Square Foot Gardening in a Real Garden - Myths or Magic?

Myths and magic
3 followers
Square foot gardening promises bigger harvests in less space—but does it really work that way? I’m sharing what I’ve learned about plant spacing, common myths, and what actually leads to a healthier, more productive garden.
#squarefootgardening #vegetablegardening #plantspacing
Have you ever heard this? You can grow more in less space if you just plant closer together.
Now that all sounds really promising, sounds great, especially if you have small space,
small garden and you would like to get more. But in real life gardening it isn't always that simple.
So let's talk about that today. So let's go ahead and gently walk through this
and I will share what my experience has been. Now this thought gained popularity from a book,
a man called Mel Bartholomew and it's called Square Foot Gardening. But like a lot of things
in gardening it's a little bit misunderstood, especially once it lands in your real garden.
So I have my notes here. So the main point here, the big promise, right?
The promise is simple. Smaller space, more plants, bigger harvest. And technically you really can
grow more in a per square foot but here's what often gets left out. You are not growing more
per plant. So when plants are planted closer together like this, they're competing for
sunlight, they're competing for water and they're competing for nutrients. So and what I've seen in
my own garden, you do end up with more plants but many times, most of the time, they're less
productive and they're smaller. And you know what? This next part, this next part is really what
surprised me. On seed packets, the spacing recommendations are not just something somebody
made up. They are based on things. They're based on how wide they get, how much their roots spread
and how much air needs to move between them. That's an important part. So what about that
airflow part? You know, this really does matter more than people realize, especially if you live
in a humid environment. You know what? Because when plants are crowded, you can run into things
like powdery mildew, blight and other fungus issues. Especially, like I said, in those humid
environments. But you can even encourage that if you live in arid areas and plant too close together.
So my main point number three. Why it does work for some people. So let's be fair here. Square
foot gardening does work in certain situations for some people. So here goes through a few of
them. It works when you're growing smaller crops like lettuce and radishes, which you can thin out
and eat as they're growing. Therefore, then you start giving them space. Your soil is very rich
and well managed. That's why a lot of times these square foot gardening techniques are done in
raised beds because you control the soil better and you're keeping a close eye on things. And this
is one big benefit. It eliminates wasted space. So you don't have wide rows or any empty gaps.
But we'll talk more about that later. And then it makes it feel like everything's productive.
So let's go into what people don't talk about. Here's what people don't tell you. Dense planting
often means more frequent watering, faster nutrient deficiency, meaning you need to
fertilize more, more maintenance overall. So it's not low maintenance. It does save space. That is
true. But it doesn't save time or effort. I saw one blog, a vlog, a video on regular zucchini,
trying to make regular zucchini climb something, a trellis. Now there are climbing zucchinis.
Those work great. But you know what? They're self-climbing or self-sustaining. You don't have
to keep after them. If you try to train a regular spreading zucchini on an arbor or a trellis,
it's going to take work. You're going to have to be out there daily tying it up.
And if you're gone feeding for a few days, you are so far behind and getting that,
what do you say, vine onto the trellis. It could snap. There's so many other things. I've tried it
and that's why I know. So if you don't want high maintenance, then you need to think about what
you're trying to get to climb. Not every plant will work well without a lot of work. So yes,
you can grow squash, zucchini vertically, but it needs to be the ones that are made too. And I will
put up a couple of seeds or packets of seeds, pictures, so that you can see which ones do.
And I've shared about the trombocino or trombino. They keep changing the names, but it is a
eaten as a zucchini. Delicious. But also you can grow it as a winter squash. You let it mature on
the vine, get hardened skin, and you can store it. I didn't know that. I just learned that. I've been
growing it for 15 years and I just learned that. You learn something new every day. So here is,
after a few seasons, if you've tried it, this is where many of us land. And I like to call it
the balanced approach. It's somewhere right in the middle. It's not strictly square foot
gardening. It's not traditional spacing, strictly speaking, but it's something that's a little more
flexible. And what I do now is, I plant greens like lettuce, spinach, even my radishes a little
bit closer together, and I give the larger plants more room. And I'll talk about a little more. I
want to say something else and I need to stick to my list. Watch how things respond. This is how I
gauge. Watch how things respond in the garden because every garden is a little bit different.
Now, when it talks about larger plants giving them space, and this has been studied at Purdue,
you will see people in the square foot gardening world where they put tomato plants,
large growing tomato plants, very close together. They'll prune them religiously of suckers and
whatever. They will expose the fruit to the sun and then claim you get more in a smaller space.
That hasn't proven true for me. I have tested and so has Journey with Jill. She's got a website
and a video channel where you plant in the same space two, three feet apart, two tomato plants,
large, like it could be some kind of beefsteak or other indeterminate tomato. And you don't prune
all the suckers off. You can prune judiciously as you need to. And I mean need to as here and there
to keep it from getting too bulky, too heavy, what have you. But for the most part, I don't prune
tomatoes and you let them do their thing. Now, those two tomatoes will give you more
poundage weight of tomatoes than if you put three together in that same amount of space
and prune heavily. And many people will prune heavily to prevent the fungus because you need
airflow, etc. And then you will get less fruit per plant. So you will get less fruit for the
three than you would if you just planted two and left them alone. Now, if you are going to plant
the three and you need to prune, etc., that's constant maintenance. You need to be out there
daily pinching out the what some people call suckers, which they're really not a sucker.
A sucker is usually a plant or part of the plant that comes up from the rootstock,
not from the branches. Now, these suckers, because your tomatoes shouldn't be grafted,
but on a grafted plant like a Japanese maple, anything below the graft is now called a sucker
because that's the old plant that you didn't want that the rootstock is made from. You want
the what's on the top, which is the grafted portion. And that's the prettier lace leaf,
whatever. Now, tomatoes, we don't, I don't, some people do graft tomatoes, but I don't graft them.
Therefore, the what grows between a limb and the stalk, stem, stem, stem, anyways, is not really
a sucker. It is another stem or another stalk and it will produce tomatoes. There's some information
out there that says they don't produce. They just suck energy from the plant. That's not true.
And lo and behold, unless you want to get big tomatoes, then pruning that off will help
it put energy into the single tomatoes and get really massive tomatoes. I'm not interested in
massive tomatoes. I just want a lot of tomatoes. And so, but by weight, if you were to weigh how much
you got from the three compared to the two, you would end up finding out that when you just have
the two tomatoes that are allowed to grow as they were designed, meaning leave them alone, you do
not need to prune everything off. And I'll give you, get to another thing that why you don't want
to prune them off either. That's the way it was designed. Now, each stem, each leaf on those tomato
plants, they produce sugars. That is what makes your tomatoes sweeter, tastier, develop flavor,
all of those things. The leaves are not robbing the plant. I've seen so much information out there
and it's not scientifically based at all. Now, if you live in a very humid environment, yes,
a lot of times people will thin out the leaves a little bit to get more airflow, but be careful.
When you expose the fruit and it gets direct hot sun, it will scald and it will cause a problem.
Therefore, you will not get as much fruit from your tomato and what you do get with the sun scald
will be damaged. And so, don't buy into if you plant closer together and you just prune them up,
then you will get more better fruit. That is not accurate. It does not make them sweeter. It does
not make them tastier. And until you've done a side-by-side test for yourself of the exact
same plants in the exact same conditions at close together and separated by the amount they should
be separated or is recommended, then you really can't say for sure. There's that. Now, like on
Gardener's World and whatever, where they're growing them, they do expose the fruit to the
sunlight and that is to get them to ripen because they do not have the summers that we have here and
the intense direct sun. They have overcast a lot and it protects the fruit. Whereas if we, me, I
live in the mountains. I have a milder climate than many, many people, but my tomatoes will get sun
scald if I continue to remove leaves and stems from my tomato plant and what people call suckers.
You don't need to put yourself to that work to have delicious and abundant tomatoes. And I just
wanted to kind of give you an example and this is kind of, I don't want to say far-fetched, but it is
indicative. Now, when just a week or so ago, here's a six pack of my petunias and these have grown.
They were very small when I got them, but you see this one cell is missing. I potted it up and gave
it more room. Do you see how much bigger it is and healthier looking? That's because it gave it
more room for the roots to expand and that's the same. It works even in square foot gardening. If
you're not giving the plant the space it needs, it's going to stay smaller. It's not going to produce
as much. Therefore, you need more of them. So, it makes you feel like you're getting the productivity
when really you could go down a couple more plants and not have as many and still get the
same productivity. Hopefully, that was a good example. I know somebody's gonna say that's not
a good example, but that's okay. You're getting the idea of what I'm telling you. Now, I just watched
another video. A gal's doing a garden and she does square foot gardening, but she showed how so many
plants came up in this area and then she plucked out the ones that she didn't want and left the one
in that whole big square. You think, oh wow, you could have fit more in there. And then the other
one, she left the three in there and she showed the difference within a week of how much bigger
this plant got than the other three. And they were in the same soil, not too far apart, so they got
the same sun, same water, and yes, the bigger plant will produce more than the three smaller plants.
So that is where, yeah, the square foot gardening can be a little bit, as I said, misleading. And
until you do a side-by-side comparison for certain plants, you won't know which ones will perform
that way for you too. So yes, when they do the spacing on the packages, that's ideal spacing
for growing. And you'll get the most from that plant if you give them that amount of space.
Now, we're not planting in rows, we're not ever, we can plant in blocks and still give them that
space. But yeah, I just, that's what I meant earlier by saying it's not by accident or it's
just some arbitrary number that is told to you on the packages for spacing of certain things.
So I've learned in gardening, it's not about cramming as much as you can into a garden space.
It's about giving each plant what it needs as far as space and attention and then benefiting
from what it gives back. And sure, I could cram tons more into a smaller space, but that also
contributes to more pest pressure and more plant stress, which then attracts the pests. And then
you have the diseases that set in and all of the above, which ends up being much more maintenance.
And that for me is a no-go. I like having what I need. And you know what, who needs
a bazillion lettuce plants? We eat a lot of lettuce and even with a little bit and giving
them the proper spacing, I end up giving some to my chickens because we get such an abundance in
a very small area. And of course it's just me and my husband now, but the same with other things.
I had a friend who planted radishes and she planted too many. I mean, they were trying to
eat up all these radishes. She tried pickling them. She tried to make mashed radishes and all
these other things that didn't work. They were hideous dishes. At least they told me that. I
didn't try that. But you can succession plant with radishes, meaning you'll plant a few,
however much you're going to think you need in a week. And then when you harvest or before you
even harvest, you can start seeding the next succession for the next ones to come into play,
etc. And you keep on going. The same with lettuce. I grow lettuce through the summer.
And once, one week I'll sow. And then once that's getting ready to harvest, or if I'm a week out
from harvesting, I'll sow another row. All of that. And you can keep on working it through.
And you don't have to cram too much in one little space to get an abundance. You can also,
I have used lettuce as an edging plant in the garden. It's really pretty. And I would harvest
each every other one. And it just made a beautiful boundary. But it was, and it was in my flower
garden. So yeah, there's so many innovative ways. And there's so many now. There are so many
vegetables that have been bred to be dwarf and for containers that you don't have to worry about
cramming larger plants into a smaller space. You've got ones that are made to be grown in
smaller spaces and grown beautifully and healthily. You don't have to compromise
in that way. And it's not more maintenance. A lot of times from what I've experienced
growing the square foot gardening way. Yeah, it just takes a whole lot more work. And even though
they say it doesn't. So that's just what I've experienced. Have you experienced the square foot
gardening method and has it worked well for you? I have found a balance works better for me. So
let me know in the comments below. I'd love to hear your experience. All right. I will see you
in my next video where we will talk something else gardening and yeah, share all about it.
