botany, theatre, liturgy, history, and this new spin on art and architecture
that we'll be discussing today.
So we looked at, last week, how this democracy might have happened, how it gave rise, but
it's upon all of us, every time we work together, for every session, also when we're striding
through Greece together, up and down the hills, in the Agora, the Acropolis, looking
at vases, looking at statues, to keep asking that question, what was it about them that
made them ask these questions, and why is it that they seem to be the only ones that
actually manage to separate the ability to have a dispassionate look at why we feel passion,
why we're asking, when we see something, and when we touch something, are we really seeing
the thing that we're seeing?
Are we really touching it?
These kinds of questions that actually influenced every aspect of their society and way of thinking,
and eventually influenced others as well, including, and ultimately, perhaps the most
profoundly, the Jews.
So the title, Vases, Statues, and Temples, How the Greeks Celebrated the Mundane and
the Divine, I kind of like that, because I was, when I said, if I can teach you art
and architecture, it's kind of, everyone does that, art history, and I think it's beautiful,
I think it's important, but it doesn't really get to what was unique, the challenge I'm
setting ourselves, what was unique and different, and how they approached what other cultures
were approaching differently.
And one of the clues, perhaps, might come, here's a map of Greece, from this interesting
fellow by the name of Hippocrates.
You might know of him as the, Hippocrates, the famous physician, the original physician,
we have many doctors swear on the Hippocratic oath to do no harm, et cetera, and many Jews
who feel uncomfortable swearing to the gods will swear to Maimonides, by the Maimonidean
oath instead.
But Hippocrates was this ancient Greek physician, and he's considered the most, the historical
founder of medicine.
And he had this interesting observation that I want to share with you.
It's a bit controversial, but bear with me.
He says, you will find, as a general rule, that the constitutions and habits of a people
follow the nature of the land where they live.
Where the soil is rich, soft, and well-watered, and where the seasons are favorable, you will
find the people fleshy, and they have watery constitutions.
Such people are incapable of great effort.
In addition, such people are, for the most part, cowards.
They are easygoing, clumsy craftsmen, and are never clean or delicate.
But if a land is bare, waterless, and rough, swept by the winter gales, and burnt by the
summer sun, you will find there are people hard and spare, by nature keen and fond of
work.
They are keener at their crafts, more intelligent, and better warriors.
You can see why I said this is a bit controversial, this statement, but he was actually asking
the same question that we're asking.
What made the Greeks suddenly find ways of building monumental architecture?
Why did they create these portraits, and statuary, and beautiful illustrations on vases, things
that nobody else's philosophies, and what gave rise to this?
And this is Hippocrates' best, his first thought, he's saying, maybe it's this.
And I thought of that two days ago when I was in Kyrgyzstan, and I was just in the steppes,
the Asian steppes, and this is an area where you can see the mountains are all around me,
and the rocks have been brought down by glaciers.
And all of these rocks, maybe, I guess, not all of them, maybe 30% of them, are covered
with petroglyphs, with drawings on stone that date from 2,000 to 3,000 BCE.
And I found that interesting.
I said, oh, these people were looking at these stones, and it made me think of my
literature with you.
So I actually took these pictures thinking of you.
And I, one moment, let me see if I can go in here.
You see here this beautiful figure of a deer, look at that.
That one also is about 1,000 BCE.
And as you're wandering this area, they also created this.
Look at that.
Doesn't that remind you of the Cycladic statues?
I was fascinated.
And I said, this reminds me of Hippocrates' theory.
These people had all this access to stone.
They didn't have much else.
And look what they started doing.
They started drawing, making statuary out of stone.
And so I thought I would throw that at you.
And then imagine Greece.
Imagine the mainland Greece with all of its, with its marble quarries on the islands,
with its kind of sparse timber, not really large trees.
So it wasn't very well.
It wasn't good for a large monumental boat building like you had in Lebanon, for instance.
And so, yeah.
And then, of course, but they still had a twist of their own.
They might have earth.
They might have clay.
And from the mud that they found by the rivers and the sea, the Greeks weren't anything special
in digging it and saying, oh, this clay, we can mold it.
We can fire it and create vessels as well as statues, of course.
And they use them as pots and cups and even funerary urns.
But what was different about the Greeks, of course, is that they started painting on their
vases and they immediately start painting.
Like, we have this proto-geometric vase.
They're already doing the shape with swirls and squiggles.
This is 975 BCE.
Look at this here next.
They're already starting this thing.
They were my favorite type of Greek art, geometric art.
Look at this.
So 900 to 700 BCE.
I wrote BJH for fun because I said before Jewish hippie.
Never mind.
It's my own shtick.
But look at these beautiful lines that you get.
You get these segments.
On the very top of this geometric period, that vase to the left, it's known as a Dipilon
graveyard.
You have a figure on a funerary burn being burnt.
So you actually have customs.
You have the women pulling at their hair.
So the Greeks of this time are already depicting this is what we do as Greeks.
Look at us.
So they dig the clay, they make pots, and they're already doing something different.
And they're telling their stories.
Some say this might even be the earliest depiction of telling the story of the Iliad,
of the funerary games of Patroclus.
That might be.
But it's incredible that they were doing this.
And as well as that, just shortly afterwards, around 725 to 600 BCE, they start showing
influences of other cultures.
So they've been trading with the Mesopotamians.
And they're learning stories about griffins.
And they start putting on their vases.
They know nothing about harpies.
They know nothing about them.
And they start actually taking myths and mythology from other cultures and putting it on their
vases.
And they also include lions and deer, elements that we know very well from Mesopotamia and
Canaan.
And so they're not just reflecting their own culture.
They're showing this influence and conversations that they're having already with other peoples.
And this is an incredible clue for us.
They're creating things that are individually their own.
And they're taking ideas from other places.
They're trading.
They're hearing.
They're listening.
And they're learning.
And this is where I'm going to start making you learn.
There's going to be a test on this.
Around the 6th century, going to the 500s, they start doing what's called black figure
pottery.
I know I introduced you to the concept last session.
But basically, they started telling stories by drawing figures in black on their vases.
They made this black gloss.
It's kind of a mixture of clay and water and dye and painting it on the actual vase
itself.
And you see these beautiful images.
Look to the one here.
They even write the names Ajax and Odysseus playing a game of what looks like checkers
on a board during the time they're in Troy.
And on the bottom, you have the story of Athena being born from the head of Zeus, Hephaestus,
the god of artisanship and mechanics.
He hits Zeus on the head who has a headache.
And out comes Athena, fully armed, the goddess of wisdom.
And what would it be?
That's not warfare, but war theory, I would say.
So look at this.
So we already are telling stories.
And they're the only people to be doing this, by the way.
And they're telling their own stories as well.
They have marriages.
They have individual soldiers going to war that I showed you last week.
And anytime I show you a figure that's a black figure, I want you to look at it and try and
gauge, is this closer to the 600s?
Are you getting down towards 550, 540, 530?
If you guessed around 530 here, you'd be right.
And suddenly, around 500, they make a shift.
And we'll look at the shift in a moment.
So look at this beautiful vase here.
Here you have Dionysus sailing on the sea, also a black figure.
Remember I told you this actual shape is called the calyx?
And because the Greeks were so fond of drinking wine, they had a game in which they would
pour their red wine into a bowl, and they'd serve it to their guests.
And they'd have their symposiums, having intellectual conversations about politics,
about the latest play, about things, about gossip.
And when they finished drinking, they'd say, what did you get?
Oh, I got a Dionysus.
What did you get?
I have Odysseus playing checkers.
And they also, of course, have pornographic scenes, which make them all giggle and get
even more drunk.
But this was a typically Greek affair.
I wanted to include this because this vase is unusual.
It's called the bilingual.
This is the time period when they actually start going from red figure to black figure,
and they're experimenting.
So look at this.
You have somebody, a fellow, sitting in a symposium, a gentleman.
He's being looked after by his attendants.
And the same painter has decided to do the other side of the vase in red figure.
Red figure means that you paint everything else black, and you allow the color of the
clay to stand on its own.
After you fire the clay, the figures that emerge are almost like a photograph, like
a negative.
Look what happens.
You get this incredibleโฆ
It's much more realistic looking.
It allows the picture to flow better.
And once they do red figure, they never go back again.
They become more and more masterful with how they do it.
And this is an incredible way to read, to understand Greek society, understand how they
were thinking, understand their habits, understand their arts, warfare, plays.
They tell you of everything, basically.
Almost like a comic book, because they actually have writing on it as well.
Here's a beautiful one of Achilles binding up for Patroclus's wound.
Look at the beautiful red figure.
You want to give me a date?
Just guess.
Look at it.
You see it's red figure, so you know it can't be 500, so you have to go to 400.
And you see it's quite well done.
So always go for aroundโฆ
When it looks that good, always go for around 490, and whoever you're with will be very
impressed, because you'll be close.
So there you go.
So basically, I wanted you to look at these vases.
And then I want to ask you this question.
If today's theme is looking at statuary and architecture, how did the Greeks really
learn how to build in grand monumental style?
And the answer is the same way as they learned how to write and read and write, and the same
way they learned about the griffins and lions and other mythological or animals that they
actually didn't have in their own in Greece, through trade, through travel.
And this is an image, of course, to show you that the Greeks were traveling by boat, were
reaching Mesopotamia, were reaching Egypt.
We spoke last week briefly about the fact that the Phoenicians who came to Greece to
trade with their beautiful timber with the Greeks, actually, ironically enough, they
loved Greek vases.
That was one of the things they traded for.
And one of the things that the Phoenicians brought to the Greeks, of course, was the
gift of writing that the Greeks adapted and added vowels.
We won't speak about that anymore today.
And they also brought the Greeks this purple dye that they use for royalty.
And this purple dye, we know it, we Jewish people know it as tekhelet, and it was worth
its weight 25 times in gold.
So the Greeks were very busy, in other words.
But one person decided to actually record his travels.
This fellow by the name of Herodotus, around 480 BCE, he's not only traveling to these
places and trading, he's actually writing about what he sees.
And he does something else that's remarkable, that is uniquely Greek.
He actually invents the concept of history.
Because other cultures that would write, let's say, Akkad, Sumer, Egypt, you name it, they'd
always talk about, it was either stories about the gods or boasting of the kings or emperors
or pharaohs.
And you never, ever get a narrative where any particular country writes anything to
its detriment, where it makes them look bad.
And Herodotus actually, look how he phrases his opening paragraph to the book that's called
The Histories.
Herodotus of Halicarnassus hereby publishes the results of his inquiries, hoping to do
two things, to preserve the memory of the past by putting on record the astonishing
achievements both of the Greeks and the non-Greek peoples, and more particularly to show how
the two races came into conflict.
If you look at the top where I wrote the word inquiries, the word in ancient Greek or in
Greek altogether for an inquiry is historia.
Historia just means inquiry.
There's nothing to do with his story or her story.
It just means basically a deeper look at things with questions.
And so, Herodotus is known as the father of history, the inventor of history because of
this.
And for many years, he was called the father of lies, because some of the stories he told,
things that he saw sounded so preposterous to his readers that they said this could never
be.
And actually, the last few decades have exonerated him more and more in terms of things
he claimed about the Egyptians, that our decipherment of hieroglyphics has actually allowed
us to prove a lot of the things that he claimed that were considered to be so outlandish that
they believe that Herodotus had just made them up.
So he's no longer, I believe, is called the father of lies by anybody.
So he's also the first person, I believe, if we're talking about what history actually
is and historiography, is that he's the first person to collect stories in a systematic
way and then test their accuracy in a way to say, why is this accurate?
Why do I believe this to be true?
And then arrange them in kind of a well-constructed and like this vivid narrative.
So he still prefers the gossipy style.
This is a great story.
I'll tell it to you.
But he does put it to some kind of scrutiny.
So he is believed to have explored Egypt, and this is relevant, around 450 BCE.
So he traveled with this Athenian fleet that was helping in a case of rebellion against
the Persians.
But when he was there, instead of taking part in any kind of battles, he starts asking
questions.
He visits the priests.
He visits temples.
And he starts writing about what he sees.
And his account, this is the world that he describes, basically a map drawn on a ground
base.
His account describes these insights into ancient Egyptian society, culture, and history
as it was understood at the time.
So as I said, some historians question the accuracy of his works, but he documents, he
goes to the pyramids.
He goes up and down the Nile.
He describes mummification.
He describes daily life, personal habits, culture, religion, and especially he describes
the temples.
And it is the oldest surviving accurate or semi-accurate records of ancient Greece.
But I want to show you this, actually.
Herodotus writes of the Egyptians, no native of Egypt will kiss a Greek, use the knife
of a Greek person, or in any way come close to his saliva, or his cooking pot, or eat
of any meat if it's been cut by a Greek sledge.
Look what Baha'i Sheikh says about the Egyptians.
It says the Egyptians will not eat with the Hebrews.
I'll read it in English.
And they set on for him by himself and did for them by themselves, and for the Egyptians
that did eat with him by themselves, because the Egyptians might not eat bread with the
So you have, interestingly enough, you have this corroboration from the Bible about what
Herodotus himself observes and comments on.
And so these are some of the things.
I'm not going to read the whole thing for you.
But he mentions that women carry on trade and frequent the market, unlike the Greeks
where the women stay home.
In Egypt, the men remain at home and weave.
The men carry the burdens on their heads, and the women carry the burdens on their shoulders.
He says the women urinate standing up and the men crouching down, which sounds strange
to me.
But he says in mourning, we Greeks cut our hair short.
The Egyptians, when death occurs, let the hair grow long on their head and that on the
chin.
That might sound familiar.
The Egyptians practice circumcision where we Greeks do not.
And as to how our clothing, the men wear two pieces of clothing, each of the women wear
one full piece.
And finally, when it comes to writing the alphabet, while the Greeks write from left
to right, the Egyptians write from the right to left.
And when they do it, they say that they're doing it the right way.
And the Greeks are doing it the left way.
And so he basically goes on and on.
This is how systematic he is.
And then I thought I'd include this cartoon for fun.
And once again, here's the red figure version of Achilles abandoning Patroclus's wound.
I want you to tell me if you can date it for me now.
Look at it, please.
It's red figure, right?
Red figure means it cannot be 500.
It's quite well done.
So you're going to be probably closer to 500 than, I mean, close to going down to the 400s.
And if you give me around a figure of 470, 460, you'd be doing well.
And I'd be happy.
Then you get a pass.
And here are just some scribal tools from about 3,400 years ago.
And just wanted to show you some of the things that he would have seen and witnessed.
And just for fun, I made up a story for you.
I call it the story of Thutmose the Schmuck and the Pillar.
So Thutmose, by the way, this is a typical Egyptian name.
So is Achmoses.
So is Ramses, by the way, which also is Rahmoses.
And the reason I'm stressing the word Moses, I may have mentioned this last session,
but Moses, mezes in ancient Greek actually means Ben, son of.
So Thutmose is the son of Thoth, the god.
Achmoses is the son of Achmose.
Ramses is the son of Rah, and so on.
So one of the theories that Freud, of all people, had about Moses, our Moses, Moshe Rabbeinu,
he says that he believes that because of his name Moses,
he probably also had some god attached to his name.
And when he became monotheistic, he chopped the name of that god off.
And I found that kind of a compelling theory.
And etymologically, it actually makes sense.
So I thought I'd share that with you.
But the story of Thutmose the Shemak and the pillar, I just imagined this fellow
living in the Nile, seeing all these reeds and these beautiful greenery everywhere,
and playing with them.
And the Egyptians were building these kind of rock pillars.
They just kind of put rocks together and started building up.
And Thutmose, or somebody, some ancient Egyptian looked at that,
and he said, this is much prettier.
These shapes are much more pleasing to me than those ugly brick shapes that we see.
And the Egyptians shortly afterwards started building like this.
They actually represented in their stone monuments,
they started carving images of bound reeds.
Look at that.
And they're really exquisite when you go there.
And it's not a stretch to say that the people who saw this, the Greek visitors saw this,
and introduced the concept of grooves in the Greek pillars, which is why we have the grooves
today that we know very well, both in Greek and in Roman pillars.
We believe, most scholars believe, archaeologists, that it was a direct influence of Egypt.
And basically what we see on our groove pillars today probably comes from those bound
reeds of ancient Egypt.
And I just wanted to share that story with you.
Something else, by the way, when you go to Egypt, as many of you may have been,
I would love to take you myself one day, but when you go there, you'll see many of these
pillars are painted, beautifully painted.
And very important for today's lesson about Greek architecture is these temples and pillars
were brightly, brightly colored in Egypt.
And we know it because the color is still there in many, many places, because Egypt,
of course, the dry heat preserves it.
Greece, the humidity and the seasons and the very fluctuations of the seasons causes the
paint to eventually disappear, unless it's buried, in which a few cases, some of the
colors are preserved.
In Egypt, you can see it everywhere.
And very important to this lesson is that if the Egyptians are transferring their knowledge,
if the Greeks are taking this knowledge and putting it in Greece, there's no reason to
think they didn't take color as well.
And in fact, now we know they did.
But for all these years that we knew that the Egyptians painted almost in garish color,
we believe that the Greeks had this idea of purity, where everything was beautifully bright,
glaring white from the sun, this pristine marble.
And in fact, now we know, it's not a theory, that every inch of these pillars was painted
to Greek taste, which would, to our taste, be almost garish, every part of it.
The statues, every element, they were clothed.
So just, it's already changing our perception, just I wanted to put that out there.
And we have, so, and as I said, the Greeks are also reaching other parts.
So it's not only Egypt they're seeing, they're seeing Mesopotamia.
Mesopotamia, of course, has the ziggurats, particularly in the area of modern-day Iraq,
which is where they built these huge monumental temples, layer by layer by layer.
And the Greeks were also influenced by that, these grand temples, like glorified kings and
made priests central.
And all around you have statues of kings as demigods, like we see in Greece as well.
So, just as an aside, the ziggurat was believed by some scholars,
biblical scholars, to be the inspiration for the Tower of Babel, the whole story behind it.
So anyway, Herodotus would have seen these beautiful,
magnificent statues of the pharaohs, as did previous Greek visitors.
And this statue is standing in Luxor, by the way.
You can go see it today, of Ramses II.
The Ramses, by the way, who's believed to be the pharaoh behind the story of Moshe
and the Exodus from Egypt.
And this is from about 1250 BCE.
But look how he's standing, by the way.
You see that one leg in front of the other?
You can kind of have one stand and show you.
But look how his hips are even.
Even though one leg is in front of the other, there's no shift in weight.
So the Greeks took that stance themselves.
If you look here, this I have next to it, the Mentu-Merhet from 700-650 BCE.
And the Greeks, their earliest statues are called the kouros.
And you can see that they have the same leg in front,
the same hands clenched in the same way.
So it makes it very difficult, actually, to not acknowledge this kind of influence from Egypt.
But they're already making a tiny shift.
Not that much.
It's still more or less central.
But you can see the Greeks are already experimenting.
These tantalizing hints of conversations that were taking place
between the Greeks with the Egyptians and then with fellow Greeks when they're back home.
Artists and carvers.
And here you have, and look, gradually, can you see this?
You have the shift of hips.
You gradually look at how the weight is going.
And one hip is going higher than the other.
And it looks much more natural, much more realistic.
So this one I showed you last week, too.
It's called the moskophoros, the ox carrier.
And I wanted to, again, start teaching you how to date.
I'm purposely choosing things from the same time period.
So this actual statue of a kouros carrying a calf, look at his eyes.
They're what we call almond-shaped.
His hair is beaded all the way down, kind of like you can see it flowing down around his legs.
And the smile he has is called an archaic smile.
So when we're together in Greece and you're going to be looking at a statue,
the same way you're going to be dating vases for red figure and black figure,
you're also going to be looking for those smiles, the archaic smile.
You're going to say, oh, this is an archaic statue.
That's how you're going to know.
Again, look closely.
This is in New York, the New York kouros.
They call the New York kouros the name of it.
You can see the same smile, the same beaded hair if you went closely.
And of course, they also have females.
They were called the kouros.
Look closely, the same beaded hair, the same archaic smile, the same almond-shaped eyes.
And again, look at the hips.
There's not much of a shift yet.
Here's how it would have actually looked when they ran it through infrared light.
They found yellow, all these different colors.
And they made copies of the kouros to show you how they actually would have looked
in ancient Greece.
They also would have had jewelry and had garments as well.
These are two statues in Delphi called Cleobates and Byton.
They're actually inscribed so in that way.
And you can look behind.
Look at how they're gradually freeing them from the stone.
And you can see the Greeks are going much further than the Egyptians or the Mesopotamians.
But what they're doing differently also, and I hope you're realizing this,
is they're not celebrating kings.
They're not celebrating gods.
These are regular people they're talking about.
They're common folk.
And they're celebrating the people for the sake of the people themselves.
And this is something remarkable.
Again, I showed you this last week as well.
But I wanted you again to look at the archaic smile, the almond-shaped eyes.
I want you to start looking for the scenes and start dating yourself.
The reason I'm including this now is that this piece of statuary was actually on an
earlier Parthenon on the Acropolis in Athens.
And after the Persians destroyed it, the Greeks buried it.
Almost the way the Jews bury their Geniza, their holy documents.
The Greeks also believed their statues to be holy and buried it,
which is why you can see some of the colors actually preserved at the tail.
And so a new Parthenon starts to get rebuilt by the Greeks to reflect this new beginning of Athens
as an example of the victors and also as an example for all the city-states to say,
look, here we are.
Here we are, the Athenians, the leaders of all these wonderful things that are Greek.
We are the leaders of what it means to be a democratic people.
We are the leaders of what it means to be victors and also leaders in terms of architecture and art.
And so I needed a statuary, again, reflecting the same time period.
Look how the Cretan boy, you already see the smile's already gone.
You have more of a different somber kind of expression.
And look at this.
This is the famous Doryphoros.
He's completely freed from the stone now.
This is a completely natural-looking human being.
Look at the musculature.
Look at the hip change, the accounting, the body shift.
And very shortly after, you start getting images like this.
This is called Laiacun and his sons.
This is an image from the Trojan War.
This is mythological, but look what comes next, though, by the way.
Already around 330 BCE, you start getting images like this.
This is just called the boxer at rest.
He's a boxer.
He's a sportsperson.
Remember, the reason they do boxing and wrestling and all these other sports,
javelin throwing, racing, is to prepare themselves for the military.
But they also have Olympic Games.
And they have the Delta Games, the Panathenaic Games.
So sports are an incredibly central part of their life.
And I just found this figure, this exhausted figure, to be very poignant.
And this is already moving way beyond what you see in any other civilization.
Look at his face.
Isn't that remarkable?
And he even has a cauliflower ear.
As a fighter, by the way, I also have one.
It's a feature of people who box and wrestle and do jujitsu and things like that.
You can see the cauliflower.
You can see even bits of blood coming out of it.
He's just finished training.
He's tired.
He's breathing hard.
And I find this incredibly poignant and beautiful.
And this is done in bronze, by the way.
The other ones are all carved out of marble.
This is actually cast in bronze.
And the next one, to show you, it's not just about the beauty.
It's also about the sadness, the pathos.
And here's a drunken old lady.
And this might be our final Greek destination from these godlike pharaohs
and beautiful statuary to the ultimate sadness of what a human can descend into.
She's a drunk person holding onto her pot, squeezing it.
She's much older.
We don't know what the ancient Greeks thought in the 300s or so when they're looking at her.
But it definitely wasn't.
Isn't this a remarkable example of what humanity is?
It's something else.
And then you have something called this boy pulling a thorn out of his foot.
So this is where the Greeks were moving to in terms of statuary.
And again, we're looking for clues together, remember?
This is a major one.
This is what they do with people.
This is what they do with vases.
What did they do with buildings?
Temples were undergoing a similar kind of transition from what we are arguing was Egyptian
influence and to making it something purely Greek.
So here you have, again, look at these bound reeds on the temple.
Can you see how similar they are to the grooves you will see later on Greek temples?
So the Greeks actually, their earliest temples are built out of wood.
And then they move from wood to grand marble.
And they apply, remember, you have to add at the same time as all this is going on,
and we didn't discuss, we will, I think, in the next lecture, that session,
the invention of philosophy.
You have people like the pre-Socratics are discussing the concept of what is the basic
element of everything.
And they're doing what Einstein would call the get back experiment, the thought experiment.
Just by sheer discussion and thinking, Democritus comes up with the idea of the atom.
Because he says, what I'm touching is actually not there.
It's actually something else.
And the Greeks love this idea of what we actually see isn't there.
And they start creating illusions on their own temples.
Yes, they love the idea of perfection, but they also realize perfection can't be attained.
But you can fool the eye into thinking it sees perfection.
And that is a remarkably complex thought.
So, and they use the math and science that's being developed and discussed by the pre-Socratics.
And they're applying it to this math to creating these spectacular temples.
So, you have this beautiful temple that one of the earliest we have around 460 BCE
on Italy, the Temple of Hera.
And this is going to be my another, what time do I have here?
Yeah, we're good.
Look here, we have, these are called the Ionic Temple.
What gives us an Ionic Temple?
First of all, if you look at the pillars, these grooved pillars, why are they grooved?
Remember, we have theories already about that.
Look at the bottom of the pillars.
There's no base.
They're going directly into the entablature, directly into the floor of the temple.
That's the first thing.
You're going to look at that.
You'll say, David, there's no base.
I think that might be dark.
And I'll say, well, how can you know for sure?
And then you're going to look up on top and you're going to say, well, at the very top,
this is kind of a donut thing that's going between the pillar and this sort of slab
that's supporting the roof.
I was thinking of a donut-shaped thing.
Yeah, I'll accept that, yes.
Okay, that's pretty dark.
And what else can you tell me that makes this a dark temple?
And you'll say, well, on the very top, I see these kind of three slats all over the place.
Three slats here, three slats there.
And I'll say, yeah, that's pretty good.
Those are called triglyphs.
And between those triglyphs, you see those square spaces?
Those are called metopes.
So this gives us a dark temple.
And these columns, once more, one more time, that hit the base just like that, straight
on, those are dark columns, the most basic.
And the Greeks built with this at first, but they didn't like the idea that if you looked
at a temple and these pillars, that the further away you go, our eye perception makes the
pillars start to go inward.
Just the way we see a road, how when you see a road, it doesn't stay parallel.
It gradually goes into this direction.
It gradually goes to a point.
The same thing happens with the pillars.
So the Greeks do something called intenses, which means that they make the pillars slightly
cigar-shaped.
And they do it very mathematically.
They have a formula for it.
It's that the further back you go, the more perfectly equal the two sides look.
So the idea of illusion is extremely important to them.
They do the same thing with the floor, with the entablature of the whole pillar, of the
entire floor of the entire temple.
They gradually raise it and bring it down to the other end in such a way, and they do
it to the roof as well, so that the further back you go, the more perfectly parallel it
looks to your eyes.
The Greeks were obsessed with the idea that the eyes have to view beauty, even if beauty
isn't actually there.
And I want to leave you with that thought for a second.
Here's a small slide about intenses.
You don't have to read it too clearly.
I just want to show it to you.
It's the application of a convex curve to a surface for aesthetic and technical purposes.
Never mind that.
Here is the temple to the wingless Nike on the Acropolis in Athens.
And if you'll notice something, does this look dark to you?
And if it doesn't, then why not?
What are the differences?
So the first thing I want you to look for is, remember, the base.
Does the pillar go directly into the ground?
Into the, no, right?
There's another base coming between the bottom of the pillar and the floor of the temple.
You say, oh, that's different.
That's already not a dark pillar anymore.
Then you look up on top, and you're going to see these two swirls on each side, these
two scrolls.
And that already tells you this is an ionic pillar, the two scrolls and the base on the
bottom.
And what makes it an ionic temple is on the very top, you no longer have the triglyphs,
those three stripes, and the square of the metope.
You have a continuously running frieze.
And these friezes are filled with statuary.
Isn't that amazing?
Now you have statues actually filling the spaces of the temples.
They're bringing the worlds that we're discussing together.
They have all the drawings that were on the vases, all the statues they're making.
Now they're telling the stories in their temples.
And they're using the temples to tell stories.
No one else does this.
And they do it along the very front of the temple where you have that triangular part,
it's called the pediment.
They also tell full stories in there.
The Greeks have what's called a horror vacui, a fear of empty space.
They try and fill every space with something, and frequently those spaces have incredibly
informative stories for us historians, archaeologists, just people who are interested.
Here's a close-up of the ionic pillar.
And I don't want you to look, you don't have to know all this technical information.
I just wanted you to see how the top shows the frieze.
Here you have, again, a look at what an ionic pillar is.
You see they're going directly into the ground.
The top is separated by a piece between the ceiling and the pillar itself.
And here you have a symbol of the triglyphs and the metope.
That's all I want you to know for now.
And last but not least, you have this other pillar.
Look at the very bottom.
You have, just like the ionic column, you have a piece separating the pillar from the ground.
But when you go to the top, you can see the impasses, you can see the bulging,
the slightly bulging of the columns.
And when you go to the top, look at these interesting shapes here.
These are actually leaves.
And these leaves are not papyrus leaves that we see in the Nile Delta.
These leaves are a local plant called the acanthus.
So the Greek pillar is, the Egyptians have their lilies and papyrus bundles.
The Greek pillar is now a composite.
They have the grooves that we know from the Egyptians.
And now they've added their own local plants.
So they've Greekified it in addition to the statuary and imagery that we've seen.
So this is a Corinthian column.
I want you to see that.
Whenever you look at this, you'll say, David, that's a Corinthian column.
And here's your three bits of knowledge that you've learned.
Doric, Ionic, and Corinthian.
D-I-C, you can decide what that spells, but it'll help you remember
those three types of columns for your knowledge.
And here is a beautiful stylized version of the Parthenon
that we're going to see together on the Acropolis.
And look at this, you have the pediment, that triangular piece in front of the temple
telling a story.
You have the Ionics.
You have the Doric pillars outside.
By the way, the Parthenon was unique.
On the outside, they had Doric, the most basic type.
The next layer inside they had was a layer of Ionic columns.
And the deepest part of the temple that houses the statue had Corinthian.
So they had all the different types ofโฆ
So in other words, on the Acropolis, on the Parthenon,
Pericles hires Phidias, this artist, to basically put the best of the best all together.
The culmination of everything we're discussing.
And look at this here.
This is a painting by Alma Kadima in 1868 of Phidias, the artist,
observing his artist's painting or creating the frieze.
Remember I told you the Ionic temple has a frieze?
And this frieze around the temple is telling the story of the Panathenaic recession.
And these marbles still exist.
You can see it.
Most of them, unfortunately, in the Elgin Marbles in the British Museum.
But they do have some of the original pieces in the Acropolis Museum
that you're going to see yourself soon.
And we also discuss that burning question as to whether Elgin is a thief or a savior.
Because by taking those marble pieces, he arguably saved them for all humanity
to be able to enjoy.
But by stripping the Greeks of their heritage, the Greeks say,
this is still ours.
You took it from us and we want it back.
And the British say, well, we saved it for you.
And so this discussion is something that we're going to have a great time
digging our teeth into.
And even the Greeks, the majority of them are passionate about getting their marble,
the Elgin Marbles back.
But even they discuss whether the British have a point
and that they actually saved it from the turbulent times of history
when the Greeks did not have control over their own land.
And the marbles may have been destroyed if they had not been taken away.
So here, I just wanted to show you again this kind of the cutout of the temple.
Look how it looks.
You can see here the ionic pillars inside.
And oh, I can't show you the other ones.
The cutout doesn't show it to you.
And this I just want to show you briefly just how the curving actually looks.
Don't read it too carefully.
But just realize this is how the Greek architects drew their marbles.
They drew it like this, not straight out sketches.
They spelled it out mathematically.
And they even have sketches in some parts of the Parthenon
where you actually see some of these sketches drawn out.
So this, I'd say, tricking the brain.
Who would believe that there's actually no straight lines or right angles in the Parthenon?
So it's just a, it's all, it's, and yeah, so I'll leave you with that thought.
It's just, it's mind-blowing.
Here, I want to show you briefly what a triglyph metope looks like.
These are the three pieces, the triglyph.
And inside every metope, they would have a, they'd have a scene of something.
This one, you have, I believe, a scene of the slaying of the Minotaur.
Here, you have Atlas bringing Heracles the apples in the presence of Athena.
And here, you have the Ionic piece, where it tells the story running all along.
And this is the Apropolis today, how it looks to us, to our eyes today.
And this is, I believe, a very accurate depiction
of what appropriately at the entrance to the Parthenon would have looked like to the Apropolis.
This building is still partially standing.
To the side, you have the temple, what's called the Temple of the Wingless Nike.
It's called the Temple of the Wingless Nike, by the way.
I wonder if I have a close-up of the, here it is, here it is.
It's called the Temple of the Wingless Nike, by the way,
because the Greeks believed that Nike, who is the goddess of victory,
knows that they had a statue of victory, who always has wings,
with her wings clipped inside her, so that she can,
so that victory can never, ever again leave Athens.
So, and if you look carefully, can you tell me, if you look at the far right,
you can actually see the curvature of the Ionic columns.
You can say this is an actual Ionic temple.
And there's a figure of one of the Nikes.
This one has wings.
And we know that the original Parthenon housed a giant statue of Athena,
created by Phidias, that held in its hand the statue of Nike.
And the only full-scale reconstruction of the Parthenon anywhere in the world
was actually in Nashville, Tennessee.
So, if you ever go, I urge you to go and see this remarkable reconstruction
to give you an idea of just the sheer scale of what this Athena would have looked like.
And he based his, the artist, I don't know if he's from Nashville,
but the artist who created it in Nashville,
based his Athena on eyewitness depictions,
on drawings that were on coins of the particular Athena in the Parthenon.
And you can see she's holding a victory in her hand.
And she's dressed pro makos, prepared for battle.
So, one more time, I want you to think about, we have a statue.
We have a building.
All around the buildings, it tells stories in the pediments,
in the frieze, in the metopes.
And on the very inside, you have Athena herself, the goddess of Athens.
And it tells, it's kind of a culmination of everything we've discussed now
throughout the last, I guess, 25 minutes or hour, I would say, almost.
Here's a coin, by the way, with Athena sitting down with her shield,
holding a victory in her hand.
And here's a good reconstruction of what it would have looked like in color.
This is the outside of the Parthenon.
Look at those beautiful triglyphs.
Look at the colorful metopes inside.
And I want to show you next here.
Here you have an Egyptian image on an Egyptian temple of a person holding two ankhs.
It's basically a person and a pillar put together.
And look what they have in Greece.
This is on the temple of Tephizidon.
It's called the Erechtheion on the Parthenon.
And these women are called karyapids.
They basically created pillars in the shape of women who are supporting,
who support the top of the temple on their heads themselves.
I find these figures kind of, they're hauntingly beautiful.
These are all replicas because the Athenians themselves today, the Greeks,
they brought the original statues into the museum.
You'll get to see the originals in the Acropolis.
Look at the clothing, look at the drapery.
And you have, only one of them was actually stolen by Elgin, Lord Elgin.
And that one was brought away.
And the Athenians still bewail that particular missing one.
They say her sisters miss her.
They're very, they're quite passionate about it.
So yeah, I will leave you with this.
Because last time, the lecture lasted a bit too long.
And I wanted to give you a chance to have some,
ask for some questions and thoughts.
So thank you.
Thank you so much, David.
That was super interesting and very detailed.
Because the Greeks were influenced because of their travel,
how do you know that the pottery didn't come from other places and that it's Greek pottery?
We don't have any examples of any other,
there are some Mesopotamian vases where you'll see certain depictions happening.
But you have no, you have no examples of daily, of day-to-day life.
You have no, you have no full-scale stories that,
it's just, it's just, there's just nothing like it anywhere you've ever seen,
including Asia, anywhere I've traveled.
It's, it's something that's uniquely, uniquely Greek.
The Greeks typically take things and make them better.
This is something that was just Greek.
It's just, for me, it just shows their, their,
their almost obsessive need to fill every space with something.
And that's something in this case was just drawings about themselves.
I think last time there was a question on if they were influenced by
other places, were they influenced by the Hebrew Bible?
And was Herodotus influenced by, by the Israelite civilization?
If he traveled through Egypt, do you travel through Israel as well?
No, he never mentions it.
There's no record of it.
And the, there are mentions, but they're mostly of Aristotle having conversations with Jews,
but they're actually, it's actually Josephus Flavius that writes about it.
And, and we're, there's actually no evidence of, of
this deeper discussions about the Hebrews at that, at that time period in particular.
So if the Greeks are taking things and, and making it better,
and they're influenced by travel and their environment and what they find,
what about the influence of war?
Does that have any influence on society?
Well, it's actually a very, it's a very helpful observation.
The, one of the things that made you uniquely Greek was that if you participated in an important
battle that, that showed you as part of your society, last week you discussed the importance
of democracy, of being, of being part of your society, discussing it, taking part in, in,
in elections.
It was very important to take part in battles to protect your people.
So the, for instance, the first playwright, Aeschylus, he does, he was, he was, in his
own time, he was famed as the winner of contests, of, of, of playwriting contests.
But on his, on his gravestone, he had written, took, took part in the Battle of Marathon.
That was what was important.
So this, this defined you.
But to go deeper into your question, what the Greeks did not want to do was share their
knowledge with anybody else.
They weren't interested in that.
Everything they did was just for the Greeks.
And they were so selfish with their knowledge that they, they, their famous Olympic Games
that started in 776 BCE, held every four years, they weren't, no non-Greek was allowed to
participate.
And there was even grumblings or mumblings and rumblings that they should allow the Macedonians
with their funny type of Greek, their, their weird accents, and their strange type of monarchy
that wasn't any kind of democracy and any kind of giving place to the people and, but
included polygamy.
They said they shouldn't be allowed in the Olympics.
And I believe I mentioned this last session as well, but Philip II was so, had such a
chip on his shoulder about being considered properly Greek that he hired Aristotle to
teach his son Alexander the Great.
He said, oh yeah, I'll make, we Macedonians will be more Greek than any of you.
And not only that, Philip II starts to conquer Persia and all kinds of other places and other
Greek city states and starts to impose what he thinks is, is Greek.
It's called absolute despotism in modern terms.
He basically imposes philosophy and culture and ideals of democracy and on everyone else.
And Alexander the Great, of course, runs with that.
When his father dies and he takes over, he imposes Hellenism on the world and the idea
of questioning and science and it's, and it's, and so then you have the reverse of that.
That's why I loved your observation, your question so much.
It does, it does the opposite.
Now, now battle actually brings, brings with it enlightenment, so to speak.
So following on from that, do you think democracy would have evolved if they didn't travel and
see and were influenced by what they saw on the outside?
We discussed the, the, the struggle of the, of the, again, back to battle.
If you have battle and you're fighting against invaders and you're, and many of your people
refuse to fight because there's nothing in it for them, you have to start making it more
and more attractive for the people.
And, and that, and that, and that eventually almost by accident gave rise to democracy.
And again, are we, are we even certain that we should call it evolution?
Is it really the best form of government?
Plato certainly didn't think so.
Plato said Socrates was killed because of, because of democracy.
You know, it's just the, he said the, he said the ideal government should be philosopher
kings where you, you hire somebody with a good ethic.
You, you, you, you elect deep thinkers who are very ethical and moral and they should
be the real rulers for people.
So, so I want to, I want to steer us away from the idea of evolution of democracy.
Is that really the best form of government?
But really think about, but it is true.
And the importance they place on every common person is unique.
And again, it's one of our clues that we're looking at.
Well, thank you so much for that.
Last week, we were compared to idiots if we didn't participate in discussion.
And this week with Hippocrates, we're cowards.
So I wait to see what we become next week.
Thank you very much for this.
Great.
Thank you.
Thank you all.
Just love to see you all.
