What Does This Generation Mean For Historical Premil Pheelan McPhelan?
#lastdays #armageddon #endtimes #eschatology #preterism #rapture #israel #jerusalem #america #dispensationalism
What does "this generation" mean relative to Jesus' prophecy in Matthew 24:34? According to McPhalen, it does not refer to the passing of the first century generation.
His explanation is novel to me, but you may judge for yourself his position. We show why this verse remains a staple in the preterist imminent texts.
Hello ladies and gentlemen, welcome back to All Things Fulfill, and in this video we're going to
talk about another point from Phelan McPhelan, who is a historical premillennialist. He has made
several arguments to claim that the reason Christ has not come and all things have been fulfilled
is because of some contingencies that took place through the rebellion or lack of faith on the part
of the Jews. And one of the arguments that he makes is on Matthew chapter 24 and verse 34.
In this particular argument, he says that this generation will not pass away does not mean
that they would not pass away by extinction, as all other generations passed away. Rather,
he says it means that they passed away because they lost their religious headship.
Now there are lots of people who come up with different ideas about what Matthew 24-34 means
because they understand how powerful a text it is and how clear and how simple the text is without
us having to try to interpret it. Just read it and accept it or reject it. And so many futurists
choose to reject it. Now some will apply it to 70 AD, but they'll think that the rest of the context
refers to the future. But you have those like Philaen, who was a historical premillennialist,
that rejects it. Some people will say, well, you know, it wasn't written in English,
it was written in Aramaic. And the Aramaic word for generation doesn't mean the same thing as the
Greek. Or they'll say, well, you need to read it in Hebrew because it doesn't mean the same thing
as it does in English. But you know, they don't have a problem with Matthew 23 and verse 36
that says all of these things will come upon this generation. They know that that would come upon
that generation before it was or became extinct. Even noted premillennial dispensationalists who
will agree to that. But when they get down to verse 34, historical premillennialists and
dispensational premillennialists will say, well, it doesn't mean that in this particular verse.
So what are we going to do with the verse saying that it just meant that their religious leadership
or headship was cut off, doesn't cut the mustard. And we're going to give you some reasons why
that's the case. First of all, all that means is that they were cut off from the covenant. If they
lost their religious headship, that just means they were cut off from the covenant. Now, how
does that change what Jesus said? In other words, that this generation will not be cut off from the
covenant until all things written are fulfilled. Philo needs to tell us when the first century
Jews, when Israel was cut off. I can give you a couple of passages that would tell us when that
occurred. Let's take a look, for example, at this text, Matthew 8, 11 and 12. And I say to you
that many will come from east and west and sit down with Abraham, Isaac and Jacob in the kingdom
of heaven. But the sons of the kingdom will be cast out into outer darkness. They will be weeping
and gnashing of teeth. Well, there's a cutting away or not just of their religious headship,
but of all those who rebel against Christ. Isn't that also precisely what Moses predicted for
their last days in Acts, the third chapter, starting in verse 22. Notice what Peter said
for Moses truly said to the fathers, the Lord, your God will raise up for you a prophet like me
from your brethren. Now, wait a minute. Moses said that God was going to raise up a prophet
for Israel from among their brethren who would be like him. But he said,
him shall you hear in all things, whatever he says to you. Now, who was that prophet?
None other than Jesus Christ. When did that occur in the first century? Now watch the next statement.
And it shall be that every soul who will not hear that prophet shall be utterly destroyed from among
the people. So he's telling them this would take place in that generation. How do we know that?
Because in verse 21, well, even before 21, let's read verse 24. Yes. And all the prophets
from Samuel and those who follow as many as have spoken have also foretold these days.
Those were the days of Jesus and his apostles. And hence, verse 21, whom heaven must receive
until the times of restoration of all things, which God has spoken by the mouth of all his
prophets since the age began. That's the same concept of Matthew 24, 34. It's saying the heavens
would receive Christ until the times of restoration of all things, which God spoke by the mouth of
all his holy prophets since the age began. You see, we can understand one generation comes,
another passes, but the earth abides forever from Ecclesiastes 1, 4. We can understand Matthew 1,
17. All the generations from Abraham to David are 14 generations. From David until the captivity
in Babylon are 14 generations. And from the captivity of Babylon unto the Christ are 14
generations. So what happened? One generation came, passed away. Another generation followed
them, passed away. And another generation followed them all the way down to Christ.
But what do you think happened to the generation in Christ's day? It passed away as well,
just like all of the previous ones. And hence, this is what Moses said. Let's take a look at
1 Peter chapter 1. 1 Peter 1, beginning at verse 10, Peter says, concerning the salvation,
the prophets have inquired and searched carefully. Who prophesied of the grace that would come to
you? He's writing to people in his generation. And he says, searching what? Or what manner of time?
So they wanted to know what the manner of these prophecies were and how they were going
to be fulfilled. And they also wanted to know the time. And Peter tells them in the verse,
he says, the spirit of Christ who was in them was indicating. So what manner and what manner
of time was the spirit of Christ? That means they were inspired by God, not to lie. The spirit of
Christ who was in them was indicating when he testified beforehand, what? The sufferings of
Christ. Now, did that occur in the first century? Of course it did. We just pointed that out.
And the glories that would follow. And on this glories that would follow, if we go to 1 Peter
5, I'll be right back in a moment. And look at verse 1. Here's what Peter said about the glories
that would follow. He says, the elders who are among you, I exhort. I, who am a fellow elder
and a witness of the sufferings of Christ. So same subject as in chapter 1. And also a partaker
of the glory that is about to be revealed. The word mellow is used here and it means to be about
to occur. So when you go back to 1 Peter 1 and read verse 11, that says,
when he testified beforehand of the sufferings of Christ and the glories that would follow,
we should read this the same way that we read 1 Peter 5 and verse 1. And the glories that were
about to follow, what were they about to follow? The sufferings of Christ. Now let's see if the
next verse bears that out. To them, it was revealed, that is to the prophets. It was revealed
that not to themselves. Why? Because you know, when the prophecies ended basically with Malachi
and we have this gap between the period of Malachi for about 400 years. And then when
John the Baptist comes on the scene, the scripture says the law and the prophets were until John.
But since that time, the kingdom of heaven is preached and every man presses into it.
So starting with John, you have the preaching of the kingdom. But notice the scripture says,
to them it was revealed that not to themselves, but to us. Who's the us there? The people living
in the first century. How do we know? Because it says they were ministering the things which
now have been reported to you through those who have preached the gospel to you by the Holy Spirit
sent from heaven, things which angels desire to look into. The Holy Spirit was poured out
on the day of Pentecost. Acts 2, 16 through 20. And it continued to the end of the age. Matthew
28, 20. First Corinthians 1, 6 through 8, which is the coming of Christ by the way. And he says
these things were now reported. That three little or three letter word says now. Peter
didn't indicate that, oh, it can't be now because the Jews didn't believe. But we see
precisely what the word of God says. And so there you have it. He says these things happen
in their time. Now, if we go to Hebrews chapter 7, we will see how and in what circumstances
the headship was taken away. The headship of Israel was their priesthood. They were the rulers.
So the scripture says, therefore, if perfection, but through the Levitical priesthood,
he's going to give you the reason why that headship was taken away for under it, the people
received the law. That means the people were in subjection to the law through the priesthood.
He says, what further need was there that another priest should rise according to the
order of Melchizedek and not be called according to the order of Aaron? Why are you going to change
the priesthood if everything is going to be the same as it always has been? But watch for the
priesthood being changed. Why was it being changed? Because there was no perfection under it.
No perfection under the Levitical priesthood, doesn't matter how hard and how loud people
stand on the street corners and shout, you got to obey the law in order to be saved.
The scripture says there was no perfection under the old law and perfection in first
Peter one and verse nine is defined as the salvation of the soul. So he says, if salvation
of the soul were through the Levitical priesthood, for under it the people received the law,
what further need was there that another priest should rise according to the order of Melchizedek
and not be called according to the order of Aaron? For the priesthood being changed,
why was it changed? Because there was no perfection. Of necessity, there is also a
change of the law. Now watch how the headship changed. He says, for he of whom these things
are spoken belongs to another tribe from which no man has officiated at the altar. So it couldn't
have been anything related to the old covenant because they all officiated at the altar,
for it is evident that our Lord arose from Judah. Isn't that a different priesthood than
the priesthood of Aaron? Of which tribe Moses spoke nothing concerning the priesthood. So
there's the headship that has changed. That's God cutting off their headship,
cutting off the Levitical priesthood, exchanging it for the priesthood of Judah.
So what does that mean? For on the one hand there is an annulling, bringing to an end,
dismantling of the former commandment because of its weakness and unprofitableness. For the
law made nothing perfect. On the other hand, there is the bringing in of a better hope
through which we draw nigh to God or near to God. So it was this hope through Jesus Christ
that brought about the perfection. Hebrews 10 and verse 9 says,
Then he said, Behold, I have come to do your will, O God. He takes away the first that he
may establish the second. So he took away the one that couldn't bring about perfection.
When we look in 2 Corinthians chapter 3, the verse is 7. He says, But if the ministry of
death written and engraved on stones was glorious so that the children of Israel could not look
steadily at the face of Moses because of the glory of his countenance, which glory was passing away,
how will the ministry of the Spirit not be more glorious? Now watch this. Verse 17,
Now the Lord is the Spirit, and where the Spirit of the Lord is, there is liberty.
So stop letting these people drag you back into bondage and place you under the law. Now that's
not what Macphailin does, but his doctrine does it because he's arguing that everything hasn't
been fulfilled. And that's the consequence of that doctrine, even though it applies to others
who make that their major theme and mantra. But he says, For if what is passing away,
that's the glorious, as he said, was glorious. What is remaining is much more glorious. Therefore,
since we have such hope, we use great boldness of speech. Well, that was their hope in the
century. It's now a fulfilled hope. They were changed, transformed into the same image,
the image of Christ, from glory to glory, just as by the Spirit of the Lord. And so from that
perspective, those things have been fulfilled. The Bible says that God would take the kingdom
from them and give it to a nation, bringing forth the fruits of it. And once again,
when that temple fell, that's when God brought judgment on those in the first century,
and that generation has passed away. It's gone extinct. But he says, Assuredly, I say to you,
this generation will by no means pass away till all these things take place. That was the
generation in the first century.

![All Things Fulfilled [William Bell]](https://image1-us-east.cloudokyo.cloud/image/v14/92/5a/58/925a58c5-a7c4-4453-ba43-2ac6ab552a6f/672.webp)