Part 3 of "Echoes of Olympus: The Enduring Gifts of Ancient Greece" (David Mendelsohn)

Echo of Antiquity
24 followers
#Arts #History #Culture #EchoofAntiquity #Part3 #EchoesofOlympus #EnduringGifts #AncientGreece" #DavidMendelsohn
virtually at the moment. So I really wanted to entitle the whole series The Invention of,
like almost every lecture I wanted to call The Invention of Democracy, The Invention of History,
The Invention of Drama. And I'd like to call today's lecture, to subtitle it, The Invention
of Philosophy, because it really is the first time we see this, what we call thinking like a Greek.
It's the first time we see this kind of introspection really appear in human thought
in terms of history, in terms of our readings across the globe. So if we looked at The
Invention of Democracy, and we looked last week at art and architecture, you notice that we discussed
a lot about the influence on the Greeks of their closest neighbors, the Egyptians,
the Mesopotamians. These people were traders, the Greeks were traders, and along with
commerce and along with products, they traded ideas, of course. And the Greeks also were,
just like the Jewish people became much later on, they set up colonies wherever they went
to enable this type of commerce, to ease it basically. So we have the Athenians with all
of their creative architecture and art, and these ideas, newfound ideas of democracy,
they start to move around and colonize different islands in, I guess you'd say,
the area of what is now modern-day Turkey. And so one of the first places we see philosophy emerge,
and in fact a lot of the great Greek epics, Homer in fact was based in modern-day Turkey as well,
not in modern-day Greece. So the Greeks actually settled in a part of Asia Minor,
a city known as Miletus, modern-day Anatolia. And in Miletus, this Athenian colony, Ionian basically,
they had a wonderful port, and they had these trade connections with advanced cultures like
Mesopotamia and Egypt. And it exposed the thinkers in these islands that had already
been exposed to this Athenian, as I said to you before last week, democracy, art, architecture,
history, all these ideas. They start, and along with the acquisition of the Greek alphabet,
they start developing all kinds of ideas and questions as to explanations to the world's
And when I say explanations as to the origins, they stop asking about mythological or religious
explanations. They start looking at new ideas as to why we're here, looking for an overall
explanation. And the reason I chose this as my first slide is, of course, the alphabet,
learning the alphabet was a huge jump from the system of hieroglyphics or cuneiform,
that the Sumerians and the Egyptians had. It allowed the common person, the common human,
to learn how to read and write, and thus have exposure to different ideas with relative ease.
And here on the left, you have a Phoenician stele. So Phoenician, remember, they developed
their alphabet, and the Hebrew alphabet was taken almost directly from the Phoenician one.
And I want you to look at it. This is about 850 BCE. And you can already see letters that we
recognize. You see, I think it looks like a W, it's actually a shin, a P, it's actually a R or
a Rish. And you can look at it, you see symbols that you know. And then the Greeks took those
symbols, of course, and turned it into their own alphabet. And that's on the right, this beautiful
calyx, which is actually a drinking vessel. And here you have one of the earliest known
inscriptions of the Greek alphabet as we know it today. So I just want you to understand that was
one of the reasons for the vessels. And if, when we speak about Homer, and all the great
epic poets, and the playwrights like Aeschylus, and Sophocles, and Euripides, they always wrote
in poetry, but with rhythm and song. And they basically would almost rap to music all of their
beautiful epics. Suddenly, these people, these thinkers in Miletus, start to stop writing in
poetry and rhythm, and they start writing in prose, the way you speak. And this in turn enables
them to start expressing their ideas and their questions. And this is where you get this term,
this phrase, known as the pre-Socratic philosophers, the philosophers who came before
Socrates. And I want to emphasize that pre-Socratic does not in any way mean that Socrates developed
as a greater thinker from these people. By no means, no. These people, on their own, came up
with such incredible, groundbreaking ideas that were in every bit as ingenious and mind-blowing
today as they would have been back then. So you have these ideas fueled by this
shift from myth to reason. They want to know rational reasons for why things look the way
they do. And they start looking at this question of a single fundamental aspect,
it's called an arche, that underlines everyone's existence. Where does everything actually come
from? Is there one common form that explains all forms? So I just wanted you to just take a look
at this Miletus, where it is in relationship to Greece, and just see these are the trading
routes all over the known world. And here you have the Greek colonization of Asia Minor. So
the Greeks, the green represents the Ionians and the Athenians, this kind of influence that they
have. And I want you to, once again, last week I spoke about, or two weeks ago, we spoke about
the development of democracy in a small city-state called Athens. And a little bit later,
I'm going to get into what a city-state actually means. But basically imagine Greece as this kind
of mini-universe. And every single city-state on every individual island or settlement developed
its own unique way of thinking, but with the common language of Greece around it.
But they had their own government, their own evolution, their own history. So in other words,
each little city is actually a whole state, a whole country, in essence. And I want you to
imagine that as a possible explanation as to why the Greeks were able to develop so differently
than almost any other civilization we know. So if you have the absence of mythological explanations,
thinkers like, we're going to talk about them later, Thales and Anaximander,
they reject mythological explanations, which involve capricious gods. Instead,
they look for natural explanations. And they try and look at the phenomena that they observe,
such as the way the stars and planets shift and seasons come full term, and you can actually
predict it. And this is something I wanted to show. This is a vase that actually illustrates
a myth of Hercules. And what I find interesting, if you look carefully, is there's an actual skull
that's supposed to be a monster that many thinkers, many archaeologists believe is actually
a reproduction, an ancient reproduction of a dinosaur skull that they would have found back
then. And so in other words, these thinkers had, and we'll see later, had full access to fossils,
to not just dinosaur bones, but seashells, fish, everything you can imagine. And they wondered
about it. They want to know where they came from. And just for fun, and to keep you all sharp,
I want you to date this vase for me. Okay? Look at the vase. Remember, we did black figure and
red figure. So what would you call this? I think you'd probably say it's black figure.
So you can feel free to type your estimates into the chat when I do this.
So it has to be older than 500 BCE. So it looks a little less fine than the other works you've
seen so far. So what you actually have here is a crater dating to about 575 BCE.
And the reason I want to show you this crater, first of all, I want you to understand Greek
vases, is the crater was used to mix water and wine together. The Greeks drank wine with every
single dinner meal they had. And one of the reasons they didn't get totally inebriated,
is they mixed it, a certain amount of wine with the water. So it gave a flavor, and they could
choose how much alcohol content they actually wanted. One of the reasons, another reason I
wanted to show this to you, is the word crater gives us a modern word in modern Greek called
krasi. And krasi actually is the modern Greek word for wine. So in other words, they took this
ancient Greek concept of a mixing bowl, and the word for wine today in Greek is actually krasi.
If you read the ancient Greek work ethics, like Homer, the word for wine is actually
hoion, hoion, which is related to our own Hebrew yayin. So just a fun little aside.
And this, I want to also show you as we're dating, we're dating. If you look below you,
this is a well-known kore, called the phrasilokleia kore. And look at the bottom,
you see this beautiful Greek inscription. So you have a depiction of a regular common woman.
On the right, you see how it would have looked when it was painted in antiquity.
And I want you to illustrate that the ancient Greeks are already celebrating the modern human,
male and female, and they're writing for everybody. So writing is available to everyone.
So yeah, again, I want to show you more Greek city-states. It's an independent,
self-governing community. And each city-state in Greece, where we speak about Sparta, Athens,
Corinth, Miletus, it had its own agricultural land. It had its own history. And each one started as
its own settlement, formed around like a fortified citadel, an acropolis for protection. And over
time, each one of these little city-states got its own culture, its own diverse kind of
government, its own distinct identity. And this gives you the political and social units of what
we know as ancient Greece. So as I said to you before, if we're looking for clues about the
invention of democracy, think of this micro-universe and how each island has its own little personality.
And that allows in many ways for this accelerated development that we don't see in other places.
So Sparta has its own development, harsh history, gives it its legendary toughness,
while Athens has like this cerebral development. They all speak Greek, they all influence each
other, and they all thought of themselves as Greeks overall and as being the only universe
that mattered. So any other culture in the world didn't matter, everything was Greek.
So I just want to show you quickly what we did last week, our look at Athens.
Every city had an acropolis, which means the high point of the city that would have its temples
and could also be defended. And the regular people and the agora would live on the bottom,
and it was always close to the sea and a port where they could trade.
So the early philosophers called themselves the investigators of nature,
or they focused their inquiries on the natural world, and they wanted to understand fundamental
principles and origins. And this is like, as I said to you before, it's just an incredible
shift from the purely religious. And we have an Ionian school, the first school of philosophy
on this island of Moedus, on the settlement. And I think I'll leave it for that for a moment,
because I want to just leave it for there. And they're looking for this one overall explanation,
this arche, it's called, this beginning, this overall beginning for everything.
So these pre-Socratics are the first ever in any kind of tradition that we know of,
especially in Western tradition, to pursue this philosophical and scientific inquiry.
And they weren't just one group, but they were a collection of thinkers that we're going to look at
now all over the Greek-speaking world. So what we call this kind of search science,
these philosophers had basic assumptions. The most basic one that we hear for the first time
is humans should not rely on their senses—touch, smell, taste, hearing—when trying to understand
the universe at the core. Of course, this gives rise eventually to Plato and his forms and Plato's
cave, but we'll talk about that in a bit. And at the core, there must be—and I'm saying this for
a second time—there must be an eternal and unchanging reality at the core of everything.
Whatever your senses tell you, something is eternal and unchanging. Even though people die
and crops wither and fondant things decay, another season brings renewed growth,
renewed birth. The stars come full circle again, the constellations come all around.
What is this eternal and unchanging reality? And so the task of the philosopher, as they understand
already at this time period, is to look for a deeper understanding of this reality.
And once they understand or can grasp or theorize, to impart this knowledge to others.
So just for fun, I included—this is a famous mosaic that's, I believe, in the Vatican now,
of Raphael. He painted it in 1509. It's known as the School of Athens.
So every school—it was the School of Miletus—they called themselves schools.
The School of Athens has somewhat ideologically Plato and Aristotle in the center. We don't
really know who the other philosophers are, but we suspect that Thales of Miletus is there,
and Socrates, Plato, they're all in the School of Athens, but they're not necessarily defined.
I wanted to ask you if you would call this science, all of you. I just wanted to pose
the question to you. Is this philosophy or is this science? Einstein would actually call it science.
He said, the whole of science is nothing more than a refinement of everyday thinking.
And Einstein explains that he came up with his own theory of relativity in his brain.
He called it the Gedanken—that's the Gedanken experiment, the thinking experiment.
So there was no telescopes or microscopes or lab equipment used, and these people believed
they could think their way to the truth, and we're going to see today if we agree or not with that.
So I wanted you just to imagine these restless Athenians, basically,
choosing to move to Central, basically to Asia Minor, where they live, they walk, they observe,
they talk. And if you look on top of this picture called The Death of Socrates,
I wanted to help out with Ari. Ari sent you an email yesterday encouraging you to study
the Greek alphabet, basically for fun. It makes things easier when you go to Greece to read signs.
But aside from that, it's a relatively easy—demanding just a little bit of effort with
a lot of reward for you to do. It's also a rightful heritage, a Semitic heritage,
because it was taken from Semitic languages. So just for fun, if you can read this word,
in front of us, the first letter is the Phi, the Phi. And then after that, you have the Iota,
which is the same as the modern I. You have the L, Lambda, the Omicron, then the Sigma,
then another Omicron, another Phi, another Iota, and giving you Philosophia, which is basically
the love of knowledge. And here in this depiction of The Death of Socrates by Jacques-Louis David,
I think from 1787—it's in the Met, actually—he shows here Socrates taking a hemlock. So I call
this the best and worst of democracy and philosophy, perhaps, at its core, because Socrates
was convicted and sentenced to death by the Athenian democratic court, ironically enough,
and also for corrupting the youth. We can get it. We're going to actually be at the
prison cell of Socrates in Athens, and we'll discuss the fact that Socrates could have chosen
not to be executed. There was plenty of people that would have happily smuggled him to exile,
but he chose to accept the verdict of his fellow, of his peers, and he drank the hemlock and died.
So in many ways, this traumatized Plato, who decided that humans, society, could not be
trusted to democratically elect a viable leader, and instead posited the idea that we had to have
find and elect among a select group of people a moral and ethical philosopher who could rule
over everybody. So that's why I call it the best and the worst.
So if over the past two sessions we spoke about empire, society, culture, and politics,
today we're looking at the simple questioning by these thinkers of the nature of the cosmos,
the Greek word for world. And again, if we said that they started to ask about the nature of
things, but my question to you is, why weren't the Greek myths concerning cosmic origins,
why weren't they good enough for these people? These myths were always good enough for other
peoples and cultures, and I wonder about this. And they say, is the cosmos eternal?
It's clear when you look around you, the world's been around for an indeterminate period of time,
and apparently would continue to exist internally. But observation, as I said,
shows you something else, is that people change, they die. Plants, animals, other organisms,
births, life, death, decay, the earth within your feet, everything undergoes constant change.
So what's a common element to everything? So here's I want to introduce you to your first
Miletus character. His name is Thales. And Thales, look at the time period, he's born in 624
to 549 BCE. And he actually starts to have theories as to what this underlying thing
could be that never changes, this basic material of which all things are made.
So Thales says he believes that water is the archaic, is this basic thing that gives rise to
everything in life that we know. And just for fun, I want to show you a Greek vase that existed at
the same time as Thales. I wrote BJH before Jewish hippie, before Common Era. And he had
another thinker, a student of Thales named Anaximander, who says it can't be water,
water can't be the archaic. How can water become its opposite, fire? And if water is the fundamental
aspect of everything, why doesn't everything return to water, to entropy?
So one of the few things I want you to know about Anaximander, I think I wrote this here,
and because he saw fossils on land, he suggested that all mankind was derived from aquatic matter.
He actually is the first to propose evolution. Remember, I asked you before, is this science?
He's coming up with all of this in his thoughts, theorizing, reasoning, by observation.
Here's an earliest relief we have representing Anaximander. And it's the only existing image
we have of him from the ancient world. And I wanted to show you a 610 BCE Doric Temple.
Oh, I want you guys to describe it for me after last week. Well, how do we know it's a Doric
Temple, guys? You have the bottom of the pillar going directly into the base. At the very top,
you have that little donut, the only thing you see between that and the roof, the ceiling.
And just above that, you have those three pieces called the triglyphs. And between every triglyph,
you have the space called the metope. And above that, you have the triangle that's going to give
you the pediment. We're going to be looking at the Greek temples all the time, and I want you to know
what they are. We have here, again, the black figure of Dionysus and a crater. Remember,
I told you already several times, at a symposium, at a Greek party, you'd be drinking your wine.
You wouldn't know what you had until you finished drinking your wine. And then you turn to your
friend and say, I got Dionysus. What did you get? Oh, I got so-and-so. I got Hercules clubbing a
lion. And you talk about it. So after Anaximander, you have another thinker on the same island,
Miletus, named Anaximenes. Anaximenes says, you can't have something that's just,
you can't just say it's not water, it's nothing. You have to claim some kind of
describable thing to be the arachne, to be this element that never changes,
that's part of everything that we know of as life. And he says, I believe it's air.
Air is less dense than fire. It can be condensed as cloud and water. More condensed, it becomes
earth and rock. And his key idea is that the differences in quality are really just differences
in quantity, how it's compressed, basically. So you see them, they're really frustrated,
all these thinkers. They're talking, saying it has to be this. And they give them compelling
reasons as to why it's not fire, why it's not water. And we have another thinker coming along
from Ephesus, not far away from Miletus, Heraclitus of Ephesus, known as the Weeping
Philosopher. Now we're moving into the time period of 537 to 447 BCE. I want you to start thinking
again about what this looked like in terms of art and architecture. And he's the first person
that comes up with the phrase pantare. Everything flows. In other words, nothing ever stays still.
Everything is in a constant state of flux. He also says,
you can never step in the same river twice because all the water's already flowed. It's
no longer the same river anymore. And Heraclitus expands on this idea of change and evolution.
But he goes back to understanding fire to be the fundamental component. He says fire is always
changing. He says fire becomes water, then earth, then soil, then meat. He further claims that the
permanence of things is just an illusion because it's due to the fact that opposing forces are
momentarily balanced. If you read Heraclitus, it's heavy stuff. His thoughts really do flow.
Socrates said about Heraclitus, what I understood is important. This is an actual quote from
Socrates. What I understood is important, but what I could not understand is equally important.
And he writes, you have to be a strong swimmer of the spirit not to drown in the works of Heraclitus.
So Heraclitus, and I'll leave him for a moment because I want to show you, these are what
vases would have looked like in this time period. And the next thinker I want to talk about is
someone named Xenophanes, Xenophanes of Colophon. Xenophanes, I think I have a slide of him.
He had a funny comment to make about why he doesn't believe that the gods exist, at least not
in the form that we think they are. I do have a slide. Here it is. He says, the Ethiopians say
that their gods are snub-nosed and black. The Thracians say that their gods have blue eyes
and red hair. But if oxen or horses or lions had hands and could draw and make things like men do,
horses would draw their gods like horses, oxes like oxes, and everybody would draw their forms
and mold their bodies just like the bodies they have for themselves. He's basically laughing at
humans for assuming that gods look like them. He says if there are gods, they look nothing like
what you think they do. He's already challenging the myths, at least the way they're depicted in
Greek art. He also wrote, again, in poetry. He actually criticizes writers like Homer and Hesiod
because of their belief in many gods. He's one of the earliest to say,
I believe God is one, eternal, and that he causes things to happen by noos, by his mind alone.
Just to see what these people, what these thinkers are playing with.
Then in the 5th century BCE, Empedocles actually says, I believe that there's going to be four
basic substances, earth, air, fire, and water. In addition, he actually looks at fossil fishes
and shells in Sicily and says that the land that I'm looking at must have been underwater at a much
earlier time. He says, I believe that everything must have been flooded here and that one day
everything will be flooded again. He's the first person to say reality is just a great wheel.
He's one of the first people that we know to actually use fossils as evidence for a theory
of the history of the world. Again, I want to remind you, these are thinkers. This is just
by observation, and we're going to see this depiction of a three-headed creature in the
Parthenon. It's actually in the Acropolis Museum across from the Parthenon, that each one is
holding an object to represent earth, air, fire, and water. I include this statuary because I
want you to look at the archaic smile, the almond-shaped eyes, and the beaded hair. From
last week, I want you to say, David, this is an archaic statue. It must be about 480
before Common Era. I'd say, wow, that's pretty good. You're right.
Another thinker, Anaxagoras of Clasimenae, which is near Turkey now, he says, everything has a
moon. The moon isn't a god, but a giant rock, and the sun is just a hot rock.
What is very important about Anaxagoras that I want you to focus on, he says,
the secret substance of the world is not water, not fire, not air, but in fact, seeds.
Seeds in different sizes and shapes, and that all matter was composed of them.
Due to these complex patterns that he assumed has to exist, Anaxagoras says,
there has to be a great mind. Again, this word nos, nos behind it, organizing everything.
Isn't this amazing, by the way? They're getting closer and closer to a theory that we might
recognize, actually. That's not all. I wanted, by the way, to show you a temple of the same
time period again. This is the Athenian treasury in Delphi. I wanted to show you about what a 500
BCE temple looks like. We're going to be there as well, I hope. I wanted to show you what a
statue would look like about the same time period. You can see, along with the Greek thinking,
you see the architecture is changing, and you see the art is changing. Look at the statuary.
This is already much more fluid than that much stiffer block like Kouros I showed you before.
This Kouros is already, you can see the more natural shape of the muscles. You can see the
shift of the hips starting to happen. This dates to about, they say, between 540-515 BCE.
Here we go, just to show you how the statues are still changing. We're moving to a thinker. This
one is about 480 BCE. Now we get to a fellow by the name of Democritus of Thrace. Democritus of
Thrace, who lived between 460 and 370 BCE. I'm sorry, again, one more time, BGH is just my own
term. BGH is before Jewish hippie, forgive me. What Democritus of Thrace comes up with is an idea
that is so unique that many claim that he came up with it with the atomic theory himself.
Democritus, also known as the laughing philosopher, he liked the idea of cosmic
seeds that we just spoke about, the seeds, and he tweaked it. He said that the entire universe
is made up of these uncountable tiny particles that the eye can't see, invisible to the eye.
These tiny particles cannot be broken down any further. The particles themselves he called
tomos, T-O-M-O-S, tomos. He says when you break it down to the smallest tomos, you can't cut it
anymore. It becomes atomos, impossible to cut. He called them atoms. He said this is what
everything in the world is made up of. So the Greeks, of course, and much of the known world
actually claim that Democritus is the first person to actually come up with the atomic theory
solely by the Daskodankan experiment, solely by thinking. Then Democritus wasn't finished with
that. He said hearing and sight are just illusions. It's a result of emanations bouncing off objects,
which become multiplied until they reach our ears. Does that make you think of sound and light waves?
So many scientists will say Democritus may in fact be the father of modern science.
He also gave, aside from that, he produced a correct explanation for eclipses,
and he's the first person to say the sun is just a fiery mass.
So this is basically Democritus. I like this quote that he has of Cosmos Skete.
The world is a stage. Life is a passage. You came, you saw, you exited. Does that remind you of
anybody know your Shakespeare? He also wrote about music, philology, the history of literature,
animal anatomy. This is a push to understand the Greek way of thinking, to understand how
to give rise to thinking as the philosophy as we know it today. I made a jump now because
they're called the Presocratics, and like I told you, that by no means in any way means that they
were in any way less intellectually gifted or capable or brilliant than Socrates or Plato or
Aristotle. But Socrates develops from the Presocratics. So he shifts this focus of
philosophy from the cosmology to the nature, to ethics and human conduct. And he starts for the
first time saying, we're asking questions, let's ask questions about virtue. And he builds on this
Presocratic move from myth to reason by using his so-called famous Socratic method of questioning
to understand the unexamined life. So this kind of lays the foundation for Western philosophy,
the focus on human knowledge and the self. So this is, by the way, up till now we've had very
few likenesses of the philosophers, except for the one by Anaximander. But here you have a portion
of Socrates from the first century, it's a Roman copy, but it's believed to be a lost bronze of a
copy made by Lysippos, who actually would have known it. So we have now, we move, so his focus
on ethics and self-knowledge affected his pupil, Plato. And Plato in turn taught Aristotle. And
they developed these ideas, and I guess you could argue they established the core of Western
philosophical thought. So this was called a herm, it's basically just kind of a slab of a statue of
Plato. I just wanted to include it. And Plato, in turn, we know, I told you he was traumatized by
the death of Socrates' beloved teacher. But he also was influenced by Socrates' focus on ethical
inquiry and the Socratic method. But he started developing his own comprehensive, I guess,
metaphysical philosophy. And he's especially famous for his theory of forms. And that sounds
very daunting, but it's actually quite simple. And so, I'll explain, I'll get into the theory
of forms in a moment. But he basically started having this ideal, this vision of what an ideal
state could be. So he's now no longer questioning how life evolved or looking at ethics. He's going
to the future. He's saying, how should things be? What is the best we can hope for? How can we
create an ideal state? And as I said before, he had this idea about philosopher kings leading the
way. And so Socrates might have sought wisdom through dialectics and focusing on the soul,
the human soul. Plato starts looking at the nature of reality, math, politics. And he builds
like this systematic and, I guess, broader philosophical system. He expands it. So the
idea of forms, I said I would try and get to it a bit. I'll try and make it simple. It really
says that there's an ultimate reality, which means that there's one world in which everything is
perfect, eternal, and unchanging. And it never changes, this perfect world. And he calls that
forms. That's the forms. He says, but the physical world that we actually live in,
that you and I all inhabit, that we smell, taste, see, touch, is actually just,
we're perceiving it. So it's already falling. We can't trust our senses. So it's an imperfect
and changing reflection. Let's use the word reflection very carefully, of these forms.
So the forms is what's actually there. And we basically just see a pale reflection of what's
actually there. But the forms, if we can ever understand them, is actually the true essence
of everything. And then he uses stronger words that are more difficult to picture, like justice
or beauty. But he says that true knowledge comes from searching for the true essence of forms,
not just through our senses, but through thinking. And again, we have this
thought. And I chose to show you this picture of Plato's cave. I don't know how many of you have
ever come across this. You probably have at some point, the story of a cave in which Plato explains
his theory of forms by saying, imagine prisoners seated in a cave, in prison, they're shackled,
and they're facing a wall. And behind them, people stand with lights. And puppeteers go and show
things. They show animals, people, and they make sounds of laughter, talking. And in the story of
the cave, Plato says, wouldn't those people or those prisoners think that that's actually the
reality of everything? Wouldn't they? Because they've never known anything else. And if somebody,
if one of the prisoners escaped and went to the outside world and saw the real world for what it
was, and came back and tried to explain it, wouldn't the other prisoners get angry at them
and say, what, you're crazy? What are you talking about? And wouldn't they get agitated as a result?
He's basically saying that's why Socrates was killed. And he says, but he says, the role of
a teacher is to come back out of the real world, out of the world, the true perception of the forms,
if you like, and explain it to everybody. So that's basically a short summation.
And here is, by the way, a depiction, an Arab depiction of Plato teaching his pupils.
And so in other words, under Islam, the Arabs revered Plato and Socrates and Aristotle.
And in fact, I just came back from Kyrgyzstan and Uzbekistan, and Bukhara and Uzbekistan
is actually where Ibn Sina taught. Ibn Sina was the most famous of all the Arab philosophers,
and he taught directly based on Plato, Aristotle, and Socrates, and developed his own way of
thinking, but based on that. And he in turn was one of the major influences on Maimonides in a
couple of centuries later, actually one century later. So I just wanted to include that to show
you that the Arabs themselves prized this thinking. So if we tried to ask to say, what are the
differences between Plato and Aristotle, who comes next? Aristotle, who is, as we know,
is famous for his being the tutor of Alexander the Great. Aristotle rejects the idea of this
physical and ideal form. Aristotle just says the ideal world and the real world and the actual
rewitness are inseparable. And he has this practical, realistic approach to understanding
reality. So Plato says true reality exists in an eternal, unchanging realm of the abstract.
And he says that the whole idea that Plato had of forms and the physical world is an imperfect
reflection, but still a true reflection of these forms. So Aristotle rejects Plato's
theories of the separate realm. And basically, Aristotle goes on to go into great detail about
everything he experiences in day-to-day life, be it medicine, be it theater, drama, poetry.
While Plato prioritizes abstract reason, Aristotle just says we have to use our sensory
experience and empirical observation. In many ways, he goes back to the priesthood products.
He says we need to use our senses to get as much information as we can.
And so that's basically a short, I guess, differentiation between the two. Plato's
method was rationalistic. Aristotle's was analytical. For Plato, reality was ideal.
And abstract, for Aristotle, it's concrete. Reality is concrete and observable.
So I promised we'll talk a little bit also about truth. So Plato believed
that you can only arrive at truth as in the ethical sense of good or bad. A lie is bad,
truth is good. It's rooted in the contemplating this idea of forms, especially the form of good.
So he says to be virtuous, to be a good person, you have to be able to contrast
your knowledge of this abstract universal ideal we're talking about through training in mathematics,
sciences, philosophy. And he says justice really is just harmony. You have to use your reason
and create a well-ordered state or universe. And that, by its own, by its bringing into reality,
makes actual justice. So harmony and justice is the same thing. So a life guided by this
understanding leads to self-control, makes a person consistently good, regardless of external
circumstances. So in other words, you have to contemplate for Plato the form that underlies
everything. Aristotle says ethics is a practical field, and you have to look at humans overall,
not on abstract universal truths. And he goes on to say that virtue is actually a habit.
It doesn't come apart. It's not just philosophy and contemplating things. You actually have to
develop your character through repeated actions and proper education. So that's where you get
the word the golden mean from, by the way. So virtues like courage, temperance, are found by
finding this kind of mean, this balance between the extremes of all kind of excess, of excess,
basically. So yeah, I'll leave you. I want to actually stop there for a moment,
because I wanted to hold on a second. I'm going to break this for a second. I'm going to stop my
screen sharing, because I wanted to actually give you a chance to ask questions. But I wanted to
to go back to the fact that I just came from Bukhara, Uzbekistan. And we lost, shortly after
these incredible discoveries of the Greeks, we went into our own, the West meaning we,
it went into its dark ages. And many of these remarkable findings of science thinking
were all lost to mankind. And they could have been lost forever. And one of the gifts
that Islam brought to the world was that, because it was such a new religion, it started
basically with the revelations of Muhammad in 610 Common Era. The Arabs, as I said, prized
Greek thought, especially Greek philosophy. And they set up schools as they started
their colonizing of the world, basically. They set up schools in Damascus, and in Bukhara,
and all over the known world, that actually transcribed all of the Greek thinking,
both Greek works and Latin. They had schools of translation that were run by, that were actually
led by amazing thinkers that were Jewish, Christian, Muslim, and otherwise, that would
actually transcribe and translate everything into Arabic. It's one of the reasons why we have all
these things today. And one of my takeaways from Bukhara, where I just was, was that's the place
where Ibn Sina was born. That's the place he was educated. And I was amazed that everything came
full circle for me there. I said, this is the reason, 100 years later, when Maimonides actually
had to flee Spain to Fez, in danger of his life, where he actually found sanctuary in Al-Qurayn,
which is one of the oldest, it is the oldest university in the world, where he basically
wrote The Guide to the Perplexed. And many of his other great works were started there,
composed there. And his base, his, he leaned heavily on Ibn Sina, and al-Farabi, and many of
these Islamic thinkers that were directly influenced by the philosophers we're speaking
about right now. And I wanted to make sure that we understand our own relationship with all this
heady Greek stuff that we've been delving so heavily into. This is really ours as well,
and we can get into that on a later date. Thank you. Wow, that was quite a less than one hour
tour of philosophy. I wish I had had that when I took a philosophy class in college,
because I had no idea what they were talking about for a whole semester, because no one
set the foundation. So thank you. Now I can go back in my time machine and take that class.
I understand. Absolutely. And I'll make some other changes too, while I'm back there. Don't
worry, everybody. Don't worry. So I guess one question is just, was on Plato. Did Plato say
that you can, that certain people like Plato can observe the forms and then teach the rest of us
about them, or that no one can really observe that? No, he believes you can get close to it,
very close to it. I believe he actually more or less says you can, and that once you do,
it's the duty of that person to teach others. He believes that it's teachable.
So it's a, so if your question is, did he believe you could actually view all the forms?
Probably not, but he believed you can get close and that, and that it was, and once you do,
it changes, it changes you forever. Both the person, so he has the first person who gets out
of the cave, which he presumably talking about himself is dazzled. He can't handle it. It's,
he almost goes crazy from the sheer, the sheer sensory overload of realizing what really,
what's really out there. Of course, the movie, The Matrix is based on that as well.
So he, so yeah, basically that's your answer. And how does this connect to like the Jewish
mystical tradition, right? The story of the four who go into the Pardes. I assume they're going to
understand the form, right? And then they come back and only one of them can teach. The rest
either go crazy, commit suicide. I mean, I'm sorry, die by suicide or, so is that connected?
Is that it? I mean, there's, I've seen, there's many countless essays written about that,
and I do believe they're very, they're very connected. The closer you get, by the way,
all types of mysticism, whether it's Kabbalah or Sufi, they all leave the whole, they leave the
whole idea of the existence of, Muhammad's not important, for instance. They all go into this
greater meaning of what, of what, of what it's all about. And it's, and it frequently touches
on these greater philosophical ideas versus, versus an actual question of believing or not
believing. That's, that's almost irrelevant. Terrific stuff. I saw a question. So you,
you asked, you posed the question to us. You said, were these early philosophers,
and even the later, the post-Socratic philosophers, were they really scientists,
right? So the question is, were there actually scientists at the same time that you had these
thinkers, or were the, because if not, then these thinkers were definitely the scientists of their
day. But were there other people analyzing questions in a more scientific method, or does
that come way later? And therefore, you, you know what I mean? Were, was there someone sitting in
the room next to a pre-philosopher, but they were analyzing something in a way that we would call
science? Right. Well, you know, you had Pythagoras, right? I didn't mention, at the
same time period, it was pre-Socratic, right? Where, where everything was about numbers. He
said everything was numbers. They were all, for in my mind, they were all scientists. They based
everything on, on observation, and they, they were not, they did not treat anything foolish lightly.
Like everything had to be explained, rational, reason. They welcomed dispute, and they, and they,
and they were, they were pursuing, they were pursuing, they were pursuing it deeper and
greater and true understanding. In my mind, the word, the word philosophy doesn't apply to them.
We should call them scientists. Yes, that, that sounds like it, based on the way you presented it.
So there was obviously pushback to the pre-Socratic, even Socratic thinkers in,
in the society, because the society was based on mythology, understanding the world one way.
When, when did it shift that? When did you get people saying, ah, we are going to now
put mythology in a certain category, and we will now proceed with science and philosophy?
Because, I mean, Socrates was, was, was, he died because he asked too many questions, right? He
wouldn't stop. Right. They say that was a trump of charge, basically, right? Because the way,
the way the Greeks worked, as I said, it's a riddle we're trying to solve together, what
you're asking. The way the Greeks worked is they come, is they compartmentalized everything,
and they, and they gave everything its due. So, for instance, Apollo, the god Apollo,
represented rationality, and logic, and cool logic, and they worshipped him. He was a god.
Another god, Dionysus, represented passion, unrestrained passion, and madness, and lust,
and they worshipped him too. And they, and they had their, and they were given their due.
I think that the Greeks were unique in that, in that they could look at everything with full
interest and give it its full. So if someone said, we don't believe in gods, or this is another,
another idea we can have like this one, they give that, they give that its due as well.
And that's, and there's, there's something unique about that, about that giving everything its
place, and it's, and it's, and it's individual respect, that I believe, that I believe never
led to real pushback. Aside from the idea that if you say there's no gods altogether,
that could be problematic. But if you said there's another reason gods don't look the way
you say they look, there's only one god, not many gods, or you're, there was, there was room for
everything, basically. And the Greeks always seem to have had that. So your question is,
I don't think there was a period where it actually changed. I think, I think that,
that it basically, they just, they just welcomed, they welcomed the continuing discussion all,
all the way through. I have, I have one more thing I want to add really quickly to that.
So in many, you can argue that in many ways, it devolves. I'll take back what I said slightly.
If you read the, the, the epic work, the Iliad works, the Iliad and the Odyssey,
the character of Odysseus, he's cunning, he's sneaky, he's wily, but he's also a hero. He's
a genuine hero. He's strong, he fights, he wins. And the later, later Greeks didn't like that.
They had to, they had to make him an outright villain because he's so sneaky and cunning.
And so they basically said, you can't have it all. But I see the, the epic works in the Iliad
and the Odyssey saying you can be very complex. Poly, they call Odysseus polytropos, a man of
many, many forms. Emily Wilson, I believe the translator we recommended for the Odyssey,
just calls him a complicated man. But, but the point is, if we look at Jacob in the Bible,
in the, you have, you have the cunning guy who, who, who tricks his brother of his birthright.
And the hero fights off all the shepherds who are, who are, who are oppressing Rachel and Leah at
the well. So you have, you have these interested multifaceted characters. And yeah, I just wanted
to get that out there while we're discussing. So, um, we're almost out of time. Give us a
promo for next week, which I think is the last session in the series, which could go on for a
long time. I know that we can give many more series. And I think we may do one extra one,
but what, what's coming up the stage of humanity, what are we going to do there?
So, so we had a perfect quote today for the stage, didn't we? All the men and women,
all the world's a stage and all the men, we basically had a, uh, I hope most of you got
the reference. So, um, next week, basically, remember, I told you that the Greeks gave
everything it's due. So, but yet that doesn't take away from the fact they were, they did,
they were deeply spiritual people. And when they, when they read from their works of Hesiod and
Homer, uh, and they had, uh, they had festivals and they would have just like at the Jewish temple,
they have rituals and, and there'll be chanted and then there'd be a sacrifice afterward.
So the, uh, the, so the song, uh, we, we call it an English ode, an ode, odos to sing and, uh,
and shragos is, um, is goat. So the word tragedy comes from goat song. You had, you, you had your
davening, you had your minion, you had like, uh, you know, you, you prayed, you, you, you, uh,
you discussed, uh, the sins and the good deeds, and then you sacrifice at the end of it to, uh,
you sacrifice for human sins. So tragedy, all it means is goat song, uh, basically.
So what the Greeks did is they, uh, the ancient Greeks did is they had their ritual, they had
the chazan, the guy coming up chanting, then they had their sacrifice. And then one, and then one
guy, when he was in the middle of chanting, he said, this is getting boring. Uh, he says, as,
as I'm, as I'm talking about, uh, about, about Odysseus and Achilles, uh, you, um, let's, let's
let's call this guy Festus, because he, that's real name, come and be Achilles. So he starts
singing and try to pretend it's, uh, it's, it's the Torah. I'm singing Moses and I make, I make,
uh, Ari Aueron. Okay, now you're going to be Aueron. And he, and he answers me. And that's,
and Festus becomes the name for Thespian, the very first actor. And that's basically how you
have the beginnings of, of theater, the invention of theater happening. Basically they, they put on
a Torah reading and they, and they added actors to it at the same time on the stage. And they
still have to sacrifice after it was all over. That's my promo. Okay. So we're looking forward
to that. And now, if I remember, I will share the Saturday night live skit from last year,
which was called the first ever theater in Greece, right? Remember where people are sitting down and
they don't know what to, they don't know what's going on because people are acting and it's a
joke on like the audience and the actors. So I thought it was pretty funny. Okay. Yeah. Is that
it? So you're going to be, where are you going to, where are you going to come to us live from
next week? Do we know? I will be here again. I'm, I'm here for the, because as I said,
my son is, he's getting drafted to the Navy, so I'll be around. Okay. Again, pass on our regards
to him and we're wishing him safety and mostly safety, I guess, but also learning, I guess,
learning and safety. Yeah. Safety first for him. Thank you everybody. Okay. David, I'll talk to
you soon. Thank you all for joining us today. See you next week. Bye for now. Great stuff.
I'm, I'm actually working on it right now. All right. Bye for now.
