The Origin of Mermaids | Myths & History

Truth exists
11 followers
Mermaids. Upper body and head of a human, tail of a fish. Not to be confused with sirens,
although over time those have evolved to be a similar thing to a mermaid. Originally to the
ancient Greeks, though, sirens were basically birds with the head of a human. Whatever.
The question is, though, are they sinister creatures that lure sailors and ships to their
doom? Or do they really just want to be part of our world? Welcome to Curious People Wanted.
I'm Dr. Darren Raymond Locke, curator of the Barnum Museum. So you all know we have a mermaid
in our collection, but it is a reconstruction of the one Barnum owned that was destroyed in a fire.
However, if you stay with me until the end of this video, I will show you our real, authentic
Fiji mermaid. That's right. We have welcomed one into our museum and I have affectionately named
it Dobby the House Mermaid, aka Dobbs for short. I'll give you a trigger warning, though. She's a
little more creature from the Black Lagoon than Ariel, but every culture has its beauty norms,
right? Yeah. Okay. Anyway, let's talk mermaids. Mermaids are divine or semi-divine creatures that
have been present in the ideology of numerous cultures going back at least to ancient Mesopotamia
and Chaldean mythology, dating to around 2500 BC. The earliest written account of a mermaid
dates to 1000 BC and comes from Syria, where the story of Atar Goddess, a fertility goddess,
was recorded. Atar Goddess is discussed by sources through the Greek and Roman period, as described
by Diodorus Siculus as having the face of a woman and otherwise the entire body of a fish.
Europe and Asia Minor weren't the only areas to have mermaid lore. Water spirits and mermaid-style
gods are found in Africa in the form of Mami Wata, Iran in the form of a water goddess with
braided hair and bisected fishtails, and the Nii Roro Kadal from Japan. All of them are equated,
interestingly, with ideas of fertility, reproduction, and prosperity. So how in the
heck did the idea of mermaids go from benevolent fertility goddess to morally ambiguous, if not
sometimes sinister? It goes back to the 3rd century BC, when Apollonius of Rhodes wrote an
epic called The Voyage of the Argos. The Argos' crew disembarks temporarily, and a boy named
Tylos gets sort of abducted by a mermaid. Tales like that abound from the story of Lorelei of the
Rhine to the carved bench found in Xenor in Cornwall, England. By the 7th century AD,
even sirens, which are half-bird, half-women in Greek mythology, somehow had become cemented into
the history of literature as half-fish and capable of luring men to their death through the use of
their beautiful voices. This idea itself is perpetuated time and time again, even through to
Shakespeare's Midsummer Night's Dream. Mermaids and sirens become something to be feared, as their
appearance, song, femininity, all mark true danger. That being said, they can be kind, but their gifts
often come with later misfortune, and they are easily offended, which also results in various
water-based problems like, you know, floods. Just seeing them while on a voyage is an omen of storms,
untamed seas, disasters, and shipwrecks. Even once benevolent fertility nymphs like the Rusalki
from the Slavic cultures turn into something dark in the 19th century when they are seen as the
ghosts of women who died pretty horrible deaths from drowning and who, in anger and sorrow, lure men
and children to their watery demise. I suppose all of this is just a metaphor. Mermaids represent
the dualistic nature of the sea. It's fascinating and a source of life, but also can be violent,
untamable, and incredibly dangerous and enigmatic. I'll stay away from discussions of the Little
Mermaid, as the Hans Christian Andersen story is a far cry from the Disney version. It has a lot of
Christian overtones and has to do with the mermaid, who is nameless in the book, trying to achieve an
immortal soul through marriage and love. Regardless, the fascination with mermaids really increased as
world exploration opened new frontiers and resulted in trade with places considered
exotic to the western world, like China, Japan, Indonesia. In 19th century colonial culture, it became
all the more popular. Items, artifacts, accounts, all funneled into this fascination. Museums and
private collections start to fill with objects from distant lands. Mermaids were among these objects,
and even though they are called Fiji mermaids, they have nothing to do with Fiji. They were just
called that in order to tap into a perceived exoticism. In truth, people probably wanted to
believe in mermaids. Certainly, there are reports of mermaid sightings during this period, but also
their existence was convenient scientifically. Carl Linnaeus, a Swedish biologist and physician,
was assembling a very horizontal taxonomic tree and solidifying what today is binomial
nomenclature, a fancy term for naming living things. He felt the existence of mermaids was
logical since it could link the animal kingdom to the human one. Mermaids were a type of missing link
in that sense, in a way, and evolution would require some sort of transmutation from one thing
to its successor. So, it wasn't really hard to make the jump to believing in their existence.
Remember, too, at this time, a lot of scientific disciplines were in their infancy.
Geology was just getting named. Mary Anning was doing her thing and, you know,
redefining our understanding of prehistoric life through paleontology. No big deal. And oh, then
there was that Darwin guy who sailed around on a ship and saw some stuff. Basically, we are looking
at an era where dinosaurs were monsters that had suddenly become real, and the discovery of the
platypus was simply mind-blowing because, well, why would anything that weird exist? So, why not
mermaids, too? Of course, you had naysayers. There were people that saw conflict in relating animals
and humans and wanted to stress the difference between the two groups. And that, my dear viewers,
is where Barnum and the Fiji mermaids come in. Fiji mermaids were not new in the 1800s. There
were at least five exhibits of mermaids in London alone between 1775 and 1795. But Fiji mermaids
really begin appearing in the 1800s as curiosities in both museums and traveling shows. Many of the
barnums are thought to have been constructed in Japan out of fish and primates. Japanese folklore
is replete with composite animals, some of which were featured in Shinto and Buddhist shrines
during this period of time. Versions of such animals could be purchased at Japanese mizumono,
which were shows or exhibits and represent the beginning of a more popular style of leisure
culture open to all strata of society. Mizumono were a part of Japanese culture for over 200
years. Different than traditional forms of artistry like kabuki theater or jesaku literature,
mizumono peddled novelty, curiosities, and commercialism. Shows like these increased
in frequency after about 1800. But whatever the case with mizumono, the popularity of the Fiji
mermaid resulted in a small manufacturing business that lasted well into the late 19th century.
Some scholars have even suggested that all of the Fiji mermaids known in the 19th century
were produced by the same artisan. Barnum and Moses Kimball's mermaid was initially purchased
by English sea captain Samuel Eads from a Japanese fisherman or sailor in 1822.
That's 20 years before Barnum exhibits it. Eads sells the ship, he captains, to purchase it for
$6,000 Spanish dollars. So I see multiple problems with this, not only the lofty sum itself,
but also the fact that Captain Eads didn't own the ship he sold. Eads's son eventually
sells the mermaid to Moses Kimball, proprietor of the Boston Museum, in 1842. Kimball showed
it to Barnum, who ends up leasing it to display in his American Museum in New York City.
I know in previous Curious People Wanted videos, curator Emeritus Adrian showed
our replica of Barnum's mermaid, but I am proud to introduce you to Dobby the house mermaid.
Ain't she a beaut? I'm sure she's the creature of your dreams. And if that is the case, she is
single and ready to mingle. Please like and share this video, subscribe to our channel,
and feel free to comment if there's a topic you'd like me to explore more. But most importantly,
remember to stay curious.
