The Messed Up Origins of Mermaids

Truth exists
11 followers
Modern day mermaids are known for three things. Their musical talents, for guiding sailors out
of dangerous waters, and their tendency to create questionable crushes.
You don't think sharks are sexy, do you? No. Wait a minute, what was a little mermaid?
But the mermaids that you and I are familiar with, who show up in our cartoons and children's books,
are a heavily sanitized simplification of their feathered and fishtailed ancestors.
These supposedly innocent ocean maidens are the descendants of soulless spirits,
demons who lured seafarers to their doom. And today, I am breaking down the history,
mythology, and folklore that contributed to their evolution.
But first, I gotta warn you that mermaid lore is as deep as the ocean floor,
and you might not like what you find at the bottom.
Now, it's a misconception that all it takes to be a mermaid is to have a fishtail with a
human body. But I'm here to tell you that... hold on a second. So that is all it takes to be a
mermaid? Well, I wish you told me that sooner. For real though, if you look at the definition
of mermaid in Webster's Dictionary, all it says is a fabled marine creature with the head and
upper body of a woman and the tail of a fish. And naturally, the etymological roots are even
more vague. It's a combination of the middle English words mere, meaning sea or ocean,
and maid, meaning girl. So, ocean girl. There are also ocean boys, or mer-men, I guess you'd call
them. Nobody's ever called me a mer-man before. But they usually play second fiddle to mermaids
and tend to only show up in stories where mermaids live in a society of mer-people. So,
we're focusing on mermaids today. Middle English was primarily spoken in, you guessed it,
middle-age England. And the earliest use of the word mermaid in writing can be found in a
Geoffrey Chaucer poem called The Nun's Priest's Tale, written in 1390. But just because they coined
the term mermaid doesn't mean they invented the idea of a fish-female hybrid. Figures like this
existed in cultures all over Europe, Asia, and Africa. They just went by different names,
might have looked different, or even acted entirely different. But if all we care about
is fitting that broad definition of half-female, half-fish, then the oldest example of a mermaid
is the Syrian fertility goddess, Atargatis. And Diodorus Siculus, the ancient Greek historian
born in 1st century Sicily, is credited with capturing the most detailed description of her.
But I would hardly call it detailed. All he says is that she has the face of a woman and
otherwise the entire body of a fish. Unless they're talking about his interpretation of
her backstory where Aphrodite curses her with an infatuation for a mortal,
she lets him get her pregnant, then out of shame tries to kill the baby, and then out of shame for
that throws herself off a cliff only to be transformed into the fish person that you see
before you. As we established though, all of these examples existed independently of mermaids,
and it's pretty unlikely that they had any influence on mermaid lore. Some experts theorize
that Atargatis must be related to England's mermaids because she looks so much like one,
but by that logic, Gunther would have decided from seals instead of wolves. Sometimes,
appearances can be deceiving, so we'd have to know more about her to say for sure,
but that information just doesn't exist. And speaking of deceiving appearances,
the legacy of mermaids goes back even further than Diodorus' writings to one of the most well
known and studied of the ancient Greek myths. But it may not be the one you think.
Because if you're anything like me, you assumed that mermaids descended from,
or were at least cousins to, the Sirens and Homer's Iliad. Both have reputations for being
kinda hot fish women that lure sailors to their death, so the connection is about as
obvious as it gets. Only, Sirens weren't fish women. They were birds. I'm sure that some of
you watching are rolling your eyes at my naivete, but it's been so long since I read the
Odyssey that I honestly forgot that Sirens don't look like mermaids at all. If you look at the
artwork from ancient Greece, like the vases and plates, you'll see that they were exclusively
depicted as part female, part bird, with the precise ratio evidently being up to interpretation.
Meanwhile, poets like Ovid and Pseudo-Apollodorus describe Sirens as having the feathers and legs
of birds. I know I'm not the only one who's made this mistake, though. Because when you google
image Siren mythology, the results are split between avian and aquatic depictions. And in
my opinion, it's reasonable to assume that sea nymphs like Sirens would look fish-like.
Edwardian era artists evidently agreed with this point, too. It's hard to pinpoint exactly when the
conflation of Sirens and mermaids started happening, but this manuscript from 1754
calls what is obviously a fish lady a Siren. And then you have Herbert James Draper's 1909
painting that depicts Odysseus and company being lured by mermaid-like beings. So by this point,
the terms were clearly being used interchangeably. Not to mention, there are legends that
long before this, there was more than one famous seafarer who encountered mermaids during their
travels. But more on them later. Despite Sirens not actually inhabiting the ocean, or looking like
they do, their role in the Odyssey was no doubt influential in how people perceived aquatic
entities. But as I alluded to earlier, this isn't the only significant myth in the mermaids' legacy.
More marine deities known for their danger and mystique are the Nyads of Greek myth,
who occupy bodies of freshwater as opposed to seawater. They show up in the Argonautica,
which tells the story of the hero Jason's quest for the Golden Fleece, and they lure one of his
companions, Hylus, into a lake, and he is never seen or heard from again.
This isn't to say that all the aquatic entities in Greek myth were dangerous. In fact, many marine
deities existed solely to protect sailors and fishermen, like Glaucus, who happened to be
half-fish himself. But he was a merman, so we don't give a ---- about him. When Glaucus wasn't
available, the Nereids filled in as protectors and guides. Not to be confused with the similarly
named Nyads mentioned a moment ago, the Nereids lived in the ocean, and according to Pliny the
Elder, looked exactly like normal women, but covered head to toe in scales. These sea nymphs
personified various facets of the sea, like the salty brine, sand, rocks, and sea foam.
And like modern day mermaids, they were often depicted mingling with marine life,
riding dolphins or hippocampi, and holding fish in their hands. They also show up in the
Argonautica to lead Jason and the Argonauts through rock-filled waters that would have
destroyed their ship. So you can already see the two sides of the modern day mermaid's reputation
taking shape in these ancient myths. While Greek mythology had a variety of humanoid aquatic
entities, they weren't all good or bad, and this dichotomy made its way into the mermaid lore of
middle England, where their intentions depended on the setting, the story, and storyteller,
who might be sharing an old folktale, warning his flock, or recounting his own encounter with the
fabled femme fish fatales. First though, if you've watched my personal updates,
then you already know that I have had a lot of doctor's appointments over the past couple of
years. And at the start of my medical mystery adventure, it was genuinely maddening trying to
find specialists who were in my network, within driving distance, and actually had enough
availability that I could squeeze in an appointment before the apocalypse. That's where ZocDoc came
through to save my sanity, and this was years ago before they were even a sponsor. ZocDoc is a free,
life-changing app and website that helps you find and book high-quality doctors in your network,
using their database of 150,000 providers across all 50 states so you can find your perfect match.
They've got almost all the medical fields covered, dermatology, dentistry, primary care, eye care,
orthopedics, endocrinology, and you're even able to choose between in-person or virtual visits,
whatever fits your schedule the best. Before using ZocDoc, there were so many times where I'd call
a doctor's office to schedule an appointment just to be put on hold for 20 minutes or find
out that the scheduling office closed early that day. ZocDoc is available to book appointments
instantly whenever you need it, whether you cut your finger making a midnight snack or you're
doom-scrolling your symptoms at 3 a.m. like I do. They make the process so easy that there is
genuinely no reason to put off your doctor's appointments anymore. Just go to ZocDoc.com
to find and instantly book a top-rated doctor today. That's Z-O-C-D-O-C dot com slash JohnSolo.
This message is sponsored by ZocDoc. So far, I've focused solely on the mermaid's mythical origins,
but the problem is, even the myths that we discussed referenced events that supposedly
happened hundreds, if not thousands of years before they were written down. While the majority
of ancient Greeks believed Nereids and Nyads and Sirens existed at one point,
there's no telling how common it was to think they were still around during the Iron Age,
or if they'd already evolved into something that closely resembled mermaids. And while we know for
a fact that sailors shared stories about seeing mermaids on their travels, the closest thing that
we have to a first-hand account from one of those sailors is Chris Columbus's journal,
but that wasn't written until the 1400s. So there's this huge middle chunk of the timeline
where we know the general public, or at least seafaring societies, believed in some kind of
ocean-dwelling female entity. We just don't know the specifics, and we have to figure them out
one piece at a time. So when I started researching for this episode alongside our resident folklorist
Jack Daly, who you should totally subscribe to on YouTube, by the way, I asked what traits and
behaviors are mermaids known for, because those are probably a good indicator of how people
thought about them back in the day. And the first trait that came to my mind was their association
with music. Some of you might have been expecting me to just jump to them drowning sailors because
I'm Mr. Morbid Curiosity, but in my defense, my older sister was obsessed with the Part of Your
World song from The Little Mermaid, and my daughter's got this board book about some
mermaids getting ready for a concert that we read at least twice a day. So that's right where my mind
goes. It's a pretty cool book though. Look, you can make her change outfits. Listen, I'm really tired.
Similar to their association with danger, I think the mermaids' musical talent partially stems from
their siren ancestors, who were known for making such beautiful music that it could put the most
stoic of Greek kings into a trance. More evidence of this lies in that Chaucer poem I mentioned
earlier. Written in 1390, the character references mermaid singing talent as it's described by the
Physiologus, an even older text that interpreted the natural world through the lens of Christian
morality. Plants, stones, and animals both real and imaginary, although they didn't realize these
animals were imaginary. And while Chaucer says the Physiologus describes mermaids as good singers,
all of the translations opt to call them sirens, not mermaids, meaning the terms have been used
interchangeably since the 14th century at the latest. Which actually segues nicely to their
second most well-known attribute, danger. And there's more to this than just the siren and
earlier, although it is all connected. Because while sailors have been warning each other about
the alluring calls of women on the water for millennia, it wasn't until Christianity came
around that mermaids, sirens, and everything in between went from simply being dangerous
to downright demonic. This was the case with a lot of the mythical creatures of religions past,
though. If the church didn't understand a pagan tradition and couldn't find a way to rebrand it
as their own like they did with the unicorn and phoenix, they usually labeled it as evil,
sinful, or a machination of Satan. And they told people to avoid such temptations like
I avoid the street corner that your mother works on. Their warnings about mermaids specifically
were both literal and allegorical. There was, of course, the very real threat of dying at sea
should you try to follow one and wrap your ship around some rocks, but they also symbolized
temptation and sexual danger. A siren trying to lure Odysseus off the path is like a temptress
seducing a married man. Only instead of wrecking his ship, he'd wreck his marriage and probably
the rest of his life along with him. He would die a different kind of death. The allure of mermaids
along with their roots in pagan tradition meant that in the public eye, mermaids could not only
kill you, they could contaminate your soul and ruin your chances at everlasting bliss in heaven.
So, fellas, for the literal love of God, don't try to stick it in one.
I'm not going to. Good, because if you did, you would rip your dick off.
What I find funny, though, is that despite all these warnings and allegiance about mermaids
being dangerous, the two most famous mermaid encounters that we have on record are as
uneventful as it gets. In 1492, Columbus sailed the Ocean Blue, and in 1493, he was still sailing
it. One of his journal entries, dated January 9, 1493, mentions that one of his admirals claimed
to have seen mermaids on more than one occasion. Apparently, those mermaids weren't as beautiful
as they were in paintings he'd seen, but they did have a somewhat human face.
Sounds like me trying to give your mom a compliment.
A little over a hundred years later, John Smith also wrote about seeing a mermaid.
Except that he didn't. Yeah, man, while Smith's first-hand account of witnessing a green-haired
mermaid swimming in the ocean has been widely circulated through 19th century literature,
folklore, and the internet, the truth is the passage is a complete fabrication.
It's false. It never happened. It's a total fabrication.
Historian Vaughn Scribner did some serious detective work and determined the original
author of John Smith's mermaid encounter was none other than Alexander Dumas,
the guy who wrote The Three Musketeers. In an article dated September 29, 1849,
and published in a newspaper called the Gazette of the Union, Dumas evidently made up the story
about John Smith writing about his mermaid encounter to legitimize the mermaid story
he had written, which is funny because now we know that Smith was a notorious liar,
so even if he did claim he saw a mermaid, I would trust him about as much as I would
trust Darth Vader to babysit. I'm getting sidetracked, though.
As effective as the church's campaign against the old ways was, there came a point a few
centuries later where Europe's citizens started to get curious about the abandoned beliefs,
which makes sense. After the Age of Enlightenment that went real strong from 1687 to 1789 and
promoted things like logic, reason, empirical evidence, and the scientific method, in other
came the Romanticism movement, which you might remember also played a role in the
messed up origins of fairies that I covered a few weeks ago. To paraphrase Clara MacGuffin's
excellent blog post that I cited in that episode, Romanticism emerged in the late 1700s,
and people got obsessed with folklore and the mystery of nature. The Age of Enlightenment was
so grounded in raw reality that the public started yearning for the fantastic, the mythical,
the stuff that couldn't be explained with science or mathematics. By the late 1800s,
folklore was established as a field of study and taken up by lawyers, scholars, and even clergymen
who became the first people to record their country's folk traditions in writing. Now I
gotta mention, there were some crafty entrepreneurs that found new ways to capitalize and monetize
this newfound interest, like P.T. Barnum who displayed a supposed mermaid skeleton in his
museum. And I am not exaggerating when I say this thing is straight up nightmare fuel,
made worse by the fact that advertisements showed a traditional sea maiden,
not a baby monkey carcass sewed to a fish, which is what this was.
Hilariously, Barnum crafted an entire fictional backstory for this thing, like he did with a lot
the oddities on display, and he claimed it was caught near the Fiji Islands in the South Pacific
and that it had previously been on display at the London Lyceum of Natural History,
which didn't even exist. Now, to a certain extent, belief in mermaids persists to this day.
You might be surprised by that, but it's understandable when you have trusted sources
like Animal Planet airing very convincing mockumentaries that present mermaids like
they're a newfound discovery. They aired specials like this back in 2012 and 2013,
and viewers bought into them hook, line, and sinker. Really? Nothing? Anyway, after these
specials aired and Animal Planet enjoyed its highest viewership ever by lying its ass off
to millions of people, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration was forced to
release a statement declaring that there was no new evidence that mermaids existed,
in response to viewers bombarding them with calls wanting to know if the mockumentaries were legit.
But even back in the 1800s, most people understood that mermaids were a product of
myths and folktales told by sailors who spent most of their time at sea, starving, dehydrated,
overworked, and lacking human contact, so they weren't the most reliable narrators.
I say this confidently because theories attempting to rationalize what sailors like
Columbus' Admiral saw can be traced as far back as 1893. There's a footnote in a translation of
Chris Columbus' journal by Clemens Markham where he states matter-of-factly that what they really
saw was a manatee, and he goes on to explain how a manatee's shape could be mistaken for a human's.
At first, I thought that sounded ridiculous because how could anyone think that a manatee
looks like a human? But when you think about the mindset that those sailors were in,
and you consider some of the straight-up ogres that folks go home with after a few too many drinks,
and it makes perfect sense.
But I'd be a madman and a dumbass if I went this whole episode without mentioning the most
famous mermaid story of all time, The Little Mermaid by Hans Christian Andersen,
which introduced into literature the idea that mermaids don't have souls.
For those unfamiliar with the story, it follows a little mermaid who's curious about the human
world and wants more than anything to earn a human soul so she can ascend to heaven when she dies.
Yeah, a little deeper than Disney's version. Andersen establishes that mermaids can live
up to 300 years, but since they lack souls, there is no afterlife. Once they die, they die,
and the only way to prevent this was for a human to fall in love with her and pledge himself to her,
effectively sharing his soul with her. When Disney adapted it, they simplified her desire
for spiritual completeness so she just wanted to be a human being and live a human life.
But why did Andersen take away her soul in the first place? Where did that idea come from?
Well, I might have to revisit The Little Mermaid's origins a second time,
because while researching for this episode, we learned that Andersen was inspired by a
German fairy tale called Undine, where a water spirit marries a knight so she can gain a soul.
But there's no doubt that he was also heavily influenced by his Christian faith. Theologians
as far back as 600 CE debated whether non-human beings like animals, fairies,
mermaids, and other monstrous creatures had souls. And the consensus was, nah, they didn't.
And in the 1500s, it was firmly established by Paracelsus's treatise that nature spirits
like the Undine may resemble a human in every way except for their possession of a soul.
So Andersen just followed the lore that was established by his faith.
And when you think about it, it kind of makes sense that the mermaids of legend,
and monsters like them, wouldn't have souls. That might be what allows them to commit such
purely evil acts like luring sailors to their doom without regret or guilt weighing down their
conscience. And while Andersen's mermaids are definitely not monsters who intentionally hurt
humans, they do play a disturbing role in sailors' deaths. Because if they see a ship
that's about to sink or in the process of, they will sing to the sailors about how great it is
to live underwater so they won't be scared when they drown. Which in theory is nice,
but the last thing that I want to hear while my lungs fill with salt water is some fish lady
singing seductively in my ear that it's better down where it's wetter. Either be a Jamaican
crab or get the hell out of here. Anyway, I think that Andersen's story was basically the best PR
that mermaids could have asked for. Because while the tide had already started turning with the rise
of romanticism a few decades before he wrote The Little Mermaid, and the reverence that creatures
like them were now being given, they still would have been seen exclusively as femme fatales,
the oceanic equivalent of fairies like the Lianenshi in La Belle Dame Sans Mercie, who seduce
men before sucking out their souls. But when he turned The Little Mermaid human, he turned her
from something to fear to someone to cheer on, someone you felt sorry for when she sacrificed
her life at the end of the story. And once that version of a mermaid existed, there was no going
back. Thanks to him, painters and poets, and the animators that came long after them, mermaids are
now known for their grace, beauty, and fragility. They represent freedom, curiosity, and adventure,
and this perception of them is now so entrenched in our culture that seeing them portrayed any
other way is a subversion of expectations, and sometimes a messy one.
